Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Maurice Saxby
To cite this article: Maurice Saxby (2004) Researching Australian children’s literature, The
Australian Library Journal, 53:1, 81-91, DOI: 10.1080/00049670.2004.10721615
W
1962 I began to research the history of Australian children’s
hen in
literature, access to the primary sources was limited and difficult. The Herald concludes
From a catalogue drawer in the Mitchell Library of hand-written with insight, ‘We
read to know that we
cards marked ‘Children’s books’ I could call up from the stacks, in
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
T h e A u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J oFEBRUARY
u r n 2004
a l 8 1
Researching Australuian children’s literature
and how you can help your child to catch it (2003), is an index of the present healthy
state of writing for children in this country. Theory is reinforced by the writer’s own
experience and expertise. Academic respectability is added to evangelical zeal in
promoting reading among children.
The early development of Australian children’s literature through the 1960s
The tremendous growth and development of resources as well as interest in Austral-
ian children’s literature began after World War II with the establishment of support
organisations such as the School Library Service of New South Wales and then similar
services in other states. The formation in 1945–6 of the Children’s Book Council of
NSW and the national body in 1959, along with the establishment of the Children’s
Book of the Year awards, was undoubtedly the most influential factor in promoting
professional and public interest in children’s reading in post-war Australia. The award
provided a carrot for writers and publishers, created media and public interest and
became a meeting ground for teachers, librarians and parents (Pownall, 1980).
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
The 1950s saw a cultural and artistic renaissance in Australia (for example, Conway,
1971; Cope & Kalanzis, 1994) that included writing for children. Nan Chauncy’s
Tiger in the Bush (1957) established the modern period of our children’s literature
(Niall 1984). The 1950s and 1960s saw the rise of an ‘establishment’ that included
names — largely female — such as Patricia Wrightson, Joan Phipson, Ivan South-
all, Eleanor Spence, Hesba Fay Brinsmead, Mavis Thorpe Clark, and Colin Thiele
(McVitty, 1981). These writers became known internationally and were reviewed in
journals such as Junior Bookshelf in Britain and The Horn Book in the USA. The interest
generated in them arose largely through the publicity given by the Children’s Book
Council of Australia and its journal, Reading Time. But developments in Australian
publishing, such as the appointment of children’s editors, also helped. As a case in
point Joyce Boniwell Saxby left the National Library of Australia to become children’s
editor with Angus & Robertson in 1963. Publications such as my own History of
Australian children’s literature 1841–1941 also had some effect in that they reached
overseas libraries.
This same period saw the growth of both school and children’s libraries. The first
full-time teacher-librarian was appointed in NSW in 1949 and children’s librarians
in public libraries grew in numbers with the inclusion of a paper on children’s lit-
erature in the LAA’s Registration Examination. Lectures were given to candidates by
myself and others. I, along with Dennis Hall and Marjorie Cotton, were examiners
in the early 1960s. Hall, who was editor of the NSW School Magazine, wrote some-
times acerbic reviews of children’s books for the Australian Book Review. Cotton was
passionate about children’s literature and was one of the most influential children’s
librarians in Australia. She was elected the first President of the Children’s Section
of the Library Association of Australia in 1953 (Cotton 1989, p50).
The visit to Australia in 1964 by Professor Sara Innis Fenwick from the University
of Chicago who spent six months in Australia at the invitation of the LAA as a Ful-
bright lecturer and the publication of her report on children’s libraries in 1966 did
much to stimulate the provision of quality children’s literature and its study among
children’s librarians, both school and public. In particular Fenwick (p39) urged
national co-operation between both school and public librarians and with all who
82 TFEBRUARY
h e A2004
u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J o u r n a l
Researching Australuian children’s literature
recognised the need for ‘more education, both formal and informal…’ including the
need for a program of continuing education.
This need was recognised by Margaret Trask who in 1972 offered a course through
the Division of Postgraduate Extension Studies at the University of New South Wales
on Fantasy, science fiction and science materials and published the papers. She offered a
similar course on picture books in 1974, and in 1975 one called ‘A sense of history.’
Previously in the late 1960s Trask had organised an open seminar on Australian
children’s literature with a paper by this writer on its history.
