Professional Documents
Culture Documents
درجة ثانية PDF
درجة ثانية PDF
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Urban densification is recommended as the most advantageous solution for the sustainable growth of
Received 20 August 2018 cities. However, when considering energy consumption, its effects are perceived as complex and con-
Revised 13 October 2018
flicting. Two of the main consequences of urban densification are changes in the climate resulting from
Accepted 16 October 2018
the urban heat island (UHI) effect and in the incident solar radiation - resulting from the surroundings
Available online 23 October 2018
buildings geometry, which can affect the energy consumption of a building in opposite ways. In a hot
Keywords: climate region a decrease in the direct solar radiation could be a positive factor but the UHI effect would
Energy simulation be negative in terms of reducing energy consumption. Thus, the overall effects of densification need to
Urban densification be evaluated for these regions. Herein, the influence of the urban environment geometry on the thermal
Hot and humid climate load of office buildings in a city with a hot and humid climate was evaluated. Energy dynamics simu-
Urban heat island lations were carried out by the modeling of the surrounding geometry and considering the UHI effect.
Urban modeling
When the urban environment was considered in the energy simulations average reductions in the ther-
Cooling load
mal load of 16–18% were observed, highlighting the importance of this approach. Shading was found to
be the major factor related to this reduction.
© 2018 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction duced solar availability, even when taking into account the in-
crease in the temperature of urban canyon air caused by the UHI
Energy consumption has been growing rapidly around the effect [4]. In regions with a Mediterranean climate, although in
world in recent decades. Cities account for a large portion of this the majority of urban contexts analyzed an increase in the en-
growth, and buildings account for more than one third of the fi- ergy consumption of buildings within urban areas is also indicated,
nal energy consumption [1]. Energy consumption in cities tends to the denser context presented a slight reduction in consumption
grow and become more important due to factors such as a strong when compared to a building modeled without the surrounding
increase in the urban population, urbanization and gas emissions buildings and without considering the modification in the climate
and the consequent increase in the air temperatures resulting from caused by the UHI effect [5].
global warming and the urban heat island (UHI) effect [2,3]. A decrease in the direct solar radiation could be a positive fac-
Urban densification is considered the best solution for sustain- tor in hot climate locations, even if the UHI effect is negative due
able growth in urban areas due to economic, social and envi- to an increase in air temperature. In addition, according to [6], the
ronmental factors. However, this densification is seen as negative UHI effect has been largely studied, and there are several technolo-
when considering energy consumption, and in this regard its ef- gies and strategies to attenuate it in relation to air temperature
fects are perceived as complex and conflicting. and surface temperature, such as the development of reflective ma-
Some studies indicate an increase in energy consumption in terials, of cool roof technologies and of cool pavement technolo-
cold climates in dense urban areas (compared to rural areas) due gies, the use of urban vegetation (trees and green roof technolo-
to increased consumption of heating equipment, resulting from re- gies) and the use of solar control and shading. Thus, the question
of whether densification could be a positive factor in hot climate
regions when considering energy consumption merits further in-
∗ vestigation.
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: bellamedeiros@hotmail.com (I. Lima).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2018.10.019
0378-7788/© 2018 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
I. Lima et al. / Energy & Buildings 182 (2019) 30–44 31
Densification causes changes in the energy balance of cities due and low density). The results, which compared the energy per-
to several factors: (i) modification in the climate due to an in- formance of buildings with and without the modeling of the ur-
crease in the external air temperature, intense soil cover, a reduc- ban environment geometry, indicated that the impact is signifi-
tion in urban vegetation, the use of high-absorption materials, and cant even in very low density urban contexts and demonstrated
a decrease in the wind speed resulting from built-up barriers, con- an increase in energy consumption for heating and artificial light-
tributing to an increase in the UHI effect [7]; (ii) an alteration in ing caused by the consideration of the urban context, as well as
the amount of solar radiation that reaches urban surfaces, resulting a reduction of energy consumption for cooling in a larger propor-
from a greater proximity of the buildings that affects the levels of tion than the other loads. In the warmer climate context (Shen-
shading and solar reflection [8] and (iii) changes in the availability zhen), where there is no consumption for heating, shading be-
of natural light [9]. The magnitude of these effects will vary de- came only a positive effect when considering energy consumption,
pending on the urban characteristics and climate conditions in the since modification in the climate due to a greater density was not
region under analysis. analyzed.
