Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Monoj Pramanik , Mark Early, Steven Wand, Diana Gottschalk, Sharathkumar K. Mendon,
James W. Rawlins
School of Polymers and High Performance Materials, The University of Southern Mississippi, Hattiesburg,
Mississippi 39406
Amidoamines are widely used as crosslinkers for epoxy was necessary to study its cure kinetics to establish structure–
resins in protective coatings on metal substrates; how- property relationships.
ever, their cure chemistry is not well elaborated in the It is well established that amine moieties (-NH and -NH2) in
technical literature. During cure, the epoxy–amine and amidoamines react with epoxy moieties at ambient and elevated
epoxy–amide NH reactions could be accompanied by temperatures. However, the reaction between NH of -
epoxy–hydroxyl etherification, epoxy–epoxy homopolyme-
rization, and reaction between hydroxyls and amide moi-
(C 5 O)NH moieties and epoxy groups at ambient or elevated
ety to form in situ ester and amine. To understand the temperatures has hardly been studied. Cure kinetic study of
epoxy–amidoamine cure chemistry and correlate it with epoxy–amidoamine systems via differential scanning calorimetry
coating performance properties, amidoamines of known (DSC) only dispenses the overall extent of reaction without dif-
structure are required. Therefore, amidoamines were syn- ferentiating between the individual component reactions [18,
thesized by reacting dimer fatty acids with diethylene tria- 20–27]. The evaluation of epoxy–amidoamine reactions via mid-
mine. When these amidoamines were cured with epoxy IR (600–4,000 cm21) spectroscopy [20, 28] has been compro-
resins, discrepancies were observed between systems
mised by the fact that epoxy resins and amidoamines exhibit
cured at ambient and thermal conditions. The presence of
solvents were seen to greatly affect the rate of epoxy– overlapping bands in the mid-IR region. Prime and Sacher [20]
amidoamine cure at ambient, and before and after vitrifi- reported that the cure of epoxy–amidoamine blends were charac-
cation. Near-IR and mid-IR spectroscopy studies indi- terized by the reaction between amine and epoxy moieties at
cated that side reactions occurred to some extent during ambient temperature, and the formation of ester and amine moi-
cure. No reaction was noted between the amide NH moi- eties via amide-alcohol reactions at elevated temperatures.
ety and the epoxide group below 1508C whereas ester for- Zhong and Guo [28] studied cure kinetics of epoxy and nylon
mation was noted above 1208C. Solvent-based clear
blends via DSC and mid-IR spectroscopy, and reported that the
epoxy–amidoamine coatings formulated at an epoxy:-
amine equivalent ratio 1.15 passed basic organic coatings reaction between epoxy groups and the amide moiety of nylon,
evaluation tests. POLYM. ENG. SCI., 00:000–000, 2018. V
C 2018 and ester formation via amide-hydroxyl reaction occurred above
Society of Plastics Engineers 2008C. The extent of side reactions is important as it alters the
curing agent functionality and induces variations in crosslink
density as a function of the thermal cure profile.
When amidoamines react with epoxy resins in bulk at ambi-
ent conditions, progressive cure results in system solidification,
INTRODUCTION
ultimately resulting in vitrification, that is, the progressive loss
Epoxy prepolymers are widely used in coatings and adhe- of functional groups slows down the molecular motion and the
sives because of their ease of processing, low shrinkage upon rate of crosslinking is typically reduced by three to four orders
curing, good thermal and mechanical stability, high resistance to of magnitude (cure is almost halted). In solvent-based epoxy–
solvents, and promising anticorrosive properties [1–6]. Amine amidoamine blends, the solvents usually impart enough mobility
curatives and reactive amidoamines are popular building blocks for virtually all the groups to react before complete solvent
for matrices in two component epoxy coatings [3, 7–15]. Such evaporation (i.e., elongated open times without vitrification),
amidoamines are synthesized by reacting fatty acids with amines and almost complete epoxy conversion is noted at ambient
[16–19]. Coatings based on epoxy resins cured with dimer fatty conditions.
