Professional Documents
Culture Documents
���������
Fall 2004
On the
Frontier
Freemasonry’s
influence on the
American west
www.freemason.org
PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY
Accept It and Teach It
155th
R Many significant resolutions for
delegate consideration
R Monday evening
entertainment variety program
October 10-13
CALIFORNIA
���������
VOLUME 52
cover story
SEPTEMBER 1, 2004
NUMBER 4
Chief Joseph Brant was the first American Indian to
PUBLICATION BOARD
Howard D. Kirkpatrick, Grand Master become a Freemason—he was initiated in London, England
John L. Cooper III, Grand Secretary in 1776. Since then, Freemasonry attracted many Native
Allan L. Casalou, Editor in Chief
Americans, including many tribal chiefs. The common bond
EDITORIAL STAFF
of Masonic fellowship between Native American Indians
Kimberly B. Murawski, Copy Editor
Steffani Kizziar, Masonic Homes Editor and White men proved a force for easing tensions in
Brad Bradbury, Online Editor
turbulent periods of American history, particularly in the
PHOTOGRAPHERS Indian Territory in the 19th century.
Skye Coddington
David Fairchild Studio
Cover Photo courtesy of
Independence National Historic Park
Design by Burritt Design
For more articles of interest, check out California Freemason Online at www.freemason.org.
OFFICERS OF THE GRAND LODGE
GRAND MASTER
Howard D. Kirkpatrick, Reading No. 254
�
155th
COMMUNICATION
��
SENIOR GRAND WARDEN Important legislation combined Read John Cooper’s stance
Frederick L. Sorsabal, Placerville No. 26
with events for family and � on Manifest Destiny and how
��
JUNIOR GRAND WARDEN friends make the 155th Annual Freemasonry provided a model of
�
ANNUAL
��
Warren J. Blomseth, Crow Canyon No. 551
be missed. Join Grand Master that eventually became states of
GRAND SECRETARY
Kirkpatrick in San Francisco this the American Union.
John L. Cooper III, Culver City-Foshay No. 467 October.
GRAND LECTURER
Harold A. Macy, Palmdale No. 769
6 history 16 masonic education
www.freemasons.org Did you miss the California Discover the similarities between
Masonic Symposium? Experience Native American traditions and
CALIFORNIA FREEMASON
early Texas Masonry with the Freemasonry. Both bring men
(USPS 083-940) is published quarterly by the
abridged keynote address by Dr. through an initiatic process that
Publishing Board and is the only official publication Howard Stewart, 2004 Fellow of seeks to return him to the center
of the Grand Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons the Institute for Masonic Studies of his spiritual existence.
of the State of California, 1111 California St.,
San Francisco, CA 94108-2284. at the.
Publication Office – Publication offices at the
Grand Lodge Offices, 1111 California Street,
San Francisco, CA 94108-2284. Periodicals
Postage Paid at San Francisco, CA and at
8 history 18 masonic education
additional mailing offices. Milo Daley takes you back to Book reviews of Beresniak’s
Postmaster – Send address changes to California Wyoming in the 1890s when “Symbols of Freemasonry” and
Freemason, 1111 California Street, San Francisco, American Frontier Masons stood MacNulty’s “’Freemasonry: A
CA 94108-2284.
up to the Red Slash Gang to Journey Through Ritual and Symbol”
Publication Dates – Publication dates are the first
day of December, March, June, and September.
provide a proper burial for a quench the avid reader’s thirst for
Subscriptions – CALIFORNIA FREEMASON
brother. knowledge.
is mailed to every member of this Masonic
jurisdiction without additional charge. Others are
invited to subscribe for $2.00 a year or $2.75
outside of the United States. 9 history 19 masonic homes
Permission to reprint – Permission to reprint The Masonic apron of Davy The programs and services of the
original articles in CALIFORNIA FREEMASON is Crockett was on display at the Masonic Homes evolve as the
granted to all recognized Masonic publications
California Masonic Symposium. needs of members change. Read
with credit to the author and this publication.
Get a closer look at this legendary about the latest efforts to meet the
Phone: 800/831-8170 or needs and challenges of a
figure and Masonic icon that gave
415/776-7000;
fax: 415/776-7170; up his life defending the Alamo. new frontier.
e-mail: editor@freemason.org.
