Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cartilage Interpositional
Grafting
Treatment Option for Glottic and
Subglottic Stenosis in Adults
Wael Hasan, MB,BCh, LRCP & SI, BAO, NUI, MCh, MRCSI,
Patrick Gullane, CM, OONT, MD, FRCSC*
KEYWORDS
Laryngotracheal stenosis Cricotracheal resection Vascularized composite autograft
Rib cartilage interposition graft Airway reconstruction
KEY POINTS
A good understanding of the respiratory function if essential to determine the optimum reconstruc-
tion technique.
Adequate airway reconstruction requires the creation of a functional airway that is able to maintain
adequate ventilation with preservation of the mucociliary function.
Tracheal resection is ideal for short segment stenosis where tension free end-to-end anastomosis
is feasible.
Airway reconstruction with a vascularized composite autograft is the minimal requirement for a
complex functional reconstructed airway.
Open Procedures
Box 2
Contraindications to cricotracheal resection Tracheal resection
Tracheal resection is ideal for short segment
Absolute stenosis, distal to the cricoid, where primary
1. Stenosis at the glottic level tension-free end-to-end anastomosis is possible.
The cricoid level is the narrowest part of the adult’s
2. Active autoimmune or inflammatory disease
upper airway and, hence, the most common
3. Stenosis that includes greater than 6.5 cm of site for iatrogenic tracheal stenosis. Therefore,
trachea this procedure is more commonly indicated for
Relative the noniatrogenic causes, in particular neoplastic
and inflammatory conditions. The preoperative
1. Diabetes mellitus (microvascular disease)
assessment is critical in determining whether or
2. Poor pulmonary reserve not, after resection of the stenotic segment, there
3. Prior irradiation to larynx and/or trachea is sufficient normal trachea below the cricoid to
4. Immunosuppressed patients (ie, high-dose perform the anastomosis. In situations where the
steroids) stenosis is high, a laryngofissure may be neces-
sary to facilitate the cricotracheal anastomosis.
192 Hasan & Gullane
Cricotracheal resection In one of the largest re- nononcologic resections, we reported no flap fail-
ported cricotracheal resection series of 80 pa- ure, successful decannulation in 91% of patients
tients, 92% were decannulated successfully.16 (n 5 10), with the mean and median time from sur-
Ideally, candidates for a single-stage cricotracheal gery to decannulation of 6.4 and 4.0 months,
resection are those who have not had a prior tra- respectively. One patients had prolonged T tube
cheostomy. Furthermore, an anastomosis closer insertion owing to recurrent granulation tissue,
to the undersurface of the true vocal cords of which required subsequent resection for a recur-
less than 1 cm increases the risk of cricoarytenoid rent chondrosarcoma. All surviving patients had
fixation. The contraindications to this procedure a serviceable laryngeal voice.20
are outlined in Box 2.
Resection and Vascularized Composite
Airway reconstruction In 1991, McIlwain17 Autograft Reconstruction: Single Institute
demonstrated that the posterior glottis is lined pri- Experience (University Health Network)
marily with respiratory epithelium that is in continu- In a retrospective study, we report on 36 consec-
ity with the subglottic and proximal tracheal utive cases of combined laryngeal, subglottic,
epithelium. In the cadaveric position of the glottis, and upper tracheal stenosis treated with a single
the posterior glottis constitutes 40% of the total 1-stage procedure of circumferential resection of
glottic circumferential area and constitutes 60% the subglottis and trachea with primary thyrotra-
of that area at full inspiration. This is achieved by cheal anastomosis, combined with laryngofissure
400% enlargement posteriorly with only 160% and laryngotracheal mucosal defect repair. This
corresponding with the anterior glottic enlarge- was a single institution experience; all oncologic
ment. The recognition of the anterior and posterior cases were excluded from this study.
glottic respiratory epithelium lining confirms the
existence of the physiologic and functional rela- RESULTS
tionship between the 2 glottis sites and the respi-
ratory system. All 36 cases were performed between July 1889
Tracheal allografts and aortic allografts have and 2000. The mean age at presentation was 18
been used and reported. In a study of 14 tracheal years (range, 16–72 years). Of those 77.7%
graft cases using cadaveric processed tracheas, (n 5 28) were females and 22.2% males (n 5 8;
only 1 patient (7.1%) was successfully decannu- Box 3). There were 29 patients (80.5%) who
lated. In addition, this case series was associated were tracheostomy dependent at the time of
with a high rate of postoperative infections (80%) referral and 27 (75%) had undergone previous sur-
requiring antibiotics.18 gical treatment.
