Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Succession planning is a business strategy that has ities and also provide insights for future development
recently gained attention in the healthcare litera- of healthcare succession planning frameworks.
ture, primarily because of nursing shortage con-
cerns and the demand for retaining knowledgeable Succession planning is an essential proactive busi-
personnel to meet organizational needs. Little re- ness strategy to ensure that internal, qualified can-
search has been conducted in healthcare settings didates are continuously identified and available to
that clearly defines best practices for succession take up leadership positions when vacancies occur.1,2
planning frameworks. To effectively carry out such It is a process that allows retention of intellectual
organizational strategies during these challenging and knowledge capital by identifying and prepar-
times, an integrative review of succession planning ing potential successors to assume new roles, thus
in healthcare was performed to identify consisten- encouraging individual advancement.3-5 Succession
cies in theoretical approaches and strategies for planning is a topic that has recently moved to the
chief nursing officers and healthcare managers to forefront of healthcare planning because of current
initiate. Selected articles were compared with busi- and forthcoming nursing shortages.6 The number
ness succession planning to determine whether health- of entry-level nurses is already not keeping pace
care strategies were similar to best practices already with those leaving the profession.7 If qualified per-
established in business contexts. The results of this sonnel are not retained and prepared to assume
integrative review will aid leaders and managers leadership roles, facilities could find themselves lack-
to use succession planning as a tool in their recruit- ing experienced personnel when most needed.8 This
ment, retention, mentoring, and administration activ- situation adds to the importance of succession plan-
ning within healthcare organizational practices. Be-
fore losing this wealth of knowledge and expertise,
healthcare leaders and managers should be practis-
Authors’ Affiliations: Captain (Mr Carriere), Canadian Forces,
Edmonton, Alberta; PhD Candidate, Faculty of Physical Education ing succession planning now to meet future orga-
and Recreation, and Research Assistant (Ms Muise); Associate nizational needs.
Professor and Principal Investigator, CLEAR (Connecting Leader- Within the business community, succession plan-
ship Education and Research) Outcomes Research Program
(Dr Cummings); Associate Professor and Associate Dean ning historically began with family-owned busi-
(Dr Newburn-Cook), Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta, nesses3 but is now integrated into frameworks with
Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. common strategies and practices.4,5,9-12 In contrast,
Corresponding author: Dr Cummings, Faculty of Nursing,
CSB 5-125, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada T6G chief nursing officers (CNOs) and healthcare man-
2G3 (gretac@ualberta.ca). agers have been slower to recognize the need for suc-
Funding: Dr Greta Cummings is supported by a New cession planning in general, and there is little research
Investigator Award, Canadian Institutes of Health Research,
and a Population Health Investigator award, Alberta Heritage regarding recommended best practices among suc-
Foundation for Medical Research. cession planning frameworks within the healthcare
Copyright @ 2009 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
literature. With recent increases in marketplace career developments, thereafter setting and pursu-
and financial pressures in healthcare management, ing career goals,15 focused at the individual level.
concerns for more resources and attention are be- Career development is focused at an organizational
ing devoted to its business operations.13 This has level16 to meet employee needs through their career
led to a shift in focus toward a more business- stages to reduce turnover, increase professional knowl-
oriented approach to healthcare decision making, edge, and improve service quality.17 Although ca-
placing the need for succession planning at the reer planning and career development were defined
forefront of healthcare organizational planning by differently in the literature, several authors used
managers and leaders. Nevertheless, nursing short- them interchangeably.18,19 Career development has
ages remain a current and complex challenge faced been mistaken for succession planning, despite
by those who manage healthcare environments. To being identified as only part of the process in both
assist healthcare leaders in dealing with workforce business and healthcare succession planning liter-
challenges, an integrative review was performed ature.3,9,11,12 Career ladders are a way of providing
to determine whether findings among available re- status and economic incentives, often professional
search in healthcare literature reveal best practices. development, to workers who stay within an organi-
The purpose of this article is to present findings from zation.20 Mentorship is a distinct type of relation-
the integrative review of healthcare succession plan- ship where mentors provide professional or personal
ning to identify similarities and differences among guidance to a protégé.21 Identifying ambiguity in
the theoretical frameworks in business and com- these terms is important to distinguish contrasts in
bine these into a common strategy for healthcare healthcare succession planning frameworks.
