You are on page 1of 20

HEALTH EDUCATION RESEARCH

Schools as centers for health educational initiatives,


health behavior research and risk behavior for dengue
infection in school children and community members:
a systematic review

Esteban E. Dı́az-González1,2, Rogelio Danis-Lozano3 and Gonzalo


Pe~naloza-Jimenez1*
1
Centro de Investigación y Estudios Avanzados del Instituto Politécnico Nacional, Unidad Monterrey, Via del
Conocimiento, 201, Parque PIIT, Apodaca, Nuevo León, 66628, México, 2Centro de Investigación y Desarrollo en Ciencias
de la Salud Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León, Av. Carlos Canseco esquina con Av. Gonzalitos s/n, Colonia Mitras
Centro, Monterrey, Nuevo León, 64460, México and 3Centro Regional de Investigación en Salud Pública, Instituto Nacional
de Salud Pública, 19 Poniente entre 4 y 6 Norte, Centro, Tapachula, Chiapas, 30700, México
*Correspondence to: G. Pe~ naloza-Jimenez. E-mail: g.pjimenez@cinvestav.mx
Received on 26 January 2020; editorial decision on 24 May 2020; accepted on 27 May 2020

Abstract and new approaches for health behavior research


are needed. Inasmuch as, schools are important
Dengue virus is the main arboviral disease trans- places for gathering community members, and
mitted by Aedes mosquitoes and affects mainly students can serve as an essential link between
school-aged children and teens. Many methods educative interventions and the community.
have been developed for dengue control, includ-
ing health education strategies for elementary
and high school students. The objective of this Introduction
study is to provide an update on the status of
health education on dengue in schools and pro- Aedes aegypti has become the most important arbo-
vide new perspectives on health behavior re- viral vector worldwide for transmitting febrile dis-
search in order to reduce the proliferation of eases, such as dengue, Zika and chikungunya. The
mosquitoes and spread of arboviral diseases distribution of this species is cosmopolitan; it is
among school-aged children and other commu- mainly found in tropical and subtropical regions of
nity members. A systematic review about health the world, and it breeds mostly in human dwellings
educational initiatives was carried out. This re- [1]. Though the chikungunya, Zika and yellow fever
search discusses the effectiveness of these strat- viruses are still causing significant outbreaks in
egies in educating students about dengue disease many regions of the world, dengue virus is still the
and mosquito control and how the school is rele- most important arbovirus, numbering almost 400
vant for community-based participation in re- million cases per year worldwide [2]. The health
search on dengue education. The study found complications of these arboviruses have been wide-
that employing ludic strategies and directly ly described, such as the hemorrhagic manifesta-
involving children in mosquito control in their tions and organic failure caused by severe dengue
households have been the most attractive and and yellow fever viruses, the long-lasting arthralgia
effective strategies for dengue education in chil- caused by chikungunya and the congenital malfor-
dren and teens. However, the sustainability of mations in newborns caused by pregnant women
protective behaviors has been poorly evaluated, becoming infected with Zika [3].

C The Author(s) 2020. Published by Oxford University Press. All rights reserved.
V doi:10.1093/her/cyaa019
For permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oup.com
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

Mosquito control is the unique strategy employed


Materials and methods
in order to prevent larger epidemics of these arbovi-
ruses. Although it is true that some dengue vaccines
A systematic review was carried out following the
have been tested in human subjects, like CYD-TDV
methodology described by Grant and Booth [10].
[4] and TAK-003 [5] vaccines, the first has been
Firstly, a scoping review was developed using the
partially effective (64.7%) and the second has not
Google Scholar, PubMed and Scielo databases
been approved for all age groups and it is not univer-
using the terms ‘dengue’, ‘mosquito’, ‘Aedes
sal. Chemical controls, along with the physical dis-
aegypti’, ‘education’, ‘school’ and ‘children’ to-
posal of water containers, are the most popular
gether. The search included manuscripts written in
strategies used for mosquito control. However, in-
English, Spanish and Portuguese. The manuscripts
secticide resistance to pyrethroids and organophos-
written in other languages and those without an
phates has been largely documented, and the vector
English-language abstract were discarded. An initial
populations are still abundant during rainy seasons,
analysis was conducted by simply reading the titles
thereby maintaining the arboviral epidemics in trop-
and abstracts of the manuscripts, and then the exclu-
ical and subtropical countries [6].
sion criteria were applied if (i) they did not include
Health promotion and education for dengue con-
elementary or high schools as part of the study and
trol has been included by Ministries of Health as an
important component of integrated vector manage- (ii) they were studies developed with undergraduate
ment [7]. Reaching communities through education- students of universities. After the first round of se-
al activities that directly involve the population in lection, a further review of selected peer-reviewed
vector control activities is ideal because the efforts publications was carried out, and the inclusion crite-
to abate mosquito populations are divided between ria for the studies were based on the following: (i)
many hands. The importance of school in teaching knowledge, attitude and practice (KAP) studies on
knowledge about dengue and mosquito vector is cru- dengue in schools and/or (ii) educative interventions
cial because when it does not exist, it could be a fac- about dengue and/or A. aegypti mosquito control in
tor in non-participation [8]. The goal is to stop schools.
mosquito reproduction through community cooper- Finally, the studies selected for review were indi-
ation by eliminating the containers in which mosqui- vidually analyzed according to the study type, the
toes breed and by killing the adults. To achieve this, data collection and the kind of analysis. The publica-
implementing educative strategies in communities, tions were assigned to one of three categories after a
especially in schools, has been proposed because general review of their contents: (i) exploratory stud-
children and teens (6–17 years old) are the age group ies in students through KAP surveys, (ii) educative
with the highest risk of being infected by dengue interventions in students and (iii) students being part
virus [9]. Moreover, schools are important places for of community-based interventions. The first group of
engaging people around a common purpose, such as studies only seeks to assess the general knowledge,
health promotion and disease prevention. attitudes, perceived risks, self-efficacy and/or practi-
The aim of this review is to provide an update on ces of dengue disease and the control of A. aegypti.
the status of health education on dengue in schools The second group of studies designed an educational
discussing the effectiveness of the educative inter- proposal aimed to teach students about dengue fever,
ventions in the schools and their communities. Also, severe dengue and/or strategies to control A. aegypti.
new perspectives on health behavior research are The third group of studies consisted of community-
discussed in order to reduce the amount of risky con- based interventions that involved schools as a meet-
duct that leads to the proliferation of mosquitoes and ing point for community education and/or students
spread of arboviral diseases among school-aged engaging with the community for the purposes of
children and other community members. dengue education and control.

2 of 20
Schools as centers for health educational initiatives

investigations were carried out in South and


Results Southeast Asia (31–50%) and South America (25–
32%), but in the case of community-based interven-
The literature search produced 6611 results, includ- tions, 37% of the studies were based in North and
ing duplicates generated by the search tools. After Central America and the Caribbean.
the first screening (reading only the abstracts and
titles and applying the exclusion criteria), 82 studies
Exploratory studies of knowledge,
were found to be potentially relevant for meeting
attitudes and practices about dengue in
the objectives of our review. Then, after a second
students
screening procedure was carried out (reading each
publication and applying the inclusion criteria), the A total of 12 studies (Table 1) were conducted to
final number of studies included was 52 (Fig. 1). evaluate the status of knowledge, attitudes and prac-
From these studies published from 1992 to 2019, 41 tices about dengue among students in selected com-
manuscripts were written in English, 10 in Spanish, munities in South and Southeast Asia [11–16], the
and one in Portuguese. The geographic distribution Middle East [17–19] and South America [20–22]
of the studies is shown in Fig. 2. Most of the (Fig. 2). Overall, students’ knowledge levels ranged

Fig. 1. Methodology of review about health education interventions for dengue prevention in schools.