In contrast, although aortic allografts used Of the patients who had previous surgical treat-
demonstrated the development of respiratory ment, 51.7% (n 5 15) had previous dilatation with
epithelium after transplant, they were associated or without laser resection, 20.6% (n 5 6) under-
with a high rate of postoperative complication, went prior open surgical procedure including lar-
infection, fistula formation, mortality, and lack of yngofissure, 3.4% (n 5 1) underwent open scar
rigid support needed for respiration, requiring resection, and 24.1% (n 5 7) had partial cricoid
long-term intraluminal silicone stenting.19 resection and resurfacing of the exposed denuded
A good understanding of the respiratory function mucosa using a buccal mucosal graft. In one of the
of the glottis and subglottis is, therefore, essential cases, a total of 5 open procedures and 252 endo-
when an optimum functional reconstruction of the scopic dilatations were performed over a 10-year
glottic/subglottic area is considered. To maintain a period at other institutions. Flexible and direct
functioning upper airway, a vascularized mucosal laryngoscopy assessment was performed in all
lining with a supporting rigid structure is required 36 patients. Preoperative assessment included a
to maximize outcome. high-resolution computed tomography scan.
At the University Health Network, University of The underlying etiology varied from postintuba-
Toronto, we have further enhanced our laryngotra- tion injury in 80.5% (n 5 29), idiopathic stenosis
cheal airway reconstructive techniques over the in 8.3% (n 5 3), blunt trauma in 5.5% (n 5 2), inha-
years and now consider airway reconstruction in lation in 2.7% (n 5 1), and congenital stenosis in
select cases with a vascularized composite auto- 2.7% (n 5 1). Of these patients, 94.4% (n 5 34)
graft as the minimum requirement for a complex had a significant reduction in cord movement
functional reconstructed airway. A retrospective limited to less than 2 to 3 mm and the cords were
study of 11 patients whose airway was recon- fixed in the remaining 5.6% of patients (n 5 2).
structed using a vascularized composite autograft All 36 patients underwent a single-stage pro-
between 2000 and 2011, after oncological and cedure: 83.3% (n 5 30) had isolated posterior
Laryngeal Split & Rib Cartilage Interpositional Grafting 193
Fig. 5. Cricotracheal resection with a membranous posterior tracheal flap. (From Pearson FG, Gullane P. Subglot-
tic resection with primary tracheal anastomosis: including synchronous laryngotracheal reconstruction. Semin
Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1996;8(4):381–91; with permission.)
196 Hasan & Gullane
1. A free buccal mucosal graft is transferred and 10. A sufficient gap is maintained between the
sutured to the tip of the defect. native airway and the costal cartilage graft to
2. A temporoparietal fascial flap or radial forearm permit the fascial flap to exit the airway and
flap is harvested (the latter is preferred for avoid strangulation.
larger defects). 11. The fascial flap is then wrapped around the
3. Sufficient buccal mucosal flap and costal costal cartilage graft and the vascular pedicle
cartilage grafts are harvested to reconstruct brought through a tunnel in the strap muscles.
and to resurface the defect. 12. The microvascular anastomosis is then per-
4. The buccal mucosal flap is sutured superfi- formed, commonly to the superior thyroid
cially to the luminal aspect of the fascial flap artery.
with interrupted absorbable sutures. They 13. The endotracheal tube is then switched to cuf-
will later become the intraluminal lining of the fed tracheal tube at the end of the procedure.
vascularized composite autograft.
5. The buccal mucosa and the fascial flap SUMMARY
construct is then inset into the surgical defect
by first suturing the construct along the defect From years of experience with airway reconstruc-
side ipsilateral to the recipient vessels. tion and the additional understanding of different
6. A sterile Montgomery Laryngeal Stent (Boston pathophysiology involved, we now know that a
Medical Products, Westborough, MA) is rigid conduit lined with respiratory epithelium is
placed within the airway lumen at the level of the minimum requirement to maintain a functional
the glottis and subglottis to provide support upper airway and minimize long-term complica-
to the reconstruction (Fig. 6). tions. The main goal of airway reconstruction is
7. A female-sized stent is used for male patients to resect the stenotic segment, maintain airway
and an adolescent-sized stent for female pa- functionality, and facilitate successful decannula-
tients. The stent is sutures to the skin using tion. Single-stage laryngofissure, cricotracheal
two 2-0 nylon sutures. resection, and defect repair with a vascularized
8. Once the stent is inserted, the fascial flap is composite autograft is in select cases the treat-
sutured to the contralateral side of the defect ment of choice today for complex synchronous
and secured to the native trachea or cricoid, glottic and subglottic stenosis that is refractory
thus completing the repair of the anterior lar- to conservative and minimally invasive endoscopic
yngotracheal defect. techniques within our institution.
