Professional Documents
Culture Documents
29
In order to estimate the strength of the Lift the failure would have occurred regardless S Figure 3
Cooling tower after collapse
28 concrete at the time of the failure, the NBS of the bolts being removed. They determined
investigators conducted tests using similar that failure was likely to occur if the concrete
concrete subjected to similar temperatures strength was below 6.9MPa. As we know, the
for a period of 20 hours – the estimated time strength at the time of failure was estimated
that had elapsed between the placement at 1.5MPa, a long way from 6.9MPa.
of the Lift 28 concrete and collapse. The This failure highlights the dangers of
results were disturbing. The concrete had governing a concrete construction schedule
a cube strength of approximately 1.5MPa based on time considerations alone, and it is
– shockingly low. The cold temperature not an isolated incident in the history of failure.
conditions on site were to blame – the Both the collapse of the Commonwealth
ASCE
temperature resulted in the concrete simply Avenue building in Boston in 1971, which killed
not having enough time to develop the four, along with the dramatic collapse of an
necessary strength to support the lift-form
system and applied loading.
apartment building at Baileys Crossroads
in Virginia in 1973, which killed 14, were also
S Figure 4
Debris within cooling tower after collapse
However, upon the release of the NBS contributed to concrete being given insufficient
report, Lev Zetlin Associates (LZA), which time to develop necessary strength. As with
had been engaged by the contractor in the Willow Island, the construction schedules were
aftermath of the failure, disagreed with the governed by time and did not consider the
official findings. They determined that a environmental conditions that the concrete
number of critical anchor bolts had been had to contend with.
removed from the structure prior to the
collapse. These bolts were located in the Aftermath
jumpform beams – and therefore played a role The OSHA was criticised for lax inspections
ASCE
in transferring the load from the scaffolding – it didn’t have enough safety inspectors on
to the tower shell concrete of Lift 27. LZA the ground to enforce regulations in West
argued that if the bolts had not been removed, Virginia. It did, however, adopt new guidelines
then failure would have been unlikely. to protect future workers, including requiring decisions from the designer to the contractor,
In response to this report, two of the detailed safety manuals be produced for and requiring mandatory testing of concrete
original NBS investigators would undertake construction projects. It also made changes samples prior to formwork removal when the
further investigation, which was released in to the US Construction Safety Act, such as concrete was being relied upon to carry load.
1980. They would ultimately conclude that moving more responsibility for formwork Many years later, 12-year-old Anthony Lauer,
while working on a school project, asked his
teacher why there was no memorial for the 51
fatalities in the incident3. His family had been
Figure 2
Diagram of
lift-form system
devastated by the tragedy: his grandfather,
Larry Gale Steele, along with Larry’s four sons –
Emmett, Ernest, Miles and Ronald – were killed
in the disaster. Young Lauer seized upon the
idea for a memorial, and four years later he had
collected over US$50 000 to build one – the
very memorial that today stands across the
highway from the completed towers.
REFERENCES:
1) Delatte N. J. (2009) Beyond failure: Forensic case
studies for civil engineers, Reston, USA: ASCE