3 of 20
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

Fig. 2. Geographic distribution of the 52 studies included for this revision about health education interventions for dengue preven-
tion in schools.

from satisfactory to poor, considering test scores of identification of breeding sites and other control
85–100% as good, 60–85% as satisfactory and methods. Regarding attitudes, only seven studies
<60% as poor (Fig. 3). Despite most of the children reported on this component, and the attitude levels
involved in the investigations knowing that mosqui- ranged from satisfactory to good in four studies,
toes can spread the disease and being aware of the while the rest were considered poor based on the
primary symptoms of dengue, such as fever and previous categorization (Fig. 3). In general, students
joint pain, they had difficulties with abstract con- considered dengue to be an important public health
cepts such as mosquito reproduction, the problem and thought that mosquitoes should be

4 of 20
Schools as centers for health educational initiatives

Fig. 3. (A) Results of KAP studies performed in South and Southeast Asia, Middle East and Central, Caribbean and North America.
The test scores of 85–100% were considered as good, 60–85% as satisfactory, and <60% as poor. (B) Effectiveness of health educa-
tion interventions for dengue prevention in schools through a KAP assessment. The graphic compares traditional (lectures, printed
materials, manual exercises) and innovative (ludic activities, practical activities) interventions and considered any significant increase
of KAP scores (graphic considered only 19 of 21 studies because the other two studies did not report KAP scores).

controlled; however, some of them believed that the performed in schools where children and teens
government must take action to control dengue. gather and spend a considerable part of the day. A
Therefore, they did not consider themselves as an total of 21 studies met the inclusion criteria and
element of vector control activities. Finally, the were classified as follows: 16 were quasi-
practice levels of children were only reported in experimental pretest–posttest designs [23–38], two
eight studies, and they ranged from satisfactory to were field trials [39, 40], one was a workshop [41],
poor according to the same categorization (Fig. 3). one was a case study [42], and one was debriefing
Most of the students have often effectuated preven- research [43]. Eighteen studies had a semi-
tion activities, such as covering or disposing of quantitative design, while the other three studies
water in containers and verifying the presence of were of a qualitative nature. Only four studies
breeding sites, but usually they remain passive. (quasi-experimental studies) followed a systematic
random sampling of the schools and children, while
Educational interventions in schools: the rest used convenience sampling to conduct their
improving knowledge, attitudes and studies (Table II).
practices The quasi-experimental studies had the purpose
As mentioned above, focusing on children and teens of carrying out an educational intervention on stu-
as the main targets of health education interventions dents and assessing its effectiveness in terms of
has been suggested because they are in the age affecting knowledge, attitudes and practices related
group at the greatest risk of dengue infection. To to dengue disease and control. The interventions
achieve this, educational interventions have been consisted mainly of government campaigns,

5 of 20
Table I. Summary of exploratory studies about knowledge, attitudes and practices related to dengue disease and control
No. Study Country Sampling and sample size Knowledge Attitudes Practices

6 of 20
1 Ibrahim et al., 2009 Saudi Arabia Multistage, stratified, random Student score: 10.08 80% considered dengue as Student score: 8.23
sample. Teacher score: 12.62 important public health Teacher score: 8.55
2693 students (15–17 years old), Range 0-30 problem Range 0–12
356 teachers and 115 90% agreed eliminate stag-
supervisors nant water
2 Trindade-Bezerra Brazil Convenience. Fourteen elemen- 67.1% dengue transmission None None
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

et al., 2011 [20] tary schools, 700 students 88.4% main symptoms
(11–15 years old) 82.7% mosquito breeding site
3 Suwanbamrung et al., Thailand Convenience. Five elementary Only five answered correctly None None
2013 [11] schools, 306 students by more than 80% of
(10–12 years old) questionnaire
4 Habibullah and India Convenience. Fourteen second- 59% had knowledge about 66% believed dengue infec- 21% had good practices to
Ashraf, 2013 [12] ary schools, 1320 students dengue fever and its tion could be controlled control A. aegypti
(15–16 years old) control methods 33% thought mosquito elim-
ination is a good method to
the control disease
5 Chanyasanha et al., Thailand Convenience. Two secondary 18% had good level of over- None 4.7% had good level of pre-
2013 [13] schools, 300 students (12–16 all dengue hemorrhagic ventive behavior
years old) fever knowledge
6 Dimbulagedara et al., Sri Lanka Convenience. Four schools, 400 54.7% had overall knowledge 62.8% showed an unwilling- 51.2% verify the presence of
2014 [14] students (14–18 years old) on prevention of dengue ness to implement prevent- breeding places
47.2% identified A. aegypti as ive measures
vector
7 Kalra et al., 2014 [15] India Convenience. Four schools, 500 Public students score: 28.17 None None
students (13–15 years old) Private students score: 31.45
Range 0–60
8 Alsheikh et al., 2015 Saudi Arabia Multistage stratified random sam- Poor levels of knowledge 93.2% had good attitudes and 85.5% disposing water
[18] ple. Six secondary schools, (22.6–70%) believed dengue fever 68.6% covering water
742 students (16–20 years old) could be controlled and containers
prevented
78.5% considered they have
an important role in dengue
fever prevention
9 Taran et al., 2016 [16] India Convenience. Four schools, 261 76.2% knew about dengue 53.6% aware of government 51.7% covering water storage
students (12–14 years old) 87.4% knew mosquito breeds program against vector tanks
in stagnant water 87.7% individual protection 33.7% cleanliness measures
(continued)
Table I. Continued
No. Study Country Sampling and sample size Knowledge Attitudes Practices

10 Alhazmi et al., 2016 Saudi Arabia Multistage stratified random 41.1% had a fair and satisfac- 88.1% importance of 70.6% would go to physician
[19] sample. Ten high schools, 362 tory knowledge score conduction of educational if there is a dengue case in
students (14–19 years old) campaign family
86.5% importance of 77.6% empty or cover unused
removing/covering stagnant containers
water
86.5% health education in
family
11 Costa-Roriz et al., Brazil Convenience. One school, 14 86% identified A. aegypti as None None
2017 [21] students (14–15 years old) dengue vector
Poor knowledge of chikun-
gunya and zika (21–43%)
12 Sarmiento-Senior Colombia Convenience. 515 students from Knowledge score: 5.6–7.2 Attitude score: 9.0–9.5 Practice score: 4.3–6.1
et al., 2018 [22] elementary schools (9.3 years Range 0–10 Range 0–10 Range 0–10
old)

Table II. Summary of studies about didactic interventions in schools for improvements in knowledge, attitudes and practices related to dengue disease and control
No. Study Country Sampling and sample size Type of intervention Relevant findings

1 Soto-Hernández Puerto Rico Convenience. Two elemen- Quasi-experimental Teacher training about dengue and mosquito and then the
et al., 1995 [23] tary schools (intervention pretest–posttest teachers educate children using a manual. Increase of know-
and control). 307 students design ledge score (16.6 treated group versus 11.4 control group)
and 8 teachers but this was not reflected in parents
2 Wangroongsarb, Thailand Convenience. Ninety-six Quasi-experimental National program for educative interventions in Thailand.
1997 [24] elementary schools. 371 pretest–posttest Integration of ‘dengue message’ in curriculum, manuals,
teachers design books for children, posters, pamphlets, audiovisual aids.
Program orientation and larval control activities were taught
by teachers and health-staff in 76.7% and 94.4% of students.
However, non-regular learning process, lack of supervision,
poor communication between different organizational staff
and irregular supplies
3 Cordero-Conejo Costa Rica Convenience. Six elementary Workshops Implementation of workshops with participation of school chil-
et al., 2000 [41] schools. 849 students (8–9 dren, with the help of principals, teachers, community lead-
years old) ers and non-government organizations. Educational
activities were carried out, as well as measures of biological
Schools as centers for health educational initiatives

