Flow Control November 2019 PDF
Flow Control November 2019 PDF
& Steam
Generators
Considerations for fluid flow
in power generation equipment
Also Inside
FLUID
Density
The effects of
temperature and
pressure
Also Inside
Performing a storage
tank risk assessment
Connect
SOLUTIONS FOR FLUID MOVEMENT, MEASUREMENT & CONTAINMENT
Magazine Like us
Subscribe to our print or digital edition on Facebook
E-News Follow us
Sign up for Flow Control newsletters on Twitter
GF Piping Systems
NEW!
Features & Benefits
• No moving parts
GF Piping Systems
9271 Jeronimo Road, Irvine, CA 92618
Phone (714) 731-8800 • Toll Free (800) 854-4090 • e-mail: us.ps@georgfischer.com www.gfps.com
subscribe today.
Flow Control is the voice of fluid handling professionals
in the Process Flow Network, which provides solutions
for the process industries and includes Processing
and Water Technology.
Essential
PROCESS
CONTROL
Automation isn’t optional
Also Inside
Flowmeter accuracy
flowcontrolnetwork.com/subscribe
Table of Contents | November 2019 • Vol. XXV, No. 11
Cover Story
10 The flow of fluids in boilers and
steam generators
By Amin Almasi
Practical guidelines are presented for a range
of boilers and steam generators — from small,
simple boilers to large, complex multisection
steam generators for large industrial facilities.
Features
13 Using digital instrumentation to
10
transition to a digital-enabled plant
By David Lincoln, ABB Measurement & Analytics
When it comes to instrumentation, digital’s benefits
over older analog-based units make it the logical
choice for process engineers seeking to improve the
efficiency and controllability of their plant.
Subscription Information
Flow Control (ISSN #ISSN 2641-6735) is published 12 times a © Endeavor Business Media, 2019. No portion of this publica-
year by Endeavor Business Media, 3918 Montclair Road, Suite tion may be reproduced in any form without written permission
210, Birmingham, AL 35213. of the publisher. Views expressed by the bylined contributors
A controlled circulation publication, Flow Control is distributed
should not be construed as reflecting the opinion of this pub- Toll Free: 877-382-9187
lication. Publication of product/service information should not
without charge to qualified subscribers. Non-qualified subscrip-
be deemed as a recommendation by the publisher. Editorial
Local: 847-559-7598
tion rates in the U.S. and Canada: one year, $99; two year, $172.
Foreign subscription rates: one year, $150; two year, $262. Wire
contributions are accepted from the fluid handling industry. Mail: PO Box 3257
Contact the editor for details. Product/service information
Transfer: $180. Please call or email the circulation manager for
should be submitted in accordance with guidelines available Northbrook, IL 60065-3257
more wire transfer information. Single copies $10 per issue in
the U.S. and Canada. Single copies $15 per issue in all other
from the editor. Editorial closing date is two months prior to the Email: flowcontrol@omeda.com
month of publication. Advertising close is the last working day
countries. All subscription payments are due in U.S. funds.
of the month, two months prior to the month of publication.
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to: Flow Control, P.O. Box Subscribe/Renew/Change of Address:
3257, Northbrook, IL 60065-3257. Periodical postage rates paid at
Birmingham, AL 35243 and additional mailing offices. flowcontrolnetwork.com/subscribe
kWh
ft/s lb/h
ft3/h
Sft3/h
fact
Steam mass flow and enthalpy measurement
OPTISONIC 8300 –
technology driven by KROHNE
• Inline superheated steam ultrasonic flowmeter for boiler and power plant monitoring
or steam billing
• Sizes 2 to 24“ (DN50-600) rated to 2900 psi (200 bar), –13 to 1004 °F (–25...+540 °C),
higher ratings on request
• P/T inputs, meter and process diagnostics, optional integrated flow computer
L
ast month, I had the opportunity to Our cover story this issue is an article JIM SEMPLE | 908-963-3008
jsemple@endeavorbusinessmedia.com
attend the 2019 Emerson Global from Amin Almasi, who talks about practi-
Users Exchange in Nashville. As a cal guidelines for a range of boilers and EDITOR IN CHIEF
MOLLY ROGERS
first-time attendee, I enjoyed seeing the steam generators and the flow of fluids.
