Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TCM 20 PDF
TCM 20 PDF
Technical Committee
Manual
Reported by the ACI Technical Activities Committee
ACI TCM-20
First Printing
February 2020
The technical committees responsible for ACI committee reports and standards strive to avoid
ambiguities, omissions, and errors in these documents. In spite of these efforts, the users of ACI
documents occasionally find information or requirements that may be subject to more than one
interpretation or may be incomplete or incorrect. Users who have suggestions for the improvement of
ACI documents are requested to contact ACI via the errata website at http://concrete.org/Publications/
DocumentErrata.aspx. Proper use of this document includes periodically checking for errata for the most
up-to-date revisions.
ACI committee documents are intended for the use of individuals who are competent to evaluate the
significance and limitations of its content and recommendations and who will accept responsibility for
the application of the material it contains. Individuals who use this publication in any way assume all
risk and accept total responsibility for the application and use of this information.
All information in this publication is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind, either express or
implied, including but not limited to, the implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular
purpose or non-infringement.
ACI and its members disclaim liability for damages of any kind, including any special, indirect, incidental,
or consequential damages, including without limitation, lost revenues or lost profits, which may result
from the use of this publication.
It is the responsibility of the user of this document to establish health and safety practices appropriate
to the specific circumstances involved with its use. ACI does not make any representations with regard
to health and safety issues and the use of this document. The user must determine the applicability of
all regulatory limitations before applying the document and must comply with all applicable laws and
regulations, including but not limited to, United States Occupational Safety and Health Administration
(OSHA) health and safety standards.
Participation by governmental representatives in the work of the American Concrete Institute and in
the development of Institute standards does not constitute governmental endorsement of ACI or the
standards that it develops.
Order information: ACI documents are available in print, by download, through electronic subscription,
or reprint and may be obtained by contacting ACI.
Most ACI standards and committee reports are gathered together in the annually revised the ACI
Collection of Concrete Codes, Specifications, and Practices.
1
2 ACI 2020 TECHNICAL COMMITTEE MANUAL
The chair of the main committee approves the roster for committee with other organizations. The rules for technical
all subcommittees and the policies and procedures proposed committees presented in this manual apply to ITGs.
by subcommittees. There are three types of subcommittees: To request establishment of an ITG, send the following
editorial, steering, and liaison. information to the TAC Secretary:
1.2.3.1 Editorial subcommittee (a) Background information on how the new technology
An editorial subcommittee provides a uniform editorial innovation will fit into ACI’s general mission
review of each document. The subcommittee usually consists (b) Advantages of the new technology over existing tech-
of an individual or a small group with editorial experience. nology in that field
1.2.3.2 Steering subcommittee (c) List of competing technologies, if any
In a large committee, a steering subcommittee may (d) List of technical papers, reports, and other publications
be established to assist the chair by providing input on that address the new technology
committee actions and plans. (e) List of field demonstration projects, if any, using the
1.2.3.3 Liaison subcommittee new technology
Liaison members represent another country or outside (f) A statement demonstrating the maturity of the new
organizations and are appointed to facilitate exchange of technology to warrant the development of an ITG document
information with ACI. Such organizations may include tech- for the transfer of this technology
nical societies, trade associations, and standards-developing (g) List any ACI technical committee(s) whose mission
organizations. For a committee to have a liaison member, the includes this technology
committee must have a liaison subcommittee. (h) Title and mission for the ITG
1.2.4 Task groups (i) A slate of members and at least one candidate for chair
Task groups are established by the main committee chair (j) A work plan and schedule
to perform short-term tasks for the committee. Members of (k) A target time to complete the mission of the ITG
task groups must be members of the main committee. The 1.3.2 Reorganization
chair submits a title, mission, goals, and roster to staff. A Occasionally, it may be necessary for TAC to reorganize a
website will be created for the task group. The task group committee or merge committees. The reasons for such steps
consists of a chair and voting members. There are no other may include:
categories of membership for a task group. Members of task (a) The committee has completed its assigned mission and a
groups must be members of the main committee. The task smaller committee is needed to maintain committee documents
group is not bound by balloting rules. (b) The mission or direction of the committee needs to be
changed
1.3—Committee establishment, reorganization, (c) Committee reorganization is needed to accomplish the
and discharge assigned mission
1.3.1 Establishment (d) A standards-only writing committee is beginning a
TAC considers and approves requests to establish new new cycle; ACI Committees 301, 318, and 562 are reorga-
technical committees or Innovation Task Groups (ITGs), nized on a regular basis
and appoints the committee chair and TAC contact. The title Upon reorganization, TAC may appoint a new chair and
and mission of the new committee are published in Concrete discharge all members or appoint a new chair who is respon-
International (CI). sible for reviewing current membership. The committee will
1.3.1.1 Request to establish a new technical committee inherit the documents from the merged committee and, once
To request a new technical committee, send the following revised, the documents will receive new numerical designa-
information to the TAC Secretary: tions. Any new publication of the document will need to be
(a) A proposed title and mission for the committee balloted by the inheriting committee.
(b) An explanation of why a new ACI committee should 1.3.2.1 Reorganization with discharge of members
be established If TAC appoints a new chair and discharges the committee
(c) A list of potential members membership, all committee members are notified of the
(d) A slate of candidates for the position of chair reasons for the discharge and given an explanation of
(e) A list of short-term goals of the committee future plans. Former committee members can apply for
(f) A discussion of potential overlap and conflict with reappointment.
other committees 1.3.2.2 Reorganization with retention of members
Additionally, TAC may request a representative of the If the present membership is to be retained, subject to
proposed committee to attend the TAC meeting when forma- review, the chair must:
tion of the new committee is discussed. (a) Review the activity of voting committee members and
1.3.1.2 Request to establish an Innovation Task Group (ITG) change the classification to a nonvoting status or terminate
Innovation Task Groups (ITGs) are temporary technical committee membership of those who have not demonstrated
committees that are formed to accelerate the development of adequate activity
a specific document, usually on new technology. TAC forms (b) Review the overall committee composition and decide
ITGs and assigns their mission. An ITG may operate as a joint on committee membership changes to obtain balance of
interests (if required) and to maintain a reasonable size to Joint seminar or workshop requests are to be submitted
accomplish tasks to TAC using the session request procedure of ACI and the
(c) Add new committee members who have expertise appropriate procedure for the cosponsoring organization.
related to the committee’s mission and who can provide An existing committee may request to sponsor a joint
vitality to the committee session or workshop with another organization when at
The chair may request a statement from a committee least 2/3 of committee voting members vote in favor of the
member on their desire to continue to serve. If a response to proposed arrangement. The chair must forward comments
the request is not received in a reasonable time (2 months is from negative voters to the TAC secretary for approval by
recommended), the chair may consider it to signify a lack of TAC. This is considered an administrative ballot and nega-
interest and decide to terminate that individual’s committee tive votes do not need to be resolved. The following ques-
membership. tions should be addressed in the request to TAC: (a) What is
A membership questionnaire (on the Chair/Officer the proposed title and mission for the joint session or work-
Work Area of the committee webpage) may be used to ask shop? (b) Who will be the lead sponsoring organization?
committee members if they desire to continue as active (c) How will the interests of both organizations be served?
members, change membership status, or resign. (d) How will the joint sponsorship speed and bring a wider
1.3.3 Discharge acceptance of results? (e) What are the session or workshop
TAC may discharge a committee that has completed its goals and the anticipated time frame for achieving these
mission, is inactive, or is ineffective. goals? (f) After achieving these goals, does the proposed
TAC discharges an ITG when the ITG document(s) is committee anticipate development of a SP? (h) Where and
published. when would the joint session or workshop be held?
1.4.2 Joint committees
1.4—Joint committees and committee cooperation ACI technical committees can become joint committees
with other organizations with one or more cosponsoring organizations. According to
1.4.1 Cooperation ACI policy on joint committees, joint committees may be
ACI committees can informally cooperate with other orga- formed when the following criteria are met:
nizations, as long as committee operating procedures are (a) Objective of the proposed activity is desirable and
not impacted. If, however, that cooperation includes formal within the field of ACI endeavor
activities, such as creating technical documents, organizing (b) Interests of both societies would be served
conferences, or symposium sessions, these activities must be (c) Joint participation will avoid duplication of effort
approved by TAC. (d) Joint participation will speed document development
Individuals who want to be involved in creating industry- (e) Joint participation will bring wider acceptance of
specific technical information on material properties of results
concrete or design, construction, inspection, and repair of (f) Joint participation offers greater prospect of funds for
concrete structures, should join ACI committees. Individuals research and experimentation than acting singly
who want to be involved with test method or specifications (g) Prospective membership would be harmonious, even
for reinforced concrete-related materials should join ASTM though there might be anticipated differences of opinion
International committees. This division of responsibilities (h) ACI will receive full recognition in any publicity given
between ACI and ASTM was formalized in 1936. the joint committee
1.4.1.1 Seminars or workshops with cosponsoring Joint committee status may be initiated by the ACI Board
organizations of Direction. The Board, or the ACI Executive Vice Presi-
ACI technical committees can sponsor joint seminars or dent on behalf of the Board, may determine that it is in ACI’s
workshops with one or more cosponsoring organizations if strategic interest for a committee to begin cooperative efforts
the following criteria are met: with another organization. In that case, TAC will work with
(a) Objective of the proposed seminar or workshop is the committee to determine the most appropriate means for
desirable and within the field of ACI endeavor cooperation.
(b) Interests of both societies would be served equally well Joint committee status requests can also be submitted
(c) Joint participation will avoid duplication of effort to TAC. An existing committee may request to become a
(d) Joint participation will speed document development joint committee with another organization when at least 75
(e) Joint participation will bring wider acceptance of percent of committee voting members vote in favor of the
results proposed arrangement. The chair must forward comments
(f) Joint participation offers greater prospect of funds for from negative voters to TAC. This is considered an adminis-
research and experimentation than acting singly trative ballot and negative votes do not need to be resolved.
(g) Prospective membership would be harmonious, even The following questions should be addressed in the
though there might be anticipated differences of opinion request to TAC:
(h) ACI will receive full recognition in any publicity given (a) What is the proposed title and mission for the joint
the joint seminar or workshop committee?
(b) Who will be the lead sponsoring organization?
(c) How will the interests of both organizations be served?
(d) How will the joint sponsorship speed and bring a wider Regular attendance at committee meetings is important
acceptance of results? because that is where members usually arrive at consensus
(e) What are the committee goals and the anticipated time on major issues, resolve negative votes on letter ballots,
frame for achieving these goals? solve problems, plan future activities, and accomplish much
(f) After achieving these goals, does the proposed committee of their work.
anticipate a change in committee or sponsorship status? Meeting schedule conflicts are difficult to avoid because
(h) Where and how often would the joint committee hold of the number of ACI committees and the varied interests
regular meetings? of the voting members. Before granting voting member
There are two options under which a technical committee status to an applicant, the chair should verify that the appli-
can operate as a joint committee: 1) ACI is the major sponsor cant will be able to attend meetings and participate actively
and another sponsoring organization is the minor sponsor; or in the committee work. If an applicant cannot attend these
2) ACI is the minor sponsor and another sponsoring organi- meetings, another membership category may be desirable.
zation is the major sponsor. The chair may waive meeting attendance requirements
When ACI is the major sponsor, joint committees are to under justified circumstances, provided the voting member
operate in accordance with the ACI Technical Committee contributes to the work of the committee.
Manual. The minor sponsor may provide technical input 1.5.1.3 Privileges
during the TAC document review and provide names of Voting members receive minutes, information on items
individuals for TAC to consider when creating a chair slate. being balloted, and correspondence; may express opinions
The committee is designated as a joint committee in all and make motions during committee meetings; vote on all
communications. ballots; have the right to appeal committee action; and have
When ACI is the minor sponsor of a joint committee, the access to the committee’s webpage.
balloting and operating procedures are determined by the 1.5.1.4 Term
major sponsor. All items approved by the joint committee Voting membership has no set term.
are submitted to the TAC Secretary for review by TAC. 1.5.1.5 Appointment
ACI requires that the committee is designated as a joint The chair appoints voting members of technical commit-
committee in all communications. tees based on the applicant’s personal knowledge and
When a joint sponsorship is approved by TAC and the expertise. Appointment as a voting member is not based
Board, a formal memorandum of understanding (MOU), on affiliation or employment. An applicant’s affiliation or
including a specific agreement on committee operations, must employment will be considered, however, in determining
be developed with the other organization(s). The ACI Execu- balance of interests.
tive Vice President is responsible for the execution of MOUs. ITG voting members are appointed by the ITG chair.
Voting members are appointed at two stages: 1) At the
1.5—Membership categories formation of the ITG; and 2) After the first draft is completed
ACI technical committees have four categories of but before the first ballot of the document. At formation, the
members: voting members, associate members, consulting voting membership shall include the chair and at least three
members, and liaison members. All four categories have other individuals. After the first draft, at least three additional
access to the technical committee webpage. Only voting voting members shall be appointed; however, membership
members can vote on ballots; however, associate, consulting, should not exceed 10 voting members. These additional
and liaison members are allowed to offer opinions on ballots. voting members should represent a wide range of interests
Information about the qualifications, requirements, privi- outside the ITG and have no direct economic interest in the
leges, term, and appointment for all membership categories outcome of the document.
is given in 1.5.1 through 1.5.4. All membership changes It is assumed that the information published in an ITG
must be emailed to headquarters along with a reason for the document will be included in a later ACI committee docu-
change in membership. ment; therefore, to facilitate communication and connection
1.5.1 Voting members with related technical committees, the ITG chair is encour-
1.5.1.1 Qualifications aged to appoint members from related technical committees
Voting members must be able to contribute to accomplish as voting members on the ITG.
the committees’ goals. They must have the training, knowl- 1.5.2 Associate members
edge, experience, time, and facilities to perform the work. 1.5.2.1 Qualifications
Voting members do not have to be ACI members but it is Associate members must be ACI members or be a
strongly recommended. member of a cosponsoring organization in the case of a joint
1.5.1.2 Requirements committee.
Voting members are required to participate actively in 1.5.2.2 Requirements
committee work by contributing technical information, Associate members have no formal committee responsibilities.
promptly returning all committee ballots, replying to corre- 1.5.2.3 Privileges
spondence, and regularly attending committee meetings. Associate members receive minutes, information on items
Committee business is conducted through email; there- being balloted, and correspondence; may express opinions,
fore, voting members need to provide an email address. but not vote, during committee meetings; may express opin-
ions, but not vote, on all ballots; and have access to the 1.5.4.3 Privileges
committee’s webpage. Liaison members receive minutes and information on
1.5.2.4 Term items being balloted, may express opinions and vote during
Associate membership .has no set term; however, when subcommittee meetings, are expected to vote on all subcom-
individuals no longer maintain their ACI membership, when mittee ballots, and have access to the main and subcom-
individuals no longer maintain their ACI membership, their mittee webpages.
associate memberships on technical committees are also 1.5.4.4 Term
terminated. Liaison members are appointed for a 3-year term and may
1.5.2.5 Appointment be reappointed.
All ACI members (individual, organizational/sustaining repre- 1.5.4.5 Appointment
sentatives, student, young professional, honorary, and fellow) Liaison members are appointed to ACI liaison subcom-
can be appointed as an associate member to a maximum of three mittees as voting members and to the main committee as
technical committees. A person maintaining a membership in an nonvoting liaison members. ITGs have one liaison member
organization that cosponsors ACI joint technical committees can from SDC.
be appointed to a maximum of three such joint committees. An
associate membership request does not require chair approval. 1.6—Committee membership
A person applying for voting membership may be 1.6.1 Application for membership
appointed as an associate member by the chair for a variety Each prospective committee member (either main
of reasons, including maintaining balance of interests within committee or subcommittee), regardless of membership
the committee or limiting voting membership changes category, is to submit a committee application (found on the
during balloting of a committee document. ACI website), which will be forwarded to the chair of the
1.5.3 Consulting members appropriate technical committee.
1.5.3.1 Qualifications With the exception of the chair and associate members,
Consulting members do not need to be ACI members, but ACI membership is not required for technical committee
should have the expertise within the mission of the committee. membership, but is desirable. All committee members are
1.5.3.2 Requirements encouraged to join ACI.
Consulting members have no formal committee 1.6.2 Appointments and membership changes
responsibilities. Chairs should add new members on a regular basis and
1.5.3.3 Privileges remove inactive members while maintaining balance of
Consulting members receive minutes, information on voting interests. Effective committees should have sufficient
items being balloted, and correspondence; may express opin- turnover so that new ideas are constantly considered. The
ions, but not vote, during committee meetings; may express chair shall decide on all membership changes, including
opinions, but not vote, on all ballots; and have access to the appointments to all membership categories, (except asso-
committee’s webpage. ciate membership), terminations, or changes of member-
1.5.3.4 Term ship status, and notify the TAC Secretary. These actions
Consulting membership has no set term. will be checked by staff for TCM compliance. The effective
1.5.3.5 Appointment appointment date shall be when the membership changes
Consulting members of technical committees are appointed appear on the committee website. No changes in member-
by the chair based on the applicant’s special expertise or a ship voting status can be acted on during an open ballot
long-time association with the committee or its mission. or during the week of an ACI convention. For example, a
After a document is drafted, the chair of an ITG may member cannot change from voting member to associate or
appoint up to three nonvoting consulting members in addi- associate to voting while a letter ballot is open or during ACI
tion to the voting members. These consulting members act conventions.
as outside reviewers and are asked to provide a detailed ACI staff sends the individual and chair a formal appoint-
review of the document. ment, termination, or status change notice showing the
1.5.4 Liaison members effective date.
1.5.4.1 Qualifications Committee members accepting committee appointments
Liaison members are appointed based on their affilia- give ACI permission to post their contact information on
tion with the related organization. Liaison members need the ACI website in a password-protected area, accessible by
not be ACI members, but should have the expertise within other ACI committee members.
the mission of the committee. If the liaison member’s 1.6.3 Appointments to joint committees
affiliation with the related organization is terminated, the When ACI is the major sponsor of a joint committee,
liaison membership on the ACI technical committee is also appointment of members conforms to ACI guidelines. When
terminated. ACI is the minor sponsor of a joint committee, appoint-
1.5.4.2 Requirements ment of members conforms to the other society’s guide-
Liaison members are expected to facilitate the exchange lines. Written agreements between ACI and other organiza-
of information between the ACI technical committee and the tions may regulate membership of joint committees when a
related organization. different arrangement is desired.
1.6.4 Overlap of membership between committees include Producer, User, or General Interest (as defined in
The chair should review the missions of closely-related 1.7.1.1, 1.7.1.2, and 1.7.1.3, respectively) and may be supple-
committees and develop overlapping membership where desir- mented by one or more of the categories in Section 1.7.1.2.1.
able, because cross-representation aids coordination. Some- Membership should ensure balanced coverage of the
times it is necessary to use capable voting members in multiple subject.
committee assignments. Voting membership on more than three 1.7.1 Interest categories
technical committees, however, is generally discouraged. The interest categories appropriate to the development of
1.6.5 Appointment not approved consensus in any given standards activity are a function of the
The chair may decline an application for voting member- nature of the standards being developed. Interest categories
ship for various reasons, including lack of qualifications, the are discretely defined, cover all materially affected parties
inability to attend committee meetings, committee balance, and differentiate each category from the other categories.
timing of a critical ballot, or committee size. 1.7.1.1 Producer
1.6.6 Membership termination A producer interest is an organization, including any
The chair should periodically review each voting repacker or relabeler, or both, who manufactures, fabricates,
member’s performance. Voting members should actively assembles, distributes, or reprocesses a finished product
participate by regularly attending meetings, answering that is used or applied by a contractor that is covered in
correspondence, and returning letter ballots. Chairs should the committee’s mission. A voting member affiliated with a
contact inactive voting members and encourage them to producer interest shall be classified as a Producer.
become more active, consider resigning, or become an asso- 1.7.1.2 User
ciate or consulting member of the committee. Because of A user interest is an organization that purchases or uses
ACI’s stringent voting requirements, voting members who materials, products, or systems covered in the committee’s
do not return ballots may stop a committee from success- mission. A voting member affiliated with a user interest shall
fully balloting a document. Failure of a voting member to be classified as a User. For example, a design engineer who
participate actively in committee activities may result in is a member of a committee writing a design guide may be
termination of membership. classified as a User, but may be classified as General Interest
When a voting member’s inactivity is documented, on a committee dealing with concrete materials.
the chair may decide to change the individual’s member- 1.7.1.2.1 Supplemental categories
ship status to associate or consulting or may terminate the At the Chair’s discretion, defined categories of interest
membership. These actions become official when staff acts for a given committee may also include one or more of the
on the chair’s decision. Before terminating membership of a following, as appropriate to achieve balance.
voting member, the chair is encouraged to discuss the situa- a. Designers (including Engineers/Specifiers/Architects)—
tion with the TAC contact. A Designer interest is any organization, such as an archi-
1.6.7 Resignation from membership tectural firm, engineering firm, or architectural and engi-
Committee members resign by notifying the chair and the neering firm issuing contract documents, administering the
TAC Secretary of such intent. Staff sends an official notice work under contract documents, or both that is covered in
confirming the resignation. the committee’s mission. A voting member affiliated with a
1.6.8 Appeal of membership action Designer interest should be classified as a Designer.
Individuals may appeal a membership action to TAC, such b. Contractors (including Applicators/Installers)—A
as a membership termination or a membership application that Contractor interest is any organization with whom the owner
has been declined. The person submits the appeal to the TAC enters into an agreement for construction of the work that
Secretary. The committee’s TAC contact reviews the appeal is covered in the committee’s mission. A voting member
and recommends action to TAC. The person may request to affiliated with a Contractor interest should be classified as
attend the TAC meeting when the appeal is considered. a Contractor.
c. Owners (End-consumers)—An Owner interest is an
1.7—Balance of interests organization, such as a corporation, association, partner-
All committees should have broad-based membership to ship, individual, or public body or authority with whom the
ensure balanced coverage, including members who represent contractor enters into an agreement and for whom the work
interests materially affected by the committee’s documents. is performed as is covered in the committee’s mission. A
All materially affected interests should have the opportu- voting member affiliated with an Owner interest should be
nity for fair and equitable participation. These members can classified as an Owner.
be classified into several interest categories that represent d. Academics/Educators—An Academic interest is an
segments of the industry. ACI is an international organization organization, such as a college, academy, school, or other
and committee documents should reflect practices that are educational institution, that provides educational or training
broadly applicable (refer to Appendix A). Wide geographical services. A voting member affiliated with an Academic
distribution of committee members guards against publication interest should be classified as an Academic. For example,
of documents that are restricted to local practices. an instructor, educator, or student would be considered an
The chair shall classify every member of a standards-writing Academic.
committee into one of several interest categories which must
e. Researchers—A Researcher interest is an organization guides and reports only) are encouraged to be in balance but
who conducts research and development or provides experi- are exempt from these criteria.
mental testing services related to the committee’s mission. A A member’s interest category shall be related to the
voting member affiliated with a Researcher interest should mission of the committee, and so a member’s interest cate-
be classified as a Researcher. gory can be different on different committees. Commit-
f. Consultants—A Consultant interest is an organization, tees that develop ACI standards must be in balance at all
including individuals or entities in the fields of life safety, times. The chair reviews and adjusts voting membership and
security, engineering, or in any particular building compo- assigns interest categories to establish and maintain balance
nent, equipment, or system that have acquired detailed, of the committee. Balance of interests is not required in
specialized knowledge and experience in the design, evalu- subcommittees or task groups.
ation, operation, repair, or installation of what is covered in Members may appeal their interest category to the
the committee’s mission. A voting member affiliated with a committee chair and ultimately to TAC. Committees seeking
Consultant interest and that is not otherwise classified should exceptions to the requirements of this section can request
be classified as a Consultant, except that a consultant retained TAC consideration. Questions regarding committee balance
by a Producer interest or by a User interest under an indefinite will be resolved by TAC. TAC will consider many factors
continuous arrangement that is covered in the committee’s affecting balance. This will include, but not be limited to,
mission should be classified as Producer or User, respectively. the total number of producer members on the committee, the
1.7.1.3 General interest number of members from a particular interest category, and
Any voting member who does not fit into any of the the number of members representing a specific product.
discretely defined categories above should be classified as More than one voting member from the same organiza-
General interest. tion is discouraged on any committee. Voting membership
1.7.2 Safety- and non-safety-related standards and documents from a single organization constituting more than 10% of the
Codes are safety-related standards. Specifications are committee must be approved by TAC.
non-safety related standards. Guides, reports and other non- 1.7.4 Membership termination to achieve balance
mandatory language documents are not considered stan- To achieve balance of voting member interest, the chair
dards. Existing ACI codes are listed in below: may change voting members to nonvoting categories or
ACI 216.1-14 terminate voting membership. This is done only after the chair
ACI 307-08 has shown that a substantial effort has been made to obtain
ACI 313-16 balance by adding new voting members and assigning new
ACI 318-19 and existing members to appropriate categories of interest.
