Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
TABLE OF CASE STUDIES
Relevancy to Manchester Connect Recommendations
Kit
Case Study Location Loop + Land Use +
Number Placemaking Organization
Riverwalk Parking
Access Portsmouth Portsmouth, NH 1
•
Amsterdam Light Festival Amsterdam,
Netherlands
3
• •
Armory Reuse Various 2
•
Butler Trail Austin, TX 1
• •
Creative Portland Portland, MD 4
• •
Detroit Creative Corridor Center Detroit, MI 4
•
Discovery Green Houston, TX 2
• •
Hamilton Canal Innovation District
(HCID)
Lowell, MA 2
• •
Iconic Placemaking Various 3
• •
Larkinville Buffalo, NY 2
• •
Metcalfe Park Sydney, Australia 3
• •
Parking and Investment Portsmouth, NH 2
•
Paths to Pier 42 New York City, NY 3
• •
Riverwalk and Waterplace Park Providence, RI 1
• •
Schuylkill River Trail Philadelphia, PA 1
• •
Spruce Street Harbor Park Philadelphia, PA 3
• •
StreetsAlive! Moorhead, MN 1
• •
The Church Street Marketplace Burlington, VT 3
• •
Three Rivers Revitalization Pittsburgh, PA 1
• •
Unified Parking Districts Various 2
•
Unusual Passages Quebec City, QC 1
• •
Walkway over the Hudson Poughkeepsie, NY 1
• •
Wintertime Public Space Activation Buffalo, NY and
Philadelphia, PA
3
•
4 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
WHAT IS PLACEMAKING?
The term placemaking is used in a variety of ways by various people. The terms
activation, placemaking, and programming are used interchangeably in this plan. At
its heart, placemaking is about using a multi-faceted grassroots approach to create
places that are enjoyable for people to work, live, and play.
immigrant hub, or a magnet for high-tech for innovative technology, whether it’s a
business. fountain lit by LEDs, public Wi-Fi networks,
or a solar-powered bus shelter that
Goals include: recharges portable devices. Manchester
• Bring life to the Downtown and benefits from an active arts scene, a
Millyard area, fostering greater talented pool of local students, and its
vibrancy own mini-Silicon Valley in the Millyard,
• Provide alluring spaces for community all of which can contribute to vibrant
activities/gatherings placemaking opportunities.
• Define separate, but complementary,
identities for the Millyard, Downtown, Goals include:
and West Side • Showcase innovative technologies
(especially those developed in
2. Placemaking offers multiple Manchester)
opportunities to showcase art and • Increase visibility of public art
innovation. Downtown, in the Millyard, and West
Placemaking often makes use of arts and Side
culture; features like beautiful murals, • Provide more opportunities for local
open-air concerts, or even sculptural artists, performers, etc. to share their
bike racks draw people’s attention and work with the public
generate further activity. The same goes
6 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
others are the ones who have the most to Community involvement contributes to the
offer—and the greatest stake in—the three success of placemaking efforts. Publicizing
placemaking themes of creating a sense events, planning activities, providing
of identity, showcasing art and innovation, new public space features, or installing
and connecting people to places. The temporary installations can all be critical
City, Board of Mayor and Aldermen, and first steps—but don’t overlook things like
various municipal departments also have coordinated signage and hand-outs on-site,
the opportunity to contribute to and play a featuring the Manchester Connects logo
large role in placemaking. At a minimum, and explaining what the placemaking event
the City should support stakeholders in or feature is. Always include a sign-in sheet
placemaking initiatives including Intown or another way for people to volunteer, get
Manchester, NHIA, the Millyard Museum, involved, or learn more.
and other community organizations (and
organizers). The City of Manchester’s Finally, follow through is important.