mrogers@endeavorbusinessmedia.com
wealth of resources, sessions, presenta- Next, David Lincoln with ABB discusses
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS
tions and solutions for attendees. In the the capabilities of digital instrumentation
JESSE OSBORNE
opening session, Lal Karsanbhai, execu- and offers tips on how to make the transi- josborne@endeavorbusinessmedia.com
tive president of Emerson Automation tion to a digital-enabled plant. MARIE MCBURNETT
Solutions, spoke about dynamic industry You’ll also find an article from mmcburnett@endeavorbusinessmedia.com
trends in oil and gas, power genera- Emerson’s Ryan Leino, who compares GROUP ASSISTANT EDITOR
tion, life sciences and food and bever- two approaches to a temperature mea- DANIEL GADDY
age processing, as well surement instrumenta- dgaddy@endeavorbusinessmedia.com
business, to the stage Gaylord Opryland Convention Center, cycle costs. mmalloy@endeavorbusinessmedia.com
Nashville. Courtesy of FC Staff
for a chat about digital Also in this issue, ACCOUNTS MANAGER
LISA WILLIMAN | 518-322-6691
transformation (the theme of the event), authors R. Barth Strempek and Thomas
lwilliman@endeavorbusinessmedia.com
its challenges and opportunities. Christensen explain flat-plat valve tech-
MARKETING MANAGER
For attendees, the event offered road- nology and its operational characteristics
SARAH DE VOS
map sessions and breakout industry including laminar flow and faster fluid
DIGITAL PRODUCT DIRECTOR
forums with experts from the chemicals, speed. Lastly, Mark Malburg with Digital NICK PHILLIPS
engineering, life sciences and pharma- Metrology Solutions shows how modern DIGITAL OPERATIONS MANAGER
ceuticals, mining, oil and gas, power, pulp texture analysis software can predict seal- MARY BETH ROMANO
and paper, and refining and petrochemi- ing performance and address root causes AUDIENCE DEVELOPMENT MANAGER
cal industries. Technology roundtables and of potential leakage. ANNA HICKS
educational services offered one-on-one I hope you enjoy reading this issue of SUBSCRIPTION & REPRINT REQUEST
conversations with Emerson’s representa- Flow Control. flowcontrol@omeda.com
Company news including Emerson’s Location Awareness allow Waukesha Bearings and Cook
and wireless video. These applications Compression to validate designs and
Emerson spotlights digital enhance personnel safety practices, analytical methods and test products
transformation at annual improve plant security and help ensure under demanding operating conditions.
users exchange environmental compliance. A reliable In addition, they equip R&D engineers to
At the 2019 Emerson Global User and fast connection between devices develop new application solutions. The
Exchange, Emerson made several and people streamlines decision mak- Innovation Lab capabilities will include
announcements, beginning with the intro- ing by providing real-time analytics. It also performance testing of journal and thrust
duction of its new Digital Transformation enables a mobile workforce to virtually bearings with oil or process lubrication
business, which provides resources to come together, collaborate and resolve over a wide range of loads and speeds;
help manufacturers develop and imple- critical issues in a timely manner. The new damper design characterization and
ment pragmatic digital transformation wireless access point supports mobile enhancement; performance and accel-
strategies. The $650+ million business applications that offer instant access erated life-cycle testing of reciprocating
combines existing expertise in consulting, to process control data, maintenance compressor components; flow charac-
project execution, smart sensor technolo- information and operation procedures, terization of compressor valves; dynamic
gies, data management and analytics. enabling improved plant productivity and testing of packing case leakage; competi-
The organization will help customers not worker safety. tive benchmarking; and advanced materi-
only establish a clear vision for digital Emerson has also enhanced its Plantweb als development. The Innovation Lab is
transformation, but also execute with con- digital ecosystem, a comprehensive scheduled for completion in the second
fidence and realize measurable results at operational analytics portfolio, delivering quarter of 2020, with test rig commis-
each step of their journey. Stuart Harris actionable insights to address industrial sioning to follow.
was named group president for Emerson’s manufacturers’ operational challenges.
