Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jacek Bartyzel - Makiawelizm
Jacek Bartyzel - Makiawelizm
OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH 6WURQD]
0$.,$:(/,=0
:áDG]H.OXEX
'RNXPHQW\
+LVWRULD.OXEX
-DFHN%DUW\]HO
$UW\NXá\
3UR)LGH5HJHHW/HJH
(QF\NORSHGLD3ROLW\NL
0$.,$:(/,=0ZáPDFKLDYHOOLVPRRZ]QDF]HQLX FLVá\PP\ OSROLW\F]QD1LFFROR
1HNURORJLXPSUDZLF\Z;;,
0DFKLDYHOOHJRRUD]SRNUHZQ\FKPXOXEQDZL ]XM F\FKGRQLHJRDXWRUyZ]D]Z\F]DM
ZLHNX
QD]\ZDM F\FKVLHELHOXEQD]\ZDQ\FK?SROLW\F]Q\PLUHDOLVWDPL?NWyUHMLVWRW MHVW
SRMPRZDQLHSROLW\NLSU]H]SU\]PDWVNXWHF]QR FLUR]XPLDQHMMDNRNRQLHF]QR ü
/LVW\.UyOHZVNLH
QHFHVVLWDQLHRG]RZQDGOD]DFKRZDQLDSD VWZDRUD]NLHURZDQLHVL UDFM VWDQXSU]\
*
]DáR HQLXQLHXFKURQQR FLVWRVRZDQLD URGNyZPRUDOQLHQDJDQQ\FKRZ]QDF]HQLX
/HNWXU\
SRWRF]Q\PV\QRQLPSROLW\F]QHMQLHPRUDOQR FLKLSRNU\]MLLZLDURáRPVWZDZJ
SR]RUQVSU]HF]QRüSRJOGyZDXWRUDDQW\WUDG\FMRQDOLVW\F]Q\LDQW\OHJLW\PLVW\F]Q\
VW\OMHJRP\OHQLDGOD0DFKLDYHOOHJRMHVWU]HF]RERM
WQSUDZRZLWRüZáDG]\
]DUyZQRZVHQVLHOHJLW\PL]PXSRFKRG]HQLDG]LHG]LF]HQLDZJXVWDORQ\FK]DVDGVXNFHVML
-DN]RVWDü OXERE\F]DMXMDNOHJLW\PL]PXFHOXRGQRV]HQLDZáDG]\GR%RJDL-HJRSUDZD=
F]áRQNLHP.OXEX"
SU]HNRQD 0DFKLDYHOOLE\áUHSXEOLNDQLQHPQDZHWGR üMDNQD?]LPQHJRUHDOLVW ?
HJ]DOWRZDQ\PQLHSU]HV]NDG]DáRPXWRMHGQDNZL ]DüVZRLFKQDG]LHLSROLW\F]Q\FK]
?NVL VWZHP?RUD]DGUHVRZDüLFKGR?NVL FLD?ZáD QLHG]L NLRERM WQR FLQDNZHVWL
6XEVNU\SFMD
WUDG\FMLLSUDZRZLWR FL0DFKLDYHOOLQLHSLV]HGOD?NVL FLD?XRVDELDM FHJRPRQDUFKLF]Q
7ZyMDGUHVHPDLO
RG]LHG]LF]\áOHF]SR]\VNDáM ?REF\POXEZáDVQ\PRU
*HPSU]H]V]F]
FLHOXERVRELVW
6XEVNU\EXM
*
3ROHFDP\ OHSLHM5]G]F\SRQLHZD*MHVWDGHNZDWQ\GODND*GHMVSHUVRQLILNRZDQHMZáDG]\EH]
Z]JO
GXQDMHMW\WXáFKDUDNWHULF]DVWUZDQLD:U]GDFK?NVL
FLDQRZHJR?XSDWU\ZDá
0DFKLDYHOOLQDG]LHLQDUHDOL]DFM
MHJRSDWULRW\F]QHJRFHOX]MHGQRF]HQLD:áRFKL
Z\S
G]HQLD],WDOLLQDMH(G(FyZ1LHPFyZ)UDQFX]yZ+LV]SDQyZ]D UHSXEOLNDE\áD
GODQLHJRLGHDOQ\PVWDQHPGRFHORZ\PLQQ\PLVáRZ\SU\QF\SDWWZRU]\DUHSXEOLND
*
XWUZDOD3RJO G0DFKLDYHOOHJRL ?UHSXEOLNLV EDUG]LHMWUZDáHRGPRQDUFKLLL
*
GáX HMGRSLVXMHLPV]F]
FLH?5R]ZD*DQLDQDGSLHUZV]\PG]LHVL
FLRNVL
JLHPKLVWRULL
5]\PX/LZLXV]DNV,,,UE\á]UHV]WZMHJRF]DVDFKHZHQHPHQWHPQDZHWMH*HOL
UHSXEOLNDQL]P0DFKLDYHOOHJRXJLáVL
SU]HGQDND]DPLSROLW\F]QHMNRQLHF]QRFLWRZ