acid-based amidoamines offer the advantages of low cost, excel- Epoxy–amine blend cure involves four reactions: epoxy–pri-
lent flexibility, and high hydrophobicity. Since the properties of mary amine, epoxy–secondary amine, epoxy–hydroxyl etherifi-
epoxy–amidoamine coatings depend on the extent of cure, it cation, and epoxy–epoxy homopolymerization, that are governed
by their energy barriers of 55–60, 71, 104, and 170 kJ/
Correspondence to: J. W. Rawlins; e-mail: james.rawlins@usm.edu mol, respectively (some variation in energy barriers is likely
Additional Supporting Information may be found in the online version of depending on the physical state and chemical structures of
this article. monomers) [29, 30]. Noting that near-IR (4,000–8,000 cm21)
Contract grant sponsor: The United States Air Force through funding by the spectra of epoxy–amine systems are characterized by distinct
Department of Defense (DoD); contract grant number: FA7000-13-2-0022
and FA7000-14-2-0011.
bands for epoxide, primary amine, phenyl, and combined pri-
DOI 10.1002/pen.24858 mary–secondary amine and hydroxyl groups, we monitored the
Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). cure kinetics of epoxy–amine blends and showed that epoxy–
C 2018 Society of Plastics Engineers
V hydroxyl etherification and epoxy–epoxy homopolymerization
occur under specific cure conditions [31]. In epoxy–amidoamine procured from Acros Organics. Diglycidyl ether bisphenol-A
blends, epoxy–amide NH reactions are also likely to occur. (DGEBA)-based liquid epoxy prepolymer, Epon 828 [reported
In this study, it was essential to discern between the individ- epoxy equivalent weight (EEW) 185–192 g/equiv.] was donated
ual epoxy–amidoamine chemical reactions in bulk and in sol- by Hexion (Momentive). Epoxy terminated polysulfide based
vent, and to correlate the extent of cure and structure–property liquid epoxy prepolymer, Thioplast EPS 70 (reported EEW
relationships while assessing the solvent effect on reactions and 310 g/equiv.) was supplied by Akzo Nobel. Benzyl alcohol
reaction rates. To understand the epoxy–amidoamine cure chem- (BzOH) and 1-methoxy-2-propanol (PGME) were purchased
istry and correlate it with coating performance properties, ami- from Fisher Scientific. Figure 1A shows the basic chemical
doamines of known structure and ability to form standard structures of dimer fatty acid, DETA, BAC, and epoxy prepoly-
organic coatings are required. Dimer fatty acid-based amido- mers. All the chemicals were used as received unless mentioned
amines were synthesized with the intent to study: (i) reactivity otherwise.
of the amine (-NH2 and -NH) and amide -NH moieties of the
amidoamine with epoxy groups at ambient and at elevated tem- Amidoamine Synthesis
peratures, (2) the effect of solvent on epoxy–amidoamine cure, DETA (476.76 g) was weighed into a 2 L, four-neck round
(3) occurrence of reactions other than epoxy–amine and epoxy– bottom flask set up with a water condenser, thermocouple,
amide NH reactions during cure, (4) chances of in situ forma- mechanical stirrer with Teflon blade, Dean Stark water trap, and
tion of ester and amine due to non-curative reactions between nitrogen in overhead space. The flask was heated to 508C under
amide and hydroxyl moieties, and (5) properties of epoxy–ami- stirring. Dimer fatty acid (1,250.24 g) was added dropwise into
doamine cured coatings to establish structure–property relation- the flask while heating the flask to 808C (to reduce viscosity
ships. Cure of epoxy resins with amidoamine was studied in and maintain flow). The reaction temperature was raised gradu-
bulk and in solvent, at ambient and elevated temperatures. As a ally to 1008C (0.5 h), 1258C (0.5 h), 1508C (1 h), and 1808C
control, the cure kinetics of the reaction between the epoxy resin (4 h). Based on its equivalent weight and assuming the presence
and N-methyl acetamide was studied to verify the occurrence of of only dimers, the molar mass of dimer fatty acid was calcu-
epoxy–amide reaction at selected temperatures. Solvent-based lated to be 576.27 g. Amidoamines-I and -II were synthesized
clear coatings were formulated using the epoxy resin and amido- by reacting DETA and BAC, respectively, with the dimer fatty
amine, and evaluated for their performance properties. The acid at an amine:acid molar ratio of 2.13. Figure 1B and C
effect of partly pre-reacting the amidoamine moiety was also shows the amidoamine synthesis scheme with structures of the
evaluated in coatings. expected trimers of amidoamines-I and -II, though higher
molecular weight products may also be formed. Amidoamine-II
EXPERIMENTAL was synthesized to verify the reproducibility of the adopted syn-
Materials thetic method.