7 of 20
control applied to semi-permanent bodies of water
(continued)
Table II. Continued
No. Study Country Sampling and sample size Type of intervention Relevant findings

8 of 20
4 Lennon and Philippines Convenience. One student (8 Naturalistic descrip- The child could develop a board game related to dengue con-
Coombs, 2002 years old) tive case study trol. Some gaps were observed; however, the study revealed
[42] that a child-centered educational game creation may serve as
a learning tool
5 Madeira et al., Brazil Convenience. One elemen- Quasi-experimental The didactical intervention (theoretical lectures and films)
2002 [31] tary school. 314 students pretest–posttest showed an increase in knowledge, attitudes and practices
(11–12 years old) design related to dengue disease and control
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

6 Vivas and Venezuela Systematic sampling. Nine Quasi-experimental This study used interventional games for dengue learning test-
Guevara, 2003 schools. 621 students (11.8 pretest–posttest ing two intervention groups: (1) games plus theory, (2) only
[32] years old) design theory and (3) control. Significative differences in dengue
knowledge between pre- and post-test observed in Groups 1
and 2, being higher the difference in Group 1. In addition,
the acceptance of the games was high among students
7 Ávila-Montes Honduras Convenience. Four elemen- Field assay A special course with three topics: water, trash and dengue,
et al., 2004 [39] tary schools. 583 students organized in a textbook. In addition, children were involved
(9–10 years old) in theoretical classes and community activities for elimin-
ation of mosquito breeding sites in conjunction with the rest
of community members. The levels of knowledge were
increased in intervention groups of students, teachers and
mothers but the larval indexes (house, recipient and Breteau)
did not show any significant change in intervention groups
8 Lennon and Philippines Convenience. One school Debriefing research A health educational game called the ‘good-bye to dengue
Coombs, 2005 (elementary and high game’ (GBD) was assessed in scholars. Then, a debriefing
[43] school). Eighty-one stu- methodology was performed to obtain the student’s percep-
dents (10–12 years old) tions about dengue from the game, new information learned,
gaps in dengue control skills and improvement areas. The
students liked the game and most of them learned the basic
concepts of dengue prevention and control
9 Lennon and Philippines Stratified random assignment. Quasi-experimental The purpose was to test the effectiveness of the educational
Coombs, 2007 One elementary school. pretest–posttest board game ‘good-bye to dengue game’ for increasing know-
[33] 168 students (11–14 years design ledge, positive attitude beliefs, and self-efficacy for dengue
old) hemorrhagic prevention in adolescents. Two groups were
compared: traditional lecture versus using board games.
Despite lecture was more effective in increasing knowledge
and attitude beliefs, the board game was effective without a
teacher and would be effective as a didactic strategy for
introducing DHF in children
(continued)
Table II. Continued
No. Study Country Sampling and sample size Type of intervention Relevant findings

10 Del Valle- Argentina Convenience. Four elemen- Quasi-experimental Educative workshops in schools about dengue and biological
Combina, 2008 tary schools. 234 students pretest–posttest cycle of vector. Then, students were motivated to look for
[34] (11 years old) design breeding sites in their homes and surroundings. The dengue
knowledge was increased up to 88% after the workshops in
schools
R
11 Jardim et al., 2009 Brazil Convenience. One high Exploratory field trial Educative program that promote the use of EvidengueV a net
[40] school. 115 students (16.2 cover for flowerpot saucers. The program had three stages: a
R
years old) lecture on dengue, delivery of EvidengueV nets and delivery
of an information leaflet regarding sealing containers. The
85.7% of student households that had flowerpot saucers were
R
using EvidengueV nets and their use was maintained for at
least 60 days
12 Ibrahim et al., Saudi Arabia Multistage, stratified, random Quasi-experimental The intervention consisted: (i) 20-min lecture that included in-
2009 sampling. Twenty girls’ pretest–posttest formation about dengue, transmission, symptomatology, pre-
high schools. 2433 students design ventive and control measures, (ii) film an cartoon about how
(15–17 years old), 310 people get infected and methods of prevention and control,
teachers and 70 (iii) spreading of information with family and friends and
supervisors (iv) diffusion of information with CD’s with dengue fever in-
formation, posters and stickers. The knowledge and practice
scores increased after the intervention to fair/satisfactory in
99.8% and 95.4%, respectively. The attitudes increased more
than 90% after the intervention
13 Vesga-Gómez and Colombia Convenience. Four elemen- Quasi-experimental Ludic interventions of 45 min about dengue disease, prevention
Cáceres- tary schools. 612 students pretest–posttest and control. They consisted of workshops, games, songs,
Manrique, 2010 (8–12 years old) design puppets, social dynamics, tales and dramas, all designed by
[36] the authors and a pedagogue. Significative increase of know-
ledge and practices was observed after the intervention (80–
100% in the most relevant items)
14 Suwanbamrung, Thailand Convenience. One Muslim Quasi-experimental The children participated actively in three groups in their com-
2012 [37] school. Fifty-nine students pretest–posttest de- munity: ‘education of dengue learning’, ‘dengue prevention
(7–15 years old) sign (Participatory campaign’ and ‘the recycle garbage bank’. The leader group
Action Research) of children (13) was trained by researchers to perform the
activities while the rest participated as support. These activ-
ities helped children to increase dengue knowledge and
adopt preventive practices such recycling. The larval indices
were considerably reduced in the student’s households
15 Sandeep et al., India Convenience. One high Quasi-experimental A planned-teaching program about dengue was administrated
2014 [38] school. Sixty students (15– pretest–posttest to high school students. The level of good knowledge was
16 years old) design increased from 1.67% to 96.66% and the effectiveness
Schools as centers for health educational initiatives

9 of 20
showed scores of 70.8% after interventions
(continued)
Table II. Continued
No. Study Country Sampling and sample size Type of intervention Relevant findings

16 Torres et al., 2014 Mexico Multistage, stratified, random Quasi-experimental The educative interventions applied in fifth and sixth grades

10 of 20
[25] sampling. Nineteen elem- pretest–posttest consisted in a lecture of 60 min about the importance of stu-
entary schools. 1562 stu- design dents in the self-care of their schools and homes for the den-
dents (10–12 years old) gue prevention through vector control. In addition,
observation in vivo of A. aegypti specimens (eggs, larvae,
pupae and adults) and rounds in school playgrounds and
backyards seeking breeding sites of mosquito. The know-
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

ledge, attitudes and practices were increased after the inter-


vention and the sixth-grade students showed a higher
knowledge than fifth grade students
17 Beinner et al., Brazil Convenience. Two elemen- Quasi-experimental A group of 75 students played the dengue board game (BGG)
2015 [26] tary schools. 136 students pretest–posttest and another group of 59 children received a traditional lec-
(10–13 years old) design ture about dengue. The BGG demonstrated changes in atti-
tudes across all questions except one. Also, showed
increased knowledge about dengue compared with tradition-
al lecture in 12 out of 18 test questions
18 Al-Zurfi et al., Malaysia Convenience. One school. Quasi-experimental The participants were given a lecture by head of community
2015 [27] 204 students (16–17 years pretest–posttest medicine unit to explain about dengue fever using posters
old) design and video exhibition. The knowledge score was significa-
tively increased after the intervention from 11.95 to 12.61
19 Ng et al., 2016 Malaysia Convenience. One high Quasi-experimental The students were given a lecture using Power Point slides
[28] school. Sixty students pretest–posttest about dengue fever and preventive measures. The knowledge
design on dengue fever increased from 50–60% to 80–100%
20 Nasir, 2017 [29] Indonesia Convenience. 21 elementary Quasi-experimental Flipcharts and posters were designed for dengue hemorrhagic
schools. 630 students (10– pretest–posttest fever education and they were delivered for 1 month in class-
11 years old) design rooms. The results showed that posters and flipcharts had 2.4
and 1.5 times to increase dengue hemorrhagic knowledge,
respectively, compared with students who did not receive
any intervention
21 Usman et al., Saudi Arabia Multistage stratified random Quasi-experimental The educational sessions were carried out through lectures with
2018 [30] sampling. 593 students pretest–posttest the help of visual aids like flipcharts and life cycle specimens
from four districts (16.2 design followed by small group discussions. Each participant was
years old) asked to spread this educational message about dengue fever
control to family and friends. The KAP scores were signifi-
catively increased after the educative sessions up to 10.76,
6.16 and 3.85, respectively (total scores: knowledge ¼ 17,
attitude ¼ 8, practices ¼ 5)

DHF, Dengue Hemorrhagic Fever.