new Digital Transformation business, Operational analytics with embedded New app calculates
which brings together existing and new domain knowledge can improve perfor- hydraulic oil viscosity
Emerson resources. mance of simple equipment, complex at different pressures
Emerson also announced that it is assets and process units, as well as entire Webtec launched a new online hydraulic
partnering with Cisco to introduce a production plants. Additionally, Emerson’s oil viscosity calculator app that calculates
next-generation industrial wireless net- enhanced portfolio includes machine the viscosity of hydraulic oil at different
working solution that transforms data learning and artificial intelligence that can operating pressures. Hydraulic fluid sup-
management to improve plant produc- be used to identify new discoveries and pliers provide oils with different viscosi-
tivity, reliability and safety. The new deepen insight to improve business perfor- ties. These oils are most-often badged
Emerson Wireless 1410S Gateway with mance. Emerson’s portfolio now provides in terms of their ISO number or grade,
the Cisco Catalyst IW6300 Heavy Duty both prepackaged analytics solutions as where common grades for hydraulic cir-
Series Access Point combines the lat- well as a complete analytics toolbox for cuits include ISO 32, 46 and 68. Using
est in wireless technology with advanced users to develop their own applications. Webtec’s app, engineers select the oil
WirelessHART sensor technology, deliv- This portfolio is supported by Emerson’s being used, along with the system tem-
ering reliable, secure data, even in the Operational Certainty consulting practice perature (°C) and pressure (bar), hit the
harshest industrial environments. To and data management capabilities. submit button and the viscosity (cSt) pops
help enable new digital transformation up in the window. To see the effects on
strategies, this industrial networking Dover breaks ground on viscosity of fluctuations in temperature
solution combines Emerson’s expertise Houston Innovation Lab or pressure, the user alters the values in
in industrial automation and applications Dover Precision Components is breaking these fields accordingly. The free Webtec
with Cisco’s innovations in networking, ground on a new Innovation Lab. The app is the company’s light version. More
cybersecurity and IT infrastructure. Driven nearly 12,000-square-foot building detailed results, including graphs (some
by the demand for greater productivity, is being constructed directly north of in 3D), can be accessed by logging in
lower maintenance costs and improved the company’s Pearland operations in (existing users) or registering (new users).
worker safety, industrial manufacturers Houston, Texas. Representing the com- The graphs can be saved for use in the
are accelerating investment in robust IoT pany’s ongoing commitment to research user’s own reports.
sensor networks combined with scalable and development, the Innovation Lab
operational analytics tools to improve will centralize test rigs for hydrodynamic Eaton collaborates with
organizational collaboration and decision- fluid film bearings and reciprocating San Jacinto College
making. This next-gen wireless access compressor components previously Eaton contributed more than $2 million
point provides enhanced Wi-Fi bandwidth housed in Pewaukee, Wisconsin, and to help San Jacinto College (San Jac) in
necessary for real-time safety monitoring, Knoxville, Tennessee. These test rigs Houston, Texas, establish its new Center
P
revious columns discussed that the Online or laboratory composition analyzers
composition of natural gas can and/or calorimeters can be used to correct
and does vary over time and at for the actual natural gas composition
different locations, and its composition when the measurement of energy flow
may be significantly different than typi- is important. Laboratory analysis can be
cal North American Energy Standards used to periodically reconfigure and/or
Board (NAESB) natural gas. As a result, recalibrate some flowmeters to account
the energy content, density and thermal for the latest natural gas compositions.
properties of the flowing natural gas can Coriolis mass, differential pressure flow-
also be different. Density and thermal meters, positive displacement, thermal,
properties can affect the performance of turbine and vortex shedding flowmeter
some flowmeters. However, energy con- technologies are often used to measure
tent variations can affect all flowmeters the flow of natural gas. Next month, I will
intended to measure the flow of energy examine how each of these technologies
— even when the flowmeter produces can be affected by changes in natural gas
measurements that accurately reflect the composition. FC
flow of natural gas.
Working backwards, if one assumes David W. Spitzer is a principal at Spitzer
that a given natural gas flowmeter accu- and Boyes, LLC, which offers engineer-
rately measures flow, the energy flow will ing, focused market research, writing/
vary directly with the energy content of the editing white papers, strategic market-
flowing natural gas because the energy ing consulting, distribution consulting,
content of the flowing natural gas can be seminars and expert witness services
significantly different than typical NAESB for manufacturing and automation com-
natural gas. panies. Spitzer has written more than
With that said, the energy content could 400 technical articles and 10 books
be more accurately determined using about flow measurement, instrumen-
the actual (measured) energy content tation and process control. He can
to improve measurement of the amount be reached at 845-623-1830 or via
of energy flowing through the flowmeter. spitzerandboyes.com.
