Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gene Nemaline Myopathy
Gene Nemaline Myopathy
Nemaline myopathy (NM) is the most common of several congenital myopathies that present with skeletal muscle
weakness and hypotonia. It is clinically heterogeneous and the diagnosis is confirmed by identification of nemaline
bodies in affected muscles. The skeletal muscle ␣-actin gene (ACTA1) is one of five genes for thin filament proteins
identified so far as responsible for different forms of NM. We have screened the ACTA1 gene in a cohort of 109
unrelated patients with NM. Here, we describe clinical and pathological features associated with 29 ACTA1 mutations
found in 38 individuals from 28 families. Although ACTA1 mutations cause a remarkably heterogeneous range of phe-
notypes, they were preferentially associated with severe clinical presentations (p < 0.0001). Most pathogenic ACTA1
mutations were missense changes with two instances of single base pair deletions. Most patients with ACTA1 mutations
had no prior family history of neuromuscular disease (24/28). One severe case, caused by compound heterozygous
recessive ACTA1 mutations, demonstrated increased ␣-cardiac actin expression, suggesting that cardiac actin might par-
tially compensate for ACTA1 abnormalities in the fetal/neonatal period. This cohort also includes the first instance of an
ACTA1 mutation manifesting with adult-onset disease and two pedigrees exhibiting potential incomplete penetrance.
Overall, ACTA1 mutations are a common cause of NM, accounting for more than half of severe cases and 26% of all NM
cases in this series.
Ann Neurol 2004;56:86 –96
The congenital myopathies are rare neuromuscular dis- structurally, these electron-dense nemaline bodies orig-
orders characterized by nonprogressive or slowly pro- inate from the Z-disc of sarcomeres. Other nonspecific
gressive muscle weakness. They often are associated pathological findings frequently found in NM include
with structural abnormalities of the contractile appara- fiber size variation, fiber-type disproportion, and type I
tus or other architectural abnormalities within muscle fiber predominance. More rarely, dystrophic features
fibers. Given significant phenotypic overlap, diagnosis such as degenerating and regenerating fibers, internal
of the specific forms of congenital myopathy generally nuclei, and increased connective tissue may be ob-
begins with the histological characterization of these ar- served.1,7
chitectural changes in a muscle biopsy specimen. In NM is genetically, as well as phenotypically, hetero-
general, clinical expression of nemaline myopathy geneous. Causative mutations have now been described
(NM) is characterized by weakness of the face, neck in five genes encoding different skeletal muscle thin fil-
flexors, and proximal muscles of the limbs.1,2 The pre- ament proteins.2 Nebulin gene (NEB) mutations are
sentation may range from stillbirth or infantile demise likely responsible for most autosomal recessive cases8,9;
to a mild skeletal myopathy presenting in later life.3– 6 however, the large size of this gene presents an obstacle
The characteristic pathological feature of NM is a to the efficient detection of pathogenic mutations. Mu-
rod-like structure, or “nemaline body,” seen on light tations in NEB usually present with typical congenital
microscopy with Gomori trichrome staining. Ultra- NM,8 but severe and mild presentations have also been
From the 1Genomics Program and Division of Genetics and 2Divi- Received Feb 20, 2004, and in revised form Apr 13. Accepted for
sion of Neonatology, Children’s Hospital; 3Harvard Medical publication Apr 13, 2004.
School, Boston, MA; 4Department of Pediatric Neurology, Scottish
Rite Hospital for Children, Dallas, TX; 5Department of Neurology, See Appendix on page 93.
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD; Published online Jun 28, 2004, in Wiley InterScience
6
Centre for Neuromuscular and Neurological Disorders, University (www.interscience.wiley.com). DOI: 10.1002/ana.20157
of Western Australia, Australian Neuromuscular Research Institute,
and Centre for Medical Research, West Australian Institute of Med- Address correspondence to Dr Beggs, Genetics Division, Children’s
ical Research, QEII Medical Centre, Nedlands, Western Australia, Hospital Boston, 300 Longwood Avenue, Boston, MA 02115.
Australia. E-mail: beggs@enders.tch.harvard.edu
Fig 1. Distribution of mutations among exons of ACTA1 gene (introns not to scale). Mutations resulting in severe (S), intermedi-
ate (I), typical (T), congenital or adult (A) clinical presentations are indicated above. Recessive mutations are indicated with an
asterisk. Exon numbers and sizes are indicated below. 5⬘ and 3⬘ untranslated region regions are indicated as unfilled boxes at ei-
ther end.
