Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ralph Godau
Received (in revised form): 24th February, 2008
Bass Strait
counnunity. This encompasses the organi- INTEGRATING ASSET MANAGEMENT
sation as a whole, and tbereiore requires a Table 1 provides examples of bow asset
holistic approach to the implementation management must be considered in the
and application of asset management. planning, service delivery and provision of
This paper explores Brimbank's asset asset services. The activities cannot be con-
management journey to date (see Figure 2). sidered in isolation, as a change in any of
Social phinniiiy (strategic focus) What type of service delivery and level ot service is
— Principally designed to support growth needed now and into the future? And by whom?
— Optimising private sector investment What facilities" options arc available to support the
— Gaining community support various types of service delivery? What arc the
Service delivery (operational focus) current and projected service levels? What are the
— Principally designed to support existing community's priorities?
Community services How well is the existing facility supporting a
specific service delivery and level of service? What
is the current capability of the facility, and how
well docs it support future service delivery and
level of service options? Is this in line with best
value (eg have comparative studies or
benchmarking been undertaken)? Docs chis meet
current community expectations?
Asset services (nssct/facility focus) How efficient and effective is the provision of asset
services (undertaking capital works, maintenance
programmes, emergency response) required to
support a specific service delivery and level of
service? Is this in line with best value?
Julo 3 Jan-S* Ju|.O4 OS Jul 05 Jan-ee Jiri-OS im-07 Jul-D7 Jin 08 Jul 08
(<n^Up Bc^t Vïlric Rciitvi
AsfM S*i<fio*s wllMn Coapoial* Sciviecs
w Assíí Minigfmíni Mïnjgei j i N » AMIS S>sl«k AtMniEtrit«
sM 0>(4 Colkellon and Condiltoa Sw**)s. Val« allons. Anal|sis & Mode Ring
Muni^ip^l fi.i-:airiitií'ti ol Viiifiin |MAV) A^jc' M?^a^c'hch• ^tcpPro^r^m ^Orpootnaf Insuitf; (Risk & Co(n(Awic« Audt Amuia Audiloi (â»n«r«l (Fm*nc(
Asset Management Reggla^tonrCompHancc % R«pO(ting
riTií? (DVCJ - A?=?l MaAa^ciTicrhf PvflofmanccTVklEVUfAlWjllly)
vieuF'd& leilÍHmrd GIS uMidFi Implen Geling new < psiHc.widc o s »Itwln
BIS k Dvmt^apMo Wof nation SuppoiI
them, will impact on the other. From a toria (MAV) established the Asset Manage-
planning perspective, an increase in levels ment Step i*rogram in 2002. This provides
of service may result in the need for councils with a framework of best practice,
greater capacity in service dehvery and allowing councils to as.sess their current
result in the need for more facilities and asset management performance in a range
therefore increase the council's repair/ of areas. Brimbank joined the Step Pro-
maintenance requirements. Every time a gram in 2003. joining 78 other councils in
new facility is constructed, it comes with a Victoria. The Step Program is now being
lifetime of costs that the council must exported to other states, with councils in
fund. The concept of financial sustainabii- Western Australia, Tasmania, New South
ity becomes an issue and asset management Wales and Queensland joining the initia-
is the tool which can be used to demon- tive."
strate it. Benchmarking of councils in Victoria
This is fiirther complicated by the politi- was undertaken and aligned with the key
cal scene, where the agendas of councillors, recommendations from the 2003 strategic
lobby groups and residents will influence asset management implementation plan.
the planning process, often resulting in less These were:
than optimal outcomes. For example, when
faced with decisions to construct or extend • development of policies, strategies, and
facilities that will benefit only a small part asset management plans;
of the community at the expense of other • implementation of asset management
initiatives, asset management data must information systems;
provide the means to inform the commu- • asset data collection and condition
nity about the consequences of such deci- surveys;
sions. • asset management analysis and
modelling.