ACI 318.2-19 When a change of employment produces a change in clas-
ACI 332-14 sification that results in an imbalance in voting interests, a
ACI 349-13 voting membership can be terminated or changed to another
ACI 350-06 membership category. Reappointment as a voting member
ACI 355.2-19 can be considered when balance of voting member interest is
ACI 355.4-20 achieved and if the person requests reappointment.
ACI 359-17
ACI 369.1-17 1.8—Committee officers
ACI 376-11 1.8.1 Chair
ACI 437.2-13 Each technical committee shall have a chair and a TAC
ACI 550.3-13 contact. All other committee officer positions are established
ACI 550.4-18 at the chair’s discretion.
ACI 550.5-18 The chair is responsible for leading the committee to
ACI 550.6-19 accomplish its mission and goals. The chair has many
ACI 550.7-19 specific responsibilities, including:
ACI 562-19 (a) Initiating voting and consulting membership actions,
1.7.3 Criteria for committee balance including appointment, membership recruitment, evalua-
To support the development of competent and objective tion, changes of voting category, and discharge
standards by ACI committees, standards-writing committees (b) Preparing and distributing meeting agenda and minutes
are to have a balance of voting member interests. The criteria in a timely manner (approximately 3 weeks before and after
for balance are that a) no single interest category constitutes a meeting)
more than one-third of the membership of a committee that (c) Maintaining communication with the TAC contact
writes safety-related standards or b) no single interest cate- (d) Conducting committee meetings
gory constitutes more than one-half of the membership of (e) Establishing task groups and subcommittees as needed
a committee that writes non-safety-related standards (i.e., (f) Scheduling committee meetings
the committee writes specifications, but not codes). ACI (g) Initiating committee letter ballots
committees that write only non-standardized documents (i.e. (h) Producing letter ballot summaries
(i) Submitting committee documents to TAC
(j) Submitting updates on any international activities to (c) Ensuring participation of all segments of the concrete
TAC after each convention (including ITGs). (k) Providing industry in committee activities
leadership training for possible successors 1.8.1.5 Chair resignation
(l) Attending the TAC chair breakfast workshop at each A committee chair resigns by notifying the TAC Secretary
convention (2.5) and is asked to supply three replacement chair candidates.
(m) Maintaining committee’s webpages 1.8.2 Vice chair
1.8.1.1 Chair qualifications A vice chair can assist the chair in administering the
A chair of an ACI technical committee must be a member committee, and is appointed at the chair’s discretion.
of ACI. Prior service as vice chair or secretary and voting Appointment does not imply that the vice chair will become
membership on the committee augment the candidate’s the next chair.
experience. 1.8.3 Secretary
The success of any committee effort depends largely on A secretary is encouraged to support the chair by recording,
the skills of the chair. Chairs of ACI technical committees preparing, and distributing meeting minutes; assisting with
must be able to perform the chair responsibilities outlined in the balloting process; and handling correspondence. The
1.8.1 and possess the following strengths: secretary is appointed at the chair’s discretion.
(a) Demonstrated ability and knowledge in the field
covered by the committee CHAPTER 2—TECHNICAL COMMITTEE
(b) Demonstrated leadership ability OPERATIONS
(c) Administrative ability and initiative
(d) Available time and facilities to perform the work 2.1—Mission and title
(e) Ability to attend all ACI conventions The main purpose of ACI technical committees is to
1.8.1.2 Chair term disseminate information through publications and conven-
TAC usually appoints a chair for a 3-year term, which tion sessions within the scope of the committee mission.
expires at the end of an ACI spring convention. A chair may TAC gives the chair considerable authority to accomplish
be reappointed for one additional term. Unusual circum- the committee mission. In most cases, missions are broad
stances are required to justify reappointment of a chair beyond so as not to limit the document type a committee produces.
6 years. Mission statements are usually in the form of: “Develop and
ITG chairs are appointed for the duration of the ITG. report information on <topic>.” A change to the mission or
An incoming chair is granted officer rights on the committee title must be approved by committee ballot before submitting
webpage 30 days before the term becomes effective. An to TAC. This is considered an administrative ballot. Tech-
outgoing chair will maintain officer rights on the committee nical committee missions may be viewed in two categories:
webpage for 30 days after the term ends. The website roster 1) General technical knowledge, such as fracture mechanics
will show incoming and outgoing chairs with temporary clas- or durability; and 2) Industry-specific knowledge, such as
sifications, such as incoming and outgoing chair. parking structures.
1.8.1.3 Chair candidates Committee missions and titles are approved by TAC and
Chairs are responsible for preparing a number of individ- posted on the committee webpage. A committee request to
uals to assume the committee leadership to ensure continuity. change the mission will be considered by TAC.
Each year, chairs are asked to identify at least three possible
replacements, in order of preference, with specific ratings 2.2—Goals
in various categories. ACI staff will notify all committee Each committee periodically reviews and prepares specific
members of the impending conclusion of their chair’s term goals that support the committee mission. Appointed chairs
one convention before the chair term ends. Voting committee will be asked to submit the goals to be completed during
members interested in the position may submit their name to their term. The chair submits information on the progress
the outgoing chair to be included on the list of candidates for of the committee goals using the Modify Committee Home
TAC consideration. link on the webpage. Any or all of the goals in 2.2.1 to 2.2.5
1.8.1.4 Chair appointment may be included.
Appointment and reappointment of technical committee 2.2.1 Develop new documents
chairs are among TAC’s most important responsibilities. A committee may prepare an ACI document within the
TAC considers the advice of chairs when appointing their mission of the committee. TAC approval is required before
successors, but chair appointments are TAC’s responsibility. developing a new ACI document.
TAC may interview the proposed candidates during the 2.2.2 Maintain existing documents
selection process. Technical committees are required to periodically reap-
TAC considers the chair qualifications of the candidates prove, update, revise, or withdraw their documents. TAC
(1.8.1.1) and other factors when selecting chairs, including: approval is not required before updating a published docu-
(a) Rotating the chairs among all qualified committee ment; however, the committee should inform TAC of the
members to keep committee output vigorous intent not to revise ACI document. If the committee does
(b) Ensuring that an individual does not chair more than not revise, reapprove, or withdraw a document within the
one ACI technical committee at a time
8-year period, TAC may reapprove or withdraw it without Committee members and ACI staff must be notified at least
committee recommendation. 21 days in advance if a scheduled meeting is to be canceled.
2.2.3 Sponsor convention sessions and related publications Only members that are physically present at the meeting
A committee may sponsor sessions or symposia at ACI can vote. A member cannot call or videoconference in to the
conventions within the committee mission and may develop meeting to cast a vote.
a related publication such as an ACI Special Publication 2.3.5 Interim committee meetings
(SP). TAC approvals are required for the development of Interim meetings can occur provided the requirements for
sessions and special publications. physical or virtual meetings are met; however, such meet-
2.2.4 Develop seminars ings are not to replace a convention meeting.
ACI’s Educational Activities Committee (EAC) reviews, The agenda and minutes for the interim meeting must be
approves, and manages all ACI seminars. In cooperation posted on the committee website in accordance with 2.3.8
with educational committees, a committee may develop ACI and 2.3.9.
seminars or workshops within the committee mission. This 2.3.5.1 Physical interim meetings
includes suggesting qualified seminar topics, speakers, perti- Chairs must submit a request to hold a physical interim
nent topics, or appropriate presentation materials. meeting at least 3 months in advance. If approved, a notice
2.2.5 Develop video information of the meeting place and time will be published in Concrete
A committee may develop video information. TAC International (CI).
approvals are required for the development of video products. 2.3.5.2 Virtual interim meetings
Chairs can hold a virtual interim meeting through their
2.3—Meetings committee webpage on the ACI website or through other
All technical committee meetings (except closed or virtual means provided the notification requirements are met. The
interim meetings) are open to visitors. The chair is encour- virtual meeting must be set up at least 2 weeks in advance.
aged to give a brief introduction of the committee work and No public notice is required because virtual meetings cannot
periodically summarize progress during the meeting. accommodate visitors. The virtual meeting interface will
2.3.1 Conducting committee meetings generate an email regarding the virtual meeting, which will
Committee chairs are to exercise control to ensure orderly be sent to committee members.
discussion at meetings. This is particularly important in 2.3.6 Closed meetings
large committees. Use parliamentary procedures, known as A closed committee meeting is permitted if the chair states
Robert’s Rules of Order. Robert’s Rules of Order for passing that the matter under consideration is administrative rather
a motion is superseded by ACI rules if the motion is related than technical. For example, a meeting to discuss a slate of
to technical committee documents. If the chair cannot attend potential chairs is closed. Discussion of technical matters
the meeting, designate an individual to chair the meeting so in a closed meeting is not allowed. For a closed meeting,
that committee work can continue uninterrupted. the chair makes the usual arrangements through staff for
2.3.2 Quorum the meeting room but is solely responsible for notifying
For technical committee issues involving technical docu- members of the meeting. Closed meetings are not listed
ments, a quorum is defined as 40 percent of all voting in the convention booklet. A closed meeting may only be
members who must be present at the meeting to conduct busi- attended by committee members and ACI staff.
ness. ACI uses conventional rounding (for example, decimal 2.3.7 Visitors
greater than or equal to 0.5, rounds up). ACI Committee 318, Visitors are welcome at committee meetings because
and other standards-writing committees that have requested committee work is of interest to the public, but their pres-
and received TAC exception to the 40 percent rule, must ence should not interfere with committee work. The chair
comply with the requirements in 3.3.2. should keep the presence of visitors in mind by periodically
2.3.3 Administrative actions summarizing meeting progress.
For passage of administrative actions at committee meet- 2.3.8 Agenda
ings, affirmative votes are required from at least 50 percent The chair should prepare the agenda in advance of the
of the voting members present at the meeting. Administra- meeting and post it to the committee’s website. The chair
tive actions include motions regarding sessions, SPs, goals, should send a notification to the committee members and
mission changes, meeting times, and approval of minutes. the committee’s TAC contact when the agenda has been
2.3.4 Convention committee meetings posted and bring printed copies to the meeting for committee
Committee meetings take place at ACI conventions. ACI members and visitors.
committees are expected to meet at every ACI conven- 2.3.9 Minutes
tion. Committee chairs are responsible for scheduling and Record important deliberations, resolution of negative
calling committee meetings. Committee officers can request votes, and decisions reached during committee meetings in
meeting rooms through the committee’s website. Chairs the meeting minutes. Minutes provide a continuous record
communicate with ACI staff for guidance and to ensure of committee work and help prevent repeated discussion of
sufficient early notification and inclusion of the meeting in the same subject. Post minutes to the committee’s webpage
the convention booklet. approximately 3 weeks following the meeting. Approve the
minutes by web ballot or at the next committee meeting. Post express their opinion as appropriate, but must indicate they
minutes to the committee webpage. do not represent ACI.
In addition to recording motions and voting results, the 2.4.5 Coordination among committees
minutes should include the names of committee members The missions of several committees may be closely
and visitors in attendance and voting members not present. related and the work of one committee may affect or overlap
with another. To avoid publishing conflicting information in
2.4—Communication ACI documents, chairs must be aware of their committee’s
Effective communication is vital to committee activity and work in relation to other technical committees and reference
progress. To ensure timely completion of committee work, other ACI documents when applicable. If a chair is unaware
concise correspondence with prompt attention and reply by of another committee’s work, a visit to that committee’s
members is necessary. webpage is helpful. The TAC contact or staff can assist the
Committee chairs and secretaries are encouraged to use chair in identifying related committee work.
the committee webpage to speed committee communication. 2.4.6 Committee reporting and webpage management
2.4.1 Correspondence within a committee Each chair is expected to review and regularly update
Make available to the entire committee correspondence their committee webpage with respect to committee mission
related to committee activities. This allows the members to statements, documents, and member balance. Changes and
be up-to-date before meetings so that committee discussions updates to the website content can be executed by clicking
are more effective. on the Modify Committee Home on the committee page, or
Make correspondence available to the main committee contacting your TAC representative.
officers so that they are aware of the work and better able to 2.4.7 Questionnaires
coordinate the committee effort. Chairs may find it useful to gather information by using
2.4.2 Correspondence between committees questionnaires. Carefully design questionnaires so as to elicit
Correspondence between committees usually occurs meaningful responses. Send a copy, along with a summary
between the chairs, with copies sent to the TAC Secretary. of the results or other appropriate information, to the TAC
If committee members correspond on committee activities, Secretary. The summary should be made available to the
send copies to the chairs of the respective committees. committee and all respondents.
2.4.3 Correspondence with TAC and ACI headquarters A membership questionnaire may be used to ask committee
The committee files at ACI headquarters are the official members if they desire to continue as active members,
files. The chair can either post all important correspondence, change membership status, or resign.
agenda and minutes, complete records of ballots, and resolu-
tion of negative votes to the committee’s website as appro- 2.5—Breakfast meeting for technical committee
priate, or distribute copies to all committee members, the TAC chairs
chair, TAC contact, and the TAC Secretary. Anything sent At each ACI convention, TAC holds a breakfast meeting
to staff for processing, such as a document submittal, must for technical committee chairs. These meetings are designed
be accompanied by instructions. Refer to the ACI website’s to allow the committee chairs to meet and interact with their
Document Development page, which can be found under the TAC contacts, find out what is expected of them as chairs,
tab Committees. Any material received at ACI headquarters hear about new developments, and ask questions.
without instructions is regarded as an information copy and, The technical committee chairs are expected to attend
after the contents are noted, is placed in the committee file. these meetings. If the chair is unable to attend a meeting, the
Post-draft documents to the website or distributed to all chair is to name an alternate so the committee can be repre-
committee members, TAC Chair, TAC Contact, and TAC sented at each meeting. Only one person should represent
Secretary. Add the following disclaimer to the bottom of the committee. At the spring meeting, the incoming chairs
each page of a draft document: “This draft is not final and is are also invited to attend.
subject to revision. Do not circulate or publish.”
The ACI President and staff, other than the TAC Secre- 2.6—Technical committee certificates
tary, do not need copies of correspondence unless it relates ACI recognizes technical committee members with the
to Institute matters outside of technical committee work. following types of certificates for technical committee
If a committee is joint with another organization, addi- participation and outstanding service by committee
tional distribution of correspondence may be required. members.
2.4.4 Discussion in outside publications 2.6.1 Chair certificates
If an outside publication publishes articles or comments on On behalf of TAC, ACI sends a certificate of apprecia-
a technical committee’s area of expertise, a committee can tion to outgoing technical committee chairs. The certificate
respond by a letter to the editor or other appropriate means. recognizes the contributions of the person for chairing a
The committee may reiterate published ACI information, but specific committee and the years of service.
must not present new technical information without TAC 2.6.2 Outstanding service by committee members
approval. TAC must approve all letters written by commit- The committee chair may recognize a committee member
tees to outside entities. Individual committee members may who has performed outstanding service, such as:
(a) Extraordinary effort in the production or revision of a 2.7.3 Strategic Development Council (SDC)
committee document The SDC periodically identifies industry-critical issues
(b) Leadership and administrative skills in organizing and that would benefit from development of ACI documents. The
conducting a successful technical session SDC coordinates with TAC at each convention regarding
The chair shall obtain TAC contact approval before recom- industry issues, including appropriate platforms for devel-
mending this recognition to ACI. ACI issues the certificate opment of documents requested by the SDC, through an
with the committee chair and the TAC contact as signatories. existing technical committee, the formation of a technical
2.6.3 Del Bloem Distinguished Service Award committee, or the formation of an ITG. Should the develop-
The Institute established a Distinguished Service Award ment of such an ACI document require funding, the SDC
in 1969 to recognize noteworthy work on ACI technical will manage the funding.
committees. The name of the award was changed to the 2.7.4 Committee work expenses
Delmar L. Bloem Distinguished Service Award in 1972 in The TAC Secretary can honor vouchers from a committee
honor of the late Delmar Bloem who had demonstrated, chair, or a person authorized by the chair, for postage or
over a period of many years, the characteristics and dedi- reproduction expenses incurred in committee work. ACI
cation required for the award. The award is given to a does not assume other committee expenses unless the Board
current (or recent) chair of a technical committee, or of Direction specifically provides prior authorization.
under special circumstances, to deserving individuals
other than committee chairs, in recognition of outstanding 2.8—Staff assistance
performance. Although the ACI engineering staff is not large enough to
One award may be given each year; however, there may provide a permanent liaison for each committee, staff can
be none or more than one recipient in any particular year. assist a chair with technical, editorial, or administrative tasks.
Any ACI member can nominate another member. Nomi-
nators will submit to ACI Headquarters an email or letter CHAPTER 3—BALLOTING
emphasizing the chair or committee member’s outstanding
performance on a particular committee. 3.1—Voting methods and rules
Nominations submitted by January 31 will be considered Letter ballots and meeting ballots are the two methods of
by TAC at the summer meeting. TAC approves the candi- voting available to committees.
dates at their summer meeting, and submits names and cita- ACI’s consensus process consists of three rules applicable
tions to the Board for approval in the fall. The awards are to letter and meeting ballots: the 1/2 rule, the 40 percent rule,
granted the following spring and the recipients are listed on and the 2/3 rule (refer to Table 3.1).
the ACI website and in CI.
Table 3.1—Three rules applicable to letter and
2.7—Committee-related finances meeting ballots
2.7.1 ACI Foundation funding Rule Description Use
The ACI Foundation is a subsidiary of the American At least half of all eligible Letter ballots for
Concrete Institute that receives, administers, and expends The 1/2 rule voting members* must cast an technical committees
funds for educational, research, and scientific purposes. The affirmative vote and ITGs
At least 40 percent of all Meeting ballots for
Foundation’s Concrete Research Council (CRC) reviews The 40
eligible voting members* must technical committees
research funding requests and provides funds as available percent rule
cast an affirmative vote and ITGs†
and appropriate. The Foundation’s Strategic Development The number of affirmative Letter and meeting
Council (SDC) is a forum for the leaders in the concrete The 2/3 rule votes must be at least twice the ballots for technical
industry, government, academia, and customers to discuss number of negative votes committees and ITGs
and develop strategies and initiatives to overcome obstacles *
Eligible voting members are all voting members on the committee roster, not only
the number of members who voted.
to technology acceptance. The SDC is a source of ideas for †
Exceptions to the 40 percent rule are given in 3.3.1.
ACI committees and ITGs.
2.7.2 Concrete Research Council (CRC)
Balloting examples, including letter ballots, meeting
The ACI Foundation’s Concrete Research Council (CRC)
ballots, and consideration of negative votes, are found on
seeks to advance the concrete industry through the funding
ACI’s website.
of concrete research projects that further the knowledge and
Proxy voting is not allowed.
sustainability of concrete materials, construction, and struc-
3.1.1 Administrative ballots
tures in coordination with ACI Committees where possible.
Administrative ballots are ballots that do not require
Visit the ACI Foundations webpage to find out how CRC
a resolution of negative votes and may be either letter or
can assist committees with items such as:
meeting ballots. Examples of administrative ballots include:
(a) Endorse a research project
(a) Changing a title or mission statement
(b) Provide partial or full funding
(b) Selecting day and time of next meeting
(c) Locate a research team
(c) Requesting joint committee status
(d) Secure funding outside of CRC
(d) Cosponsoring documents with other ACI technical If a member votes negative on an item and has editorial
committees comments that are not part of the negative, they must be
(e) Sponsoring a session or special publication (SP) clearly marked as editorial. If the comments are not clearly
(f) Approval of committee meeting minutes marked, the chair must communicate with the negative voter
(g) Transfer of documents from committee to committee to clarify which comments are editorial.