9. The costal cartilage graft is contoured to the
size of the defect or the planned anterior REFERENCES
expansion of the airway and secured to the 1. Ogura J, Biller H. Reconstruction of the larynx
native laryngotracheal skeleton with interrup- following blunt trauma. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol
ted sutures. 1971;80:492–506.
Laryngeal Split & Rib Cartilage Interpositional Grafting 197
2. Gerwat J, Bryce D. The management of subglottic 11. Miller RD, Hyatt RE. Obstructing lesions of the larynx
stenosis by resection and direct anastomosis. and trachea: clinical and physiologic characteris-
Laryngoscope 1974;84:940–7. tics. Mayo Clin Proc 1969;44(3):145–61.
3. Pearson FG, Cooper J, Nelms J, et al. Primary 12. Myer CM, O’Connor DM, Cotton RT. Proposed
tracheal anastomosis after resection of the cartilage grading system for subglottic stenosis based on
with preservation of the recurrent laryngeal nerve. endotracheal tube sizes. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol
Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1975;70:806–16. 1994;103(4 Pt 1):319–23.
4. Pearson FG, Brito-Filomeno L, Cooper J. Experience 13. McCaffery TV. Classification of laryngotracheal ste-
with partial cricoid resection and thyrotrachea anas- nosis. Laryngoscope 1992;102(102):1335–40.
tomosis. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1986;95:582–5. 14. Lano CF, Duncavage JA, Reinisch L, et al. Laryngo-
5. Couraud L, Bichon P, Vally J. The surgical treatment tracheal reconstruction in the adult: a ten year expe-
of inflammatory and fibrous laryngotracheal steno- rience. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1998;107:92–7.
sis. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 1988;2:410–5. 15. Lee KH, Rutter MJ. Role of balloon dilatation in the
6. Grillo H, Mathison D, Wain J. Laryngotracheal resec- management of adult idiopathic subglottic stenosis.
tion and reconstruction for subglottic stenosis. Ann Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 2008;117(2):81–4.
Thorac Surg 1992;53:54–63. 16. Pearson FG, Gullane P. Subglottic resection with pri-
7. Maddaus M, Toth J, Gullane P, et al. Subglottic mary tracheal anastomosis: including synchronous
tracheal resection and synchronous laryngeal re- laryngotracheal reconstructions. Semin Thorac Car-
construcion. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1992;104: diovasc Surg 1996;8(4):381–91.
1443–50. 17. McIlwain J. The posterior glottis. J Otolaryngol
8. Foreman A, Johnson BT, Gullane PJ. Head & neck 1991;(Suppl 2):1–24.
surgery book. Tracheal stenosis and tracheal neo- 18. Propst EJ, Prager JD, Meinzen-Dierr J, et al. Pediat-
plasms. JAYPEE - The Health Sciences Publisher. ric tracheal reconstruction using cadaveric homo-
[Chapter 41]. 2015. p. 711–26. graft. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2011;137:
9. McAdam LP, O’Hanlan MA, Bluestone R, et al. Re- 583–90.
lapsing polychondritis: prospective study of 23 pa- 19. Davidson MB, Mustafa K, Girdwood RW. Tracheal
tients and a review of the literature. Medicine replacement with an aortic homograft. Ann Thorac
(Baltimore) 1976;55(3):193–215. Surg 2009;88:1006–8.
10. Miller RD, Hyatt RE. Evaluation of obstructing lesions 20. Rich JT, Goldstein D, Haerle SK, et al. Vascularized
of the trachea and larynx by flow-volume loops. Am composite autograft for adult laryngotracheal steno-
Rev Respir Dis 1973;108(3):475–81. sis and reconstruction. Head Neck 2016;38:253–9.