Department of Planning, the Department Send out a survey asking what kind of
of Public Works, Parks and Recreation event residents want to see next, or invite
Department, and Arts Commission volunteers to assist with painting a mural,
all should play a role in facilitating and evaluate attendance and responses
placemaking. Members of the Manchester to make sure your placemaking efforts are
Connects working group will also be achieving the desired results.
involved, as will businesses and property
owners from the Millyard and Downtown, Think about the best ways to connect to
particularly those interested in enlivening specific groups of community members—
their first-floor commercial spaces, whether it’s younger people, bicycling
attracting new tenants, or contributing enthusiasts, Millyard employees, or recent
amenities to the surrounding area. immigrants. Placemaking in many cities
and neighborhoods brings people from all
walks of life together; Manchester is no
exception!
Stakeholders in placemaking initiatives include Intown Manchester, NHIA, the Millyard Museum, and
other community organizations (and organizers), as well as the City of Manchester’s Department of
Planning, Department of Public Works, Parks and Recreation Department, and Arts Commission, and
individual residents passionate about one or more of those themes.
Source: CivicMoxie
8 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
WINTERTIME PUBLIC SPACE ACTIVATION
Buffalo, NY and Philadelphia, PA
Buffalo, NY and Philadelphia, PA are and sledding options… It’s time to
two examples of cities that embrace the embrace our well-known wintry
winter months and program activities to reputation and tell the world about all
suit the cold weather. Each city features the fun we have this time of year; we
a variety of weekend festivals and couldn’t be more thrilled to collaborate
temporary winter-month public space with our tourism partners to create these
installations. Through these activities, Winter Weekends.” With a wide range of
residents are enticed to bundle up with activities, Buffalo Winter Weekends is a
scarves, mittens, and coats, and leave magnet for young and old alike.
their homes to embrace the winter fun.
Philadelphia has similar programming.
Near Buffalo’s downtown waterfront, For four months of the year beginning
the city hosts a series of events titled in late November, Penn’s Landing is
Buffalo Winter Weekends. These events transformed into a winterized riverfront
are planned via a collaborative effort by park. Blue Cross RiverRink Winterfest,
Visit Buffalo Niagara, Erie Canal Harbor an event that has been going on for over
Development Corporation, HarborCenter, twenty years, features an Olympic-size
Buffalo RiverWorks, Niagara Frontier skating rink, ski chalet-style lodges,
Transportation Authority and many others. winter beer gardens made from recycled
Recently, the three main waterfront shipping containers, a heated tent, fire
destinations (Canalside, RiverWorks, pits, and an abundance of cozy seating.
and Larkinville) worked together for the The event is a must-see winter attraction
first time to collaboratively promote for the area, with dozens of family-
their events. Patrick Kaler, Visit Buffalo friendly activities and delicious food
Niagara’s President and CEO, said, and cocktails, which leaves residents
“…. from one of the country’s largest and visitors no choice but to come out
outdoor rinks at Canalside to the Ice and join the fun. RiverRink Winterfest
Bikes of Buffalo, curling at RiverWorks, is made possible by Visit Philadelphia,
tobogganing at Chestnut Ridge and a Philadelphia Magazine, Blue Cross and
number of nearby skiing, snowshoeing Blue Shield, and many others.
Source: www.visitphilly.com/events/philadelphia/waterfront-winterfest-at-penns-landing/
10 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
governments, which has existed for over
a decade to manage the large Riverpark
system on a daily basis. Hamilton County
Mayor Claude Ramsey explains: “By
agreement, the City of Chattanooga
and Hamilton County share the ongoing
cost of maintenance, security, and
programming for these wonderful public
places. Fortunately, the elected officials
in both Chattanooga and Hamilton
County realize the critical importance
the Riverpark has on improving our local of Eastside and College Hill are now a dominant symbol in this part of town.
