Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research Report
On
By
August 2020
Page 1 of 59
DISCLAIMER
This report is prepared by CARE Advisory Research and Training Limited (CART). CART has
taken utmost care to ensure accuracy and objectivity while developing this report based on
information available in public domain. However, neither the accuracy nor completeness of
information contained in this report is guaranteed. CART operates independently of ratings
division and this report does not contain any confidential information obtained by ratings
division, which they may have obtained in the regular course of operations. The opinion
expressed in this report cannot be compared to the rating assigned to the company within
this industry by the ratings division. The opinion expressed is also not a recommendation to
buy, sell or hold an instrument.
Page 2 of 59
List of Abbreviations:
Page 3 of 59
Table of Contents
1. ECONOMIC OUTLOOK................................................................................................................. 5
Page 4 of 59
1. ECONOMIC OUTLOOK
1.1 Global Economy
Global growth for the year 2019 was at 2.9%. As a result of Covid-19 pandemic, the same is
expected to contract sharply to -4.9% in 2020. Also, it is expected that the pandemic will fades in
second half of 2020 and containment efforts can be gradually unwound, the global economy is
projected to grow by 5.4% in 2021, as per The World Bank, World Economic Outlook June 2020.
Page 5 of 59
Growth in the advanced economy group—where several economies are experiencing widespread
outbreaks and deploying containment measures—is projected at –8.0% in 2020. Most economies
in the group are forecast to contract this year. In parts of Europe, the outbreak has been as
severe as in China’s Hubei province. Although essential to contain the virus, lockdowns and
restrictions on mobility are extracting a sizable toll on economic activity. Adverse confidence
effects are likely to further weigh on economic prospects. In 2021 the advanced economy growth
rate is projected to strengthen to 4.8 percent, leaving 2021 GDP for the group about 4 percent
below its 2019 level.
Among emerging market and developing economies, all countries face a health crisis, severe
external demand shock, dramatic tightening in global financial conditions, and a plunge in
commodity prices, which will have a severe impact on economic activity in commodity exporters.
Overall, the group of emerging market and developing economies is projected to contract by –
3.0% in 2020. Downward revision to the 2020 growth projection reflects large anticipated
domestic disruptions to economic activity from COVID-19. In 2021 the growth rate for emerging
market and developing economies is projected to strengthen to 5.9 percent, largely reflecting the
rebound forecast for China (8.2 percent). The growth rate for the group, excluding China, is
expected to be –5.0 percent in 2020 and 4.7 percent in 2021, leaving 2021 GDP for this subset of
emerging market and developing economies slightly below its 2019 level.
Emerging Asia is projected to have a nominal decline rate in 2020 (-0.8%). The rebound in 2021
with projected growth rate of 7.4% in emerging Asia depends critically on the pandemic fading in
the second half of 2020, allowing containment efforts to be gradually scaled back and restoring
consumer and investor confidence. Several economies in the region are forecast to grow at
modest rates, including India at 1.9%.
Financial markets across the world are experiencing extreme volatility: equity markets recorded
sharp sell-offs, with volatility touching levels seen during the global financial crisis; flights to
safety have taken down sovereign bond yields to record lows; risk spreads have widened; and
financial conditions have tightened. Global commodity prices, especially of crude oil, have also
declined sharply in anticipation of weakening global demand on the one hand, and the failed
negotiations of the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) and Russia, on the
other.
Many central banks have eased monetary, liquidity and regulatory policies to support domestic
demand, including through emergency off-cycle meetings. The International Monetary Fund
(IMF) and the World Bank Group are making available US$ 50 billion and US$ 14 billion,
Page 6 of 59
respectively, through various financing facilities to their membership to help them respond to the
crisis.
The annual growth of India for 2020 has been projected to be -4.5% as per IMF world Economic
Outlook June 2020. However, it is expected to rebound to 6.0% in 2021.
GDP is the sum of private consumption, gross investment in the economy, government
investment, government spending and net foreign trade (difference between exports and
imports). Sectorial GDP Growth is as under:
Sectorial Growth
9.4
8.2 7.7
6.8 8.8
5.7 6.1
7.3
5.6
2.4 4.6
3.7
2.8 0.9 3.0
Agriculture, Mining & Manufacturing Electricity, Gas, Construction THTCB FRP PAD
Forestry & Quarrying Water Supply
Fishing & other Utility
Services
-5.8 FY 19 FY20
(Source: MoSPI)
(Note: Agriculture includes Agriculture, forestry & fishing, Utility includes Electricity, gas, water supply& other utility
services, THTCB include Trade, hotels, transport, communication and services related to broadcasting, FRP include
Financial, real estate & professional services, PAD include Public administration, defense and Other Services).
Page 7 of 59
Gross value added (GVA) is the measure of the value of goods and services produced in an
economy. GVA gives picture of supply side where as GDP represents consumption.
Real GVA, i.e, GVA at Basic Constant (FY 11-12) Prices for the FY 19-20 is estimated to grow at
3.7% over Revised Estimates of GVA for the FY 18-19 as estimated by MoSPI.
Manufacturing
22.26% 17.39%
Electricity, Gas, Water Supply &
other Utility Services
Construction
7.82% 2.31%
19.56%
THTCB
(Source: MoSPI)
It may be noticed from the above that Financial, Real Estate and Professional services (FRP)
contribute highest followed by contribution from Trade, Hotels, Transport and Communication
services (THTCB). Share of Manufacturing and Agriculture sector was 3rd and 4th largest
respectively.
Page 8 of 59
The cumulative Index of Industrial Production (IIP) growth during FY 19-20 was at -0.7%.