Unidyme 14, a liquid dimer fatty acid (reported acid value
194.70 mg KOH/g) was donated by Arizona Chemicals. From Preparation of Coatings and Free Films
the acid value, the equivalent weight of the dimer fatty acid was All coating formulations were based upon amidoamine-I with
calculated to be 288.14 g/equiv. Diethylene triamine (DETA, an epoxy:amine ratio of 1.15:1. Coating C1 was prepared by
98% pure) and 1,3-bis(aminomethyl)cyclohexane (BAC, 98% mixing 33.96 g (0.1799 equiv.) Epon 828, 18.0 g (0.1565
pure) were purchased from Acros Organics and TCI America, equiv.) amidoamine-I, and 22.27 g solvent blend (1:1 by weight
respectively. Deuterated chloroform (CDCl3, 99.8% pure) was of BzOH and PGME) in a 100 g FlackTek cup. The cup
contents were mixed at 1800 rpm for 4 min in a centrifugal was determined from the isopropanol solution of amidoamine.
speed mixer (FlackTek, Inc.). Coating C2 was prepared by pre- Chloroform solution of amidoamine was agitated at ambient
reacting amidoamine-I with 10 equiv.% Epon 828 overnight at with salicylaldehyde and titrated with hydrochloric acid to esti-
ambient in the same solvent blend as used in C1, before adding mate secondary amine and tertiary amine content. A chloroform
the remaining Epon 828 (to maintain the 1.15:1 epoxy:amine solution of amidoamine was treated with phenyl isothiocyanate
ratio). The coatings were applied on two different steel panel and titrated with hydrochloric acid to determine the tertiary
types (S36 and QD), Leneta chart, and polypropylene sheets. amine content. Subtracting the amine value of the third titration
The coatings were cured at ambient for 16 h and at 808C for from the amine value obtained from the second titration yielded
4 h. The coated steel panels (S36) were characterized by wet the secondary amine value. Primary amine value was calculated
and dry crosshatch adhesion (ASTM D 3359), and solvent resis- by subtracting the secondary and tertiary amine values from the
tance via methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) double rubs (ASTM total amine value. Amine hydrogen equivalent weight (AHEW)
D5402). Pull-off stress, mandrel flexibility, and impact resis- of amidoamines was calculated using primary and secondary
tance tests were conducted on coated QD panels. Gloss meas- amine value. N-methyl acetamide was employed as a control
urements were taken on the coated Leneta chart. Coatings from amide and titrated against 0.05 N hydrochloric acid to determine
the polypropylene sheet were peeled off and analyzed for resid- its amine values. Its zero amine value validated the absence of
ual solvent via thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and dynamic interference from the amide nitrogen during titration with hydro-
mechanical properties (storage modulus and glass transition tem- chloric acid. AHEW values of amidoamines-I and -II were
perature, Tg). determined to be 115 and 188 g/equiv respectively.
Dynamic Mechanical Analysis. Dynamic mechanical analysis to application, studs were prepared by abrading the surface first
(DMA) was performed on a DMA Q800 (TA Instruments, Inc.). with 60 grit sand paper and then with Scotch Brite pads. Before
Free films (0.08-mm thick, 5-mm wide) were analyzed at a fre- adhering the studs to the panel, the coating was also abraded
quency of 1.0 Hz using a heating rate of 28C/min with the set with Scotch Brite. Studs were adhered to the coating surface
of strain control in tension mode. The DMA dataset for each with Scotch Weld D460 and applied by hand. The adhesive was
sample represents the average of three specimens. Storage (E’) cured for 24 h prior to testing. Supporting Information Fig. S2A
and loss moduli (E’’) as well as tan d were monitored for each shows the specimen and arrangement for pull-off adhesion test.
sample. The tan d maxima were characterized as the mechanical
Tg of the sample. The molecular weight between crosslinks (Mc) Solvent Resistance Test. Solvent resistance of coatings applied
was determined from the storage modulus in the rubbery plateau to S36 panels was evaluated following ASTM D 5402 using
region. Storage modulus (E’) is inversely proportional to the MEK as the solvent. Protective organic coatings are expected to
chain length between entanglement molecular weight (Mc) as: pass 200 MEK double rubs without any detectable visual dam-
age. A MEK double rub test set up is shown in Supporting
3qrRT Information Fig. S2B.