(both committees need ballot) TAC strongly encourages the use of the balloting feature
on the committee website for all letter ballots.
3.2—Letter ballots 3.2.1 Passage of letter ballot items
A letter ballot is an official written action to determine if Items on a letter ballot pass if both the 1/2 rule and 2/3
an item has the consensus of a technical committee or ITG. rule are satisfied.
Letter ballots can be used to vote on preparing new docu- The 1/2 rule is satisfied if at least half of all eligible voting
ments, revising or withdrawing existing documents, reap- members on the committee roster cast an affirmative vote.
proving documents, responding to TAC and public discus- The 2/3 rule is satisfied if the number of affirmative votes
sion comments, and administering administrative ballots. is at least twice the number of negative votes.
A letter ballot consists of one or several items. Each item A letter ballot item supersedes all previous ballots on that
passes or fails separately, and may include as much content same item.
as desired: an entire document, a chapter, a section, several A summary of the process to analyze letter ballot results is
sections, a paragraph, or other information. shown in Fig. 3.2.1.
Members have the following voting options for each item The final letter ballot is defined as the last letter ballot that
on the letter ballot: affirmative, affirmative with editorial contained an item that completed the document, allowing the
comments, negative, or abstain. Members are expected to committee to submit it for TAC review. A letter ballot item
return a vote on each item. to find negative votes from previous ballots nonpersuasive
is not considered a final letter ballot. Balloting information 3.2.5.2 Affirmative votes with comments
and tools are found on the ACI website under Committees, An ACI letter ballot must allow for members to submit
Document Development Guidance. affirmative votes with comments. An affirmative vote with
3.2.2 Initiation and format comment is considered as an affirmative vote when deter-
A committee chair can initiate a letter ballot at any time, mining if an item in a letter ballot passes. If the committee
or a voting member can call for a letter ballot by making a chair deems a comment is editorial and appropriate, the
motion at a committee meeting. To pass such a motion, a chair has the authority to implement the change if there
majority of voting members present at the meeting must vote are no objections by voting members; no further action by
affirmatively. the committee is required. An editorial comment could be
The chair formats the letter ballot items as deemed suitable. a style or grammar correction according to The Chicago
It is suggested to distribute the ballot items in portable docu- Manual of Style, incorrect format according to Chapters 5 or
ment format (pdf) (not as word processing files) with page 6 of the TCM, missing reference information, or repetitive
and line numbers. Committee members can then reference information.
the page and line numbers when making comments using the If the chair or voting member believes that the comment
document ballot form. The chair should upload the document is not editorial, or if there is doubt, the committee chair must
ballot form, available on the ACI website, with the ballot. ballot the comment.
3.2.3 Time frame The chair may also decide to relegate the changes
All letter ballots must specify a closing date, which should suggested by the voter to new business to be addressed in a
be no less than 30 days from the date of initiation. later revision of the document.
To specify a balloting period shorter than 30 days, the chair 3.2.5.3 Negative votes with reason
must obtain approval from the committee’s TAC Contact, An ACI letter ballot must allow for members to submit
and notify the TAC Secretary of the approval. In such a case, negative votes. If a committee member casts a negative vote
the chair must ensure that all voting members received the on an item in a letter ballot, a reason for the negative vote
letter ballot and have had the opportunity to vote. An accept- must be included. If appropriate, the voter should provide
able method is for the chair to contact any voting member alternative wording or a solution that would satisfy the
who has not responded a few days before the ballot closes. voter’s concerns. All negative votes cast on an item in a
There are no restrictions on the maximum number of days letter ballot are considered by the committee using the reso-
that may be specified for a balloting period. For example, lution procedures described in 3.4.
the chair may extend the closing date if an insufficient If the negative voter does not provide a reason for the
number of ballots are received by the closing date. All negative vote, the vote is recorded as a negative without
voting members must be notified in the case of an extension comment. A negative without comment is considered an
and given the opportunity to vote or change their existing abstention when determining if a ballot item passes, does
vote. All votes received, including negative votes received not need to be resolved by the procedures given in 3.4, and
during the extended voting period, shall be included in the requires no further committee action.
ballot analysis. Votes received after the closing date are not 3.2.5.4 Abstentions
counted and do not have to be resolved. Balloting ends at An ACI letter ballot must allow for members to submit
11:59 pm Eastern Standard Time. abstentions. Abstentions impact letter ballots because only
3.2.4 Distribution affirmative and negative votes are counted when applying
A letter ballot shall be distributed to all committee members. the 1/2 rule to determine if a ballot passes. Voting members
A letter ballot can be distributed by the web balloting feature usually abstain if they do not have enough relevant expertise
of the committee’s ACI website or by e-mail. Web balloting to cast an educated vote, or if they have a conflict of interest
is the preferred method, and chairs are encouraged to use the with the item being balloted. In addition, only affirmative
ACI website to issue and tabulate letter ballot results. If the and negative votes are counted when applying the 2/3 rule to
chair prefers not to use the web balloting feature, the ballot determine if a ballot passes.
must include the due date for ballot response, method to 3.2.5.5 Ballots not returned
respond to the ballot, voting options, and ballot description. If a member does not return a vote on a letter ballot, their
A notice of the web ballot shall be sent to the TAC contact. ballot is recorded as not returned. An unreturned ballot is
The results of the letter ballot must be placed on the agenda considered an abstention when determining if an item in a
of the next committee meeting and reported in the minutes ballot passes, and can therefore impact the result in the same
of that meeting. manner as an abstention. If an insufficient number of ballots
3.2.5 Votes are returned by voting members, items in the ballot will not
Voting members, including the chair, are required to vote receive enough affirmative votes to meet the 1/2 rule.
on every item on all letter ballots. For web ballots, submit a 3.2.5.6 Comments from nonvoting members on committee
vote using the web ballot form or as required by the chair. Associate, consulting, and liaison members may submit
3.2.5.1 Affirmative votes comments on letter ballot items. The comments are not
An ACI letter ballot must allow for members to submit counted in the final ballot tally, do not affect the outcome of
affirmative votes. Affirmative votes require no further a ballot item, and do not have to be resolved. However, these
committee action. comments must be distributed to the committee for review.
3.2.6 Analysis and further action revised and reballoted. Each ballot on an item supersedes the
Once the letter ballot is closed, the chair reviews all previous ballot on the same item, so the negative votes from
votes received on individual items of the ballot and deter- the previous ballot do not have to be resolved.
mines if each item satisfies the 1/2 and 2/3 rules. At this 3.2.7 Subcommittee letter ballots
point, the chair shall notify the committee of the letter ballot Committees with subcommittees shall establish proce-
results, including all editorial comments and negative votes dures for subcommittee letter ballots. The purpose of
received. Letter ballot items that do not pass can be revised subcommittee ballots is to obtain the consensus opinion
and submitted for another letter ballot or withdrawn from of that group, which is passed on to the main committee.
further consideration. The chair may require subcommittees to follow all of ACI’s
If a ballot item passes but some members cast negative consensus procedures; however, because an item approved
votes, further action by the committee is required. All nega- by the subcommittee must still be balloted by the main
tive votes cast on a passing ballot item must be resolved by committee to be accepted, there is no ACI requirement that
the committee using the procedures described in 3.4. If a negatives on subcommittee ballots be resolved. Reasons for
negative cannot be resolved on an item that pertains to a unresolved negative votes on subcommittee ballots need to
revision of a document, the ballot item can be withdrawn be forwarded to the main committee.
and no change is made to the document that relates to the 3.2.8 Patented items
ballot item. During balloting of the document, the committee must be
3.2.6.1 Updating results informed if the document refers to the use of patented tech-
Negative votes withdrawn by the negative voter change nology. If a member believes that a committee document
the results of the 1/2 and 2/3 rules. A withdrawn negative is under ballot would require a user of the resulting ACI docu-
reclassified as affirmative or abstention based on 3.4.1. ment to violate the intellectual property rights, such as patents
3.2.6.2 Revising and reballoting or copyrights, that member is expected to alert the committee.
Even if an item passes, the chair may decide that too many If the committee includes information on patented items
negative votes have been received and it is not practicable to within a document, include the disclaimer in 14.2.7.
attempt resolving them, or that the ballot has identified major
deficiencies in the document. In either case, the chair informs
the committee members that the ballot items will need to be
If a letter ballot item or meeting ballot to find a nega- When a ballot to change a document in response to a
tive vote unrelated fails, the negative vote must be resolved persuasive negative vote passes unanimously, including an
under 3.4.3 or 3.4.4. affirmative vote from the voter who cast the original nega-
If the ballot to find a negative vote unrelated is successful, tive, the original negative is recorded in the minutes as an
the ballot results and the committee’s reasons are reported in affirmative. The minutes shall also record the affirmative
the meeting minutes. The vote is recorded in the minutes as vote on the motion to resolve the previous negative.
an abstention. The comment may be considered as new busi- If a document is revised in response to a persuasive nega-
ness by the committee. tive vote, the meeting minutes must report that the nega-
3.4.3 Nonpersuasive (no change to document) tive was found persuasive and give the approved technical
The chair may issue a letter ballot or a voting member at change and the vote count.
a meeting may make a motion that the stated reason for the 3.4.5 Appeals
negative vote is nonpersuasive. A member whose negative vote is found unrelated or
By letter ballot nonpersuasive has the right to appeal. A note in the minutes
The chair issues a letter ballot with an item to find the is sufficient notice of this right. The appeal must be submitted
reason given for a negative vote nonpersuasive and provides to TAC and must state whether it is based on technical or
a statement to support the action. The ballot item must procedural grounds. The appeal cannot be submitted before
satisfy both the 1/2 and 2/3 rules to pass. Negative votes on the committee balloting on the document is complete.
this ballot item do not need to be resolved.
By meeting ballot 3.5—Ballot summaries
During a meeting, a voting member makes a motion that The results of all letter and meeting ballots must be
the reason given for a negative vote is nonpersuasive, and recorded in the committee minutes, as minutes are the official
provides a statement to support the motion. The committee record of committee actions. If a separate ballot summary
discusses the motion and then votes. The ballot must satisfy of a letter ballot was mailed to the committee, it must be
both the 40 percent and 2/3 rules to pass. Negative votes on attached to the minutes of the next meeting. Alternatively,
this ballot do not need to be resolved. the text of the minutes can summarize the ballot results.
If the ballot to find a negative vote nonpersuasive fails, Additionally, a formal ballot summary must be submitted
the negative vote must be resolved under 3.4.4, or the to the TAC Secretary for each letter ballot at the time the
committee must withdraw the item from further consider- document is submitted to TAC for review. A ballot summary
ation and ballot a revised item. Ballot results are reported in allows a complete ballot history to be maintained at ACI
the meeting minutes. headquarters during the development and processing of a
If the ballot to find a negative vote nonpersuasive is document to publication. The ballot summary must include:
successful, the ballot results and the committee’s reasons are (a) A list of the items balloted
reported in the meeting minutes. The original negative vote (b) The date the ballot was initiated
is recorded in the minutes as a nonpersuasive negative. (c) The closing date
3.4.4 Persuasive (technical change to document) (d) A list of voting members at the time of the final ballot
Unless the negative vote is withdrawn, is found to be unre- (e) For each item, the initial vote tally, including:
lated, or is found to be nonpersuasive, the negative vote must (i) The number of affirmative votes
be considered to be persuasive. The committee must vote to (ii) The number of affirmative with editorial comment
approve a technical change to the document in response to votes
the negative vote. (iii) The number of negative votes and names of each
By letter ballot negative voter
The chair issues a letter ballot with an item to accept the (iv) The number of abstentions and names of voters who
proposed change. The ballot item must satisfy both the 1/2 and abstained
2/3 rules to pass. Negative votes on a successful ballot item (v) The number of ballots not returned and the names of
must be resolved by another letter ballot or by meeting ballot. voters who did not respond
By meeting ballot (vi) The resolution of each negative, including a
During a meeting, a voting member makes a motion to summary for subsequent letter or meeting ballots
accept the proposed change. The committee discusses the (f) For each item, the final vote tally if any votes changed
motion, considers suggested amendments, and then votes. The due to consideration of negatives.
ballot must satisfy both the 40 percent and 2/3 rules to pass. A copy of the ACI web ballot results page along with
Negative votes on a successful ballot must be resolved by documentation on resolution of negative votes is sufficient.
another meeting ballot or by letter ballot, unless the negative
voter agrees that formal resolution of the negative vote is not 3.6—Procedures when ACI is the minor sponsor
required. Such an agreement shall be recorded in the minutes. When ACI is the minor sponsor of a joint committee, the
If a ballot to change a document in response to a persua- balloting and operating procedures are determined by the
sive negative vote fails, the negative vote must be resolved major sponsor. All items approved by the joint committee
under 3.4, or the committee must withdraw the item and are submitted to the TAC Secretary for review by TAC.
ballot a revised item that addresses the negative vote.
PART 2—ACI STANDARDS covered by an existing code. Code cases ensure that such
clarifications or provisions are given general distribution.
CHAPTER 4—DEVELOPMENT OF STANDARDS The TAC Secretary considers code case requests and, if
accepted, a processing fee is charged.
4.1—Description Individuals requesting a code case must do so in writing.
Standardization is the most rigorous consensus process The TAC Secretary acts as a liaison between the indi-
used by ACI. It provides the widest input and highest overall vidual and the appropriate committee and is responsible for
quality assurance for a document. The ACI standardization submitting requests to the committee. The code case will be
process is approved by the American National Standards published in Concrete International (CI) within 6 months of
Institute (ANSI). Documents that go through this process the date of approval.
are identified as ACI standards; however, the word “Stan- A code case applies only to the designated edition of a
dard” does not appear in the title. The phrase “An ACI Stan- code (for example, ACI 318-14) and not to other editions.
dard” appears on the cover of the standard. ACI standards 4.1.1.3 Acceptance criteria
are written in mandatory language and can be referenced An acceptance criteria document is a subset of a code and
by model codes, authorities having jurisdiction over local is written in such a form that its requirements can be coordi-
building codes, persons or agencies that provide specifica- nated directly with a specific code (for example, ACI 318-14).
tions, or in legal documents such as Project Specifications. Acceptance criteria follow the code requirements format.
4.1.1 Standards 4.1.1.4 Design specifications
Standards may contain design, construction, durability, A design specification provides minimum requirements for
assessment, maintenance, repair, and rehabilitation require- concrete or masonry structures within its scope to safeguard
ments. Standards must be worded in explicit, mandatory the public safety, health, and general welfare. It is available
language so that there is only one possible interpretation. for reference in legal documents other than building codes,
Standards shall cite only mandatory-language documents. such as federal government contracts. Design specifications
References to nonmandatory language documents such as follow the code requirements format.
guides, reports, papers, and research results can be made in 4.1.2 Construction standards
a separate commentary. ACI construction standards are written to direct the
When submitting revisions to a design standard for review producers, testing agencies, and construction team and not
by TAC, the committee must provide reason statements for the design professional. Construction standards are worded
the revisions, including background information, and an in explicit, mandatory language so that there is only one
explanation of the significance of the revisions. Committees possible interpretation.
should consider “new business” items from the previous 4.1.2.1 Construction specifications
standard when working on a revision. Construction specifications are reference specifications
4.1.1.1 Code requirements that can be included as part of a contract between Owner
An ACI code provides minimum requirements for concrete and Contractor.
or masonry structures within its scope to safeguard public Titles of construction specifications should indicate that
safety, health, and general welfare. Codes may be adopted by they pertain to construction.
a model building code or by a regulatory agency or may be 4.1.2.2 Material specifications
used by an industrial or governmental organization for which Material specifications are reference specifications that
construction or manufacture of a work which uses concrete. prescribe requirements for materials used in projects, are
ACI committees can publish commentaries to complement written to the producer, and may be incorporated by reference
their codes, which often provide supporting documentation into construction specifications or into Contract Documents.
for code provisions. A commentary is organized to parallel ASTM committees have the general responsibility for
the code section numbering. Not all code sections require developing material specifications for concrete-related prod-
corresponding commentary sections, but all commentary ucts. In support of other ACI design or construction stan-
sections require a corresponding code section. dards, and with TAC approval, ACI committees may develop
A commentary is written in nonmandatory language and material specifications. TAC and ACI staff will notify ASTM
can reference documents that are written in nonmandatory of this proposed activity and confirm that ASTM is not
language. Commentaries may offer alternatives for satisfying preparing a similar standard. Material specifications must be
specific provisions in the codes, and may refer to patented published as stand-alone documents and not as a section in
items that can be used to meet the intent of a specific provi- a larger document.
sion. Because they are written in nonmandatory language, The committee is to follow the document outline and
commentaries cannot be referenced by codes. format shown in the Form and Style of ASTM Standards
4.1.1.2 Code cases (available at www.astm.org) for preparing a specification,
A code case clarifies an existing code or provides new but otherwise use ACI style. After publication by ACI, if
provisions for situations not covered by an existing code a material specification falls within the scope of an ASTM
and might result in a new code requirement, which will be subcommittee, ACI staff sends the test method to the ASTM
included in the next code edition. Specific requirements in staff manager responsible for the committee that addresses
code language provide rules for additions or alternatives not that area of technology.
historical and no committee action is required. (A standard Committee standards, at any stage of development, must
is designated historical when it has been superseded by a not be released for publication other than to ACI or cospon-
revision.) The revised standard’s number receives the new sors of joint committees, except on approval of TAC. Similar
year of adoption. restrictions apply to test data or unpublished technical infor-
Committees are to submit to TAC reason statements for mation circulated in a committee.
revisions to ACI standards, including background informa- Posting draft or published documents on independent
tion and explanations of the significance of the revisions. websites is not permitted. Posting draft standards on the
4.2.2.3 Withdrawal committee’s ACI website is encouraged.
The committee should ballot for withdrawal of the stan- 4.2.6 Coordination of ACI standards
dard when the committee determines that the information it 4.2.6.1 Industry standards
contains is obsolete and should not be revised. A letter ballot Table 4.2.6.1 lists committees that write the governing
of the committee is required. The recommendation for with- standards for a specific industry.
drawal should include a statement that, in the judgment of
the committee, the standard is no longer useful or amenable Table 4.2.6.1—Industry standards
to updating. The committee’s recommendation and related ACI design and construction
ballot summary must be submitted to the TAC Secretary for standards
review by TAC. ACI committee New Repair
Upon TAC’s approval of the recommendation, the docu- 301 — Specifications for Concrete Construction —
ment is no longer included in the next edition of the ACI 318 — Structural Concrete Building
Design —
Code
Collection. It may still be available for purchase from ACI
562 — Evaluation, Repair, and
as a historical standard. Rehabilitation of Concrete Buildings
— Design
4.2.3 Maintenance of the content of ITG standards 563 — Specifications for Repair of
After an ITG standard is published, TAC will request an — Construction
Structural Concrete in Buildings
ACI committee to assume jurisdiction over the ITG stan- 307 — Concrete Chimneys Design —
dard. Related technical committee(s) may have been identi- 313 — Concrete Bins and Silos Design —
fied during formation of the ITG. 332 — Residential Concrete Work Design —
The technical committee should: 350 — Environmental Engineering
Design —
(a) Review and revise the content of the ITG standard Concrete Structures
or incorporate the information into an existing committee 346 — Cast-in-Place Pipe Construction —
standard 349 — Concrete Nuclear Structures Design —
(b) Ballot the revised content of the ITG standard as soon 359 — Concrete Components for
Design —
Nuclear Reactors
as practicable because the ITG standard only has a 5-year
376 — Concrete Structures
life in the ACI Collection; however, TAC can extend that for Refrigerated Liquefied Gas Design build —
time. To request an extension, the Chair should e-mail the Containment
TAC Secretary requesting an extension and a reason why an
extension is necessary. 4.2.6.2 Interaction among standards-writing committees
4.2.4 Committee editorial review ACI committees listed in Table 4.2.6.1 develop standards
The committee’s editorial subcommittee or task group that are specific to an industry. ACI does not want to create
should edit a standard thoroughly before final committee standards with overlapping scopes; therefore, TAC limits the
letter ballot. When submitting the standard to TAC, the chair number of ACI standards to one for each industry for new
should state that the editorial subcommittee has completed and existing construction. For example, in the commercial
its task. building industry, ACI 318 is the design standard, ACI 301
The editorial subcommittee should review the stan- is the construction standard, ACI 562 is the repair design
dard for organization, sentence structure, grammar, standard, and ACI 563 is the repair construction standard.
redundancy, spelling, and typographical errors. Because With approval from TAC, technical committees whose
many people contribute to a standard, it is essential topics are intended to address specific industry segments are
that the subcommittee review the separate sections for free to create a standard within its mission as long as the
consistency in style and format. Members of the edito- standard does not overlap that of another standard. Ensure
rial subcommittee need to be familiar with the format and the scope of the standard does not overlap that of another
style of ACI standards. ACI standard.