-0.7
(Source: MoSPI)
As per IIP, in view of the global COVID-19 pandemic and consequent nationwide lockdown
measures implemented since March, 2020, the data flow from the producing units was impacted.
As some of these units are yet to resume operations, the response rate has been lower than
usual. Consequently, the Quick Estimates are likely to undergo revision and will be incorporated
in subsequent releases as per the revision policy of IIP.
6.1%
5.1% 5.1%
4.2%
3.9% 3.9%
FY 18-19
FY 19-20
During the year FY 19-20, growth in per capita GDP, income and private consumption have
decreased compared to previous FY 18-19. It may be noted share of private consumption as %
Page 9 of 59
GDP has increased slightly from 56.7% in FY 18-19 to 56.9% in FY 19-20 indicating an increasing
share of private consumption in the country.
India has not been spared from the exponential spread of COVID-19. As per IMF, growth in India
is projected to be -4.5% in 2020 and “V” shape recovery with 6.0% growth in 2021.
While efforts are being mounted on a war footing to arrest its spread, COVID-19 would impact
economic activity in India directly through domestic lockdown. Second round effects would
operate through a severe slowdown in global trade and growth.
Domestic and global shocks to key conditioning variables such as global crude oil prices, global
trade and growth, the exchange rate, the monsoon outturn and the rising frequency of their
visitations make forecasting a challenging task. Such uncertainties make the forecasting of
growth highly challenging. The actual outturn would depend upon the speed with which the
outbreak is contained and economic activity returns to normalcy.
Since March 2020 the inflation outlook has become highly uncertain due to the COVID-19
outbreak turning into a pandemic. Crude oil prices have collapsed to lows not seen since early
2000s. With several major economies in lockdown mode, demand conditions may weaken
sharply. Accordingly, countries across the world are bracing up for deflationary forces to take
hold. India may not be immune to these extreme downside pressures imparted by the pandemic.
The pick-up in economic activity would be dependent on the easing of lockdown across the
country and the containment of the spread of the virus. The longer the economy at a standstill
the longer the return to normalcy. Even with easing of lockdown, revival across sectors would
vary significantly and be contingent on how they are able to address the challenges of liquidity,
labor, logistics, demand and capacity utilization.
Page 10 of 59
Significant monetary and liquidity measures taken by the Reserve Bank and fiscal measures by
the government would mitigate the adverse impact on domestic demand and help spur
economic activity once normalcy is restored. Still, the government would have to play a critical
role for the revival of the economy mainly through investments which could to an extent address
the dire employment situation and also prompt consumption.
Page 11 of 59
The Global volume of Real Estate Sector in 2019 finished down on the record levels of 2018, but
were still the second highest on record. This fall was not for a lack of capital, rather a lack of
assets in the market.
By sector, offices and senior housing had the biggest growth in global investment volumes during
2019, both increasing by more than 5%. Industrial sector saw a more modest growth of 2.7%, but
the sector is now the third largest followed by more than 3% falls in residential investment and
18% fall in retail investment.
Page 12 of 59
450 10
400
5
350
300 0
250
-5
200
150 -10
100
-15
50
0 -20
Office Residential Industrial Retail Hotel Senior
2018 390 260 185 195 90 19
2019 410 250 190 160 90 20
Change (%) 5 -3 2.7 -18 0 5
Mounting evidence suggests that global economic growth contracted in Q1 2020, marking the
first quarter of contraction in 11 years.
Global industrial volumes rose by 7% in Q1 2020, while multifamily largely maintained its
performance relative to a very strong Q1 2019.
Fundraising by private closed-end real estate funds fell to its lowest Q1 level since 2013 with
US$22.3 billion rose through the first three months of the year.
The first quarter of CY2020 saw an increase in global cross-border purchases, which rose by 13%
year-on-year to US$55 billion, with the largest recipients being the office, multifamily and
industrial sectors and markets in the U.S., U.K. and Japan. Importantly, many of these
transactions were negotiated and finalized well before the COVID-19 outbreak.
Page 13 of 59
Office Sector
o Leasing activity across all the regions softened in the first quarter of CY2020 with
global volumes 23% lower than in Q1 2019 as deals were canceled or delayed.
Residential Sector
o Since 2010, global investment in the multi-family sector has risen at an annual
growth rate of 15.6%, putting it among the fastest-growing asset classes.
The Indian Real Estate sector is one of the largest employment generators only second to
agriculture and has a multiplier effect on various allied industries.
The year 2019 was a mixed bag for the industry having attracted investments worth around USD
5 billion and around 66% of these investments were in the commercial real estate market which
witnessed healthy increase in volumes of around 27% on y-o-y basis. The healthy demand has
been from private equity investors scouting for stable rent yielding assets. The residential
housing segment has been witnessing sluggishness in demand and lower absorption in the past
few years owing to structural reforms such as RERA, demonetization, and GST as the developers
Page 14 of 59
took time to re-align to the changing market dynamics and regulations. Further, economic
slowdown, NBFC crisis, low buyer sentiments too led to stagnant demand in the residential
segment.
o Real estate sector in India is expected to reach US$ 1 trillion in market size by
2030, up from US$ 120 billion in 2017.
o By 2025, it will contribute 13 per cent to the country’s GDP.
o India’s real estate market is estimated to grow at a CAGR of 19.5 per cent during
2017-2028.
1000
650
180
120
f-forecast
Urbanization
o Rapid urbanization bodes well for the sector. The number of Indians living in urban
areas is expected to reach 525 million by 2025.
o More than 70 per cent of India’s GDP will be coming from urban areas by 2020.