Mc 5 (1)
E0Tg150
Mandrel Bend Flexibility Test. Resistance to cracking or flexi-
where q is a front factor usually taken as 1.0 and followed for bility of cured epoxy–amidoamine coatings on S36 panels was
our calculations, r is density (g/cm3) acquired using thermome- tested following ASTM D 522. The mandrel bend flexibility test
chanical analysis (TMA) at Tg1508C, R is universal gas constant setup is shown in Supporting Information Fig. S2C.
[8.314 J/(mol K)] and E’Tg150 is the storage modulus (MPa) at
Tg1508C. Impact Resistance Test. Impact resistance of coatings on QD
panels was tested following ASTM D 2794.
Adhesion Test. Coatings on steel panels (S 36) were character-
ized by wet and dry crosshatch adhesion on a scale of 0B–5B as Gloss Measurement. Coating specular gloss at 208, 608, and
per ASTM D3359. Six parallel cross cuts were made on a 858 was measured on coated Leneta charts using a BYK gloss
coated panel using a sharp knife. Adhesion test tape was taped meter following ASTM D 523.
over the cross cut area and peeled off sharply. For wet adhesion
test, the cross cut area was moistened with a paper towel wet Water Sorption Measurement of Free Films. Free films of
with deionized (DI) water for 10 min prior to taping it. Support- coatings C1 and C2 were used to measure water sorption prop-
ing Information Fig. S1 clarifies the 0B–5B scale for adhesion. erties. Using a circular hollow punch, samples (13-mm diame-
Pull-off stress tests were performed using a MTS Insight ter) were cut from the films and weighed. The samples were
instrument equipped with a load cell of 2.5 kN following submerged in scintillation vials filled with DI water and held at
ASTM D4541-02. The test was conducted at a crosshead speed ambient. Over the course of two weeks, the disks were removed
of 0.5 mm/min. Each dataset represents the average of nine periodically; patted dry with paper towels, and its mass was
specimens for each sample. The adaptors for the load frame recorded before being placed back in the vial. The test was con-
used in pull-off testing were customized to hold a coated panel ducted in triplicate. The change in mass due to swelling was
on the bottom with an Elcometer 20 mm stud on the top. Prior calculated from the Equation as:
FIG. 5. DSC curves of curing of (A) stoichiometric mixture of Epon 828 and amidoamine-I, and (B) stoichiometric
mixture of EPS 70 and amidoamine-I, (C) Kissinger plot, and (D) Ozawa plot.
Increasing the heating rate to 108C/min shifted the Ti and peak 249 6 7.09 and 213 6 9.94 J/g, respectively. A stoichiometric
temperature (Tp) to higher values as expected and reported in blend of Epon 828 and amidoamine-I comprises of 6.58 milie-
literature [33, 34]. The exothermic heat of reaction (DH) of quiv reactive moieties per gram, while the EPS 70–amidoamine-
Epon 828 and EPS 70 with amidoamine-I was determined to be I stoichiometric blend contains 4.54 miliequiv of reactive
FIG. 7. (A) DSC curves when heated (2.58C/min in N2 atmosphere) to 1508C, (B) near-IR spectra during cure at
ambient/15 h 1 808C/6 h 1 1208C/1 h of stoichiometric blend of Epon 828 and N-methyl acetamide. [Color figure
can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
moieties per gram. The difference in DH values shows the dilu- of epoxy functional groups. On the other hand, the secondary
tion effect on the EPS 70–amidoamine-I blend system relative amine peak (6,500 cm21 in Fig. 6A) did not disappear
to the Epon 828–amidoamine-I system. Activation energy for completely, indicating the presence of residual amine content
Epon 828 and amidoamine-I, and EPS and amidoamine-I sys- even after all the epoxy groups had reacted. When the epoxy:-
tems were determined using Kissinger and Ozawa models amine ratio was increased to 1.15, the residual secondary amine
(shown in Supporting Information) [34]. Kissinger and Ozawa peak (Fig. 6B) was still evident despite the complete consump-
plots (Fig. 5C and D) indicated activation energies of 58 and tion of epoxy moieties. This indicates that side reactions (third
53 kJ/mol for Epon 828 and amidoamine-I, and EPS 70 and and fourth reactions shown in Fig. 4) occurred during cure at
amidoamine-I systems, respectively. By comparison, 2- elevated temperatures in both the stoichiometric and 1.15 epoxy
methylpentanediamine, a liquid aliphatic amine crosslinker that amine ratio systems. To verify occurrence of epoxy–hydroxyl
is reactive with epoxy prepolymers at ambient conditions, has reaction, a triethanolamine–Epon 828 blend was evaluated via
an activation energy of 56 kJ/mol as determined in our labo- non-isothermal DSC and near-IR (Supporting Information Fig.