PREPARATORY STAGE
Early initiatives involved examining the Feedback from other councils clearly high-
existing documentation and the work lighted that a lack of corporate support
already in progress at other councils. An was a barrier to the implementation of
asset management audit was conducted by asset management.
consultants in 2002, and a strategic asset
management implementation plan was ESTABLISHING THE CORPORATE
developed the following year. The emphasis ASSET MANAGEMENT FUNCTION
and staging of the recommendations were Brimbank's CEC^ and executive manage-
reviewed and realigned to match the imple- ment team believed that by adopting an
mentation programme needed by Brim- enterprise asset management approach to
bank City Council. all levels of the organisation they could
Research into the application of asset transform the council from a reactive
management by other councils identified organisation to one that could operate
very little change since the findings proactively and more strategically. This
reported by Godau in 2003,' and it was involved embracing a five-year asset man-
acknowledged that the writings covering agement improvement programme sup-
local goverinncnt asset management did ported and driven from the top down.
not refiect what was actually happening on Brimbank wanted integration of service
the ground. Due to the lack of progress in planning, service delivery assessment and
this area, the Municipal Association of Vic- asset management, through involvement
across the whole organisation to develop ACCOUNTING FOR AND REPORTING
and implement asset management practices, ON ASSET MANAGEMENT
policies, strategies and asset management The executive management team estab-
plans. lished the asset management steering com-
In early 2004, Brimbank City Council mittee (AMSC), which required the full
underwent a restructure and took the participation of the executive team, man-
opportunity to form asset services as a ager, asset services and, when required,
corporate function by integrating the key experts from various departments
key functions of asset, spatial and demo- including information technology and
graphic iuformation management and engineering. Table 2 represents how the
strategic asset management. In an internal role and accountabilities associated with
document, asset services was scoped as: asset management were aligned with who
was providing the service planning, asset
'providing a range of asset, geographical management planning, technical support,
(GIS) and demographic information, maintenance and other support tunctions
and asset management services to (eg fmance, information technology etc).
support both strategic and operational In the earlier stages, the focus of the
decision making across all departments AMSC was on the implementation and
to improve evidence based planning and management of the asset management
operational performance'. improvement programme.
• operations, where response times and stormwater, facilities and open space assets
interventions are within acceptable (refer to Table 3 which quantifies the range
community levels. of assets Brimbank City Council is responsi-
ble for).
EMERGING NEED TO FILL
ORGANISATIONAL GAPS: THE OPEN
IMPLEMENTATION OF A CUSTOMER
SPACE PLANNER & PROPERTY
AND ASSET MANAGEMENT
MANAGER
INFORMATION SYSTEM
The ability for a council to deal with any
In partnersliip with the IT unit, an internal
particular issue with existing resourcing is
audit was carried out in 2003 to identity
highlighted when attempting to fill in the
and report on the asset data systems and
gaps in the AMPs. Two areas that lacked
sources currently held within the council.
the resourcing were open space planning
The audit resulted in the identification
and facilities/property management.
of over 60 spreadsheets and databases of
REVISITING THE WAY DATA varying quality, level of duplication and
COLLECTION AND CONDITION currency, lack of accessibility, and as such,
SURVEYS ARE CONDUCTED not used in any real form of analysis or
One of the most difficult areas to address decision making. It was apparent that an
has been that ot data collection and condi- intormation management framework had
tion surveys. The inconsistent and often not been developed tor the council.
duplicated data collection activities, lack of The data model given in Figure 3 was
data spécifications, data allowed to go out developed in conjunction with IT to ex-
of date, poor data quality practices, inabil- plore the concept of an enterprise approach
ity to analyse data, reliance on consultants which maximises integration rather than
to do the analysis etc required considerable interfacing.