Page 15 of 59
525
461 460 471
429
f-forecast
India's Global Real Estate Transparency Index ranking has improved by one notch to 34 on the
back of regulatory reforms, better market data and green initiatives, as per property consultant
JLL. During 2018 bi-annual survey, India ranked 35th in the index, while the country was at 36th
position in 2016 and 39th in 2014.
48
39
36 35 34
Year 2012 Year 2014 Year 2016 Year 2018 Year 2020
Page 16 of 59
Note: The Index evaluates transparency based on over 210 variables relating to transaction processes, regulatory &
legal frameworks, corporate governance, performance measurement, data availability, sustainability and resilience,
health and wellness, prop-tech, and alternatives sectors.
Transparency Index which covers 99 countries and territories and 163 cities globally.
India has registered one of the largest improvements globally and regionally. This improvement is
led by the progress in the country’s REIT framework attracting greater interest from institutional
investors.
The structural reforms such as the Real Estate Regulation and Development Act 2016 (RERA),
GST, Benami Transaction Prohibition (Amendment) Act, 2016, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code
and digitization of land records have brought about greater transparency in what was an
erstwhile largely unregulated sector a few years back, JLL said.
India has also edged into the top 20 for Sustainability Transparency through the active role of
organizations like the Indian Green Building Council and Green Rating for Integrated Habitat
Assessment.
RBI proposed to allow banks to invest in real estate investment trusts and infrastructure
investment trusts, attracting more institutional investors to such assets.
Indian Banks, which are allowed to invest about 20 per cent of their net-owned funds in
equity-linked mutual funds, venture capital (VC) funds and stocks, could invest in these
trusts within this limit.
Between 2009-19, Indian real estate sector attracted institutional investment worth US$
30 billion and received US$ 5.15 billion in 2019.
Investment from private equity (PE) players and VC funds reached US$ 4.47 billion in 2018
and US$ 1.47 billion in Q12019 in the sector.
Real estate attracted around US$ 14 billion from foreign PE players between 2015 and
Q32019.
Institutional investment into Indian real estate sector stood at US$ 712 million during
Q4FY20.
Page 17 of 59
PE funds of around US$ 390 million and US$ 615 million were attracted by the
Information Technology (IT) hubs of Pune and Bangalore, respectively, in 2019. Both cities
witnessed an inflow rise by 210 per cent and 47 per cent, respectively in a year.
Although, there was drop in PE funds in Hyderabad, the showstopper of 2018. It
attracted PE funds of just US$ 440 million in 2019 against US$ 1.1 billion a year ago.
According to experts this drop was expected as 2018 was a one-hit wonder rather than a
steady trend.
The funding in logistics and warehousing witnessed a drop of 50 per cent attracting about
US$ 200 million in PE funds against the previous year.
Mixed-use developments saw inflows of around US$ 155 million in 2019, as compared to
US$ 310 million a year ago.
4,981 5,147
4,467
3,178
Page 18 of 59
3% 2%
8%
Office
10%
40% Residential
Entity Level
Retail
Mixed-use
Others
37%
The migration of labors post-lifting of lockdown kept the run rate for construction of real
estate projects low.
Limited availability of construction materials due to logistics issue affected construction
activities, leading to delay in delivery of residential projects.
As per HDFC securities research, “In Indian markets, the 1HCY20 residential
sales/launches were down 51%/24% YoY. In May 2020, the Tier 1 developers were
reporting about 40% of pre-COVID sales, while Tier 2 developers were at 20% of pre-
COVID sales.”
Warehousing is seeing good demand as online retailers are doing well in the lockdown.
Debt to equity is changing especially for under construction assets, from 70:30 earlier to
50:50 now as per HDFC Securities Institutional Research.
Page 19 of 59
On the leasing front, new leasing activity is likely to be impacted and may see some delay.
However, commercial rental of operational assets is largely insulated.
The worst hit segment is likely to be hospitality (low double digit occupancy at lower
realization leading to losses in division) with sharp decline in retail rental due to malls
closure and subsequent 50% rental waiver given by developers for lockdown period and
few months thereafter.
The sales of key residential players such as Oberoi Realty and Brigade has been affected
and is expected to decline by 50% - 60% y-o-y Q1FY21E especially in MMR Region.
Page 20 of 59
Global house price inflation had already lost significant momentum before the Covid-19
pandemic broke out. Year-on-year growth in real residential property prices for major advanced
economies (AEs) and emerging market economies (EMEs) slowed down to 0.9% in aggregate
during the last quarter of 2019, the lowest rate since 2015. Real prices all but stagnated in EMEs,
rising by a mere 0.2% years on year. In AEs, they continued to rise at a moderate pace (+1.8%),
which was significantly below the rates seen in 2014–18. Within the G20 economies, Germany,
Mexico, Russia and France saw the strongest annual real house price inflation in Q4 CY2019,
while only India recorded a marked decline.
Page 21 of 59
Real residential property prices growth slowed in EMEs, from 1.4% in Q3 2019 to 0.2% year on
year in the last quarter of 2019. This was driven by developments in emerging Asia (–0.4%),
where real prices fell by 3% in India and by 1% in China.
The Knight Frank Global House Price Index tracks the movement in mainstream residential prices
across more than 50 countries and territories worldwide using official statistics.
India ranks 43rd out of 56 in the list with 2% increase in y-o-y growth rate in housing price
appreciation.
The top 10 Countries showing better y-o-y growth in Global House Price Index for the CY Q1 2020
is given in the following chart:
% Change
(CY Q1 2019 - CY Q1 2020)
15.0% 14.5%
13.8%
11.9% 11.1%
10.3% 10.0%
9.4% 8.9% 8.6%
The Knight Frank Global Residential Cities Index tracks the movement in mainstream residential
prices across 150 cities worldwide using official statistics.
