Professional Documents
Culture Documents
131–139
www.elsevier.nlrlocaterjim
Abstract
The deep red fluorescing agent ŽDRAQ5. is a synthetic anthraquinone with a high affinity for DNA and a high capacity
to rapidly enter living cells or stain fixed cells. DRAQ5 is optimally excited by red-light emitting sources and yields a deep
red emission spectrum which extends into the low infra-red. DRAQ5 shows excitation at sub-optimal wavelengths including
the 488 nm line and the multi-line UV wavelengths emitted by argon-ion lasers. Single beam Ž488 nm. flow cytometry has
been used to demonstrate the utility of DRAQ5-nuclear DNA fluorescence as a discriminating parameter for human
leucocytes and lymphoma cells, in combination with fluorochrome-labelled antibodies for the detection of surface antigens
and subpopulation recognition. DRAQ5 fluorescence was found to reflect cellular DNA content as evidenced by cell cycle
distribution profiles for asynchronous and cell cycle-perturbed populations. Importantly, DRAQ5 can be used in combination
with FITC and RPE-labelled antibodies, without the need for fluorescence compensation. q 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All
rights reserved.
0022-1759r99r$ - see front matter q 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 0 2 2 - 1 7 5 9 Ž 9 9 . 0 0 1 1 6 - 7
132 P.J. Smith et al.r Journal of Immunological Methods 229 (1999) 131–139
DNA content, the latter being required when cell is a cell-permeant nucleic acid stain that shows
cycle dependence or perturbation needs to be evalu- fluorescence enhancement on binding to DNA and
ated. There are a number of DNA-binding fluo- RNA. LDS-751 has been used to discriminate intact
rochromes available Žfor reviews see, Latt and Lan- nucleated cells from non-nucleated cells and despite
glois, 1990; Waggoner, 1990; Darzynkiewicz and a peak excitation at ; 543 nm on dsDNA, the
Kapuscinski, 1990. which cover the UV and visible fluorophor can be excited by the argon ion laser at
regions of the spectrum with convenient Ex l maxr 488 nm, exhibiting a far-red emission maximum
Em l max values such as: Hoechst 33258 Ž346 nmr460 ŽTerstappen et al., 1988, 1989.. LDS-751 binds to
nm., DAPI Ž350 nmr470 nm., acridine orange Ž502 double-stranded DNA and RNA and there has yet to
nmr526 nm., ethidium bromide Ž510 nmr595., pro- be any demonstration of its utility in discriminating
pidium iodide Ž536 nmr617 nm., and the recently cellular DNA content at the resolution required for
described DNA-intercalating cyanine fluorochromes cell cycle analysis although it can give adequate
TOTO 1 Ž514 nmr533 nm. and TOTO 3 Ž642 differentiation of apoptotic from non-apoptotic cells
nmr661 nm.. in a model thymocyte system ŽFrey, 1995..
Conventionally, propidium iodide is used to iden- Each of the agents discussed above has one or
tify cellular DNA content but cells need to be fixed more deficiencies which restrict their use with intact
and RNase digested. Aminoactinomycin D Ž7-AAD., cells and conventional argon ion laser-equipped flow
selective for GC-rich DNA regions, has also been cytometers as used in blood cell analysis. Accord-
used to discriminate cellular DNA content by multi- ingly, agents may lack cell permeant properties, have
parameter flow cytometry ŽRabinovitch et al., 1986.. emission spectra which overlap with those of other
Although 7-AAD can be excited by the argon-ion relevant fluorophors, lack sufficient DNA specificity
laser, emitting beyond a wavelength of 610 nm, it for critical DNA content discrimination or require
appears to be generally excluded from intact viable UV-excitation. Here we describe the characteristics
cells. The bisbenzimide dyes, Hoechst 33258 and of the new agent, DRAQ5, with properties which
Hoechst 33342, are cell-permeant, minor groove circumvent the shortcoming of other agents ŽSmith
binding DNA stains that fluoresce bright blue upon and Patterson, 1998.. DRAQ5 is a 1,5-bisw2-Žmeth-
binding to DNA. Hoechst 33342 has higher mem- ylamino .ethylxamino4 -4,8-dihydroxy anthracene-
brane permeability than Hoechst 33258, but both 9,10-dione, designed with the aid of molecular mod-
dyes require UV excitation ŽSmith et al., 1985; Wat- elling to inform the effects of side-chain composition
son et al., 1985.. on the DNA binding properties which would alter
Some SYTO nucleic acid stains ŽMolecular the intracellular fluorescence characteristics of cell
Probes, Eugene, OR; Frey et al., 1995. are character- permeant anthraquinones ŽPatterson, 1989; Smith et
istically able to penetrate intact live cells. Although al., 1997a,b.. DRAQ5 achieves nuclear discrimina-
SYTO stains can be used as visible light excitable tion by its high affinity mode of DNA intercalation
dyes for labelling DNA and RNA they do not act and the nature of its modelled base-pair specificity.
