Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/7214271
CITATIONS READS
200 1,844
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Daniel G Dawson on 25 July 2018.
48
Syndrome
Nick Mamalis, MD
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
edema which has been described as “limbus-to-limbus” corneal
edema (Figure 48-1). This diffuse corneal edema is due to wide-
CHAPTER HIGHLIGHTS spread damage of the corneal endothelial cells. This finding is
very different from the focal areas of corneal edema which may
>> Clinical recognition of toxic anterior segment syndrome occur after routine cataract surgery. A second common finding
(TASS)
associated with this entity is marked anterior segment inflam-
>> Causes mation. This is characterized by diffuse breakdown of blood–
>> Treatment aqueous barrier with a marked increase in inflammatory cells
>> Protocol for managing a TASS outbreak in the anterior chamber. These cells may settle to the lower part
of the anterior chamber forming a hypopyon (Figure 48-2). In
addition, significant breakdown of the blood–aqueous barrier
Toxic anterior segment syndrome (TASS) is an acute, sterile postop- may lead to fibrin formation in the anterior chamber which
erative anterior segment inflammation following any anterior seg- may extend across the pupil from the iris onto the surface of
ment surgery. This entity is by definition sterile or noninfectious. the intraocular lens and toward the incisions. Finally, TASS
This condition was initially described as sterile postoperative may result in damage to the iris which can cause a permanently
endophthalmitis, but in 1992, Monson et al.1 coined the term toxic dilated or irregular pupil with thinning of the iris stroma
anterior segment syndrome (TASS). In addition, cases of TASS (Figure 48-3). There may be associated trabecular meshwork
which are characterized by localized corneal endothelial damage damage which can lead to secondary glaucoma which may be
have been termed toxic endothelial cell destruction syndrome difficult to control.
(TECDS).2–6 A recent review/update on TASS as well as its accom- It is important to differentiate the sterile inflammation seen in
panying editorial has provided a detailed, in-depth discussion of this TASS from an infectious postoperative endophthalmitis. One of
entity.7,8 the signs that are most helpful in differentiating these two entities
TASS occurs most commonly following cataract surgery, but is the fact that TASS occurs acutely in the vast majority of cases
may occur following anterior-segment surgeries of any kind with signs appearing within the first 12–48 h. In bacterial
including glaucoma or cornea transplant surgeries. While TASS endophthalmitis, the typical signs do not often appear until 4–7
is most commonly noted to occur acutely following anterior seg- days postoperatively. The symptoms in these entities are different
ment surgery, in rare instances it can have a delayed onset. This in that greater than 75% of patients who have an infectious
postoperative inflammation is sterile or noninfectious and is felt endophthalmitis will have pain. The majority of cases of TASS
to be caused by a substance that enters the anterior segment are pain free. The anterior segment inflammatory changes in both
either during or immediately after surgery, resulting in toxic of these entities are often very similar with significant inflamma-
damage to intraocular tissues. tion and hypopyon formation. However, the diffuse corneal edema
589
vii Management of Complications
ETIOLOGY OF TOXIC ANTERIOR SEGMENT SYNDROME
Figure 48-1 Diffuse limbus-to-limbus corneal edema. (From Mamalis N, Figure 48-2 Anterior segment inflammation with hypopyon formation. (From
Edelhauser HF, Dawson DG, Chew J, LeBoyer RM, Werner L: Toxic anterior Mamalis N, Edelhauser HF, Dawson DG, Chew J, LeBoyer RM, Werner L:
segment syndrome, J Cataract Refract Surg 32:324–333, 2006 (review/update). Toxic anterior segment syndrome, J Cataract Refract Surg 32:324–333, 2006
(review/update).
▪
tiple patients throughout the United States were found to have
ETIOLOGY OF TOXIC ANTERIOR
▪
signs and symptoms of TASS, but cultures of the anterior cham-
ber and vitreous showed no signs of infectious endophthalmitis.