quality of life.” The acknowledgment connected to the downtown via 12 new The pedestrian-centered bridge not only
of the Riverpark’s importance by the pedestrian and vehicular bridges. By connects the two riverbanks, allowing
City propels its success forward, as the expanding pedestrian access to the people to easily cross, but also features
Riverpark continues to be a lively public riverfront, more residents are able to an observation deck in the top of The
space for Hamilton County residents to enjoy the beautiful sites and plentiful Loop. This attraction provides unique
enjoy. shops and eateries that Providence has views of Amsterdam. The café in the
to offer. observation deck invites visitors to sit,
Riverwalk and Waterplace Park visit with one another, and linger. The
(Providence, RI) Amstel Loop Footbridge (Amsterdam, iconic design of the Amstel Loop instantly
The completion of the Riverwalk and Netherlands) draws the attention of anyone passing
Waterplace Park in 1994 marked the In 2011, Amsterdam launched a design by, transforming a simple pedestrian
rebirth of a historic urban center in competition for a new pedestrian bridge. connection into a vibrant public space that
Providence, RI. The return to an open The proposed designs not only needed to is a destination as well as a connector.
air river and the relocation of I-195 from reflect contemporary design tendencies
the downtown transformed Downtown but also needed to take the location and
Providence. A large public works project, the surrounding urban neighborhood into
which included two public parks along the consideration. In addition to providing a
river, a series of pedestrian bridges linking new pedestrian connection from one side
the east and west neighborhoods, and of the bridge to the other, the goal was to
a large central plaza, Waterplace Park create a new architectural symbol for the
reconnected the city to the waterfront city. The competition organizers thought
and invigorated a new sense of identity that an iconic bridge would generate
in Downtown Providence. To encourage discussion about the intersection of
activity along the new corridor, the City infrastructure and arts and sculpture.
implemented a series of programs and
activities including public art, concerts The Amstel Loop, designed by Evgeni
and festivals, pop-up markets, and Leonov Architects, won the competition.
Waterfire – a river festival that brings The design stood out from other
40,000 people to the downtown during submissions because of its focus on
fall and spring weekends. vertical as well as horizontal space. Most
other submissions presented horizontal
Today, Downtown Providence boasts 1.5 solutions. The height of the bridge
miles of Riverwalk and 11 acres of urban allows it to be seen from different places
riverfront parkland. The neighborhoods throughout the City, quickly making it
Source: CivicMoxie
12 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
and reviving former initiatives. Thanks to The map and list on the previous page
Intown Manchester, NHIA, UNH, SNHU, show that most of the placemaking and
and others, things are happening! The events that occur in Manchester today are
map here illustrates what was occurring located in Downtown. Very few events and
in Manchester as of Summer 2017 and activities happen in the Millyard. The map
categorizes events according to the season and table on the next page are presented
in which they occur. The varied weather as a menu of possible sites for activities,
is an important consideration when taking public art, events, gathering spaces, etc.
a placemaking approach to ensure the
public realm remains as vibrant as possible These sites can host placemaking activities
throughout the year. individually or be grouped together
depending upon the event planned or
Many of the city’s existing public spaces the space needed. For instance, Sites A
and events are already located downtown through L could be combined for a River
(from the farmer’s market right next to Fest where access to the river and the
NHIA to the summer concert series hosted adjacent parking areas provide space
at Veteran’s Park by Intown Manchester). for food trucks, children’s activities, and
Placemaking efforts should build on music. Likewise, Sites N or O (or both)
this momentum. However, the lack of could be the location for a Ciclovia-type
placemaking in the Millyard is an indication event in which the streets are closed to
of a high level of need for more vibrancy. vehicular traffic each Sunday and cyclists,
Many of the recommendations in this Kit roller bladers, pedestrians, and tricycle
focus on the Millyard and Riverfront to riders are invited to take over the streets
support this area as a destination, provide for the day. The possibilities are endless…
things to do for workers after 5pm, and limited only by imagination, energy, and
to utilize vast parking areas for more funding. Because the focus should be
lively purposes on weekends. Focusing on making things happen, this Action
on Millyard and Riverfront placemaking Kit offers the basics on the sites here to
can help enliven the mostly single-use take the guesswork out of things such as
Millyard. The potential sites recommended ownership, size of the site, etc. The goal
here include smaller-scale events that is to eventually have a well-oiled system
enliven underutilized spaces, opportunities in which each site is understood for its
to showcase public art and sculpture, and pros and cons regarding particular events
ways to activate the Millyard beyond its or activities, that property owners are on
typical 9 to 5 weekday work and class board with placemaking, and that the
schedule. The suggestions offered here City provides streamlined permitting to
also derive from community input provided make this all as easy as possible. Then,
at public meetings and working group placemakers can focus on event concepts,
sessions, highlighting important places or fundraising, and execution–all things that
suggesting ideas for activation. take time and effort!
