Professional Documents
Culture Documents
L. Mansani
luigi.mansani@ann.ansaldo.it
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Debate on Waste Management Strategy
for Sustainability of Nuclear Energy
• The radio-toxicity of the fission products dominates the total radio-toxicity during
the first 100 years and reaches the uranium ore mine level at about 300 years
• The long-term radio-toxicity is dominated by the actinides (mainly by the Pu and
Am isotopes) and the uranium ore mine level is reached only after more than
100,000 years
• By recycling and then ‘burning’ all the MA, the period over which high-level
radioactive waste remains hazardous could theoretically be reduced from
hundreds of thousands of years down to a few hundred years
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Strategy for Sustainability of Nuclear Energy (1/2)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Strategy for Sustainability of Nuclear Energy (2/2)
Both fast spectrum critical reactors and sub-critical ADS are potential
candidates for dedicated transmutation systems
Critical reactors, however, loaded with fuel containing large amounts of MAs
pose safety problems caused by unfavourable reactivity coefficients and
small delayed neutron fraction
– Core fuelled with only MA (Uranium free) has no Doppler nor Delayed Neutrons
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Sustainable Nuclear Energy Technology Platform (SNETP)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
In a nutshell: from strategy to implementation
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Fast Neutron Reactors in the frame of the
European Sustainable Nuclear Industrial Initiative (ESNII)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Structural Material Issues in Molten Lead Environment
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Structural Material usable in Molten Lead Environment
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Design Provisions to fulfil
the Structural Material Corrosion Issue (1/2)
1,E+02
PbO (Gromov)
1,E+01
1,E+00
Domaine large de fonctionnement
1,E-01
[O] (ppm)
1,E-02
1,E-04
1,E-07
1,E-08
300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650
Température (°C)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Design Provisions to fulfil
the Structural Material Corrosion Issue (2/2)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Design Provisions to fulfil
the Structural Material Erosion Issue
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
The ELSY project
• In 2006 the EC partially funded, within the FP6 programme, the ELSY project
(European Lead-cooled System)
• The ELSY project has been conducted by a large consortium of European
organizations to demonstrate the feasibility of a competitive and safe Lead Fast
(critical) Reactor using simple engineered features, while fully complying with
Generation IV goals, including the MA burning capability
• ELSY project ended on February 2010, but LFR development continued with the
LEADER project (Lead-cooled European Advanced Demonstration Reactor)
started on April 2010 in the frame of EC FP7
FA Support System
FAs extended to
Steam generator: cover gas space
Safety Vessel B
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
The LEADER project
LEADER Objectives
Deep analysis of the hard points of the ELSY design in order to identify possible
improvements with the goal to reach an improved European Lead Fast Reactor,
ELFR configuration
Definition of a new “frozen” ELFR configuration to be used as a reference plant
Conceptual design of a scaled down facility respect to the reference plant the
Advanced Lead Fast Reactor European Demonstrator - ALFRED (300 MWth)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ELSY - Revisited Critical Issues
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ELFR - Fuel Assembly, blocked with Tungsten ballast,
connected to Lower and Top Core Plates
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ELFR - Inner Vessel, Core support and Fuel Assembly
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ELFR - Reactor Vessel
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ELFR - Steam Generator
Power MW 187.5
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ELFR - Reactor Configuration
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ELFR - Decay Heat Removal Systems
• Several systems for the decay heat removal function have been
conceived and proposed for ELFR
– One non safety-grade system, the secondary system, used for the normal
decay heat removal following the reactor shutdown
– Two independent, diverse, passive, high reliable and redundant safety-
related Decay Heat Removal systems (DHR N1 and DHR N2): in case of
unavailability of the secondary system, the DHR N1 system is called upon
and in the unlike event of unavailability of the first two systems the DHR N2
starts to evacuate the DHR
• DHR N1: Isolation Condenser System (ICS) in the secondary system
• DHR N2: Water Decay Heat Removal System (WDHRS) in the cold pool
• DHR Systems features:
Independence obtained by means of two different systems with nothing in
common
Diversity obtained by means of two systems based on different physical
principles
Redundancy is obtained by means of three out of four loops (of each
system) sufficient to fulfil the DHR safety function even if a single failure
occurs
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Isolation Condenser History
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ELFR - Decay Heat Removal Systems
Water CORE
Helium
Lead
Parameters Value
Water Inlet Temperature (ºC) 335
Steam Outlet Temperature (ºC) 464.5
Water Flow kg/s 114.7 x 8
Water Inlet Pressure (bar) 191
Steam Outlet Pressure (bar) 180
Cycle Results
Cycle Efficiency (%) 42.15
Plant net output (MWe) 623.8
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ELFR - Overall Plant Layout
Laboratory
Access Control
Access Control
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED – Design of the LFR Demonstrator
Some components of ALFRED will be different from the design proposed for ELFR
- SGs: double wall straight bayonet tubes, continuous monitoring, permits use
of SGs tube bundles as part of DHR system, easy coating and/or
surface treatment: speed-up to construction
- Core: MOX
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Core Configuration
4 Safety Rods
12 Control Rods
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Upper and Lower Core Support Plates
Hole for
Instrume
nts
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Inner Vessel
Upper grid
Cylinder
Inner Vessel
assembly
Pin
Lower grid
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Steam Generator Bayonet Tube Concept
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Steam Generator Bayonet Tube Geometry
Length of exchange 6m
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Steam Generator
Water
Steam
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Steam Generator Performances
Tubes
Second
tubesheet
First tubesheet
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Reactor Vessel
• The RV is a cylindrical vessel with a torospherical bottom head anchored to the reactor pit from the top
• The reactor vessel is closed by a roof that supports the core and all the primary components.