ND *G\PUD]LHE\áRQ]GHF\GRZDQ\PSU]HFLZQLNLHPQLHRGSRZLHG]LDOQHMDXWRNUDFML
?ZáDGFDERZLHPNWyUHPXZV]\VWNRZROQRSRVW
SXMHMDNV]DOHQLHF?WDP*H,
7UDG\F\MQDE\áDQDWRPLDVW0DFKLDYHOOHJRNODV\ILNDFMDJDWXQNRZDXVWURMyZ
*
Z\Uy QLDM FDIRUP\U] GXPRQDUFKLF]Q SULQFLSDWRDU\VWRNUDW\F]Q RWWRPDWRL
*
GHPRNUDW\F]Q SRSRODUHE\áRQMHGQDN ZLDGRP HXVWURMHGREUHáDWZRZ\URGQLHM ]
SRZRGXSRGRELH VWZDGRIRUP]á\FKE G F\FKLFKRGSRZLHGQLNDPLGODWHJR]DZ\M FLH
]V\WXDFML]DSHZQLDM FHXVWURMRZLWUZDáR üDSD VWZXSRNyMVSRáHF]Q\X]QDZDá?U] G
PLHV]DQ\?UHSXEEOLFDPLVWD]SUHIHUHQFM GODUHSXEOLNL?RSW\PDWyZ?F]\OLWDNLHM
MDNLVWQLDáDZMHJRURG]LQQHM)ORUHQFML
*
NWyU\PSU]HFKRG]LGRUR]ZD DQLDNZHVWLLVSRVREXZMDNLZáDGFDSRZLQLHQRGQRVLüVL
GRSRGGDQ\FKLSU]\MDFLyá?PRLP]DPLDUHPMHVWSLVDüU]HF]\X \WHF]QHGODWHJRNWR *
MHUR]XPLHSU]HWRRZLHOHEDUG]LHMZáD FLZ\PZ\GDMHPLVL L ü]DSUDZG U]HF]\ZLVW
* *
]GDU]H YHULWDHIIHWWXDOHGHOODFRVDQL ]DMHMZ\REUD HQLHPLPDJLQD]LRQHGLHVVD
*
QLHXFKURQQLH]JLQüZUyGW\OXNWyU]\QLHVGREU\PL?:\QLNDMFH]WHJRVWZLHUG]HQLD
VPXWQHNRQVHNZHQFMHF]HNDMFH?EH]EURQQ\FKSURURNyZ?MDN6DYRQDURO
VWDQRZL
WH*Z\MDQLHQLH]DJDGNRZ\FKVáyZGHG\NDFML.VL
FLDGOD:DZU]\FD0HG\FHXV]D
?7HJRG]LHáDQLHXEUDáHPLQLH]DSHáQLáHPJyUQ\PLZ\UD*HQLDPLDQLV]XPQ\PLL
NZLHFLVW\PLVáRZDPLDQL*DGQLQQSRQ
WOXER]GRE]HZQ
WU]QMDNLPLSLVDU]H
]Z\F]DMQLH]GRELVZHXWZRU\ERFKFLDáHPE\QLF]\P]JRáDQLHE\áRXSL
NV]RQHLE\
Z\áF]QLHSUDZG]LZRüWUHFLWXG]LH*ZDJDSU]HGPLRWXF]\QLá\MHPLá\P?
(VHQFM PVWDQRZL ]DOHFHQLDW\F] FHVSRVREX]GRE\FLDLXWU]\PDQLDZáDG]\Z\áR RQH *
QLHVáXV]QHOLWR FLZHOXERNUXWQHFKZDOHEQHOXEVURPRWQH1DGZV]\VWNRLQQH]ZD Dü *
*
QDOH \ZWHG\QDWRDE\]DSHZQLüMHMSU]HWUZDQLHLXUDWRZDüMHMZROQR ü?,,,
5]\PLDQVDOXV5HLSXEOLFDHVXSUHPDOH[HVWR
*
*
QLHJR]DVDGQLF]RVHQVSRQLHZD Z\á F]RQDMHVW]QLHJRQLH]DOH QDRGSROLW\NLWUH ü *
PRUDOQD0DNLDZHOLD VNDYLUWXWRUR]XPSROLW\F]Q\SDQXM F\ PLDáRQDGFLHPQ\P
SRVSyOVWZHPRUD]QDJLQDM F\MHJRQDURZ\LIDQDEHULHGRUHDOL]DFMLFHOyZVáX *F\FK
NRQLHF]QR FLRPSROLW\F]Q\PYLUWXWZRU]\QLHRGá F]Q SDU ])RUWXQ ORVHP
ZFKRG] F]QL ZDPELZDOHQWQ\SU]\FL JDM FRRGS\FKDM F\]ZL ]HNTXDVLPLáRVQ\
)RUWXQDERZLHPMHVWNRELHW NWyU ?WU]HEDNRQLHF]QLHELüLGU F]\üDE\M SRVL üL
WDF\NWyU]\WRF]\QL]Z\FL
*DMáDWZLHMQL*FLNWyU]\SRVW
SXMRJO
GQLH?WDP*H
;;9)RUWXQDSU]\UyZQ\ZDQDMHVWWDN*HGRUZFHMU]HNLNWyUDMHVWJUR(QDOHF]QLH