Masonry’s Future Is
Today’s Frontier
M
asonry’s future depends upon do, clearly and concisely, and have an
the present actions we take to informed membership able to do so.
meet the frontier of our vision: Increased communication between
a vision that insures continuing Grand Lodge, lodges, their membership,
education and exploration into the and the community is essential.
relevance and value of Masonic Masonry itself will encourage new
principles in our daily lives. membership when understood. A movie
At the warden retreats it was titled “Field of Dreams” emphasized that
emphasized that the crucial issue if you build a stadium (or as in our case,
in Masonry is not membership, a great fraternity), they will come. This
but leadership. Knowledgeable these same lodges have dues of $40, of will occur if we properly communicate
enthusiastic officers with a vision taking which $25 is sent to Grand Lodge for our shared vision to all. Our stadium
appropriate action thereon will achieve per capita assessment, leaving $15 per has been erected from the cement of
an increase in membership. member for payment of rent and other Masonic ideals and leadership.
Wardens, with the help of their wives, expenses. With no social or community Masonry requires an attitude
wrote what they wanted their lodges to activities, lodge survival is questionable. adjustment with a positive, enthusiastic
be like in three to five years. One wrote: The help or guidance of Grand Lodge approach. We are proud to be
In my lodge, fellowship, brotherhood, cannot create or maintain a viable lodge. Americans. We should be proud to be
and family come together in a No magic panacea emanates from San Masons. As a matter of note, in the
friendly nurturing environment with Francisco. A successful lodge is found year 2000 the average age of a Mason
increased membership and community within its own membership. was 71, in 2004 it is 68, and by 2019 it is
involvement. Men seek to join an organization estimated it will be 54.
Some wardens alleged their vision whose principles have survived through Grand Lodge and each lodge must
could not be achieved because of the ages as a beacon by which to live have a vision and a plan of action
obstacles by a Grand Lodge composed of a just and upright life emphasizing shared by its membership. When
past masters. However, of the delegates fraternalism, friendship, family, and communicated and acted upon,
at our last Grand Lodge session, the involvement. our lodges will become a place of
present masters and wardens had 72 These are the attributes that Masonry brotherhood, friendship, and family
percent of all votes. offers. Such men demand to know if serving our fellow man.
Other wardens stated there were no Masonry can fulfill their needs. The frontier of Freemasonry is in
funds for social activities or community The task of our present frontier is your hands.
partnerships. Without a large reserve, to ascertain how to impart who we
are, what we stand for, and what we
Melvyn B. Stein
Junior Grand Warden
Annual Communication
JOHN L. COOPER III, GRAND SECRETARY
LEGISLATION
Copies of the legislation have been mailed to all lodges, and
are available from the secretary of the lodge. All legislation can
be found on www.freemason.org.
California Freemason 5 Fall 2004
HISTORY
abandoned in a 14, he sank his two cannon in the “which-way tree.” It was a fork in the road:
Guadalupe River for lack of transport one fork leading to the right toward San
moment’s notice, and pulled out heading west. Virtually Jacinto, the other toward Louisiana. Without
breakfast still on tables, everyone in the town accompanied him, hesitation, Houston ordered, “columns
cribs full of corn, and leaving behind the red glow of the town right,” and the die was cast.
they had set on fire. On reaching San Felipe, Santa Anna and
yards full of chickens. This was the real beginning of the his army burned it to the ground and the
Runaway Scrape that would depopulate story of this town comes to an end—but not
the entire frontier in a pell-mell manner Houston’s story.
summons inviting all interested Masons and leave the people feeling that Houston and his men defeated Santa
to meet at San Felipe on February 11, Houston was running from Santa Anna. Anna’s forces at the decisive 17-minute
1828. This was the first official Masonic Houston reached the Colorado battle of San Jacinto on the afternoon of
meeting ever held in Texas. River on March 17, now with 600 men. April 21, 1836. Houston was wounded in
On December 24, 1832, a Mason by They crossed the river and burned the battle when his horse was shot from
the name of Samuel Pablo Houston rode the ferry. The army then marched underneath him, and he would forever be a
into San Felipe and applied for a land southeast resting, drilling, and recruiting hero in the history of Texas.
grant. During the events of the Runaway volunteers. When the Mexican army He led the Texas rebels to independence,
Scrape, Houston would be called a followed, they found entire farms became the first president of the Republic of
pacifist and would even be branded a abandoned in a moment’s notice, Texas, and presided at the formation of the
coward. breakfast still on tables, cribs full of corn, Grand Lodge of the Republic of Texas.