The average annual growth rate across 150 cities is 4.3%. 85% of Cities tracked registered static
or positive price growth over the 12 month period.
Indian City Hyderabad ranks 20th on the list with 10% y-o-y growth while Delhi, Kolkata, and
Ahmedabad ranks 67th, 85th and 90th with a y-o-y growth rate of 4.5%, 3.1%, and 2.7%
Page 22 of 59
respectively. Mumbai, Pune and Chennai has shown de-growth of -2.5%, -3.0%, and -5.0%
respectively in the list.
The top 10 Global Cities showing the best growth is given in the following chart:
16.3% 16.3%
14.8% 14.7% 14.0%
13.4% 13.3% 12.9% 12.9%
Price-to-income ratio is the ratio between the prices of a median home to that of the median
annual household income in a particular area.
Page 23 of 59
The Global Purchase or Investment in the Residential sector depends on the Net-worth of
Individuals. As per The Knight Frank’s Wealth Report 2020, The World’s Ultra High Net-worth
Individuals population (those with net-worth of more than US$ 30 million or more) rose by 6% in
the year CY2019 to 5,13,244 individuals while the U.S. dominates the rankings with 2,40,575
UHNWIs that is more than Europe and Asia combined accounting for almost half the global.
Residential property accounts for a large proportion of total UHNWI wealth – almost a third,
according to the Attitudes Survey.
240575
61587
23078 18776 17013 14367 10701 9325 8924 8395
Asia is quickly closing the gap on Europe and our figures predict that by 2024 it will be the world’s
second largest wealth hub, with forecast five-year growth of 44%. However, even following this
heady rise Asia’s UHNWI cohort will still only be half the size of North America’s, which is
forecast to grow by 22% over the same period.
Over the next five years we forecast that global UHNWI numbers will grow by 27%. Of the top 20
fastest growing countries that we measure, six are located in Asia (led by India with 73% growth),
five are in Europe (led by Sweden with 47% growth) and three are in Africa (led by Egypt with
66% growth).
Page 24 of 59
Property makes up the largest proportion of investment portfolios held by UNHWI. Equity comes
second at 23%.
The Prime International Residential Index (PIRI) 2019 has 100 cities in its graph that shows the
Annual % price change in terms of Luxury Residential Property.
Page 25 of 59
78 of 100 locations in PIRI registered flat or positive price growth in 2019. The average annual
growth of PIRI 100 is +1.8% in 2019 which is more than +1.3% growth in 2018. The average
change in prime prices across Asian markets (the highest performing world region in 2019) is
+3.1%. Frankfurt has topped the list by showing a growth of +10.3% in 2019. Indian metropolitan
city Delhi and Mumbai has ranked 16th and 68th on the list with a growth of 4.7% and 0.5%.
10.3%
9.6%
8.9%
7.6% 7.4% 7.0% 6.6% 6.5% 6.5% 6.3%
Following are the Key Global Players in the Commercial Real Estate Market:
i. Lennar Corporation
a. Lennar Corporation is a home construction and real estate company based in
Miami, Florida.
b. The company is ranked 154th on the Fortune 500 as of year 2019.
ii. D.R. Horton Inc.
a. D.R. Horton, Inc. is a home construction company incorporated in Delaware and
headquartered in Arlington, Texas.
b. The company ranked number 194th on the 2019 Fortune 500 list of the largest
United States corporations by revenue.
iii. Pulte Group
a. Pulte Group Inc. is a home construction company based in Atlanta, Georgia,
United States.
Page 26 of 59
The Revenue data of these key Global Companies is provided in the chart below:
17.593
9.915
7.221
4.8
Page 27 of 59
Real estate sector is one of the most globally recognized sectors. It comprises of four sub sectors
- housing, retail, hospitality, and commercial. Residential segment contributes ~80 per cent of the
real estate sector. Housing launches across top eight Indian cities increased 23 per cent y-o-y in
2019 to 2,23,325 units. The growth of this sector is well complemented by the growth in the
corporate environment and the demand for office space as well as urban and semi-urban
accommodations. The construction industry ranks third among the 14 major sectors in terms of
direct, indirect and induced effects in all sectors of the economy.
It is also expected that this sector will incur more non-resident Indian (NRI) investment, both in
the short term and the long term. Bengaluru is expected to be the most favored property
investment destination for NRIs, followed by Ahmedabad, Pune, Chennai, Goa, Delhi and
Dehradun. Demand for residential properties has surged due to increased urbanization and rising
household income. India is in the top 10 price appreciating housing markets internationally.
Housing sales reached 2.61 lakh units in 2019 across seven major cities. The growing flow of FDI
in Indian real estate is encouraging increased transparency. Developers, in order to attract
funding, have revamped their accounting and management systems to meet due diligence
standards.
According to the data released by Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade
Policy (DPIIT), construction is the fourth largest sector in terms of FDI inflow. FDI in the sector
(includes construction development and construction activities) stood at US$ 42.50 billion from
April 2000 to March 2020.
The trend in the % change in Total Income and Total Expense of Housing Construction Industry is
given in the following chart along with its forecast:
Page 28 of 59
14.18
10.38
7.14 6.22 6.13
4.25
1.63 0.91
(Source: CMIE)
The year 2019-20 has seen a slowdown in terms of growth in both Expenses and Income of
Housing Construction Industry.
7.32 7.4
6.33 6.44 5.92
5.85 5.63 5.21
0.39
-4.24
(Source: CMIE)
Due to pandemic impact, the country might observe de-growth in terms of Income generated
within the Housing Construction Industry and then may see a near constant growth from 2021-22
to 2024-25.