4.2.5 Circulating draft standards 4.2.6.3 Proposed changes from outside of committee
Mark drafts of ACI standards as “This draft is not final Committees are permitted to propose changes to the
and is subject to revision. Do not circulate or publish.” The ACI standards given in Table 4.2.6.1, such as ACI 318.
chair may only circulate the draft to individuals outside the The proposed change has to be approved by the submit-
committee, TAC, and ACI staff to obtain expert technical ting committee in accordance with balloting procedures of
advice not available in the committee or to ensure that all Chapter 3. The communication should include the proposed
interested parties are given an opportunity to express view- change in strikeout/underline, reason for change, and tech-
points when developing an ACI standard. nical background. The committee receiving the proposed
change is expected to consider the change in a timely fashion Technical committees define terms in their standards,
and notify the submitting committee of the results. and are to ensure consistent usage within both the technical
4.2.6.4 Coordination among technical committees committee and ACI. The CT is available on the ACI website.
Coordination with other technical committees is an impor- Individuals may submit proposed CT changes to TAC. The
tant part of developing standards. Some reasons for coordi- CT is updated on a yearly basis.
nation with other committees are: TAC reviews each standard’s definitions at the time of
(a) To incorporate or reference information from another submission for TAC review.
committee standard 4.2.7 Translation of ACI standards
(b) To minimize instances of standards with parallel or Translation of an ACI standard into a language other
overlapping scopes than English may be permitted. Refer to the Board Policy
(c) To minimize technical conflicts between committee on translation of ACI products. Where the Board Policy
standards requires review and approval by the policies of the origi-
If there are substantial technical conflicts between the stan- nating committee, TC considers an editorial change and no
dards of two technical committees, the matter can be referred further balloting by TAC is required.
to TAC. It is acknowledged that standards submitted for TAC 4.2.8 Patented items
review may be in conflict with or vary from published ACI ACI technical committee standards cannot and do not
documents. If committees are aware of such conflicts, the endorse or promote patented products or proprietary tech-
submitted standard should substantiate identified conflicts. nology of any kind. ACI standards shall not refer directly
4.2.6.5 Standards sponsored with other ACI technical to a particular patent or proprietary technology by use of
committees trademarks or trade names. If a standard’s requirement can
ACI committees may agree to cosponsor a standard when only be satisfied practicably by use of a patented material,
the scope of the standard overlaps their missions. Commit- product, process, procedure, or apparatus, full and apparent
tees may request to jointly sponsor a standard when at least disclosure of the controlling patent shall be made within the
75 percent of voting members from each affected committee commentary of the design standard or the optional require-
vote in favor of the proposed arrangement. The chairs must ments checklist of the specification.
forward the comments of negative voters to TAC. In such ACI standards shall not mandate the use of patented
arrangements, one committee is the major sponsor and the items, but they may allow patented technology as a possible
others are minor sponsors. solution. During the balloting of such a requirement, the
The major sponsor committee is responsible to draft and committee will be informed on the ballot that the ballot item
ballot the standard. Members from the minor sponsor commit- includes references to patented technology. If a member
tees may assist in the development of the draft. The minor believes that a committee standard under ballot would
sponsor committees will ballot the final draft of the stan- require the user of the resulting standard to violate the intel-
dard. At least 50 percent of voting members from the minor lectual property rights (such as patents or copyrights), that
sponsor committees must vote in favor of the draft standard member is expected to alert the committee. If the committee
before it is submitted to TAC. The chair must forward the includes information on patented items within a standard,
comments of negative voters from the minor sponsor to TAC, staff will include the patent disclaimer.
but the negative votes do not have to be resolved. If an ASD receives a notice that a proposed, revised, or
The standard designation includes all sponsoring commit- approved ANS may require the use of such a patent claim
tees. The standard’s roster includes only members of the that is not already covered by an existing assurance, the
major sponsor committee. procedures in this clause shall be followed.
4.2.6.6 Coordination with the Construction Liaison Statement from patent holder:
Committee (CLC) The ASD shall receive from the patent holder or a party
Part of the ACI Board of Direction’s Construction Liaison authorized to make assurances on its behalf, in written or
Committee (CLC) mission is to review technical committee electronic form, either:
standards that deal with constructibility and economy. As a) assurance in the form of a general disclaimer to the
part of the TAC review process, staff sends standards that effect that such party does not hold and does not currently
contain sections on construction to the CLC for review. intend holding any essential patent claim(s); or
4.2.6.7 Coordination with TAC b) assurance that a license to such essential patent claim(s)
TAC assists committees in preparing standards. As part of will be made available to applicants desiring to utilize the
the TAC review process, staff sends construction standards license for the purpose of implementing the standard either:
to TCSC for review. The TCSC reviews draft construction i) under reasonable terms and conditions that are demon-
standards for conformance to ACI format, style, and clarity strably free of any unfair discrimination; or
of expression. ii) without compensation and under reasonable terms and
4.2.6.8 Coordination of terminology conditions that are demonstrably free of any unfair
Concrete-related terms are defined within “ACI Concrete discrimination.
Terminology” (CT) to promote consistent use of termi- Such assurance shall indicate that the patent holder (or
nology in ACI standards. third party authorized to make assurances on its behalf) will
include in any documents transferring ownership of patents
subject to the assurance, provisions sufficient to ensure that (d) A ballot summary of the final letter ballot(s), including
the commitments in the assurance are binding on the trans- resolutions to all negatives
feree, and that the transferee will similarly include appro- (e) A summary of revisions to the existing standard in the
priate provisions in the event of future transfers with the case of a revision
goal of binding each successor-in-interest. The assurance (f) A statement of balance of interest
shall also indicate that it is intended to be binding on succes- The committee is encouraged to provide a list of at least
sors-in-interest regardless of whether such provisions are three potential external reviewers for the standard.
included in the relevant transfer documents. Standards prepared by joint committees may be subject
For items on commercial use and Antitrust policies, ACI to the review procedures of the sponsoring organizations.
follows ANSI Essential Requirements Section 3.1. Discuss required submissions to such organizations with the
4.2.9 Errata TAC Secretary for coordination.
Errata are posted on the ACI website. When potential 4.4.2 Staff editorial review
errors are discovered in an ACI standard, the committee TAC has directed staff to perform an editorial review
chair has the authority to decide if a correction needs to be of each standard that is submitted for TAC review. Staff
made and provides staff with the correction. The chair is not reviews the standard for grammatical errors, misspelled
required to ballot the committee. words, and ambiguous statements, and checks the standard
for compliance with ACI style. All staff-recommended edito-
4.3—Writing standards rial changes are sent to the chair for approval. Once the chair
4.3.1 Format and staff have agreed upon editorial items, staff submits the
Refer to Chapter 5 for format of codes. Refer to Chapter 6 edited standard to TAC for review.
for format of specifications. 4.4.3 TAC review
4.3.2 Units One of the most important functions of TAC is the review
In accordance with ACI Board Policy, standards shall be of technical committee standards. TAC reviews standards for:
published in two versions, one with inch-pound units and (a) Technical content and correctness
one with SI units. (b) Potential conflicts, duplications, and overlaps with
This policy may be waived by TAC in exceptional circum- other ACI standards
stances. TAC approval to waive the requirements for two (c) Compliance with ACI formats
versions is required before submitting the standard to TAC. (d) Clarity
The application must describe the circumstances supporting (e) Mandatory language
a publication of one document with dual units. The submitted standard is sent to all TAC members and
The committee may prepare and ballot the second version select external reviewers who are experts on the subject
or they may request that staff prepare the second version matter and who are not members of the committee submit-
when it is considered an editorial conversion. If a committee ting the standard. ACI staff also forwards the standard to
considers a unit conversion editorial, no further balloting by technical committees that have standards, guides, or reports
the committee is required to approve the unit conversion. that may cover the subject matter in the standard to help iden-
The chair can either decide if the conversion is editorial or tify conflicts, duplications, and overlaps between committee
initiate an administrative ballot. ACI standards are published standards. Reviewers are given 4 weeks to review the stan-
with the unit conversion disclaimer. dard and submit comments.
For additional information on units, refer to Chapter 11. TAC will review the entire standard, even if only one
4.3.3 Notation section has been revised.
Refer to Chapter 10 for information on notation. 4.4.3.1 TAC review group
4.3.4 Style Each standard is assigned to a TAC review group (RG) that
Refer to Chapter 9 for information on style. is composed of a TAC member as review chief, two other
TAC members as primary reviewers, and a staff liaison. All
4.4—TAC review comments received from TAC members, external reviewers,
4.4.1 Submission package TCSC, CLC, staff, and chairs of coordinating committees are
Submit all materials required for submitting standards for compiled as TAC review comments and distributed to the RG
TAC review to the TAC Secretary at least 3 months before a by the review chief.
TAC meeting; standards will be given first priority. Submit- The TAC RG reviews all comments and meets with a
ting the standard by deadline does not guarantee placement committee representative, usually the chair, to discuss the
in the next TAC standard review cycle. Submit the Standard TAC review comments. The review chief leads the discus-
Submittal Checklist with the standard. The checklist can be sion on TAC’s behalf.
found on the ACI website. TAC typically selects the stan- 4.4.3.2 Review comment classifications
dards for review in the order received. With the submittal, Reviewers classify each of their comments as primary (P),
the chair shall include: editorial (E), or secondary (S) and also provide specific page
(a) An electronic copy of the standard in Microsoft Word® and line number references for each comment, or label them
(b) Original artwork, minimum resolution is 300 dpi as “Page 0” and “Line 0” for general (G) comments that
(c) Statement of the type of standard being submitted apply to the entire standard.
Primary (P) comments identify technical issues that the (b) All original or revised artwork
committee must address before publication of the standard. (c) The comment form including the committee responses
Editorial (E) comments identify editorial issues that to the TAC review comments
the committee must address before publication of the (d) A ballot summary on the responses to TAC review
standard. The committee is expected to implement all E comments, including any related committee minutes and
comments unless the committee agrees that the change is negative withdrawals
not an improvement or that it would change the intended When compliance with TAC review comments is verified,
meaning. staff proceeds with preparing the standard for public comment.
Secondary (S) comments identify technical or editorial If a committee decides to abandon a standard after TAC
issues that should be addressed either in this standard or the approval has been received, the committee is required to
next revision of the standard. letter ballot this decision. The balloting summary of the
General (G) comments identify issues general to the entire decision to abandon the standard must be submitted to ACI
standard that the committee must address before publication staff. This ballot is considered an administrative ballot and
of the standard. the negatives need not to be resolved.
4.4.4 TAC decision Technical committees must respond to TAC review
After the RG meets with the committee representative, the comments within 2 years of the review, otherwise TAC
RG makes a recommendation to TAC regarding the stan- approval is withdrawn. In such cases, the committee must
dard. TAC considers the recommendation and makes one of resubmit the standard for TAC review and respond to a new
two decisions on the standard: set of TAC review comments. In exceptional cases, TAC
1. Draft standard is approved for further processing, contin- may extend the time frame for acceptance of the committee
gent upon satisfactory response to TAC review comments in responses upon written request from the committee chair
a timely manner and Standards Board approval. with detailed explanation of the reasons.
2. Draft standard is not approved for further processing, 4.4.4.3 Standard not approved
and it is returned to the committee for revision, reballoting, If the standard is not approved by TAC, the committee is
and resubmission (commonly called “3R”). usually expected to revise, reballot, and resubmit (commonly
The committee is notified of TAC’s decision, and the offi- called “3R”) the standard to TAC. The decision not to
cial TAC review comments are sent to the committee for approve is usually the result of major technical deficiencies
consideration. in the standard. Therefore, TAC expects a comprehensive
4.4.4.1 Standard approved effort by the committee before the standard is resubmitted.
When the standard is approved, the committee should When a standard is not approved, the TAC RG will indi-
act promptly to prepare a response to each TAC review cate what they believe is necessary to revise the standard.
comment. Although TAC expects the committee to address issues
4.4.4.2 Responding to TAC comments raised during the TAC review when revising the standard,
The committee must document its response to each TAC the committee is not expected to respond individually to
review comment. The committee can agree with a P, E, or G each review comment.
comment and make an appropriate change to the standard
or disagree with reason. When the committee disagrees, a 4.5—Public discussion process
reason statement for the disagreement must be documented. 4.5.1 Release for public discussion
The committee can agree with an S comment and make When TAC approves a proposed standard, the balloting
a change to the standard, disagree (no documentation is history shall be given procedural review by the ACI Stan-
required), or agree to take the issue up as new business. dards Board. Upon review of the standard’s balloting history,
Responses to TAC comments must be approved by the the Standards Board either approves opening the proposed
committee by either letter ballot or meeting ballot, regardless standard for public discussion or returns the proposed stan-
of whether the response resulted in a change to the standard. dard to TAC with comments.
Include in the ballot the standard with the proposed changes 4.5.2 Public discussion
resulting from the proposed responses to TAC comments Proposed standards, other than code cases, approved by
(usually in strikeout/underline). the Standards Board are made available for a 45-day public
If a comment is strictly editorial and appropriate, the chair discussion and comment period. Upon TAC recommenda-
has the authority to implement the editorial change, and tion, the proposed standard, or its revision, is published for
ballot by the committee is not required. If a voting member public discussion in an ACI periodical, on the ACI website,
believes that the comment is not strictly editorial, or if there or both.
is doubt, the committee must ballot the proposed change. When the proposed standard is to be published for public
After the standard has been revised in response to TAC discussion on the ACI website, an email that provides instruc-
review comments, the following shall be submitted to the tions on how to access the standard on the ACI website and
TAC Secretary: how to submit comments is sent to all ACI members. A notice
(a) The revised standard in Microsoft Word® format of availability for review is also published in CI. The public
showing the changes to the version approved by TAC using discussions will begin no more than 30 days before the CI
the strikeout/underline feature issue in which a notice of availability is published. In addi-
tion, each issue of CI includes a Public Discussion page with 4.6—Appeal of committee actions related to
a summary of standards open for public discussion. Public standards development
discussion drafts will have the following disclaimer on the Persons who have directly and materially affected inter-
bottom of each page: “This draft is not final and is subject to ests and who have been or will be adversely affected by any
revision. This draft is for public review and comment.” procedural action or inaction by an ACI technical committee
4.5.2.1 Code case related to the development of a standard have the right to
A code case is adopted upon Standards Board approval and appeal. Standards developed under the ACI consensus
published in CI with a number for each code case and the adop- process may be appealed, but appeals may be filed only on
tion date. A code case can lead to a change in the next edition procedural grounds.
of the code. With this action, the code case is completed. The ACI Technical Activities Committee (TAC), as the
4.5.2.2 Provisional standard committee responsible for establishing and enforcing proce-
Upon TAC recommendation and Standards Board dures for ACI technical committees and standards, will
approval, a proposed standard may be published as an ACI consider the appeal and will have final authority. If an appeal
provisional standard before or during the public discussion specifically calls into question an action of TAC itself, the
period. TAC establishes an expiration date for the provi- appeal will be considered by the Standards Board, who will
sional standard and such a standard shall not be reapproved. have final authority.
A provisional standard may be referenced by other stan- A voting committee member also has the right to appeal
dards. Once public discussion and closure is completed, the a TAC decision regarding a standard under development
term provisional is removed from the title of the standard. by a committee. In such cases, appeals must be filed within
4.5.3 Committee response to public comments six months after the committee action in question to be
The technical committee must prepare and ballot a considered.
response to all comments received by the Institute during Once a standard under development is released for public
the public discussion period. While the Institute and the comment, any materially affected party may file an appeal.
committee welcome all comments, those that pertain to Appeals must be filed within 6 months after the draft is
provisions that have not been changed in the current revision released for public comment.
are usually considered as new business for the next revision. 4.6.1 Appeal requirements and procedure for submittal
In this case, an acknowledgment, a short explanation, and The appellant must submit an appeal package in writing
proposed committee actions under new business is usually to the TAC Secretary. The required elements of an appeal
an appropriate closure response. package are the appellant (including name, affiliation, and
After the response to public comments is prepared, it contact information), standard under appeal, basis of appeal
must be approved by the committee by either letter ballot (citation of relevant procedure), rationale for appeal (how
or meeting ballot. The committee-approved responses are was the procedure not followed), substantiation of how the
submitted to the TAC Secretary for review and approval by appellant is materially affected, and supporting documenta-
TAC. The public commenter will be notified of the commit- tion. The burden of proof to show adverse effect shall be on
tee’s response and notified of their right to appeal, according the appellant. Because appeals are normally heard at ACI
to Section 4.6. Upon TAC approval, the balloting results are conventions, all appeal packages must be submitted in writing
forwarded to the Standards Board. The committee responses to the TAC Secretary at least 6 weeks before a convention
to all public comments are posted online for a minimum of for inclusion on the agenda of the hearing committee (TAC
90 days. or Standards Board). Packages received within this 6-week
4.5.4 Release for publication window may be deferred to the next convention.
Balloting of the closure will be given procedural review by 4.6.2 Appeal review and adjudication process
the ACI Standards Board. Upon Standards Board agreement For appeals of technical committee action or inaction,
that ACI’s procedures have been followed, the Standards the matter will be adjudicated by TAC according to the
Board releases the discussion and closure for publication in following process, except that if an appeal calls into question
an ACI periodical, on the ACI website, or both, and recom- a specific action/inaction of TAC, then the Standards Board
mends publishing the standard as an ACI standard. Other- will adjudicate the appeal.
wise, the Standards Board returns the balloting of the closure Upon receipt of an appeal package, the TAC Secretary
to TAC with comments. Upon publication of the closure and informs the TAC Chair of the appeal and will perform a
any approved revisions, the standard is complete. preliminary investigation , which will include informing the
4.5.5 Adoption as an ACI standard chair of the committee that is the subject of the appeal. The
When the Standards Board releases the standard for publi- appeal will be placed on the TAC agenda for discussion at
cation, it is officially adopted. the next appropriate meeting.
4.5.6 Approval as an American National Standard At the discretion of TAC, information may be indepen-
A proposed ACI standard will be submitted to ANSI, using dently gathered by ACI staff or another appointed task
procedures in accordance with ANSI Essential Require- group. At TAC’s discretion, hearing(s) may be scheduled
ments. Upon successful ANSI processing, the ACI standard (typically at the next scheduled TAC meeting) to allow TAC
is adopted as an American National Standard. to hear directly from both the appellant and the committee
representatives relevant to the standard in question. TAC
will consider the information gathered from the appeal, (d) Keywords—Keywords indicate significant topics
investigation(s) and hearing(s) and will deliberate in closed covered by the code. The title, synopsis, and table of contents
session. Based on results of its deliberations, TAC will ballot of the document are good sources for keywords. List up to
a written response to the appeal. Formal response to the 20 keywords. The keywords should reflect the code’s subject
appeal will be issued by letter from the TAC Secretary to the matter without being too general. For example, avoid listing
appellant, with copy to the chair of the committee that is the “concrete” or “water-cement ratio.” List keywords in alpha-
subject of appeal, relating the findings and final decision of betical order and separate them with semicolons. Do not use
TAC regarding the appeal. multiple forms of the same word as keywords.
Upon receiving an appeal, the hearing committee (TAC or (e) Table of contents—A table of contents includes titles
Standards Board) will resolve the appeal at the next sched- of chapters and articles only. Do not include page numbers
uled meeting. Any member of the hearing committee with a in the table of contents; page numbers are assigned by staff
conflict of interest on the subject matter of the appeal will after final formatting of the document.
be removed to ensure the hearing committee is fair and (f) Preface—A preface is a brief summary of the subject,
unbiased. scope, and purpose of the code. It may contain a general
If an appeal is upheld, the standard shall not be processed identification of important code changes. If the code is to be
further, but will be returned to the originating committee to approved by the International Code Council (ICC), it must
address the findings of the appeal and re-initiate the standard include the following statement: This code was developed
review process related to the subject of the appeal. by an ANSI-approved consensus process. This code can
supplement a current (ICC) building code, supplement the
CHAPTER 5—FORMAT AND LANGUAGE FOR codes governing new and existing structures of a local juris-
CODES diction authority, or act as a stand-alone code in a locality
that has not adopted an existing building code.
5.1—General 5.2.2 Code chapters
Design requirements are written for the licensed design The first three chapters in codes are:
professional. Responsibilities of the licensed design profes- Chapter 1—General
sional are presented in ACI 132R-14. Chapter 2—Notation and definitions
A code provision should provide a single requirement. Chapter 3—Referenced standards
Code provisions can include equations, lists, tables, or figures. The code’s remaining chapters provide requirements in
ACI codes may have attached nonmandatory text, called the general order of design, construction, inspection, and
commentary (denoted with an “R” before the provision commissioning. Design chapters can include loads, analysis,
number), which is not considered part of the code. structural systems, assessment of exisiting systems before
repair, and member design and detailing. Construction chap-
5.2—Organization ters can include limits on materials, material properties,
5.2.1 Front matter formwork, and construction processes. Inspection chapters
The organization of front matter of ACI codes is: can include quality assurance and quality control along with
(a) Title—The title of the code should appear prominently component testing to measure performance.
on the first page, and it should read “Code Requirements Design chapters are directed to the licensed design
for... and Commentary” professionals.
(b) Roster—All voting members (on the main committee In codes, construction and inspection chapters instruct
and subcommittees) and consulting members at the time of the the design professional to include requirements in Contract
opening date of a document’s last letter ballot before submis- Documents.
sion for TAC review, are listed on the roster published on the Codes may be written with performance-based require-
front page of the committee document. Associate members ments or with prescriptive requirements or both.
are not listed. When a committee reapproves a code, the The following is a description of information to be
committee roster published with the original code is retained, included in Chapters 1, 2, 3, and a member chapter.
and the roster of the current committee is not shown.
The chair may list other individuals who contributed to the CHAPTER 1
document and should receive recognition. GENERAL
Place an appropriate note immediately below the roster. The Chapter 1 includes the items in the following list. ACI
acknowledgement should not list specific contributions. An codes should only address construction issues as they relate
example of an appropriate note is: “Special acknowledgements to the code’s design assumptions. Where required, ACI codes
to {list of individuals} for their contributions to this Code.” can direct the licensed design professional to include perti-
(c) Synopsis—A one- or two-paragraph synopsis should nent construction information in the contract documents.
state the code’s scope and purpose, and should inform The adopting authority having jurisdiction over an ACI
without going into too much detail. Each synopsis is printed code needs to be clarified to avoid confusion.
in Concrete International, and should therefore make sense 1.1—Scope
when read independently of the code. 1.2—General
1.3—Purpose
EXAMPLE
CHAPTER X
X.1—Article
X.1.2—Section
X.1.2.3—Sub-section Reinforcement “spacing” refers to the center-to-center
X.1.2.3.4—Paragraph distance between reinforcement and does not require addi-
X.1.2.3.4(a)—Sub-paragraph tional description. “Clear spacing” is the distance between
edges of reinforcement elements and must be stated explicitly.
5.3—Language The adjective “minimum” should be used with caution
5.3.1 Verb usage in conjunction with measured distances, such as “minimum
1. Codes use only mandatory verbs spacing,” because it can imply a minus tolerance of zero.
2. To direct or permit an action, “shall be” is normally used 5.3.3 Comparative phrases
3. To define a condition in present tense, “is” and “are” are When comparing measurements, use “longer,” “higher,”
normally used or “deeper.”
4. Permissive verbs, such as “may” or “should” are never When comparing distances, use “longer” or “shorter;”
used in the code but can be used in the commentary although “greater” is acceptable.