ratory by the same method [31]. This indicates that the activa- S3). Both these techniques confirmed the occurrence of epoxy–
tion energy of amidoamine-I with liquid epoxy prepolymers is hydroxyl reaction.
consistent with that of reactive liquid amines and epoxy If Reactions 3–5 (Fig. 4) occur singularly or together during
prepolymers. cure of epoxy amidoamine systems, then it could explain the
presence of detectable amounts of residual secondary amine.
Near-IR Spectra during Cure of Liquid Epoxy Resin with
Zhong and Guo [28] reported that amide NH reacts with epox-
Amidoamine-I ide above 2008C in an epoxy–nylon blend. One could therefore
expect that both the stoichiometric and 1.15 epoxy:amine ratio
Cure of Epon 828 and amidoamine-I in bulk at stoichiomet- systems did not involve Reaction 5 (Fig. 4) during cure up to
ric proportion and 1.15:1 epoxy amine ratio at ambient as well 2008C in bulk. To further verify whether the amide NH reacts
as at elevated temperatures was monitored via near-IR spectros- with epoxide, the N-methyl acetamide and Epon 828 stoichio-
copy (Fig. 6A and B). The epoxy band at 4,530 cm21, phenyl metric blend in bulk were evaluated via DSC and near-IR (Fig.
band at 4,622 cm21, primary amine band at 4,933 cm21, and 7). The lack of any exotherm in the non-isothermal DSC curve
combined band of primary and secondary amine at 6,500 cm21 (Fig. 7A) validates that the amide NH of amidoamine-I does not
are of specific interest and are highlighted in the figure. Each react with epoxide at 1508C. Near-IR spectra (Fig. 7B) during
acquired spectrum was normalized against an internal standard cure at ambient for 15 h 1 808C/6 h 1 1208C/1 h also exhibited
peak (phenyl band) at 4,622 cm21. As expected, the intensities unchanged epoxide and amide NH peak intensity, again indicat-
of the epoxy band at 4,530 cm21, primary amine band at ing that the amide NH remained unreactive with the epoxide up
4,933 cm21, and combined band of primary and secondary to 1208C.
amine at 6,500 cm21 were observed to decrease consistently Apart from first five reactions (first to fifth), sixth ones may
with time as a result of reaction between epoxy and amine func- occur during cure of epoxy and amidoamine blend at elevated
tional groups, regardless of stoichiometry. The epoxy peak temperature (Fig. 4). This reaction between hydroxyl groups and
(4,530 cm21) in the stoichiometric blend (Fig. 6A) disappeared amide moieties to form in situ ester and amine has been
completely after 16 h at ambient 1 808C for 2 h 1 1208C for 2 reported to occur in an epoxy–nylon blend heated above 2008C
h 1 1608C for 2 h 1 2008C for 2 h, indicating complete reaction [28]. For this, mid-IR spectra were collected at the end of each
step of temperature rise during cure of Epon 828 and and 1.15 epoxy amine ratio during cure at ambient and elevated
amidoamine-I systems (both stoichiometric and 1.15 epoxy:- temperatures. Conversions were calculated from normalized
amine ratio blends) in bulk (Fig. 8A and B). At 2008C, a promi- near-IR spectra displayed in Fig. 6 using the following
nent mid-IR band (low intensity) was observed at 1,729 cm21 Equation.