It is from this period the Children’s Section of the LAA and the Australian Section
of IBBY (International Board on Books for Young People) — which operated under the
umbrella of the LAA — along with ASLA (Australian School Library Association) and
numerous bodies interested in literacy and children’s literature, were to hold regular
conferences and seminars across Australia emphasising the value of quality literature
in the personal and social development of children. Such events were to proliferate
and are too numerous to list. However a sampling of such conferences includes:
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
T h e A u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J oFEBRUARY
u r n 2004
a l 83
Researching Australuian children’s literature
ian children’s literature by Jeffey Prentice and Bronwen Bennett (1992) documents
milestones and achievements in the literary and commercial contexts of Australian
children’s literature to the date of publication. The arrival in 1993 of The Oxford
companion to Australian children’s literature edited by Stella Lees & Pam Macintyre
with impeccable scholarship established the credentials — recognised internationally
— of an Australian literature for children.
This period of the late 1960s was also a time when the Commonwealth Department
of Education was anxious to develop better school libraries. Federal aid to second-
ary libraries was mooted, but learning from previous grants for science equipment
that gathered dust because teachers were not sufficiently trained in its use, it was
agreed that teachers properly trained in the organisation and utilisation of resources
were just as important as the resources themselves. In 1968/9 Milton Simms, the
librarian from James Cook University, and myself from Alexander Mackie College in
Sydney, offered a two-week course at Townsville for teachers released from both state
and private schools. There was firm emphasis on the selection and use of literature,
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
8 4 TFEBRUARY
h e A2004
u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J o u r n a l
Researching Australuian children’s literature
collection of Australian nursery rhymes (1988) led the way to collections of rhymes,
chants and songs that are peculiarly Australian. An academic, Walter McVitty, had
also in 1985 established his own specialist children’s list, paying particular attention
to quality both in writing and in book production. His deluxe illustrated editions of
Ethel Turner’s Seven Little Australians in 1994 and Colin Thiele’s Sun on the stubble in
1996, along with the picture book editions of traditional stories such as Ali Baba and
Robin Hood, illustrated by Margaret Early, mark a high point in Australian children’s
book production. Julie Watts, the present executive publisher, Books for Children and
Young Adults at Penguin Australia, in a letter to the author in June 2003 confirms
that company’s commitment to quality in children’s books and her own nurturing
of publications such as Jennings’s The reading bug in the belief that such books can
help ‘change the world.’
Along with specialist publishing came specialist bookshops. Albert Ullin estab-
lished a children’s bookshop, ‘The Little Book Room’ in Melbourne in 1960, and he
was to be followed by Pegi Williams in Adelaide and by Robin Morrow who opened
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
‘The Children’s Book Shop’ in Beecroft, Sydney, in time for Christmas 1971. In Perth
The Singing Tree children’s bookshop in the 1980s and 1990s, owned by David and
Rayma Turton, not only drew customers from across Australia but from overseas.
The emergence of periodical literature related to children’s books
It was Rayma Turton who, at the time of a combined gathering of IBBY and the
Loughborough Conference on Children’s Literature in Great Britain, held in Perth in
1985, conceived the notion of a journal devoted to children’s literature along the lines
of the British Books for Keeps. In Australia the embryonic New Books for Boys and Girls
founded in 1957 by the Children’s Book Council of NSW had evolved into Reading
Time, at present in its 47th year. That journal began as a vehicle for short annota-
tions of children’s books which evolved into more lengthy critical reviews. Under the
editorship of Anne Bower Ingram and later Geoffrey Atkinson and now John Cohen,
it also includes articles related to the criticism and value of the literature.
In 1977 the very practical and unpretentious Children’s Library Newsletter pre-
pared by a volunteer group headed by Val Watson, an eminent children’s librarian,
metamorphosed into Orana: Journal of School and Children’s Librarianship, a refereed
journal published by the Library Association of Australia (now Australian Library
and Information Association). Today Orana contains a judicious mixture of news,
information technology, reviews of professional reading, international comments,
and an open forum for subscribers. It features articles such as ‘Australian YA fiction
— a catalyst for innovation and evolution: a Canadian view’ by Russ MacMath (32
[4] November 1996), and in the same issue, ‘Once upon our time: research into the
value of told story today’ by Barbara Poston-Anderson and Lea Redfern.
