Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PLASTIC ANALYSIS
Dr. Suresh Bhalla
Professor
Department of Civil Engineering
Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
24/09/2019 1
Password: cvl756
ENGINEERING DESIGN APPROACH
Working
Design stress
Approach
Limit State
σ
Ultimate strength = σ u
Yield stress = σy
Yield Point
Allowable stress = σ all
σY ε
Working stress method: σ all =
FOS
2. For limit state values of axial force, shear force and bending moment
we simply multiply by load factor.
But the structure has not yet reached collapse state, can still
carry further load
FLAWS WITHCONVENTIONAL ANALYSIS
APPROACH
The structure still has capacity to sustain higher loads and bending
moment.
Correspond to yielding at
By plastic analysis, we can get two points only.
Pult
Actual Load Factor λ=
Py
Plastic Analysis basically extends the Limit state approach (so far
restricted to design aspect only) to analysis
Yield Point ∈
σ all
Compression
σY
ε
ASSUMPTIONS (Contd.)…..
5) Section has at last one line of symmetry.
Axis of
bending
BI-SYMMETRIC MONO-SYMMERTIC
Not considered
Why…..???
So that the plane of loading and the plane of bending coincide with
the plane of symmetry….else formulations won’t apply
STEP-BY-STEP ANALYIS TILL COLLAPSE
Elastic NA Z < Z
C T σ Tension
(Bottom)
Compression
3
N A 2
4 5
Tension 0 1
-Let plane section remain plane. 1
<σY Y
C-T = No net axial force.
B
dy
∫
ENA
y
ENA
σ bdy = o
ye
x
<σY
M M
σ = y *
= ( y − ye )
I I
∫ σ bdy = 0 Y
y*
M dy
∫
A
I
( y − y e ) bdy = 0 ENA
∫y bdy − y e ∫ bdy = 0
1
ye =
A A
∫ y dA A= Total are of section.
INCREASE LOADS TO REACH POINT<2>
Y σ
B 2 Tension
dy
σ < σ y. Bottom
ENA Compression
y top
ye
σ = σ y. 2
x
Comp. Tension
∈y σy
ε +ε
φ Curvature = tan φ = top
D
bott
Absolute
values
∈ σ
Derive Depth of section
∈<∈ y σ <σy ?? φ ⎛ ∈ − ∈t ⎞ With sign
=⎜ b ⎟ convention
Yield condition arrived ! ⎝ D ⎠
(one point only, @ compression) +ive value implies concave upwards
POINT<2> contd…….
Hence moment acting an the section = YIELD MOMENT = My
σy My
σ=
I
yce σ yI
Yield moment = M y = = σ yZe
E NA y ce
yte
σ <σy
Elastic section
I modulus
Ze =
ye,max Larger of the two extreme fibre distances from
ENA
∈>∈y σ y
Plastic
∈y region
Elastic Provides a measure of
∈y core curvature
∈>∈y σ y Plastic
region
LOAD THE STRUCTURE SUCH THAT
ELASTIC CORE VANISHES POINT <5>
σ Tension
Top and bottom plastic zones
merge with one another
3 (Bottom) σy
2
0 1 4 5 A1
1
Plastic
5 4 3 2
neutral axis
Compression
depth. = yp
(top)
σy
A2
‘NA’ defined by C = T
New neutral axis is called as
Plastic neutral axis (PNA)
FULLY PLASTIC SECTION.
Curvature ∞ σy
A1
C = T
σ y A1 = σ y A2
A1 = A 2
σy
PNA bifurcates the section into 2 equal areas A2
A1
CG
M P = σ y A1 y1 + σ y A2 y2
y1
y2 A
A1 = A2 =
2
A
A2 MP =σ y ( y1 + y2 )
2
M P = σ yZP
Distance between the CGs of
Plastic section A two areas into which PNA
ZP = modulus
=
2
( y1 + y2 ) divides the cross section.
M Z
Shape factor = = f =
p p
M y Z e
EXAMPLE (1)
B 1
Z e = bd 2
d 6
4 NA
d d NA A
4 Z p = ( y1 + y 2 )
2
2
bd
=
4
Z
f = = 1 .5
p
Z e
150
Z e ? Z p ?
1 10 f ?