ZV]HFKPRFQDL]Z\FL
*DW\ONRZWHG\NLHG\QLHQDSRW\NDRSRUX]HVWURQ\JRWRZHMM
XMDU]PLüYLUWXMDNZ]QDQ\PSRU]HNDGOHORVVSU]\MD]DWHPPLDá\P]ZáDV]F]D
PáRG\PERFLV?EDUG]LHM]DSDOF]\ZLL]ZL
NV]]XFKZDáRFLUR]ND]XM?WDP*H]
GUXJLHMVWURQ\QDZHWQDMZL
NV]\JHQLXV]QLH]GRáDSU]HFLZVWDZLüVL
WHQGHQFMRPVZRLFK
F]DVyZODTXDOLWDGHLWHPSLPR*HW\ONRZ\NRU]\VWDüXPLHM
WQLHVSRVREQRü
RFFDVLRQHNWyURQHQDVWU
F]DM
)DGQD]?QLNF]HPQ\FK?UDG0DFKLDYHOOHJRVDPDZVRELHQLHE\áDZJUXQFLHU]HF]\
* * ( *
QRZDLND G ]RVREQDPR QDRGQDOH üZPDNV\PDFKUy Q\FKDXWRUyZVWDUR \WQ\FK*
MDNUyZQLH*ZZ\NáDGDQHMSU]H]VFKRODVW\NyZUHGQLRZLHF]Q\FKHW\FHV\WXDF\MQHM
GRW\F]FHMVWDQXNRQLHF]QRFL]ZDQHJR?NRQLHF]QRFLFHOX?NWyUDNDQRQLVWRPVáX*\áD
]DX]DVDGQLHQLHSDSLHVNLHJRSUDZDG\VSHQVDFMLRGUHJXá\RJyOQHM3RPL
G]\ILOR]RIDPL
NODV\F]Q\PLLWHRORJDPLNDWROLFNLPLD0DFKLDYHOOLPLVWQLHMHQDWRPLDVWNDUG\QDOQDUy*QLFD
ZW\P*HGODSLHUZV]\FKRGVW
SVWZRRGQRUP\PRUDOQHMXVSUDZLHGOLZLRQHMHVWW\ONRZ
REOLF]XQLHEH]SLHF]HVWZDU]HF]\ZLVWHJRLMX*]DLVWQLDáHJRDV\WXDFMHWRX]DVDGQLDMFH
WUDNWRZDQHV]DZV]HMDNRSU]\SDGNLDQRUPDOQHLQG\ZLGXDOQHLQLHSRZWDU]DOQH
SRGF]DVJG\0DFKLDYHOOLXZD*D*HSRVW
SRZDQLHWDNLHMHVWGRSXV]F]DOQHMX*
SUHZHQF\MQLHZVDP\PSU]HZLG\ZDQLXQLHEH]SLHF]HVWZDDV\WXDFMHWHJRURG]DMX
XZD*Dá]DWUZDáHWRWH*]SRVW
SRZDQLDZEUHZQRUPLHF]\QLáQRUP
]DVDG
GODDXWRUD
.VL
FLDSU]HVWU]HSROLW\NLMHVWREV]DUHPSHUPDQHQWQHJRVWDQXZ\MWNR
ZHJR
&HOMDNLVWDZLDVRELHLZáDG]\0DFKLDYHOOLMHVWW\ONRSUDNW\F]Q\XW\OLWDUQ\MDN
SR]QDZF]HJRPDNLDZHOLD VND?SUDZGDU]HF]\ZLVW\FK]GDU]H ?WRFRQDMZ\ HM*
SU]\F]\QRZRVNXWNRZH]ZL]DQLHNRQNUHWQ\FKIDNWyZQLHGDMFHSRGVWDZGRV]HUV]\FK
XRJyOQLHHSLVWHPRORJLF]QLHMHVWRQDEH]ZDUWRFLRZDSRQLHZD*QLH]DVáXJXMHQDPLDQR
SUDZG\WRFRRERZL]XMHW\ONRZNRQWHNFLHFLJOH]PLHQLDMF\FKVL
RNROLF]QRFLZP
SUDZGDUR]XPLDQDNODV\F]QLHMDNR]JRGQRüVGX]U]HF]\ZLVWRFLDWDN*HSUDZGD
RQWRORJLF]QD]JRGQRüE\WXRGZ]RURZDQHJRQD]LHPL]E\WHPZLHF]Q\PQLH
RGJU\ZDM*DGQHMUROL?SUDZG?MHVWWXW\ONRWRFR]DSUDZG
XFKRG]L5RV]F]HQLHP
GRRGNU\FLDQLH]QDQHMMDNRE\ZF]HQLHM?SUDZG\RSROLW\FH?MHVWZWSOLZHQLHW\ONRZ
ZLHWOHQLHRU\JLQDOQRFLSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKP\OLF]\]DOHFHDOHWDN*HRJUDQLF]HMHJR
WHRULRSR]QDZF]HJRQRPLQDOL]PXNWyU\ZVNXWHNQHJDFMLLVWQLHQLDXQLZHUVDOLyZ
*