Rayma Turton’s vision gave birth to three magazines: Magpies: talking about books
for children founded in 1986, to be followed four years later by The literature base and
Papers: explorations into children’s literature, each edited by Alf Mappin. The literature
base continues to provide teachers with practical approaches to making quality litera-
ture part of the school day and helping children to become avid but critical readers.
It includes units ranging from the value and uses of traditional literature — myth and
legend, fable, folk and fairy tale — to poetry, environmental and Aboriginal studies
and other relevant topics. Papers has now been taken over by Deakin University
T h e A u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J oFEBRUARY
u r n 2004
a l 85
Researching Australuian children’s literature
and its focus is on refereed articles of a highly academic nature with an emphasis
on contemporary literary theory. Many of the articles derive from work in progress
toward the contributor’s PhD thesis.
Magpies and Reading Time are glossy, full-colour quarto-sized journals with the
implied readership of teachers and librarians. They both review recent children’s
books from both Australia and New Zealand, arranged through readership from pre-
schoolers to young adults. Along with the reviews, both publications increasingly
feature articles and scholarly papers by leading Australian — and sometimes overseas
— practitioners in the field. The May 2003 issue of Magpies contains, among other
features, a ‘Know the author’ — Joanne Horniman; the profile of the book designer
duo Donna Rawlins and Wayne Harris, both prize-winning illustrators; along with
an article about three new natural history books for children. Reading Time (also
May 2003) contains profiles of two publishers: David Harris of Scholastic and Mark
Macleod of Random — now Hodder Headline — along with a comprehensive and
scholarly article by Dr Belle Alderman which documents with appropriate references
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
the formation, function and range of the Lu Rees Archives of Australian Children’s
Literature housed in Canberra. The archives, founded in 1974 also issues an annual
journal, begun in 1981, The Lu Rees archives: notes, books and authors which also in-
cludes articles arising from academic research — such as ‘A tradition of innovation:
folklore in Australian children’s literature’ by Carole Carpenter from York University,
Toronto. As a Harold White Fellow at the National Library of Australia, Carpenter
carried out an investigation into the ‘role of children’s literature as a discourse of
Australian multiculturalism’ (Carpenter 2001, p5).
Complementary to Reading Time and Magpies is Viewpoint: on books for young
adults founded in 1992 and compiled by an editorial board from the University of
Melbourne. As with the other journals it publishes regular reviews along with feature
articles, but with an emphasis on publications — including appropriate picture books
— suitable for use with late teenagers.
In the late 1980s Magpies conducted seminars at The Singing Tree and published
transcripts of the talks in Magpies. ‘Over the rim of reality’, taken from a paper
presented by Maurice Saxby at the Magpies fantasy seminar in 1987, for example,
was published in Vol 3, No 1, March 1988. Susan Cooper, the American writer
of fantasy, also presented a paper that was published in Vol 3, No 2, May 1988.
Australian children’s literature is now well served through such publications and a
growing number of theses and regular book events, such as those organised by Agnes
Nieuwenhuizen, author of No kidding: top writers for young people talk about their work
(1991), both at the Australian Centre for Youth Literature, State Library of Victoria
and throughout that state.
Biographical dictionaries
The first Who’s who of Australian children’s writers appeared in 1992 and in 2002
came Book people: meet Australia’s children’s authors and illustrators in seven volumes
edited by Paul Collins, published by Macmillan Education. The Eye of the soul (1998)
by Stephen Matthews contains a perceptive introduction and then interviews with
seventeen of the younger generation of Australians writing for children and young
adults. Heather Scutter’s Displaced fictions: contemporary Australian fiction for teenagers
and young adults (1999) critically examines the ideology of that now considerable
86 TFEBRUARY
h e A2004
u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J o u r n a l
Researching Australuian children’s literature
body of fiction. Perhaps the most influential theoretical study by an Australian is from
John Stephens of Macquarie University. His Language and ideology in children’s fiction
(Longman, 1992) is quoted widely in children’s literature studies across the globe.