Schools as centers for health educational initiatives

lectures, exercises in manuals, films, ludic activities indices were not considered for the evaluation. For
(board games, songs, tales, dramas and puppets), example, the workshops performed in Costa Rican
sharing informative material (pamphlets, aids and elementary schools were limited to educational
posters) and practical activities (seeking out and activities and how the student body can be engaged
controlling breeding sites and identifying larvae, in the control of mosquito larvae in semi-permanent
pupae and adults). These interventions were eval- bodies of water. An evaluation of the outcomes was
uated through a pretest–posttest design using di- conducted through the qualitative description of
verse instruments, such as surveys, in-depth children learning and how they actively participated
interviews and KAP tests. in the control of bodies of water, but KAP scores
The most relevant results observed in these stud- and larval indices were not reported [41].
ies showed that the most effective educative strat-
egies were those that used innovative interventions School and community-based interventions
such as ludic and practical activities or direct in- to control A. aegypti
volvement in the vector control [25, 26, 32–34, 36, A total of 19 community-based studies in which
37]. Besides the increased knowledge, attitudes and schools had a role in educative and/or gathering
practices related to dengue, the children exhibited activities were included in this review. Among
more engagement in the activities in which their them, 11 non-randomized studies [44–54] and four
tasks were looking for and eliminating breeding cluster randomized controlled trials (CRCT) [55–
sites and/or playing games. Though traditional inter- 58] included community-based interventions for
ventions, such as lectures, sharing printed materials dengue control, such as massive communications
and doing exercises from manuals, also helped to in- strategies (TV and radio spot ads), home visits by
crease the KAP scores [17, 23, 25, 27, 29–33, 38], health workers and/or students for health promotion
one study had adverse results using these strategies (dengue education, use of vector control methods,
[24] (Fig. 3). etc.), and/or workshops for dengue education in
Only two field trials were conducted in schools schools, churches, public parks, and/or other places
with the aim of reducing the vector presence in where people gather. In addition, two community-
children’s households. A study carried out in based interventions tested novel strategies for den-
Honduras consisted of teaching children about gue control (the use of copepods and the ‘Little
dengue, water, trash and how to dispose contain- dab’, a technique of cleaning water tanks in order to
ers to prevent A. aegypti from breeding. Then, eliminate mosquito eggs), where the school was
they applied their practical knowledge to elimin- used as a place for training and community mobil-
ate breeding sites in their households with the ization [59, 60]. Finally, the remaining two studies
support of community members. It was observed evaluated the sustainability of two non-random
that the levels of knowledge increased in the chil- community interventions in which the schools also
dren and parents. However, the larval indices did participated [61, 62] (Table III).
not show any substantial change when compared
with the control groups [39]. On the other hand, a
Brazilian study evaluated the use of nets to cover Discussion
flowerpot saucers in students’ households and
observed a reduction in larval indices for at least The most relevant findings of these interventions
60 days [40]. are mentioned in general terms. First, the
The rest of qualitative studies (a workshop, case community-based interventions, which included the
study and debriefing research) centered mainly on diverse strategies previously mentioned, mostly
the qualitative description of the intervention and showed good effectiveness in terms of increased
the outcomes, so KAP tests or measuring larval knowledge and good practices (e.g. cleaning

11 of 20
Table III. Summary of studies where schools formed part of community interventions to control Aedes aegypti
No. Authors Country Description of study Relevant findings

12 of 20
1 Swaddiwudhipong et al., Thailand Dengue education program that included mass media, lec- There was significative reduction of breeding sites in
1992 [44] tures and discussions was provided to health-care person- households after the educative interventions and mos-
nel, government officers, school children, teachers and quito control, however, the larval indexes arose 3 months
people in the community. In addition, education cam- later. While in schools, the average of larval containers
paigns were carried out in communities by health work- was considerably reduced but the presence of water con-
ers accompanied of two school children. Then, larval tainers remained high
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

surveys were conducted in households and schools of


community
2 Winch et al., 2002 [44] Puerto Rico Community-based dengue prevention programs were per- Higher levels of child–parent communication were associ-
formed and consisted of television aids, posters, elemen- ated with higher levels of correct knowledge of A.
tary and pre-school educational programs and a museum aegypti larval habitats, but higher levels of incorrect
visit. The pre-school activities were games, drawings and knowledge of cause of dengue among parents of elemen-
parades described in an activity book, while the elemen- tary school children. In addition, the elementary school
tary school activities were exercises, inside and outside program was associated with a significantly lower
of classrooms, outlined in a dengue pamphlet. The pro- Breteau index. However, there was no evidence that pro-
gram requires that students look for larval habitats at gram activities decreased the number of disposable con-
home and destroy or control them tainers on people’s premises
3 Nam et al., 2004 [59] Vietnam A community program that used the copepod Mesocyclops The use of predacious copepods combined with new water
for larval control of containers that could not be discarded, management practices by nine communes in northern
designed a top-down training using the local authorities, and central Viet Nam helped to control the main dengue
schools and community members as key elements for com- vector mosquito
munity empowerment and engagement. The school host
drama performances to motivate the community for the
use of the copepod for larvae controlling
4 Méndez-Galván y Rivas- México The main of the project was to identify and test appropriate A decline was seen post-intervention across all three ento-
Gutiérrez, 2004 household-based control methods for key A. aegypti-pro- mological indices (house, container and Breteau); a de-
ducing containers and the creation of an education/com- cline that was also seen when only examining the key
munication strategy for the dissemination of highly containers. There was a positive increase in the behavior
specific messages for the key containers. Education cam- scores post-intervention, with a significant increase in the
paigns were addressed to community members (TV and self-report of the behavior for tires (use of lime, 0.6%–
radio spots, home visits) and students of fourth grade 13%) linked with no mosquito breeding in tires
were given messages during school-based activities
5 Luna et al., 2004 [48] Colombia A dengue prevention initiative was developed for social A sample of elementary school students’ homes participat-
mobilization using educative and communications strat- ing in the initiative was visited and the A. aegypti house
egies. One day a week, residents were to seek and des- index was established before and after the intervention.
troy the sites where the A. aegypti mosquito might occur. This procedure was also followed at the schools. In all
On this day, communication and educational actions cases, the number of houses and schools with immature
were used to mobilize and motivate the people. A. aegypti was fewer in the post-intervention evaluation
Innovative printed materials were designed and compared with the pre-intervention survey
(continued)
Table III. Continued
No. Authors Country Description of study Relevant findings

