Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
ScienceDirect
Procedia CIRP 42 (2016) 412 – 417
18th CIRP Conference on Electro Physical and Chemical Machining (ISEM XVIII)
Abstract
During the process of micro electrochemical machining (Micro ECM) of metallic alloys, insoluble electrolytic products restrict the depth of
micro holes with high aspect ratio. The selection and optimization of composite electrolyte are researched to dissolve and remove electrolytic
products smoothly. Composite electrolyte containing neutral salt and complexing agents is adopted, in which the ligands are utilized to generate
soluble products with metal ions. To optimize the electrolyte constituent, products deposition on electrode surface, inlet diameter, material
removal rate (MRR) and ratio of removal rate to current (MRC) are taken as evaluation criterions. Micro ECM experiments on stainless steel
304 (SS304) are carried out. The electrolyte which contains 1.0 mol/L NaNO3 and 0.01 mol/L sodium citrate is selected as optimal constituent.
Micro holes with diameter of 160~190 μm are achieved on SS304 with 0.5 mm thickness. Experimental results show that the MRR of micro
holes with above electrolyte is increased by 35%. Meanwhile, the composite electrolyte maintains its good machining localization and being
eco-friendly. No electrolytic products are deposited on the surface of the tool electrode or workpiece. As a result, both machining efficiency
and stability are improved by using the composite electrolyte.
© 2016
2016 The
The Authors.
Authors.Published
PublishedbybyElsevier
ElsevierB.V.
B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of 18th CIRP Conference on Electro Physical and Chemical Machining (ISEM
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
XVIII).
Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of 18th CIRP Conference on Electro Physical and Chemical Machining
(ISEM XVIII)
Keywords: Micro ECM; electrolyte; SS304; complexing agents; sodium citrate.
2212-8271 © 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of 18th CIRP Conference on Electro Physical and Chemical Machining (ISEM XVIII)
doi:10.1016/j.procir.2016.02.223
Liu Guodong et al. / Procedia CIRP 42 (2016) 412 – 417 413
H atoms on amino are partially ionized and mixed clathrate As shown in Fig. 3. Inlet diameter reflects the stray
could be generated with OH-. The structure of complexone is corrosion with the electrode feeding, namely the machining
shown as Fig. 2c. The O atoms on both N atoms and –COO-in localization. Increase rate of material removal rate (IRMRR) is
the structure could participate in complexing reaction. used, whose physical meaning is the increase coefficient of
Therefore, its complexing ability is very strong. And stable MRR with complexing agents (with L) compared to MRR
chelates could be generated. with pure primary electrolyte (without L). Its expression is
shown as equation (5). As a result, both MRR and IRMRR
reflect the machining efficiency. The largest feed rate reflects
process stability of ECM process. In other words, the more
Fig. 2. Chemical structural formula of three kinds of ligands stable of ECM process, the larger feed rate could be reached
under the same condition.
Considering the properties and complexing ability. The MRR with L - MRR without L
IR MRR = u 100% (5)
complexing agents are preliminary screened in the above MRR without L
analysis. However. The electrochemical reaction and Electrolytic products in inter-electrode gap would
influence factors in ECM are very complicated. So the deposit on the electrode surface and the side wall of holes,
selection of electrolyte constituent must refer to the which adversely influence the process stability of ECM. The
experimental results. products deposition condition on electrode surface can
reflect process stability and surface quality of the workpiece.
3. Selection and optimization method of composite Meanwhile, the entrance circular degree and contour shape
electrolyte for Micro ECM of micro holes present shape accuracy. In order to study the
material removal of workpiece under a certain current
As for the selection and optimization of composite conditions, we define the ratio of removal rate to current
electrolyte for Micro ECM, the evaluation criterions for good (MRC) to reflect the match performance of materials with
machining performance are proposed combined with electrolyte. In brief, MRC is the MRR of workpiece under
experimental results. The optimal electrolyte is gained by certain current of 1 A, whose expression is shown as
three steps as selecting the primary electrolyte, optimizing equation (6). The current I is measured by the power supply
concentration and selecting the complexing agents. The automatically. Its physical meaning is the amount of energy
schematic diagram of selection and optimization for which consumes for material removal in ECM process. In
composite electrolyte constituent is shown in Fig. 3. other words, the larger MRC value under the same
conditions, better match performance of materials with
electrolyte. Current efficiency and machining efficiency are
improved with high MRC value.