A
ccurately transmitting the differential pressure gener- Additional complicating factors
ated by the flow element to the transmitter involves In some installations, it is not possible to install impulse
keeping the impulse tubing full of gas. Locating the tubes that constantly slope upward to the transmitter, so
transmitter below the flow element enables any liquid present other means may be used to effect accurate transmission
to accumulate and potentially adversely affect accurate signal of the differential pressure signal. These include diaphragm
Pobytov/iStock
transmission of the differential pressure signal, eliminating seals or pots where liquid can accumulate without affecting
Answers C and D. The downward sloping impulse tubing also the measurement.
eliminates Answer B. Thus, Answer A is correct.
S
team is important in many plants furnace section of the boiler, the faster the is not suitable, nor acceptable, in many
and facilities, and it is widely used steam production. Any remaining heat in cases. High velocities of hot gases can
in applications including industrial the combustion gases can then either be be problematic, as associated erosion or
heating, heat tracing, steam turbine drivers, evacuated or made to pass through an corrosion effects are damaging. As an
steam cleaning, process usage, atomiza- economizer; the role of which is to warm indication, the gas velocity through the
tion using steam, cleaning, moisturization boiler feedwater before it reaches the boiler. boiler passes should usually be less than
and humidification. A boiler or steam gen- Superheated steam is needed in many 14 m/s. However, the velocity is often
erator is a device used to produce steam applications and plants. The advantage of more than this value.
by applying heat energy to water. strong, superheated steam is that more Burners should be provided so that no
This article discusses boilers and steam work can be done by smaller volumes of flame impingement on the boiler’s walls
generators and the flow of fluids in them. steam. This enables all the components, would occur when firing the specified fuel
Useful guidelines are provided for a wide piping, devices and equipment to be under all operating conditions. Emissions
range of boilers and steam generators — reduced in size, and steam turbines and are a major problem in boilers. The firing
from small, simple boilers to large, complex steam consumers can be better adapted system should be equipped with advanced
multisection steam generators for large to installations and applications. low emission and low NOx burners.
industrial facilities.
Combustion Air flow to boilers
Boilers and steam generators The furnace section of a boiler should be To create optimum burning characteristics
A boiler incorporates a firebox or furnace in sufficient in size for flame development of the fire, air should be supplied to the
order to burn the fuel and generate heat. and should allow complete and efficient
The generated heat is transferred to water to combustion of the fuel before leaving the
make steam — the process of boiling. This furnace. The furnace section should pref-
produces steam at a rate that varies accord- erably be a single compartment. Central
ing to boiler operation. High-quality treated wall or division walls on a furnace section
water known as boiler feedwater should be
used to produce steam. Pressurized boiler
feedwater is pumped to boilers or steam
generation systems using boiler feedwater
pumps. The higher the temperature of the
Thossaphol/iStock
W
ith the world increasingly going
digital, it is no surprise that
industry is rapidly adopting
this game-changing technology. As the
frontline of any industrial process, instru-
mentation provides an invaluable starting
point for gauging performance, safety and
compliance, as well as identifying areas
for potential improvements.
Offering greater accuracy, range and
depth of information, digital technology
can provide operators and process engi-
neers with a timely and detailed picture of
both operating conditions and the status
of their measurement equipment. This
article looks at the benefits delivered by
the latest generation of digital instru-
ments and explains how to make the
transition to a digital-enabled plant.
Most instruments make a measure-
ment, amplify it, convert it and then
transmit it. Because data is sent as a
stream of discrete ones and zeros, a
digital instrument will always provide
an accurate representation of process
values. By contrast, analog instruments
represent data through a varying electrical
signal. One of the problems with this is
scaling, whereby a mismatch can occur
between the transmitting range of an
instrument and the input scaling range Diagnostic data allows engineers to
quickly spot faults and ensure they are
of the receiving instrument. This can properly equipped with the knowledge
create incorrect readings, as well as send and parts needed to fix them.
operators looking for measurements that All images courtesy of
are unaccounted for. ABB Measurement & Analytics
Unmatched Reliability
Your productivity and profitability is our #1 concern.
O
ne of the common challenges of Optimizing thermowell design using analysis
specifying industrial tempera-
ture measurement installations software minimizes flow obstructions and pressure
is sorting through the enormous range loss while extending equipment life.
of possible options and configurations
when selecting instrumentation and all in designing the process piping, it was • Secure ultimate termination at the
the components of the measurement loop anticipated that a temperature reading I/O card of the automation system.