The analysis of changes caused by densification and their im- Pisello et al. [14] also reinforced two important contributions of
pact at the different climatic scales and on the thermal and ener- a previously presented study: the distortion of the results for the
getic performance of buildings still presents a challenge for build- prediction of energy use when analyzing a building without tak-
ing energy simulation software. Different temporal and dimen- ing into account the surrounding buildings and the variation in the
sional scales considered in the models, limitation of the equip- size of this effect in different climatic contexts. The results, simu-
ment, the need for more information on the urban characteristics lated in extreme USA climatic contexts (Miami and Minneapolis),
and the difficulties associated with predicting user behavior hinder compared simulations of a building with and without surrounding
predictions of the annual energetic impacts of all characteristics buildings and presented greater inaccuracies in the annual energy
of the urban setting [2,10]. Mao et al. [11] highlighted the urgent prediction for a hotter climate context (with a reduction of up to
need for simulation tools that quantify the real impact caused by 32.7% when considering the urban environment). The study also
interactions between the thermal behavior of buildings in an urban showed that the two main contributors to changes in energy con-
context and modifications in the urban climate. sumption caused by the adoption of the urban environment factor
Despite the limitations in this regard, investigations need to be are shading and solar reflection.
aimed at the development of solutions to address these important Han et al. [8] continued the study by Pisello et al. [14], and
issues. Thus, in this study, the influence of the urban context on disaggregated the effects of shading and solar reflection into three
the energy performance of buildings was investigated through an distinct climatic contexts: temperate (Washington), warm (Miami)
analysis of the cooling load. The influence of the solar radiation on and cold (Minneapolis). The results showed that shading has a sig-
the energy performance of buildings is analyzed in depth based on nificantly greater impact in relation to solar reflection. Here again,
variations in the values for the surface reflectance and window to the greater impact in hotter climates was highlighted.
wall ratio (WWR) of the elements of the urban environment and In Brazil, Martins et al. [3] evaluated the impact of taking into
of the shading patterns provided by different urban geometries. account the urban context in five different urban typologies in a
Other changes promoted by urban densification that affect city with a hot and humid tropical climate (Maceió, Brazil), and
building energy performance, such as modifications in the climate indicated that the more dense and vertical context had the lowest
and access to natural light, were considered in a simplified way. energy consumption. The least dense typology was the one with
Changes in the air temperature and relative humidity (caused by the lowest energy efficiency. The analysis showed the important
the UHI effect) were considered through the generation of new ur- effect of verticalization and urban densification on a reduction in
ban weather files with UWG software. The use of artificial lighting the energy demand of buildings in the climate analyzed, due to
was considered during all hours in which the building was in use, shading.
without considering natural lighting. According to Li and Wong Other authors have considered the inclusion of the urban con-
[12] and Pisello et al. [9], taking into account natural lighting has a text in simulations only considering the changes in climate caused
significant effect on the energy demand, but this is mainly related by the UHI effect, resulting from the modification of the weather
to the artificial lighting load and not the thermal load, which was file from non-urbanized areas according to the urban characteris-
the parameter under analysis in this study. tics of the place of analysis, aimed at a more accurate prediction of
The amount of solar radiation incident to buildings within ur- the energy performance in dynamic simulations. In these studies,
ban areas is dependent on the reflection and shading caused by the modeling of surrounding buildings was not considered, consti-
surrounding elements, such as buildings, trees and soil, as well as tuting its main limitation.
geographic factors, such as latitude. When there is a greater prox- The modification of the weather file can mainly occur in two
imity of buildings, the effects of solar reflection and shading can ways. The first is through field measurements, where both a station
become more or less intense, especially in cities with a high urban located in an open field setting (rural) and a station located in an
density. Therefore, further studies are needed to evaluate buildings urban center are monitored [4,15]. In this method the annual cli-
within urban contexts when considering energy consumption anal- matic data measured at the station in a given urban context would
ysis. form a weather file equivalent to the urban climate of that portion
In this regard, although in most research related to building en- of the city, while the difference between the data measured in the
ergy consumption the impact of surrounding buildings is not in- urban context and the data measured in rural context would indi-
cluded in the analysis, the urban environment can be considered cate the proportion of the UHI effect. However, obtaining field data
in some energy simulations as shading elements and some studies is difficult and expensive, in addition to being spatially and tem-
have demonstrated the importance of taking into account the in- porally limited [2]. Therefore, the availability of this data is very
fluence of the urban context in simulations. Climatic phenomena, limited, making it impossible to use this method in several places.
such as UHI, are not considered together, constituting the main In order to overcome these limitations related to the first way
limitation of these research studies. of modifying weather files, it is possible to extend data from a ru-
Samuelson et al. [13] highlighted the great importance of con- ral meteorological station to other sites using extrapolation tech-
sidering the urban context in thermo-energy simulations in the niques or climate-generating software [2]. The modification of the
initial stages of a project in three climatic contexts (Beijing, New air temperature values from mathematical models (according to
York and Shenzhen) and in three urban contexts (high, medium characteristics of the urban environment where the building under
32 I. Lima et al. / Energy & Buildings 182 (2019) 30–44
analysis is located) constitutes the second form of modification of performance of buildings, in this study the influence of the urban
a weather file. environment on the thermal load of air-conditioned office build-
Nowadays there are several mathematical methods for modi- ings in Maceió, was analyzed. This city is characterized by a hot
fying weather files. Some are more simplified, such as that de- and humid climate and located in the northeast of Brazil. To this
scribed by Crawley [16], who calculated the hourly difference in air end, modification of the climate caused by the urban environment
temperature according to population size. Others require a greater was considered through the generation of new urban weather files
level of detail of the thermal and physical characteristics of the with the UWG software and energy simulations were carried out
study area, such as the approach proposed and improved by Bueno with the EnergyPlus software.