SEGMENT SYNDROME These patients tended to occur in clusters and responded well
Any substance that is used during or immediately after cataract to intense topical corticosteroid treatments. This outbreak was
surgery which can access the anterior segment of the eye can evaluated by investigators from the Intermountain Ocular
cause TASS. The corneal endothelium is especially sensitive Research Center at the University of Utah, as well as investigators
to any form of toxic insult as are many of the structures in the from the United States Centers for Disease Control (CDC). A
anterior segment of the eye in general. The etiology of TASS thorough investigation of 112 cases from this outbreak by the
is relatively broad and may include problems involving irrigating CDC found that the vast majority of patients were exposed to
solutions such as balanced saline solution (BSS) and any additives one particular brand of BSS that was used during cataract surgery.
included.9–13 In addition, any other ophthalmic solutions used Samples were taken from many different lots of BSS and tested
during surgery, especially those which contain preservatives or for endotoxin. Several lots of BSS were found to have levels of
590
Toxic Anterior Segment Syndrome 48
endotoxin exceeding the allowable limit of 0.5 EU/mL. It was range of therapeutic versus toxic doses and has been found to cause
found that this BSS was manufactured by Cytosol Laboratories macular toxicity.26,27 These agents have been mostly discontinued
and distributed by AMO as Endosol. This BSS was withdrawn for use in the BSS for prevention of infection.
from the market which resulted in termination of the outbreak There has been recent work done mainly in Europe on the use
(U.S. Food and Drug Administration FDA – Reported Recall – of intracameral antibiotics which are injected at the conclusion of
Cytosol Laboratories, Inc. Product Contains Dangerous Levels the surgery to help prevent endophthalmitis. Initial studies in Swe-
of Endotoxin. February 13, 2006). den regarding the use of intracameral cefuroxime for endophthal-
mitis prophylaxis showed no signs of toxicity with a 1 mg/0.1 cc
dose of intracameral cefuroxime.28 The European endophthalmitis
PRESERVATIVES
study which has recently been published showed a significant
Ophthalmic solutions which contain preservatives or stabilizing reduction of endophthalmitis following the intracameral injection
agents may be toxic to the corneal endothelium and result in of cefuroxime at the conclusion of the case.29 The issue of the
TASS.13–15 The corneal endothelium is exquisitely sensitive to pre- use of intracameral antibiotics to prevent endophthalmitis is an
servatives which are used in many topical ophthalmic drops or solu- important topic that will need to be addressed by surgeons in the
tions. One of the most commonly used preservatives is United States in the near future. The American Society of Cataract
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
wound may lead to ointment gaining access into the anterior chamber
INTRAOCULAR ANESTHETICS
of the eye and causing inflammation.
Intracameral anesthetics are often used in routine cataract surgery to
help supplement topical anesthetics. Preservative-free anesthetics
OPHTHALMIC VISCOSURGICAL DEVICES
which are in a relatively low concentration have not been found to
be toxic to the endothelium. However, doses of lidocaine which is An additional potential source of TASS are commonly used
preservative free (methylparaben free-MPF) at a level of 2% or higher OVDs (previously referred to as viscoelastics). A large amount
have been known to cause significant corneal thickening and opacifi- of remnant OVD in the anterior chamber of the eye can cause
cation postoperatively.22 Although these agents are preservative free, an increase in intraocular pressure (IOP) as well as increased
intracameral use of anesthetics can potentially cause corneal endothe- inflammation postoperatively.
