You are on page 1of 6

Prescribing in practice

Ichthyosis: guide to recognition


and current treatment options
Ann Sergeant MRCP and Colin Munro MD, FRCP
Ichthyoses are a collection
of disorders characterised
by dry, scaly skin. Here, the
authors discuss current
treatments for the condition
and also look at rarer condi-
tions that may be present.

Figure 1. Scaly skin curled up at the edges is characteristic of ichthyosis vulgaris.


The mainstay of treatment is avoidance of irritants and regular use of emollients

he ichthyoses (derived from disorder, harlequin ichthyosis. a mutation or compound het-


T the Greek ‘ichthys’, meaning
‘fish’) are a heterogeneous group
Ichthyosis may be a prominent fea-
ture in rare systemic syndromes,
erozygotes for these mutations, but
within the pedigrees heterozygotes
of clinical disorders characterised usually due to defects in lipid also exhibited milder dry skin.1
by rough, ‘dry’, scaling skin, usu- metabolism. Ichthyosis vulgaris usually
ally over the whole body. becomes apparent during the first
Abnormal skin scale results from Ichthyosis vulgaris year of life and, in the vast major-
abnormalities of keratinisation, Ichthyosis vulgaris is the most com- ity, by the age of five years. The
barrier (cornified envelope) for- mon inherited ichthyosis, account- extent of scaling increases until
mation or shedding (desquama- ing for more than 95 per cent of puberty and subsequently
tion). Most presentations in early ichthyosis cases, and is associated decreases with age. The scales are
life are genetically determined. with reduced expression of the small, flaky and white or grey, often
Mild degrees of acquired dry skin cornified envelope precursor pro- curling up at the edges to give the
are common with advancing age, tein filaggrin in the granular layer skin a rough feel (see Figure 1).
but more severe acquired of the epidermis. Scaling is most pronounced on the
ichthyosis may signal systemic dis- Traditionally, it was thought to extensor surfaces of the arms and
ease or malignancy (see Table 1). be an autosomal dominant trait, lower legs and characteristically
but recent research has shown that spares the flexural creases. There
Inherited ichthyoses it is pseudodominant, 1 due in may be increased markings of the
Most genetic forms of ichthyosis Caucasians to two common muta- palms and soles.
are due to defects in the formation tions each of which prevents Keratosis pilaris (‘cheese
of the stratum corneum. The clin- expression of filaggrin. grater’ skin) is commonly associ-
ical severity spans a broad spec- In families with ichthyosis vul- ated and usually apparent on the
trum from mild ichthyosis vulgaris garis, severely affected individuals upper arms (see Figure 2).
to the life-threatening congenital were shown to be homozygous for Keratosis pilaris is also common in

www.escriber.com Prescriber 19 April 2006 35


Prescribing in practice

Causes edged scale (ichthyosis linearis cir-


cumflexa) is accompanied by
drugs, eg nicotinic acid, hypocholesterolaemic agents severe atopic disease including
chronic hepatic disease, renal failure, thyroid and parathyroid disease asthma as well as eczema.
malabsorption states Examples of a variety of rare
AIDS inherited disorders that present
lymphoma and other malignancies primarily as ichthyosis are
connective tissue disease, eg systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), described in Table 2. For details of
dermatomyositis numerous other disorders of kera-
sarcoidosis and leprosy tinisation, and metabolic disorders
Investigations of which ichthyosis is a feature or
incidental finding (eg Sjögren-
full blood count Larsen, Refsum, Chanarin-
urea and electrolytes Dorfman syndromes or multiple
calcium and phosphate sulphatase deficiency), the reader
thyroid function tests is referred to a specialist text such
chest X-ray as reference 2.2
Consider
Treatment
antinuclear antibodies and extractable nuclear antibodies Few treatments for ichthyosis have
creatinine kinase been subjected to rigorous or sys-
skin biopsy tematic trial. The approach to
HIV test treatment is largely symptomatic
and dictated by clinical signs and
Table 1. Causes of acquired ichthyoses and investigations used to diagnose the disease
symptoms, which var y between
isolation in the general popula- patients and within the same indi-
tion. Signs and symptoms of vidual over time. The main aims
ichthyosis vulgaris may improve are to maintain barrier function
during the summer months. and suppleness and to improve
In general, ichthyotic skin has appearance. In the more severe
poor moisture retention: transepi- ichthyoses, it is particularly impor-
dermal water loss is increased but tant to acknowledge the unrelent-
stratum corneum hydration is ing nature of the condition and to
reduced. An impaired barrier is direct affected individuals and
prone to enhanced penetration of their families to groups that offer
topical agents and may be easily support.
irritated. However, the main
symptoms of isolated ichthyosis Emollients
vulgaris are roughness or dryness Regular and sufficient application
of the skin and the cosmetic of emollients is critical.2,3 Lighter
defect. water-based emollients, such as
Many children with atopic aqueous cream, are suitable for
eczema have ‘dr y skin’, but the milder ichthyoses. Paraffin-based
cutaneous changes of mild eczema (mixtures of white soft and liquid
may mimic ichthyosis and clinical paraffin) or cetostear yl alcohol-
distinction is difficult. Pruritus is containing emollients are better
not a problem in isolated for more severe cases. Table 3
ichthyosis vulgaris and, in patients shows a list of prescribable emol-
who also have eczema, excoriation lients.
and flexural lichenification are Emollients need to be applied
additional features. Netherton’s regularly, often several times a day.
Figure 2. The blocking of follicles on the upper arm with syndrome, an unusual ichthyosis Ideally, assistance from carers and
keratin is indicative of keratosis pilaris characterised by arcuate double- at school should be arranged for