disseminated which resulted in a massive mobilization of


high school students, housekeepers and other publics
6 Fernández et al., 2004 [60] Honduras A large-scale social mobilization and communication plan Around 35% of housewives in the sample were aware of
was developed to promote the ‘Untadita’ (Little dab), an the Untadita method but results also showed a need for
ovicide strategy which consists in the cleaning of the ce- periodical reinforcement in the method that could be pro-
ment tanks with bleach and detergent. School children vided through a school-based intervention or directly
and teachers were given general information on dengue through community-based interventions
and vector control. Each year they received more com-
plete information and helped to develop a special module
on dengue prevention. Children were mobilized to visit
neighbors and provide information on dengue and A.
aegypti
7 Spiegel et al., 2005 [49] Thailand A pilot project was implemented in communities using top- The success of this intervention was evidenced by a signifi-
down and bottom-up approaches. Local administrative cant reduction in both dengue mosquito vector popula-
authorities, including public health and school officials tions and serologically confirmed dengue cases in control
in collaboration with householders, public health volun- areas compared with non-control areas (pre-intervention:
teers and school children were involved. The activities 265.25 versus 217.86 per 100 000 population; post-inter-
included source-reduction campaigns in houses with den- vention: 0 versus 332.23 per 100 000 population). The
gue cases reported and schools attended by children from KAP survey showed that background knowledge on den-
the control area and the use of easy methodologies such gue and its mosquito vectors among householders was
as net covers, copepods and home-made lethal ovitraps moderately high, but knowledge alone did not translate
to control action; dengue did not rank as a high-priority
disease to Thai’s in most communities
8 Khun and Manderson, 2007 Cambodia An ethnographic study was carried out in order to evaluate Students acquired elemental knowledge about dengue and
[50] the approaches used in health education and their effect- its vectors. Despite they know the dengue transmission
iveness to control dengue in the community. Also, biol- mechanism and the vector control, the containers were
ogy curriculum for primary school children in Grade 5 abundant in houses and schools
that included dengue sessions was evaluated. School
children from the research villages participated in four
focus group discussions and 63 open-ended exercises
exploring knowledge and practices of dengue and its
control. Observations were conducted at the time of the
interviews for evidence of preventive practices. Finally,
thematic analysis was conducted of the dengue health
education materials produced by the National Dengue
Control Program, and the curriculum materials provided
to schools were analyzed for content
(continued)
Schools as centers for health educational initiatives

13 of 20
Table III. Continued
No. Authors Country Description of study Relevant findings

9 Tuyet-Han et al., 2009 [61] Vietnam This study had the aim to assess the project sustainability of The schools and other mass social organizations were ac-

14 of 20
an oldest community-based intervention using tively involved in environmental clean-up and discard
Mesocyclops management campaigns. A total of 4600 pupils between
11 and 15 years old and 12 500 local people received
educational talks about Mesocyclops and dengue in
schools
10 Nu~
nez-Samudio, 2009 [51] El Salvador This study recognized the effectiveness of a program where A diminution of 56% in larval indexes was observed after
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

students participated in dengue control activities. A total the intervention. The knowledge of population from
of 250 children between 11 and 14 years old from two households treated by students improved significatively
scholar centers. The children were trained about dengue
and its prevention and were assigned to apply control
methods in their households and two immediate neigh-
borhoods for 2 months
11 Cáceres-Manrique et al., Colombia A community trial was conducted in four high-incidence A total of 99 children were included in the program of lead-
2010 [52] neighborhoods which two received empowerment train- ership training and participated in the community activ-
ing and two served as controls. Households and schools ities of dengue promotion and control along with other
were visited promoting dengue control activities reach- community leaders. The social mobilization was effect-
ing 1968 homes and 2455 students. The children were ive for improving actions of empowerment and control
encouraged to share their knowledge of dengue preven- but not for dengue prevention
tion and collaborate with vector control activities in their
communities
12 Jayawardene et al., 2011 [53] Sri Lanka Following a planned and systematic training and mobilizing In intervention areas, all proportions of larval indexes were
program, in conjunction with a public information cam- found to be significantly lower following the interven-
paign, seventh-, eighth-, and ninth-grade students in two tion. Surveillance data showed a 73% reduction in case
schools performed multiple mosquito control and education load for the urban area and a 61% reduction in the rural
interventions in their communities once a week for 8 weeks area during the year following intervention
13 Ávila-Montes et al., 2012 Honduras The environmental health program was designed focused The results, as measured by behavioral change and reduced
[54] on primary schools to increase knowledge and develop larval indices, were satisfactory in most of the participat-
skills in the identification and control of A. aegypti ing schools showing a decrease of house index from 29.6
breeding sites, as well as in water and solid waste man- to 7.8 and Breteau index from 64.5 to 16.7. The initiative
agement. Teams formed by children of fifth- and sixth- involved not only children but also their parents and
grade, teachers and health personnel carried out larval teachers. In addition to reducing larval indices, PEA was
inspections in home environments and after the home successful in promoting community participation in en-
visits the children indicate their mothers the measures to vironmental issues, particularly Aedes control
keep the households free of breeding sites
14 Mitchell-Foster et al., 2014 Ecuador An integrated intervention strategy (IIS) for dengue preven- Overall, IIS was successful in reducing pupa per person
[55] tion (an elementary school-based dengue education pro- index (PPI) levels in intervention communities versus
gram, and clean patio and safe container program) was control clusters, with intervention clusters in the six
(continued)
Table III. Continued
No. Authors Country Description of study Relevant findings

implemented in 10 intervention clusters from November paired clusters that followed the study design experienc-
2012 to November 2013 using a randomized controlled ing a greater reduction of PPI compared with controls
cluster trial design (20 clusters: 10 intervention, 10 con- (2.2 OR, 95% CI 1.2–4.7)
trol; 100 households per cluster with 1986 total house-
holds). Children between 8–12 years old were trained
over 2 weeks about dengue and control methods and
identifying and collecting mosquito pupa specimens
15 Caprara et al., 2015 [56] Brazil A CRCT was designed and included: community work- The study results showed the effectiveness of the Ecohealth
shops; community involvement in clean-up campaigns; program in terms of a significant reduction of the dengue
covering the elevated containers and in-house rubbish vector population through targeted interventions in the
disposal without larviciding; mobilization of schoolchil- most productive container types. The project also
dren and senior inhabitants; and distribution of informa- achieved an increase in people’s knowledge of dengue
tion, education and communication (IEC) materials in and willingness to participate in preventive actions. The
the community. Community participation was strength- intervention strategy was based on community participa-
ened, and elderly people and schools planned continuous tion and a partnership approach with public control
actions together with the municipal workers services
16 Andersson et al., 2015 [57] Mexico and The objective of this CRCT was to test whether community Serological evidence from intervention sites showed a
Nicaragua mobilization adds effectiveness to conventional dengue lower risk of infection with dengue virus in children
control through a CRCT. The research team invited vol- (relative risk reduction 29.5%, 95% confidence interval
unteers (brigadistas) from participating communities to 3.8–55.3%), fewer reports of dengue illness (24.7%, 1.8–
receive training as organizers and educators. 51.2%), fewer houses with larvae or pupae among houses
‘Brigadistas’ visited households and schools to show evi- visited (house index) (44.1%, 13.6–74.7%), fewer con-
dence of larval/pupal infestation in water receptacles, to tainers with larvae or pupae among containers examined
inform households and schools of the mosquito’s life (container index) (36.7%, 24.5–44.8%), fewer containers
cycle and to counsel on ways to interrupt the cycle with larvae or pupae among houses visited (Breteau
index) (35.1%, 16.7–55.5%) and fewer pupae per person
(51.7%, 36.2–76.1%)
17 Overgaard et al., 2016 [58] Colombia The objective of this trial was to investigate whether inter- A factorial CRCT was carried out in 34 rural primary
ventions against diarrhea and dengue will significantly schools (1301 pupils). Interventions had no apparent ef-
reduce diarrheal disease and dengue entomological risk fect on pupil school on adult female A. aegypti density;
factors in rural primary schools. Insecticide-treated cur- however, the dengue interventions reduced the Breteau
tains were installed to reduce mosquito entry into schools index on average by 78%
and fitted lids or nets were provided for covering the
water containers. In addition, containers that could not
be handled with lids or nets were treated with pyriproxy-
fen. Solid waste clean-up and collection campaigns
arranged by teachers and project staff were carried out
by pupils
(continued)
Schools as centers for health educational initiatives