200
190 1
∫
2
Y e = ydA
A
7
Y1 A1 + Y 2 A
= 2
ALL DIMENDIONS IN MM A1 + A 2
Yield stress= 250MPa
5 × (150 × 10 ) + (10 + 1902 )(190 × 7 )
=
150 × 10 + 190 × 7
= 52 mm
EXAMPLE (2) contd…
P Q b 1
I= bd 3
(2) 10 3
52 d
42
E R NA
(1) 148
(3)
7
1 1 1
I = ( 7 )(148 ) 3 + (150 )( 52 ) 3 − (150 − 7 )( 42 ) 3
3 3 3
= 11.06 × 10 6 mm 4
Ze =
I
=
11.06 ×106
= 74750mm3 M y = σ y Ze = 18.66×106 Nmm = 18.66kNm
ymax 148
250
PLASTIC MOMENT
G1 A1
YP 150 9.4 A web = 190 × 7 = 1330 mm 2
PN 10 A
0.6 A f = 1500 mm 2
A2
∴ NA must lie in flange.
A3
190
A 1 = A 2 + A 3
7
150 Y p = 150 (10 − y p ) + 190 × 7
Y p = 9 . 4 mm .
Z p = First moment of A1 , A 2 , A 3 About PNA
= 133801 mm 3
Mp = Plastic moment capacity
= σ yZ p
= 33 . 45 × 10 6 Nmm
= 33 . 45 kNm
Mp Zp 33 . 45
f = = = = 1 . 79
My Ze 18 . 66
150
12
8 300
H.W:
D
Determine f
12
180
24/09/2019 23
24/09/2019 24
MOMENT CURVATURE RELATION
b
σ Tension
(Bottom)
Fully plastic
Rectangular
section
d
2
3 4 5
σ y
0 1
1
Elastic ε 2σ
5 4 3 2 φ =
∈ core de φ = y
=
y
d / 2 de / 2 Ed
Compression 2σ Plastic
e
(top) =
Ed σ y region
-Plastic (end) regions – will undergo strain
without any increase in stress.
1
M y = σ y Z e = σ y bd 2
6 -Any moment beyond My will be resisted by
shrinking of the elastic core .
5 4 3 2 φ
φ
Compression φ y p
(top)
2σ 2M
φ y =
y
φy = y
Ed EdZ e
MOMENT CURVATURE RELATION
Moment curvature plot
M σy
M 5 Plastic
p
Lever
2
My d Arm
de PNA
φ Plastic
φ y
φ p σy region
M = M core +M plastic
M = σ y Z ec + σ y b ( d −2de )( d +2de )
1 2
6 bd e
M = M y 3−( ) 1
2
[ de 2
d
] M y < M < M p
MOMENT CURVATURE RELATION
M y < M < M p
or φy < φ < φp
M = 1
2 M y [3 − ( de
d ) 2
] φ=
2σ y
Ed e
φ
φy
= d
de
2σ y
φy = Ed
φy 2
M = My − M ( ) 3
2
1
2 y φ
φ 1 1
= M y = σ y bd 2
φ y 3 − 2(
M
) 6
M y
Condition M = M p
1
M P = σ y bd 2
4
M 3 φ → ∞
=
φ p ??
p
M y 2 H.W.
MOMENT DEFLECTION RELATION
σy
σy
σ
Assume that structure is determinate
σ <σy
σ Tension M
σy
3 Bottom
2 Mp 5
0 4 5
1
1 My 2
5 4 3 2 δ
Compression
top
SEQUENCE OF PLASTIFICATION
P
D
B L C
PL
M mid − pt = Increase load beyond Py
Lp 4
Region under plastification My < M < MP
Lp
Plastic zone
Rest of the beam is elastic.
My My
P L − Lp
> My M = M y =
2
(
2
)
Increase P such that P
P= Pu M = MP
L
Pu L
MP = My
4
4M P
=> Pu = MP
L
M y M p
M y Solving the two
Limiting length of equations
L po
plastic zone Lpo
= 1 − f −1
Pu L − L po Pu L L
( )= M MP = Rectangular section: 0.33
4
y
2 2
H.W.: Shape of plastic region?
MOMENT CURVATURE RELATION
Very high ductility
σ Tension
Bottom
M
φ f ≈ 5 to 10φ p
Mp
My
φ y
φ p
φ f
Compression top
The phenomenon of large
My My increase in curvature when
Mp
load reaches Pu is called as
“unrestricted plastic flow”
Variation of curvature φ φ
y
y
Actual
Theoretical
TYPICAL PLASTIC HINGE
LOAD APPLICATION
Vertical Load
Horizontal
Load
24/09/2019 37
24/09/2019 38
24/09/2019 39
PROVISIONS OF IS 800 (2007)
SEC 3.7 CLASSIFICATION OF SECTIONS
Plate elements of a cross‐section may buckle locally due to
compressive stresses. The local buckling can be avoided
before the limit state is achieved by limiting the width to
thickness ratio of each element of a cross‐section subjected
to compression due to axial force, moment or shear.