At this time, Austin’s mind was on and yards full of chickens. Today the area of San Felipe de Austin
such things as relations with Mexico Meanwhile, Houston and his army forms the western boundary of the Stephen
and forming Masonic lodges. In 1835, reached the vicinity of San Felipe, where F. Austin Historical Park. A bridge crosses
in answer to a petition from the Masons he was forced to deny rumors that he the river there where one can stand as the
of San Felipe, the General Grand Royal was seeking refuge in Louisiana. He details of the role this village played in the
Arch Chapter issued a charter to San retreated farther north up the Brazos development of Texas come rolling back.
Felipe de Austin Chapter No. 1. Due to and then pushed another 50 miles in
the tumultuous times and the ultimate less than three days. Eventually, Houston
arrival of the dreaded news from the came to a tree that some have called
Six Guns
By Milo D. Dailey IV
With
Anchor Lodge No. 7 in Buffalo refused on government grass, then sold the
to be cowed, but instead chose to put fattened beef at profits.
their own lives in peril to see that their Then in the 1880s, horrid winters
brother received a proper burial. brought huge losses. The cattlemen
T
he Tiler stood The vicar carried arms under his were very sensitive to anything that
guard at the door vestments and the Masons had six-guns lessened their margins. And even the
of the church under their aprons. It was said that the barren northern high plains drew their
with his sword over gang was impressed with the courage own tough settlers. Some were cowboys
his shoulder—and his and combat potential of the Masons; the who yearned for something of their
revolver under his apron. services and burial proceeded without own. Nobody owned the grass and
It was May 13, 1892, in Buffalo, incident. mavericking was easy.
Johnson County, Wyo.: two years after The Johnson County Cattle War is Mavericking is putting your brand on
the U.S. Census Bureau declared the the stuff of legend and movie scripts a calf that has none. In practice, plenty
American frontier closed. of these ambitious cowboys gathered
Freemason George Wellman had
The Red Sash and claimed calves that still were with
been shot in an ambush. The newly their branded mother.
married ranch foreman had just been Gang of rustlers That, to the big cattlemen, was theft.
commissioned a deputy U.S. Marshal during the famed Rustling, as they put it.
when a .44-40 calibre saddle carbine Johnson County As the Johnson County Cattle War
shot to his spine killed him instantly. wound down, Wellman was slain. Some
Cattle War had
The Red Sash Gang of rustlers during in the Buffalo community during the
the famed Johnson County Cattle sworn to kill him. famed cattle war were critical of the
War had sworn to kill him. They also sheriff. “Red” Angus, they said, should
threatened the lives of any who would —literally—because it came in such a have quickly chased down Wellman’s
bury him with proper ceremony. modern era. There were telephones, killer or killers but there was neither
The word from the gang leaders for rails, telegraph, phonograph, and store- arrest nor prosecution.
Brother Wellman? “The Potter’s Field bought clothing. Some believe the killer was known
for him.” The Masonic lodge was an old throughout the community, although he
The gang was so feared and fearless establishment. Newspapers were in got away free. And Angus? He was also a
they had set fire to a military barracks at print every week. Nobody considered it Mason and Knight Templar in the York
Fort McKinney just outside Buffalo as a the dark ages. Rite. On the other hand, he was aligned
warning to the U.S. Army to stay out of Yet unlike more settled areas, in the public mind with the “rustler” side
their affairs. Wyoming’s open range was covered with of the cattle war.
Despite the threats of the gang, the huge cattle herds owned by corporations It was an interesting era.
Reverend Charles Duell and Brethren of that bought young cattle, fed them free
W
hen most people hear the name Davy Crockett, the most popular politicians in stodgy Washington, D.C. His
one thing comes to mind: the raccoon-fur cap short story, “Bear Hunting in Tennessee,” published in 1834,
worn by Fess Parker in the 1950s Disney adventure became an instant classic, and Crockett developed a national
series. Many are surprised to learn that the real Crockett reputation that transcended politics. It would be a mistake,
was far more than an affable woodsman and hunter: He however, simply to label Davy Crockett as a caricature of the
was a three-term congressman, a member of the Tennessee Old West frontiersman. His personal credo was “be always
legislature, and a legendary defender of the Alamo, where he sure you are right, then go ahead.” These words guided his life
died in battle in 1836. Among his many accomplishments in from a young age all the way until the end, when he was one of
life, Colonel David Crockett was also a Master Mason, as were 140 men—and one of six Masons—killed defending the Alamo
many of Texas’ other early heroes, including Sam Houston, fortress.