managers. The integrative review, based on restructured
The authors believe that a precise succession methodology recommended by Whittemore and
planning framework that includes strategies from Knafl,22 began with a preliminary literature search
best business practices can guide and promote suc- using the following keywords: succession planning
cession planning within healthcare organizations. and succession management individually, each com-
Three questions guided the integrative review: (1) bined with nurse, nursing, or healthcare. The results
How are healthcare succession planning frame- identified that enough pertinent literature was pre-
works similar or different? (2) Are these frameworks sent in various databases using the term succession
similar to business literature examples? (3) What planning, a term historically important to business
are the strategies implied by these frameworks for planning.3 Succession management, a synonymic
healthcare organization? Articles were reviewed and equivalent, was used to capture all seminal articles.
analyzed based on type of literature (theoretical, Twelve online databases were searched using the
research, other), framework congruency and differ- keywords succession planning and succession man-
ences, and similarities with business models. agement in separate searches for the time period of
1998-2008. These databases are recorded as an
initial search in Table 1. Those meeting the follow-
ing inclusion criteria were retained for screening: all
The Review Method articles relating to healthcare succession planning,
Before conducting the integrative review, ‘‘succession for either the chief executive officer (CEO) or the
planning’’ was differentiated from similar and com- CNO position, with a framework, template, or ap-
monly used terminology. Online database searches proach to implement best practices as the article’s
of career development, career planning, retention, focus. Articles that specifically focused on research
career ladder, and mentoring confirmed that each of succession planning were not chosen because of
had different definitions, meanings, and uses when their limited number, and commentaries, editorials,
compared with succession planning in both busi- and articles that did not present a complete succes-
ness and healthcare literature. Succession planning sion planning framework were excluded. For arti-
is a structured process involving the identification cles with business succession planning frameworks,
and preparation of a potential successor to assume Business Source Complete, ABI Inform Global,
a new role within an organization.3 In the liter- Academic Search Complete, PsycInfo, and Social
ature, there are also similar strategies to succession Sciences Full Text were searched.
planning. Succession management is a formalized To ensure that the most relevant articles were
process of role planning and leadership develop- chosen, the primary author reviewed titles and ab-
ment to ensure that the leadership pipeline is filled stracts using the inclusion criteria, and the selected
and the right talent is available when required.14 articles were then agreed upon through consensus
Career planning is the process of outlining future with a second reader to reduce bias. The theoretical
Copyright @ 2009 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Table 1. Search Strategy
Database 1998-2008 Search Terms Returned Selected Included
Abbreviations: CINAHL, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature; EMBASE, Excerpta Medica Database; ERIC, Education
Resources information Center.
The ‘‘Selected’’ column numbers are associated with advanced searches, where articles were limited to those with full text and abstracts.
frameworks and critical elements of the retained candidacy development plan and an evaluation pro-
articles were described, and specific strategies for cess to ensure that the succession planning frame-
effective succession planning were extracted. Arti- work performed as expected.
cles were analyzed using the questions guiding the
integrative review to determine congruence, differ- Theoretical Frameworks and Strategies
ence, and comparison with business succession plan- Of the 8 healthcare articles that discussed succes-
ning frameworks. sion planning frameworks, 4 articles7,23-25 predom-
inantly described the critical elements of effective
succession planning strategies. Describing addi-
Results tional features of a succession planning framework,
A total of 1,419 titles and abstracts were reviewed, Collins and Collins8 reviewed the succession plan-
with 122 meeting the inclusion criteria for health- ning process as a systematic preparation of the next
care succession planning. These were retrieved and generation, whereas Rollins26 examined the success
rescreened, and duplicates were removed, leaving 8 of implementing a succession planning conceptual
retained from all databases (see Table 2 for the framework through a case study. Two remaining
characteristics of the included studies). Eighteen arti- articles1,27 illustrated how to follow a succession
cles specific to business succession planning were planning process. From all articles, 8 common strat-
selected separately, with 5 used for comparison with egies were identified, using a qualitative content
healthcare succession planning frameworks.4,5,9-12 analysis, and are discussed in relationship to their
The healthcare succession planning models were application to succession planning in healthcare
comparable with the selected business succession organizations (Table 3). These succession planning
planning models, which all recommended planning, strategies are strategic planning, identifying desired
recognizing the importance of clarifying expectations skills and needs, identifying key positions, detect-
and future needs, and identifying future leaders as ing possible succession candidates, mentoring and
imperative steps in succession planning. Further- coaching, further developmental processes, resource
more, all selected business articles stressed having a allocation, and evaluation.