14 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
POTENTIAL PLACEMAKING SITES
Source: CivicMoxie
The spaces are identified…now what? While the possibilities might be endless, there are certain activities and attributes of placemaking
that are common themes. Open space, movable furniture/seating, public art, music, food trucks, beer gardens, and movie nights are a
few of the activities that have typical site layouts, design considerations, and space needs. The following menu of placemaking options is
meant to help match activities/public realm design with the spaces available and the placemaking goals so that things can move forward
with as much ease as possible.
16 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
Temporary Art Installations Concerts + Cultural Festivals
From murals on plywood Manchester hosted Riverfest
to temporary sculptures at one time and people still
and sidewalk chalk painting talk of the success of that
contests, temporary art events event. The riverfront is an ideal
can create an appreciation of site for a weekend cultural or
public art and attract varied music festival. These events
participants from children to are often recurring…drawing
artists and everyone in between. larger crowds and spillover
The temporary nature of the smaller activities before and
art—those street chalk drawings after the main music days…
won’t last long—creates an all things that help local
urgency to view that can draw businesses.
crowds and support energy and
high visibility…all good things
for Elm Street and the Millyard,
particularly on quiet weekends.
In a very tangible way, placemaking creates more activity points on the Manchester
map. Momentum is built for more connections, and placemaking can improve
multimodal access and connectivity by not only creating the need for those
connections but by then supporting infrastructure improvements needed to improve
traffic, circulation, and parking. It’s a virtuous cycle…places people want to be, with
things people want to do, strengthens the web of connections which is all about
mobility. Better mobility supports these places and activities.
18 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
MANCHESTER CONNECTS CONCEPT MAP
OWNERSHIP
Source: CivicMoxie
20 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
METHOD FOR TACTICAL URBANISM
Source: CivicMoxie
substantial bricks and mortar projects the strong art ethos of the city and the
• Transform public space to make it existence of educational institutions
more user-friendly, more beautiful, and cultural organizations. In this case,
more welcoming, and/or better fitting the stated goal may be to “establish
an image of the community, town, or Manchester as a city associated with art
city excellence and celebrate the arts and
• Create a new image for a place cultural institutions and organizations in the
• Incentivize investment and increase city.” A perusal of the map might help one
property values identify locations where each goal can be
• Support businesses through easier carried out.
work force recruitment or through
increased foot traffic A specific location can also be the driving
• Support residential uses by making factor. If the desire is to enhance the
places more user-friendly and livable Downtown’s image as a place to live, a
• Strengthen connections between collaborative group of residential property
existing places owners could work with the City and
• Test innovations in technology for Millyard owners to identify interventions
wider community use in public and semi-public places that
• Support public art invite people to sit, walk dogs, etc. Using
the map on the previous page with the
Goals are intrinsically tied to place. In list of potential sites and identifying goals
Manchester, a goal might be to celebrate for that location, placemaking spots can
Sources: www.wilmatakesabreak.nl
22 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
be discussed and the property owners and availability. For small projects (chair
approached about possibilities. bombings, sidewalk art, etc.) one or two
people may do it all. For larger projects,
When placemaking or tactical urbanism some or all of the following roles must be
occurs on private property, written filled:
agreements with property owners are
usually created covering permitting, • Project Lead/Manager
liability, restrictions, sponsorship wording, • Liaisons to Community Partners
etc. These agreements also outline • Permitting and DPW Liaison
who will be responsible for maintaining • Marketing and Promotion
or repairing temporary installations or • Fundraising (and perhaps Volunteer
structures. Coordinator)
2. Bring all Potential Partners and Many of the most successful placemaking
Collaborators to the Table and Create a projects are collaborative efforts bringing
Work Plan together organizations, public agencies,
Most events and placemaking efforts and private entities such as residents and
require multiple partners and collaborations businesses to achieve a common goal. But
with individuals, businesses, and to make sure everything is coordinated and
organizations. In addition, the City of running smoothly, one person needs to be
Manchester may be very involved in in charge.
