Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this study is to understand the reason for reverse migration into
approach. The data was collected through face to face interview method using a
answer for the migrant workers to return to their native places and evaluate
Dehradun city in the Uttrakhand state. The Exploratory factor analysis and the
analyze the ground reality of reverse migration. Factors that were identified in
this study were emotional causes, loss of employment, health, and hygiene.
This study has concluded and suggests migrant workers cope with the change
2
INTRODUCTION
ABOUT COVID-19
no vaccine or anti-drug has been found yet to prevent human infection. Social
distancing is only one tool that can prevent coronavirus from spreading.
Birth of Coronavirus
The official sources have reported that the birth of COVID- 19 took place in the
Wuhan city of China near the seafood market, where transmission of the virus
to human was first traced. The World Health Organisation (WHO) has declared
that the novel coronavirus outbreak had led to public health emergency of
January 2020.
Black clouds are blowing in the world due to COVID-19. It has thrown up
sectors, which had been grappling with a downturn for the last five years, had
started seeing some green shoots of recovery earlier this year. However, the
coronavirus and lockdown have led to a slump in their sales, halt operation,
3
Lockdown Interpretation and Its Effects:
regions face penury and deprivation as economic activity grinds to a halt due to
developing nations.
statistical data reports. The outbreak of lethal COVID-19 has brought India
along with other countries around the world to a standstill. The government of
India had announced its first lockdown for 21 days starting from 25 th March to
14th April to control the spread of this pandemic. A rising number of confirmed
cases had forced the government to extend lockdown for the safety of the
shattered, all schools closed, restaurants and hotels shut, millions were
without jobs, and closure of all places of worship. There was the prohibition of
activities.
All shops and services were closed except hospitals, banks, grocery,
pharmacies, and other essential services. All private establishments were closed
and had started doing work from their home. The poor have been hit like never
before and the middle class too will soon begin to crumble. The nationwide
worker’s force nation after China. COVID-19 Pandemic and the resultant
lockdown strategy has affected everyone [ CITATION Ton20 \l 16393 ] . However, the
4
impact has been prominent on the lives of the migrant workers. The lockdown
brought the lives of migrant workers to a pause, as they had no work to do, nor
were they able to return to their places of origin. This is aggravated by the fact
that some of them are not able to meet their basic necessity due to the financial
crisis. Earlier Indian workers had been going abroad for purposes of
believe that the availability of Indian workers is relatively economical. But this
pandemic led to the global recession in the demand and supply of the
workforce.
Ground Reality and Problems which Migrants workers have been facing:
the backbone of our nation’s economy and GDP. These commercial sectors
employ lakhs of workers. But lockdown forces factories and other commercial
causal and uncontracted workers, and people who rely on their daily wages to
meet their daily necessities. Lakhs of people live with this reality throughout
their lives.
They were engaged in construction or daily wage work, with an average earning
Pradesh, Tamil Naidu, Chandigarh, West Bengal, and many others are hub
areas of industries, factories, companies where lakhs of people came all across
India for employment purpose. But in lockdown, workers were receiving the
are not able to make payments to workers they often have neither savings to
5
cushion them against sustained economic disruption nor employment
Despite the government have appealed that all employers should give full wages
and salaries to their workers in the period of lockdown. Still, many employers
were unable to pay daily wages to workers. Indian migrant workers during the
COVID-19 pandemic have faced multiple adversities. They begin their journey
in the scorching heat, wearing a rubber slipper at their feet with heavy bags on
their shoulder, had decided to leave the city with their family members, and
return to their native places. There is no transport facility for them to start their
journey. The only thing that is reflecting is sorrow and pain in their eyes, which
compel them to walk long distances to reach their native place(destination). The
journey towards home was paralyzed for most of the cases, where dozens of
migrant workers had died on their way due to starvation, suicides, exhaustion,
road and rail accidents, police brutality, and denial of timely medical care .
It’s a difficult journey because it is very long and tough. Perhaps that’s why it is
called the longest march in India. Since then, the government has announced
palliation measures for migrant workers and made arrangements for migrants
to return to their native places. The Supreme Court of India, while recognizing
included Ashok Bhushan, S.K Shah, M.R Shah. After this order, the Ministry
6
of Home Affairs had finally directed the Indian Railways to start the Shramik
providing free services to them. But for the ticket, they had paid money. Besides
this, the migrant workers had also stood in a long queue for their registrations,
form fillings, and also to get themselves a fitness certificate from the doctor. The
most painful thing was to happen in this adverse situation that doctors were
taking money for fitness certificates. Workers didn’t have enough money. They
felt helpless and miserable. Additionally, they felt that going back to their native
land, they could return to farming or take up small jobs under the Mahatma
is Indian labour law and social security measure that purpose is to provide
In cities where they were working before, they had no assurance of their job.