5.3.2 Adjectives and adverbs When comparing reinforcing bars, use “bigger” or “larger.”
Use adjectives or adverbs to achieve precision; they should When comparing areas or volumes, use “larger.”
not be ambiguous. Don’t use shortened or jargon terms. 5.3.4 Preferred words or phrases
When referring to the material, use “reinforcing steel” or Don’t use “a and/or b;” use “a, b, or both.”
simply “reinforcement.” Don’t use “either...or.” Although “either...or” is used in
The adjective “special” is reserved for seismic applica- other contexts, “either” is not usually required within a code.
tions, inspectors, and post-tensioned anchorage devices The exception is when a sentence begins with “either.”
defined in AASHTO. Don’t use “neither” or “nor.”
the Contractor that provisions not applicable to the Work are 1.2—Interpretation
to be ignored. The specification should clarify its relationship 1.2.1 Unless otherwise explicitly stated, this Specifica-
to the Contract Documents and referenced standards. The tion shall be interpreted using the following principles.
following is preferred wording for the scope of construction 1.2.1.1 Interpret this Specification consistent with the
specifications. plain meaning of the words and terms used.
1.2.1.2 Definitions provided in this Specification govern
PREFERRED WORDING over the definitions of the same or similar words or terms
found elsewhere.
1.2.1.3 Whenever possible, interpret this Specification
1.1—Scope
so that its provisions are in harmony and do not conflict.
1.1.1 This specification covers...
1.2.1.4 Headings are part of this Specification and are
1.1.2 This Specification is incorporated by Contract
intended to identify the scope of the provisions or sections
Documents and provides requirements for the Contractor.
that follow. If there is a difference in meaning or implica-
1.1.3 This Specification governs for construction within
tion between the text of a provision and a heading, the
its scope, except project-specific Contract Documents
meaning of the text governs.
govern if there is a conflict.
1.2.1.5 Footnotes are part of this Specification. The
1.1.4 This Specification governs if there is a conflict
meaning of the provision text governs in the event of a
with referenced material and testing standards.
difference in meaning or implication between the provi-
1.1.5 Contractor is permitted to submit written alterna-
sion text and a footnote to that provision.
tives to any provision in this Specification for consideration.
1.2.1.6 Where a provision of this Specification involves
1.1.6 Do not use this Specification in conjunction with
two or more items, conditions, requirements, or events
ACI 301 or ACI 350.5 unless Contract Documents state
connected by the conjunctions “and” or “or,” interpret the
that this Specification governs for Work covered by 1.1.1.
conjunction as follows:
1.1.7 Ignore provisions of this specification that are not
“and” indicate that all of the connected items, condi-
applicable to the Work.
tions, requirements, or events apply
1.1.8 Values in this Specification are stated in inch-
“or” indicates that the connected items, conditions,
pound units. A companion specification in SI units is
requirements, or events apply singularly
available.
1.2.1.7 The use of the verbs “may” or “will” indicates
1.1.9 The Notes to Specifiers are not part of this
that the Specification provision is for in-formation to the
Specification.
Contractor.
1.2.1.8 The phrase “as indicated in Contract Docu-
6.2.6.2 Interpretation ments” means the specifier included the provision require-
The interpretation provides the rules for interpretation ments in Contract Documents.
of the specification and explains key phrases and words. 1.2.1.9 The phrase “unless otherwise specified” means
All specifications shall have an interpretation section that the specifier may have included an al-ternative to the
follows the scope. ACI construction specifications shall default requirement in Contract Documents.
include the following provisions that are applicable to the 1.2.1.10 The phrase “if specified” mean the speci-
Specification. fier may have included a requirement in Contract Docu-
ments for which there is no default requirement in this
Specification.
1.2.1.11 If an ACI specification refers to combined
ASTM standards, include the following provision in the
interpretation article: “Unless otherwise stated, the inch-
pound system [or metric, whichever is applicable] of units
is applicable to combined standards referenced in this
Specification.” Provisions should include the complete
designation of a combined standard.
6.2.6.3 Definitions
The following terms are unique to specifications and shall
be included without modifications, if used, in the specification.
Words capitalized in the definitions below should be capital-
ized throughout the specification. See 10.2.1.2 for guidelines
on writing definitions.
There are two types of checklists: the mandatory requirements F2. ACI Specification XXX may be referenced by the
checklist and optional requirements checklist. The mandatory specifier in the Project Specification for any building project,
requirements checklist identifies information that is required together with supplementary requirements for the specific
to be included in Contract Documents because there is no project. Responsibilities for project participants must be
default requirement in the specification. The optional require- defined in the Project Specification. ACI Specification XXX
ments checklist identifies alternatives to default require- cannot and does not address responsibilities for any project
ments or optional requirements for which there are no default participant other than Contractor.
requirements. A default requirement is a limiting requirement F3. Checklists do not form a part of ACI Specification
that has been selected for the specification. Unless other- XXX. Checklists assist the specifier in selecting and speci-
wise specified in Contract Documents, default requirements fying project requirements in the Project Specification.
are mandatory conditions of the specification. The optional F4. The Mandatory Requirements Checklist indicates
requirements checklist provides guidance to the specifier in work requirements regarding specific qualities, procedures,
specifying alternative or additional requirements. Checklists materials, and performance criteria that are not defined in
do not provide explanations for the requirements; instead, ACI Specification XXX. The specifier must include these
refer to ACI guides and reports for additional information. requirements in the Project Specification.
To assist the specifier, checklists notes can include: F5. The Optional Requirements Checklist identifies speci-
(a) Reference citations fier alternatives or additions. The checklist identifies the
(b) Recommended values sections, parts, and articles of ACI Specification XXX and
(c) Alternative products the action required or available to the specifier. The specifier
(d) Alternative installation procedures should review each of the items in the checklist and make
Refer to 6.2.9.4 for checklist format. adjustments to the needs of a particular project by including
6.2.9.1 General notes, foreword to checklists, and list of those selected alternatives or additions as mandatory require-
references ments in the Project Specification.
ACI construction specifications shall include the following F6. Cited references—Documents and publications that are
wording without modification except for insertion of title referenced in the checklists of ACI Specification XXX are
and number of the ACI specification. Paragraphs F4, F5, and listed below. These references provide guidance to the specifier
F6 may be omitted if they do not apply. and are not considered to be part of ACI Specification XXX.
(Provide a list of the applicable references using the
NOTES TO SPECIFIER format in 8.3.)
General notes 6.2.9.2 Mandatory requirements checklists
G1. ACI Specification XXX is to be used by reference in the Notes are provided in the mandatory requirements check-
Project Specification. Do not copy individual sections, parts, list if a product or installation procedure is required for
articles, or paragraphs into the Project Specification because construction within the scope of the specification but there
taking them out of context may change their meaning. is no default requirement in the specification. Minimize the
G2. If sections or parts of ACI Specification XXX are number of items in the mandatory requirements checklist.
copied into the Project Specification or any other document, The following shows an example of notes in a mandatory
do not refer to them as an ACI specification. requirements checklist.
G3. A statement such as the following will serve to make
ACI Specification XXX a part of the Project Specification: EXAMPLE
“Work on (Project Title) shall conform to all Mandatory Requirements Checklist
requirements of ACI (Specification number with Section/
date suffix and title) published by the American Part/Article Notes to Specifiers
Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Michigan, 4.2.2.8 Indicate the specified compressive strength of
except as modified by these Contract Documents.” Specified concrete fc′ for various portions of the Work.
G4. Each technical section of ACI Specification XXX is strength Sample language for Contract Documents:
written in the three-part section format of the Construction “The specified compressive strength of
Specifications Institute, as adapted for ACI requirements. concrete, fc′, for all concrete in the Work is
The language is imperative and terse. 4000 psi.”
G5. If ACI Specification XXX is referenced in Contract
Documents along with another ACI specification that Items outside the scope of the specification, such as direc-
contains overlapping provisions, identify which require- tions on how to write Contract Documents or project admin-
ments are in conflict and state in Contract Documents which istrative requirements, cannot be included. The General
requirements govern. Notes provide guidance on how to incorporate the specifi-
cation into Contract Documents. Do not add a mandatory
Foreword to checklists requirement for the scope statement that requires the speci-
F1. This foreword is included for explanatory purposes fier to specify the scope. Reminders to the designer of what to
only; it is not a part of ACI Specification XXX. include on project drawings may be included in the checklist
notes but are not appropriate in the specification text because phrase. If there is no referral phrase in a provision, there
the specification is not written to instruct the designer. should not be a checklist entry referring to that provision.
6.2.9.3 Optional requirements checklists
The specifier may want other requirements in place of the 6.3—Language
default requirements in the reference specification. In addi- 6.3.1 Tolerances
tion, the specifier may wish to require items for which there Refer to ACI 117 unless it does not cover a required
are no default requirements in the specification. The optional tolerance. Specify tolerances not covered and notify ACI
requirements checklist informs the specifier of the options Committee 117 of the need for additional tolerances.”
that may be invoked and can provide sample language that
the specifier can use in Contract Documents. Limited discus- EXAMPLE
sion or citations explaining circumstances when an option Tolerances for reinforcement location shall be in accor-
should be invoked may be included. dance with ACI 117.
6.2.9.4 Checklist format
Use the following format for each item in the mandatory 6.3.2 Verb usage
and optional requirements checklists. In the left column, Write ACI specifications in mandatory language. Use terse
provide the numbering of the referenced article and provide imperative language. Avoid passive tense. Do not provide a
a brief description of the subject. In the right column include reason for the requirement.
the following:
(a) Concise instruction to specifier EXAMPLE
(b) Concise guidance to specifier (optional) Use: “Cure concrete.”
(c) References for additional guidance (optional) Instead of: “The concrete shall be cured so that it will
(d) Sample language to invoke optional requirement (optional) gain strength.”
The following is an example of an entry in an optional
requirements checklist. 6.3.3 Gender-specific language
Avoid using gender-specific terms. Such terms can often
EXAMPLE be replaced by “operator” or “person.”
Optional Requirements Checklist 6.3.4 Subjective language
Section/ Use specific, objective language rather than vague, subjec-
Part/Article Notes to Specifiers tive descriptions. Do not use the following words or phrases:
5.3.2.6 If bond is required at construction joints,
Joint specify acceptable joint preparation. The adequate
preparation following joint preparations are acceptable: all
(1) Adhesive applied in accordance with the any
manufacturer’s recommendations appropriately
(2) Surface retarder in accordance with approximately
manufacturer’s recommendations comprehensive
(3) Roughened surface that exposes the detailed
aggregate uniformly and does not leave each
laitance, loosened particles of aggregate, or every
damaged concrete at the surface good
(4) Portland-cement grout of the same in a workmanlike manner (or other similar phrases)
proportions as the mortar in the con-crete in immediately
an acceptable manner. nearly
Sample language for Contract Documents: rigorous
“At construction joints, roughen the surface shall function as intended
that exposes the aggregate uniformly and to the satisfaction of the specifier
does not leave laitance, loosened particles significantly
of aggregate, or damaged concrete at the special
surface.” Alternatively, the specifier may substantial
allow Contractor to choose any of the four such
options. thoroughly
usual
6.4—Referenced standards for all products or procedures needed to complete the Work,
6.4.1 Standards in specification text information required to make the referenced specification
ACI construction specifications often refer to stan- complete must be provided in the Contract Documents. In
dards developed by other organizations. There are two key addition, the Contractor needs to be aware that the Speci-
requirements for such referenced standards. The standard fier referencing ACI construction specifications may include
has to be written in mandatory language and it has to have supplementary requirements in the Contract Documents
been developed by an ANSI-accredited standards developer corresponding to the checklist items in the referenced ACI
(refer to Chapter 4 and www. ansi.org). Such accreditation construction specification. Language similar to the following
ensures that the standard was developed in accordance with should be used if the specification refers to another ACI
an ANSI-approved written procedure that meets require- construction specification: “(Insert scope of work) shall
ments for openness, balance of interest, consensus, and due be in accordance with ACI XXX including supplemen-
process. ANSI accreditation also ensures that standards will tary requirements indicated in Contract Documents;” for
be reviewed on a regular basis to keep up with changes in example, “Concrete construction during hot weather shall
accepted practice and technology. The committee is respon- be in accordance with ACI 305.1 including supplementary
sible for verifying that referenced standards are written in requirements indicated in Contract Documents.”
mandatory language and that they were developed by ANSI- The provision that refers to another ACI construction spec-
accredited standards bodies. ification should have a corresponding entry in the mandatory
Referenced standards are listed in Part 1 of a single-item requirements checklist that instructs the specifier to review
specification and in Section 1 of a multi-item specifica- both the mandatory and optional requirements checklists of
tion. Include the full title and year designation in the list of the referenced specification and provide the necessary infor-
referenced standards. It is preferred to use the latest version mation or requirements in the Contract Documents. The
of referenced standards unless there is a reason not to. Do following is an example of the language to be included in the
not indicate the year of the standard where the standard is mandatory requirements checklist: “Review the mandatory
mentioned in the text of the specification. Organize refer- and optional requirements checklists in the Notes to Speci-
enced standards according to the standards-producing orga- fier of ACI XXX and provide the necessary requirements in
nization and list the organizations in alphabetical order. the Contract Documents.”
If the referenced specification has requirements that
EXAMPLE conflict with the main specification, the main specification
1.4 Referenced standards should state that its provisions govern in case of conflicts with
Standards cited in this Specification are listed by name the referenced specification. An example of the language to
of standards-producing organization, and designation, use is: “Provisions of this Specification shall govern if there
including year, and title. are conflicts with ACI XXX.”
1.4.1 American Concrete Institute 6.4.3.2 Referencing sections of multi-item specifications
ACI 117-10—Specification for Tolerances for Concrete A construction specification may refer to applicable
Construction and Materials sections of another multi-item specification. The same prin-
1.4.2 ASTM International ciples discussed in 6.4.3.1 apply. The specifier will need to
ASTM C39/C39M-18—Standard Test Method for review the entries in the mandatory and optional require-
Compressive Strength of Cylindrical Concrete Specimens ments checklist that pertain to the referenced sections and
provide missing information in the Contract Documents.
It is acceptable for an ACI specification to modify an Language similar to the following should be used in the
ASTM specification for a specific requirement. specification that refers to sections of a multi-item ACI
construction specification: “Requirements for (insert scope
EXAMPLE of work) shall be accordance with Sections x, y, and z of
Use fine aggregates conforming to ASTM C404, Size ACI XXX including supplementary requirements indicated
No. 2, except that all materials shall pass the No. 16 sieve. in Contract Documents;” for example, “Requirements for
formwork, reinforcement, concrete materials, concrete
6.4.2 References in checklists production, and construction of cast-in-place concrete shall
The cited references in the checklists are to be listed as be in accordance with Sections 1,2, 3,4, and 5 of ACI 301
the last item of the Foreword to Checklists using the format including supplementary requirements indicated in Contract
in 8.3. Documents.” The provision that refers to sections of a multi-
6.4.3 Reference to other ACI construction specifications item ACI construction specification should have a corre-
6.4.3.1 Referencing entire specification sponding entry in the mandatory requirements checklist that
A construction specification (the main specification) may instructs the specifier to review the mandatory and optional
refer to other ACI construction specifications (referenced requirements checklists pertaining to those sections in the
specification). The committee, however, should review care- referenced specification and provide the necessary infor-
fully the referenced specification to avoid having missing, mation or requirements in the Contract Documents. The
redundant, or conflicting provisions. Because most ACI following is an example of the language to be included in
construction specifications do not have default requirements the mandatory requirements checklist: “Review the items
in the mandatory and optional requirements checklist in the Recommended specification Notes to Specifier
Notes to Specifier of ACI XXX that apply to the referenced Consider these additional
Submit proposed methods for
sections of ACI XXX and provide the necessary require- mixing, conveying, finishing,
submittals:
ments in the Contract Documents.” • The shotcrete placement plan;
curing, and testing along with a list
and
Care is required if referring to sections of another ACI of proposed equipment for each
• Specific provisions to cure and
construction specification. The committee needs to under- task.
protect in-place shotcrete.
stand the content of the referenced sections to avoid having Usually a Type I, II, or III cement
missing, redundant, or conflicting provisions in the commit- is specified, but other types
Cement shall conform to ASTM
tee’s specification. In some ACI multi-item specifications, C150 or be of the type specified by
may be specified under certain
there may be specialty sections that invoke general sections circumstances. Type II or other
the owner.
types may require special attention
of the specification. For example, Section 6 of ACI 301 on to the accelerator compatibility.
.architectural concrete invokes Sections 1 through 5 of ACI For mixtures volume-batched on
301. Thus, if a construction specification were to refer to site, check aggregate moisture The suggested frequency is daily
the provisions for architectural concrete in ACI 301, the content and mixture proportions unless moisture content obviously
recommended wording is: “Requirements for cast-in-place at the frequency specified by the has not changed.
architectural concrete shall be in accordance with Sections 1 engineer.
Shotcrete that is nonconforming
through 6 of ACI 301 including supplementary requirements If the project QA organizations
shall be removed and replaced by
indicated in Contract Documents.” the contractor. Alternatively, if
determine to accept the shotcrete
“as-is,” no further remedial action
approved by the owner, additional
will be necessary.
6.5—Appendixes shotcrete shall be applied.
Appendixes are generally not allowed in specifications; In the case of natural curing, an
however, they may be included if they are approved by TAC. 85% relative-humidity condition
Natural curing is allowed only if is not by itself sufficient and may
Appendixes are considered to be written in nonmandatory
the underground environmental need to be augmented by spraying
language and can only contain information-only material. conditions are satisfactory, such water on the finished shotcrete.
They appear after the checklists. as when the relative humidity is Extremes of heat, cold, or
above 85%. excessive evaporation and dry-out
6.6—Guide for specifying concrete construction due to airflow should always be
avoided.
6.6.1 There may be cases where a Committee decides that
it is not possible to write a reference construction specifica-
PART 3—GUIDES AND REPORTS
tion that would have general applicability. This may occur if
the construction activity to be covered by the specification is
CHAPTER 7—DEVELOPMENT OF GUIDES AND
complex and the requirements may be based on site-specific
REPORTS
conditions. In such cases, the Committee may decide to
write a guide for writing a project-specific specification for
7.1—General
a particular aspect of concrete construction. The resulting
Technical committees may author ACI guides and reports.
document would not be published as an ACI standard but
would be developed as a guide in accordance with Chapter
7.2—Description of guides and reports
7. The document would be titled “Guide for Specifying
7.2.1 Guides
(enter topic covered).” An example is ACI 506.5R “Guide
ACI guides present committee recommendations for
for Specifying Underground Shotcrete.” Such guides should
analysis, design, specifying, selection, evaluation, testing,
not be referenced in Contract Documents. The specifier must
construction, or repair of concrete materials or structures.
include in the Contract Documents the provisions recom-
If the committee does not give recommendations, the docu-
mended in the Guide.
ment should not be titled as an ACI guide. ACI guides can be
6.6.2 Format
in the form of handbooks, manuals, and TechNotes.
There is no rigid format for writing this type of guide. In
A guide can provide pertinent examples and case studies
general, the guide may contain technical discussion on the
to explain covered concepts and indicate advantages and
factors to be considered in specifying the requirements for
disadvantages of various alternatives.
a particular construction activity. The discussion would be
ACI committees can write guides to assist the user to develop
followed by a guide specification in two-column format,
Project Specifications for a specific construction activity.
with the left column providing the recommended specifica-
ACI guides are written in nonmandatory language. Manda-
tion text and the right column providing notes to the speci-
tory language can be used in nonmandatory-language docu-
fier. The content of the guide specification should follow
ments when quoting directly from or referring to provisions
the general three-part format discussed in 6.2. The recom-
in a document that uses mandatory language or is suggesting
mended specification text should be written in terse manda-
requirements.
tory language using the imperative mood as discussed in 6.3.
7.2.1.1 Handbooks and manuals
The following examples of the content of a guide specifica-
Handbooks provide information and guidance on how
tion are taken from ACI 506.5R.
to apply design standards in practice and typically contain
charts and tables to facilitate design of concrete structures. of the committee’s reasoning for removing the designation.
Charts, tables, and figures may also be used to illustrate the TAC approval is needed to remove the ETR designation.
detailed steps in designing a concrete member or a struc- 7.2.2.2 Investigation reports
ture. They may also include examples to illustrate specific Investigation reports are individually authored papers that
design methods. Examples of handbooks include SP-17, are reviewed by TAC.
ACI Design Handbook, and SP-4, Formwork for Concrete 7.2.3 Errata
(which is individually authored but committee sponsored). Errata are posted on the ACI website. When poten-
Manuals generally provide guidance and instructions to tial errors are discovered in an ACI guide or report, the
field personnel involved in different aspects of concrete committee chair has the authority to decide if a correction
construction. An example is SP-2, ACI Manual of Concrete needs to be made and provides staff with the correction. The
Inspection. chair is not required to ballot the committee.