Severe 25 14 56 13 1 0
Intermediate 23 3 13 3 0 0
Typical 50 10 20 6 0 4
Mild/childhood 2 0 0 0 0 0
Adult onset 3 1 33 1 0 0
Unknown/other 6 0 0 0 0 0
Total 109 28 26 23 1 4
NM ⫽ nemaline myopathy; AR ⫽ autosomal recessive; AD ⫽ autosomal domoinant.
sumed dominant missense changes. In 16 patients, numbers that do not correlate well with disease sever-
dominant pathogenesis could be confirmed by the ab- ity.
sence of mutation in either parent (indicating de novo Common findings on hematoxylin/eosin staining
mutation and/or gonadal mosaicism in one parent). and myosin ATPase staining were fiber size variation,
For the remaining five cases, either or both parents mild to severe atrophy of type 1, type 2 or both types
could not be tested because of nonavailability of DNA. of fibers, type 1 fiber predominance, and occasional
The 21 probands, excluding the autosomal recessive hypertrophy of type 1 or 2 fibers. None of the cases
case, had clinical presentations ranging from severe to had the “nontyping” pattern of pathology defined by
typical congenital onset. Thirteen of these probands Ryan and colleagues7 and Sanoudou and colleagues,26
had severe, one had intermediate, and seven had typical nor did any exhibit type 2 fiber predominance which
congenital NM. The clinical outcome was poor for se- has been reported in 4% of unselected NM cases.7
vere and intermediate cases: 9 of 13 severe cases and Moderate to severe increases of endomysial and or peri-
the intermediate case were all deceased by 1 year of mysial connective tissues were noted in two cases
age. All seven typical congenital NM cases with ages (117-1 and 308-1). Severe cases with ACTA1 muta-
ranging from 2.5 years to 38 years were alive, ambula- tions were associated significantly with marked variabil-
tory, and needed no respiratory assistance. ity in fiber size ( p ⫽ 0.006) and severe atrophy of
some fibers ( p ⫽ 0.015). Conversely, typical cases usu-
Pathological Findings ally exhibited only mild to moderate variability in fiber
Detailed pathology data and or slides were available for size. However, because severe cases were invariably in-
25 of the 28 probands in whom ACTA1 mutations fants at time of biopsy, whereas typical cases were often
were identified (see Appendix). With one exception older, we cannot exclude age at biopsy as a confound-
(Patient 226-1), all patients had nemaline bodies on ing variable affecting this association. In general, nema-
Gomori trichome staining and/or on electron micros- line bodies resulting from actin mutations were ultra-
copy. Patient 226-1 presented with congenital contrac- structurally indistinguishable from those in cases
tures, profound weakness, and respiratory insufficiency without ACTA1 mutations. Other EM findings, in-
and a mutation at ACTA1 residue 146 (Gly146Asp). cluding Z-line streaming and myofibrillar disorganiza-
This patient’s biopsy was characteristic for actin myop- tion, were seen in both ACTA1 and non-ACTA1 mu-
athy,25 with presence of small masses of Z-band mate- tated cases.