Stephen Austin, Jim Bowie, and William Travis. Crockett’s The history of the Alamo—indeed, of Texas—is inextricably
Masonic apron was brought west by his descendants, and is linked to Freemasonry. James David Carter’s “Masonry in
now on display in the library of the Grand Lodge of California Texas: Background, History, and Influence to 1846” shows that
in San Francisco. Masons were strongly represented in the Texas Revolution,
Most of the early American patriarchs were men of wealth forming more than a quarter of the fighting force in many
and education—Thomas Jefferson founded the University battles. Masons continued to play a significant leadership
of Virginia and both Presidents Adams attended Harvard. role in the Republic of Texas; in fact, all of the presidents, vice
Crockett, the son of a tavern owner in rural Tennessee, presidents, and secretaries of state were members of the craft.
represented a new breed of leader from the rural territory west As large a figure as Davy Crockett was in life, his heroic
of the original 13 colonies. Despite having less than a year of death made him a legendary figure. Perhaps his epitaph says it
formal schooling, his quick wit and tall tales of the frontier all: “Davy Crockett, Pioneer, Patriot, Soldier, Trapper, Explorer,
made him a beloved figure in his home state. In 1826, at the State Legislator, Congressman, Martyred at the Alamo. 1786—
age of 41, Crockett was elected to the first of his three terms in 1836.” The Texas Freemasons honored this American icon in
the United States House of Representatives after serving 1925, when Davy Crockett Lodge No. 1225 was created in
two terms in the state assembly. San Antonio, the city that Crockett
Crockett’s rustic wit and ability to tell colorful died defending.
stories about his experiences as a cattle
driver, soldier, farmer, hat maker, and
sharpshooter made him one of
MANIFEST
DESTINY Freemasonry
and
M
ost historians agree that the grand lodge, with George Washington
United States of America was as its first general grand master, did
a unique experiment at its not succeed. And just as new republics
beginning, and continued to exhibit were admitted to the Union as they were
unusual characteristics throughout organized as political territories of the
�
its history, even to the present time. expanding nation, so each of these units
�
Although history records not a few formed its own Masonic grand lodge.
republics or states that had no monarch, Sovereignty was surrendered by the
� �
only the United States emerged on the United States to each of its new states
stage of history as a republic composed of
individual republics. And only the United
States, of all countries in the world, set
as they were created, and grand lodges
similarly surrendered sovereignty over
their lodges in the expanding territories
� ��
�
out to establish its empire by creating self- as new—and equal—grand lodges were
governing, self-sustaining republics as it formed. Today there are 51 Masonic grand
�
grew into its manhood. lodges in the United States, something
Beginning with thirteen original that could not have happened had it not
�
and sovereign political units when been for the unique American political
independence from Great Britain was experiment of creating sovereign states as
declared in 1776, by 1787 these original it expanded westward.
English colonies had formed the world’s
first republic within a republic—a
The expansion of the United States
to the Pacific shore is sometimes called �
federation of individual republics, or Manifest Destiny. Many Americans in
states, which had irrevocably bound the 19th century believed that it was a
themselves together into a federal union God-given destiny that the United States
called the United States of America. should eventually rule the portion of
Freemasonry in the United States North America from the Atlantic Ocean
mirrored this unique political creation. to the Pacific Ocean. Later pared down
An abortive attempt to create a national by the realities that both Canada and
� maintained that whenever at least three was our Masonic experiment. The idea
�
lodges in a territory came into existence of local sovereignty was implicit in the
�
take out a new charter from a grand lodge of each grand lodge was also implicit in
newly formed in the territory or state. our understanding that lodges could leave
Thus each new territory became a behind their original allegiance, and form
grand lodge in due course—except for a new allegiance to a grand lodge in the
� �
California, which did not pass through emerging state in which it was located.
the state of an organized territory before Freemasonry was changed by the
being admitted as a state in the American American experience of Manifest Destiny.
California Freemason 11
11 Fall 2004
11
COVER STORY
Freemasonry on the
Frontier
By Martha Davidson
Masonic fellowship provided a common bond that eased tensions between
Whites and American Indians and helped unite tribal factions on the frontier.
In turbulent times, particularly in Indian Territory during the 19th century,
Freemasonry mitigated political differences, prompted acts of brotherhood,
and contributed to the stability and betterment of the community.
JOSEPH BRANT Continental Army, was taken prisoner and was about to
Indians have been active in Freemasonry since 1776, be burned at the stake when he gave a Masonic signal of
when Mohawk chief Thayendanegea, more widely known distress. Recognizing the signal, Brant ordered McKinstry
as Joseph Brant, was inducted into a lodge in London, released. Later the two became close friends.