There was no food to fill their stomach, not enough resources to bear the rent
burdens and with this, they also had to maintain social distancing with an
average of 5 people in a 10/10 ft. room. India has been struggling with
magnification are not new in COVID-19, but India had been facing these
problems for the last many years. Before this pandemic, migration meaning was
to shift from a place of residence to a place where they could work for some
has a great impact on the economic status as well as, social, cultural, and
psychological life of people [ CITATION Kau111 \l 16393 ] . But now India is facing a
7
problem of reverse migration. After a long tolerance of lockdown, reverse
migration has been seen where migrant workers were returning to their native
Even today, if we think about the misery and struggle which people had faced
at the time of partition between India and Pakistan in 1947, where migration
took place to a large extent, we have tears in our eyes. It was a painful and
nostalgic time in our history. That partition bought morph into a fatal situation
The Indian economy recently had badly been affected by the past event of
Narendra Modi Ji, to curb out black money and convert old currency into the
new currency. Due to a lack of proper planning and strategy, it’s consequences
were not that effective, which was expected before taking its decision. As we all
know that black money is bad but it creates employment opportunities for
lakhs of workers.
opportunities. Businesses and jobs are affected at the macro level within the
country. Still, India recovers slowly from its adverse effect, but now the country
is facing a more stringent and complex problem i.e. COVID-19. It enhances the
8
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
workers which helps to ensure equity and social justice, (ii) the government
should adopt complete measures for migrants who are experiencing loss in
income during the pandemic, (iii) to make sure better medical care services, free
access to testing and screening and wide range of social protection to migrant
coterie and worksite housing, (v) provide migrant workers all legitimate panacea
countries, ILO assists and support Migrant Worker Resource Centres and
related to COVID-19, help them to realize their labour right, training, and
published guidance for member states for the implementation of the regulation
9
Recommendations on Recruitment provide assistance and direction to
and employment.
were used to fulfill the objectives. The following methods were qualitative
employment, and wages. This report also designed voluntary migrants. They
10
Meenakshi Thapan (2014) showed a reason for the fact that women migrated
to Jamia Nagar in Delhi for leading a more fulfilling life. Evidence is drawn in
Oded Stark, Dorn Agnieszka (2013) designed a model that defines the
possibility of employment in a developed country that increases the level of
their livelihood with the Green Revolution. The state largely depends on migrant
permanent and seasonal labour from outside Punjab. In their research, they
research were average, percentages. Besides this t-test was used to find the
existence of a difference between the wage rates for the agricultural operation of
11
RESEARCH GAP
There are many studies available relating to the migration of workers in various
states of India, but hardly any study is available on workers who are
penetrating from their places of work to their native places all over India during
the novel pandemic. Therefore an effort will be made to study factors that have
12
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
RESEARCH DESIGN
framework that provides direction to the investigation being carried out more
efficiently. After several reviews of literature and some empirical researches, the
exploratory research design was applied to fulfill the study’s framework and
DATA COLLECTION
For this present research, both primary and secondary data are collected and
ground reality.
13
SAMPLE PLAN AND SAMPLE UNIT
In this present study, the sample plan comprises of the migrant workers in
SAMPLE SIZE
The sample size for the research work is covering 210 respondents out of which
only 172 have given complete responses. It may be noted in the study that the
sample size is more than 5 times the number of variables (eleven). Data is
personally visited to understand the true gravity of migrant workers, who were
returning to their home more closely and also filled questionnaire by personally
MEASUREMENT OF FACTORS
In the study, all determinants causing movement of migrant workers from their
seven-point Likert scale, ranging from 7(very highly agree), 6(highly agree),
14
DATA ANALYSIS AND ITS INTERPRETATION
along with the rotation approach of Varimax for summarising the real
According to (Hair, Black, Babin, Anderson & Tatham,2010; Joti & Arora,
2013) items with factors loadings minimum than 0.5 will be not considered in
technique was used to assist in exploring the independent factors for knowing a
three factors which were the actual causes of migrant workers returning to
their native places. These causes were emotions, health, hygiene, and loss of
(migrant workers sample). Further, Bartlett’s test of sphericity testing for the
connected to the chi-square statistic. The p-value is 000, which is less than
0.05, the expected level of significance had indicated the rejection of the null
loading and extracted commonalities for all the factors is above 0.5. The EFA
15
Table 1: Exploratory Factor Analysis
Component
1 2 3
MULTIPLE REGRESSION
variables (loss of employment, emotional causes, and health and hygiene cause)
which have a positive linear relationship with dependent variable I,e Migration
of workers who had returned to their native places. Regression results are
presented in Table 2 which indicates that 37.8 percent of the variation in the
Further table 3 reflecting the coefficient of all the three factors is significant.
Model Summary
Adjusted R
Model R R Square Square Std. Error of the Estimate
16
Table 3: Multiple Regression Coefficients
Coefficients
Standardized
Unstandardized Coefficients Coefficients
RELIABILITY
The reliability of all the factors has been scrutinized through Cronbach’s alpha.
The value of Cronbach alpha equal to or greater than 0.70 indicate good
this research are greater than 0.70 which indicates that the scales are truly
reliable.