Copyright @ 2009 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Table 2. Characteristics of Included Manuscripts
Author (Year) Journal Country Design Purpose/Objective Setting
Blouin and Nursing United Theory Discusses how healthcare lags Hospitals and
McDonagh Management States behind other corporate health systems
(2006) organizations in creating a
succession plan and provides
practical approaches for
succession planning, identifying
key elements
Bolton and Journal of United Theoretical Describes the critical elements of Healthcare
Roy (2006) Nursing States instruction a succession plan and suggests organizations
Administration ways to implement them
Bonczek and Journal of United Theoretical Describes steps for succession Healthcare
Woodward Nursing States instruction planning, stating its importance organizations
(2004) Administration
Collins and The Health Care United Theoretical Provides a framework for improving Healthcare
Collins Manager States analysis the systematic preparation of the organizations
(2007) next generation of managers
by analyzing the succession
planning process
Husting and Nursing United Theoretical Describes required steps for Healthcare facilities
Alderman Management States instruction succession planning and how
(2001) to phase it in
Noyes et al Seminars for United Theory Identifies how critical succession Hospitals
(2002) Nurse States planning can be to an
Managers organization and discusses
succession planning steps
Redman Journal of United Theoretical Identifies the essential needs that Healthcare industry
(2006) Nursing States instruction individuals face when developing
Administration a cadre of available leaders
through succession planning
Rollins (2003) Healthcare United Qualitative Identifies the benefits of succession Multi-institutional
Executive States analysis and planning and describes the healthcare
theoretical necessary steps using a specific system
instruction organization as an example
Copyright @ 2009 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Table 3. Common Succession Planning Framework Strategies in the Healthcare Literature
552
Identification Other
of Desired Needs Identification of Detection of Mentoring and Developmental Resource
Author (Year) Strategic Planning and Skills Key Positions Candidates Coaching Processes Allocation Evaluation
Blouin and Demand forecasting Early and frequent Formal and informal Exposure to For leadership When desirable
McDonagh and gap analysis detection development development successors leave
(2006) for key positions competency the organization
opportunities
Bolton and Identify key and Identify potential Mentoring Commit time
Roy (2006) new positions candidates and financial
resources
Bonczek and Define strategic Current nurse Determine who Mentor and coach Develop an
Woodward imperative of leaders identify possesses aspiring leaders education and
(2004) organization leadership skills necessary growth plan
and talents to skills; possible
replace themselves acceleration pool
Collins and Evaluate short- and Examine gaps Identify key areas Analyze skills/ Identify Time, energy, Extensive evaluation
Collins long-term between existing and their core resources of development and employees program of
(2007) goals; match skills and core competencies available process of formalization,
organizational competencies of candidates proposed control and
goals with proposed position successor information
candidacy pool systems, political
and technical
criteria, staff role
and business impact
Husting and Conduct strategic Identify current job Assess current job Identify Mentoring and Assess learning and Part of the Extensive evaluation
Alderman planning requirement and requirements, high-potential coaching development evaluation process of program:
(2001) future positions future positions, candidates needs of organization,
and future participants objectives, and
competency participants
requirements
Noyes et al Determine purpose Identify and assess Mentorship Formalized
(2002) and vision of high-potential program developmental
organization; candidates plan involving
conduct strategic multiple skill sets
planning
Redman Identify desirable skills Assess specific Assess individuals Mentoring and Use a transparent, Assessment, periodic
(2006) and qualities for positions in terms of coaching flexible process evaluation, and
successors; analyze (competencies, leadership to develop improvement as
gaps comparing desired qualities, capabilities/ high-potential needed
talent pool future needs) potential employees
Rollins (2003) General Identify the talents, Plan describes skills
characteristics skills, and and experiences
and requirements characteristics needed, along with
of future leaders and assess the timeline to achieve
leadership skills these; assign
of those involved managers new
Copyright @ 2009 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
responsibilities
outside area
of expertise
Copyright @ 2009 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
who exhibit behaviors and values outside of the Summary
training environment. Proper regular evaluation to