lial cell damage at a high enough dose.22–24 Therefore, it is very An additional problem is the possibility of denatured residual
important that any anesthetics used in anterior-segment surgery are OVD left in either reusable cannulas, tips or handpieces which
not only of the proper dose but are free of preservatives. have not been properly flushed following surgery. This residual
OVD may be broken down during sterilization and can cause
toxic inflammation following flushing of this material into the
INTRAOCULAR ANTIBIOTICS
eye in subsequent cases.16 In addition, this OVD may actually
Antibiotic agents are an additional source of toxicity when either retain other materials such as detergents or enzymes which are
they are used in irrigating solutions or are injected into the anterior used during cleaning and processing of instruments that could
segment of the eye at the conclusion of surgery. These agents are conceivably lead to inflammation in the anterior segment of the
often used to help prevent endophthalmitis. Surgeons had initially eye or TASS. It is critically important that any reusable cannulas
advocated the use of either gentamicin sulfate or vancomycin in the or instruments be thoroughly flushed at the conclusion of a case
irrigating solution (BSS) to help prevent endophthalmitis.25 How- in order to not allow the OVD to dry on the instruments which
ever, concerns were raised about the possibility of toxicity, espe- can occur when cannulas are exposed to the air, making cleaning
cially with intraocular gentamicin, which has a relatively narrow very difficult. It is recommended that all cannulas, handpieces or
591
vii Management of Complications
phacoemulsification tips that are exposed to OVD be thoroughly may cause potential inflammation. There have been reports of an
flushed using sterile, deionized, or distilled water to ensure that increase in corneal thickness secondary to endothelial damage in
there is no residue left on the instruments between cases. both rabbits and humans due to enzymatic detergents.13,19
Initial evaluations of the toxicity of detergents to the corneal
▪
endothelium were referred to as the toxic endothelial cell destruc-
CLEANING AND STERILIZATION
▪
tion (TECD) syndrome. Reports of severe TECD following cat-
OF OPHTHALMIC INSTRUMENTS aract surgery have been found to occur from detergent residues on
reusable cannulas.2
The cleaning and sterilization of instruments for use in anterior Furthermore, the use of ultrasound baths to clean ophthalmic
segment surgery has become an important factor in many recent instruments between cases is a potential source of TASS. The
cases of TASS. Beginning in February of 2006, the number of ultrasound baths may become contaminated by Gram-negative
TASS cases reported to the Intermountain Ocular Research bacteria which can produce a heat-stable endotoxin that can sur-
Center of the University of Utah, as well as to the TASS center vive autoclaving and cause TASS. Even though the bacteria are
at Emory University and to industry representatives began to incapacitated by heat from the autoclave, the endotoxin remains
increase markedly. Multiple clusters of cases of TASS were found viable. Deposits of the heat-stable lipopolysaccharide endotoxins
TREATMENT OF TOXIC ANTERIOR SEGMENT SYNDROME
in surgical centers throughout the United States and Canada. The can remain attached to the instruments or cannulas and can cause
Ad Hoc TASS Task Force was established with funding from the significant inflammation in the anterior segment of the eye if they
ASCRS to help investigate this outbreak. Two questionnaires are injected into the eye.31 Endotoxin is difficult to remove from
regarding instrument reprocessing as well as the use of products ophthalmic instruments and may require an alcohol rinse. Con-
in anterior segment surgery were developed and a database was sideration should be given to eliminating the use of ultrasound
established to investigate the causes of the TASS outbreak baths in the cleaning of ophthalmic instruments. Ultrasound
Approximately 130 different centers reporting TASS were baths are often necessary to remove bulk contamination on
evaluated. The Ad Hoc TASS Task Force issued its final report instruments which is important in areas such as general surgery,
on September 22, 2006 regarding the analysis of this TASS out- but is not a factor in most anterior segment ophthalmic surgeries.
break (Toxic Anterior Segment Syndrome (TASS) Outbreak:
Task Force Final Report - www.ascrs.org and www.aao.org).
There was no conclusive epidemiologic evidence to suggest any
one product was responsible for the increase in the TASS cases
▪ TREATMENT OF TOXIC ANTERIOR
SEGMENT SYNDROME ▪
reported. Also, analysis of the information did not reveal a single
cause or point source related to this particular TASS outbreak. Once again, it is important to ensure that an infectious etiology has
However, there were multiple potential etiologic factors which been adequately ruled out of cases of suspected TASS. Once the
were found to be related to the cases of TASS. The issue of toxic agent enters the eye and causes inflammation and damage
cleaning and sterilization of instruments for cataract surgery was which leads to TASS, the mainstay of treatment is the suppression
found to be the most important factor involved in many of the of the secondary inflammatory response. The primary treatment
cases of TASS. Specifically, the taskforce found that the short for patients with TASS is the use of intense topical corticosteroids
to help calm the inflammation and limit the damage not only from
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
to the trabecular meshwork, as well as possible peripheral synechia,
ments do not tend to have large bioburdens on them. If ultrasound
water baths are used, they should be drained and thoroughly cleaned
on a regular basis to prevent the buildup of Gram-negative bacteria
and possible endotoxin contamination.