Page 29 of 59
The country has announced nearly INR 1348 billion of 128 New Projects in the year 2019-20 and
completed 290 projects of nearly INR 991 billion during the same period while the details of the
rest is provided in the Chart below:
(Source: CMIE)
These new projects announced are located in the following states of India:
906.5
142.1
38.6 31.9 28.3
(Source: CMIE)
Page 30 of 59
Government Sector
o Central Government
o State Government
Private Sector
980.4
367.4
(Source: CMIE)
Housing sales reached 2.61 lakh units in 2019 across seven major cities. NCR (National Capital
Region) is expected to generate maximum demand in MIG and HIG category followed by
Bengaluru. Developers are now focusing on affordable and mid-range categories to meet the
huge demand.
Page 31 of 59
25
LIG
1982
647
MIG
1457
351
HIG
717
The Q1 CY2020 saw a marginal increase in new launches of residential units compared to the
same period last year. Q1 recorded new launches of 40,574 units (an increase of 3% when
compared to Q1 CY2019).
Mumbai and Bengaluru continued to dominate new launches and formed nearly 60% of the
overall launches during the quarter.
A closer analysis of launches during the first quarter of CY2020 shows a sizeable proportion of
62% in the affordable and mid-price segments.
Page 32 of 59
25569
The developers across cities continued to launch new projects in the initial two months of the
quarter. It gradually slowed down in the beginning of March in line with growing concerns of
the impact of COVID-19 before it came to a standstill, on account of the nationwide lockdown.
Q2 CY2020 was the most impacted quarter with launches being the lowest since 2013. During
this quarter, new launch supply declined by 97% over Q1 CY2020 and 98% over the same period
last year.
The new launch supply in H1 CY2020 declined by 56% compared to H2 2019. The share of
affordable housing in H1 CY2020 new launches was around 36% of the total supply. This
decreased from 41% in H2 CY2019. In absolute terms, the half-yearly decline in this segment
was around 61%. No new supply was added in the affordable segment in Q2 CY2020.
The trend in new launch supply activity in the top 7 cities is given in the chart below:
Page 33 of 59
30000
20000
10000
0
NCR MMR Bengaluru Pune Hyderabad Chennai Kolkata
H1 2020 6190 10490 9190 8540 3380 3680 1140
H2 2019 13690 28100 19850 17890 5830 5940 5780
H1 2019 21600 49890 20080 28220 9000 7060 3640
The situation is likely to aggravate the liquidity challenges faced by developers and restrict new
launches for some time after normal business conditions are restored. In the subsequent
quarters, developers are expected to focus on completion of under construction projects and
clearing their unsold inventory. Moreover, consolidation in the residential market with an
increasing number of joint developments will continue to be a major trend with the size of pie
belonging to reputed developers increasing consistently.
India’s residential housing sales will decline sharply in the ongoing financial year. This will be on
account of current economic slowdown in the country. The lockdown has affected the businesses
across all the sectors and lead to several job losses and pay cuts. Therefore, several prospective
home buyers will defer their purchases owing to the COVID-19 led economic slowdown and
concerns over their job security.
The sales of residential units decreased by 29% in Q1 CY2020 over the same period last year.
The sales trend in the first quarter of Top 7 cities of the country is given in the Chart below:
Page 34 of 59
30204
26861 27451
Note: Top 7 cities include Delhi NCR, Mumbai, Bengaluru, Chennai, Hyderabad, Pune and Kolkata Mumbai includes
Mumbai city, Mumbai suburbs, Thane city and Navi Mumbai.
The sales of residential units in Q1 CY2020 declined in all the seven major residential markets of
India as compared to Q1 CY2019. This was the second largest dip in residential sales in the last
five years, after Q1 CY2017, when the market witnessed a 37% y-o-y fall in sales due to
demonetisation. Bengaluru, which was the largest contributor to sales in Q1 CY2019 witnessed
the maximum decline in the offtake of units, registering a 52% fall in Q1 CY2020 on a y-o-y basis.
Mumbai, Delhi NCR and Bengaluru continue to account for majority sales.
Despite the prevailing unprecedented crisis created by the COVID-19 pandemic, 57,940 units
were sold, and sales continued to exceed launches in H1 CY2020. Sales decreased by 49% in H1
CY2020 compared to H2 CY2019 as every city underwent contraction. The contraction was in the
range of 46% to 51% across the top 7 cities of India. Sales in Q2 CY2020 accounted only for 22%
of H1 CY2020, which primarily led to an overall decline in half-yearly sales. Q2 CY2020 units sales
were 72% lower than the previous quarter and nearly 81% down from Q2 CY2019.
Page 35 of 59
Sales Trend
50000
45000
40000
35000
30000
Units
25000
20000
15000
10000
5000
0
NCR MMR Bengaluru Pune Hyderabad Chennai Kolkata
H1 2020 10250 17530 11620 9360 3340 2670 3170
H2 2019 20530 35500 21710 17960 6760 5400 6380
H1 2019 26380 45370 28740 22830 9830 6420 7550
All cities witnessed a decline in sales to the tune of 46% to 51%, over the second half of CY2019.
In the subsequent quarters, the pick-up in sales will primarily hinge on enhanced consumer
confidence, which in turn depends upon the continued implementation of progressive
government policies amidst the gradual revival of the Indian economy at large. In the backdrop of
fears over timely deliveries and the financial health of developers, buyers will become even more
cautious. Traction in completed projects, especially by reputed developers is expected to aid the
recovery of the market.
The first quarter of CY2020 witnessed an increase in unsold inventory as launches outpaced sales
by a significant margin. Unsold inventory increased from 442,228 units in Q4 CY2019 to 455,351
units in Q1 CY2020. Moreover, Mumbai surpassed Delhi NCR to become the market with the
maximum quantum as well as value of unsold inventory.