Library resources
Such research into the source material, and the publication of learned books and
articles has been made possible largely through the healthy growth of specialist col-
lections since my own early forays into the holdings of the Mitchell and National
libraries. Prentice and Bennett (1992, pp25–37) list fourteen special collections. Since
then the State Library of Victoria has added to its rare book section an extensive
archive of wartime and post-war children’s books and ephemeral material painstak-
ingly collected by the philanthropic Ken Pound after whom the collection is named.
Many rare books and variant editions of the same book provide fertile ground for
the research student. Similarly a collection housed at St Peter’s school, Sydney, and
named AORA, was put together and is managed by a group of enthusiastic children’s
librarians under the leadership of Miranda Harrowell of Ryde Public Library.
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
T h e A u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J oFEBRUARY
u r n 2004
a l 87
Researching Australuian children’s literature
latest. The Harry Potter phenomenon is the extreme of what has always existed: the
fad, the popular. It takes to the limit the Biggles or Blyton syndrome and the fixa-
tion on such series. It highlights the need for studies such as Jennings’s The reading
bug (2003). There is a danger that publishers will concentrate on ‘best-sellers’ to the
detriment of deserving contenders in the marketplace. Unless sales are guaranteed
through prior consultation with book clubs and standing orders — where schools
accept books sight-unseen — publishers now seem reluctant to risk an untried
author or illustrator.
A further reservation expressed at the May Gibbs mentorship program mentioned
above was that libraries could be in danger of diminished book votes because of the
demands of technology. While never once denying the need for computer literacy
or the power of the visual image, the question arose as to whether there is a danger
of encouraging children to be answer-rich and question-poor. The internet provides
instant answers, but does it nourish the soul? it was asked. Spufford (2002, p9)
contends that ‘the book becomes part of the history of our self-understanding’; ‘the
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
book in the hand is a tool of growth.’ An editorial (Turton in Magpies Vol 17, No 5,
November 2002) quotes Ros Price, children’s publisher, Allen & Unwin, as stating
that too many children’s books are being published, but that there is a narrower range
of books on bookseller’s shelves. The editor concludes: ‘Better, perhaps, for publish-
ing to reflect the changing patterns in both trade and institutional purchasing and
prune lists to those well-deserving of their place on the shelves — be they offerings
of a literary nature or stories of wider appeal well-written within their genre.’ Harris
(2003, p15) supports this view, and Macleod (2003, p20) adds a further cautionary
note: ‘Children’s literature has become a playground for adults rather than those for
whom the books were originally intended.’ Genuine and worth-while research could
well become academic one-upmanship.
Be all this as it may, the short-list of books entered for the CBCA Awards, 2003,
indicates that there are still books to entice, entertain and enrich young readers.
From some twenty entries in 1946 the number has risen steadily over the years until
in 2003 the number was 331. For early childhood there are now such simple but
evocative and informing picture books as A year on our farm by Penny Matthews and
illustrated by Andrew McLean (2002), or Pamela Allen’s rhythmic and exuberant
The potato people (2002) incorporating the chant, ‘One potato, two potatoes.’ For
those who have mastered print and are independent readers, Simon French’s Where
in the world (2002) delights both the mind and the senses with the imagery of music
and of travel to evoke character and place, along with a growing sense of identity,
and so to provide the reader with a home in the wider world of human experience.
A similar epiphany and a developing sense of place is offered to mature readers in
James Aldridge’s The girl from the sea (2002), while Ian Bone and Markus Zusak in
their respective novels, The song of an innocent bystander (2002) and The messenger
(2002) mine goodness, beauty and understanding from unlikely soil.
Australian children’s literature today has become ‘all things to all people’; an eclectic
smorgasbord to nourish as well as entertain young readers; a means of documenting
social change and contemporary mores, and a fertile ground for research. Specialist
collections, bibliographical aids, numerous papers and reports, lectures, confer-
ences and academics committed to serious study, along with teachers and librarians
88 TFEBRUARY
h e A2004
u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J o u r n a l
Researching Australuian children’s literature
actively promoting quality literature, confirm that the state of children’s literature in
this country has never been healthier. An editorial in the Sydney Morning Herald (21
June 2003) claims that the Harry Potter hype ‘has made books cool’ and improved
literacy: ‘Non-readers have turned into readers, book-haters into bookworms.’ It might
also be argued that despite the lure of the visual media there are still an enduring
number of children committed to print. An editorial in The Australian on the same
day claims: ‘The war against the dark digital lords is not lost and books can defeat
the supposed spells TV and video games cast on the young.’ The Herald concludes
with insight, ‘We read to know that we are not alone. That’s enough.’ It is certainly
enough for both children and adults; and is as true today as it ever was.