improvement. In late 2003, Brimbank City Council
An early project was the collection of tendered for a customer and asset manage-
data on 70,000 street trees in 2003/04. The ment information system and selected the
asset management information system had Confirm Enterprise software solution
not yet been purchased and not much (from Southbank Systems, now owned by
thought had gone into how to analyse the Pitney Bowes Maplnfo) in late 2004. The
data once collected. With the involvement
oí park services, risk management and asset
services, a realistic data specification was Table 3: Asset register in Confirm comprises
developed. Once the data were collected, (as at December 2007)
the main problems were deciding who
would analyse the data and how was it Buildings 251
going to be kept up to date. The asset ser- Bridges & culverts 41
vices group provided limited analysis, iden- Conservation zones 97
tifying high-risk trees for follow-up action. Land titles 2562
The data have since been imported into Footpath segments 12,366
the asset management information system, Maintenance assets 1116
Playgrounds 178
and the asset services group is working with
Sportsgrounds 65
park services to ensure their ongoing Trees 87,354
upkeep. Traffic signals 137
Data collection and condition surveys are Park & sporting assets 18.000
also being addressed in the areas of roads.
Figure 3: Data model
tender included the need to undertake Over three months, intensive training of
business process workshops and reviews, 20 expert users was conducted, as well as a
develop data transfer and configuration month of testing the customer request
specifications, import data and configure system and site/asset registers. Ongoing
the software, and provide onsite training training to service unit champions in the
(train-the-trainer techniques) and other customer request system was offered. In
support functions (eg installation, testing order to go live with everything at the
etc). The basis for selection was price, user same time, the maintenance and condition
acceptance, and compliance with the survey modules were activated without a
tender specification, feedback from refer- standard testing phase. This was incorpo-
ence sites, vendor expertise and experience. rated in the operational phase of the first
Brimbank City Council went "live' to few months and created a lot pressure for
all statf with Confirm Enterprise in Octo- the engineering and operational statf in the
ber 2006. The arrangement was based on a early stages. To offset this, the Confirm
site licence, moving away from the tradi- consultants worked full-time with the
tional pay per module/person cost model, engineering and operational staff in the
which often limits user access and rollout first two weeks and then returned twice in
across the organisation. the next six months to review and assist
The 'going live' date was postponed with further development.
twice due to a lack of readiness caused by To date, over 50,000 maintenance jobs
conflicting priorities and a lack of resources have been created in Confirm Enterprise,
to ensure full operational functionality. with only 3,000 Jobs outstanding. In addi-
The CEO set the 'drop dead' date, which tion, 156,000 defects (faults found on
sent a clear message that staif priorities had assets) have been logged or imported into
to be rearranged to ensure that the new- Confirm Enterprise as a result of field con-
live date was achieved successfully. dition surveys etc.
Why asset management should be a corporate tunction
1 of 1 Close
concept of gaining access to Trim records REAL ASSET MANAGEMENT HAS ONLY
is becoming a reality. Brimbank worked JUST BEGUN...
with Pitney Bowes Maplnfo to facilitate The following are some examples of what
the link between Exponare and Trim — is happening now.
this was completed at the end of 2007.
Work on the Confirm and Trim hnk is Data capture
plainied for 2008/09. Introducing an asset management informa-
Pitney Bowes Maplnfo has been tion system such as Confirm Enterprise cre-
engaged to develop the integration with ates considerable pressure for the capture of
Exponare and this work was expected to field data in an accurate and timely manner.
be completed by early 2008. This has been Brimbank has trialled six IPaqs (mobile
delayed owing to technical ditficulties and computers) utilising Confirni's mobile
has been broken up into two stages (to applications with varying success (issues
meet urgent functional requirements). The with speed, mapping/GPS, memory etc). It
first stage was completed by July 2{)(}8 and is clear that the greatest challenge is to
it is expected that the second stage w^ill be adopt this technology to deal with the mas-
completed by October 2008. sive increases in data and to avoid adininis-
tration meltdown due to manual proces- pcrtormance against the conncirs service
sing. New mobile models have been evalu- commitments will be refined.
ated and the purchase of two field-specific
mobile handhelds is in progress. As part of Data quality
the forward planning process, a three-year Improvement ot existing records is a prior-
mobile application programme business ity as those who rely on this information
case is currently being prepared tor submis- are now keen to keep it up to date.