England. Masons were prominent in the American After the war, Britain granted Brant a large tract of
colonies, and it is likely that Brant became acquainted land along the Grand River in Ontario that became the
with Freemasonry through his close friendship with Sir Six Nations Reserve. He settled there with his followers,
William Johnson, the British superintendent of Indian established a village, built the first Protestant church in
affairs, and other White friends. Canada, and helped organize local Masonic lodges.
As chief sachem of the Six Nations (Mohawk, Oneida, In 1793, George Washington, a fellow Mason, asked
Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca, and Tuscarora), Brant was Brant to help the United States secure a peace treaty with
regarded as an influential figure in the impending conflict the Miami Indians, on the western frontier in what is now
between Great Britain and the American colonies. With Indiana.
the Revolution brewing, he sailed to England as part of Though Brant and Washington had fought on opposite
a small delegation to discuss Britain’s relations with the sides in the Revolution, they evidently respected each
Indians. In London, he appeared at court, met with the other. Masonic historian William R. Denslow tells us in
secretary for the colonies, and received a Masonic apron his book, “Freemasonry and the American Indian,” that
from George III. Brant was inducted into Hiram Cliftonian Brant, at Washington’s solicitation, assisted the Indian
Lodge No. 417, which met at a tavern called The Falcon, commissioners in obtaining a peace treaty between the
and he voyaged home with a signed certificate of Miami and the United States.
membership that he kept to the end of his life.
On his return to America, Brant led Indian forces in FREEMASONRY AND INDIAN SOCIETY
support of the British. There are several stories of Brant’s Brant was only the first of many eminent Indian leaders
freeing a captured enemy when he recognized, through to be attracted to Freemasonry. Denslow observes that
signs or gestures, that they were fellow Masons. In one there are many similarities between Masonic lodges and
account, for example, John McKinstry, an officer in the traditional Indian brotherhoods, or secret societies. Both
Continued on page 14
California Freemason 12 Fall 2004
California Freemason 13 Fall 2004
COVER STORY
have rituals of initiation and other contending that Indians were subject and land-jumpers. After stirring with
ceremonies, spiritual guides or officers, to state laws and regulations. In 1830, requests for the return of some lands,
special meeting places (the lodge or Congress passed the Indian Removal steep in a few gallons of White man’s
kiva), symbolic signs and gestures, Act to relocate the Five Civilized Tribes whiskey; bake in a western sun, and
special songs, and a belief in a Supreme from the Southeast to reservations in slice it in two parts with a Civil War.
Being. Both are concerned with the “the great American desert” of what is The result would be Indian Territory in
spiritual or life path of each member. now Oklahoma and Kansas. 1886.”
Perhaps these affinities were Some Cherokees, weary of legal In this volatile mix, Freemasonry
what drew the principal chiefs and harassments and land-grabbing by served as a means for establishing
other distinguished men of so many Whites, had already moved to the connections and promoting harmony
Indian nations to Masonic orders. western frontier (now Arkansas), along among divergent factions. Robert
Among them were chiefs John Ross with Chickasaws and Choctaws. The G. Davis, General Secretary of the
and William P. Ross of the Cherokee, Treaty of New Echota, signed in 1835 Guthrie Scottish Rite Bodies, describes
Pushmataha and Peter Pitchlynn of by only a small group of Cherokees, this role of Freemasonry in “A Shared
the Choctaw, John Jumper (Seminole), required the others to sell their land Spirit: Freemasonry and the Native
and Opothleyahola (Creek). These and move as well. American Tradition”: “This fraternal
leaders and other Freemasons played John Ross was a leader of Cherokee tie which was so prominent in Indian
important roles in one of the most resistance to this treaty, one of Territory quickly evolved into active
painful and chaotic episodes in approximately 17,000 who remained in lodge development, led mostly by tribal
American history—the forced removal the Southeast. In 1838, the U.S. Army leaders who had long held a reverence
of the Five Civilized Tribes (Cherokee, routed this remaining population of for sacred things, and who were
Chickasaw, Choctaw, Creek/Muskogee, Cherokees and Creeks. Their forced steeped in a tradition of symbolism and
and Seminole) from the Southeast winter march to Indian Territory was ritualistic ceremonies. Freemasonry
to Indian Territory in the 1830s and so harsh that an estimated 4,000 died became the most prominent secret
the settlement of that frontier in the along the way, suffering from hunger, society of the day. The lodge culture
following decades. disease, and exposure. gave birth to a major source of mutual
That bitter journey is remembered as friendship that aided significantly
FREEMASONRY STABILIZES
the Trail of Tears. in working out the problems of
VOLATILE FRONTIER
Seminoles in Florida resisted, too, development in the Territory.”