rial resembling mininemaline bodies on electron mi-
croscopy. In all remaining cases, nemaline bodies were Immunolocalization and Isoform Composition of
mostly sarcoplasmic or subsarcolemmal, appearing as Sarcomeric Actins
extensions of the Z-disc on electron microscopy and Although skeletal muscle ␣-actin (ie, the ACTA1 gene
often staining positively with anti–␣-actinin-2 antisera product) is the predominant sarcomeric actin isoform
by immunofluorescence analysis (Fig 2). Of the cases in skeletal muscle, ␣-cardiac actin (the ACTC gene
with nemaline bodies, one previously reported16 case product) is also present, particularly in the fetal and
with severe disease (Patient 86-1) had both intranuclear postnatal periods and in regenerating fibers at all
and sarcoplasmic nemaline bodies, whereas the rest had ages.27,28 Because ACTC expression might compensate
sarcoplasmic bodies only. Nemaline bodies were for, or otherwise modulate, the effects of ␣-skeletal ac-
present in variable numbers, and in variable propor- tin abnormalities, we assessed expression of these pro-
tions of fibers, ranging from 10% to virtually all fibers. teins in muscles from eight patients with, and three
Most cases (87%) had abundant nemaline bodies in without, ACTA1 mutations (Table 2; Figs 2, 3). All
cases analyzed were biopsied at younger than 1 year of (108-1 and 18-3) with intermediate and typical clinical
age. Double-label indirect immunofluorescence stain- presentations exhibited uniform, low-level expression of
ing with cardiac actin-specific and anti–pan-actin anti- ␣-cardiac actin in all fibers without evidence for any
bodies showed several distinct patterns of ␣-cardiac ac- regeneration (eg, see Fig 2A–C). Two non-ACTA1
tin expression. Two patients with ACTA1 mutations mutation NM cases (164-1, 256-1), as well as an un-
8-2 T10 Yes Marked None 23% 19% Variable Uniform Quadriceps 18 days
221-1 T164 Yes Moderate 50–60%, 10% 30% Variable Uniform Gastroneimus 8 mo
prominent
103-1 T71 Yes Moderate Indistinct 16% 70% Variable Not uni- Quadriceps 3 days
form
95-1 T77 Yes Moderate 80%, Promi- 17% 2% Variable Occasional Unknown 10 mo
nent intense
108-1 T80 Yes Minimal Few, indistinct 0 100% Low Uniform Quadriceps 7.5 weeks
117-1 T93 Yes Marked Occasional 100% 100% High Uniform Quadriceps 5 weeks
226-1 T156 Yes Marked None 100% 100% Increased inten- Uniform Quadriceps 5.5 mo
sity subsar-
colemmal re-
gion
18-3 T66 Yes Minimal Not done 0 100% Low Uniform Unknown 6 mo
164-1 T115 No Minimal 10%, Indis- 0 50% Low Uniform Quadriceps 7 days
tinct
174-1 T124 No Significant 75%, Promi- 9% 50% Variable Uniform Quadriceps 8 mo
nent
256-1 T182 No Moderate Few, granular 0 90% Low Not done Quadriceps 14 days
223-1 T149 Unaffecteda Mild None 0 50% Low Uniform Quadriceps 1st week
of life
a
Muscle sample from a control patient with no muscle disease.
affected control case (223-1), also exhibited similar sarcolemmal staining with anti–pan-actin antibodies,
findings. In contrast, muscles from another group of consistent with the pathological diagnosis of actin my-
ACTA1 mutated cases (8-2, 221-1, 103-1, 95-1), rang- opathy (Fig 2G–I). Remarkably, a similar pattern was
ing in clinical presentation from typical to severe, con- seen using specific anti–␣-cardiac actin antisera, sug-
tained 10 to 25% small intensely staining fibers, indic- gesting that both mutant ␣-skeletal actin and nonmu-
ative of active regeneration (eg, see Fig 2D–F). The tated ␣-cardiac actin proteins were present in the ab-
third non-ACTA1 mutation case (174-1) had similar normal filamentous accumulations. Muscle from the
findings to this group. There was no obvious correla- recessively inherited ACTA1 NM patient (117-1) at 5
tion between cardiac actin expression and severity of weeks of age was also remarkable. This biopsy alone
disease in this admittedly small group. All these mus- exhibited intense staining for cardiac actin in every
cles exhibited uniform, sarcomeric pan-actin staining in myofiber (see Fig 2J–L). Western blot analysis for sar-
all muscle fibers with no evidence for abnormal accu- comeric actins and cardiac actin confirmed the appar-
mulations or localization of actin proteins. ent increase in cardiac actin expression in muscle from
The remaining two cases with ACTA1 mutations this patient (see Fig 3). No additional abnormalities in
each had a unique patterns of actin expression. Muscle quantity or quality of actin isoforms were noted.
from Patient 226-1, biopsied at 5.5 months of age,
contained many fibers showing intense ring-like, sub- Discussion
We identified 29 ACTA1 mutations causing NM in 28
of 109 probands screened, suggesting that ACTA1 mu-
tations account for approximately a quarter of NM
cases worldwide. This is higher than the 19% (11/59)
and 15% (5/35) in previously studied cohorts16,17;
however, as ACTA1 mutations are more common
among cases of severe NM, observed differences in
ACTA1 mutation frequency may represent ascertain-
ment biases in phenotypic severity of the referral pop-
ulation.