et al., [17], Nakano et al. [18], Yang [19] and Mao et al. [11], that The overall objectives of the study include: (a) to promote the
resulted in the urban weather generator (UWG) model. The UWG discussion of taking into account urban contexts in dynamic build-
is a specific software program for the production of urban weather ing energy simulations, considering the main changes it causes
files obtained by modifying existing rural weather files in Energy- (modification in climate, from the UHI effect, and changes in so-
Plus Weather file (EPW) format. The use of modified weather files lar radiation) in the modeling of the urban environment; (b) to
allows coupling with energy simulation programs [20]. determine the characteristics of buildings in urban environments
Some studies in which urban weather files have been used were that most strongly influence the energy performance of a building
focused on analyzing the modification in the climate due to the (focusing on reflectance of the envelope and WWR) and (c) to ob-
UHI effect in urban canyons. Unzeta et al. [20] conducted a UWG serve the energy performance behavior of office buildings within
simulation in Abu Dhabi and showed an increase in air tempera- urban contexts located in a hot and humid climate.
ture at all hours of the day when the urban context is taken into In order to achieve the objective described in (b), more de-
account and indicated a greater variation between the night and tailed conditions of the urban context in building energy simula-
early morning (up to 5 °C), in agreement with the UHI literature. In tions were analyzed to reach a more accurate prediction of the en-
Bueno et al. [21], air temperature values calculated by UWG sim- ergy consumption of buildings. In this regard, not only considering
ulations were compared to seven measurements from different ur- external elements such as shading, but also their reflectance and
ban contexts of Singapore and also to measurements from a non- WWR values, so that the solar reflection from direct and diffuse
urbanized area. The values calculated by the UWG were closer to radiation could approximate the conditions which actually exist in
those measured in urban contexts than the values measured in a the urban environment, originating from soil or from vertical sur-
non-urbanized area. faces.
Other authors have used the urban weather file and analyzed In this sense, recent studies have already been carried out ana-
its impact on energy performance. Results obtained by Liu et al. lyzing the impact of the alteration of the characteristics of the ur-
[7] indicated that climate change has led to an increase in energy ban materials in the temperature of the urban canyons and empha-
consumption in three different areas analyzed in the city of Sin- sizing the importance of considering them correctly in the compu-
gapore (hot and humid equatorial climate) and that the largest in- tational simulations. Jandaghian and Akbari [24] observed in differ-
crease (11%) was identified in the most densified area of the city ent cities of the United States (Sacramento, Houston and Chicago)
and the lowest increase (4%) in a less densified area. However, that the increase of the albedo of the urban surfaces resulted in
Crawley [16] showed that in cold climates the change in annual en- the reduction of the urban temperature, increase of the air speed
ergy consumption due to urbanization would be positive from an and increase of the relative humidity. Morini et al. [25] observed
energy point of view, reducing consumption by up to 10%. How- that the use of cold materials (with high reflectance) in building
ever, for tropical climates, the annual energy consumption would envelopes in urban canyons reduced the air temperature in the
suffer an increase of up to 20%. Santamouris [22] concluded that urban canyons in three different urban typologies (H/W ratio of
the available studies comparing the energy consumptions of simi- 1, 0.5 and 2). In this way, the present research seeks to analyze
lar buildings located in urban and rural areas are limited, but the the impact of the consideration of the urban environment as it re-
existing data show that the average increase in the cooling load ally presents itself in the city, considering also the variations of
due to UHI (13%) is statistically significant. reflectance of its surfaces, taking into account its impact on the
Although studies on both the insertion of the physical charac- energy consumption of a building within cities.
teristics of urban contexts, such as shading elements, and the mod-
ification of the climate in urban areas have been reported, few au- 2. Methodology
thors have simulated the energy performance coupling these two
approaches. The insertion of the urban context in thermo-energy simula-
In the search for a more accurate and realistic prediction of en- tions is increasingly necessary due to the increasing proximity of
ergy consumption, Allegrini et al. [4], Bueno et al. [23] and Sal- buildings within a city, resulting from urban densification. Based
vati et al. [5] conducted energy simulations coupling the mod- on a literature search, it was possible to observe that studies where
eling of the elements of urban geometry, such as shading de- micro-climatic changes are coupled with modifications of the ge-
vices, and the use of weather files modified according to the ur- ometry provided by the urban context in simulations are concen-
ban context of analysis, including the UHI effect. These studies, trated in cities with a temperate or Mediterranean climate. To fill
performed in Switzerland, France and Italy, respectively, demon- this climatic gap, this study was carried out in Maceió, a city with
strated that the UHI effect and the inclusion of urban geometry a hot and humid tropical climate, located in Alagoas State, in the
in the thermal-energy simulations significantly modifies the esti- northeast of Brazil.