When plastic analysis is used, the members shall be capable of
forming plastic hinges with sufficient rotation capacity (ductility)
without local buckling, to enable the redistribution of bending
moment required before formation of the failure mechanism.
When elastic analysis is used, the member shall be capable
of developing the yield stress under compression without
local buckling.
Class 1 (Plastic) — Cross‐sections, which can develop
plastic hinges and have the rotation capacity required
for failure of the structure by formation of plastic
mechanism.
Class 2 (Compact) — Cross‐sections, which can develop
plastic moment of resistance, but have inadequate
plastic hinge rotation capacity for formation of plastic
mechanism, due to local buckling.
Class 3 (Semi‐compact) — Cross‐sections, in which the
extreme fiber in compression can reach yield stress, but
cannot develop the plastic moment of resistance, due to local
buckling.
Class 4 (Slender) Cross‐sections in which the elements
buckle locally even before reaching yield stress.
EX 1: SIMPLY SUPPORTED
BEAM UNDER U.D.L
b
A C
B
d
wl 2
= M < My
8
Mp
2σ y bd 2
wu = 2 = Ultimate collapse load.
L
Compare with yield capacity
EX 2: PROPPED CANTILEVER
A P PL
P
PL
C 8 8
B
P < Pu
6 PL 3 PL PL +
o 16
PL
32 16 8
5 PL
32
P
1st Plastic hinge shall form at ‘A’ 3 PL
16
Collapse will not occur
P 3P P 3P
Let P = P H 1 when BM @ A = M p + −
2 16 2 16
σ Tension
3 PH 1 l
Bottom
= M 16 M
PH 1 =
p
p
16 3L
ε
Structure can still carry further loads
Compression top
EX 2: PROPPED CANTILEVER
(Contd.) MP
B
A
When P = PHI C
5
MP
6
Increase " P " after formation of Plastic hinger at ' A'
For load P > PHI → B .M cannot increase @ A
5 Δ PL
Net BM @ B = M P + ΔPL
6 4
4
PU
H1 H2
Mechanism
5 Δ PU L 2 M
M p = Mp+ Δ PU = (
p
)
6 4 3 L
Pu = P H 1 + Δ Pu 6M
Pu = P
L
δ δ
M P
For incremental load (H 2 )
BMD Δ PH 2 = ?
For next incremental load (H 3 )
BMD Δ PH 3 = ?
For next incremental load
BMD
Δ PH 4 = ?
(H 4 )
BEAM UNDER U.D.L
The solution process very tedious
Pu = PHI + Δ PH 2 + Δ PH 3 + Δ PHN
EQULIBRIUM
Methods for
simplified analysis
VIRTUAL WORK
EQUILIBRIUM APPROACH
P
A H1 H 2
0 .5 L B 0 .5 L C
M P Pu
Consider equilibrium of BC C
A B
RA
Rc
M P 0 .5 L Moment about A
c
B Rc
M P + ( 2 Mp
L ) L = Pu × 0 .5 L
2 Mp
Take moment about B Rc = 6M
Solving Pu =
p
L
L
Advantage – Skip solving an in determinate structure,
which is otherwise tedious….
VIRTUAL WORK APPROACH
ASSUMPTIONS: P
A = MP B =
1. Structure @ verge of collapse C
MP θ θ
2. Geometry of the structure not change
Identify hinge locations and apply small virtual (RIGID BODY) rotation θ.
BMD
(Elastic range)
Pu = ?
Problem: Four hinges till collapse, but seven possible locations
Which four of the seven possible hinges will be the governing mechanism….???
This won’t be problem in the long‐hand method of sequential formation of hinges…
In equilibrium or virtual work method, we rely on some important theorems..
THEOREMS FOR PLASTIC
ANALYSIS
ASSUMPTIONS: At the point of collapse
(1) Loading system not affected
(2) Geometry of structure not affected.
2) YIELD CONDITION
At all points of the structure, the bending moment < MP
P > PU
−
…This would imply that the structure is either safe or just at the verge of
collapse
P < P U
−
If LBT and UBT are satisfied simultaneously
P = PU
ANAYLYSIS PROCEDURE
(1) Formulate possible collapse mechanism. ( Guess!)