The primary component of muscle thin filaments is
Fig 3. Western blot analysis of total actin (A) and ␣-cardiac F-actin, formed by the self-association of G-actin
actin (B) in two control muscles and muscle biopsies from monomers. Many areas of the actin monomer are
nemaline myopathy patients (patient identifications indicated known to be involved in the polymerization to F-actin
above). Relative loading in each lane is indicated by Coomas- or interaction with different actin-binding proteins, in-
sie blue–stained gel section shown in (C). cluding myosin, tropomyosin, troponin, and nebulin,
Appendix. Clinical, Pathological, and Molecular Findings in Nemaline Myopathy Patients with ACTA1 Mutations
Amino Acid Disease Presenting Respiratory Feeding
Patient Sex Mutation Substitution Severitya Inheritanceb Symptomsc Issues Issues Status Pathological Findingsd
8-2 M c.949C⬎G Asn280Lys SC De novo No spontaneous Needed in- Gastrostomy Died at 9 mo Marked fiber-size variabil-
movements, poor termittent tube and of aspiration ity, numerous atrophic
respiratory efforts ventilatory fundopli- pneumonia fibers including clusters
at birth support cation of atrophic fibers, nu-
merous nemaline bodies
18-3 M c.654G⬎A Gly182Asp TC Isolated Failure to thrive and Frequent Gastrostomy Improvement Type I fiber predominance,
hypotonia at 3 pneumonia tube from after in- scattered atrophic fibers,
weeks, delayed during 2–18 mo fancy, now numerous nemaline bod-
motor milestones infancy 3 yr ies, majority myofibrils
intact
25-1 M c.966A⬎G Asp286Gly SC Isolated Hypotonia, joint Ventilatory Exclusively Died at 6 days Marked fiber size variabil-
contractures, femur support tube fed ity, severe atrophy both
fracture, no move- until death fiber types, numerous
ment, no respira- nemaline bodies, severe
tory effort at birth disruption of myofibrils.
35-1 F c.656C⬎G Arg183Gly SC De novo No spontaneous Needed in- Exclusively Died at age 1 Type I fiber predominance,
movements, poor termittent tube fed yr marked fiber size vari-
feeding, hypotonia, ventilatory ability, mildly increased
at birth support connective tissue, abun-
dant nemaline bodies
80-1 M c.231A⬎G Gln41Arg TC AD Delayed milestones, None None Alive and am- Mild fiber size variation,
hypotonia, weak- bulatory at many sarcoplasmic nema-
ness presenting in 56 yr line bodies.
infancy
80-2 M c.231A⬎G Gln41Arg TC AD Recurrent pulmonary None None Alive and am- Mild fiber size variation,
infections, failure bulatory at atrophy of mainly type I
to thrive, hypoto- 23 yr fibers, sarcoplasmic rods,
nia from infancy mild disorganization of
myofibrils
86-1 M c.227C⬎T His40Tyr SC De novo Hypotonia, contrac- Supplemental Mostly tube Died at 2 mo Moderate number of intra-
tures at birth oxygen for fed cytoplasmic and intranu-
cyanosis, clear nemaline bodies,
dyspnea mild increase in connec-
tive tissue, disorganized
myofibrils
90-1 M c.1226A⬎C Lys373Gln TC AD Hypotonia at birth Restrictive Tube fed Alive and am- Biopsy done in 1960s, re-
and failure to lung dis- for several bulatory at port unavailable
thrive, recurrent ease easy mos 34, surgery
pneumonia fatiguabil- for scoliosis
ity at 18 yr
90-2 M c.1226A⬎C Lys373Gln TC AD Presented in infancy None Slow feeder Alive and am- Not done
with delayed mo- bulatory at
tor milestones 7 yr
95-1 F c.338A⬎G Thr77Ala TC De novo Poor suck at birth, None Gastrostomy Alive and am- Type I fiber predominance,
failure to thrive, tube and bulatory at marked fiber-size vari-
delayed motor fundopli- 2.5 yr ability, numerous nema-
milestones cation at line bodies, myofibrils
9 mo relatively intact
103-1 M c.327A⬎T His73Leu SC De novo Hypotonia, contrac- Ventilatory Exclusively Died at 5 days Marked fiber size variabil-
tures, no spontane- support tube fed ity, type I fibers not pre-
ous movements, until death dominant, small,
no respiratory ef- rounded and atrophic
fort at birth fibers, numerous nema-
line bodies.