mated energy consumption of buildings, which is higher in most of Maceió, latitude −9°67 and longitude −35°74 , has high tem-
the cases analyzed in temperate and Mediterranean regions, com- peratures throughout the year, with monthly averages between
pared to routinely performed simulations (isolated buildings and 23.6 °C in August and 26.8 °C in March and high relative humidity
rural weather files). However, Salvati et al. [5] highlighted that the all year round, with monthly averages between 72.7% in November
higher the density, the lower the load of buildings in these cli- and 86.5% in May. Low annual thermal amplitude and low relative
mates, because a reduction in incident solar radiation is compen- humidity variations are accompanied by a low daily thermal am-
sated by an increase in temperature resulting from the UHI effect. plitude of 6.9 °C on average. Summer and winter are differentiated
In order to increase the climatic range of studies that analyze by the rainy season, which occurs in winter, with higher precipita-
in a coupled way the impacts of the urban context on the energy tion rates between April and July.
I. Lima et al. / Energy & Buildings 182 (2019) 30–44 33
Fig. 1. Urban context with location of building lots analyzed, surrounding lots with building, roads and sidewalks. (For interpretation of the references to color in this figure,
the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)
Fig. 2. Dimensions of the buildings analyzed: Office 1 (a) and Office 2 (b).
ing with lower height and higher occupancy rate and another with clude the climatic changes in the new urban weather files and the
a vertical building of higher height and lower occupancy rate. modifications in the solar radiation pattern through the insertion
Two environmental settings were defined for the urban con- of the geometry of buildings in the urban environment.
text: with and without urban environment geometry considered. To conduct a detailed analysis of the influence of solar reflec-
The model without urban environment geometry is characterized tion coming from the surrounding buildings, parametric simula-
by the lack of buildings in the surrounding lots and in the context tions were performed to analyze three different reflectance and
with urban environment geometry the surrounding lots contain three different WWR scenarios of the vertical shading elements of
buildings with the same dimensions as the building analyzed. The the urban environment buildings (Table 3).
urban environment buildings were modeled as shading elements. The variations in the reflectance rate of vertical surfaces
The insertion of the characteristics related to these elements (re- were classified according to the following range: low (<0.3),
flectance, WWR and type of glass) was carried out in the object medium (0.3–0.6) and high (>0.60). To represent the three
ShadingProperty: Reflectance, in EnergyPlus. types of reflectance for the façades of the surrounding build-
The combination of the location of the building analyzed (lot ings the colors chosen were: gray (low), beige (medium) and
N or S), the configuration of building analyzed (Office 1 or 2 ty- white (high) with reflectance values of 0.13, 0.45 and 0.73, respec-
pology) and the type of urban context (without or with urban tively. The glass types were also classified according to the re-
environment geometry) resulted in 6 analysis cases, as shown in flectance range presented. Monolithium single gray glass (6 mm,
Table 2. SF = 0.6 and U = 5.79 W/m²K), laminate single clear glass (8 mm,
In cases Office1 and Office2 the rural weather file (EPW INMET) SF = 0.29 and U = 5.67 W/m²K) and double glass (6 mm, SF = 0.21
was used. Therefore, these cases represent the type of building and U = 1.3 W/m²K) with reflectance values of 0.053, 0.4 and 0.62,
simulations generally conducted, without taking into account the respectively, were selected to represent low, medium and high re-
urban context in relation to its geometry and the climate changes flectance.
resulting from the UHI effect. The need for a variation in the WWR (20%, 60% and 80%) arose
For the cases Office1_N, Office1_S, Office2_N and Office2_S, the because the reflection provided by vertical elements behaves dif-
rural EPW INMET file was modified according to the urban con- ferently depending on the type of surface in the EnergyPlus soft-
text of each scenario, resulting in new urban EPW files for Maceió, ware, being considered diffuse when coming from opaque ele-
named UWG 1 and UWG 2, referring to cases of Office 1 and Of- ments and specular from translucent elements.
fice 2, respectively. The simulation parameters used in the UWG For all simulations, the model was considered for a ter-
software are detailed below (Section 2.2). rain within a city, with a solar distribution with full in-
These cases with urban environment geometry represent the terior and exterior reflections, the building had direct con-
type of simulation proposed herein as being more suitable for tact with the soil and the soil reflectance was maintained at
building energy simulations within urban contexts, since they in- 0.2.
I. Lima et al. / Energy & Buildings 182 (2019) 30–44 35
Table 2
Cases for computer simulation.
Cases
Case terminology Office2 Office2_N Office2_S
Analysis building Office 2 Office 2 Office 2
Lot location North or South North South
Urban context Without urban environment With urban environment With urban environment
Cases
Table 3
Cases for computer simulation of each case with urban environment geometry (Office1_N, Office1_S, Office2_N and Office2_S).
Case WWR variation Reflectance rate of surrounding Reflectance rate of Facade of surrounding buildings per
terminology (%) buildings walls surrounding buildings floor
glass type
Table 4
Input data from urban weather files UWG 1 and UWG 2.