MRR
MRC= (6)
I
Considering the thickness of workpiece and the aspect experiments. As for complexing agents with polyhydroxy acid
ratio of holes, the target dimension of micro hole is selected group, sodium citrate (Na3Cit), sodium tartrate (Na2Tart) and
as inlet diameter of 160~190 μm. The relationship between sodium gluconate (NaGlu) are the representatives.
MRR, inlet diameter with feed rate is shown in Fig. 4. Triethanolamine (Tea) which contains alcamines group is
chosen as complexing agents. Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid
disodium (EDTANa2) is selected as a kind of complexone.
Above complexing agents react with Fe3+, Fe2+ and Ni2+
from SS304. Different clathrates are generated and the
stability of them is various. Consequently, hydroxide
participate dissolving capacity of them is various. Under the
condition of PH = 7, taking Fe(OH)3 dissolution as an
example, the competition coefficient logarithm lgKj is shown
in table 2.
Table 2. Competition coefficient logarithm lgKj value of above complexing
agents for Fe(OH)3[16]
Complexing agents lgKj
Na3Cit -9.6
Fig. 4. Relationship between MRR, inlet diameter with the feed rate Na2Tart -19.1
NaGlu -26.0
MRR achieved in ECM experiments with NaNO3 and Tea -16.8
NaClO3 solution as electrolyte are almost equivalent (about
EDTANa2 -11.4
7.5×10-4mm3/s). The inlet diameter range of holes with
NaNO3 is 157 ~ 218 μm, which meet the demand of the target.
The corresponding diameter of NaClO3 is 208 ~ 249 μm. Utilizing 1.0 mol/L NaNO3 with 0.01 mol/L above
MRR reached with NaCl as electrolyte is larger than above complexing agents, ECM experiments of micro holes are
(13.5×10-4mm3/s). However, the inlet diameter is larger than carried out. Experimental parameters are shown in table 1.
320 μm. Utilizing the evaluation criterions of primary The case with no additive and adding H2SO4 (PH = 5) is set as
electrolyte, NaNO3 solution is selected as the primary comparison experiments.
electrolyte in later ECM experiments. Inlet diameter and IRMRR with different composite
The relationship of inlet diameter with feed rate using electrolyte are shown in Fig. 6. IRMRR with EDTANa2 and Tea
different concentrations of NaNO3 solution is shown in Fig. 5. in the electrolyte is increased by 22% and 10%, respectively.
The largest feed rate reaches 15μm/s with electrolyte The corresponding range of inlet diameter is 200 ~ 215 μm.
concentrations of 1.5 mol/L. But the corresponding inlet IRMRR with Na3Cit, Na2Tart and NaGlu in electrolyte
diameter is larger than 195 μm. The largest feed rate with 0.25 increased by 35%, 34% and 43%, respectively. The
and 0.5 mol/L NaNO3 are lower (<7 μm/s), namely, the corresponding range of inlet diameter is 178 ~ 195 μm. It
corresponding process stability are worse. Inlet diameter of demonstrates that the machining efficiency improved
1.0 mol/L NaNO3 is in the range of 169 ~ 215 μm and the significantly with complexing agents with Na3Cit, Na2Tart
largest feed speed is 12 μm/s, which meet the demand of the and NaGlu in electrolyte (>34%). And the inlet diameter
target. Taking into account the evaluation criterions of meets the demand of the target. The composite electrolyte
primary electrolyte concentration, the optimal electrolyte with these three complexing agents have good machining
concentration of NaNO3 solution is 1.0 mol/L. performance.
7b show the products deposition of the entrance and exit of is the best. So composite electrolyte with Na3Cit have good
the hole respectively. And Fig.7c shows the state of the machining performance.
electrode surface. There are some electrolytic products.
and shape accuracy. performance of ECM for micro holes with high aspect ratio is
The complexing capable of EDTANa2 is very strong significantly improved.
(lgKj=-11.4). So the removal of insoluble electrolytic products
could be achieved smoothly. Furthermore, the structure of Acknowledgements
generated chelate is stable and its adhering effect is weak. So
there are no products on the electrode and workpiece surface. This research is supported by National Natural Science
The molecular volume of the chelate generated by EDTA2- Foundation of China (Grant No. 51275255) and Digital
ligand and metal ions is large, which causes slower diffusion Electrochemical Machining Key Lab of Jiang Su Province
rate in electrolyte. It results in the concentration polarization. (Changzhou Institute of Technology) Open Foundation (Grant
Finally machining efficiency and process stability are
No. KFJJ2004005).
deteriorated. Therefore it results in lower IRMRR (10%) and
poor process stability.