SRM üRJyOQ\FKVDPVND]DáVL QDQLHPR QR üSR]QDQLDF]HJRNROZLHNFRZ\NUDF]D
SR]DVIHU GR ZLDGF]HQLD]P\VáRZHJR9HULWDHIIHWWXDOHVWDQRZLUyZQLH NDPXIOD GOD * *
*
]DSR \F]RQHM]DSR UHGQLFWZHPV]NRá\SDGHZVNLHMRG$ZHUURHVDNRQFHSFML
?SRGZyMQHMSUDZG\?RGGDQHMZG\VSR]\FM ZáDGF\?SUDZG\GODPDOXF]NLFK?F]\OL
*
X \WHF]QHJRSROLW\F]QLHNáDPVWZDL?SUDZG\GODP GUFyZ?NWyUHMXGRVW SQLHQLH
GLDJQR]RZDQLDV\WXDFMLPHWRGSRVW SRZDQLDNDONXODFMLVNXWNyZSRGHMPRZDQ\FK
* *
G]LDáD F] VWR]UHV]W RSUREOHPDW\F]QHMSU]\GDWQR FLNWR ]áR OLZLH]DXZD \á H
WUDNWXMFG]LHáD0DFKLDYHOOHJRMDNRLQVWUXNWD *PR*QDZQDMOHSV]\PZ\SDGNXGRMüGR
VWDQRZLVNDSRGSUHIHNWDPMHVW]DWHPDPHWDIL]\F]Q\ERSR]EDZLRQ\
RGQLHVLHQLDGRE\WXSR]DMHJRHPSLU\F]Q\PLSU]HMDZLHQLDPL
*
-DNRQDLZQ\LXSURV]F]RQ\QDOH \QDWRPLDVWRNUH OLü]DU]XW?QLHPRUDOQR FL?Z
VWRVXQNXGR0DFKLDYHOOHJR6N GLQ GZLDGRPR HMDNRF]áRZLHNSU\ZDWQ\SURZDG]LáRQ *
*\FLHSU]\NáDGQHDMDNRXU]
GQLNSDVWZRZ\E\áZU
F]Z]RUHPXF]FLZRFLL
* *
VXPLHQQR FL*DHWDQR0RVFDSRGNUH OD H?SRVLDGDáRQWH ZZ\VRNLPVWRSQLXFQRW
NWyUQD]\ZDP\XF]FLZRFL]DZRGRZ DNWyUDSROHJDQDSRGDQLXF]\WHOQLNRZLVZHM
P\OLEH]Z]JO
GXQDSRZRG]HQLHOXEQLHSRZRG]HQLHNVL*NLEH]Z]JO
GXWDN*HQD
NRU]\FLOXEQLHEH]SLHF]HVWZDZ\QLNDMFHVWGGODDXWRUD?+LVWRULDGRNWU\Q
SROLW\F]Q\FKRGVWDUR*\WQRFLGRQDV]\FKF]DVyZ:DUV]DZD>@1LHE\áDQL
NDULHURZLF]HPERJG\E\QLPE\áWRSU]\VZRLFK]GROQRFLDFK]DV]HGáE\QDSHZQR
Z\*HMDQLRV]XVWHPERJG\E\QLPE\áWRQLHQDSLVDáE\NVL*NLXF]FHMV]WXNL
ZSURZDG]DQLDZEáGSUDZG]LZLRV]XFLQLHXMDZQLDMVZRLFKWDMHPQLF7\ONRSR]RUQ\P
SDUDGRNVHPMDNR*HGRW\F]\F]áRZLHND?NWyUHJRQD]ZLVNRVWDáRVL
V\QRQLPHP
GZXOLFRZRFLLV]DOELHUVWZD?MHVWWH*VSRVWU]H*HQLH*H0DFKLDYHOOL?MDNZL
NV]Rü
W\FKNWyU\FKP\ONV]WDáWRZDáDVL
QDNVL*NDFKMHVWLGHDOLVW DMDNZV]\VF\
LGHDOLFLE\ZDQDLZQ\?WDP*H
$XWRU.VL FLDQLHE\áHW\F]Q\PUHODW\ZLVW QLH]DSU]HF]DáLVWQLHQLXRELHNW\ZQHJRGREUD
* *
VL RGQLFKQDRJyáSURZDG]LGR]JXE\:EUHZSRPyZLHQLRPQDMEDUG]LHM]DSDOF]\Z\FK
DQW\PLDNLDZHOLVWyZDOERSRFKZDáRPQLHSURV]RQ\FKDSRORJHWyZ0DFKLDYHOOLQLJG\QLH
*
JáRVLáMDNRE\F]\Q\QLHPRUDOQHL]EURGQLF]HQDOH DáRSRSHáQLDüDW\PEDUG]LHMDE\Z
LFKSRSHáQLDQLX]QDMGRZDüVDG\VW\F]QHXSRGREDQLHSU]HFLZQLH]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDP
?EH]LQWHUHVRZQL?VDG\ FLSRNURMX.DOLJXOLF]\7DPHUODQDV QDMJRUV]\PL]PR OLZ\FK *
QLHMHVWVNXWHF]Q\LQLHE G]LH]GROQ\RFDOLüSD VWZD?']LNDVURJR üLQLHOXG]NR üZ