Care should be taken to completely review all of the medica-
tions that are used in the cataract surgery and its aftermath. It
is important that confirmation be obtained that the anesthetics
used intracamerally are preservative free and of the proper dose.
In addition, any additives to the BSS, such as epinephrine, should
not only be preservative free but should also be bisulphite free. If
any intracameral antibiotics or antibiotics in the BSS are used, the
proper dosing and dilution of these medications should also be
confirmed. Both are off label uses in cataract surgery.
process is aware of the protocols. It is crucial that the entire sur- [3] Grimmett MR, Williams KK, Broocker G, Edelhauser HF. Corneal edema after Miochol. Am
J Ophthal 1993;116:236–238.
gical team including nurses, operating room technicians, physi- [4] Duffy RE, Brown SE, Caldwell KL, et al. An epidemic of corneal destruction caused by plasma
gas sterilization – the toxic cell destruction syndrome investigation team. Arch Ophthalmol
cians, and pharmacists are aware of what is appropriate for use 2000;118:1167–1176.
in ophthalmic surgery and that they be educated about protocols [5] Liu H, Routley I, Teichmann K. Toxic endothelial cell destruction from intraocular benzalkonium
chloride. J Cataract Refract Surg 2001;27:1746–1750.
that are in place. The TASS task force investigations of outbreaks [6] Eleftheriadis H, Cheong N, Sandman S, et al. Corneal toxicity secondary to inadvertent use of
benzalkonium chloride preserved viscoelastic material in cataract surgery. Br J Ophthalmol
of TASS at various surgical centers found that often there were 2002;86:299–305.
not adequately established protocols in place for the cleaning, [7] Mamalis N, Edelhauser HF, Dawson DG et al. Toxic anterior segment syndrome. J Cataract
Refract Surg 2006;32:324–333. [review/update].
processing, and sterilization of instruments. The level and inten- [8] Mamalis N. Toxic anterior segment syndrome. J Cataract Refract Surg 2006;32:181–182.
[editorial].
sity of cleaning of instruments often depended on who was doing [9] Swan KC. Reactivity of ocular tissues to wetting agents. Am J Ophthalmol 1944;27:1118–1122.
the cleaning of the instruments on a particular day and it was [10] Edelhauser HF, Van Horn DL, Schultz RO, et al. Comparative toxicity of intraocular irrigating
solutions on corneal endothelium. Am J Ophthal 1976;81:473–481.
often obvious that there were not well-established guidelines in [11] Gonnering R, Edelhauser HF, Van Horn DL, et al. The pH tolerance of rabbit in human corneal
endothelium. Inv Ophthalmol Vis Sci 1979;18:373–390.
place for the surgical staff. [12] Edelhauser HF, Hanneken AM, Pederson HJ, et al. Osmotic tolerance of rabbit in human corneal
To help increase the awareness of TASS and to help guide in endothelium. Arch Ophthalmol 1981;99:1281–1287.
[13] Parikh CH, Edelhauser HF. Ocular surgical pharmacology: corneal endothelial safety and toxicity.
the prevention of this complication, the Ad Hoc TASS Task Curr Opin Ophthalmol 2003;14:178–185.
Force has taken several steps to create educational materials for [14] Britton B, Hervey R, Kasten K, et al. Intraocular irritation evaluation benzalkonium chloride in
rabbits. Ophthalmic Surg 1976;7:46–55.
PREVENTION OF TOXIC ANTERIOR SEGMENT SYNDROME
surgeons and surgical staff. A video symposium discussing the [15] Green K, Hull DS, Vaughn ED, et al. Rabbit endothelial response to ophthalmic preservatives.
Arch Ophthalmol 1977;95:2218–2221.
findings of TASS, etiological factors, and possible ways to pre- [16] Kim JH. Intraocular inflammation of denatured viscoelastic substance in cases of cataract extrac-
vent TASS comprised of members of the Task Force, as well as tion and lens implantation. J Cataract Refract Surg 1987;13:537–542.