Across the top seven cities, developers are sitting on an unsold inventory worth INR 3.7 trillion at
the end of March 2020.
Page 36 of 59
200000
150000
Units
100000
50000
0
NCR MMR Bengaluru Pune Hyderabad Chennai Kolkata
H1 2020 171020 209560 60390 91910 24250 33020 42920
H2 2019 175080 216600 62820 92720 24200 32020 44960
H1 2019 181930 224010 64680 92790 25130 31470 45560
Majority of the cities witnessed a decline in Unsold Inventory in the range of 1% to 5%.
An assessment of years to sell (YTS) reveals that the expected time to liquidate this stock has
increased marginally from 3.2 years in the last quarter of 2019 to 3.3 years in Q1 2020. With
anticipated slower sales in the coming quarters, the time to sell is likely to increase. Thus, the
duration to monetize the existing inventory of around 6,33,070 units is expected to extend. The
RBI’s intervention to provide a 3-month moratorium on all term loans by financial institutions will
alleviate short-term liquidity concerns and help developers survive in these uncertain times.
Page 37 of 59
Inventory Overhang
Months
67
54
47 49
40
29
22
Since, the unsold inventory is going to stay for a while at least until the buyer are not confident
to invest. Hence, to sell these locked-in properties the developers are expected to cut down their
prices by 10-15%.
The prices of residential properties in the top 7 cities is shown in the Chart below:
Page 38 of 59
10610
5510
4580 4975 4935
4195 4385
While Mumbai continues to be the most expensive housing market with affordability index of
7.1, it has seen affordability of homes significantly improve from 11 times the annual household
income in 2010. NCR and Hyderabad are marginally above the benchmark affordability with
scores of 5 each, while Bengaluru has an affordability index of 3.9. The affordability levels have
raised the most for Pune at just 2.5 times of their average household incomes.
NHB RESIDEX, India’s first official housing price index, was an initiative of the National Housing
Bank (NHB). NHB RESIDEX is designed to track changes in housing prices at neighbourhood, city
and national levels. Price changes will be measured over time and across cities and various
locations within cities. NHB RESIDEX will help recognize current trends in micro as well as macro
markets, and predict future behaviour of the housing market.
The HPI represents the price changes in residential housing properties. At present, the
geographical coverage consists of 50 cities in India including 18 State/UT capitals and 37 smart
cities, which will progressively be expanded to over 100 cities including all State/UT capitals and
smart cities. Measuring overall change in housing prices in India is complex and challenging
Page 39 of 59
because of various data sources with dissimilar data sets. The information on housing prices
varies according to the stage of transaction in which data is collected. As a result, three different
prices including registered price, assessment price, and market price may apply.
110.46
108.86
105.54 105.62
104.08
Page 40 of 59
Economic Growth along with Growing Urbanization is boosting Real Estate Demand
The Indian economy has experienced robust growth in the past decade and is expected to
be one of the fastest growing economies in the coming years.
India’s urban population is expected to reach 525 million by 2025, up from an estimated
461 million in 2018.
Rising income and employment opportunities have led to more urbanization and more
affordability for real estate in cities.
10%
9% 9%
8% 8% 8% 8%
Page 41 of 59
525
461 483
429
The real estate segment has received a massive boost from the government initiatives
such as Affordable Housing Scheme, Goods and Services Tax (GST) and the Real Estate
(Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA).
Despite their initial troubles, developers and buyers now hail the moves as the increased
transparency and competence of the sector have not only boosted the confidence of
domestic investors but foreign as well, which has led to increased FDI into the sector.
Page 42 of 59
206.75
192.82
169.62
154.97
138.19
India’s disposable income is rising year on year and has reached its top in the year 2019.
The Disposable Personal Income has increased at a CAGR of 10.60% during the last 5
years.
This growth in disposable income increases the Purchasing Power of an Individual that
may lead to a better way of living.
Page 43 of 59
COVID-19
Due to lock-down, the real estate projects which were in various stages of construction,
development and completion have come to a standstill. The period for which the pandemic
will prolong is uncertain. The impact of lockdown on real estate sector is going to be huge
and one will see a lot of real estate insolvencies/bankruptcy in the times to come. COVID-
19 has severely hit residential real estate business and the sector has come to a standstill in
the short term. While the sector was coming out of the woods after the liquidity crisis
initiated by the IL&FS fiasco and subsequent fallouts of various financial institutions, the
pandemic outbreak could further impact residential sector.
According to industry estimates, 90% of the workforce employed in real estate and
construction sector is engaged in the core construction activities, while the rest 10% is
involved in other ancillary activities. Since majority of the workers are immigrants, labor
shortage could possibly pose a major challenge for the sector post COVID-19 lockdown.
Post Demonetization, RERA and Liquidity crisis, the survival of the fittest and financially
strongest has become the new norm in the Indian real estate sector and well capitalized &
established players have gained substantial market share over the years. This consolidation
phase is likely to continue amidst the current COVID-19 outbreak and probably accelerate,
as we emerge from this pandemic and many weak players may cease to exist.
Land Availability
Another challenge that has affected the growth of the real estate sector and the
developers is litigated land. According to a survey conducted by the MahaRERA, around 16
per cent of projects and 31 per cent of built-up spaces are, or have been, in legal disputes.
In Mumbai, these figures tally to about 30 per cent of the real estate projects and 50 per
cent of the built-up space; for Thane, the corresponding figures are 26 per cent and 36 per
cent respectively.
Page 44 of 59
With the current rate of population explosion, the demand for space is vital. Over 50 per
cent of the world's population lives in cities, and the number is expected to rise by 2.5
billion by the year 2050. However, the current Floor Space Index (FSI) norms in the cities
are not on par with the growing demands of the consumers.