• The RV upper part is divided in two branches by a “Y” junction: the conical skirt that supports the whole
weight and the cylindrical that supports the Reactor Cover.
• A cone frustum welded to the bottom head has the function of bottom radial restraint of Inner Vessel.
Cover
Support flange
flange
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Reactor Block Configuration
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Decay Heat Removal Systems
• Several systems for the decay heat removal function have been conceived and
designed for ALFRED
– One non safety-grade system, the secondary system, used for the normal decay
heat removal following the reactor shutdown
– Two independent, passive, high reliable and redundant safety-related Decay Heat
Removal systems (DHR N1 and DHR N2): in case of unavailability of the secondary
system, the DHR N1 system is called upon and in the unlike event of unavailability of
the first two systems the DHR N2 starts to evacuate the DHR
• DHR N1:
– Rrelay on the Isolation Condenser system connected to four out of eight SGs
• DHR N2:
– Other four Isolation Condenser to the other four SGs have been added
• Considering that, each SG is continuously monitored, ALFRED is a demonstrator
and a redundancy of 266% is maintained, the Diversity concept could be relaxed
• DHR Systems features:
Independence obtained by means of two different systems with nothing in common
Redundancy is obtained by means of three out of four loops (of each system)
sufficient to fulfil the DHR safety function even if a single failure occurs
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - DHR Systems (Isolation Condenser)
• 8 Independent loops
• DHR N1 4 loops
• DHR N2 the other 4 loops
• Each Isolation Condenser loop is
comprehensive of:
– One heat exchanger (Isolation
Condenser), constituted by a vertical
tube bundle with an upper and lower
header
– One water pool, where the isolation
condenser is immersed (the amount of
water contained in the pool is sufficient
to guarantee 3 days of operation)
1 loop (typical) – One condensate isolation valve (to
meet the single failure criteria this
function shall be performed at least by
two parallel valves)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Isolation Condenser Heat Exchanger
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - DHR System Performances
500 550
480
460 500
440
420 450
400
°C
°C
Core inlet temp Core inlet temp
Core outlet temp Core outlet temp
380 400
360
340 350
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Secondary System
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED - Overall Plant Lay Out
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
Selected materials for the main components
of ALFRED and ELFR
Material
Components
ALFRED ELFR
Reactor Vessel AISI316L AISI316L
Vessel Support P295GH P295GH
Safety Vessel (Cavity Liner) AISI316L AISI316L
Reactor Cover AISI316L AISI316L
Inner Vessel AISI316LN AISI316LN
Core Lower Grid AISI316LN AISI316LN
Core Upper Grid AISI316LN AISI316LN
Steam Generator T91 T91
Primary Pump: Duct and Shaft AISI316LN AISI316LN
Primary Pump: Impeller tbd (Maxtal ?) tbd (Maxtal ?)
Deep Cooler na AISI316LN
Fuel Assembly: Cladding 15-15/Ti T91
Fuel Assembly: Grids 15-15/Ti T91
Fuel Assembly: Wrapper T91 T91
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED and ELFR Design Options (Differences)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED and ELFR Design Options (Similarities)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
ALFRED and ELFR Design Options (Similarities)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
GIF LFR Reference Concepts
CONTROL
CLOSURE HEAD ROD
DRIVES
CO2 OUTLET NOZZLE
CONTROL
(1 OF 8) ROD GUIDE
CO 2 INLET NOZZLE TUBES AND
(1 OF 4) DRIVELINES
THERMAL
Pb-TO-CO 2 HEAT BAFFLE
EXCHANGER (1 OF 4)
GUARD
FLOW SHROUD VESSEL
SSTAR (10 - 100 MWe) BREST 300 (300 MWe) ELFR (600 MWe)
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
European LFR Activities
Accelerator Reactor
MYRRHA (600 MeV - 4 mA proton) Subcritical mode - 65 to 100 MWth
project schedule
2010-2014 2016-2018 2020-2022
2015 2019 2023 2024-
Front End Construction of
Tendering & On site Commissioning Progressive Full
Engineering components &
Procurement assembly start-up exploitation
Design civil engineering
GUINEVERE
The Zero-Power facility – solid Lead – critical and sub-critical operation
Lead-Bismuth
Nuclear data, nuclear instrumentation, Keff measurements, code validation coolant
Criticality reached in February 2011
Subcritical coupling performed in October 2011 MYRRHA
Multipurpose
Flexible
GUINEVERE and MYRRHA Irradiation
the first two steps of the EU Road Map for the development of LFR technology Facility
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012
European LFR Activities
ALFRED
Training Course on Seismic Protection of Lead-cooled Reactors Palazzo Camozzini, Verona, May 21-25, 2012