SRáF]HQLX]QLH]OLF]RQ\PL]EURGQLDPL?.VL*
9,,,W\UDQD6\UDNX]$JDWRNOHVD
SU]\QLRVá\PXZSUDZG]LHVXNFHVDOHRNU\á\MHJRLPL
WDNKDE*HQLHZV]HGáRQGR
SDQWHRQXERKDWHUyZOXG]NRFLZSU]HFLZLHVWZLHGR7H]HXV]D5RPXOXVD0RM*HV]DL
&\UXVDNWyU]\ZSUDZG]LHWH*SRSHáQLDOLF]\Q\NUZDZHDOHW\ONRRW\OHRLOHE\áRWR
NRQLHF]QHLNRU]\VWQHGODRE\ZDWHOL1DQHJDW\ZQ\FKSU]\NáDGDFK3L]\VWUDWD'LRQL]MRVD
L&H]DUD0DFKLDYHOOLGRZRG]LWDN H]JXEQR FLF]\VWHM * *G]\ZáDG]\
*
?]ZLQL FLD?VSLUDOLMX ]DLVWQLDáHMSU]HPRF\SU]\ ZLHFDGRNRQDQHPXSU]H]
*
*
RNUXFLH VWZHPNWyUHSROHJDQDW\P H?GREU]HX \W\PLPRJ QD]\ZDüVL WHMH HOLR *
*
*
]áHPZROQRSRZLHG]LHü HMHVWGREUHPNWyUHSRSHáQLDVL UD]MHGHQ]NRQLHF]QR FLGOD
(
XEH]SLHF]HQLDVL QLHSRZWDU]DVL LFKSy QLHMDNWyUHQDGWRSU]\QRV] PR OLZLH *
* ( *
QDMZL NV]\SR \WHNSRGGDQ\P?QDWRPLDVW? OHX \W\PLV WDNLHNWyUHFKRüE\]
SRF]WNXQLHOLF]QH]F]DVHPPQR*VL
]DPLDVWU]HGQLHü?WDP*H
5] G\EH]P\ OQLHRNUXWQHLSRJDUGOLZLHGHSF] FHXF]XFLDOXG]LZFDOHQLHV GODZáDGF\
EH]SLHF]QHGREUHU] G]HQLHSROHJDSU]HFLH QDVNXWHF]Q\PZ\WZDU]DQLX *
*
SU]H ZLDGF]HQLD HZáDGFDF]\QLGREU]H'ODWHJR?GREU]HXU] G]RQHSD VWZDLP GU]\
NVL*
WDVWDUDOLVL
]DZV]HEDUG]RSLOQLHRWRE\PR*Q\FKQLHSU]\SURZDG]DüGR
UR]SDF]\DGRJDG]DüOXGRZLL]DGRZROLüJRJG\*WRMHVWMHGQR]QDMZD *QLHMV]\FK]DGD
NVL
FLD?WDP*H;,;0LQLPXPWHJRFRXF]\QLüPR*HUR]WURSQ\NVL*
DE\QLHE\ü
]QLHQDZLG]RQ\PMHVWSRZFLJQL
FLHVL
?RGPLHQLDVZRLFKRE\ZDWHOLLSRGGDQ\FKLRG
LFKQLHZLDVW?DOERZLHP?OXG]LHSU
G]HMSXV]F]DMZQLHSDPL
üPLHUüRMFDQL*VWUDW
RMFRZL]Q\?WDP*H;9,,7HJRURG]DMXUDG\QLHW\ONR*HQLHVQLHPRUDOQHDOHQDZHW
QDWOH]DVWDQHMSUDNW\NLPR*QDMHWUDNWRZDüMDNRSUyE
SRGGDQLDZáDGFyZQLHEáDK\P
RJUDQLF]HQLRP-HGQDNZL
NV]H]QDF]HQLHQL*GRSUREOHPDW\F]QHMDSULRULPRUDOQRFL
ZáDGFyZSU]\ZL]\ZDá0DFKLDYHOOLGR]ZL]DQLDU]G]F\FKSU]HSLVDPLSUDZDZF]\P
XSDWU\ZDáOHSV]HM?U
NRMPLEH]SLHF]HVWZDGODZV]\VWNLFKLFK
SRGGDQ\FK?5R]ZD*DQLD,GDMF]DSR]\W\ZQ\Z]yU.UyOHVWZR)UDQFML
*
-HG\QHF]HJR0DFKLDYHOOLU]HF]\ZL FLHSUDJQLHGRZLH üWRWZLHUG]HQLHL ZSROLW\FHQLH
* *
GDVL XQLNQ üF]\QyZZ \FLXSU\ZDWQ\PXZD DQ\FKSRZV]HFKQLH]DQLHHW\F]QHPLPR
WRMHGQDNSROLW\NDRERZL]XMHSRF]XFLHPLDU\LJUDQLF0DFKLDYHOOLWHG\QLHMHVW
?QLHPRUDOQ\?OHF]?DPRUDOQ\?QLHSU]HF]\HW\FHRELHNW\ZQHMW\ONR]DZLHV]D
MHMRERZL ]\ZDQLHZG]LHG]LQLHSROLW\NLZLPL Z\PRJyZSROLW\F]QHM?NRQLHF]QR FL?