UWG is a computational design tool that provides specific cli- Simulation results were divided into three topics in order to ad-
mate data for a given city geometry and land use from climatic dress the following three main questions:
data obtained from rural reference weather stations, located in
• Which factor resulting from the insertion of the urban context
open field conditions [18]. The software is a computational model
in simulations has the greatest influence on the prediction of
to predict changes in air temperature and humidity at the urban
the building thermal loads?
canyon level for architects, planners and engineers [21].
The simulation output is a modified EPW (EnergyPlus Weather) This question was addressed through a graphical comparison
file. It is generated from an EPW file for a non-urban weather sta- between the values for the annual cooling load of the cases with
tion and an XML (Extensible Markup Language) file that describes and without urban environment geometry, observing the influence
the urban characteristics of the site under analysis and the rural separately of the modification of the weather file and the consid-
characteristics of the location of the meteorological station [18]. eration of the geometry of the surrounding buildings (Section 3.1).
For this study two weather file simulations (UWG 1 for Of-
fice1_N or S and UWG 2 for Office2_N or S) were performed ac-
• Which characteristics of the envelope of the surrounding build-
cording to the cases with urban environment. In the simulation, ings have the greatest influence on the prediction of the ther-
the rural EPW file referring to the city of Maceió (INMET 2016) mal load of the buildings analyzed?
was used. The XML files, which contain the urban characteris- In relation to this question, the results of all cases with urban
tics of each of the simulated cases, were elaborated according to environment geometry were analyzed (Section 3.2), to evaluate if
the parameters of the urban environment cases described above there is a difference in the effects of the solar reflectance and the
(Section 2.1) and the additional data given in Table 4, requested by WWR on the annual thermal load.
the UWG. Other input parameters requested were extracted from
Nakano [27]. • Are there changes in the behavior of the results or in the differ-
Nakano et al. [18] noted that although simplifications and as- ences between the cases with and without urban environment
sumptions in the modeling prevent the capture of very specific mi- geometry for the different months of the year, different num-
croclimate effects at the site, the models can remain robust enough bers of floors or different thermal zones?
to produce values for temperature and humidity changes able to
Based on the results associated with the previous question, the
represent the UHI effect (mesoclimatic scale) according to vali-
two most extreme cases were selected to perform a more detailed
dations made in four climatic contexts, Basel in Switzerland and
analysis of the thermal load of the buildings analyzed, showing
Toulouse in France [17], Singapore [28] and Boston in the USA [27],
their load per month, per floor and per thermal zone (Section 3.3).
and in different urban contexts. For this reason, in the UWG sim-
Based on the above considerations, the aim of this study was to
ulations the envelope variations of the surrounding buildings were
contribute to (i) a discussion of the use of urban contexts in build-
not taken into account in relation to the reflectance and WWR. In
ing energy simulations, considering the main changes it causes (in
all cases the values for medium reflectance of the walls and glass
terms of climate and the solar radiation that reaches buildings), (ii)
and a WWR of 50% were adopted.
to determine the characteristics of the surrounding buildings that
I. Lima et al. / Energy & Buildings 182 (2019) 30–44 37
Fig. 3. Annual cooling load of cases without urban environment and cases with
urban environment (50MR).
3. Results
In this section, the results for the thermal load for cooling ob-
tained from computational simulations for the climatic context of
Maceió are reported. In the graphs, the results obtained from the
simulations as they are generally performed (without modeling the
urban environment geometry or modifying the weather file), that
is, cases Office1 and Office2, are presented in green. The results
from the simulations conducted as proposed herein, for buildings
within urban contexts (modeling the urban environment geom-
etry and using the modified weather file) are presented in red
(Office1_N), blue (Office1_S), orange (Office2_N) and purple (Of-
fice2_S).
Fig. 6. Temperature difference between weather files: urban EPW UWG 1 (a) or UWG 2 (b) and rural EPW INMET.
Table 5 urban densification causes the UHI effect (Fig. 6), for the climate
Difference between annual cooling load for cases with urban environment
and urban density studied, this was not a significant factor from
and cases with urban environment by without the influence of shading and
reflection, separately. the thermal load viewpoint. This is because the phenomenon oc-
curs on a larger scale at night and at dawn (when the building in
Office1_N Office1_S Office2_N Office2_S
question is not being used). Also, in the morning, which represents
Without shading 15% 16% 14% 15% half of the building operating hours, the urban temperature (EPW
Without reflection −3% −3% −4% −4% UWG 1 and 2) is slightly below the values measured in the open
field setting (EPW INMET) due to the presence of shading. Thus,
the UHI effect probably has a greater impact on buildings that are
occupied during the nighttime period.