104-1 F c.846A⬎G Gln246Arg TC AD Difficult steps and None None Alive and am- Not done
frequent falls start- bulatory at
ing 2 yr age 9 yr
104-2 F c.846A⬎G Gln246Arg TC AD Difficult steps and None None Alive and am- Type I fiber predominance,
frequent falls in bulatory at mild fiber-size variability,
early childhood 41 yr numerous nemaline bod-
ies
104-3 F c.846A⬎G Gln246Arg TC AD Difficult steps, fre- None None Alive and am- Biopsy findings similar to
quent falls, weak- bulatory at 104-2
ness in early child- 40 yr
hood
104-4 F c.846A⬎G Gln246Arg TC AD Difficult steps and None None Alive and am- Not done
frequent falls in bulatory at
early childhood 20 yr
104-5 F c.846A⬎G Gln246Arg M AD Mild leg weakness in None None Alive and am- Not done
childhood bulatory at
15 yr
108-1 M c.510T⬎C Val134Ala IC AD Failure to thrive, hy- Nighttime Gastrostomy Alive and am- Uniform fiber size, numer-
potonia, cyanosis ventilatory feeds bulatory at ous nemaline bodies,
in infancy support 6 yr relatively intact myofi-
brils
108-4 F c.510T⬎C Val134Ala U AD Slow runner in child- None None Alive and well Not done
hood, slender at 34 yr
adult
108-7 M c.510T⬎C Val134Ala U AD Tall, thin, long face, None None Alive and well Not done
basketball player at 63 yr
115-1 F c.212G⬎C Val35Leu SC De novo Hypotonia, no spon- Needs me- Gastrostomy Unable to roll Type I fiber predominance,
taneous movement chanical feeds over or sit, atrophic type II fibers,
at birth ventilation can hold her numerous nemaline bod-
⬎20hr/day head alive at ies
18 mo
117-1 M c539delG/ trunc188/ SC AR Hypotonia, contrac- Ventilatory Tube fed Died at 2 mo Marked fiber size variation,
c.885A⬎T Glu259Val tures, no spontane- support exclusively mild-moderate increase
ous movements, until death in connective tissue, scat-
no respiratory ef- tered atrophy of both
fort at birth type fibers, numerous
nemaline bodies, in-
creased glycogen
120-1 M c.300T⬎C Ilc64Asn TC AD Feeding problems in Recently di- None Alive and am- Few nemaline bodies in
infancy, weakness agnosed bulatory at sarcoplasm, mostly intact
and low muscle with sleep 48 yr myofibrillar arrangement.
bulk apnea
120-3 F c.300T⬎C Ilc64Asn TC AD Failure to thrive, None Slow feeder Alive and am- Not done
weakness frequent bulatory at
falls during in- 8 yr has
fancy bilateral foot
drop
166-1 F c.645A⬎G Asp179Gly SC De novo Severe hypotonia, Ventilator Gastrostomy Alive at 2 yr, Marked fiber-size variabil-
inability to dependent tube for severely ity, diffuse and wide-
breathe or feed since feeding hypotonic spread both fiber type
independently, no birth; with no atrophy with round fi-
movements at tracheos- head con- bers, abundant nemaline
birth tomy trol bodies
181-1 F c.911G⬎T Gly268Cys TC Isolated Hypotonic at birth, None Poor suck, Alive and am- Not available
delayed motor slow bulatory at
milestones feeder 7 yr, wors-
ening lor-
dosis
186-1 F c.788A⬎G Met227Val IC De novo Hypotonia, delayed Needs CPAP Gastrostomy Alive and am- Not done
motor milestones, support tube for bulatory at
poor feeding since 2 yr feeding 3 yr
age
186-2 F c.788A⬎G Met227Val IC De novo Hypotonia, delayed Needs CPAP Gastrostomy Alive and am- Type I fiber predominance,
motor milestones, support tube for bulatory at numerous nemaline
poor feeding since 2 yr feeding 3 yr bodies, areas of Z-line
age streaming
188-1 M c.1134delG Gly342Ala ⫹ 75 A AD Weakness on exercise None Difficulty Alive and am- Significant disruption of