planning because permits will be necessary
for most events. There are three basic 3. Financial Strategy, Fundraising, and
questions you should ask: Reliance On Volunteer Help
All placemaking projects need a budget.
1. What is the purpose of the event? A spreadsheet with a first pass on all
anticipated costs is valuable as the first
2. Who is the intended audience?
step toward a financially responsible and
3. Who can collaborate and bring viable project. It can often be helpful to
resources to the effort? contact a public agency of non-profit that
has done something similar and get a
It is good planning to ensure that everyone previous budget from which to work.
who has something to offer is fully involved
from day one. This avoids surprises and Consider the costs of permits and materials
ensures your event has sufficient resources ranging from tents and extension cords
to be a success. to the cost of printing flyers. Keep a
running list of funding opportunities
With goals, location(s), and collaborators and sources, and don’t be afraid to ask!
agreed upon, organizers will need to Some organizations or agencies may
develop a phased work plan and decide be eligible to apply for public art grants
who will do what. The work plan should and other grant funding. Private donors
work backwards from the desired and crowdfunding can also support
“unveiling” or event date and should placemaking projects. Local businesses or
include time for time-sensitive tasks sponsors may be willing to offer support
or in-kind donations—such as paint or the Even the simplest of things can draw people
like permitting and promoting an event. into a space. Above, public art is combined with
Roles and responsibilities should be use of folding chairs. Clarify whether they
have expectations like placing their logo on seating, children play on a makeshift rock wall,
assigned based on experience, interest, and strips of fabric create a shaded place to sit.
Sources, top to bottom: www.archdaily.com,
www.bouldergeist.com.au/bouldering-consultancy.html,
www.artflyz.com/e27e189c7490f209.html
24 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
SPRUCE STREET HARBOR PARK
Philadelphia, PA
The Spruce Street Harbor Park was initially envisioned as a short-term placemaking
project to improve an underutilized space at the Penn’s Landing Marina. The pop-up
park includes restaurants, beer gardens, barges that have been converted to floating
lounges, floating gardens, hammocks, outdoor seating, an urban beach, and colorful
LED lighting and attracted more than 30,000 people over the course of two months.
Due to the overwhelming success, the Spruce Street Harbor Park has opened each
spring since 2014 and now remains open from May through September with a wide
variety of events and activities including concerts and temporary attractions like
a tightrope, magic shows, or craft time with local art companies. Even though the
Harbor Park closes for the winter, a Winterfest now operates in the same space and
offers ice skating, restaurants, and shopping during the holiday season.
Metcalfe Park is primarily used on weekdays and most users are local employees.
The park’s busiest time is weekday mornings; many people now walk through the
park on their daily commutes. To encourage people to work outside, the park’s
designers ensured that this open space was served by Wi-Fi and outdoor power
sources. In addition, the park has been outfitted with planters, moveable and fixed
seating, solar harvesting umbrellas, and table tennis. All of the furniture is designed
to be easily moved and stored. Though there is no specific programming in Metcalfe
Park, local rugby and other teams have used the space for practice or pick-up games.
26 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
on the scale of the intervention and • Posters – area shops and businesses,
location of activities. The Board of Mayor public notice boards
and Aldermen, Planning and Community • Flyers – area businesses, email
Development Department, and Parks and distribution
Recreation Departments can help identify • Radio and TV
necessary permits, licenses, and approvals. • Websites
Depending on the size of your event, it • Email listservs
is also helpful to work with the Police • Print media
Department. 3. Think about partnering with local
businesses to increase marketing
6. Create Marketing Materials and Get the power.
Word Out!