of solar reflection alone, the value of 0 was adopted in the re-
In relation to the differences between the two architectural
flectance of the vertical elements of the surrounding buildings. In
configurations defined for the buildings analyzed (Offices 1 and 2),
order to evaluate only the influence of the shading provided by
it can be observed that the values are up to 35 kWh /m² a year
these elements, a transmittance of 1 was adopted for the surfaces
higher for Office 2. Two factors can explain this higher cooling
of the surrounding buildings, making them "transparent" to the ef-
load value: the first is the greater distance between buildings in
fect of shading, but maintaining their characteristics of reflectance
the case of Office 2, which allows a higher incidence of solar radi-
in the analysis, as described by Han et al. [8]. Table 5 shows that
ation and promotes less shading; and the second is that, although
the influence of shading (with an increase of 14–16% in the cool-
both typologies have the same vertical surface areas, their influ-
ing load when this factor is not considered) is higher than the in-
ence is greater for Office 2, since in this case the perimeter zones
fluence of reflection (with a reduction of 3–4% in the cooling load
(ZN, ZS, ZL, ZO) correspond to 95% of the area of each floor while
when this factor is not considered).
for Office 1 the perimeter zones correspond to 70%. In relation to
In relation to the modification of the weather files (Fig. 5), the
the differences for the buildings located in the N or S lots, the val-
small difference (3%) between the rural EPW file (INMET) and the
ues for the S cases were slightly lower than those for the N cases,
urban EPW files (UWG 1 and UWG 2) may indicate that although
I. Lima et al. / Energy & Buildings 182 (2019) 30–44 39
for both Offices 1 and 2, since the north façade receives direct in- ence between the parametric cases was 8%. However, here it is
solation for 60% of the hours of the year, while the south façade important to note that EnergyPlus does not account for the long-
receives direct sunlight for 40% of the hours of the year. wave radiation from surrounding buildings, which would probably
reduce this difference.
3.2. Parametric variation in envelope of surrounding buildings A variation in the reflectance has a greater impact on the
cooling load when compared to a variation in the WWR. The
Figs. 7 and 8 report the annual cooling load results for all cases. highest load variations for different reflectance values, consider-
The values for the cases considering the urban environment ge- ing the same WWR (20%), were 8.5 kWh/m²/year for Office 1 and
ometry show the parametric variation of the surrounding building 12.7 kWh/m²/year for Office 2, while the highest differences in the
envelopes with WWRs of 20%, 50% and 80% and low, medium and load on varying the WWR, considering the same reflectance (high),
high reflectance. were 6.4 W/m²/year for Office 1 and 10.4 kWh/m²/year for Office 2.
On comparing the cooling load values for the cases with and In a detailed analysis of the thermal load, the case with a WWR
without urban environment geometry, a maximum difference of of 20% and high reflectance (higher annual load), named 20HR, and
22% is observed in the case of 80% WWR and low reflectance, and the case with a WWR of 80% and low reflectance (lower annual
a minimum difference of 13% for the case of 20% WWR and high load), named 80LR, were selected. It should be noted that this re-
reflectance. sult does not indicate that buildings within urban contexts should
The parametric variation of cases with urban environment ge- adopt envelopes of low reflectance and high WWR. It only indi-
ometry indicates that the lower the WWR and the higher the re- cates that the characteristics of the urban environment have a sig-
flectance of the surrounding buildings the higher the cooling load nificant influence on the analysis of the thermal load of urban
values for the building analyzed will be and, conversely, the higher buildings, and therefore must be taken into account in thermo-
the WWR and the lower the reflectance of the surroundings build- energy simulations. In general, envelopes with low reflectance and
ings the lower the cooling load values will be. The largest differ-
40 I. Lima et al. / Energy & Buildings 182 (2019) 30–44
the greater load in all months for 20HR compared to 80LR for the
cases with urban environment, and for the cases without urban
environment (Office1 and Office2) compared to cases with urban
environment (Office1_N or S and Office2_N or S).
In the warmer months (between October and May) the cool-
ing load is higher than in the winter period, characterized in Ma-
ceió by the rainy season. The difference in load between sum-
mer and winter, however, is more pronounced for Office 2, reach-
ing a maximum difference of 4.5 kWh/m²/month between July
and January, whereas for Office 1 this maximum difference was
3.0 kWh/m²/month.
On comparing the values for the cases with urban environ-
ment and without urban environment, presented in green, it can
be observed that the differences for the cases in the north lot (Of-
fice1_N and Office2_N) are always smaller in the winter, while for
the cases in the south lot (Office1_S and Office2_S) the differences
are always smaller in the summer months. These results demon-
strate the influence of direct radiation on the cooling load. For
the Office1_N and Office2_N cases the east, west and south fa-
cades are significantly more obstructed than the north facade. The
north façade, which is unobstructed, receives 60% of the direct ra-
diation for the year, concentrated mainly in the winter months.
Thus, in the winter months, the loads for the Office1_N and Of-
fice2_N cases are closer to the cases without urban environment
Fig. 9. Monthly cooling load for Office 1 cases. than in the summer months, because in winter the amount of ra-
diation that reaches the buildings analyzed in the Office1_N and
Office2_N cases is more similar to that for the cases without urban
environment. In the summer this difference becomes larger due to
the fact that the southern façade, which receives more direct radia-
tion at this time, is more obstructed. The same logic applies to the
Office1_S and Office2_S cases in relation to higher solar radiation
received during summer.