]SRZRGXRZ\FKLPPDQHQWQ\FKFHFKUHOLJLLFKU]H FLMD VNLHM?]DNRU]HQLáDVL QD ZLHFLH
VáDER üZ\GDM FWHQ ZLDWQDáXSQLHJRG]LZFyZ?0DFKLDYHOOLDVHNXURZDáVL
]DVWU]H*HQLHP*H?MHOL ZLDWMHVW]QLHZLHFLDá\DQLHERZ\GDMHVL
EH]VLOQHQLH
SU]\SLVXMP\]DWRZLQ\QLNRPXLQQHPXMDNW\PNWyU]\UHOLJL
QDV]SRM
OLQDVSRVyE
SUy*QLDNyZDQLHWDNMDNE\Z\PDJDáRWHJRP
VWZR*G\E\ERZLHP]ZUyFLOLRQLXZDJ
QDWR*HUHOLJLDQDV]DSR]ZDODQDZ\Z\*V]HQLHLREURQ
RMF]\]Q\SU]HNRQDOLE\VL
*H
QDND]XMHQDPRQDW
RMF]\]Q
NRFKDüF]FLüLVSRVRELüVL
GRMHM
REURQ\?5R]ZD*DQLD,,-HGQDNSRZRáXMFVL
JG]LHLQG]LHM+LVWRULHIORUHQFNLH
QD]DVá\V]DQSRQRüRG.X(P\0HG\FHXV]DPDNV\P
?QLHGDVL
U]G]LüSDVWZHP
RGPDZLDMF2MF]H1DV]?0DFKLDYHOOLVWDZLDáSU]HG?NVL
FLHP?QDRVWU]XPLHF]D
SU]HF]F\SRZ\*V]HMDVHNXUDFMLG\OHPDWDOER]EDZLHQLHZáDVQHMGXV]\DOERRFDOHQLH
SDVWZDLND]DáPXZ\ELHUDüWRGUXJLH
7HRUHW\F]QLHGRNRQDQ\ZPUR]G]LDáSROLW\NLRGUHOLJLLFKU]H FLMD VNLHMQLHPXVLDá
*
SRFL JDü]DVRE ODLF\]DFMLSD VWZDSRQLHZD 0DFKLDYHOOLE\áZLHOELFLHOHPSRJD VNLHM
UHOLJLLU]\PVNLHMUHSUH]HQWXMFHMZMHJRRF]DFKWHFQRW\RE\ZDWHOVNLHNWyU\FK
EUDNRZDüPLDáRFKU]HFLMD VWZX3UDNW\F]QLHMHGQDNNRQVHNZHQFMMDVNUDZHM
DQDFKURQLF]QRFLWHJR?QHRSRJDQL]PX?0DFKLDYHOOHJRDZL
FWDN*HMHJR
DEVWUDNF\MQRFLPXVLDáDE\üODLF\]DFMDSROLW\NLSROLW\F]Q\DWHL]PSUDNW\F]Q\LODLF\
]PSDVWZRZ\
27RPPDVLQL/DYLWDHJOLVFULWWLGL1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOLQHOODORURUHOD]LRQHFRO
0DFKLDYHOOLVPR,,,5RPD7RULQR)LUHQ]H)(UFROH/DSROLWLFDGL
0DFKLDYHOOL5RPD)$OGHULVLR0DFKLDYHOOLOC$UWHGHOOR6WDWRQHOOCD]LRQHHQHJOL
VFULWWL7RULQR+)UH\HU0DFKLDYHOOL/HLS]LJ$+*LOEHUW0DFKLDYHOOLCV
?3ULQFH?DQG,WV)RUHUXQQHUV'XUKDP1&5.|QLJ1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL=XU
.ULHJVDQDO\VHHLQHU=HLWWHQZHQGH=ULFK$5HQDXGHW0DFKLDYHOOCpWXGH
GCKLVWRLUHGHVGRFWULQHVSROLWLTXHV3DULV/2OVFKNL0DFKLDYHOOLWKH6FLHQWLVW
%HUNHOH\&$/-:DONHU7KH'LVFRXUVHVRI1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL,,,/RQGRQ
:/HZLV7KH/LRQDQGWKH)R[/RQGRQ(9RHJHOLQ0DFKLDYHOOLCV
?3ULQFH?%DFNJURXQGDQG)RUPDWLRQ?7KH5HYLHZRI3ROLWLFV?)&KLDSHOOL
6WXGLVXOOLQJXDJJLRGHO0DFKLDYHOOL)LUHQ]H*3UH]]ROLQL0DFKLDYHOOL$QWLFULVWR