7.2.1.2 TechNotes
TechNotes are narrowly focused, single-topic guides, 7.3—Development
usually practice oriented. A TechNote presents specific direc- 7.3.1 New guides and reports
tion on a particular issue, and may contain pictures, figures, Committees must obtain TAC approval before beginning
tables, and numeric examples. TechNotes can cover topics work on a new document. The proposal, sent to the TAC
such as design, construction, or repair methods, or can provide Secretary, should indicate why it is needed and include a
recommendations on a concrete technology. TechNotes are preliminary outline. Once TAC approves the work on the
written in nonmandatory language. TechNotes are published new document, ACI staff will assign the document a numer-
electronically and in the ACI Collection. In addition, Tech- ical designation; for example, ACI 123.XR. The letter will
Notes may be published in Concrete International (CI) at the be replaced by a number at time of publication.
editor’s discretion. The committee is to maintain a TechNote ACI guides and reports are developed in a four-step process:
in accordance with 7.3.2. Refer to 8.1.1.2 on how to write a 1. Preparation of a new document or revision of an existing
TechNote. document
7.2.2 Reports 2. Letter balloting of the draft document by the committee,
ACI reports provide information on concrete technology according to the procedures of Chapter 3
in the committee’s area of expertise. Reports may include 3. Submission of the committee-approved document for
recommended action but are not required to do so. Reports TAC review, according to the procedures of 7.4. There is no
can cover topics such as research results, design or construc- public discussion period for ACI guides and reports.
tion methods, or current knowledge on a particular concrete 4. Revision of the document in response to TAC comments.
technology. After a new document has been successfully balloted by
If there is insufficient knowledge to write a comprehen- the technical committee, the chair must submit the document
sive ACI report, committees may publish Emerging Tech- for TAC review.
nology Reports. Once a document has been approved by TAC and the
ACI reports are written in nonmandatory language. committee has responded adequately to TAC’s review
Mandatory language can be used in nonmandatory-language comments, ACI publishes the document.
documents when quoting directly from or referring to provi- 7.3.2 Existing guides and reports
sions in a document that uses mandatory language. Committees are expected to revise, reapprove, or with-
7.2.2.1 Emerging Technology Report (ETR) draw a document within 8 years from its adoption date. The
An ACI Emerging Technology Report provides information adoption date is the month and year of first publication. TAC
on emerging concrete technology in the committee’s area of may remove those documents from the ACI Collection that
expertise where there is insufficient knowledge to write a have not been reapproved or revised within 8 years of the
comprehensive ACI report. It is intended to introduce a new adoption date. In the case of an ITG document, the document
technology into practice by providing basic information to is removed from the ACI Collection after 5 years; however,
allow implementation and permit accumulation of perfor- TAC can extend the time period. To request an extension, the
mance histories. The document should include a statement Chair should e-mail the TAC Secretary requesting an exten-
of limitations and a discussion of research needed to provide sion and a reason why an extension is necessary.
the missing information. These documents are identified by If the committee does not revise (7.3.2.2), recommend
the designation “Emerging Technology Report” on the front reapproval (7.3.2.1), or recommend withdrawal (7.3.2.3) of
cover and title page, and by an introductory statement on a document within the 8-year period, TAC may reapprove or
the title page (14.2.4). The document shall have a maximum withdraw it without committee action.
lifetime of 10 years from date of initial publication, by 7.3.2.1 Reapproval
which time it must have either been withdrawn or revised The committee may decide to reapprove a document
and published as a report or guide. because the information in an existing document, while not
To publish the document as a regular ACI report, the new, is still valid. The first reapproval of a document is for
committee must letter ballot to remove the ETR designation 5 years. The second and subsequent reapprovals (if any)
from the next edition. When submitting the revised document are for 3 years. The committee is required to letter ballot
for TAC review, the chair must include a written summary the reapproval. Negative votes do not need to be resolved,
but the ballot must still pass. The reapproval may include committees
updating references and minor editorial improvements of ACI committees may agree to cosponsor a document when
notation, terminology, metrication, or other similar items. A the scope of the document overlaps their missions. Commit-
reapproval must not include technical changes. tees may request to jointly sponsor a document when at least
The committee must submit its recommendation for reap- 75 percent of voting members from each affected committee
proval of the document to TAC for approval. The recom- vote in favor of the proposed arrangement. The chair must
mendation includes a letter ballot summary (3.5) and a forward the comments of negative voters to TAC. In such
statement that technological progress at this point does not arrangements, one committee is the major sponsor and the
require revision or that the document is currently being others are minor sponsors.
revised but the revision is not complete. Include a summary The major sponsor committee is responsible to draft and
of the updates to the document. Generally, TAC reviews ballot the document. Members from the minor sponsor
only the committee’s ballot summary and the summary of committees may assist in the development of the draft. The
updates. A reapproval does not change the year of adoption minor sponsor committees will ballot the final draft of the
but “Reapproved” with the year of reapproval is added to the document. Negative votes from both the major and minor
document number. sponsor committee must be resolved. At least 50 percent of
7.3.2.2 Revision voting members from the minor sponsor committees must
The committee should revise a document when the infor- vote in favor of the draft document before it is submitted
mation in the document needs to be updated. Committees to TAC. The chair must forward the comments of negative
should consider “new business” items from the previous voters and their resolutions to TAC.
document when working on a revision. The document designation includes all sponsoring
The committee must letter ballot revisions according committees. Rosters of all sponsoring committees appear on
to Chapter 3 and submit the document to TAC for review. the document.
Upon adoption of a revised document, the existing version 7.3.4 Restrictions on circulating drafts
is marked historical. (A document is made historical when it Add the following disclaimer to the bottom of each page
has been superseded by a revision.) The revised document’s of a draft document: “This draft is not final and is subject to
number receives the new year of adoption. revision. Do not circulate or publish.” Include date of the
7.3.2.3 Withdrawal final draft. The chair may only circulate the drafts to indi-
The committee should recommend withdrawal of a docu- viduals outside the committee, TAC, and ACI staff to obtain
ment when the committee determines that the information it expert technical advice not available in the committee or to
contains is obsolete and should not be revised. A letter ballot ensure that all interested parties are given an opportunity to
of the committee is required. Negative votes do not need to express viewpoints.
be resolved, but the ballot must still pass. The recommenda- Committee documents, at any stage of development, must
tion for withdrawal should include a statement that, in the not be released for publication other than to ACI or cospon-
judgment of the committee, the document is no longer useful sors of joint committees, except on approval of TAC. Similar
or amenable to updating. The committee’s recommendation restrictions apply to test data or unpublished technical infor-
and related ballot summary must be submitted to the TAC mation circulated in a committee.
Secretary for review by TAC. Posting of draft documents on the committee’s ACI
Upon TAC’s approval of the recommendation, the docu- website is encouraged. Posting of draft documents on inde-
ment is not included in the next edition of the ACI Collec- pendent websites is not permitted because control, copy-
tion. It may still be available for purchase from ACI as a right, and document status are not secure.
historical document. 7.3.5 Coordination of information
7.3.2.4 ITG guides and reports 7.3.5.1 Technical committees
After an ITG document is published, TAC will request an Coordination with other technical committees is an impor-
ACI committee consider the incorporation of the content of tant part of processing documents. Some reasons for coordi-
the ITG document into a new or existing committee docu- nation with other committees are:
ment. Related technical committee(s) may have been identi- (a) To provide agreement for information that will be
fied during formation of the ITG as described in 1.3.1.2. incorporated or referenced in another committee document
The technical committee should: (b) To improve quality of the document through the input
(a) Review and revise the content of the ITG document of another committee
or incorporate the information into an existing committee (c) To minimize instances of documents with parallel or
document overlapping scopes
(b) Ballot the revised content of the ITG document as soon (d) To minimize technical conflicts between committee
as practicable because the ITG document only has a 5-year documents
life in the ACI Collection; however, TAC can extend the time If substantial difficulties arise between two committees,
period. To request an extension, the Chair should e-mail the the matter can be referred to TAC.
TAC Secretary requesting an extension and a reason why an Documents submitted for TAC review may be in conflict
extension is necessary. with or vary from existing ACI documents. The committees
7.3.3 Documents sponsored with other ACI technical should identify conflicts between the submitted document
and existing ACI documents and provide reasons for the 7.4.5 Editorial review
differences, if applicable. The committee’s editorial subcommittee or task group
7.3.5.2 Construction Liaison Committee (CLC) should thoroughly edit a document before final committee
Part of the ACI Board of Direction’s Construction Liaison letter ballot. When submitting the document to TAC, the
Committee (CLC) mission is to review technical committee chair should state that the editorial subcommittee has
documents that deal with constructability and economy. As reviewed the document.
part of the TAC review process, staff sends documents that The editorial subcommittee should review for document
contain sections on construction to CLC for review. structure, sentence structure, grammar, redundancy, spelling,
7.3.5.3 Terminology and typographical errors. Because many people contribute to
TAC reviews each document’s definitions at the time of a document, it is essential that the subcommittee review the
submission for TAC review (10.2.2.2). If the committee separate sections for consistency in style and format. The
wants to develop a unique definition for a term defined in editorial subcommittee should be familiar with Chapters 8
“ACI Concretete Terminology” (CT), they must provide the and 9.
reason for the modification.
7.3.6 Translation of ACI documents 7.5—TAC review
Translation of an ACI document into a language other 7.5.1 Submission package
than English may be permitted. Refer to the Board Policy All materials required for submitting documents for TAC
on translation of ACI products. Where the Board Policy review shall be submitted to the TAC Secretary at least 3
requires review and approval by the policies of the origi- months before a TAC meeting. Submitting the document by
nating committee, TAC considers translation an editorial the deadline does not guarantee placement in the next TAC
change and no further balloting by the committee is required. document review cycle. TAC typically accepts the docu-
7.3.7 Guides and reports authored by ACI chapters ments in the order received. With the submittal, the chair
ACI chapters may publish their documents without TAC shall include:
approval. They must, however, use a disclaimer stating that (a) An electronic copy of the document in Microsoft Word®
the document was prepared and reviewed by the chapter and (b) Original artwork
has not been reviewed or approved by ACI. Chapter docu- (c) Statement of the type of document (7.2) being
ments must only use chapter logos on their documents. submitted
If a chapter wishes to use the ACI logo, the document (d) A ballot summary of the final letter ballot(s) (3.5),
must be processed through an ACI technical committee and including resolutions to all negatives
receive a TAC review and approval. (e) A summary of revisions to the existing document in the
case of a revision
7.4—Writing guides and reports The committee is encouraged to provide a list of at least
7.4.1 Format three potential external reviewers for the document.
Refer to Chapter 8 for format of a guide or a report. Documents prepared by joint committees may be subject
7.4.2 Units to the review procedures of the sponsoring organizations.
In accordance with ACI Board Policy, guides and reports Coordinate with staff the required submissions to such
shall be published in dual units (14.3). The primary units shall organizations.
be stated in inch-pound followed by SI units in parentheses. 7.5.2 Staff editorial review
Soft unit conversion of a document may be considered TAC has directed staff to perform an editorial review
editorial. No further balloting by the committee is required of each document that is submitted for TAC review. Staff
to approve the unit conversion. When hard unit conversions reviews the document for grammatical errors, misspelled
are developed, they must be balloted. words, ambiguous statements, and checks the document for
This dual-units requirement may be waived by TAC in compliance with ACI style. All staff-recommended editorial
exceptional circumstances. TAC approval to waive the changes are sent to the chair for approval. Once the chair
requirements for dual units is required before submitting and staff have agreed upon editorial items, staff submits the
the document to TAC. The application must describe the edited document to TAC for review.
circumstances supporting a waiver. 7.5.3 TAC review
A committee may request a waiver for certain figures, One of the most important functions of TAC is the review
tables, or examples because of the resulting complexity if of technical committee documents. TAC reviews documents
dual units were incorporated. If a waiver is given for figures for:
or tables, a unit conversion table must be provided. For (a) Technical content and correctness
numerical examples, comparable separate examples in each (b) Potential conflicts, duplications, and overlaps with
system of units must be provided. other ACI documents
For additional information on units, refer to Chapter 11. (c) Compliance with ACI formats
7.4.3 Notation (d) Clarity
Refer to Chapter 10 for information on notation. The submitted document is sent to all TAC members and
7.4.4 Style to selected external reviewers who are experts on the subject
Refer to Chapter 9 for information on style. matter and who are not members of the committee submit-
ting the document. ACI staff also forwards the document to 7.5.4.2 Responding to TAC comments
committees that have guides or reports that may cover the The committee must document its response to each TAC
subject matter in the document to help identify conflicts, review comment. The committee can agree with a P, E, or G
duplications, and overlaps between committee documents. comment and make an appropriate change to the document
Reviewers are given approximately 4 weeks to review the or disagree with reason. When the committee disagrees, a
document and submit comments. detailed reason statement for the disagreement must be
TAC will review the entire document, even if only one documented.
section has been revised because a revision of one section The committee can agree with an S comment and make
of the document may necessitate a change elsewhere in the a change to the document, disagree (no documentation is
document. required), or agree to take the issue up as new business.
7.5.3.1 TAC review group Responses to TAC comments must be approved by the
Each document is assigned to a TAC review group (RG) committee by either letter ballot or meeting ballot, regardless
that is composed of a TAC member as review chief, two other of whether or not the response resulted in a technical change
TAC members as primary reviewers, and a staff liaison. All to the document (Chapter 3). Include with the ballot the docu-
comments received from TAC members, external reviewers, ment with proposed changes resulting from the proposed
CLC, staff, and chairs of coordinating committees are responses to TAC comments (in strikeout/underline).
compiled as TAC review comments and distributed to the If a comment is strictly editorial and appropriate, the chair
RG by the review chief. has the authority to implement the change, and no further action
The TAC RG reviews all comments and meets with a by the committee is required. If a voting member believes that
committee representative, usually the chair, to discuss the the comment is not strictly editorial, or if there is doubt, the
TAC review comments. The review chief leads the discus- committee must ballot to approve the proposed response.
sion on TAC’s behalf. After the document has been revised in response to TAC
7.5.3.2 Review comment classifications review comments, the following shall be submitted to the
Reviewers classify each of their comments as primary (P), TAC Secretary:
editorial (E), or secondary (S) and also provide specific page (a) The revised document in Microsoft Word® format,
and line number references for each comment, or label them showing the committee’s changes using the strikeout/under-
as “Page 0” and “Line 0” for general (G) comments that line feature
apply to the entire document. (b) All original or revised artwork
Primary (P) comments identify technical issues that the (c) The comment form including the committee responses
committee must address before publication of the document. to the TAC review comments
Editorial (E) comments identify editorial issues that the (d) A ballot summary on the responses to TAC review
committee must address before publication of the document. comments, including any related committee minutes that
The committee is expected to implement all E comments provide records of the resolution of negative votes and nega-
unless the committee agrees that the change is not an tive withdrawals
improvement or that it would change the intended meaning. When compliance with TAC review comments is verified,
Secondary (S) comments identify technical or editorial the document is adopted. The adoption date is the same as
issues that should be addressed either in this document or the the publishing date.
next revision of the document. If a committee decides to abandon a document after TAC
General (G) comments identify issues general to the approval has been received, the committee is required to
entire document that the committee must address before letter ballot this decision. The balloting summary of the
publication of the document. decision to abandon the document must be submitted to ACI
7.5.4 TAC decision staff. This ballot is considered an administrative ballot and
After the RG meets with the committee representative, the the negatives do not need to be resolved.
RG makes a recommendation to TAC regarding the docu- Technical committees must respond to TAC review
ment. TAC considers the recommendation and makes one of comments within 2 years of the review, otherwise the TAC
the following decisions on the document: approval is withdrawn. In such case, the committee must
(a) Document is approved for publication, contingent resubmit the document for TAC review and respond to a new
upon satisfactory response to TAC review comments in a set of TAC review comments. In exceptional cases, TAC
timely manner may extend the time frame for acceptance of the committee
(b) Document is not approved for publication, and it is responses upon written request from the committee chair
returned to the committee for revision, reballoting, and with detailed explanation of the reasons.
resubmission (commonly called “3R”) 7.5.4.3 Document not approved
The committee is notified of TAC’s decision, and the offi- If the document is not approved by TAC, the committee is
cial TAC review comments are sent to the committee for usually expected to revise, reballot, and resubmit (commonly
consideration. called “3R”) the document to TAC. The decision not to
7.5.4.1 Document approved approve is usually the result of major technical deficiencies
When the document is approved, the committee should act in the document. Therefore, TAC expects a comprehensive
promptly to prepare a response to each TAC review comment. effort by the committee before the document is resubmitted.
When a document is not approved, the TAC RG will indicate to hear directly from both the appellant and the committee
what they believe is necessary to revise the document. Although representatives relevant to the standard in question. TAC
TAC expects the committee to address issues raised during the will consider the information gathered from the appeal,
TAC review when revising the document, the committee is not investigation(s) and hearing(s) and will deliberate in closed
expected to respond individually to each review comment. session. Based on results of its deliberations, TAC will ballot
a written response to the appeal. Formal response to the
7.6—Appeal of Committee Actions Related to appeal will be issued by letter from the TAC Secretary to the
Documents appellant, with copy to the chair of the committee that is the
Persons who have directly and materially affected inter- subject of appeal, relating the findings and final decision of
ests and who have been or will be adversely affected by any TAC regarding the appeal.
procedural action or inaction by an ACI technical committee The hearing Committee (TAC or Standards Board) will
related to the development of a document have the right endeavor to conduct appropriate investigations and hearings
to appeal. Documents developed under the ACI consensus within 1 year of receipt of an appeal and issue a final decision
process may be appealed, but appeals may be filed only on within 18 months of the date of appeal, though adjustments
procedural grounds. may be necessary to complete a thorough consideration of
The ACI Technical Activities Committee (TAC), as the the matter. The appellant and subject committee officers will
committee responsible for establishing and enforcing proce- be informed by the TAC Secretary if delays are encountered
dures for ACI technical committees and documents, will in meeting this schedule.
consider the appeal and will have final authority. If an appeal If an appeal is upheld, the document shall not be processed
specifically calls into question an action of TAC itself, the further, but will be returned to the originating committee to
appeal will be considered by the Standards Board, who will address the findings of the appeal and re-initiate the docu-
have final authority. ment review process related to the subject of the appeal.
During the development of a document in committee,
only voting members of the relevant committee may file an CHAPTER 8—FORMAT AND LANGUAGE FOR
appeal of a committee action. A voting committee member GUIDES AND REPORTS
also has the right to appeal a TAC decision regarding a docu-
ment under development by a committee. 8.1—Format
7.6.1 Appeal Requirements and Procedure for Submittal 8.1.1 Outline
The appellant must submit an appeal package in writing Below is an example of an outline with the required
to the TAC Secretary. The required elements of an appeal sections for ACI guides and reports, with the exception of
package are the appellant (including name, affiliation, and TechNotes (8.1.1.2).
contact information), standard under appeal, basis of appeal 8.1.1.1 Guide and report outline example
(citation of relevant procedure), rationale for appeal (how
was the procedure not followed), substantiation of how the
EXAMPLE
appellant is materially affected, and supporting documenta-
Title page—Title, roster, synopsis, keywords, and table
tion. The burden of proof to show adverse effect shall be on
of contents
the appellant. Because appeals are normally heard at ACI
CHAPTER 1—Introduction and Scope
conventions, all appeal packages must be submitted in writing
1.1—Introduction
to the TAC Secretary at least 6 weeks before a convention
1.2—Scope
for inclusion on the agenda of the hearing committee (TAC
CHAPTER 2—Notation and definitions
or Standards Board). Packages received within this 6-week
2.1.—Notation
window may be deferred to the next convention.
2.2—Definitions
7.6.2 Appeal Review and Adjudication Process
FINAL CHAPTER—References
For appeals of technical committee action or inaction,
the matter will be adjudicated by TAC according to the
Appendix (if used)
following process, except that if an appeal calls into question
a specific action/inaction of TAC, then the Standards Board
will adjudicate the appeal. 8.1.1.2 TechNote outline example
Upon receipt of an appeal package, the TAC Secretary The structure and body of a TechNote consists of an intro-
informs the TAC Chair of the appeal and will perform a duction; a short, concise question; followed by the answer,
preliminary investigation, which will include informing the which is a brief summary of the subject matter; discussion;
chair of the committee that is the subject of the appeal. The and an optional summary. The TechNote format is found on
appeal will be placed on the TAC agenda for discussion at the Document Development Guidance webpage.
the next appropriate meeting.
At the discretion of TAC, information may be indepen- 8.1.2 Description of required front matter
dently gathered by ACI staff or another appointed task (a) Title—The title of the document appears prominently
group. At TAC’s discretion, hearing(s) may be scheduled on the first page of the draft document. The title of the docu-
(typically at the next scheduled TAC meeting) to allow TAC ment should include either the word “guide” or “report,”
depending on the document, and indicate the subject matter, Appendixes—Some documents use appendixes to
for example, “Report on ….” or “Guide for…” present supplementary information such as long deriva-
(b) Roster—All voting members (of the main committee tions, research data, or sample calculations. Use a separate
and the subcommittee that developed the document) and appendix for each main purpose, lettered consecutively
consulting members at the time of the opening date of a (Appendix A, Appendix B, etc.). Appendixes, if included,
document’s final letter ballot before submission for TAC should follow the reference chapter. Appendixes should also
review are listed on the roster published on the front page of be listed in the table of contents.
the committee document. Associate members are not listed. 8.1.5 Numbering and titles
When a committee reapproves a document, the committee Chapters and sections should have titles. Items may or
roster published with the original document is retained, and may not be titled, but number them consecutively following
the roster of the current committee is not shown. the decimal designation system. The numbering system
The chair may list other individuals who contributed to the should not exceed four levels.
document and should receive recognition.
Place an appropriate note immediately below the roster.
EXAMPLE
The acknowledgement note should not list specific contri-
Chapter 1—Chapter (title)
butions. An example of an appropriate note is: “Special
1.1—Introduction—Section (title)
acknowledgements to {list of individuals} for their contri-
1.1.1 Item
butions to this [report or guide].”
1.1.1.1 Sub-item
(c) Synopsis—A one- or two-paragraph synopsis should
state the document’s scope and purpose, and should inform and
spark interest without going into too much detail. Each synopsis 8.2—Language
is printed in Concrete International (CI), and should therefore 8.2.1 General principles
make sense when read independently of the document. Technical writing must be precise and convey a single,
(d) Keywords—A list of items discussed in the docu- specific meaning. Using multiple terms when referring to a
ment that aid users in retrieving material. The title, synopsis, single item or idea creates confusion, and can lead to misin-
and table of contents of the document are good sources for terpretation of information. ACI requirements for technical
keywords. Approximately three to 10 keywords are required. writing include:
The keywords should reflect the document’s subject matter (a) Avoid words or phrases that have more than one
without being too general. For example, avoid listing meaning that can be applicable to the context of the document
“concrete” or “water-cement ratio.” List keywords in alpha- (b) Do not use slang expressions
betical order and separate them with semicolons. Do not use (c) If there is any doubt that a specific phrase or term can
multiple forms of the same word as keywords. be confused with another and it must be used in the docu-
(e) Table of contents—A table of contents includes titles ment, define the exact intended meaning at its first mention
of chapters and sections. Do not include page numbers in the or in the definitions chapter
table of contents; page numbers are assigned by staff after (d) Use terminology and definitions from the CT unless
final formatting of the document. there is a technical reason for using a different definition
(f) References—Final chapter; includes standards and 8.2.2 Clarity
cited references. ACI technical document language should not hedge or
8.1.3 Description of chapters convey uncertainty, as this causes the document to lose cred-
Chapter 1—Introduction (1.1) and Scope (1.2)—provides ibility to the reader. Avoid beginning sentences with phrases
the history, the scope of the document and context of the such as “It is recommended that…,” “Committee XXX recom-
information, and may provide a brief description of each mends that…,” or “It is suggested that...” It is understood that
chapter in the document. the document presents recommendations of the committee.