15 of 20
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

backyards and eliminating and controlling water

students have pointed out the relationship between swim-


gue were associated with adult mosquitoes, and only few
against diarrhea and dengue carried out 2 years before. It dengue was not sustainable in three of four arms observ-

Participative and semi-participative workshops were per- Among children, most common representations about den-
was measured in two categories: maintenance of the ben- ing a reinfestation of immature A. aegypti in households

more comprehensive attitude against domestic breeding


that promotes exploration and inquiry about dengue, chi- and to perform strategies to prevent mosquito presence.
ming larvae and adult mosquitoes. After the workshop,

sources of risk in their school and their neighborhood,


containers) and reducing the levels of larval indi-
After 2 years post-project, the level of sustainability for

addressed to the rest of the community (adults, other edu- sites and, most importantly, the relationship between
Drawings and texts after workshop sessions reveal a
domestic containers and adult mosquitoes. The participa- collective discussions motivated children to identify
ces (the house index, container index and Breteau
index). The main role of schools in many of these
studies was to serve as a meeting point for chil-

swimming larvae and adult mosquitoes


dren, teens and adults where educative workshops
Relevant findings

were offered. Additionally, students were recruited


and trained to carry out home visits in their com-
munities for health promotion and larviciding
activities. The more reliable results were shown in
the CRCTs because the randomization offers the
best experimental design and reduces sources of
bias. For instance, the trials carried out in Mexico
and schools

and Nicaragua gave diverse outcomes such as a re-


duction of larval indices in the intervention clus-
ters and even the reduction of dengue transmission
in susceptible children [57]. Nonetheless, only two
kungunya and zika and better understanding of mosquito
ing the people understanding of the relationship between

tive workshops involved children from 5 to 12 years old


efits and interventions, and institutionalization and abil-

for dengue awareness and reduce breeding sites, assess-


formed in order to increase the community engagement

studies performed a follow-up study to measure


This study evaluated the sustainability of an intervention

the sustainability of the actions carried out in the


life cycle. The semi-participative workshops were

communities [61, 62]. However, the results were


not conclusive. The Vietnam study was limited to
cative community members, people in jail)

describing that the community had attended edu-


Description of study

ities development of the community

cative talks on the correct use of Mesocyclops as a


biological control and cleaning campaigns, but en-
tomological indices were not reported [61]. In add-
ition, the Colombian study reported a lack of
sustainability in its community-based activities for
dengue and diarrhea control 2 years after imple-
menting the project [62].
This review focused only on school-aged chil-
dren because they represent the group with the
highest risk of acquiring dengue infection and
because schools offer an appropriate place to
hold educative interventions and vector control
Country

Colombia

training. The exploratory KAP surveys showed


Mexico

that the knowledge, attitudes and practices about


dengue disease and control are generally poor
PEA, Programa Escolar Ambiental.

among students. Traditional educative strategies


18 Jaramillo et al., 2018 [62]

19 Medone and Hernández-

such as lectures, doing manual exercises and


sharing printed educative material help to in-
Suárez, 2019 [46]
Authors
Table III. Continued

crease students’ knowledge of dengue and im-


prove their attitudes; however, students are more
interested in ludic strategies and practical activ-
ities, which are demonstrated in the significantly
higher KAP scores in the studies from
No.

Venezuela [32] and Brazil [26]. Nonetheless, a

16 of 20
Schools as centers for health educational initiatives

study from the Philippines [33] showed the oppos- Nonetheless, another health educative program has
ite results for dengue hemorrhagic fever, revealing achieved a success sustaining protective behaviors:
higher KAP scores for traditional lectures, but the SunSafe program from Australia. This study
using a board game was efficient without the included adolescents entering sixth to eighth grades
guide of a teacher. Additionally, the strategies in- that sustained behaviors for sun protection in pools
side the classrooms are described in detail only in and beaches after 2 years of educative interventions
two studies from Philippines [33, 43] having be- in high school communities [66].
tween 30–35 min for each activity. For future de- The main goal of any health education program is
sign of didactic sequences, educative real behavioral change and not only an increase of
investigation in classrooms is needed in order to knowledge and an improvement of attitudes toward
assess whether the activities are pertinent for chil- dengue disease and control. Additionally, this be-
dren students and whether they had time to capture havioral change must be sustained over time without
the content of each activity. needing any reinforcement by health-care staff,
The inclusion of dengue prevention in the cur- teachers, trainers in dengue control, or giving tips
riculum of elementary and high schools has for diffusion. Ecological models for health behavior
been mentioned in some studies [13, 17, 24, 45, research in dengue control are needed for scholars
50]. A meta-analysis has evidenced that includ- and the rest of the community [67]. These models
ing topics for obesity prevention in the curricu- recommend considering individual, social and en-
lum, educational interventions were much more vironmental factors for ensuring real behavioral
effective compared with when it was not change that many of the studies cited in this work
included [63]. However, in the case of dengue did not consider. For example, models for individual
prevention only three studies from Cambodia and social health behavior have been used such as
[50] and Thailand [24] have assessed the poten- the KAP model (all KAP studies), health belief
tial effect of the inclusion of dengue prevention model [68], social cognitive theory [33], stage of
in the curriculum of elementary schools and change model [48] and a derived theory of planned
found that dengue knowledge is poorly linked to behavior known as CASCADA [69] (meaning con-
the preventive practices and low frequency and scious knowledge, attitudes, subjective norms and
non-regularity of the teaching and learning pro- positive deviation from these, intention to change,
cess, respectively. Endemic countries should con- agency to make a change, discussion of possible ac-
sider a redesign of their curriculums in order to tion, and action or change of practice). However,
involve more actively the teachers and students only some community-based interventions consid-
for dengue prevention translating the knowledge ered environmental factors, such as local policies,
into practice at schools and their households. behavior settings (neighborhood, recreation, house-
Despite students being able to increase their holds, schools, workplaces and transportation) and
knowledge, attitudes and practices related to dengue the information environment (mass media and ac-
through an educative intervention, long-term evalu- cess to the internet) [67]. For example, studies from
ations of this acquired knowledge are lacking and Thailand [44, 49], Puerto Rico [45], Honduras [54],
the sustainability of protective practices against den- Sri Lanka [53], Brazil [56] and Mexico [46, 47]
gue among students has been poorly elucidated, had the political will to integrate local health
with the exception of some discouraging outcomes authorities, mass media diffusion, museums and/
presented in a Colombian study [62]. The lack of at- or even prisoners in addition to scholarly com-
tachment to protective behaviors and learning rever- munities (students, teachers and principals) for
sal after long periods of time have also been educative interventions and dengue control.
observed in other health education programs in chil- However, the rest of the studies worked independ-
dren, such as obesity [64] and dental health [65]. ently of health authorities.