References
A mother’s offering to her children by a lady long resident in the colony [Charlotte
Barton] (1841) The Gazette, Sydney.
Alderman, Belle (2003) ‘The Lu Rees Archives of Australian Children’s Literature’
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
T h e A u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J oFEBRUARY
u r n 2004
a l 89
Researching Australuian children’s literature
Green, H M (1961) A history of Australian literature: pure and applied, 2 vols. Angus
& Robertson, Sydney.
Harris, David (2003) ‘It’s not child’s play’ Reading Time. 47 [2].
Hunt, Peter ed. (1996) International companion encyclopedia of children’s literature,
Routledge, London & New York.
Jennings, Paul (2003) The reading bug … and how you can help your child to catch
it, Penguin, Melbourne.
Lees, Stella & Macintyre, Pam (1993) The Oxford companion to Australian children’s
literature, Oxford University Press, Melbourne.
Macartney, F T (1956) Australian literature: a bibliography to 1938 by E Morris
Miller, Extended to 1950, Angus & Robertson. Sydney.
Macleod, Mark (2003) ‘Mark Macleod editor and publisher — behind the name’
Reading Time, 47 [3].
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
9 0 TFEBRUARY
h e A2004
u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J o u r n a l
Researching Australuian children’s literature
Saxby, Maurice (1988) ‘Over the Rim of Reality’ Magpies 3 [1], March.
Scobie, Susan comp (1997) The Dromkeen book of Australian children’s illustrators,
Scholastic, Sydney.
Scutter, Heather (1999) Displaced fictions: contemporary Australian fiction for teen-
agers and young adults, Melbourne University Press, Melbourne.
Silvey, Anita ed. (1995) Children’s books and their creators, Houghton Mifflin,
Boston & New York.
Spufford, Francis (2002) The child that books built: a memoir of childhood and read-
ing, Faber, London.
St James Guide to Writers Series (formerly Twentieth-Century Writers Series)
(1999) St James guide to children’s writers, 5th ed. St James Press, Detroit &
London.
St James Guide to Young Adult Writers, 2nd ed. St. James Press, Detroit & Lon-
Downloaded by [164.132.51.91] at 02:14 07 June 2016
don.
Stephens, John (1992) Language and ideology in children’s literature, Longmans,
London.
Thiele, Colin and Lennox, John illus. (1996) Sun on the stubble, Walter McVitty,
Montville, Queensland.
Trask, Margaret ed. (1972) Fantasy, Science Fiction, Science Materials: papers pre-
sented at the course offered by the School of Librarianship through the Division of
Postgraduate Studies, University of New South Wales, 16–19 May 1972. School
of Librarianship, University of New South Wales, Sydney.
Turner, Ethel and Lennox, John illus. (1994) Seven little Australians, Walter
McVitty, Montville, Q’ld.
Turton, Rayma (2002) Editorial Magpies 17 [5] November.
Watson, Victor ed (2001) The Cambridge guide to children’s books in English, Cam-
bridge University Press, Cambridge.
Who’s who of Australian children’s writers (1992, 2nd ed. 1996) Thorpe in Associa-
tion with the National Centre for Australian Studies, Melbourne.
Wighton, Rosemary (1963) Early Australian children’s literature. Australian writers
and their works, Lansdowne, Melbourne.
Zusak, Markus (2002) The messenger, Pan Macmillan, Sydney.
Dr Maurice Saxby AM is the author of the standard reference work History of Australian children’s
literature and collaborated with Margaret Trask in the 1960s and 1970s to spread knowledge
of Australian children’s literature. Maurice worked at Kuring-gai CAE at the time Margaret was
establishing new courses in library and information studies. He has received many awards including
the Dromkeen Medal and the Nan Chauncy Award and has lectured on the subject both in Australia
and internationally.
T h e A u s t r a l i a n L i b r a r y J oFEBRUARY
u r n 2004
a l 9 1