Considering the same urban environment (with the same re-
flectance value and WWR), the loads for the Office1_N and Of-
fice2_N cases in relation to those for the Office1_S and Office2_S
cases are higher only during the winter. The maximum annual dif-
ference between the N and S cases with same urban environment
was 1% but the maximum monthly difference was 7% in July.
Thus, the monthly analysis was important to demonstrate that
the low annual difference between the load values for the N and
S cases, considering the same urban environment, is not constant
throughout the year, since it is much more significant in the winter
period.
4. Discussion
1. In relation to variable (ii), there were no significant differences urban context (iii) showed that the greater the urban densification
in the load between the north or south locations of the buildings the lower the cooling loads required will be, since shading is a ma-
analyzed in the lots, and the loads of the buildings located in the jor influencing factor in terms of the thermal load.
north lot (main façade facing north) always gave slightly higher Considering the parametric variation of the envelop character-
values, since the north façade receives direct radiation for 60% of istics of the surrounding buildings in cases with the urban envi-
the hours of the year while the south façade receives direct radi- ronment factor (iv), it was possible to observe that the higher the
ation for 40% of the hours of the year. The results for the type of reflectance of the surrounding buildings the greater the cooling
I. Lima et al. / Energy & Buildings 182 (2019) 30–44 43
Fig. 15. Shade mask of the north façade on the 2nd floor of Offices 1 (a) and 2 (b). Fig. 17. Shade mask of the east façade (Office 2) on the 2nd floor (a) and 14th floor
(b).
the comfort of users in this climate and reduces the energy con- [5] A. Salvati, H. Coch, M. Morganti, Effects of urban compactness on the build-
sumption associated with the cooling load. ing energy performance in Mediterranean climate, Energy Procedia 122 (2017)
499–504, doi:10.1016/j.egypro.2017.07.303.
Finally, it is pointed out that this methodology can be applied [6] H. Akbari, C. Cartalis, D. Kolokotsa, A. Muscio, N. Hien, M. Zinzi, Local climate
to other climates, as long as the tool used to modify the weather change and urban heat island mitigation techniques – the state of the art, J.
file (n this research the UWG) has validation for a climate at least Civ. Eng. Manag. 22 (2016) 1–16, doi:10.3846/13923730.2015.1111934.
[7] Y. Liu, R. Stouffs, A. Tablada, N.H. Wong, J. Zhang, Comparing micro-scale
similar to the one that the research will be applied. However, in weather data to building energy consumption in Singapore, Energy Build. 152
order for the results to be compared with the present research, the (2017) 776–791, doi:10.1016/j.enbuild.2016.11.019.
building to be analyzed must have simulation parameters similar [8] Y. Han, J.E. Taylor, A.L. Pisello, Exploring mutual shading and mutual reflection
inter-building effects on building energy performance, Appl. Energy (2015),
to those presented here for the building analyzed.
doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2015.10.170.
[9] A.L. Pisello, V.L. Castaldo, J.E. Taylor, F. Cotana, Expanding inter-building effect
5. Conclusions modeling to examine primary energy for lighting, Energy Build. 76 (2014) 513–
523, doi:10.1016/j.enbuild.2014.02.081.
[10] J. Srebric, M. Heidarinejad, J. Liu, Building neighborhood emerging properties
The aim of this study was to analyze the influence of the urban and their impacts on multi-scale modeling of building energy and airflows,
environment geometry on the thermal load of conditioned office Build. Environ. 91 (2015) 246–262, doi:10.1016/j.buildenv.2015.02.031.
buildings in a city with a hot and humid climate, based on com- [11] J. Mao, J.H. Yang, A. Afshari, L.K. Norford, Global sensitivity analysis of an urban
microclimate system under uncertainty: design and case study, Build. Environ.
putational simulations that aggregate climatic and geometric mod- 124 (2017) 153–170, doi:10.1016/j.buildenv.2017.08.011.
ifications related to the urban context. [12] D.H.W. Li, S.L. Wong, Daylighting and energy implications due to shading ef-
Based on the results reported, it was concluded that the ur- fects from nearby buildings, Appl. Energy 84 (2007) 1199–1209, doi:10.1016/j.
apenergy.20 07.04.0 05.
ban environment geometry cannot be ignored in computational [13] H. Samuelson, S. Claussnitzer, A. Goyal, Y. Chen, A. Romo-Castillo, Parametric
thermo-energy simulations of buildings within urban contexts, es- energy simulation in early design: high-rise residential buildings in urban con-
pecially in relation to the floors closest to the ground, where a re- texts, Build. Environ. 101 (2016) 19–31.
[14] A.L. Pisello, J.E. Taylor, X. Xu, F. Cotana, Inter-building effect: simulating the
duction of up to 29% in the cooling load was observed in the sim- impact of a network of buildings on the accuracy of building energy per-
ulations where the urban environment geometry was considered. formance predictions, Build. Environ. 58 (2012) 37–45, doi:10.1016/j.buildenv.