17 of 20
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

On the other hand, other environmental factors


Conflict of interest statement
such as active living domains (active recreation,
household activities, active transport and occupa-
None declared.
tional activities), perceived environment (safety, at-
tractiveness, accessibility, convenience and
comfort), sociocultural aspects (perceived crime, References
social activities and social climate) and the natural
environment [67] are barely mentioned. One excep- 1. Campbell LP, Luther C, Moo-Llanes D et al. Climate change
tion was the Camino Verde study [57] which con- influences on global distributions of dengue and chikungunya
sidered sociocultural and perceived safety factors in virus vectors. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2015; 370:
20140135.
the design of the model using environmentally 2. Bhatt S, Gething PW, Brady OJ et al. The global distribution
friendly strategies proposed by the Mexican and and burden of dengue. Nature 2013; 496: 504–7.
Nicaraguan communities for dengue control. 3. Paix~ao ES, Teixeira MG, Rodrigues LC. Zika, chikungunya
and dengue: the causes and threats of new and reemerging
However, it opposed health authorities’ traditional arboviral diseases. BMJ Glob Heal 2018; 3:e000530.
schema of vector control using pesticides. 4. Villar L, Dayan GH, Arredondo-Garcı́a JL et al. Efficacy of
Considering more environmental factors would a tetravalent dengue vaccine in children in Latin America. N
Engl J Med 2015; 372: 113–23.
help in the construction of efficient models for 5. Tricou V, Sáez-Llorens X, Yu D et al. Safety and immuno-
health behavior for dengue control because most of genicity of a tetravalent dengue vaccine in children aged 2–
the aspects that influence behaviors related to vector 17 years: a randomised, placebo-controlled, phase 2 trial.
Lancet 2020; 8: 1–13. e3158.
control would be considered. The political will, the 6. Fernández-Salas I, Danis-Lozano R, Casas-Martı́nez M et al.
setting, the mass media, the larval ecology, the Historical inability to control Aedes aegypti as a main con-
availability of piped water, the sociocultural aspects, tributor of fast dispersal of chikungunya outbreaks in Latin
America. Antiviral Res 2015; 124: 30–42.
the way of living and other environmental factors 7. Fonseca DM, Unlu I, Crepeau T et al. Area-wide manage-
that affect dengue transmission differ according to ment of Aedes albopictus. Part 2: gauging the efficacy of
region and should be considered individually for traditional integrated pest control measures against urban
container mosquitoes. Pest Manag Sci 2013; 69: 1351–61.
each case. Designing community-based interven- 8. McNaughton D, Clough A, Johnson P et al. Beyond the
tions under an ecological approach is necessary in “back yard”: lay knowledge about Aedes aegypti in northern
order to achieve a real and sustainable health behav- Australia and its implications for policy and practice. Acta
Trop 2010; 116: 74–80.
ior change for dengue control among students and 9. Dantés HG, Farfán-Ale JA, Sarti E. Epidemiological trends
other community members. of dengue disease in Mexico (2000-2011): a systematic lit-
Most of the findings obtained in these studies erature search and analysis. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2014; 8:
e3158.
face validity, reliability and generalizability limita- 10. Grant MJ, Booth A. A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14
tions because almost all were conducted using quali- review types and associated methodologies. Health Inf Libr J
tative methodologies or quasi-experimental designs 2009; 26: 91–108.
11. Suwanbamrung C, Promsupa S, Doungsin T et al. Risk fac-
with convenience sampling of a target population. tors related to dengue infections in primary school students:
Only four studies in which schools were involved as exploring students’ basic knowledge of dengue and examin-
a part of the community-based intervention fol- ing the larval indices in southern Thailand. J Infect Public
Health 2013; 6: 347–57.
lowed a CRCT design, which is more reliable for 12. Habibullah S, Ashraf J. Perceptions and practices for the con-
carrying out and evaluating the outcomes of a com- trol of dengue fever in Karachi—a school based survey. Pak
munity intervention [70]. Nonetheless, we cannot J Med Res 2013; 52: 102.
13. Chanyasanha C, Han MM, Teetipsatit S. Dengue hemor-
disregard these findings because they can be helpful rhagic fever knowledge, perception, and preventive behavior
in qualitative analyses and defining new hypotheses among secondary school students in Bangkok. J Med Assoc
for dengue education in students and the rest of Thai 2013; 96:S14–24.
14. Dimbulagedara DP, Jayathilaka K, Madhavi AVP et al.
community that could be tested under aCRCT in Knowledge and practices among school children on dengue
subsequent investigations. prevention. Annu Acad Sess 2014; 185–9.

18 of 20
Schools as centers for health educational initiatives

15. Kalra S, Kaur J, Sharma SK et al. Awareness of dengue fever attitude, and practices in public and private high school chil-
among school children: a comparison between private and dren of Jeddah. Cureus 2018; 10:e3809.
government schools. Indian J Community Health 2014; 26: 31. Madeira NG, Macharelli CA, Pedras JF et al. Education in
438–42. primary school as a strategy to control dengue. Rev Soc Bras
16. Taran SJ, Taran R, Bhandari V. Knowledge, awareness and Med Trop 2002; 35: 221–6.
practice study for mosquito borne diseases among school 32. Vivas E, Guevara de Sequeda M. Un juego como estrategia
children of Malwa region of India. Indian J Child Health educativa para el control de Aedes aegypti en escolares vene-
2016; 3: 125–8. zolanos. Rev Panam Salud Pública 2003; 14: 394–401.
17. Ibrahim NKR, Al-Bar A, Kordey M et al. Knowledge, atti- 33. Lennon JL, Coombs DW. The utility of a board game for
tudes, and practices relating to dengue fever among females dengue haemorrhagic fever health education. Health Educ
in Jeddah high schools. J Infect Public Health 2009; 2: 2007; 107: 290–306.
30–40. 34. Del Valle-Combina V. Determinación del nivel de conoci-
18. Alsheikh AA, Noureldin EM, Sahli AA et al. Dengue know- miento sobre dengue en alumnos de escuelas municipales de
ledge, attitudes and preventive practices among secondary la ciudad de Córdoba, Argentina. Perspectivas para la pre-
school students in Jazan, Saudi Arabia. Flora Fauna 2015; vención. Rev Salud Pública 2008; 12: 37–51.
21: 241–51. 35. Ibrahim NK, Abalkhail B, Rady M et al. An educational pro-
19. Alhazmi S, Khamis N, Abalkhail B et al. Knowledge, atti- gramme on dengue fever prevention and control for females
tudes, and practices relating to dengue fever among high in Jeddah high schools. East Mediterr Health J 2009; 15:
school students in Makkah, Saudi Arabia. Int J Med Sci 1058–67.
Public Health 2016; 5: 930. 36. Vesga-Gómez C, Cáceres-Manrique FDM. Eficacia de la
20. Trindade-Bezerra JM, Soares-da Silva J, Silva-Ibiapina S et al. educación lúdica en la prevención del Dengue en escolares.
Evaluation of students’ knowledge as a contribution to dengue Rev Salud Pública 2010; 12: 558–69.
control programs. Cien Saude Colet 2011; 16: 4367–73. 37. Suwanbamrung C. Children’s basic knowledge and activities
21. Costa-Roriz PA, Vargas-Peres W, Soares-Ramos R. for dengue problem solution: an Islamic religious school,
Percepç~ao de estudiantes de 9 Ano sobre Dengue, Zika e Southern Thailand. Asian Pac J Trop Dis 2012; 2: 456–64.
Chikungunya. Nexus – Rev Extens~ ao Do IFAM 2017; 2. 38. Sandeep KR, Shettigar D, Jayappa S. An educational inter-
22. Sarmiento-Senior D, Matiz MI, Gómez JFJ et al. vention programme on dengue and its prevention among
Knowledge, attitudes and practices about dengue among rural high school children, Karnataka, India. Nitte Univ J
pupils from rural schools in Colombia. Biomédica 2019; 39: Health Sci 2014; 04: 109–12.
478–90. 39. Ávila-Montes GA, Martı́nez M, Sherman C et al. Evaluación
23. Soto-Hernández RJ, Fernández-Cerna EA, Avila-Montes de un módulo escolar sobre dengue y Aedes aegypti dirigido
GA. Evaluación de un programa educativo sobre dengue y a escolares en Honduras. Rev Panam Salud Pública 2004;
Aedes aegypti focalizado en ni~ nos de escuela primaria. Rev 16: 84–94.
Med Hondur 1995; 63: 12–8. 40. Jardim JB, da Silva Barros H, Gonçalves CM et al. The con-
24. Wangroongsarb Y. Dengue control through schoolchildren trol of Aedes aegypti for water access in households: case
in Thailand. Dengue Bull 1997; 21: 52–65. studies towards a school-based education programme
25. Torres JL, Ordó~ nez JG, Vázquez-Martı́nez G. through the use of net covers. Dengue Bull 2009; 33:
Conocimientos, actitudes y prácticas sobre el dengue en las 176–86.
escuelas primarias. Rev Panam Salud Publica 2014; 35: 41. Cordero-Conejo AC, Sandı́-Nogueral F, Mejı́as-Fonseca G
214–8. et al. Rese~na de una experiencia de promoción de la salud y
26. Beinner MA, Angélica É, De Morais H et al. The use of a lucha contra el dengue utilizando el control biológico, en
board game in dengue health education in a public school. J escuelas de Chacarita, Puntarenas, Costa Rica. Rev Costarric
Nurs UFPE Line 2015; 9: 7304–13. Salud Publica 2000; 9: 20–5.
27. Al-Zurfi B, Fuad M, Abdeiqader M et al. Knowledge, 42. Lennon JL, Coombs DW. Study of child-invented health
attitude and practice of dengue fever and health education educational games on dengue fever. Dengue Bull 2002; 26:
programme among students of Alam Shah Science 195–202.
School, Cheras. Malays J Public Health Med 2015; 15: 43. Lennon JL, Coombs DW. The good-bye to dengue game:
69–74. debriefing study. Simul Gaming 2005; 36: 499–517.
28. Ng SW, Lim SY, Beth M. A study to determine the effective- 44. Swaddiwudhipong W, Chaovakiratipong C, Nguntra P et al.
ness of health education on knowledge of dengue fever and Effect of health education on community participation in
preventive measures among high school students in a control of dengue hemorrhagic fever in an urban area of
selected private school, Malaysia. Int J Contemp Pediatrics Thailand. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 1992;
2016; 3: 553–8. 23: 200–6.
29. Nasir NM, Baequni B. Improving knowledge on the preven- 45. Winch PJ, Leontsini E, Rigau-Pérez JG et al. Community-
tion of dengue hemorrhagic fever among elementary school based dengue prevention programs in Puerto Rico: impact on
students in Jakarta, Indonesia: a quasi experimental study. In: knowledge, behavior, and residential mosquito infestation.
Freisleben H-J (ed). 1st International Integrative Conference Am J Trop Med Hyg 2002; 67: 363–70.
on Health, Life and Social Sciences (ICHLaS 2017). 46. Medone P, Hernández-Suárez CM. ‘Swimming mosquitoes’:
Indonesia: Atlantis Press, 2017, 103–06. a key stepping stone to prevent Dengue, Zika and
30. Usman HB, AlSahafi A, Abdulrashid O et al. Effect of health Chikungunya: an educative experience in Colima, Mexico.
education on dengue fever: a comparison of knowledge, Health Educ Res 2019; 34: 389–99.