References
It is verified that complexing ability is an important
factor for selecting complexing agents according to the [1] K.P. Rajurkar, M. M. Sundaram. et al. 2013. Review of Electrochemical
experimental results. But the structural properties of ligand and Electrodischarge Machining, The17th CIRP Conference on Electro
(e.g. Na2Tart), surface adhering effect of the generated Physical and Chemical Machining (ISEM), p. 13.
clathrate (e.g. Tea), and the molecular volume (e.g. EDTANa2) [2] M. Sen, H.S. Shan. 2005. A review of electrochemical macro- to micro-
should be taken into account. So experimental verification is hole drilling processes. International Journal of Machine Tools &
Manufacture, p. 137.
necessary based on the theoretical analysis when select the [3] Yuang-Cherng Chiou, Rong-Tsong Lee. 2012. Fabrication of high aspect
optimal composite electrolyte constituent. ratio micro-rod using a novel electrochemical micro-machining method.
Precision Engineering, p. 193.
5. Conclusion [4] Ma Xiaoyu, Li Yong, Lv Shanjin. 2009. Influence of electrolytic
products in machining gap on micro ECM. Advanced Materials
Research, p. 388.
Based on the analysis of the reaction mechanism with
[5] Wang Minghuan, Zhu Di. Xu Huiyu. 2006. Use of Micro-helix Electrodes
complexing agents in ECM, the experiments of micro holes in Improving Performance of Micro-ECM. Mechanical Science And
on SS304 are carried out. Combined with the experimental Technology, p. 349. (in Chinese)
results, the electrolyte constituent is selected and optimized. [6] S.H. Ahn, S.H. Ryu, D.Choi. 2006. Electro-chemical micro drilling using
Finally, the reaction characteristic and experimental ultra short pulses. Precision Engineering, p. 348.
phenomena are discussed. The main conclusions can be [7] Liu Yong, Zhu Di, Zeng Yongbin.et.al. 2010. Experimental Investigation
obtained as follows: on Complex Structures Machining by Electrochemical Micromachining
Technology. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics, p. 579.
x Composite electrolyte containing neutral salt solution and [8] Ma Xiaoyu. 2010. Research on Fundamental Techniques of Micro ECM
complexing agents is adopted. The complexing agents in for Array Hole Fabrication. doctoral dissertation. Tsinghua university,
electrolyte compete for metal ions to dissolve the insoluble p. 102.
electrolytic products. It is verified to be effective to [9] Wang Minghuan et al. 2009. Fabrication of multiple electrodes and their
applicationfor micro-holes array in ECM. Int J Adv Manuf Technol, p. 42.
increase the machining depth of micro holes in ECM.
[10] Chen Hui, Wang Yukui, Wang Zhenlong. et al 2011. Effects of
x The selection and optimization of composite electrolyte Complexing Agent on Electrochemical Micro Machining of Stainless
constituent are employed for good performance in ECM. Steel. American Journal of Nanotechnology, p. 100.
Products deposition on the electrode surface, inlet diameter, [11] S. H. Ryu. 2009. Micro fabrication by electrochemical process in citric
MRR, MRC are taken as evaluation criterions. The acid electrolyte, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, p. 2831.
[12] B. Bhattacharyya, S. Mitra, A.K. Boro. 2002. Electrochemical machining:
machining accuracy, efficiency and process stability are
new possibilities for micromachining. Robotics and Computer Integrated
overall considered. Consequently, the optimal composite Manufacturing, p. 284.
electrolyte constituent is obtained. [13] Kuang Wenhuan. 1983. Chemical equilibrium and the insoluble
x The composite electrolyte used for SS304 is optimized as electrolyte dissolution. Chinese Journal of Chemical Education, p. 10.
1.0 mol/LNaNO3 + 0.01 mol/L sodium citrate. MRR of [14] Kong QuancunˈLi YongˈLiu Guodong. et al. 2015. Three-electrode
pulse power supply with inter-pulse outputs for micro ECM. J Tsinghua
ECM with electrolyte containing Na3Cit is increased by
Univ (Sci & Techol), p. 268. (in Chinese)
35% compared to pure NaNO3 and MRC increases by 2 [15] Kong Quancun, Liu Guodong, Li Yong et al. Preparation of hollow
times. No products are deposited on the surface of the electrode used for micro ECM[J]. Optics and Precision Engineering.
electrode and workpiece. 2015.10(23)79-86. (in Chinese)
Under the precondition for maintaining good machining [16] Fang Jingli. Theory & Application of Coordination Compounds in
Electroplating. Beijing: Chemical Industry Press, 2008. (in Chinese).
localization and being eco-friendly, the machining