Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Civil Obligations and Natural Obligations Distinguished
Civil Obligations and Natural Obligations Distinguished
Article 1423 gives the distinctions between civil obligations and natural obligations,
viz.:
Voluntary fulfillment means that the debtor complied with the same even if he knew
that he could not have been legally forced to do so.
EXAMPLES
(a) obligation to pay interest for use of money, even if not agreed upon in writing.
(b) duty to support natural or spurious children (even if not recognized voluntarily or
by judicial compulsion and even if there is a judgment denying recognition).
(c) giving of material and financial assistance to children upon their marriage.
Kapag ang karapatan na maghain ng reklamo sa isang obligasyonng sibil ay
natapos na sa papamagitan ng extinctive prescription, ang may pananagutan na
kusang isinagawa ang kontrata ay hindi na maaring bawiin ang naibigay o halaga
ng serbisyong ginawa.
Article 1424 provides that if an obligee fails to pursue a cause of action based on a
civil obligation within the period fixed by law, the obligation is extinguished. It
cannot be anymore be enforced in court. It becomes a stale claim.
While the prescribed cannot be asserted anymore in a court, nevertheless under the
rule on performance of natural obligations it is indirectly ressurected when the obligor
voluntarily pays the stale claim. The payment is valid payment because of the obligors
recognition of his debt. He cannot recover what he paid or the value of the service he
had rendered in cases of obligation to do.
Illustration:
Morning owes Evening the sum of 5,000 pesos under a written contract. After ten
years the debt of morning prescribes for failure of evening to file the necessary action
for the recovery of the same. If morning knowing the prescription voluntarily pays
evening, he cannot recover anymore what he has paid.