5RPD+%XWWHUILHOG7KH6WDWHFUDIWRI0DFKLDYHOOL/RQGRQ*6DVVR
1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL6WRULDGHOVXRSHQVLHURSROLWLFR,,,1DSROL%RORJQD>@
/6WUDXVV7KRXJKWVRQ0DFKLDYHOOL*OHQFRH,OOLQRLV&KLFDJR>@-'H
/DPDUUHG0DFKLDYHOOL&\QLF3DWULRWRU3ROLWLFDO6FLHQWLVW"%RVWRQ*)LVFKHU
1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOLGLH7ULORJLHGHU0DFKW:HLQKHLP)&KDERG6FULWWLVX
0DFKLDYHOOL7RULQR>@*6DVVR6WXGLVX0DFKLDYHOOL1DSROL*
3UH]]ROLQL7KH&KULVWLDQ5RRWVRI0DFKLDYHOOLCV0RUDO3HVVLPLVP?7KH5HYLHZRI
1DWLRQDO/LWHUDWXUHV?5'H0DWWHL,OSHQVLHURSROLWLFRGL0DFKLDYHOOLHODVXD
IRUWXQDQHOPRQGR)LUHQ]H$%RQDGHR&RUUXSWLRQ&RQIOLFWDQG3RZHULQWKH
:RUNVDQG7LPHVRI1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL%HUNHOH\/$3(%RQGDQHOOD
0DFKLDYHOOLDQGWKH$UWRI5HQDLVVDQFH+LVWRU\'HWURLW(*DULQ1DGP\ O
0DFKLDYHOOHJR?$UFKLZXP+LVWRULL)LOR]RILLL0\ OL6SRáHF]QHM?30DQHQW
1DLVVDQFHVGHODSROLWLTXHPRGHUQH0DFKLDYHOOL+REEHV5RXVVHDX3DULV0
.UyO.áRSRW\]0DFKLDYHOOLPZàDGXWDMRQ\.UDNyZ,%HUOLQ2U\JLQDOQR ü
*
0DFKLDYHOOHJR?/LWHUDWXUDQD ZLHFLH?/6WUDXVV7U]\IDOHQRZR \WQR FL
?5HV3XEOLFD?*%RFN46NLQQHU09LUROLUHG0DFKLDYHOOLDQG
5HSXEOLFDQLVP&DPEULGJH9'H&DSUDULLV6FULWWLVX0DFKLDYHOOL0HVVLQD
+-'LHVQHU9LUWX)RUWXQDXQGGHV3ULQ]LS+RIIQXQJEHL0DFKLDYHOOL*|WWLQJHQ
(*DULQ0DFKLDYHOOLIUDSROLWLFDHVWRULD7RULQR+&0DQVILHOG0DFKLDYHOOLCV
YLUWXH&KLFDJR/RQGRQ-%DUW\]HO?3U]HVW SQ\?0DNLDZHOGXPDQLD
]JU]\ELDáHJRNRQVHUZDW\VW\?3UR)LGH5HJHHW/HJH?$2ULDQL
1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL1DSROL>@09LUROL0DFKLDYHOOL2[IRUG7%0DFDXOD\
0DFKLDYHOOL>@Z2UHZROXFMDFKPDNLDZHOL]PLHLSRVW SLH:\EyUV]NLFyZ.UDNyZ
0DNLDZHOL FL
.DOOLNOHVL7UD]\PDFK%H]SR UHGQLPLSRSU]HGQLNDPL0DFKLDYHOOHJRE\OLQLHNWyU]\
SU]HGVWDZLFLHOHZF]HVQHJRKXPDQL]PXZáRVNLHJRD]ZáDV]F]D*LDQ)UDQFHVFR3RJJL
R%UDFFLROLQLNWyU\WZLHUG]LáL ZV]\VWNLHVáDZQHF]\Q\GRNRQDQH *
]RVWDá\ZEUHZSUDZXDXLFKSRGVWDZOHJáDSU]HPRF?0DNLDZHOLVW ZLHU] F\PZ
2SDWU]QR ü?QD]\ZDQ\E\ZDIUDQFXVNLSROLW\NLSDPL WQLNDU]3KLOLSSHGH&RPP\Q
*F\NUyORZL/XGZLNRZL;,NWyU\PyJáE\VáX*\ü]D
HVYDQGH&O\WHVáX
*