sion to the 2008/09 budget. Improvement
projects have started converting paper- BENEFITS OF APPLYING A CORPORATE
based processes so they are electronically APPROACH TO ASSET MANAGEMENT
embedded with the Confirm Enterprise The benefits are evident from;
software, involving collaboration between
engineering and operations staff. • the rapid improvement of the MAV
'Step' Program asset management
Forward planning balanced scorecard from an average 'D'
A review of the annual capital works pro- rating to one of As and Bs;
cess is currently underway to take into • a reduction in risk through improved
account the long-term asset management management of assets;
position and service planning needs. The • improved service delivery through
direction envisaged by the current CEO, improved asset management planning
Nick Foa, leads to the existing one-year and analysis; and
capital works programme being developed • changes in financial strategies to address
into an approved three-year rolling pro- the issue of asset liabihties.
gramme by the 2009/10 financial year.
Brimbank could only have achieved this
internal relationships outcome in the short timefranie because
There has been a significant improvement the transition of asset management to a
in the relationship between operations and corporate function was championed and
customer services through regtilar consul- supported by both the previous and cur-
tation and constructive feedback. rent CEOs. The council was fortunate that
the current CEO is also an advocate for
Valuation and reconciliation asset management and is keen to raise the
The first round of asset valuation is bar in terms of improving the quality of
planned for 2007/08. This will be done decision making within the council.
within Confirm Enterprise (for buildings, It is important to acknowledge the
land, footpaths and roads) and reconciled importance of having a high-level cham-
with existing registers held by the finance pion who provided the leadership and
unit. The realignment of account numbers commitment. This became particularly
(f>om service unit groupings) to suit activ- relevant as most of the issues were about
ity-based costing is planned to provide (1) developing capability and (2) change
better information on where money is management, which needed to be driven
being spent. This project is subject to the tVom the top down.
decision on the future of the existing finan- The success to date is also due to the
cial system, which is expected in 2008/09. commitment of staff who acknowledged
and took on the ehallcngc they were
Data extraction otfered. They came from asset services,
Extracting data tt) analyse and measure finance, GIS, IT, human services, engineer-
Why asset management should be a corporate function
ing and operations, customer service and self-assessment of its current asset manage-
risk management to name just a few. ment capability and commitments to a
These champions provided the bottom-up long-term programme of organisational
perspective that is so important in provid- development and learning.
ing the building blocks to embed asset
management in the organisation.
REFERENCES
(1) Godau, R. (2003) "Key relationships per-
CONCLUSION ceived by decision makers in the technical
Brimbank City Council's asset manage- management of infrastructure: grounded
ment journey is about building organisa- theoretical models', unpublished FhD
tional capacity to ensure it is able to meet thesis, RMÍT University.
and sustain the needs and expectations of (2) Municipal Association of Victoria (2{)()5)
the community. This case study highlights 'The final step', available at: http://
that it takes time and effort to enable the www.mav.asn.au/bulletins.nsf/name/536/
organisation to develop competence in the SFile/()306.pdf?OpcnEIement (accessed
application of asset management and inte- 2nth February, 2008).
grate it into the way the council conducts (3) Institute of Public Works Engineering
Australia and Association of Local Govem-
business. This cannot be done successfully
ment Engineering NZ (2002) 'International
without the support of the CEO.
Infrastructure Management Manual';
By sharing Brimbank City Council's revised edition available .it: http://www.
endeavours, it is hoped that others may ipwea.org.au/up]oad/nMM_iirticie_2()()6.
learn and benefit from the council's experi- pdf (accessed 20 February, 2(K)8).
ences, and that feedback might be obtained (4) Brimbank City Council, 'Demographies',
from those who have travelled further into available at: http://www.brimbank.vic.gov
the asset management journey. It is impor- .au/Page/page.asp?Page_ld — 379&'h = 0
tant for any organisation to undertake a (accessed 20th February, 2008).