36 Prescriber 19 April 2006 www.escriber.com


Prescribing in practice

Disorder Protein (gene) Incidence Cutaneous signs and symptoms Other features

X-linked ichthyosis steroid sulphatase 1 in 6000 males large brown/grey scale; scaling is prolonged labour; corneal opacities
MIM 308100 (ARSC) evident in the first weeks of life, on slit-lamp exam (no functional
increasing throughout childhood; significance); may be associated
scaling more prominent on with Kallman’s syndrome
extensor surfaces and legs, but (anosmia, hypogonadism, renal
flexures may be involved agenesis); testicular maldescent;
inguinal hernia

Congenital arachidonate 12R- 1 in 300 000 heterogeneous; tight membrane ectropion ~ 30%; short stature, but
ichthyosiform lipoxygenase (‘collodion baby’) present in 90% may catch up with delayed growth
erythroderma (CIE) (ALOX12B); of cases; after shedding the spurt in adolescence
MIM 242100 arachidonate membrane, variable scaling and
lipoxygenase-3 erythema persists; thin, superficial
(ALOXE3); ichthyin white/grey scale affects all areas;
hyperkeratotic palms and soles;
itch; sweating absent or markedly
reduced; deteriorates in summer

Lamellar ichthyosis keratinocyte 1 in 500 000 less common cause of collodion ectropion; scarring alopecia; in
MIM 242300 transglutaminase baby than CIE; scaling occurs severely affected individuals the
(TGM1) within the first month of life and is thick, rigid scale is intermittently
typically large, dark brown or grey shed causing deep and painful
and firmly adherent; pruritus is rare fissures; limitation of joint move-
but sweating is severely impaired ment, flexion contractures and
digital sclerodactyly may result

Bullous keratins 1 and 10 <1 in 100 000 mild erythroderma at birth; blisters, hyperkeratosis of palms and soles,
ichthyosiform (KRT1, KRT10) peeling and erosions at sites of may result in painful fissures,
erythroderma (BIE) minor trauma within first few hours contractures, sclerodactyly and foot
(Epidermolytic of life; gradually the fragile skin is deformity; repeated bacterial and
hyperkeratosis) replaced by thickened yellow- fungal skin infection, with
MIM 118300 brown waxy/ridged skin; tends to associated body odour
improve with age

Netherton Syndrome LEKTI serine protease <1 in 100 000 neonatal erythema; later ichthyosis severe atopic disease
MIM 256500 inhibitor (SPINK5) with typical circumflex and double-
edged scale; trichorrhexis
invaginata (bamboo hair)

Harlequin ichthyosis ABCC12 ~5 in UK per year affected infant is usually premature, water loss, electrolyte abnormalities,
MIM 242500 sometimes stillborn; born with a temperature dysregulation,
massive horny shell of dense infection, restricted movement,
plate-like scale and contraction respiratory insufficiency, absence of
abnormalities of the eyes, ears, effective sucking
mouth and appendages