in both the systems, indicating ester formation. Further evalua-
tion of the spectra in the region of 1,675–1,825 cm21 indicated A0 2At
Conversion ð%Þ5 3100 (3)
that the ester peak started growing at 1608C. Therefore, the A0
occurrence of Reactions 3–5, and in situ occurrence of Reaction
6 (Fig. 4) during cure at elevated temperature of Epon 828 and where A0 and At are areas under the peaks at 0 h (first spectra
amidoamine-I blend in bulk are the likely cause of secondary acquired immediately after mixing) and any time t during cure,
amine retention despite complete conversion of epoxy groups. respectively. The area under the near-IR peak at 4,530 cm21
To discern cure characteristics of solvent-based epoxy amido- was used to calculate epoxy conversion. Epoxy conversion
amine systems, Epon 828–amidoamine-I blends (stoichiometric increased rapidly up to 5 h but slowed down thereafter as vitrifi-
and 1.15:1 epoxy:amine) in BzOH and PGME (50:50) solvent cation restricted the mobility of the reactive functional groups.
mixture at 70% solids were monitored at ambient and 808C. The It was noticed that the initial rate of epoxy conversion in
near-IR spectra of this system are displayed in Fig. 6C and D. As solvent-based systems is higher than the rate of epoxy conver-
was noted in bulk, the intensities of the epoxy peak, primary sions in bulk, regardless of stoichiometry. Higher initial rate of
amine peak and combined band of primary and secondary amine epoxy group conversions in solvent-based systems is attributed
peak decreased consistently over time via reaction between epoxy to higher mobility of functional groups as well as the accelerat-
and amine groups during cure at ambient and post-cure at 808C. ing influence of the solvent hydroxyl groups on the epoxy–
Complete reaction of both epoxy and amine moieties was noted amine reaction via hydrogen bonding with the epoxy ring oxy-
in the 1.15:1 epoxy:amine ratio blend after ambient cure for 16 gen. In addition, visual heterogeneity was noted in the bulk
h 1 808C/1 h (Fig. 6D). The stoichiometric blend exhibited com- sample whereas the solvent-based system was visually transpar-
plete reaction of epoxy groups after 16 h at ambient 1 808C/1 h ent and homogeneous. These combined effects led to epoxy con-
with detectable presence of residual secondary amine (Fig. 6C). version values of 77.81% and 68.53% in stoichiometric and 1.15
Figure 7A and B confirmed that amide NH does not react with epoxy:amine ratio systems respectively, whereas corresponding
epoxide up to 1508C. Figure 8C and D (mid-IR spectra) also indi- values for the bulk condition were 51.27% and 48.90%, respec-
cated that in situ ester and amine formation did not occur when tively after 5 h at ambient. After 16 h at ambient, the stoichiomet-
Epon 828 and amidoamine was heated to < 1608C. This denotes rically formulated solvent-based system exhibited 98.32% epoxy
that to a certain extent, some side reactions (Reactions 3 and 4 in conversion while the stoichiometric bulk system was limited to
Fig. 4) occur along with the main epoxy–amine reaction in 64.15% epoxy conversion. This indicates that the epoxy conver-
solvent-based Epon 828–amidoamine-I systems. sion rate of solvent-based stoichiometric system in the vitrified
state was higher than the epoxy conversion rate in vitrified state
Epoxy Conversion during Cure of Liquid Epoxy Resin with of stoichiometric bulk system. In other words, residual solvent did
Amidoamine-I affect the epoxy conversion in vitrified state.