[17] Richburg F, Reidy J, Apple DJ, Olson RJ. Sterile hypopyon secondary to ultrasonic cleaning solu-
representatives from ophthalmic nurse's organizations is available tion. J Cataract Refract Surg 1986;12:248–251.
[18] Carter LM, Duncan G, Rennie GK. Effects of detergents on the ionic balance and permeability of
at www.TASSFacts.com. isolated bovine cornea. Exp Eye Res 1973;17:409–416.
In addition, the members of the Ad Hoc TASS Task Force were [19] Parikh C, Sippy BD, Martin DF, Edelhauser HF. Effects of enzymatic sterilization detergents on
the corneal endothelium. Arch Ophthalmol 2002;120:165–172.
involved in a symposium held at Emory University in the fall of 2006 [20] Edelhauser HF, Hyndivk RA, Zeeb A, Schultz RO. Corneal edema and the intraocular use of
epinephrine. Am J Ophthal 1982;93:327–333.
with representatives from the major ophthalmic nurses associations, [21] Slack JW, Edelhauser HF, Helenek MJ. A bisulfite-free intraocular epinephrine solution. Am
as well as other personnel with expertise in the cleaning and steriliza- J Ophthal 1990;110:77–82.
[22] Kadonosono K, Ito N, Yazama F, et al. Effect of intracameral anesthesia on the corneal endothe-
tion of ophthalmic instruments. Input was also obtained from other lium. J Cataract Refract Surg 1998;24:1377–1381.
[23] Anderson NJ, Nath R, Anderson CJ, Edelhauser HF. Comparison of preservative-free Bupiva-
organizations such as the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) and caine vs lidocaine for intracameral anesthesia: a randomized clinical trial and in vitro analysis.
the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regarding the develop- Am J Ophthal 1999;127:393–402.
[24] Guzey M, Satici A, Dogan Z, et al. The effects of Bupivacaine and lidocaine on the corneal endo-
ment of proper guidelines for the cleaning, sterilization, and proces- thelium when applied into the anterior chamber at the concentration supplied commercially.
sing of ophthalmic instruments. These guidelines are now available Ophthalmologica 2002;216:113–117.
[25] Gills JP. Filters and antibiotics in irrigating solution for cataract surgery. J Cataract Refract Surg
to surgeons and their staff on the ASCRS website (www.ASCRS. 1991;17:385.
[26] Judson PH. Aminoglycoside macular toxicity after subconjunctival injection. Arch Ophthalmol
org), as well as the ASORN website and were disseminated with 1989;107:1282–1283.
the March 2007 issue of the Journal of Cataract and Refractive Sur- [27] Campochiaro PA, Conway BP. Aminoglycoside toxicity – a survey of retinal specialists; implica-
tion for ocular use. Arch Ophthalmol 1991;109:946–950.
gery. These guidelines should help the surgeons and their staff in [28] Montan PG, Wejde G, Setterquist H, et al. Prophylactic intracameral cefuroxime: Evaluation of
safety and kinetics in cataract surgery. J Cataract Refract Surg 2002;28:977–981.
the critical process of cleaning and sterilization of instruments with [29] Barry P, Seal DV, Gettinby G, et al. ESCRS study of prophylaxis of postoperative endophthalmi-
the goal of preventing further TASS outbreaks. tis after cataract surgery: Preliminary report of principal results from a European multicenter study.
J Cataract Refract Surg 2006;32:407–410.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[30] Werner L, Shear JH, Taylor JR, et al. Toxic anterior segment syndrome and possible association
with ointment in the anterior chamber following cataract surgery. J Cataract Refract Surg
References 2006;32:227–235.
[31] Kriesler KR, Martin SS, Young CW, et al. Postoperative inflammation following cataract
[1] Monson MC, Mamalis N, Olson RJ. Toxic anterior segment inflammation following cataract extraction caused by bacterial contamination of the cleaning bath detergent. J Cataract Surg
surgery. J Cataract Refract Surg 1992;18:184–189. 1992;18:106–110.
[2] Breebaart AC, Nuyts RMMA, Pels E, et al. Toxic endothelial cell destruction of the cornea after
routine extracapsular cataract surgery. Arch Ophthalmol 1990;108:1121–1125.
594
View publication stats