In addition to the previous financial challenges, the implementation of the GST is another
factor that haunts the real estate sector. Before the implementation of GST, a service tax of
4.5 per cent was applicable in the case of an under-construction property. However, post-
GST, the rate has risen sharply to 12 per cent, stealing the attractiveness of the ordeal for
property investors.
As buyers were paying registration charges and stamp duty on properties, the inclusion of
GST has increased the statutory cost of the property of the investor by 20 per cent.
The real estate sector in India is heavily regulated by the central, state and local
governments. Real estate developers are required to comply with a number of laws and
regulations, including policies and procedures established and implemented by local
authorities in relation to land acquisition, transfer of property, registration and use of land.
These laws often vary from state to state. If the project is in preliminary stages of planning
and any delay in obtaining approvals could warrant revised scheduling of project timelines.
It not only delays a project but also increases the cost of the property by 10-20% for both
buyers and developers.
The prices of land and real estate in India has increased exponentially in last decade and
causes overpricing of commercial or residential property. Further real estate agents or
brokers buy or sell property frequently with their own investments and cause of surging
prices in property.
Sources of Finance
Finance is the key for development of any industry. The lending to real estate developers
by NBFCs and HFCs fell by almost half to about INR 27,000 crore in FY19, triggered by the
IL&FS crisis,. This NBFC crisis has further deteriorated the liquidity situation for smaller
Page 45 of 59
developers who had to resort to alternative funding in absence of long term loans from
banks. Due to poor image of Real Estate sector, banks are becoming reluctant to provide
loans and making regulation tougher to avoid the bad loans. Alternate sources of finance
are very costly and ultimately impact total cost of the project.
The real estate is a capital and labour intensive industry; thus rise in cost of labour and
construction material due to inflation poses many problems to real estate industry. Further
real estate builders many times raise a question about unfair practices in cement industry
for rise of price more than 50% in quick time.
Page 46 of 59
7. GOVERNMENT INITIATIVE
Page 47 of 59
Make in India
This initiative was boosted by Government of India in the year 2014.
The main motive behind the campaign was to foster manufacturing within the
country by focusing on bringing worldwide investment for this sector.
The campaign has further heralded the development of townships, roads, bridges,
hospitals and other infrastructure.
It has boosted a lot of investment growth in India.
The Ease of Doing Business (EoDB) Rank of India has improved from 184 in 2014 to
27 in 2019. This improvement has been mainly on the account of decrease in the
number of procedures and time taken for obtaining construction permits in India.
This will ultimately boost people to purchase residences near their office/business
centers.
Page 48 of 59
Smart Cities
The building and push towards SMART Cities also heralded the opportunity for
infrastructure development which includes roads, railways, commercial centres,
and much more.
And with Government easing the transaction and compensation process around
land acquisition also helped developers overcome challenges and hurdles in
development projects.
Housing and inclusiveness - expand housing opportunities for all.
Demonetization
Introduced on 8th November, 2016, the demonetization move of the government,
putting a sudden ban on the then existing Rs 500 and Rs 1000 currency notes was
indeed a difficult move for many to deal with.
And though, it did bring about multifarious challenges, it also eliminated some of
the prevalent malpractices in the real estate industry such as Black Money
transactions and helped to enhance transparency in the sector.
The introduction of REITs is aimed towards allowing the investors to make safe
investments into the real estate of India, and the amount so collected will
subsequently be utilised towards the development of commercial properties in
order to generate income.
This is an initial step and may be in upcoming future, REITs also fund Residential
Segments.
Page 50 of 59
houses to all eligible families/ beneficiaries against the validated demand for
houses for about 1.12 cr. As per PMAY(U) guidelines, the size of a house for
Economically Weaker Section (EWS) could be upto 30 sq. mt. carpet area, however
States/UTs have the flexibility to enhance the size of houses in consultation and
approval of the Ministry.
Under the scheme, the government will provide interest subsidy of three to four
per cent for a home loan amount of up to Rs 9 lakh and Rs 12 lakh.
Government of India’s Housing for All initiative is expected to bring US$ 1.3 trillion
investment in the housing sector by 2025.
Page 51 of 59
Assistance of Rs. 1.2 lakh in plain areas and Rs. 1.3 lakh in hilly states, difficult
areas and IAP districts.
Page 52 of 59
to facilitate real estate transactions and provide relief to the sector, the
government increased the limit from 5% to 10%.
New income tax regime for taxpayers
The Government introduced an alternative tax regime and in case an
individual moves to the new tax regime, the tax exemption including
deduction repayment of principal (for INR 1.50 lakh) and deduction on
interest payable on housing loan has to be forgone, which is potentially
negative for the sector.
Page 53 of 59
2. DLF Limited
a. DLF is a Gurugram based Commercial Real Estate Developer founded in the year
1946.
b. DLF has developed ~153 real estate projects and developed an area of
approximately 330 msf. DLF Group has 221msf (approx.) of development potential
across residential and commercial segment.
c. The company has ready to sell inventory worth nearly INR 90 billion.
d. The company has planned new projects across of approx. 19 msf in FY20.
e. The company has gross sales of INR 34.5 billion in FY20 that is 10% more than
FY19 and net sales booking of INR 24.85 billion in FY20.
f. The Company generated INR 23.70 billion revenue from Operations standalone in
FY 20 which is 28.08% less than that generated in FY 19.
g. The consolidated Net Profit of the company stood at INR 26.64 billion in FY 20.