— from sensor to the automation host would be useful, and a 3-inch flanged
system. In this article, two solutions to process connection was installed on the On the surface, it is a simple project and
the same straightforward installation are pipe, which has been closed with a blank should be easy to implement. The follow-
presented. The first illustrates traditional flange. The scope of the installation proj- ing examples illustrate the differences and
best practices with basic components. ect calls for the following: advantages between two approaches.
The second uses more advanced com- • Replace the blank flange with a
ponents and design techniques that can suitable flanged thermowell to Standard traditional approach
deliver a safe installation with a higher immerse the temperature sensor In a traditional approach, a hypothetical
degree of accuracy, greater reliability and in the liquid stream while providing engineer would select a stock thermowell
lower life-cycle cost. a terminal block for the electrical with a compatible mating connection and
The installation for this discussion connections. made from a suitable material. The inser-
involves adding a process temperature • Install a temperature sensor in the tion length should reach the center of the
measurement point to an 8-inch straight, thermowell and secure the neces- main pipe, so in this case, the insertion
horizontal section of Schedule 40 piping. sary terminations. length should be half the inside diam-
The process fluid is water with an aver- • Run appropriate extension wiring from eter of the 8-inch pipe plus the additional
age flow of 750 gallons per minute at the thermowell terminal block to the length of the spud. Given the length, a
pressure of 75 pounds per square inch automation host system via existing straight-stem thermowell with an outside
and temperature of 150ºF. Originally, cable trays and marshalling cabinets. diameter of 1 inch would be about right
1010 West Bagley Road I Berea, Ohio 44017 I P: 440.243.0888 I F: 440.243.3472 I www.noshok.com
While transmitters have been in use for operating, so the transmitter can switch costs through the following advantages:
many years, developments in advanced seamlessly from a primary sensor to a • Better temperature measurement
diagnostics have been more recent. New backup sensor, reducing the chance of performance can help support pro-
features can identify changes to sensors losing a temperature reading. cess optimization.
indicating degradation before outright fail- The hot backup capability can be • Condition diagnostics reduce trou-
ure. While something basic like an open employed with a single dual-element sen- bleshooting and maintenance costs.
circuit or erratic transmission is easy to sor or two independent sensors. Risk of • Sensor selection options provided
identify, advanced transmitters (see Figure losing a measurement is reduced with two by the transmitter eliminates the
4) can use their capabilities to detect more independent sensors versus a single dual- need to replace cabling if changing
subtle problems that can lead to serious element sensor; however, this requires sensor type.
issues such as on-scale errors. additional process intrusions. Two inde- • Optimizing thermowell design using
For example, a transmitter designed pendent sensors — even if they are analysis software minimizes flow
to work with both TCs and RTDs must wired to one transmitter — can reduce obstructions and pressure loss while
have built-in capabilities to read both the probability of losing the reading by up extending equipment life.
voltage and resistance. If a TC is in use, to 80%, depending on the failure rate of • Eliminating higher-cost sensor wiring
it processes the signal by measuring volt- the sensors. Two sensors measuring the reduces installation cost.
age, but it still has a resistance circuit, same temperature can also be monitored
so it can be programmed to take resis- for drift by comparing their values via a While configuring advanced systems may
tance measurements of the TC element drift alert diagnostic. If the differential require some additional effort and engi-
at specific intervals. This can be done between the two readings exceeds a neering time, the results — improved
quickly to minimize any interference with user-specified baseline, it can indicate performance and reduced maintenance
a critical temperature measurement. This one of the sensors is degraded and has — are worth it. FC
resistance check provides a snapshot begun to fail.
of the condition of the TC and can be
used to detect deterioration capable of Advantages of Ryan Leino is a global tem-
causing problems with the temperature advanced solutions perature product manager
measurement. The initial instrumentation cost of the for Emerson’s Automation
When a temperature measurement is advanced solution can be higher than a Solutions business in Shakopee,
especially critical to a process, redun- more traditional approach; however, the Minnesota. He holds a Bachelor of
dant sensors can be an option. This adds advanced solution delivers critical opera- Science in chemical engineering from
an online “hot” backup capability while tional cost savings and lower installation University of Wisconsin, Madison.