The results also provided evidence that current building simu- 2012.06.017.
[15] A. Pyrgou, V.L. Castaldo, A.L. Pisello, F. Cotana, M. Santamouris, Differentiating
lation software is not suitable for analyzing satisfactorily all of the
responses of weather files and local climate change to explain variations in
major changes caused by the urban context in terms of the annual building thermal-energy performance simulations, Sol. Energy 153 (2017) 224–
energy performance of buildings. 237, doi:10.1016/j.solener.2017.05.040.
[16] D.B. Crawley, Estimating the impacts of climate change and urbanization on
In addition, it was concluded that considering the climatic con-
building performance, J. Build. Perform. Simul. 1 (2008) 91–115, doi:10.1080/
text and the cases analyzed, urban densification, from the energy 19401490802182079.
point of view, can be considered a good urban strategy to re- [17] B. Bueno, L. Norford, J. Hidalgo, G. Pigeon, The urban weather generator, J.
duce the thermal loads of commercial buildings with daytime work Build. Perform. Simul. 6 (2013) 269–281, doi:10.1080/19401493.2012.718797.
[18] A. Nakano, B. Bueno, L. Norford, C.F. Reinhart, Urban weather generator - a
hours, since the consideration of surrounding buildings in the sim- novel workflow for integrating urban heat island effect within urban design
ulations resulted in an average reduction of around 16–18% in the process, in: Proceedings of the Forteenth Conference of International Building
cooling load. Performance Simulation Association, BS2015, 2015.
[19] J.H. Yang, The Curious Case of Urban Heat Island : A Systems Analysis, Mas-
The main limitations of this study are that the impact of wind sachusetts Institute of Technology, 2016.
pattern modification was not analyzed and the effects of longwave [20] B.B. Unzeta, L.K. Norford, R. Britter, An urban weather generator coupling
radiation exchange between buildings was not investigated due to building simulations with a physically based urban model, in: Proceedings
of the Seventh International Conference on Urban Climate, „ YokohamaJapan,
the high computational cost. 2009, pp. 1–4.
[21] B. Bueno, A. Nakano, L. Norford, Urban weather generator : a method to pre-
Declarations of interest dict neighborhood-specific urban temperatures for use in building energy sim-
ulations, in: Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Urban Cli-
mate (ICUC9) jointly with 12 Symposium on the Urban Environment, 2015.
None. [22] M. Santamouris, On the energy impact of urban heat island and global warm-
ing on buildings, Energy Build. 82 (2014) 100–113, doi:10.1016/j.enbuild.2014.
07.022.
Acknowledgment
[23] B. Bueno, L. Norford, G. Pigeon, R. Britter, Combining a detailed building energy
model with a physically-based urban canopy model, Bound. Layer Meteorol.
This research was supported by CAPES (Brazilian government (2011) 471–489, doi:10.1007/s10546- 011- 9620- 6.
agency). [24] Z. Jandaghian, H. Akbari, The effect of increasing surface albedo on urban cli-
mate and air quality : a detailed study for Sacramento, Houston , and Chicago,
Climate (2018), doi:10.3390/cli6020019.
References [25] E. Morini, B. Castellani, S. De Ciantis, E. Anderini, F. Rossi, Planning for cooler
urban canyons : comparative analysis of the influence of façades reflective
[1] IEA, Transition to sustainable buildings: strategies and opportunities to 2050, properties on urban canyon thermal behavior, Sol. Energy 162 (2018) 14–27,
Int. Energy Agency (2013) 12, doi:10.1787/9789264202955-en. doi:10.1016/j.solener.2017.12.064.
[2] L. Frayssinet, L. Merlier, F. Kuznik, J.L. Hubert, M. Milliez, J.J. Roux, Modeling the [26] ASHRAE, STANDARD 90.1. Energy standard for buildings except low-rise resi-
heating and cooling energy demand of urban buildings at city scale, Renew. dencial buildings, (2004).
Sustain. Energy Rev. 81 (2018) 2318–2327, doi:10.1016/j.rser.2017.06.040. [27] A. Nakano, Urban Weather Generator User Interface Development: Towards a
[3] T.A.deL. Martins, M. Bonhomme, L. Adolphe, Análise do impacto da morfologia Usable Tool for Integrating Urban Heat Island Effect Within Urban Design Pro-
urbana na demanda estimada de energia das edificações: um estudo de caso cess, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2015.
na cidade de Maceió, AL, Ambient. Construído. 13 (2013) 213–233. [28] B. Bueno, M. Roth, L. Norford, R. Li, Computationally efficient prediction of
[4] J. Allegrini, V. Dorer, J. Carmeliet, Influence of the urban microclimate in street canopy level urban air temperature at the neighbourhood scale, Urban Clim.
canyons on the energy demand for space cooling and heating of buildings, En- 9 (2014) 35–53, doi:10.1016/j.uclim.2014.05.005.
ergy Build. 55 (2012) 823–832, doi:10.1016/j.enbuild.2012.10.013.