19 of 20
E. E. Dı́az-González et al.

47. Galván JM, Gutiérrez LR. Dengue prevention in Merida, 59. Nam VS, Kay B, Thi Yen N et al. Community mobilization,
Yucatan, Mexico: use of formative research to refine an edu- behaviour change and biological control in the prevention
cation. Dengue Bull 2004; 28: 44–7. and control of dengue fever in Viet Nam. Dengue Bull 2004;
48. Luna JE, Chain I, Hernandez J et al. Social mobilization 28: 57–61.
using strategies of education and communication to prevent 60. Fernández E, Martı́nez M, Sherman C. Social mobilization
dengue fever in Bucaramanga, Colombia. Dengue Bull 2004; for dengue control in Honduras. Dengue Bull 2004; 28:
28: 17–21. 30–4.
49. Spiegel J, Bennett S, Hattersley L et al. Barriers and bridges 61. Tuyet-Hanh TT, Hill PS, Kay BH et al. Development of a
to prevention and control of dengue: the need for a social- framework for evaluating the sustainability of community-
ecological approach. Ecohealth 2005; 2: 273–90. based dengue control projects. Am J Trop Med Hyg 2009;
50. Khun S, Manderson L. Community and school-based health 80: 312–8.
education for dengue control in rural Cambodia: a process 62. Jaramillo JF, Vargas S, Sarmiento-Senior D et al.
evaluation. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2007; 1: e143. Sostenibilidad en intervenciones para la prevención de den-
51. Nu~nes-Samudio V. Ni~ nos contra el dengue. An Pediatrı́a gue y diarrea en escuelas rurales de dos municipios de
2009; 66: 89. Colombia: evaluación de dos a~ nos post-proyecto. Cad Saude
52. Cáceres-Manrique F de M, Angulo-Silva ML, Vesga-Gómez Publica 2018; 34: e00189017.
C. Efficacy of the social mobilization and the social partici- 63. Liu Z, Xu HM, Wen LM et al. A systematic review and
pation in dengue control measures. Biomedica 2011; 30: meta-analysis of the overall effects of school-based obesity
539–8. prevention interventions and effect differences by interven-
53. Jayawardene WP, Lohrmann DK, Youssefagha AH et al. tion components. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 2019; 16: 95.
Prevention of dengue fever: an exploratory school- 64. Wen LM, Baur LA, Simpson JM et al. Sustainability of
community intervention involving students empowered as effects of an early childhood obesity prevention trial over
change agents. J Sch Health 2011; 81: 566–73. time. JAMA Pediatr 2015; 169: 543.
54. Ávila-Montes GA, Araujo R, Leontsini E et al. Un programa 65. Goel P, Sehgal M, Mittal R. Evaluating the effectiveness of
escolar para el control del dengue en Honduras: del conoci- school-based dental health education program among chil-
miento a la práctica. Rev Panam Salud Pública 2012; 31: dren of different socioeconomic groups. J Indian Soc Pedod
518–22. Prev Dent 2005; 23: 131.
55. Mitchell-Foster K, Ayala EB, Breilh J et al. Integrating par- 66. Olson AL, Gaffney C, Starr P et al. SunSafe in the middle
ticipatory community mobilization processes to improve school years: a community-wide intervention to change early-
dengue prevention: an eco-bio-social scaling up of local suc- adolescent sun protection. Pediatrics 2007; 119: e247–56.
cess in Machala, Ecuador. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 2015; 67. Sallis JF, Owen N, Fisher E. Ecological models of health be-
109: 126–33. havior. In: Glanz K, Rimer BK, Viswanath K (eds). Health
56. Caprara A, Lima J, Peixoto ACR et al. Entomological impact Behavior: Theory, Research, and Practice, vol. 5 . San
and social participation in dengue control: a cluster random- Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, 2015, 43–64.
ized trial in Fortaleza, Brazil. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 68. Wong LP, AbuBakar S, Chinna K. Community knowledge,
2015; 109: 99–105. health beliefs, practices and experiences related to dengue
57. Andersson N, Nava-Aguilera E, Arosteguı́ J et al. fever and its association with IgG seropositivity. PLoS Negl
Evidence based community mobilization for dengue pre- Trop Dis 2014; 8: e2789.
vention in Nicaragua and Mexico (Camino Verde, the 69. Andersson N, Beauchamp M, Nava-Aguilera E et al. The
Green Way): cluster randomized controlled trial. BMJ women made it work: fuzzy transitive closure of the results
2015; 351: h3267. chain in a dengue prevention trial in Mexico. BMC Public
58. Overgaard HJ, Alexander N, Matiz MI et al. A cluster- Health 2017; 17: 408.
randomized controlled trial to reduce diarrheal disease and 70. Andersson N. Community-led trials: intervention co-design
dengue entomological risk factors in rural primary schools in in a cluster randomised controlled trial. BMC Public Health
Colombia. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2016; 10: e0005106. 2017; 17: 397.

20 of 20

You might also like