exclusively as nuclear stains in live cells and should Excitation at a wavelength of 647 nm, close to the
therefore not be equated with compounds such as Ex l max , produces a fluorescence spectrum extending
Hoechst 33258 or Hoechst 33342. Members of the from 665 nm out to beyond 780 nm wavelengths.
SYTO series have different spectral properties. In Thus the emission spectrum is beyond that of fluo-
particular some have excitation and emission spectra rescein, phycoeryrthrin, Texas Red and Cy 3. At
similar to those of fluorescein and thus cannot be high DNA:DRAQ5 ratios a spectral shift contributes
used with FITC-labelled antibodies. SYTO-16 has to a partial separation of the DRAQ5-DNA emission
been used as an apoptotic discriminator ŽFrey, 1995.. spectrum from that of Cy 5.
A red fluorescent derivative ŽSYTO 17. has excita- Preliminary studies revealed that DRAQ5 could
tionremission maxima ; 621r634 nm for the be sub-optimally activated by the 488 nm line of an
dye–nucleic acid complex, which results in a signifi- argon ion laser. Here we describe the ability of this
cant overlap with the excitationremission maxima of novel far redrinfra-red fluorescing agent to stain the
the commonly used Texas Red fluorophor. LDS-751 DNA, of viable human cells, in comparison with
P.J. Smith et al.r Journal of Immunological Methods 229 (1999) 131–139 133
LDS-751, and demonstrate its application to the cycle-arrested populations ŽWatson et al., 1987; Ep-
rapid analysis of whole and isolated blood prepara- stein et al., 1988..
tions.
2.2.2. Preparation 2
As for Preparation 1 but processed for surface
2. Materials and methods antigen analysis using directly labelled antibodies:
anti-CD45-FITC Ždetected by the FL1 photomulti-
2.1. Cell culture and treatments plier; i.e., FL1 PMT., anti-CD19-PE ŽFL2 PMT..
First a single beam low power laser excitation Scane.. Fig. 1a–d shows typical results demonstrat-
provided by the FACScan system ŽBecton Dickin- ing the ability of DRAQ5 to identify nucleated cells
son, Cowley, UK. which incorporates an argon ion in complex populations. Fig. 1a shows the detection
laser Žmax 15 mW output., tuned to the 488-nm line. of cell cycle distribution vs. cell surface antigen
Forward light scatter, 908 light scatter and fluores- expression for intact cells. Fig. 1b shows the discrim-
cence emissions ŽFL parameters. were collected for ination of subsets according to staining potential
1 = 10 4 cells using the forward light scatter ŽFSC. while Fig. 1c and d demonstrate the application of
parameter, where appropriate, as the master signal. DRAQ5 in detecting nucleated cells in whole blood
The standard analysis optics provided the FL1 and lysed blood. Factors relating to the ability of
Žgreen., FL2 Žorange., and FL3 Žred;) 650 nm. DRAQ5 to stain nuclei are analysed in Table 1.
PMT parameters with pulse analysis performed on Using viable cultured asynchronous lymphoma
the FL3 originating signals. Pulse height measure- cells ŽPreparation 1. DRAQ5 rapidly stained cells in
ments were displayed for FL1 and FL2 parameters, a reproducible manner and generated fluorescence
with pulse area for the FL3 parameter. distinct from the low autofluorescence background.
Second, to compare fluorochrome staining charac- The large standard deviation values derive from the
teristics cells were analysed using a FACS Vantage expected spread of cells throughout the cell cycle
cell sorter ŽBecton Dickinson, Cowley, UK. incorpo- Žanalyses given in footnote to Table 1.. The mean
rating a Coherent Enterprise II laser simultaneously value reflects the cellular DNA content as evidenced
emitting at multiline UV Ž350–360 nm range. and by the 1.7-fold increase for G2 arrested populations.