17
CAUSES WHICH COMPELLED MIGRANT WORKERS TO
DISPLACEMENT
The following are the main causes that compelled migrant workers to be
Emotional Cause:
The migrants are more vulnerable to the emotional, social, and psychological
ordeal in this critical situation which creates fear of negativity due to ignorance
of the local community and concerns about the well-being of their families and
safety at their native places. Stress and trauma have been robustly associated
with the risk of mental disorders of migrant workers. In this adverse scenario,
they had missed their families which had compelled them to go back to their
native land. The study has been surveyed that lakhs of migrant workers from
Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, and many other states in India left their families who
were living in a vernacular place and had shifted to the city for employment or
some left for enhancing the standard of living, better education, and lifestyle of
their children but due to lack of their basic and social needs, they were
compelled to shift back to their families in the native land because they know in
their village they will get food and love of their family members. A study reveals
that migrant workers were facing stress or trauma due to the crisis and
18
care), esteem needs(prestige, feelings of accomplishment), self-actualization
Loss of employment:
their native places. Migrants belong to the most marginalized sections of the
society who are dependent on daily wages for their living, and in times of such
distress, need the sympathy and understanding of the community. But they
had lost confidence and trust in their employers because they had abandoned
them in this adverse situation without paying wages or salaries. They were
struggling with the problem related to food, shelter, healthcare, fear of getting
an infection, loss of wages, concerns about the family, fear, and anxiety (Singh,
2020). Sometimes, they had also faced harassment and the bad reaction of
their local community. With a little chunk of savings in their hand, they had
decided to return to their native land with this belief that in their villages or
cities at least they have their families and land to grow crops or with help of
Health and hygiene is one of the most important element for every living being.
The study after the survey through a structured questionnaire reveals that the
migrant workers were unable to get proper food, water, and proper nutrition
in 10/10 ft. room with a lack of proper sanitation system, ventilation, and
difficulty for them to maintain social distance in this pandemic where the virus
19
is spreading contagious from one human to another human. They had no
guide migrant workers to start up their new business idea into operation.
elevation of the gig economy will help in reshaping the overall economy of
more special economic zones in the backward areas and this will
2. The government must make sure that all workers must enroll themselves
20
their aadhar cards and ration cards. Besides this, there will be many
in which all workers should be enrolled. In this welfare fund, the equal
attention to the health and hygiene of workers. They must take care of
(a) Daily proper sanitization at every place within the premises of work.
(d) Provide adequate facilities like tissues, soaps, and alcohol-based sanitizers
(e) Spread awareness among workers about the severe pandemic and giving
frequently washing their hands, avoiding close contact with people, etc.
(f) Ask them to download various government apps like Aarogya Setu, etc.
Employers must make sure that they comply with all guidelines and directions
prescribed by WHO for the safety and well being of the human being.
formalities for those workers who want to make a reverse entry from their
21
5. The Finance Minister Smt. Nirmala Sitharaman had announced
the fight against COVID-19. In this reform, the Government had considered
migrant workers regarding their basic necessity. But there are some important
aspects which must be considered immediately for the livelihood of workers and
their families. The government has to use escape velocity through this Abhiyan
up their business in micro and small level or buy economical agriculture land
in their native city to grow crops and feed themselves and their families and
earn normal profit which will help them to cross Break-even point level. This
will help them to save money because in their native places they have less
22
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Company, M. &. (2016). People On The Move: Global Migration's Impact And
https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/McKinsey/Featured
%20Insights/Employment%20and%20Growth/Global%20migrations
%20impact%20and%20opportunity/MGI-People-on-the-Move-Full-
report.ashx
Ekkanad, S. (2020, April 13). COVID-19 In India: The Shunned & The Forgotten
https://feminisminindia.com/2020/04/13/covid-19-india-shunned-
forgotten-migrant-workers/
Hair, J. W. (2010). Multivariate data analysis (7th Ed.). NJ: Pearson Prentice
Hall.
ed_protect/---protrav/---migrant/documents/publication/wcms_743268.pdf
23
IOM. (2020). IOM Releases Global Guidance on International Recruitment and
https://www.iom.int/news/iom-releases-global-guidance-international-
recruitment-and-protection-migrant-workers
file:///C:/Users/Resistrar/Downloads/12-Baljinder-kaur%20(2).pdf
%20of%20migrant%20research%20paper%20sci%20hub/12-Baljinder-
kaur%20migrant%20workersvvvy%20important%20tool.pdf
http://ssrn.com/abstract=2211503
and Opportunities. Wiley Online Library. Retrieved June 11, 2020, from
https://publons.com/publon/10.1111/imig.12737
24
Purohit, K. (2020). India COVID-19 lockdown means no food or work for rural
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/04/india-covid-19-lockdown-
means-food-work-rural-poor-200402052048439.html
Standards, I. (2020). ILO Standards and COVID-19. Retrieved May 29, 2020,
from https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_norm/---
normes/documents/genericdocument/wcms_739937.pdf
Retrieved from
file:///C:/Users/Resistrar/Downloads/EncyclopeadiaEntry-
TheeffectofWorldWarIIonMigration.pdf
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.1525-1499,1997,00076,x.
25
26