In the early 1800s, these Indian fighting the U.S. Army until 1842, but
nations occupied large sections of ultimately most of them were also GOLDEN AGE OF THE CHEROKEE
Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, and banished to the West. Cherokees were the first to establish
North Carolina, and parts of Arkansas, The forced move divided the a Masonic lodge in the Territory:
Tennessee, and Florida. White settlers Cherokees into two groups: one that Cherokee Lodge No. 21, chartered in
were increasingly drawn to the accepted the relocation and the other 1848 by the Grand Lodge of Arkansas.
region for its fertile soil and other that opposed it. Other sources of Its members included men of differing
natural resources. In 1825, President conflict in Indian Territory developed political views, both those that had
James Monroe proposed that the over the next half-century. Denslow accepted the relocation and those
Indians be persuaded to move west describes Indian Territory fifty years that opposed it, and a few White men
of the Mississippi River. After gold later: “Take 64,233 square miles of who had married Cherokee women.
was discovered in Georgia in 1828, plains; drive in 79,469 Indians against William P. Ross served as secretary;
President Andrew Jackson carried out their will; settle ancient enemies side David Carter, a judge of the Cherokee
that plan more aggressively. Although by side; sift in inter-tribal factions; Supreme Court, was treasurer. Most
the Supreme Court had ruled that add a large number of soldiers; other prominent men of the tribe were
Indian tribes constituted nations sprinkle with outlaws, cattle thieves also members. Cherokee Lodge No.
with rights to their occupied land, and murderers; and season well with 21 was granted title to a plot of land
Jackson and many others disagreed, liberal portions of sharpies, boomers, in the town of Tahlequah, the seat of
Indian Freemasons
Other Cherokee, Choctaw, and Creek Masonic lodges were
1
established in the Territory in the 1850s. Members included political
leaders, merchants, military men, farmers, and missionaries, Whites as
JOHN ROSS 1790-1866 CHEROKEE well as Indians. The principles and ideals of Freemasonry made these
lodges engines of change for their communities, providing charitable
After gold was discovered, this uncle of William P. Ross
aid to those in need and initiating plans for the construction of schools
resisted Georgia’s attempt to relocate the Cherokee
and churches. After the upheaval of the previous decades, this period of
west of the Mississippi and fought for his tribe’s rights
economic and cultural development was so remarkable that it came to
to the Supreme Court. But an 1835 treaty forced their
be called “the Golden Age of the Cherokee.”
relocation and Ross led the 15,000 Cherokees to Indian
Territory (later Oklahoma). After their arrival there,
END OF THE AMERICAN FRONTIER
Ross was chosen chief of the united Cherokee nation.
The Civil War brought that era to an end, ushering in another period
Member of Cherokee Lodge No. 21 in Tahlequah, and
of divisiveness. Chiefs John Ross, Peter Pitchlynn, John Jumper, and
as chief approved the giving of the ground for the first
Opothleyahola strove to keep their nations neutral, but were inevitably
Masonic temple in Tahlequah. Given a Masonic funeral
drawn into the conflict. Many Indians were slaveholders and sided with
in Washington, D.C.
the Confederates. Others supported the Union.
Albert Pike, considered in his time “the best and best-known Mason
in the world,” was appointed Indian Commissioner by the Confederacy.
Pike, a lawyer, journalist, explorer, and orator, was a White man who
championed Indian rights. As an attorney for the Choctaw in the 1850s,
he had obtained a $3 million settlement from the U.S. Senate for lands
taken by the federal government. In the Civil War, he commanded the
Cherokee and Choctaw regiments of the Confederate Army.
Although more than 2,000 Cherokee soldiers fought for the Union,
2
the United States maintained a hostile stance toward the Five Civilized
Tribes. The war left Indian Territory in ruins, with crops and buildings
PETER P. PITCHLYNN 1806-1881 destroyed by both Northern and Southern forces. Freemasonry, too,
CHOCTAW CHIEF suffered, and several lodges lost their charters.