Chapter 2—Definitions and notation—list the notation When using phrases such as “It has been observed that…”
used throughout document. Arrange in alphabetical order, or “Research has shown that...,” the reader wonders, “Who
with roman letters appearing first and Greek letters at the observed? What research?” In these instances, identify the
end. Upper-case letters should come before lower-case source or cite a reference.
letters in the list. Define technical terms that are unique to 8.2.3 Gender-specific language
the document. Refer to “ACI Concrete Terminology” (CT) Avoid using gender-specific terms, such as “he,” “she,” or
on the ACI website. “man,” when possible. Such terms can often be replaced by
For documents with terms defined, add the following “operator” or “person.”
statement: 8.2.4 Vague language
ACI provides a comprehensive list of definitions through Do not use vague adjectives or adverbs.
an online resource, “ACI Concrete Terminology.” Defini-
tions provided here complement that source.
Other chapters—Present information in a logical order.
8.1.4 Description of back matter
EXAMPLE EXAMPLE
(a) Adequately
(b) Appropriately CHAPTER 10—REFERENCES
(c) Comprehensive ACI committee documents and documents published by
(d) Currently other organizations are listed first by document number,
(e) Immediately full title, and year of publication followed by authored
(f) Presently documents listed alphabetically.
(g) Recently (recent)
(h) Rigorous American Concrete Institute
(i) Significantly ACI 212.3R-04—Chemical Admixtures for Concrete
(j) Substantial
(k) Usual American Society of Civil Engineers
ASCE/SEI 7-10—Minimum Design Loads of Buildings
and Other Structures
8.2.5 Active versus passive voice
When possible, write in the active voice. This means that
ASTM International
the subject of the sentence performs the verb of the sentence,
ASTMC39/C39M-12—Standard Test Method for
which makes for more forceful and direct writing. The
Compressive Strength of Cylindrical Concrete Specimens
passive voice usually employs a form of the verb “to be.”
When using the passive voice, the subject of the sentence Authored documents
receives the action of the verb. Kosmatka, S. H.; Kerkhoff, B.; and Panarese, W. C.,
2002, Design and Control of Concrete Mixtures, EB001, 14th
EXAMPLE edition, Portland Cement Association, Skokie, IL, 372 pp.
Active: The manual provides helpful hints for writing Mathur, R.; Lee, H.; and Orsolini, G., 1999, “Two-
technical papers. Level Design Spectrum for Highway Bridges,” Seismic
Passive: Helpful hints for writing technical papers are Response of Concrete Bridges, SP-187, K. Krishnan, ed.,
provided in this manual. American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, MI, pp.
345-360.
8.3—References
Cited references should be in the author/date format. Cite references in the text as follows.
All references must be mentioned at least once in the docu- EXAMPLE
ment to be included as a reference. ACI does not publish (Smith 2013) one author
bibliographies. Include each element of the authored refer- (Smith and Jones 2013) two authors
ence, including month and page number(s) where applicable. (Smith et al. 2013) three or more authors
(Smith 2013; Jones and Johnson 2013)...separate works
by different authors with a semicolon
(Smith 2012, 2013; Jones et al. 2013)..separate works
by the same author with a comma
(Smith et al. 2013a,b; Jones 2013)...if an author or group
of authors has two works with the same year, designate
them “a” and “b” (and so on, as necessary).
EXAMPLE
Whitmore, D., Installation of Embedded Galvanic
Anodes, American Concrete Institute, http://www.
concrete.org/general/RAP-1.pdf (accessed Feb. 17, 2016)
EXAMPLE
American Concrete Institute, Concrete: A Century of Inno- Place simple mathematical expressions in line with text.
vation, American Concrete Institute, http://www.concrete.
org/staffreport/concrete.html (accessed Feb. 17, 2016)
EXAMPLE
Suryavanshi, A. K., “Cementitious Adhesive for Ceramic
Tiles,” Concrete International, V. 26, No. 8, 2004, http://
www.concreteinternational.com (accessed Feb. 17, 2016)
PART 4—STYLE
number, an Em dash (—), and the caption. Place a period at All the text in a group of figures must appear identically sized
the end of figure captions. on the printed page (provide to Publishing Services a table of
9.3.2 Figure captions figure widths that will render the text at the intended size).
Figure numbers are the same as the provision or section
number. If a provision or section refers to more than one Text is sized as follows:
figure, add a letter suffix to the figure number. Begin sentences
with the full word “Figure” rather than the abbreviation “Fig.” Minimum text height = 0.08 in.
9.3.3 Figure quality and copyright Text type Height
Transmit each figure as an individual file of the highest Full size (must use when combined with
0.10 in.
available quality in an editable format. Figures cannot superscript/subscript)
be placed in the text as images or object. Figures that are Subscript/superscript 0.08 in.
embedded in the Microsoft Word® document are usually Reduced size (no subscript/superscript) 0.08 in. minimum
not of the best quality and are used by ACI Staff as a refer-
ence only with respect to the general position within the Font styles used are as follows:
document. If a figure requires permission to be used, the Regular body text Font style
Annotations, notes Arial
committee should contact ACI to coordinate permission.
Internal captions Arial + italic (not underlined)
ACI Staff places all figures in their proper position before
publication. All submitted figures should have high contrast
Notation/variables Font style
and be easy to read. Adhere to the following guidelines when
Roman characters Arial + bold + italic
submitting graphics for documents.
Arabic numerals Arial + bold
For electronic photos:
Greek characters Symbol + bold (+ italic in 318 only)
(a) .eps, .tif., .jpg, or high-resolution (600 dpi) .pdf files
ℓ MT Bold + bold
are the preferred formats. Avoid .bmp or .gif files.
(b) Photos should be a minimum of 300 dpi and need to be Purpose Thickness Example
at least 3.33 in. wide. Edge of concrete 0.006 in. black,
(c) Digital editions of the publication are published in (without predicted plus inner
color, and print editions are printed in black and white. breakout shading) 0.05 in. shaded
For drawings and line art:
(a) eps, .tif., .jpg, or high-resolution .pdf files are the Strut 0.020 in.
preferred formats. Avoid .bmp or .gif files. Edge of concrete
(b) Avoid using fill patterns, or shading, in figures as they (with predicted 0.025 in.
do not reproduce well. breakout shading)
(c) Use only sans-serif fonts, such as Arial or Helvetica, Predicted breakout
0.006 in.
for labels in drawings and graphics. boundary
(d) Avoid using fine lines and small text that can become Object 0.010 in.
illegible when the figure is reduced for publication. Leader, dimension,
0.006 in.
break line, centerline
(e) Avoid using color as a distinction between lines in a
graph or photograph, as the print editions will be printed in
9.4—Tables
black and white.
A table title is at the top, the first letter of the title is capi-
For printed photographs:
talized, the remaining letters are lower case, and the table
(a) Original high-contrast photographs result in the
caption is boldfaced. Table numbers are the same as the
highest-quality printed image.
provision or section number. If more than one table is in a
(b) If photographs cannot be reproduced with suitable
provision or section, add a letter suffix to the table number.
quality and contrast, staff will eliminate the image and revise
9.4.1 Table footnotes
the text accordingly.
Footnotes in tables are mandatory information and are
Videos are allowed in electronic guides and reports. The
shown at the bottom of the table. Symbols used for table
committee must submit a video that can be embedded in an
notes should follow this list: *, †, ‡, §, #, ||.
electronic document; URLs to videos are not allowed. A
9.4.2 Table formatting
photo is required for the printed document.
All tables must be in an editable format. They cannot be
placed in the text as images or objects. The left-most column
Figure size:
should contain the conditions and the right-most column
Figures are formatted to fit within a column of 3.3 in., or a
should contain the result. If a table row needs to be refer-
full-page-width margins of 7.0 in. The maximum width for
enced, assign a letter to that row.
Commentary figures is 5.0 in.
Text:
Annotations, notes, and internal captions use sentence
case (only the first word capitalized).
9.6—Grammar
9.6.1 Gender-specific language
Avoid using gender-specific terms, such as “he,” “she,” or
“man,” when possible. Such terms can often be replaced by
“operator” or “person.”
Use column and row lines only as necessary for clarity. Do 9.6.2 Conditional phrases (use of if, when, and where)
not use lines on sides of a table. These conditional phrases are used in provisions where
the action depends on whether a stated condition is satisfied.
9.5—Lists When so used, these words have the following meanings:
The first word in the list is capitalized, unless it is a If—on condition that; in case that
number, symbol, or equation. Use a complete sentence When—at the time that; in the event that
followed by a colon to introduce a list; the list itself does not Where—in whatever place or situation
need punctuation or a conjunction, such as “and,” after the These definitions have subtle differences. For consistency,
penultimate term. use “when” for cases that refer to time, use “where” for cases
When using lists: that refer to position, and use “if” for all other cases.
(a) Lettered—Preferred identifier for a list 9.6.3 Acceptable and unacceptable terminology
(b) Numbered—Permitted when sequential actions are Certain terms and phrases should typically not be used in
required or if it is a section with a letter ACI documents. Some terms to be avoided are listed in the
(c) Bulleted—Don’t use bulleted lists following along with their acceptable alternatives.
Mathematical expressions in a list don’t require an equa-
tion number and don’t have units because units are implied Avoid Use
in the calculation. about approximately
air-entraining agent air-entraining admixture
below the following
place concrete cast concrete
the Board Policy is available as a separate publication from Table 11.3—Derived SI units
ASTM International. Quantity Unit (name) Abbreviation Derivation
square
mm2 —
11.2—Inch-pound units Area millimeter
Abbreviated units only when preceded by a numeral. Do square meter m 2
—
not add an “s” to the end of a unit abbreviation to make it Density, mass kilograms per
kg/m 3
—
per unit volume cubic meter
plural.
millimeter mm —
Derived units are formed by combining base units, supple- Length
meter m —
mentary units, and other derived units according to the alge-
Mass kilogram kg —
braic relations linking the corresponding quantities. Several
meter per
examples of derived units are given in Table 11.2. Note that Velocity
second
m/s —
some of the derived units have been given special names. milliliter mL —
Volume cubic meter m3 —
Table 11.2—Derived inch-pound units liter L —
Quantity Unit (name) Abbreviation Derivation Temperature Celsius °C —
square foot ft2 — kelvin K —
Area
square yard yd2 — Electrical
volt V m2·kg/(s3·A)
Density, mass pounds per potential
lb/ft3 —
per unit volume cubic foot Force newton N kg·m /s2
inch in. — Frequency hertz Hz 1/s
Length
feet ft — Pressure or
pascal Pa kg/(m·s2)
Mass pound lb — stress
Velocity foot per second ft/s — Quantity of
coulomb C s·A
fluid ounce fl oz — electricity
Volume cubic yard yd3 — Current ampere A —
gallon gal. —
Temperature Fahrenheit °F — 11.4—Hard versus soft conversion
Force pound lb — “Soft” conversions are exact mathematical conversions,
Frequency hertz Hz 1/s rounded to an appropriate number of significant digits.
pounds per “Hard” conversions are measurements in one system
psi —
Pressure or square inch converted to a standard dimension in the other system that
stress pounds per would be used in design and construction.
lb/ft2 —
square foot
The ACI Board Policy statement requires ACI codes and
specifications be published in two separate versions, one
11.3—SI units using hard-converted SI units and the other inch-pound
“Metric” is a somewhat generic term, as there are a units. Other ACI documents must be published using dual
number of different metric systems in use worldwide. For units. The primary units are stated in inch-pounds followed
example, many countries use kgf/cm2 instead of Pa for by SI units in parentheses.
stress. The International System of Units (SI) is the metric Except for the codes and specifications, conversions may
system adopted in the United States. SI includes seven base be either hard or soft, as appropriate. Soft conversions are
and two supplementary units and a large number of derived generally appropriate for reporting measured values such
units. Prefixes are used with the base units and derived units as test data or dimensions of existing structures. Hard
to indicate powers of 10. conversions are appropriate for codes and specifications
Derived units are formed by combining base units, supple- and for making recommendations, setting requirements,
mentary units, and other derived units according to the alge- or discussing products that are available in that system of
braic relations linking the corresponding quantities. Several measurement. If manufacturers have elected to make only
examples of derived units are given in Table 11.3. Note that soft conversions of their products, use their soft-converted
some of the derived units have been given special names. values to describe or reference the product.
11.4.1 Soft metric conversion
To make soft metric conversions, apply the conversion
factor from IEEE/ASTM SI 10 (Table 11.6.1), then round
to the number of significant digits that gives an accu-
racy equivalent to that of the inch-pound value. Show the
resulting soft-converted value in parentheses following the
inch-pound value.
(a) Make a soft metric conversion of the ASTM C39/
C39M test result of 4030 psi.
Use the conversion factor of 1 psi = 6.894757 kPa:
4030 psi × 6.894757 kPa/psi = 27785.87071 kPa = 11.5—Format for unit names and abbreviations
27.78587071 MPa 11.5.1 General
In ASTM C39/C39M, compressive strength is reported to A unit name is its full, written name, such as kilogram or
the nearest 10 psi, which is approximately 70 kPa. Thus, it microgram. Its abbreviation is the letters used to shorten it,
would be appropriate to report the strength to the nearest 0.1 such as kg or µg.
MPa. You would show the soft conversion in your document as: When spelling out the full name of a unit, print the unit
ASTM C39/C39M test result of 4030 psi (27.8 MPa) name in lower case, even those derived from a proper name,
(b) Make a soft conversion of a distance of 125 ft. such as newton, kelvin, hertz, or pascal.
First, use the exact conversion of 0.3048 m = 1 ft: Use the plural of written unit names—“several kilograms.”
Use abbreviations in conjunction with numerals (the area
125 ft × 0.3048 m/ft = 38.100 m is 10 m2); write out names if numerals are not used, such as
Assuming three figures are significant, that is, distance “area is measured in square meters.”
was reported to the nearest foot, you would show the soft Indicate the product of two or more units in abbreviated
conversion as “a distance of 125 ft (38.1 m).” form by using a dot positioned above the line—kg·m·s–2.
If, however, the distance of 125 ft was obtained by rounding Do not mix names and abbreviations—write N·m or
to the nearest 5 ft so that the value could have been anywhere newton meter, not N·meter or newton·m.
between 123 and 127 ft, only two significant figures are justi- 11.5.2 Percentages, decimals, and fractions
fied, and you would write the conversion as “a distance of 125 Spell out the word “percent.”
ft (38 m).” Refer to 11.6.3 for information on rounding. Don’t use percent on numbers that include decimals.
If you do not know the precision of the measurement, make
a reasonable estimate. Ideally the number of significant digits EXAMPLE
retained should be such that precision is neither sacrificed nor Use: 0.0001
exaggerated in making the conversion. See the documents of Instead of: 0.01 percent
ACI Committee 304 for an example of soft conversion.
11.4.2 Hard metric conversion Don’t use numbers with exponents.
Apply the appropriate conversion factor from IEEE/
ASTM SI 10 (Table 11.6.1) and then round to the standard
dimension that would be used when design and construc- EXAMPLE
tion are in the other system of units. Show the original value Use: 0.0001
followed by the hard conversion separated by the word “or” Instead of: 1 × 10–4
or placed in brackets.
For hard conversion of bar spacing of 16 in., first multiply Don’t confuse “percentage point” with “percent.” Use
by the conversion factor: “percentage point” where changes to values measured in
“percent” are made.
16 in. × 25.4 mm/in. = 406.4 mm
EXAMPLE
The 406.4 mm value could be rounded to 410 mm, to have Use: For fc′ greater than 5000 psi, it is permitted to reduce
the same precision as the original 16 in. But for hard conver- air content indicated in Table X.X by 1.0 percentage point.
sion, it would be more appropriate to use further rounding Instead of: For fc′ greater than 5000 psi, it is permitted
that reflects actual field practice: “bar spacing of 16 in. or to reduce air content indicated in Table X.X by 1.0 percent.
400 mm” or “bar spacing of 16 in. (400 mm).”
Using the word “or” indicates that 400 mm is an alter-
Do not spell out fractions. Use numerals.
native to, but not necessarily an exact equivalent of 16 in.
Fractions are common for measured distances in inch-
Always consider using actual dimensions of products and
pound units.
equipment that are available and manufactured to SI dimen-
sions when making a hard metric conversion, and vice-versa
when going from SI to inch-pound units. The exception is if EXAMPLE
comparing test results with a specification limit that is given Use: A specificed cover of 3/4 in.
as decimal percent. Instead of: A specified cover of 0.75 in.
All ACI documents containing both inch-pound and
SI units, with one as a hard conversion of the other, shall 11.5.3 Degrees
include the following statement in the first chapter: Don’t abbreviate the word “degree.” When referring to
“The paired values stated in inch-pound and SI units are Fahrenheit or Celsius, use the degree symbol (°), not the word
usually not exact equivalents. Therefore, each system is to “degree.” When referring to an angle, spell “degree.” Don’t
be used independently of the other. Combining values from add a space between the number and the degree symbol.
the two systems may result in nonconformance with this
document [guide or report, as appropriate].”
Table 11.6.1—Conversion factors for commonly used values in the concrete industry
From Multiply by To get
Area
1 square yard (yd2) 0.8361274 square meter (m2)
1 square foot (ft2) 0.0929034 (exact) square meter (m2)
1 square inch (in.2) 645.16 (exact) square millimeter (mm2)
Area per volume (coverage)
1 square foot per gallon (ft2/gal.) 0.02454 square meter per liter (m2/L)
Energy
BTU 1055.87 joule (J)
Heat
thermal conductivity (k value) (BTU / ft·h·°F)) 1.730735 watt per (meter·kelvin) (W/(m·K))
thermal resistance (R value) (ft2·h·°F/BTU) 0.176110 square meter·kelvin per watt ((m2·K)/W)
specific heat (BTU / (lb·°F)) 4186.800 joule per (kilogram·kelvin) (J/(kg·K))
Force
1 pound (lb) 4.448222 newton (N)
1 kip (1000 lb) 4.448222 kilonewton (kN)
Length
1 inch (in.) 25.4 (exact) millimeter (mm)
1 foot (ft) 0.3048 (exact) meter (m)
1 yard (yd) 0.9144 (exact) meter (m)
1 mile (mile) 1.609 44 kilometer (km)
Mass
1 pound (lb) 0.4535924 kilogram (kg)
1 ton (=2000 lb) 0.9071847 metric ton (t)
appropriate. Significant digits are any digits necessary to 11.6.4 Reinforcing bar designations
define a value or quantity. Generally, leading zeros are not Converting reinforcing bar designations is complicated by
significant; trailing zeros may or may not be significant. the various schemes used to designate bar sizes and proper-
ties. The best approach is to fully describe the bars in terms
of physical dimensions such as diameter or cross-sectional
EXAMPLE
area rather than using a national designation. Also, different
6 = one significant digit
countries use different standards in which the tensile proper-
0.0037 = two significant digits
ties of the steel may differ from those in the United States.
1.297 = four signicant digits
Report the properties of the steel used such that the reader
1000 = one, two, three, our four significant digits,
can understand the reinforcement without detailed knowl-
depending upon the precisiion of the original measure-
edge of a particular country’s design standard.
ment; if measurement is to the nearest digit, there for four
11.6.5 Degree of precision
signiciant units.
In the context of this section, precision refers to the
lowest common working limit for a measured quantity. For
11.6.3 Rounding example, a measuring tape is commonly shown to 1/8 in.
After considering the precision of a value, round the It is not appropriate to report or require more precision
converted value so that the same level of precision is implied in measurements than is appropriate for the values being
as in the original value. discussed. Refer to Table 11.6.5 for recommended degrees
If the inch-pound measurement is expressed as a combina- of precision.
tion of units, convert to the smaller unit and then multiply by The values shown in Table 11.6.5 are recommended for:
the appropriate conversion factor. For example, convert 5 ft (a) Reporting new research work
6 in. to 66 in. before converting. (b) Preparing Project Specifications
Do not round off either the unit or conversion factor before (c) Writing general technical papers
multiplying. (d) Making recommendations regarding concrete practice
After multiplying by the conversion factor, round off to a Note that the same degree of precision may not be
number of significant digits to represent the accuracy of the appropriate for reporting measured values and for use in a
original measurement. specification.