488 nm wavelengths with the beams made non-co- The processing of cells for surface antigen analysis
linear using dichroic separators. Forward light scat- ŽPreparation 2. does not affect the above character-
ter, 908 light scatter and fluorescence emissions were istics. The isolation of intact mononuclear blood
collected for 1 = 10 4 cells using the forward light cells ŽPreparations 3 and 4. yielded samples which
scatter parameter as the master signal from the pri- could be stained within a convenient cell density
mary 488 nm beam, while side scatter was collected range and be processed for surface antigen analysis.
through a 488r10 nm band-pass filter. The analysis In Preparations 3 and 4 we consistently observed an
optics were: Ži. primary beam-originating signals enhanced staining potential of monocytes vs. lym-
analysed at FL1 ŽFITC filter; barrier filter of 530r30 phocytes Ž1.14–1.4 fold.. It is likely that enhanced
nm. after transmission at SP610 and SP560 dichroics, staining relates to the accessibility of DNA binding
or at FL2 Žbarrier filters of 585r42 nm. after trans- sites, these differing according to cell type as has
mission at SP610 and reflection at SP560 dichroics, been observed for the Hoechst dyes ŽSmith et al.,
or at FL3 Žbarrier filter of LP715 nm. after reflection 1985.. We suggest that it is likely that optimal
at a SP610 dichroic; Žii. delayed beam-originating staining conditions have not been achieved and
signals analysed at FL4 Žbarrier filter of LP695 nm. should be investigated according to the cell type
or at FL5 Žbarrier filter of DF424r44 nm. after under investigation. However, such differences in
transmission or reflection at a LP640 dichroic, re- viable cell staining potential, if maximised, may be
spectively. Forward and 908light scatter were anal- used as a means of subpopulation discrimination.
ysed to exclude any cell debris. All parameters were The results for whole blood suggest that nucleated
analysed as pulse height using CellQuest software cells Žincluding granulocytes. can be stained to a
ŽBecton Dickinson.. similar degree in the presence ŽPreparation 5. of red
blood cells ŽRBCs. or following RBC lysis and mild
fixation ŽPreparation 6..
Fig. 2 summarises the DRAQ5 concentration-de-
pendent differences in DRAQ5 staining for viable
3. Results
cell populations obtained using Preparation methods
1 and 2. The populations show similar titration curves
We have sought to demonstrate the utility of with saturation occurring in a manner which reflects
DRAQ5 in a single beam cytometer Ži.e., a FAC- relative DNA content Žfor a given cell type, e.g.,
P.J. Smith et al.r Journal of Immunological Methods 229 (1999) 131–139 135
Fig. 1. Single beam flow cytometric analysis ŽFACScan. of DRAQ5 fluorescence ŽFL3-area. vs. antibody fluorescence ŽFL2-height
monitoring phycoerythrin-labelled anti-CD19 or FL1-height monitoring FITC-labelled anti-CD45. for cultured and blood-derived human
cells. Cell suspensions Ž2.5 = 10 5 rml. were maintained in phosphate buffered saline containing 1% bovine serum albumin. Human blood
mononuclear cell subpopulations, obtained using standard Ficoll gradient separation, were identified and gated according to their forward-
and side-light scatter characteristics. Doublets were excluded by pulse analysis gating on normal FL3-area vs. FL3-width parameter values.
Panel a: cultured asynchronous SUD4 lymphoma cells. Panel b: blood mononuclear cell subpopulations, obtained using standard Ficoll
gradient separation. Panel c: whole blood Žtriggered on CD45q events.. Panel d: lysed whole blood. Arrowed subpopulations: G1, S and
G2rM represent cell cycle phases; L, lymphocytes; M, monocytes; G, granulocytes; N, nuclei lacking plasma membranes.