In the following decades of Reconstruction, new Masonic lodges
Elected member of the national tribal council of
were founded. Many Indian Freemasons led their nations, including
the Five Civilized Tribes and headed the 1828
Joseph Garland, a judge and member of the Choctaw national council;
delegation to select lands for their homes. After
Choctaw chief and cattleman Wilson N. Jones; and Napoleon Bonaparte
the Civil War, he went to Washington, D.C., to
Moore, Creek treasurer and delegate to Washington, who obtained a
represent his tribe in claims for lands sold to the
federal payment of $400,000 for confiscated Creek lands. A Masonic
U.S. Although his lodge is not known, he attended
Grand Lodge of Indian Territory was established in 1874.
the Grand Lodge of Georgia in 1854 and was a
As Indian Territory was opened up to railroads and, in 1889, to
member of the Scottish Rite, having received his
White settlers in the Oklahoma Land Run, the frontier era drew to
32° at the hands of Albert Pike in 1860. A friendship
a close. Looking back on that period, Dr. Arthur C. Parker (Seneca),
between Pitchlynn and Pike developed and it was
a distinguished archaeologist and ethnologist who was himself
Pike’s intention to elevate Pitchlynn to the 33° but
a Freemason, wrote in 1922: “Masonic influence was gradually
Pitchlynn passed away before that could take place,
3
developed until it became a real power for constructive good….
and Pike conducted his Masonic funeral.
Masons and Masonic support have done many valuable things for the
JOHN JUMPER SEMINOLES CHIEF Indian[s]…though it is largely unrecorded, for Masons do not flaunt
their charities.” Through those charities and the bonds of brotherhood,
A Freemason, he was also a member of an Indian
Freemasonry quietly contributed to the transformation of the frontier.
secret society called Moon Order that flourished
among Seminoles before they were relocated west. Martha Davidson is a Washington D.C.-based writer
who contributes frequently to “American Indian.”
Only a limited number were admitted to the order,
which seems to have vanished with Jumper’s death.
California Freemason 15 Fall 2004
MASONIC EDUCATION
Freemasonry
and
Native American Traditions
As presented at the 4th Annual California Masonic Symposium
By Dennis V. Chornenky
T
here have been many that Native Americans practiced teachings only to the initiate.
legends and myths Freemasonry prior to the There is now record of many
regarding Native advent of European settlers, it such societies, though there
American traditions and their is worthwhile to examine the were likely many more. Some
similarity to Freemasonry. notable parallels and similarities of the societies have dozens of
Since North American tribes between Masonic and Native levels of initiation, or degrees.
did not employ writing systems American initiatic structures Membership in certain societies
to document the precise and rites. was said to give great powers to
manner and meaning of their Most initiatic rites in Native the initiates, in some cases even
rites, and Western interpretation American traditions have been the ability to will death upon
of Native American traditions taking place in what is generally anyone.
has been poorly informed, many referred to as secret societies, Among the tribes of the Great
fantastic and dubious claims or dancing societies. They are Plains there were war societies
and assertions have been made secret in the same way that in which advancement through
regarding the Freemasonry of Freemasonry is, not by seeking the various degrees depended
the Indian. to conceal their existence, on age, demonstrated courage,
While it is absurd to claim but by revealing their secret and other attainments.
Book
Symbols of Freemasonry
Daniel Beresniak
Assouline
By Dennis V. Chornenky
Reviews
Freemasonry
A Journey Through Ritual and Symbol
W. Kirk MacNulty
Thames & Hudson, Inc.
By Adam Kendall
Providing Relief
O N T H E N E W F RO N T I E R
By Allen B. Gresham, PGM
C
alifornia Master Masons founded the Masonic
Homes of California over 100 years ago to provide
organized relief to our widows and orphans.
Inspired by brotherly love, they built magnificent
and sound buildings to last centuries and provide a home for
our fraternal family.
Today, in residential and community-based programs, the
membership currently over the age of 70.
Masonic Homes cares for seniors and children in the name
We predominately fit a middle income profile, which
of every Mason in California—past, present, and future. We
typically means we have fewer choices regarding our
continually strive for excellence in all that we do to ensure
long-term care and are in need of affordable services and
that our services are delivered in a manner befitting our
programs. The majority of us would prefer to age in our own
founding ideals.
home or home community as long as possible.
Masonic Homes focuses on future Middle-aged Masons are members of the “sandwich
In response to the changing needs of our membership generation” and are often coping with age-related issues
and society, the programs and services of the Masonic with our parents while raising and educating our children.