ensure a framework’s performance is optimal and In examining the current literature, we found exam-
meets the organization’s expectations is both nec- ples of approaches to succession planning in health-
essary and feasible. care contexts; however, to date, no best-practices
Collins and Collins8 suggested multiple ap- framework for implementation has emerged. To
proaches to evaluate the succession planning process. mitigate knowledge loss, current CNOs and health-
These included evaluating policies and procedures care leaders need to integrate succession planning
used in the succession planning process (formal- with organizational needs by developing and pro-
ization), ensuring delivery of equal and appropriate moting its best resources into future leadership posi-
use of power and attention (control systems), eval- tions. Although there is a body of literature on
uating how selection decisions are based (technical succession planning in healthcare organizations, the
criteria), criteria for selection (political criteria), lack of a best-practices succession planning frame-
degree of involvement of all applicable personnel work may be due to inconsistently defined concepts,
(staff role), and how data are statistically or finan- leading to potential confusion and lack of concept
cially measured (business impact). These processes clarity. This is not conducive to best practices and
included return on investment, patient satisfaction, may lead to inconsistent implementation of succes-
and evaluation of resource allocation. Only this sion planning.
framework identified transition issues of predeces- Findings from the integrative literature review
sor to successor, possible feelings of rejection by suggest the need for best practices in succession
those not selected, and means to address them. planning, and 8 such strategies were identified for
healthcare managers. Implementation of these strat-
Differentiating Frameworks egies will assist CNOs to identify internal successor
Beyond these 8 strategies, the separation of succes- candidates. This will provide employees with a
sion planning into 2 distinct processes differentiated leadership goal to strive for and may also reduce
the succession planning frameworks. Collins and poaching of established leaders from other orga-
Collins8 treated the first 5 strategies of succession nizations. Furthermore, fostering mentoring/coaching
planning as one process and the evaluation phase relationships initiates camaraderie as staff members
of succession planning as another. Alternatively, and leaders develop relationships, recognizing sim-
Noyes et al27 separated the development of organi- ilarities in skills and aptitudes, as opposed to
zational strategies from the creation and implemen- differences.
tation of personalized plans. Redman25 replicated The establishment of team building, although
this approach using Noyes et al27 as a template for not specifically identified within the current literature
his recommended framework. as an outcome of the mentoring/coaching strategy,
Nevertheless, from the common strategies in all is a logical progression considering that personal
frameworks, a best-practices model would include interactions will occur. Encouraging both predeces-
the need for strategic planning before considering sors and successors to participate in the evaluation
a succession planning process or developing a suc- process will ensure that the succession plan ad-
cession planning framework. The desired skills of dresses stakeholder needs. More research needs to
candidates need to be identified, ensuring that or- be directed toward establishing a best-practices
ganizational needs are met. Key positions that re- succession planning framework for healthcare that
quire succession planning need to be recognized and is informed by business succession planning. This
possible succession candidates identified. Then, a will not only provide consistency in succession plan-
development plan should be implemented to ensure ning in healthcare but also establish frameworks
that potential succession candidates acquire all conducive to optimal employee satisfaction, organi-
skills required for the position. This includes pro- zational efficiency, and better patient care. These
cesses that focus on both individual and generalized positive responses could resonate outside the health-
components; however, from the literature, it is care facility and attract long-term employees who
imperative that mentoring/coaching be included. are looking for an enduring employer-employee
The appropriate allocation of resources is also neces- relationship that will hone their skills. Implement-
sary to ensure that the succession plan has appro- ing a successful succession planning framework will
priate funding, time, and energy. Once the succession ensure that healthcare organizations survive leader-
plan is implemented, evaluation is essential to ensure ship changes as effectively as possible, supporting
that the framework is on track and includes all organizational goals and the opportunity for em-
aspects of the process. ployees to develop to their potential.