Figure 9 displays the epoxy conversions of Epon 828 and Post-curing of the solvent-based stoichiometric system at
amidoamine-I blends in bulk and solvent, stoichiometric (1.0), 808C for 2 h led to epoxy conversion values of >99%. On the
Residual solvent 20/60/85 gloss on Dry/wet Mandrel MEK double Impact resistance Pull-off
Coatings (wt%) by TGA Leneta chart adhesion flexibility rubs in-lb (J) stress (MPa)
other hand, post-cure of the stoichiometric bulk system at 808C/ displayed excellent crosshatch dry and wet adhesion (on S36
2 h resulted in 71.48% epoxy conversion, which increased to panels), excellent flexibility via the mandrel bend test, and very
>99% after post-curing at 1208C/1 h 1 1608C/2 h 1 2008C/2 h. good solvent resistance (>200 MEK double rubs). Impact resis-
Post-cure of the 1.15 epoxy:amine ratio bulk system at 808C/2 h tance of C1 and C2 coatings were determined to pass 145 in-lb
resulted in 66.09% epoxy conversion, that is, lower than the (16.38 J) and 160 in-lb (18.08 J), respectively. Pull-off stress
stoichiometric bulk system, due to its higher epoxy content. The values of coatings C1 and C2 were 1.33 and 0.64 MPa, respec-
epoxy conversion increased to > 99% upon further post-curing tively (standard deviation in measurement was 50%). Meis
at 1208C/1 h 1 1608C/2 h 1 2008C/2 h. As mentioned earlier, et al. [8] reported pull-off stress of 2.8–8.6 MPa of stoichiomet-
both the stoichiometric and excess epoxy (1.15) bulk systems rically balanced epoxy–amine coatings on pretreated aluminum
had residual secondary amine even after full conversion of alloy 2024-T3 metals. High standard deviation ( 50%) in pull-
epoxy moieties at elevated temperature (Fig. 6A and B). The off stress tests of several epoxy–amine coatings was also
solvent-based stoichiometric system contained trace amounts of reported by Meis et al. Pull-off adhesion values in the range of
residual secondary amine after full conversion of epoxy at 808C 1–3.75 MPa were reported by Almeida et al. [35] for several
(Fig. 6C). The solvent-based system formulated at 1.15:1 epoxy–polyamide coatings on Sa 2.5 blast clean steel substrates.
epoxy:amine ratio proceeded to 91.60% epoxy conversion in The lower pull-off stress of coatings C1 and C2 compared with
16 h at ambient, that is, lower than the stoichiometric solvent- the values reported in literature is attributed to the use of
based system. The theoretical epoxy conversion drops to untreated, smooth QD panels that limits the physical interaction
86.96% if only amine moieties of amidoamine-I are considered between substrate and coating. Overall, there was very little dif-
to react with epoxy. This means that side reactions (Reactions 3 ference between coatings C1 and C2 in terms of gloss, dry/wet
and 4 in Fig. 4) also occurred along with cure reactions (Reac- cross-cut adhesion, flexibility, impact resistance, solvent resis-
tions 1 and 2 in Fig. 4) during cure at ambient. Post-curing of tance, and pull-off stress.
the 1.15:1 solvent-based system at 808C/2 h led to > 99% epoxy Figure 10A and Table 3 display the dynamic mechanical
conversion with complete reaction of amine moiety (Figs. 6D properties (in terms of storage modulus, Tg, and full width at
and 9). Side reactions, that is, epoxy–epoxy homopolymerization half height of tan d curve). Coatings C1 and C2 showed no
and epoxy–hydroxyl etherification, occur depending on cure practical difference in Tg in the second cycle. The breadth of
condition and efficiency of in situ formed tertiary amine in the the tan d (first cycle) curves suggests the presence of residual
system. This reasoning also favors having excess epoxy in coat- solvent in both coatings. The Tg in first cycle was centered
ing formulations. around 70 and 758C for C1 and C2, respectively, and the dispar-
The solvent-based 1.15 epoxy:amine ratio system exhibited ity between the two coatings is professed to be because of the
complete amine consumption before the epoxy moiety, and differences in their residual solvent content. The noticeably
complete epoxy conversion after cure for 16 h at ambient and higher storage modulus (2 MPa) in the rubbery region of the
post-cure at 808C/2 h. Figure 8C and D displays mid-IR spectra second cycle cannot be due to residual cure as near-IR cure
of coatings C1 and C2 at ambient, 80, 120, 160, and 2008C. A kinetics and near-IR spectra of these clear coatings suggested
prominent ester peak at 1,729 cm21 was noticed in coatings C1 that no residual cure was left in coatings C1 and C2. Post-
and C2 when heated at 2008C, which started growing at 1608C. heating of cured coatings (C1 and C2) to 2008C resulted in in
Thus, ester formation in situ occurred in this epoxy– situ formation of trace amounts of ester (Fig. 8C and D) while
amidoamine-I system at 1608C. Figure 8C and D indicates the near-IR of the same samples did not show detectable amounts
lack of ester groups upon post-heating of coatings C1 and C2 to of amine (Supporting Information Fig. S4). It is thus understand-
1208C. Literature reports and the reaction shown in Fig. 4 sug- able that the extent of reaction between amide and hydroxyl
gest that ester formation is accompanied by in situ formation of groups to generate ester and amine is nominal when C1 and C2
amine as well. Near-IR (Supporting Information Fig. S4) analy- were heated to 2008C. This in turn indicated that this traceable
sis of coatings C1 and C2 at the same temperatures used for amount of reaction between amide and hydroxyls can cause
mid-IR analysis (Fig. 8C and D) did not show any amine peak only little change in the rubbery region storage modulus in sec-
at 6,500 cm21; so any amine that may have formed was prob- ond cycle, which may very well fall within the standard devia-
ably in the undetectable range. tion range.