(4) To rule out missing of critical mechanism, apply LBT (Yield and
equilibrium criteria)
Pu ≥ Pcrit
(5) If both LBT & UBT satisfied simultaneously imply correct collapse
load
P = Pu
EXAMPLE
Mp B
A B M L C
p
A H1 B H2 C
δ φ
θ
=
External virtual work θ +φ Internal virtual work
( wx ) δ
2 + w (l − x ) δ
2 = M P θ + M P (θ + φ )
@A @B
Disp. of CG
θ = δ
x φ = δ
L−x
Solving w = (
2M
L
p
) [2L−x
(L−x)x
] Infinite mechanisms depending an value of x
EXAMPLE (CONTD..)
dw
To get lowest = 0 ⇒ x = 0 . 586 L
dx
M p
wu = w = 11 . 65 ( 2 )
( x = 0 . 586 L ) L
To ensure correct mechanism, use LBT & check yield & equilibrium condition.
CHECK BY LBT
B
Equilibrium Check : ← 0 . 586 L → 0 . 414 L →
Mp
A M p
C
B w
A w B
M p
C
M p
0.586L M 0.414L
RA = ?
p
RC = ?
R A × 0 . 586 L = w x2
2 + 2M p RC ( L − x) = M p + w ( L − x )2
2
R A = 0 . 586 wL R C = 0 . 4140 wL
Check R A + RC = wL
R A = 6 . 83 Mp
L Rc = 4 . 83 Mp
L
= RAx − − M
2
wx
Compute M B 2 P
= ??
Alternately, we can keep MA as unknown fix MB to a value equal
to MP
NUMBER OF INDEPENDENT
MECHANISMS
= 1
EXAMPLE
How to identify possible hinge locations ???
P P
H1 L H2 L H3 L
D m = n − r
A B C
= 3 − 1
= 2
Pu1 Pu1 PU 2 PU 2
A 2θ C D
B φ φ
3θ θ 2φ
Pu 1 ( 2 θ L ) + Pu 1 ( L θ ) = M P ( 2θ ) + M p ( 3θ ) PU 2 ( φ l ) = M P φ + Mp ( 2 φ )
5 Mp
Pu 1 = ( ) PU 2 = 3 ( MpL )
3 L
MECH 1: EQUILIBRIUM CHECK
UBT ⇒ PU 1 , PU 2 , > PU
LBT – To rule out missing any mechanism. Check for equilibrium & yield.
5 Mp 5 Mp
MP ( ) ( )
3 L 3 L
B
C
A MP D
10 Mp
Check : R A + R D = = 2 PU 1
3 L
∴ Satified .
MECH 1: YIELD CHECK
5 Mp
5 Mp ( ) 4
( )
3 L
3 L Use BCD- R D = ( Mp
)
MA 3 L
A B C D
MP Vertical equilibrium
R A = 2( Mp
L )
4 Mp 5
Overall equilibrium - M A + ( L ) × 3L = ( Mp
L ) [L + 2 L ]
3 3
M A = M P
Check for M C
Using CD
5 Mp 4
( )
MP 3 L D MC = (M P )
3
B C
A 2 Mp
L
Yield criteria not satisfied
=> WE MISSED OUT A CRITICAL MECHANISM
NUMBER OF INDEPENDENT
MECHANISMS
LBT- Some mechanism missed out……………
Mechanism <1> IB
IA
Check I (B)
MECHANISM I(B): MISSED OUT
P U1B P U1B
B M P
D
M P A θ C 2θ
3θ
External virtual work = Internal virtual work
PU 1 B ( L θ ) + P1 B ( 2 L θ ) = M P θ + M P ( 3θ )
@ A @C
PU 1 B =
M p
4
3 ( L )
'
This is lower than P UI
Check for equilibrium & yield condition.
<1> ABC → R A CD → R D check vertical equilibrium.