4. Use the City’s calendar to market
Events and activities are meant for people online. You can request the event
and success is often measured in turnout. be added to the calendar by going
We recommend the following steps to to: www.manchesternh.gov/City-
make sure everyone knows about your Calendars/Apply-to-Post-an-Event.
event: Use social media and ask other
organizations to help publicize.
1. Create a compelling “pitch” for the 5. Social media can be a significant
event and provide visuals. Make benefit for your event.
it short and pithy. If possible, use
professional graphic design services to • Social media campaigns should be
create a logo or poster/flier. To garner coordinated with all other platforms
support, solicit funding, and create used. It is important to use the same
excitement, it helps to be very clear language and style in order to keep the
about your goals for the event. branding of the event clear.
• Try putting together a contest before
2. Establish a promotion schedule the event to get audiences engaged.
that outlines the dates, cost, and • Consider creating a hashtag for the
type of media promotion you’d like event on all platforms.
to use. Marketing should include a Placemaking can be tailored to any community.
• Consider live tweeting or streaming Manchester Connects will work to identify the
combination of the following: video on Facebook during the event particular brand of placemaking that will work
• Local newspaper – articles, to keep attendees and non-attendees best for the city, its residents, businesses, and
advertisements, online calendars aware of the activities at the event. visitors.
Sources, top to bottom: Slide the City (www.nerdreactor.
com), JCDecaux showscreens in Australia (www.jcdecauxna.
com), Digital Water Pavilion (www.divisare.com)
The neighborhoods surrounding Paths The pop-up park opened in 2013 and its focus to also include developing
to Pier 42 include a mix of business and became known as Paths to Pier 42. environmental education programs and
residential uses. Subsidized housing When the park opened, it featured art, projects for the after school and summer
makes up 85% of the nearby residential educational, and design installations camp programs that visit the park.
properties. The People’s Proposal grew surrounded by picnic tables. All of the
out of local concerns that the lower- installations and furniture were purchased In addition to opportunities for education
income community that lives near through a fundraising campaign or and recreation, the Paths to Pier 42 park
the park had not been included in the donated by local organizations or has provided opportunities for local artists
development of park proposals. The businesses. By the time the park returned to show their work and provide activities
People’s Plan was a representation of in Summer 2014, design firms Combo for children. An art and education
what the surrounding neighborhoods Colab and Stereotank had joined forces program, the Pier Ambassador Program,
needed and was accepted as the to create DrumReef42, an interactive engages local artists and participants
development plan for the area. Not only structure made from recycled plastic in a ten-week program that focuses on
was it representative of the community, barrels, that serves as seating (and for storytelling, history walks, and public
the proposal was only one-third of the some, a play space) and provides a speaking. There have also been one-off
cost of NYC EDC’s plan! visual reminder of the vulnerability of clinics and educational programming for
the waterfront in the wake of Hurricane children. For example, several fishing
To bring the project to reality, the Sandy. Each year, as the pop-up park clinics have been held at the park. The
Waterfront Alliance partnered with NYC returns, more design professionals and stages have been well-used, hosting
EDC, New York City’s Department of community members contribute to the concerts and dances. Numerous public
Parks and Recreation, Good Old Lower park’s design. In 2015, Leroy Street Studio events and celebrations are held each
East Side, Hester Street Collaborative, created the Water’s Edge Canopy, which year, including a Hurricane Sandy
Lower East Side Ecology Center, Lower provided seating that could be either in Commemoration, Wellness Festivals,
Manhattan Cultural Council, Two Bridges the shade or sun. DLandStudio originally Community Build Days, Seasonal
Neighborhood Council, and State Senator installed planters, bench seating, and Festivals, Art Workshops, and City
Daniel Squadron. stage platforms, but eventually expanded Waterfront Days.
Source: www.pathstopier42.com
28 CIVICMOXIE, LLC
PRECEDENTS FOR
PLACEMAKING – FURTHER
EXAMPLES AND RESOURCES