at 42 yr, now swallow- bulatory at myofibrillar architecture
difficulty climbing ing 55 yr with due to nemaline bodies,
stairs, swallowing increasing focal accumulations of
and has head weakness mitochondria
drop
188-2 M c.1134delG Gly342Ala ⫹ 75 A AD Unaffected None None Died at 85 yr Not done
of unre-
lated cause
199-1 M c.790G⬎C Met227Ile TC Isolated Onset at 2 yr with Easy fatiga- None Alive and am- Mild fiber size variation,
difficulty running, bility bulatory at subsarcolemmal nema-
climbing stairs 38 yr, sur- line bodies, slight in-
gery for crease in connective
scoliosis at tissue
18 yr
220-1 F c.332A⬎C Ile75Leu SC De novo No spontaneous Ventilator Gastrostomy Alive at 1.8 yr, Not available
movement, no dependent tube for not able to
respiratory effort since feeding hold head/
at birth birth sit
221-1 M c.944T⬎C Tyr279His IC De novo Hypotonia, feeding Apnea, bra- Tube for Died at 9 mo Type I fiber predominance,
difficulty dycardias feeding abundant cytoplasmic
since age rods, streaming and
3 wk multifocal enlargement
of Z lines
226-1 F c.546G⬎A Gly146Asp SC De novo Contractures, mark- Intermittent Tube feeds Died at 6 mo Type I fiber predominance,
edly reduced ventila- and scattered atrophy, small
movements, hy- tion for gtube masses of Z-band mate-
potonia at birth apnea and feeds rial resembling mini-
pneumo- nemaline bodies on
nia EM. Strong staining
with actin immunoper-
oxidase seen as subsar-
colemmal ring distribu-
tion in most fibers
234-1 F c.861G⬎A Gly251Asp SC De novo No spontaneous Needs me- Tube fed Alive at 8 yr, Type I fiber predominance,
movements chanical since unable to 50% fibers abnormally
ventila- birth hold head small, several nemaline
tion 24 or sit with- bodies, variable disorga-
hr/day out support nization of myofibrils
since 8
mo
239-1 M c.780A ⬎ G Glu224Gly TC De novo Presented in infancy None None Alive at 3 yr Less than 10% fibers con-
with hypotonia, tain nemaline bodies
failure to thrive,
limb girdle and
bulbar weakness
307-1 M c.327A⬎G His73Arg SC Isolated Severe hypotonia, Ventilator Tube fed Alive at 11 yr Marked variation in fiber
insufficient respi- dependent since with severe size, several rounded fi-
ration since birth birth weakness bers, abundant nemaline
bodies
308-1 F c.222C⬎T Pro38Leu SC De novo Severe hypotonia, Ventilatory Tube fed Died at 15 Marked fiber size variabil-
insufficient respira- support until days ity, diffuse atrophy, ex-
tion, no spontane- until death death tensive perimysial and
ous movements at endomysial fibrosis, nu-
birth merous nemaline bodies
349-1 M c.356G⬎A Glu83Lys TC De novo Hypotonia noted at None None Alive and am- Not done
3 mo bulatory at
3 yr
349-2 M c.356G⬎A Glu83Lys TC De novo Hypotonia at birth, None None Alive and am- Marked type 1 fiber pre-
had delayed mile- bulatory at dominance, moderate
stones, sat at 9 mo 3 yr fiber-size variability, scat-
and walked at 16 tered and grouped atro-
mo phy, numerous nemaline
bodies
350-1 F c.698G⬎A Gly197Ser SC De novo Hypotonia, no respi- Ventilator Tube fed Died at 3 mo Marked type I fiber pre-
ratory efforts dependent since dominance, hypotrophic
since birth birth both type fibers, abun-
dant nemaline bodies
a
SC ⫽ severe congenital; IC ⫽ intermediate congenital; TC ⫽ typical congenital; IC ⫽ intermediate congenital; M ⫽ mild (childhood or
juvenile onset), A ⫽ adult onset, U ⫽ unaffected.
bAD ⫽ autosomal dominant; AR ⫽ autosomal recessive; de novo ⫽ indicates sporadic mutation ruled out in both parents; isolated, sporadic