SUD4. or nuclear staining potential Že.g., lympho- DNA content, and to demonstrate a far-red fluores-
cytes vs. monocytes. at concentrations of ) 10 mM. cence signature. Fig. 3 shows the intensity distribu-
We have compared the ability of DRAQ5 and tions for cells stained with DRAQ5 or LDS-751
LDS-751 to stain viable cells, provide resolution of compared with that achieved using propidium iodide
136 P.J. Smith et al.r Journal of Immunological Methods 229 (1999) 131–139
Table 1
FACScane flow cytometric analysis of DRAQ5-labelled human cells
Cell preparation and DRAQ5 exposure period Žmin. Mean fluorescence intensity Ž"SD. of gated populationa
SUD4 cells Lymphocytes Monocytes Granulocytes
b
Preparation 1: Õiable cultured cells
0 1.3 " 6.8
5 Ž1 st sample. 499.4 " 143.3
5 Ž2nd sample. 532.4 " 148.3
120 645.1 " 177.7
0 Ž0.25 mM VP-16. 6.0 " 16.6
5 Ž0.25 mM VP-16. 891.8 " 126.4
stained cells. DRAQ5 provides resolution of G1, S The fluorescence characteristics of viable SUD4
phase and G2 DNA contents of intact cells compara- cells exposed to 0.2 mgrml LDS-751 or 20 mM
ble with that obtained using propidium iodide in DRAQ were compared for two different excitation
fixed cells. There was no resolution of DNA content conditions. First, excitation at 488 nm gave mean
using LDS-751. fluorescence values of y1.6 " 3.5 and 1.8 " 1.1 for
P.J. Smith et al.r Journal of Immunological Methods 229 (1999) 131–139 137
FL1 parameter Ž530r30 nm., 70.7 " 5.3 and 13.8 "
18.3 for FL2 parameter Ž585r42 nm., 567.4 " 59.4
and 346.3 " 90.5 for FL3 parameter Ž) 715 nm.
with LDS-751 and DRAQ, respectively. Second, ex-
citation using multiline UV Ž350–360 nm. gave mean
fluorescence values of 238.7 " 27.6 and 299.6 " 67.6
for FL4 parameter Ž) 695 nm., and 0.3 " 0.1 and
0.2 " 0.1 for FL5 parameter Ž424r44 nm. with
LDS-751 and DRAQ, respectively. The results show
that both LDS-751 and DRAQ5 can be excited by
488 nm wavelength or multiline UV light with simi-
lar far-red emission intensities. There were no signif-
icant signals, beyond the autofluorescence back-
ground, obtained from DRAQ5 monitored by the Fig. 3. Typical DNA content distributions ŽFL3., analysed by flow
FL1 and FL5 detectors. For blue line excitation there cytometry ŽFACS Vantage. of LDS-751 Žbroken line. or DRAQ5
are significant levels of LDS-751-associated cellular Žbold line. stained viable SUD4 cells. The fine line shows the
fluorescence monitored by the FL2 parameter overlayed distribution, obtained at lower FL3 amplifier settings
for ethanol-fixed propidium-iodide stained cells.
Ž585r42 nm. while the ‘‘breakthrough’’ signal in
this region is 5-fold lower for DRAQ5 and not
4. Discussion
Žintact cells. and intensive staining Ždamaged cells. role for DRAQ5 in the expanding area of flow
could be distinguished. This approach was extended cytoenzymology, particularly for the monitoring of
to a method for immunofluorescence measurements cell cycle-related enzyme activity or reporter gene
of cells by flow cytometry which does not require expression.
washing procedures, permitting absolute enumeration Supported in part by research grants from the
of cell subpopulations ŽTerstappen et al., 1989.. High Association for International Cancer Research
resolution analysis, approaching or surpassing that of ŽAICR. and the UK Medical Research Council.
propidium iodide, does not appear to be feasible with
LDS-751 although it has been used for the quantifi-
cation by flow cytometry of function-associated anti-
gens on neutrophils and monocytes in unlysed, un- References
fixed, peripheral blood samples ŽMcCarthy and
Macey, 1993.. These workers also pointed out the Darzynkiewicz, Z., Kapuscinski, J., 1990. Acridine orange: a
advantage of avoiding potential artefacts that can versatile probe of nucleic acids and other cellular constituents.
occur due to the use of fixatives, erythrocyte lysing In: Melamed, M.R., Lindmo, T., Mendelsohn, M.L. ŽEds..,
Flow Cytometry and Sorting, 2nd edn. Wiley-Liss, New York,
agents, or anticoagulants which are also divalent p. 291.
metal ion chelators. These advantages also apply to Epstein, R.J., Watson, J.V., Smith, P.J., 1988. Subpopulation
the use of DRAQ5 in whole blood preparations. induced cell-cycle delay in human tumor cells using 908 light
The comparison of LDS-751 and DRAQ5 reveals scatter. Cytometry 9, 349.
the lack of DNA content discrimination achieved by Frey, T., 1995. Nucleic acid dyes for detection of apoptosis in live
cells. Cytometry 21, 265.
