Professional Documents
Culture Documents
21st Century is a period of time when the globalization process has reached its apogee.
All over the world exists thousands diverse international political and economic
organizations and unions. According to Garret (2000, pp. 941-991) the most important
cause of globalization is related to the international market integration. The major
impact on this process has had the appearance of the European Union by
Maastricht Treaty in 1993. Peace, prosperity, stability, economic and social
progress towards nations and individuals were the main objectives of the EU
creation (BBC, 2002; Europa, n.d a). After twenty years of cooperation different
disputes about the benefits and disadvantages of the EU membership for a nation
came up. Based on history, values and aims of the union this essay will examine both
points of view and will try to make an overall conclusion.
1
MAIN BODY
2
Advantages
According to Europa (n.d b) the EU was set up with the purpose of ending
destructing and bloody wars between neighbors which has culminated in two
world wars. Grabtee (2007) assumes that European history could be truly called a
military history of war and territory dividing, because of centuries-long series of
wars between all countries. He stated that multilateralism which had started to
develop after the beginning of function of Coal and Steel Committee has brought
the never seen peace in Europe. The new political path lead to the total absence of
war for all Member states and is attracting all European countries to join the Union till
nowadays. I believe that it is one of the major advantages to a nation to align the
EU, because it has power to settle all civil and international disputes in a peaceful
way.
One of the main objectives of the European Union was the development of integrated
economy and single economical area. Europa (n.d. d) describing the single market
and related policies stated that all borders between Member countries disappeared
allowing the freely movement for goods, people and capital in order to stimulate
industrial and economical extending within a large area. Grabtree (2007)
researching the EU operation has found that the introduced unique currency called
Euro has an advantageous impact on companies function and on economy in
general. He stated that transfers became easier, costs more transparent and
prices on goods became averaged in the whole union. Such strengthening of the
economy brought stability and bright future. Moreover, because all economies
became unified, countries gained the ability as a common body to overcome
financial crises and agree on issues that mainly affect the economy. The Europa
(n.d. e) also made a suggestion that such strengthening of economy made possible the
financial help for poor regions that require the raising of life standard. Because of
this reasons it is beneficial to a country to join the union.
Another beneficial cause for a nation to become the member of EU is the ability of
multinational union to fight against global issues. Nowadays world society meets
thousands of different global problems that need to be overcome and there are no
countries that are able to deal with these issues by themselves. The official site of
the European Union - Europa (n.d f) affirms that EU has some of the highest
environmental standards as like protection of nature, more efficiently using of
national resources and the most magnetic desire to make Europe green.
Moreover, two main environmental issues that countries in general meet all over the
world are pollution and shortage of water. And EU is one of the biggest international
organizations that fights against all kind of pollution and seriously work in the sphere of
correct water utilization. In other words, it is obvious that in order to overcome
environmental problems it is necessary to join the international union. Another huge
issue that world society fights for long time is war against terrorism. According to
France Diplomatie (2010) EU has two main groups that specifically fight contra
3
terrorism: technical and diplomatic, and other organizations as like Europol that
general provide security but have jurisdiction it the area of terrorism
confrontation.
Disadvantages
One of the biggest disadvantages for a nation to join the EU is loss of sovereignty.
Every year European Union tries to implement new policies and laws related to
enlargement of the integration process. New rules and changings in social,
political and economic life clearly lead to the loss of sovereignty. Will Huton (2007)
in his article about British loss of sovereignty said that it is the well-known process for
Britain. He stated that in the last few years 20% of Britain leading companies,
almost all investment banks and lots of industry companies have become
foreign-owned. This is the reason why nearly all of British newspapers treat the EU
reform as a mortal threat to independence and sovereignty. If more than 50% of
businesses are owned by foreign companies and individuals the market definitely
cannot be treated as a national one. Stephen Mulvey (2005) the correspondent of the
BBC news, have written an article about Dutch people attitude towards the elections for
the Common Constitution for Europe. The head of the Better Europe foundation and a
former MEP Michen van Hulten (n.d, quoted in Mulvey 2005) said about elections that
simple people complain about the elite elections and no permission for public to
participate in them. Because only politicians are more frequently allowed to participate
in voting and making really important decisions it is believed to be undemocratic and
gives the strong reason not to become the member of the EU.
4
Conclusion
Concluding, my personal point of view is that even there are strong disadvantages for a
separate country to become a member of the European Union, advantages that could
be brought due to integration and future encouraging abeyance deserves the respect
and risky step. According to Crabtree (2007) the future of the EU is by all means
beneficial because the Europe capacity to function as a union is much higher in
comparison with capability of the small separate country.
Based on history, values and objectives of the EU this essay has investigated the
advantages and disadvantages of membership for a nation giving overall conclusion.