Molecular weight between crosslinks (Mc) of coatings C1
Clear Coatings Properties and C2 was determined from rubbery plateau storage modulus
Table 2 shows the properties of clear coatings C1 and C2. using Eq. 1. The theoretical Mc of a stoichiometrically balanced
Despite post-curing at 808C for 4 h, coatings C1 and C2 con- Epon 828 and amidoamine-I system was calculated to be 623 g/
tained 7–8 wt% residual solvent (boiling points of BzOH and mol, and the experimental Mc values of both C1 and C2 coat-
PGME are 205 and 1188C, respectively). Both coatings ings were reasonably close to the expected value. In addition,
the nominal difference of Mc between the first and second DGEBA-based epoxy resins exhibit total water uptake of 0.5–5
cycles of both coatings C1 and C2 suggested that the chemical wt%. The free films studied here exhibited similar behaviors
changes (observed via mid-IR of post heated samples) between with values of 0.75 and < 1.5 wt% for coatings C1 and C2,
cycles have negligible effect on the coatings network. Compari- respectively. Water sorption of coating C1 decreased after
son of storage moduli across the glassy state in first and second achieving equilibrium, probably due to leaching of residual sol-
cycles indicated anti-plasticization at sub-ambient temperatures, vent from the film. Polymer hydroplasticization followed by
either due to residual solvent occupying the free volume within water sorption would allow for greater mobility of polymer
the polymer without swelling and resulting in a net decrease of chains, which would result in solvent being released into the
free volume or being involved in strong intermolecular interac- water and a decrease in overall sample mass. A morphological
tions with polymer chains that provided molecular level rein- difference between the two systems could also be responsible
forcement against glassy state (sub-Tg) motions [36–38]. The for the water sorption differences with more or less densely
intermolecular interactions between solvent molecules and poly- crosslinked regions allowing for greater polymer–water
mer chains are favored by the hydroxyl groups of residual interactions.
PGME and BzOH. Anti-plasticization lowers the Tg but During cure of an epoxy–amidoamine system, we can expect
increases the resistance to deformation at sub-Tg temperatures. epoxy–amine, epoxy–hydroxyl etherification, epoxy–epoxy
Figure 10B shows water sorption data of coatings C1 and C2 homopolymerization, epoxy–amide NH, and hydroxyl–amide
measured via immersion technique. Several researchers have esterification reactions. Epoxy–amine reactions occurred at
investigated the water sorption properties of bulk epoxy thermo- ambient as well as at elevated temperatures in case of Epon 828
sets [39–41] and fully formulated epoxy-based coatings [8, 42], and amidoamine-I blend as has been reported by others. The
and found a range of water sorption and transport behaviors that amide NH in N-methyl acetamide did not react with epoxide up
were influenced by a multitude of factors such as polymer to 1508C, suggesting that the amide NH in amidoamine-I was
chemistry, substrate, pigments, and residual solvents. In general, also unlikely to react with Epon 828 under similar conditions.
First Second First Second First Second First Second First Second
Coatings cycle cycle cycle cycle cycle cycle cycle cycle cycle cycle