M B = RAL − M A
= 53 M p − M p
M B = 23 M p
m1P m 2P m 3P m 3P
A DSI=3
Ha B C D E
L L L L
Possible independent mechanisms = 7 – 3 = 4
Mechanism 1
m1P m 2P m 3P m 3P
A
Ha B C D E
APPLICATION OF SHORT-CUT APPROACH ON
COMPLICATED STRUCTURE
Mechanism 2
m1P m 2P m 3P m 3P
A
Ha B C D E
Mechanism 3
m1P m 2P m 3P m 3P
A
Ha B C D E
Mechanism 4
m1P m 2P m 3P m 3P
A
Ha B C D E
PRACTICE PROBLEMS
2P P
1. L L L
First solve by first principles
P 2P
2P
H2 H2 H3
H4
H3
H4
H1 H 5 H1
m = n − r = 2 m = n − r =1
5 3 3
4
2 D FRAMES
Symmetric Under horizontal loads or
vertical loading not symmetric or
Under symmetrical structure not symmetric
vertical loads
No sway frame Sway frame
Beam mechanism
(local collapse)
Sway mechanism
(complete collapse)
Beam mechanism Sway mechanism
Combined mechanism
Hinge
cancellation
EXAMPLE
m = n − r = 2
P D M = 300 kNm .
P B C
P
1 Beam Independent
L = 2m 2 Sway
2L 3 Combined.
E
A
ϕ E
PU 2 = 450 kN
A
Equilibrium of DE -
400 kN
400 kN D 300
C
300 D
H E L
H A
E
A 300 E
300 H E
300 V V E
A V E
H E L = 300 + 300
H E = 300 kN
Equilibrium of CDE -
L D
C
300
Moment about C −
L
300 300 L = V E L
E 300 V E = 300 kN
V E
2 D FRAMES
ABC B
400 kN C
AB-
B L
300
2L 300
H
H 300 Cannot find H ,V
A
A
Solution Not possible!
A A
A
V A
A
V A
400 kN
From horizontal /vertical
equilibrium -
300
H A = 100 kN
H
V A = 100 kN A
300 kN 300
300
V A
2 D FRAMES
Check equilibrium of ABC
400 B C
L
300 Check moment equilibrium about C
2L
M B = 100 × 2 L − 300
2L
= 100 kNm
100 < M p ok
300
A
100
2 D FRAMES
Yield Check @ C -
400 B L C
M
= 100 × 2 L + 100 × L − 300
C
2L M C
100
Check : Equilibrium & yield check for
other mechanisms.
HOW DOES THE GOVERNING MECHANISM CHANGE WHEN THE STRUCTURE IS
UNDER (A) ONLY VERTICAL LOADS (B) ONLY HORIZONTAL LOADS
(A) Sway mechanism not possible (B) beam mechanism not possible
PRACTICE PROBLEM
3 P P
4 P
3m 3m 3m
Mp = 300 kN − m
4m
6m
EXAMPLE
P M p = 600kNm( Beam) = M B
M p = 300kNm(Cols) = M C
P B D
L C L
L
2L E
A
Beam Mechanism
P M p = 600kNm( Beam) = M P1
M p = 300kNm(Cols) = M P 2
P B L L D
300kN − m C 300kN − m
L
2L
600kN − m E
IVW = EVW
A
M P 1 ( 2ϕ ) + M P2 ϕ + M P2 ϕ = PU L ϕ
1
PU 1 = ??
Sway Mechanism
M p = 600kNm( Beam) = M P1
P M p = 300kNm(Cols) = M P 2
P B L L D
300kN − m
300kN − mC
L
2L E 300kN − m
A
300kN − m
IVW = EVW
M P2 (ϕ ) + M P2 (ϕ ) + M P2 ( 2ϕ ) + M P2 ( 2 ϕ ) = PU 2 ( 2 L ϕ )
PU 1 = ??
Combined Mechanism
M p = 600kNm( Beam) = M P1
M p = 300kNm(Cols) = M P 2
P
P B L L D
300kN − m
300kN − mC
L
2L E 300kN − m
A
300kN − m
IVW = EVW
M P 2 (ϕ ) + M P2 ( 2ϕ ) + M P2 ( 3ϕ ) + M P1 ( 2 ϕ ) = PU 3 ( 2 L ϕ ) + PU 3 ( L ϕ )
PU 3 = ??
INCLINED PORTAL FRAMES
P 5 3
5 . 38 m
P m = n − n
2m
B D = 2
5m
(1 ) A
C
SWAY
A
5m 5m
NOT A (2)
MECHANISM A
INCLINED PORTAL FRAMES
(2) B
(1 ) B
Comallastion
Hirge comallastion.
Combine IA+2A
IB+2B
INCLINED PORTAL FRAMES
SWAY MECHANISM
Pu 1 Pu 1 (1A)
EVW = IVW
PU 1 × 0 = −
PU 1 = ∞
φ
(2A) C
I = Instantaneres centre of rotation
ϕ + φ D
give small rotation about I = ϕ
B
φ
α + φ α
Δ ICD reasains rigid
A E