Table 2. Some rarer genetic disorders that present primarily as ichthyosis

38 Prescriber 19 April 2006 www.escriber.com


Prescribing in practice

severely affected children. Nonproprietary preparations


Individual preference is important
in optimising compliance. If pro- aqueous cream, BP hydrous ointment, BP
vided with samples of a variety of emulsifying ointment, BP paraffin, white soft, BP
suitable preparations, patients can liquid and white soft paraffin paraffin, yellow soft, BP
choose the most acceptable. Low ointment, NPF
humidity environments, common Proprietary preparations
in winter, exacerbate the problem.
Conversely, bathing too often may Aveeno cream and lotion Lipobase cream
also be an irritant. Bubble baths Cetraben cream Neutrogena Dermatological Cream
and detergents should be avoided, Decubal Clinic cream Oilatum cream
and use of soaps and shampoos Dermamist spray Ultrabase cream
minimised. Diprobase cream and ointment Unguentum M cream
Preparations such as aqueous Doublebase gel Vaseline Dermacare cream and lotion
cream, emulsifying ointment and E45 cream, wash and lotion Zerobase cream
solid moisturiser bars can be used Epaderm ointment Dermol cream and lotion (contains
as soap substitutes. Emollient bath Hydromol cream and ointment antiseptic)
oils are useful; again, establishing
individual preference is important Emollient bath additives
for compliance. After bathing, Alpha Keri Bath E45
patients’ emollients should be Aveeno emollient medicinal bath oil
applied before the skin fully dries Balneum Hydromol Emollient
to retain hydration. Cetraben Oilatum
Prescribers often fail to appre- Dermalo (there are further bath additives
ciate just how much emollient is Diprobath containing antiseptics if required)
needed. Liberal application
should be encouraged – 500g per Preparations containing alpha-hydroxy acid
week for adults and two weeks for
children is recommended. LactiCare lotion (lactic acid 5%) cosmetic counters in pharmacies and
Pruritus associated with Calmurid cream (lactic acid 5%) department stores)
ichthyosis is often mild and may (many more are available from
respond to emollients alone, but
Preparations containing urea
nonspecific antipruritic agents are
included in many creams and bath Aquadrate cream (urea 10%) E45 Itch Relief Cream cream (urea 5%)
oils. These tend to be more expen- Balneum Plus cream (urea 5%) Eucerin cream and lotion (urea 10%)
sive. Response to topical steroids Calmurid cream (urea 10%, also Nutraplus cream (urea 10%)
suggests an undiagnosed low-grade contains lactic acid)
eczema.
Source: BNF. No 50, September 2005
Keratolytic agents
The cosmetic effect of excessive Table 3. Emollients currently available that may be used in ichthyosis management
scale is important to patients.
Keratolytic agents such as 1-5 per Alpha-hydroxy acids Alpha- more expensive, than salicylic
cent salicylic acid may be added to hydroxy (‘fruit’) acids (eg lactate, acid compounds. See Table 3 for
emollient cream bases to encour- glycolic, malic or other organic available preparations.
age exfoliation of scale, but are acids) in oil, lotion, cream or Urea Emollients containing
often too irritant for regular use. ointment bases are widely avail- urea (5-10 per cent: see Table 3
Their widespread application able as exfoliants. They are for available preparations) also
should be avoided due to the risk humectants that increase the stra- have a humectant and keratolytic
of systemic absorption and toxicity tum corneum’s water-holding effect. 4 In practice, keratolytic
(salicylate poisoning), especially in capacity, and are keratolytic at and urea treatments should be
young children with a high surface higher concentrations. 4 They applied as tolerated for a couple
area relative to body size. may be less irritant, although of weeks or so to produce a mild

www.escriber.com Prescriber 19 April 2006 39


Prescribing in practice

General measures Treatment is often lifelong.


Patients with severe ichthyosis are
avoid dry or cold environments reluctant to discontinue treatment,
avoid irritants and many have been taking oral
retinoids for 20 or more years. 6
Emollients
Retinoids have important adverse
find the ‘best’ product for the individual by providing samples effects on bone, liver and serum
apply emollient soon after bathing lipids, and their teratogenic poten-
apply regularly tial should be borne in mind in any
use soap substitute and bath oil woman of, or approaching, child-
prescribe sufficient quantities! bearing age. Due to its long half-
life, pregnancy should be avoided
Keratolytics, alpha-hydoxy acids and urea for two years after discontinuing
acitretin. Mandatory contraception
consider addition of salicylic acid, alpha-hydroxy acids or urea to aid
following oral isotretinoin is only
exfoliation and increase hydration
four weeks, but this agent is gener-
may be irritant
ally less effective. In the UK, pre-
avoid applying to large areas of inflamed skin (systemic absorption can occur)
scription of oral retinoids is
Antiseptics and antibiotics restricted to hospital specialists.
Topical retinoids used in psori-
not generally required in the ichthyoses but used to treat secondary infections asis, such as tazarotene (Zorac
in fissured sites (and particularly in BIE to control repeated cutaneous gel)7 and vitamin D analogues, eg
infections and associated body odour) calcipotriol (Dovonex), 8 have
been reported to be of benefit but,
Retinoids
in practice, irritancy is a problem
oral retinoids (acitretin and isotretinoin) are sometimes helpful in the more and widespread and continuous
severe ichthyoses, but should only be used under the supervision of a use carries the risk of systemic tox-
dermatologist; side-effects include teratogenicity, hepatotoxicity, icity.
triglyceridaemia, and chronic skeletal toxicity in long-term use
The role of the GP
Table 4. Summary of ichthyosis management The diagnosis of mild ichthyosis
vulgaris can be made on the char-
exfoliation, which can then be Retinoids acteristic clinical signs (see figures
maintained with less frequent The systemic retinoids acitretin 1 and 2) and may be supported by
application. (Neotigason) and isotretinoin a family histor y of dr y skin. In
Mechanical exfoliation can be (Roaccutane) reduce scaling, pru- more severe male cases, it is impor-
achieved with a loofah or bath ritus and er ythema in most tant to consider the possibility of
mitt while bathing. In patients patients with severe congenital X-linked recessive ichthyosis
with prominent inflammator y ichthyosis.5 For many patients, the (XLRI) due to steroid sulphatase
lesions of keratosis pilaris, er y- effect of oral retinoids is life- deficiency, which has implications
thema may be reduced with a changing, allowing normal partic- for obstetric care of female carri-
potent topical steroid ointment ipation in school, sports and ers due to prolongation of labour
applied for 7-10 days. socialising. in affected male children.

