Professional Documents
Culture Documents
K. V. Ashokan
Madagascar is a global hotspot for biodi- Recently, German and Malagasy prima- ences between members of the two popu-
versity and conservation1,2. It is the world’s tologists have described two new species lations were most pronounced with respect
fourth largest island, and is located in the of lemurs, Mirza zaza (Figure 1 a) and to canine height, tail length, ear length
Indian Ocean about 250 miles off the Microcebus lehilahytsara (Figure 1 b). and testes volume. When they used head
southern coast of Africa, across the Mo- The mouse and dwarf lemurs (Cheiro- length as control for size effects, most
zambique Channel. The hallmark of the galeidae) represent the largest lemur variables scaled allometrically with a
flora and fauna of Madagascar is not family. All members of the five currently clear separation between the northern
necessarily their diversity but their re- recognized genera (Allocebus, Cheiro- and southern populations, with little to
markable endemism. The various endemic galeus, Microcebus, Mirza and Phaner) no overlap. Thus, the northern Mirza clearly
species of Madagascar in their size and are relatively small (< 500 g) and noctur- is a scaled-down version of the southern
percentage of endemism are – plants 11,600 nal3. Several field studies of Cheirogalei- Mirza. This suggested that the two popu-
(99.2%), mammals 144 (92.9%), birds dae revealed the existence of new species lations actually represented distinct spe-
181 (58.4%), reptiles 367 (95.6%), am- and prompted systematic taxonomic work cies. Comparative genetic analysis also
phibians 229 (99.6%) and fishes 97 on this group using a combination of os- confirmed the distinctiveness of the two
(59.1%). Compared to birds, diversity of teological, morphometrical and genetic populations and led to the description of
the mammalian species is relatively low, data4,5. the northern population as a new species,
but the level of endemism is exceptional. Until recently, a single species Co- M. zaza. ‘Zaza’ is a Malagasy (language
About 90% of more than 150 mammal querel’s dwarf lemur, Mirza coquereli, of Madagascar) word for children. This
species that live on the island are ende- represented the genus Mirza. This genus name was chosen because the new spe-
mic. And new species are being discove- is restricted to western lowland forests, cies is the smaller of the two Mirza spe-
red in Madagascar at a rapid rate: for where it appears to have a disjunct dis- cies. Also, with this name the new lemur
example, in the last 15 years, 22 new tribution, with a gap between sub-popu- is dedicated to Madagascar’s children, to
mammal species and subspecies have lations spanning several hundred kilo- remind them of their responsibility for
been described. metres. Fieldwork by the DPZ (German preserving the island’s unique biodiver-
The lemurs of Madagascar are repre- Primate Center) team led by Peter M. sity for future generations.
sented by five families of primates unique Kappeler revealed morphological and Genetic analysis to determine the taxo-
to the island. Lemurs are ‘primitive’ behavioural differences between mem- nomic status of the two Mirza popula-
primates, and research on their behaviour bers of these two populations of Mirza6. tions unexpectedly revealed the existence
and ecology is central to our understand- This genus from Ambato (northern popu- of one more new species of mouse lemur,
ing of the origin and evolution of human lation) had significantly smaller means M. lehilahytsara.
societies. Their populations are dwin- of tail length, head length, head width, The genus Microcebus was considered
dling though; improper farming practices canine height, ear length, hind foot length, monotypic until the late 1970s. Later, two
have contributed to the destruction of femur length, tibia length, humerus length, distinct forms of the genus were recogni-
more than 80% of the island’s rainforests. and radius length. Proportional differ- zed – murinus and rufus. In the last de-
OPINION
N. Panchapakesan
‘Science can only answer a very small num- sen by only one team, the host school to be destroyed, and only one sentence
ber of questions that face us in our day to which was not competing for any prizes. passed on to the next generation of crea-
day life. Answers to a very large number The presentations were high tech – tures, what statement would contain the
of questions, require a moral and ethical using the power point software. There most information in the fewest words? I
base and depend on our likes and dislikes was more than enough to catch the eye believe that it is the atomic hypothesis
(superficial and deep, hidden and manifest). and sustain interest. One of the teams had that all things are made of atoms – little
These are outside science and are deter- Princess Diana on their opening slide. particles that move around in perpetual
mined by our world view based on various Not surprising, as these were all elite motion, attracting each other when they
factors – religion, culture, parental train- prestigious schools of Delhi. Except for are a little distance apart, but repelling
ing (brain washing!).’ one team which declared that astrology upon being squeezed into one another.’
I had written this much when the tele- was not a valid science, the others were To pick one wrong prediction and ignoring
phone rang and the science teacher of a all in high praise for astrology assuming the other important observations of Dalton
well-known school in Delhi, wanted to its validity and accepting it as science. seems a highly wrong way of analysing
know if I would be a judge of a contest One unusual argument for astrology an issue.
among schools for the C. V. Raman Sym- went like this. Astrological predictions Cosmology is a science in which, unlike
posium Trophy. I accepted and a few are often wrong. But this does not matter physics or chemistry or biology, planned
days later, found myself listening to as Dalton who is famous for his atomic experiments are not possible. One has to
teenagers from classes ninth to twelfth theory was also wrong in saying that atoms analyse astronomical observations, using
talking about what I thought would be were indivisible. Dalton’s atomic theory, science known from laboratory to recon-
science. But there was no science. Out of based on careful observation of chemical struct the past of the universe and predict
thirteen teams, seven chose to speak on reactions, established the existence of atoms the future. Little is known about early
‘Astrology – scientific reality or myth’, for the first time. Earlier ideas of Kanada universe. Nothing is known about what
five on ‘What existed before the Big in India and Democritus in Greece were happened before the birth of the uni-
Bang?’, both groups giving full play to speculations (albeit profound). Richard verse. There is a point of view that holds
imagination and speculation almost to- Feynman, a famous and colourful physicist that space time itself came into existence
tally lacking in any concern about the va- and a Nobel Prize winner, had written in at the birth of the universe and so the
lidity of what they were saying. The third his famous books on physics called question of what was there before is
and only scientific subject ‘Plastic elec- Feynman Lectures: ‘If in some cata- meaningless. The teams that spoke on
tronics – the future technology’ was cho- clysm, all of scientific knowledge were ‘Before the Big Bang’ did say that little