Copyright @ 2009 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
References
1. Bonczek ME, Woodward EK. Who’ll replace you when you’re 16. Gunz HP, Jalland RM, Evans MG. New strategy, wrong
gone? Nurs Manag. 2006;37(8):31-34. managers? What you need to know about career streams. Acad
2. Schmalzried H, Fallon F Jr. Succession planning for local Manag Exec. 1998;12(2):21-37.
health department top executives: reducing risk to commun- 17. Chang P, Chou Y, Cheng F. Designing career development
ities. J Community Health. 2007;32(3):169-180. programs through understanding of nurses’ career needs.
3. Garman AN, Glawe J. Succession planning. Consult Psychol J Nurses Staff Dev. 2006;22(5):246-253.
J Pract Res. 2004;56(2):119-128. 18. McGillis-Hall L, Waddell J, Donner G, Wheeler MM.
4. Rothwell WJ. Succession planning for future success. Strateg Outcomes of a career planning and development program
HR Rev. 2002;1(3):30-33. for registered nurses. Nurs Econ. 2004;22(5):231-238.
5. Rothwell WJ. Putting success into your succession planning. 19. Umiker M. Staff career development programs: the role of
J Bus Strategy. 2002;23(3):32-37. supervisors. Health Care Superv. 1998;17(1):12-16.
6. Goudreau KA, Hardy J. Succession planning and individual 20. Shapiro MM. A career ladder based on Benner’s model:
development. J Nurs Adm. 2006;36(6):313-318. an analysis of expected outcomes. J Nurs Adm. 1998;28(3):
7. Bolton J, Roy W. Succession planning: securing the future. 13-19.
J Nurs Adm. 2004;34(12):589-593. 21. Murphy P. Mentors offer footsteps to follow. Men Nurs.
8. Collins SK, Collins KS. Changing workforce demographics 2006;August:50-55.
necessitates succession planning in health care. Health Care 22. Whittemore R, Knafl K. The integrative review: updated
Manag. 2007;26(4):318-325. methodology. J Adv Nurs. 2005;52(5):546-553.
9. Aquila AJ. Key best practices for succession planning. 23. Blouin AS, McDonagh KJ. Leading tomorrow’s healthcare
Accounting Today. 2007;21(11):23. organizations: strategies and tactics for effective succession
10. Burns-Martin T. How to: here are 10 tips on developing a planning. J Nurs Adm. 2006;36(6):325-330.
succession planning program. T & D. 2002;November:15. 24. Husting PM, Alderman M. Replacement ready? Succession
11. Ibarra P. Succession planning: an idea whose time has come. planning tops health care administrators’ priorities. Nurs
Public Manag. 2005;87(January):18-24. Manag. 2001;September:45-50.
12. Miles SA, Dysart TL. Roadmap for successful succession 25. Redman RW. Leadership succession planning: an evidence-
planning. Directors & Boards. 2008;First Quarter:57-59. based approach for managing the future. J Nurs Adm. 2006;
13. Abrams MN. Succeeding at succession planning. Health 36(6):292-297.
Forum J. 2002;45(1):27-29. 26. Rollins G. Succession planning: laying the foundation for
14. Vestal K. Succession management: a key to future leadership. smooth transitions and effective succession planning. Healthc
Nurse Lead. 2004;April:10-11. Exec. 2003;18(6):14-21.
15. Zikiz J, Klehe U. Job loss as a blessing in disguise: the role 27. Noyes BJ, McNally K, Tourville S, Robinson P. Preparing
of career exploration and career planning in predicting tomorrow’s leaders through succession planning from the pro-
reemployment quality. J Vocat Behav. 2006;69:391-409. vider perspective. Semin Nurse Manag. 2002;10(4):240-243.
Copyright @ 2009 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.