Page 54 of 59
4. SOBHA Limited
a. SOBHA Limited is an Indian multinational real estate developer incorporated in
1995 and based in Bangalore.
b. As of 31st March 2020, SOBHA has overall completed 109.74 msf of area.
c. The company currently has ongoing real estate projects aggregating to 39.36 msf
of developable area and 27.41 msf of saleable area.
d. The company has a real estate presence in 10 cities, viz. Bengaluru, Gurugram,
Chennai, Pune, Coimbatore, Thrissur, Kozhikode, Kochi, Gujarat (Gift City) and
Mysore. Overall, SOBHA has a footprint in 27 cities in 14 states across India.
e. In the residential space, we completed 5.86 msf of developable area during the
financial year.
f. The Company achieved 4.07 msf of new sales area which is the highest since its
inception. The total value including joint development share at INR 28.81 billion at
an average price realization of INR 7,075 per square feet.
g. The Company generated INR 37.56 billion revenue from operations standalone in
FY 20 which is 11.82% more than that generated in FY 19.
h. The Net Profit of the company stood at INR 2.90 billion in FY 20.
Page 55 of 59
100.00
90.00
80.00
INR in billion
70.00
60.00
50.00
40.00
30.00
20.00
10.00
0.00
Prestige
Macrotech
Estate Godrej
Developers DLF Ltd. Sobha Ltd.
Projects Properties
Ltd.
Ltd.
FY 20 81.15 23.7 33.56 37.56 17.47
FY 19 95.16 32.95 24.41 33.99 14.34
Page 56 of 59
20
INR in billion
15
10
0
Macrotech Prestige
Godrej
Developers DLF Ltd. Estate Sobha Ltd.
Properties
Ltd. Projects Ltd.
FY 20 4.33 22.64 2.62 2.89 3.13
FY 19 12.12 6.86 2.89 2.87 2.09
Page 57 of 59
In 2020-21, the industry’s sales revenue will continue to decline as sluggish economic
growth will impact housing sales. Profitability of the industry will be under tremendous
pressure as realty developers will look to reduce their housing inventory by offering
discounts on home purchases.
Real estate project completions will see a sharp decline in 2020-21. During the year
projects worth Rs. 686 billion are expected to be completed, 35% lower as compared to
the year 2019-20.
Consolidation in residential units is going to rise in the short-term future causing branded
players to gain market share to the tune of 75%-80%.
Township project that accounts for only 5% across the major cities are likely to rise in the
future as residents would prefer to work-live-play in controlled environment.
The design specifications are likely to be altered going forward as there will be a higher
demand for flexible homes that are capable of functioning as office and classrooms if
required.
Realty developers that are low on cash will turn towards financially sound builders to
take-over stuck projects. Stressed Realty developers will form Joint Ventures, monetize
their land and extend development management contracts across major cities.
Prices are likely to remain range bound as developers will be keen to liquidate existing
inventory.
New Real estate project announcements across the country will see a sharp decline in the
year 2020-21. Real Estate developers will look to clear existing inventory instead of
announcing new projects.
Moreover, lack of funding sources due to tighter lending norms by banks and other
financial institutions and delay in payments from housing units already sold will also
affect cash flow of developers, which in turn will impact new project announcements.
Work from home is likely to find acceptance in the Indian corporates, causing a spike in
reverse migration of professionals. As a result, housing demand may gain momentum in
tier II and tier III cities.
The nature of the Residential market is expected to be Buyer’s market and not Seller’s
market due to decrease in Buyer’s market confidence.
The decline in Residential housing demand will trigger a fall in housing prices across all
segments.
Page 58 of 59
Lenders are now facing the risk that the value of the collateral for which the loan is
disbursed may go down in future as housing prices are projected to decline. This may
create a situation similar to the sub-prime crisis in the US in the year 2008. Therefore,
lenders are more cautious while disbursing home loans.
*****
Page 59 of 59
CART Profile
CARE Advisory Research & Training Ltd. (CART) is a wholly-owned subsidiary of CARE Ratings Limited .
CART is engaged in the business of rendering financial and management advisory services,
undertaking diligence studies and appraisals of all types of projects and other related research. CART
also caters to the training needs of corporates and professionals through its training programme
offerings.
CARE Research
CARE Research services a variety of business research needs with credible, high-quality research and analysis on various facets of the
Economy and Industries. CARE Research provides customised research services to Indian and Multinational corporates for their various
requirements. CARE Research draws its strengths from CARE group's more than two decade long experience and its in-depth
understanding of the economy/industries, use of rigorous analytical methods and its knowledge pool. CARE Research has an in-house
team of qualified, experienced analysts. CARE Research is committed to provide accurate and reliable research to its clients within
specified timeframe to enable them make superior decisions.
CARE Training
CARE Training caters to the training needs of corporates and professionals. Our training programmes are designed to assist trainees in
gearing up to the dynamic business requirements. Meticulous thought process, mix of case Studies and in-house expertise gathered
within CARE group over 2 decades is used to develop course module & content. CARE Training offers its programmes through on-line as
well as through class room mode. CARE Training also offers customised training programme to Corporates/FIs for their specific training
needs.
Contact us at:
CARE Advisory Research and Training Ltd.
1102/1103, 11TH Floor, A wing, Kanakia Wall Street, Chakala, Andheri Kurla Road, Andheri East, Mumbai - 400093.
EMISPDF in-mdi_emis_access from 103.27.235.139 on 2020-11-23 07:12:16 GMT. DownloadPDF.
Ph. No:by91-22-
Downloaded 6837 4400
in-mdi_emis_access I E-mail: cart@care-cart.com
from 103.27.235.139 I www.care-cart.com
at 2020-11-23 07:12:16 GMT. EMIS. Unauthorized Distribution Prohibited.