Forum
If you have any issues you would like to air with your colleagues or comments on articles published
in Prescriber, the Editor would be pleased to receive them and, if appropriate, publish them on our
Forum page. Please send your comments to:

The Editor, Prescriber, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, or e-mail
to prescriber@wiley.co.uk

40 Prescriber 19 April 2006 www.escriber.com


Prescribing in practice

In the presence of extracuta- ment of the more severe genetic


neous features (especially devel- ichthyoses.
opmental delay), even with mild
childhood ichthyosis, specialist References
opinion should be sought to 1. Smith FJD, Ir vine AD, Terron-
exclude metabolic causes. Kwiatkowski A, et al. Semidominant
In marked ichthyosis develop- loss-of-function mutations in the filag-
ing in adulthood, causes of grin gene cause ichthyosis vulgaris.
Nature Genetics 2006;38:337-42.
acquired ichthyosis (see Table 1)
2. Judge MR, McLean WHI, Munro CS.
should be excluded. Disorders of keratinisation. In: Burns T,
As with any chronic disease, Breathnach S, Cox N, Griffiths C(eds).
patients with genetically deter- Rook’s textbook of dermatology. Seventh
mined ichthyosis require support edition. Malden, Mass; Oxford:
and encouragement to empower Blackwell Science, 2004.
the family and individual to man- 3. Fleckman P. Management of the
age their condition. More practi- ichthyoses. Skin Therapy Lett 2003;8:
cally, patients require huge 3-7.
quantities of emollients, and they 4. Williams ML, Elias PM. Enlightened
will appreciate repeat prescrip- therapy of the disorders of cornifica-
tion. Clin Dermatol 2003;21:269-73.
tions for an emollient that they
5. Lacour M, Mehta-Nikhar B,
both use and like. The greasy Atherton DJ, et al. An appraisal of
nature of many effective prepara- acitretin therapy in children with
tions may have implications for inherited disorders of keratinisation.
clothing, bedding and laundry. Br J Dermatol 1996;134:1023-9.
6. Katugampola RP, Finlay AY.Oral
Conclusion retinoid therapy for disorders of kera-
Mild degrees of genetically deter- tinization: single-centre retrospective
mined ichthyosis are common, 25 years’ experience on 23 patients. Br
and merge into normality. For J Dermatol. 2006;154:267-76.
the majority of patients, treat- 7 Hofmann B, Stege H, Ruzicka T, et
al. Effect of topical tazarotene in the
ments are directed at relieving
treatment of congenital ichthyoses. Br
symptoms due to dr y skin, and J Dermatol 1999;141:642-6.
avoidance of irritants and regular 8. Kragballe K, Steijlen PM, Ibsen HH,
emollients are the mainstay of et al. Efficacy, tolerability, and safety of
treatment. calcipotriol ointment in disorders of
Patient choice is important to keratinisation. Results of a random-
ensure compliance. Samples of sev- ized, double-blind, vehicle-controlled,
eral nonbranded or branded prod- right/left comparative study. Arch
ucts may need to be provided Dermatol 1995;131:556-60.
before the ideal preparation is
found, and this may change over Resources
time. The addition of salicylic acid, The Ichthyosis Support Group
alpha-hydroxy acids or urea to a (ISG) is a UK registered charity
moisturising base may help to that provides support and infor-
remove scale, but these prepara- mation. ISG, PO Box 7913,
tions are usually more expensive Reading RG6 4ZQ. Tel: 0845 602
and can be irritants. 9202; website: www.ichthyosis.
For more severe ichthyosis, par- org.uk.
ticularly if not present from
infancy or of late onset, specialist Dr Sergeant is specialist registrar and
opinion is recommended. Oral Professor Munro is consultant in der-
retinoids under specialist supervi- matology at the Southern General
sion are valuable in the manage- Hospital, Glasgow

42 Prescriber 19 April 2006 www.escriber.com

You might also like