Homes have evolved over the years while the commitment to The majority of those over the age of 60 planned
providing relief has remained unwavering. responsibly for retirement yet many still find themselves
Some come to the Masonic Homes because they have no without the resources necessary to live out their lives with
other place to turn; others come to the Homes because they dignity and self-sufficiency. The financial resources that
choose to retire in a community of residents with common would have been sufficient to provide for them into their 70s
ideals; no matter why they come they are treated with can run out as they enter their 80s, 90s, and beyond—just at
dignity, respect, and fraternal affection once they are here. the time that their need for assistance is greater than ever.
We maintain responsive services and programs by To further complicate the picture, our society is in a time
focusing on the issues and challenges faced by our of economic uncertainty with long-held investments often
membership. losing some or much of their value.
In planning for our future, we consider the many Our elderly widows are the most vulnerable members
characteristics of our fraternal constituents. We are aging of our fraternal family. Nationally, elderly widows are three
in unprecedented numbers—with over 50 percent of our times more likely to live in poverty and isolation than their
male counterparts. Our own survey their children and their aging parents. of today’s generation.
showed that the widowed respondents For the past two years, the Board In recent years, our investments,
were significantly less affluent than of Trustees and staff of the Masonic while outperforming the industry,
their Masonic counterparts. Homes of California have been suffered reductions in value consistent
It is an unfortunate fact that the with general market conditions. Further
constituents most likely to need challenging our economic future is the
The Masonic Homes of
services are also the most likely to be health care inflationary rate, which is
disconnected from the fraternity. Many California is, and always 2.5 times that of general inflation. This
have not been able to attend lodge for will be, the safety net for makes it that much more difficult for
years—in the meantime their lodge may the earnings from investments to keep
those with no other
have consolidated—and as a result, pace with increases in health care costs.
they and/or their widows can lose touch options or resources. From our planning process, we have
with their fraternal support system just identified three ways to respond to the
at the time they may need it most. engaged in a collaborative strategic projected funding shortfalls:
planning process to address these Philanthropy—at the same time
Responding to Our Needs
issues. Our planning has included it is aging, the overall membership
and Challenges
extensive research into trends in is also shrinking. As a result, we are
The Masonic Homes of California
aging services and the needs of our in the middle of demand cycle that
is, and always will be, the safety net
membership. Particularly informative is disproportionate to our resources.
for those with no other options or
and helpful were our discussions with Proceeds from the Annual Fund now
resources. Our primary consideration
representatives from other Masonic directly support the Masonic Outreach
is to define a strategic direction that
Homes across the country in which we Services (MOS) program. These
will safeguard and extend our ability to
explored ways to protect and further philanthropic dollars, as important as
serve those in need.
our mission and make the best use of they are, represent only a small portion
When the Homes were founded, the
the resources entrusted to our care. of our total operating budget. Even with
average life expectancy was 49; today it
projected increases in charitable giving,
is 77. With this has come a range of age- Financial Realities
we recognized that philanthropy alone
related issues unimaginable at the time Currently, the Masonic Homes
is insufficient to address the scope of
of our founding. When faced with these of California relies heavily on our
our economic challenges.
realities, we have come to recognize investments to fund operations. We
Expense Reduction—for the past
that need today is much broader than operate under spending guidelines that
few years, we have embarked on a
strictly economic. Further, we have hedge against inflation and protect our
comprehensive operational review
recognized that we must do more to resources for future generations, while
to improve the quality and cost
help our middle-aged Masons who are funding our charitable model of care
effectiveness of our care. In this regard
facing the dual pressures of caring for and responding to the emerging needs
Faces of Masonry
F
or Michael Allen, Masonry has truly made him a Michael. His brother Stephen and brother-in-law Sean are
better man. “Freemasonry not only exposed me to both Masons as well as several of his life-long friends.
the mysteries and wisdom handed down throughout
Michael, 37, lives in San Diego with his wife and two
the ages,” he says “it gives me access to many patriots of
children. He has traveled extensively throughout Europe, South
freedom who are honorable and free-speaking men who
East Asia, and North America, and has most enjoyed meeting
are willing to share their wisdom. Association with all these
fellow Masons abroad. “If I had to describe what the perfect
faith-based, hope-filled, charitable Freemasons has made me
wave and experiencing the intimation degrees of Freemasonry
a better man!” Michael is the current master of Point Loma
are like, I would have to say it is a mystical thing,” says
Lodge No. 620 in San Diego and a past master of S.W.
Michael. “Something I will never forget.”
Hackett Lodge No. 574 in San Diego.