I
n 1911, Dutch physicist Heike and molecules also be coaxed to flow characteristics while achieving full control.
Kamerlingh Onnes discovered the without impedance? But turbulence always seems to occur.
phenomenon of superconductivity. Therefore, the development of practicable
When certain materials are supercooled Laminar flow nonturbulent fluid control devices has
to critically low temperatures, resistance It has been shown that, under certain been elusive — until recently.
drops to zero. In 1937, Pyotr Kapitsa and conditions, turbulence in fluids can If there were a way to induce fluids to
John F. Allen discovered the phenomenon be minimized, leading to laminar flow. act as if there were no resistance — as if
of superfluidity. In supercooled helium, Thankfully, laminar flow does not require nothing were in the way, as if turbulence
viscosity drops to zero. Superconductivity supercooling. However, it has proven dif- did not exist — immense practical benefits
operates at the subatomic scale while ficult to realize the benefits of laminar might be achieved. If pressures and flows
superfluidity appears to manifest itself flow in fluid control valves due to the could be influenced in an instant without
primarily at the atomic scale but with necessary design restrictions (such as pressure spikes and interactive systems
quantum implications. A reasonable obstructions, barriers and edges) required effects, if fluid control devices could be
question to ask might be: If electrons can for operation. Consequently, laminar flow substantially reduced in size, if noise and
be induced to flow without resistance is primarily observed in pipes and linear vibration could be reduced, and if device
and helium atoms can be induced to stretches of flow, not in valves. The practi- activation could be achieved with minimal
flow without viscosity, can larger atoms cal problem has been to sustain laminar force, benefits would be significant.
Figure 1. Two
parallel flat plates
can induce laminar
flow in valves.
All images
courtesy of R. Barth
Strempek and
1a) Stacked plates (shut) 1b) Stacked plates (open) 1c) Stacked plates (surfaces) Thomas Christensen
T
he shape and texture of a surface Most surface functionalities are not measurable purely in
is critically important to its func-
tionality. This is particularly true in
units of height. Local curvatures and the connectedness
sealing applications. Today, there is no of surface features can provide more valuable insight.
shortage of instruments for measuring sur-
face texture. Yet, despite the great amount in contact. Furthermore, they are well- valley height (Rz). In some cases, a wavi-
of data that can be gleaned from surface suited to predicting how a relatively soft ness height (Wt) may also be specified.
texture measurements, most engineers surface (e.g., a gasket or seal) will interact These parameters are well-known and
continue to specify only basic height-based with a relatively rigid surface. This article readily measurable with most surface
parameters, such as average roughness discusses how sealing performance can profiling instruments.
or total flatness. (See Figure 1.) be predicted with this analysis via modern Unfortunately, these statistics do not
The challenge, however, is that most surface texture analysis software. necessarily indicate how the surface will
surface functionalities (sealing, for exam- perform. Figure 2 shows two very differ-
ple) are not measurable purely in units of Can average roughness ent surfaces with virtually identical Ra, Rz
height. Local curvatures and the connect- distinguish a “good” and Wt values. If these parameters were
edness of surface features can provide sealing surface? specified on a print, the two surfaces
much more valuable insight. As previously mentioned, the most com- would be virtually indistinguishable and
In recent years, morphological filters monly specified surface finish parame- would pass similar quality control test-
have been introduced in surface texture ters in sealing applications are based on ing. Yet, none of these parameters would
literature and standards. The morphologi- heights measured along a profile. These reveal that the repeating milling pattern
cal opening and closing filters provide a common parameters include average in the second surface could create leak
powerful means of simulating surfaces roughness (Ra) and average peak-to- paths between mating surfaces.
Figure 2. Parameters such as Ra, Rz and Wt moved along the surface data. For the be altered in real time. With a smaller
have identical values for both surfaces yet offer closing filter, the virtual ball rides along radius, the ball will enter more val-
little insight into how the parts will perform.
the surface. A closing filter acts as a vir- leys, thereby modeling a more compli-
tual gasket that follows the peaks and ant gasket material. Raising the cutoff
New surface texture leaves voids in the regions of the val- wavelength for the waviness profile will
filters provide insight leys. By analyzing the gaps created by the increase how much the virtual gasket
into function closing filter, potential leakage under an will “crush” peak material.