the former together with its significant ‘‘contamina- Frey, T., Yue, S., Haugland, R.P., 1995. Dyes providing increased
tion’’ of emission wavelength regions below 600 nm sensitivity in flow-cytometric dye-efflux assays for multidrug
which would require electronic compensation. These resistance. Cytometry 20, 218.
disadvantages were not apparent with DRAQ5. Latt, S.A., Langlois, R.G., 1990. Fluorescent probes of DNA
We have recently determined that DRAQ5 inter- microstructure and DNA synthesis. In: Melamed, M.R.,
Lindmo, T., Mendelsohn, M.L. ŽEds.., Flow Cytometry and
action with DNA by intercalation is accompanied by Sorting, 2nd edn. Wiley-Liss, New York, p. 249.
a red-shifted emission spectrum which potentially McCarthy, D.A., Macey, M.G., 1993. A simple flow cytometric
enhances its utility as a far redrlow infra-red probe procedure for the determination of surface antigens on unfixed
if used in combination with visible range fluo- leucocytes in whole blood. J. Immunol. Methods 163, 155.
rochromes ŽPJS; unpublished data.. Furthermore, Patterson, L.H., 1989. Anthraquinone anticancer compounds with
Ždisubstituted amino-N-oxide.alkylamino substituent. UK
there appears to be little contribution to the fluores- Patent GB 2 237 283.
cence of whole cells originating from interaction Rabinovitch, P.S., Torres, R.M., Engel, D., 1986. Simultaneous
with RNA, and the resolution of DNA content distri- cell cycle analysis and two-color surface immunofluorescence
bution is similar to that achieved by propidium io- using 7-amino-actinomycin D and single laser excitation: ap-
dide staining of fixed cells. Here we have demon- plications to study of cell activation and the cell cycle of
murine Ly-1 B cells. J. Immunol. 136, 2769.
strated its utility in the analysis of nucleated cells in Smith, P.J., Patterson, L.H., 1998. An anthraquinone and its
whole blood and density gradient-separated blood derivatives. British Patent Application No. 9813062.8.
cell preparations using a conventional bench-top flow Smith, P.J., Blunt, N.J., Desnoyers, R., Giles, Y., Patterson, L.H.,
cytometer equipped with a standard low power argon 1997a. DNA topoisomerase II dependent cytotoxicity of alky-
laminoanthraquinones and their N-oxides. Cancer
ion laser. DRAQ5 could also be considered as a
Chemotherap. Pharmacol. 39, 455.
fluorochrome used in the calibration, standardisation, Smith, P.J., Desnoyers, R., Blunt, N., Giles, Y., Patterson, L.H.,
and configuration of such systems given that no 1997b. Flow cytometric analysis and confocal imaging of
compensation correction is required for DRAQ5r anticancer alkylaminoanthraquinones and their N-oxides in
FITC combinations. Furthermore, we suggest that intact human cells using 647 nm Krypton laser excitation.
Cytometry 27, 43.
the introduction of bench-top systems incorporating
Smith, P.J., Nakeff, A., Watson, J.V., 1985. Flow-cytometric
inexpensive red-light emitting sources will permit detection of changes in the fluorescence emission spectrum of
the further exploitation of the novel fluorescence a vital DNA-specific dye in human tumour cells. Exp. Cell
signature of DRAQ5 in cellular studies. We foresee a Res. 159, 37.
P.J. Smith et al.r Journal of Immunological Methods 229 (1999) 131–139 139
Terstappen, L.W., Meiners, H., Loken, M.R., 1989. A rapid Melamed, M.R., Lindmo, T., Mendelsohn, M.L. ŽEds.., Flow
sample preparation technique for flow cytometric analysis of Cytometry and Sorting, 2nd edn. Wiley-Liss, New York, p.
immunofluorescence allowing absolute enumeration of cell 209.
subpopulations. J. Immunol. Methods 123, 103. Watson, J.V., Chambers, S.H., Smith, P.J., 1987. A pragmatic
Terstappen, L.W., Shah, V.O., Conrad, M.P., Recktenwald, D., approach to the analysis of flow cytometric DNA histogram
Loken, M.R., 1988. Discriminating between damaged and data. Cytometry 8, 1.
intact cells in fixed flow cytometric samples. Cytometry 9, Watson, J.V., Nakeff, A., Chambers, S.H., Smith, P.J., 1985.
477. Fluorescence emission spectrum analysis of chicken thymo-
Waggoner, A.S., 1990. Fluorescent probes for cytometry. In: cytes using Hoechst-33342. Cytometry 6, 310.