After rounding off, move the decimal point as necessary 11.6.6 Mass versus weight
to express the SI converted value using one of the preferred Mass represents the amount of substance in an object
prefixes. The numerical value for SI dimensions should be and weight represents the gravitational force acting on the
between 1 and 999. For example, use 1.2 km, not 1200 m. object. In the inch-pound system, the pound (lb) is used as
Going back to the example of 6 in. slump in 11.6.2, the both the unit of weight (or force) and as the unit of mass. In
implied precision of the measurement is ±0.5 in. or approxi- general, there is no need to make a distinction between mass
mately ±10 mm. Therefore, the appropriate conversion of 6 and weight except when performing a dynamic structural
in. slump is 150 mm slump. analysis. In this case, the mass of the object has to be used in
the calculations. The mass is obtained by dividing the weight this chapter applies to sessions and symposia, referred to as
in pounds by the gravitational acceleration g, which is 32.2 sessions for simplicity.
ft/s2. The resulting quantity has the unit slug. A single session has a 2-hour duration. Requests for up
In the SI system, kilogram is the unit of mass and newton to four sessions are common. Requests for five or more
is the unit of force. The weight of an object in newtons is sessions will require persuasive reasons.
obtained by multiplying the mass in kilograms by 9.81 m/s2, A symposium is a larger event and usually consists of at
which is the gravitational acceleration in SI units. least four 2-hour sessions, two of which may run concur-
When converting a quantity in units of pounds to the rently. The ACI website contains the necessary forms for
corresponding quantity in SI units, make sure that the correct requesting a technical session.
conversion factor is used. For example, pounds of cement
in a mixture represent the mass (amount) of cement and 12.2—TAC approval
would be converted to kilograms by multiplying the number TAC uses a two-step process to approve technical conven-
of pounds by 0.4545924. On the other hand, a dead load in tion sessions:
pounds would be converted to newtons by multiplying the 1. Preliminary approval of a session proposal, which
number of pounds by 4.448222. requires submitting basic information about the proposed
11.6.7 Decimal point and implied tolerances session, such as the name of the moderator, the general topic,
If numerical limits are given in a document, the tolerances and goals of the session.
should also be given. If tolerances are not stated explicitly, 2. Final approval of the session program, which requires
then tolerances are implied by the way the limit is written. For submitting all final details about the session, including
example, if a temperature is specified as 23°C, by the rules a list of all speakers and the titles and abstracts of their
of rounding, any temperature between 22.5°C and 23.5°C presentations.
will round to 23°C and satisfy this requirement. However, TAC uses the following criteria when approving session
if the temperature is specified as 23.0°C, then the permitted requests:
range is from 22.95°C to 23.05°C. If a numerical limit is (a) The request form indicates a strong justification for the
given as a whole number, the implied tolerance is ±0.5, if session, including:
a limit is given to the nearest 0.1 the implied tolerance is (i) A statement on the scope of the session and how it
±0.05, and so forth. These principles need to be considered would benefit the attendees
when using decimal points in numerical limits. (ii) How the speakers are selected
(iii) A description of the content of the session
PART 5—SESSIONS AND VIDEO PRODUCTS (iv) An abstract for each presentation
(b) The scope and outcome are relevant to ACI’s mission,
CHAPTER 12—CONVENTION SESSIONS AND including:
RELATED PUBLICATIONS (i) Presentation of new documents
(ii) Emerging technology
12.1—Committee planning (iii) Awareness of an established technology
ACI offers mini sessions and convention sessions that are (c) The session is sponsored by more than one technical
held at ACI conventions. committee
Mini sessions are limited to one-hour in length and are (d) The session topic is relevant to the convention theme.
held during the first hour of a committee’s regularly sched- A technical committee may seek to publish papers related to
uled meeting time. Each presentation should be a minimum their sessions as an ACI Special Publication (SP)
of 10 minutes. Mini sessions support PDH’s and special There is only one-step process for approving mini sessions.
publications are permitted; however, presentations will not Committees should submit requests for mini sessions to TAC
be recorded. ACI will provide an LCD projector and screen, at least six months before the planned convention.
however speakers must provide their own laptops. 12.2.1 Session moderator training
Every 3 to 4 years, ACI technical committees should plan The session moderator and comoderator are encouraged to
technical convention sessions at ACI conventions. Commit- review the online Session Moderator Training available on
tees need to initiate an administrative ballot for a new tech- the ACI website.
nical session.
Presentation materials used during technical sessions at 12.3—Sponsorship of technical sessions at non-
ACI conventions are to be high quality and are expected ACI conventions
to report new or unpublished work that adds to the existing Technical committees may sponsor technical sessions that
knowledge base. Presentations that promote the use of are held outside ACI conventions. The technical content of
proprietary products without sufficient, objective, supporting the proposed session is to be consistent with the commit-
data are generally not acceptable. tee’s mission and there is to be no financial obligation by the
Depending on the subject and the number of presentations committee or the Institute. The request shall be submitted to
that can be generated, the committee may decide to plan a the SP and Session Coordinator.
session, multiple sessions, or a symposium. The guidance in
TAC will consider a request to publish proceedings from The ACI Board of Direction approved a policy in 1991 for
a technical session held outside an ACI convention. Refer to honoring prominent ACI members with sessions at conven-
12.5.1 for details. tions with the requirements that:
(a) The honored individual has made an outstanding
12.4—Convention session procedures contribution to ACI and the concrete industry.
12.4.1 Initiating a session (b) The Convention Committee has the responsibility
A technical committee usually volunteers to either of evaluating the honored individual’s contributions and
sponsor or cosponsor a technical session, but TAC may ask approving this event.
a committee to assume such an assignment. If appropriate, (c) The request for sessions honoring prominent ACI
the committee should consider inviting other committees to members is reviewed for technical content and approved by
cosponsor the session. TAC.
Session topics should relate to the convention theme (d) The proposal for sessions and dinner honoring a promi-
if possible, but it is not required. Potential session topics nent ACI member is submitted for consideration to the Conven-
may include presentations of new committee documents, tion Committee by TAC after approving the technical content.
new research findings, case histories, or timely topics that (e) The sessions and dinner must be approved at least one
the committee determines will be of interest to convention convention in advance by the Convention Committee.
attendees. (f) The sessions and dinner cannot be held to conflict with
After deciding to sponsor a session, the committee selects a the Opening Reception, the President’s Reception, or the
session moderator who will have overall responsibility for the Concrete Mixer.
session. A comoderator should also be selected, and a task group Sessions honoring prominent ACI members should
may be organized to assist in selecting session presentations. adequately reflect and represent their field of activity and
12.4.2 Preliminary TAC approval may consist of either multiple sessions or a symposium and
The preliminary technical session request form is completed are titled accordingly:
by the committee chair or proposed session moderator and (a) Session Honoring [Name of prominent ACI member],
submitted to staff from the ACI website. The proposal should Part 1: [Title], Part 2: [Title], etc. Sessions usually consist of
indicate to TAC that the committee is planning the session a minimum of two 2-hour sessions.
with a clear objective (200 to 300 words) and has chosen (b) Symposium Honoring [Name of prominent ACI
session topics that will be of widespread interest. member], Part 1: [Title], Part 2: [Title], Part 3: [Title], Part
TAC reviews the session request and accepts it, declines it, 4: [Title], etc. Symposia usually consist of a minimum of
or requests additional information before making a decision. four 2-hour sessions.
When TAC approves a session, a time slot is reserved by staff 12.4.5 Speakers
at the requested convention. The session moderator will be noti- There are several sources to identify prospective speakers
fied of the TAC decision by staff. A call for papers (presenta- such as the committee itself, known authorities in the subject
tions) in Concrete International (CI) may be submitted online. field, or a call for papers in CI.
12.4.2.1 Deadlines for preliminary TAC approval 12.4.5.1 Calls for papers
The committee must submit a preliminary technical session Calls for papers or presentations are published announce-
request form to TAC at least two conventions before the ments in CI requesting people to submit abstracts for presen-
convention where the technical session will be held. Staff must tation at ACI conventions or other meetings. Calls for papers
receive the request at least 1 week before the TAC meeting. are initiated on the ACI website. Complete all fields of the
If the committee plans to have a call for papers, more lead form, including whether a manuscript is expected to be
time is required. Refer to 12.4.5.1 for guidance on preparing submitted if the abstract is selected. Issue the call for papers
a call for papers or presentations. Refer to the ACI website or presentations as soon as TAC approves the preliminary
for technical session and SP deadlines. session request. The call should indicate the session objec-
12.4.3 Time allotted for presentations tive and list examples of potential topics for presentation.
Typically, each convention session consists of 2 hours Give the name of the person to whom the abstracts are to be
with an appropriate number of 20-minute presentations, sent along with the deadline for receipt of abstracts and the
adequate time for floor discussion, and speaker introduc- date for final papers (for SPs). (Abstracts should be sent to
tions. Sessions with fewer than four presentations are the moderator 8 months before the technical session.) Refer
discouraged and sessions with more than six presentations to a current issue of CI for examples of calls for papers.
will not be approved. Session moderators are responsible for A typical time schedule is:
monitoring presentation times, discussions, and the timely Time (months) before
conclusion of each presentation and the session. Actions the technical session
TAC and the Convention Committee require that a time- Submit preliminary request for session 12
table of speakers be published in the convention program and Submit preliminary request for companion
18
session SP (optional)
posted outside the session room. This allows for convention
Initiate Call for Papers (presentations) at the
attendees to plan their time to attend specific presentations.
ACI website. There is a 3-month lead time 16
12.4.4 Sessions honoring prominent ACI members for publication of the notice in CI.
A Call for Papers is published in three the session will be approved. If the session receives final
13 to 11
consecutive issues of CI. approval, staff will notify the moderators and the committee
All abstracts should be received by the chair. The information in the final approval form will be
moderator(s) so that the committee can 8 used in the preconvention program mailing, in CI, and in
select final speakers.
other publicity. The sponsoring committee should arrange
for appropriate local publicity, specialized publicity, and
12.4.5.2 Selecting speakers
attendance from particular groups that might be interested
Contact prospective speakers early, but do not make defi-
in the session.
nite arrangements until receiving preliminary TAC approval.
The committee may not alter the details of the session
At initial contact, speakers should have an idea of the presen-
once final approval has been granted without the permission
tation subject and possible title.
of TAC. Submit any requested changes to the SP and Session
Prospective speakers should prepare an abstract (2000
Coordinator.
to 300 words) of the presentation as soon as possible and
12.4.6.1 Deadlines for final TAC approval
submit it to the session moderator for the committee’s
Sessions must be submitted for final TAC approval no later
consideration.
than the Friday after the end of the preceding convention.
The sponsoring committee should review the submitted
Failure to meet the deadline will postpone the TAC review and
abstracts with regard to the theme of the session. In selecting
thus the session may be postponed or not approved.
speakers, consider the quality of past presentations by
12.4.7 Staff assistance
prospective speakers, if such information is available. Avoid
ACI Event Services staff will secure the necessary stan-
selecting speakers who have a history of failing to appear at
dard audio visual equipment for the session once staff is
previous conventions to make their presentations. Submit to
advised of the committee’s needs.
the Event Services Department the names and addresses of
Staff sends copies of authors’ guides and guidelines for
speakers who are not ACI members so that they can receive
preparing slides to session moderators for distribution to the
registration forms. Encourage speakers to visit the ACI
speakers.
website for the latest convention information.
12.4.8 Presentation materials
12.4.5.3 Notifying speakers
Quality slides are important to the overall quality of a
Upon selection by the sponsoring committee, notify
presentation. TAC encourages speakers to prepare slides
speakers that they are on the tentative program, inform them
using Microsoft PowerPoint®. Presentations should be
of the allocated presentation time, and ask them to proceed
professional in appearance. Presenters should refrain from
with preparing their presentation.
the use of brand names and specific product endorsement
If paper versions of the presentations are to be considered for
whenever possible. Small logos are acceptable.
session or symposium publication (SP), indicate the deadline
for submission of manuscripts and approximate date for notifi-
12.5—Publication of session papers in an ACI
cation of acceptance. Also, advise the speakers that selection of
Symposium Publication
a presentation for convention session does not guarantee publi-
The committee may wish to publish papers from convention
cation of a paper and that manuscripts are reviewed in accor-
sessions or a symposium in a Symposium Publication (SP). A
dance with the ACI publication policy. The Event Services
minimum of 10 papers is recommended for an SP. ACI SPs
Department will send appropriate forms to each session moder-
are published in PDF format. Contact ACI staff if interested
ator for distribution to the selected speakers.
in publishing in a different format. Individual authors are
ACI does not pay speakers’ expenses or travel, or offer an
encouraged to submit their papers for consideration by an ACI
honorarium. This is stated in the letter advising a speaker
periodical if a collection of papers as an SP is not planned.
that the abstract has been selected for presentation.
An SP may include papers from convention sessions, papers
Notify speakers who are not selected for the program.
submitted but not presented, and other papers dealing with the
If an SP is planned and if the abstracts have merit, those
same subject matter received by the Institute and approved by
submitting the abstracts may be asked to prepare papers to
the committee for inclusion in the SP. Papers must be orig-
be considered for the SP with other papers developed from
inal unless otherwise approved by TAC. Committees must
the technical session.
approve by administrative ballot a request to sponsor a special
12.4.6 Final TAC approval
publication before submitting such a request to ACI.
For final approval by TAC, submit all details of the
The SP is to be available at the time of the technical
technical session, including summary of the session to be
session. This requires careful planning, coordination with
published in the convention program (200 to 300 words),
the SP and Session Coordinator, and a rigid timetable for
the name and contact information of the moderator(s) and
manuscript submissions and reviews. Technical session and
of each speaker, titles of their presentations, and abstracts
SP deadlines are available on the ACI website.
(200 to 300 words) for each presentation. The final session
Final manuscripts and all backup material must be
request form is completed online by the session moderator,
submitted at least 3 months before the technical session to
who has completed the session moderator training, and
ensure that the SP will be available for sale at the conven-
submitted to staff. These forms can be found on the ACI
tion or other event. In rare cases, however, the SP will be
website. TAC will make a final review to determine whether
published after the technical session. In this case, final
manuscripts and all backup material must be submitted to as primary units. The secondary units must be provided in
the SP and Session Coordinator within 6 months of the tech- parentheses.
nical session. Some papers presented at a convention session might not
Information on obtaining TAC preliminary and final be published. Experience shows that some oral presenta-
approvals and preparing an SP can be found on the ACI website. tions cannot be adapted to written format. After the SP editor
12.5.1 SP from conferences outside ACI conventions selects presentations for the session or symposium publica-
TAC will consider requests to publish proceedings from tion, notify the presenters promptly that an SP is planned,
technical sessions held at conferences outside an ACI and invite them to prepare a manuscript for review. Give
convention, provided the following requirements are met: authors a firm deadline for submission of manuscripts.
(a) The conference must have formal cosponsorship by ACI 12.5.5 Review of papers
(b) The technical session must be associated with an ACI TAC generally delegates coordinating the reviews of SPs
committee to the SP editor. The editor selects at least two qualified
(c) A financial agreement must be in place for publishing reviewers for each paper. Except in special cases approved
the SP by TAC before papers are reviewed, a reviewer must not
(d) ACI’s SP procedures must be followed on all papers review more than 25 percent of the papers for any SP or 10
Cosponsorship by ACI requires the approval of the ACI papers, whichever is less.
Executive Vice President. The topic of the SP should precede The editor should provide the SP and Session Coor-
the name of the conference in the title. Submit the request, dinator with a list of the reviewers and how many papers
along with a discussion of the financial implications for ACI each reviewer has been assigned. When the SP editor has
to the SP and Session Coordinator. authored one of the papers, the editor shall submit that paper
12.5.2 SP honoring an individual to the SP and Session Coordinator, who will assign anony-
SPs honoring an individual can have a title and preface mous reviewers.
dedicated to the individual. The topic of the SP, however, Reviewers follow the criteria listed in the manuscript
should precede the name of the individual being honored in review forms available on the ACI website. Reviews
the title. The preface should be no more than 1 page (approx- should be returned to the editor within 30 days. At least two
imately 600 words). The preface should discuss the individ- reviewers must recommend publication. If one of the two
ual’s contribution to the concrete industry. reviewers does not recommend publication, a third reviewer
12.5.3 Preliminary TAC approval shall be assigned. For convention sessions, session papers
TAC approves or declines preliminary SP requests based that are not to be published in the SP are permitted to be
on appropriateness of the subject matter and anticipated shared with the audience if the author gives permission.
usefulness of the publication. When a decision is made Inform the session audience that these papers can be found
to publish an SP, the committee should submit an online on the ACI website for a short time following the session.
preliminary SP request form to the ACI staff SP and Session All papers made available on the session handout page must
Coordinator before proceeding with production of an SP. be reviewed by the editor for style before posting.
This request should: The editor provides authors with copies of anonymous
(a) Identify the SP editor(s), including contact information review comments and instructions for submitting final manu-
(b) Provide a brief overview of the proposed SP scripts. Authors must address review comments in preparing
(c) List proposed paper titles and authors, including their their final manuscripts, and must provide an explanation to
contact information (this requirement may be waived if a the editors why particular review comments were not incor-
call for papers is planned to be issued in CI) porated into the final manuscript.
(d) Provide a timetable leading to the publication of the SP The editor is responsible for determining that the final manu-
(e) Identify individuals serving on the scientific committee script addresses all review comments in a satisfactory manner.
that will advise the sponsoring committee on matters related Final manuscripts for all papers, along with all reviews, a
to the session and serve as reviewers for the papers. It is preface providing background information and a summary of
advantageous to have the scientific committee composed, at the SP contents, and any other information requested are then
least partially, of representatives from other ACI committees submitted to ACI staff for final TAC approval.
with an interest in the topic of the SP. These other commit- 12.5.6 Final TAC approval
tees should also be considered for co-sponsorship of the SP For final TAC approval, the committee must submit a final
12.5.4 Preparation of papers SP request to the TAC Secretary, including the completed SP,
Information on the ACI website includes: the table of contents, preface, all papers, the reviews for all
(a) Information for SP editors (processing information, papers with the reviewers’ names, copyright transfer forms,
initial and final approval requirements, initial and final paper and the number of accepted and declined papers. TAC reviews
submission checklists, calls for papers, review forms, and the final documentation and verifies that procedures have
paper awards criteria) been followed. Following TAC approval, ACI staff prepares
(b) Information for SP paper authors (manuscript guide- materials for publication of the SP.
lines and copyright transfer form)
All SP papers, including figures, require dual units. SI
(metric) or inch-pound units of measurement can be used
of ACI documents are requested to contact ACI their basis, may not be as extensively developed and
via the errata website at http://www.concrete.org/ tested as those for more mature technologies. This
publications/documenterrata.aspx. Proper use of document identifies areas in which information is
this document includes periodically checking for believed to be less fully developed, and describes
errata for the most up-to-date revisions. related research needs. The professional using this
“ACI committee documents are intended for the document should understand the limitations of this
use of individuals who are competent to evaluate document and exercise judgment as to the appro-
the significance and limitations of its content and priate application of this innovative technology.”
recommendations and who will accept responsi-
bility for the application of the material it contains. 14.2.4 Statement describing Emerging Technology Reports
Individuals who use this publication in any way The first page of an ETR shall include the following
assume all risk and accept total responsibility for statement:
the application and use of this information.
“All information in this publication is provided ‘as “ACI encourages the development and appropriate
is’ without warranty of any kind, either express or use of new and emerging technologies through the
implied, including but not limited to, the implied publication of the Emerging Technology Reports.
warranties of merchantability, fitness for a partic- These documents present information and recom-
ular purpose or non-infringement. mendations based on available test data, technical
“ACI and its members disclaim liability for reports, limited experience with field applications,
damages of any kind, including any special, and the opinions of committee members. The
indirect, incidental, or consequential damages, presented information and recommendations, and
including without limitation, lost revenues or their basis, may not be as extensively developed
lost profits, which may result from the use of this and tested as those for more mature technologies.
publication. This report identifies areas in which information is
“It is the responsibility of the user of this document believed to be less fully developed, and describes
to comply with all applicable laws and regulations related research needs. The professional using this
of any nature, and to establish environmental and/ document should understand the limitations of this
or health and safety practices appropriate to the document and exercise judgment as to the appro-
specific circumstances involved with its use. ACI priate application of this emerging technology.”
does not in any way represent, imply, or warrant
that the information in this document complies with 14.2.5 Translation disclaimer
any or all laws, nor does it make any representa- The first page of a translated document shall include the
tions with regard to environmental and/or health following statement:
and safety issues and the use of this document. The
user must determine the applicability of all laws and (a) “Copyright by the American Concrete Institute
regulatory limitations before applying the docu- (ACI), Farmington Hills, MI. All rights reserved.
ment and must comply with all applicable laws and This material may not be reproduced or copied, in
regulations, including but not limited to, United whole or part, in any form or media, without the
States Occupational Safety and Health Administra- written consent of ACI.”
tion (OSHA) health and safety standards. (b) “This document was originally published in
“Participation by governmental representatives in English. Consequently, whenever there is doubt
the work of the American Concrete Institute and about the exact meaning, it is the English version
in the development of Institute standards does not that must be taken as authentic.”
constitute governmental endorsement of ACI or the (c)“This translation is not able to, nor intended to,
standards that it develops.” supplant individual training, responsibility, or judg-
ment of the user of the information presented. Indi-
14.2.3 Statement describing ITG reports viduals who use this publication in any way assume
The first page of Innovative Task Group (ITG) documents all risk and accept total responsibility for the appli-
shall include the following statement: cation and use of this information. All informa-
tion in this publication is provided ‘as is’ without
“ACI encourages the development and appropriate warranty of any kind, either express or implied,
use of innovative technologies through the publi- including but not limited to, the implied warranties
cation of the Innovation Task Group Documents. of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose
These documents present information and recom- or non-infringement.”
mendations based on available test data, technical (d) “ACI and its members disclaim liability for
reports, limited experience with field applications, damages of any kind, including any special,
and the opinions of committee members. The indirect, incidental, or consequential damages,
presented information and recommendations, and including without limitation, lost revenues or
lost profits, which may result from the use of this APPENDIX A—TAC’S INTERNATIONAL
publication.” OUTREACH
V Grammar, 9.6
Vice chair, 1.8.1.1, 1.8.2 - Abbreviations, 9.6.9
Video products, Chapter 13 - And/or, 9.6.12
Votes, 1.5.1.3, 1.5.2.3, 1.5.3.3, 1.5.4.3, 2.3.4, 2.3.5, Chapter 3 - Capitalization, 9.6.10
Voting members, 1.2.3, 1.5.1, 3.1, 3.2.1, 3.2.5, 3.3, 3.4.2, - Footnotes, 9.6.7
3.5, 4.2.6.5, 4.4.4.2, 7.3.3, 7.5.4.2 - Hyphens, 9.6.5
- Numbers, 9.6.4
W - Parentheses and brackets, 9.6.8
Withdrawals, 3.4.1, 4.2.2.3, 7.3.2.3 - Serial comma, 9.6.6
Workshop, with cosponsoring organizations, 1.4.1.1 - Per versus “/”, 9.6.11
Writing style, Chapter 9 Lists, 9.5
Equations, 9.2, 9.2.1 Tables, 9.4
Figures, 9.3
· Technical committees that produce consensus reports, guides, specifications, and codes.
· Periodicals: the ACI Structural Journal, Materials Journal, and Concrete International.
Benefits of membership include a subscription to Concrete International and to an ACI Journal. ACI
members receive discounts of up to 40% on all ACI products and services, including documents, seminars
and convention registration fees.
As a member of ACI, you join thousands of practitioners and professionals worldwide who share
a commitment to maintain the highest industry standards for concrete technology, construction,
and practices. In addition, ACI chapters provide opportunities for interaction of professionals and
practitioners at a local level to discuss and share concrete knowledge and fellowship.