In recent years, new parameters have actual gasket can be predicted. This article focuses more attention on
been developed that closely correlate with For an opening filter, the ball is essen- the closing filter.
particular functionalities. Engineers can tially pushing up from below the surface. The path of the closing filter (as shown
use these functional parameters to com- The opening filter highlights the peaks in in black in Figure 3) may be an inter-
pare design options during development a surface that are sharper than a given esting presentation of the amount of
and then specify these parameters on radius. These sharp peaks can be related deformation to be expected by a seal or
prints to improve component performance to oil film penetration points or cosmetic gasket. However, the difference between
and longevity. defects, or stress concentrations that the measured surface and closing filter
One such functional analysis is based could lead to cracking. is much more important: It is a direct
on using surface texture filters that can One crucial aspect of this type of representation of the cross-sectional
simulate the shape of a mating surface. analysis is that both closing and open- leakage area.
Figure 3 shows morphological opening ing filters can be adjusted in real time, This surface texture analysis method
and closing filters applied to a surface. letting engineers explore how changes provides direct modeling of the sealing
The filter in these examples is the in materials, processes and tolerances interface. Thus, it is a valuable method
path of a virtual circle (or ball for 3D might improve performance. For exam- for understanding and controlling the root
measurements) of a given radius that is ple, the radius of the closing filter can causes of leakage.
Using Pit and Porosity At any cross-sectional height level, the specified on prints to guide production
analysis to trace leak paths open and closed pores can be counted. and track surface quality. FC
Other advanced analyses can help Or, the pit density, the number of pits per
determine which voids in a surface may square centimeter, can be calculated.
link up to form leak paths. In Figure 6, Pit density can give a better indication Dr. Mark Malburg is a sur-
an interactive Pit and Porosity analysis of the surface in general, irrespective face metrologist with BSME
(shown in OmniSurf3D software) has of the size of the measurement area. and MSME degrees from
been applied to a surface to analyze Analysis tools like this make it easy to Michigan Technological University and
the voids, or pores, which may lead visualize what is happening and provide a doctorate from the University of
to leakage. The analysis shows a 3D traceable numbers. Warwick. Dr. Malburg spent 10 years
map of surface heights on the left, in industry prior to forming Digital
the material ratio curve in the middle, Conclusion Metrology Solutions in 1999. Digital
and a plot of pores and leak paths on Surface texture filters and functional Metrology provides custom metrology
the right. parameters make it possible to quickly software development, training and con-
The porosity features shown in red are and easily measure the properties of a sulting, and it has developed numerous
considered closed pores, meaning that surface that are most specifically tied surface texture analysis software pack-
they are completely enclosed by mate- to a desired function. ages including OmniSurf, OmniSurf3D
rial at this given cutting plane. Blue A morphological closing filter can and OmniRound. Dr. Malburg’s work,
features are open pores, meaning they provide insight as to how well a sur- mathematics and software are incorpo-
open onto the edge of the data set. The face will seal and provide insight about rated into many commercial measuring
green regions may be the most impor- other functionalities. These filters can systems. Visit digitalmetrology.com or
tant. These are edge-connected regions, be used to explore changes to mate- email info@digitalmetrology.com for
representing potential leak paths that are rials and methods that may address more information.
open along either the X or Y axis of the the root causes of sealing issues, as
data set. well as provide parameters that can be
FOCUS
Send products for consideration in this section
to mrogers@endeavorbusinessmedia.com
3
2
FollowFollow
us us
Like usLike us E-News
E-News Directory
AD INDEX
Advertiser Page# Advertiser Page#
Bronkhorst USA............................................................................... 5 Gorman-Rupp Company................................................................. 11
BC = Back Cover IBC = Inside Back Cover IFC = Inside Front Cover
FlowControlNetwork.com
@FLOWCONTROL_MAG
Prediction of #compressor
performance requires Coriolis meters keep the
accurate aero-mechanical beer flowing
machine model-based
#monitoring, application of In this case study, a Belgium
gas #thermodynamic theories brewery installs the world’s first
underground beer pipeline with
and adequate calculation
priority on quality and innovative
tools | ow.ly/fpsn50wBSuY measurement solutions.
@IPC_ENG
bit.ly/2VGHkI0
32 | November 2019
MULTIPLE INDUSTRIES
THREE BRANDS
ONE POWERFUL NETWORK
ProcessFlowNetwork.com