UHDOQ\SLHUZRZ]yUPDNLDZHOLD VNLHJR?NVL FLD?&RPP\QHVWH RFHQLDáF]\Q\
SROLW\F]QHZJNU\WHULXPVNXWHF]QRFLQLHPQLHMXZD*Dá*HZDUXQNLHPSRZRG]HQLDMHVW
SU]HVWU]HJDQLH]DUD]HPPRUDOQ\FKLSUDNW\F]Q\FK]DVDGWDNLFKMDN]DXIDQLHWURVND
*
RGREURSXEOLF]QHLSRER QR ü2U\JLQDOQDE\áDMHJRNRQFHSFMDSURZLGHQFMDOLVW\F]QHM
*
NRUHNW\GOD?PDNLDZHOVNLHM?SROLW\NLSROHJDM FDQDW\P H2SDWU]QR ü%R DGDMH *
*
ND GHPX]NVL *WMDNRSU]HFLZZDJ
GUXJLHJRNVL
FLDNWyU\QDGQLP?F]XZD?W]Q
SU]HV]NDG]DPXZ]UHDOL]RZDQLXQD]E\WDPELWQ\FKSODQyZ
-HGQ\P]SLHUZV]\FKOHF]]DUD]HPXSUDV]F]DM F\FKP\ OUHFHSWRUyZ0DFKLDYHOOHJRE\á
MHJRSU]\MDFLHOLZVSyáSUDFRZQLNUyZQLH MHGHQ]SLHUZV]\FKNU\W\NyZ8WRSLL0RUXVD *
)UDQFHVFR9HWWRULDNWyU\XWU]\P\ZDáL NWRFKFHE\üZáDGF *
*
SUDZG]LZ\PQLHPR HOLF]\üQDWRE\XZD DQRJR]DF]áRZLHNDUHOLJLMQHJRDMX * *
]XSHáQLHQLH]JRGQLH]SU]HNRQDQLDPLDXWRUD.VL FLD HZU]HF]\ZLVWR FLZV]\VWNLH
*
?EDUEDU]\ FyZ?L]MHGQRF]HQLX,WDOLL]D *XLFFLDUGLQLQLHSR]ZDODáVRELHQD DGQH *
* *
SURURFWZD3ROHPL]RZDáWDN HZSURVW]XZLHOELHQLHPDXWRUD5R]ZD D QDG/LZLXV]HP
* * *
GODVWDUR \WQHJR5]\PXXZD DM F HSU]\ZRá\ZDQLHMDNLFKNROZLHNZ]RUyZ]
SU]HV]áRFLMHVWMDáRZHJG\*QLHPDFLVáHJRSRGRELHVWZDPL
G]\RGOHJá\PLIDNWDPL
KLVWRU\F]Q\PLSU]HWRQLHSRGREQDLFKQRUPDW\ZQLH]ZL]Dü
7DNVDPRMDNKLVWRULRJUDILDDQDOLW\F]QDLQG\ZLGXDOLVW\F]QDLSHV\PLVW\F]QDE\áD
DQWURSRORJLDSROLW\F]QD*XLFFLDUGLQLHJR0RWRUHPG]LHMyZMHVWGOD MHGQRVWNDZUD]]MHM
]UHJXá\QLHFKZDOHEQ\PLF]\QDPLLQLHEXGXM F\PLQDPL WQR FLDPL=JDG]DáVL RQ
* *
ZSUDZG]LH]DáR \ü HOXG]LHV]XNDM GREUDLVSUDZLHGOLZR FLRLOHLFKUR]XPQLHMHVW
]DüPLRQ\SU]H]LQWHUHVZáDVQ\OXEQDMEOL V]\FKDOERSU]H]REDZ SU]HG]HPVW *
V\WXDFMHWDNLHV MHGQDNUHJXá 1LHQDOH \WDN HSRNáDGDüQDG]LHLQDXV]ODFKHWQLHQLH * *
]ZLHU] FLHP]ZDULRZDQ\PNWRZ\SRZLDGDVáRZR?
OXG?
PDQDP\ OLRV]DODáH]ZLHU]
VL ZMHJRPDNV\PDFKPRW\ZLGHQW\ILNRZDQHJR]YLUWXKRQRUX?NWyU\MHVW
( *
SáRPLHQQ\PERG FHPQDMZ\ V] FQRW EH]NWyUHMPDUWZHV LSXVWHSRF]\QDQLD
SU]H]ZSURZDG]DQLHGRQLFKOXG]LNWyU\FKPR QDSU]HNXSLüOXE]DVWUDV]\ü=P *
*
SUHPLHU$QWRQLR6DODQGUDX]DVDGQLDM FQLP]áDPDQLH7UyMSU]\PLHU]D]$XVWUR
: JUDPLL1LHPFDPLDSU]\VW SLHQLHSU]HFLZNRQLPGRZRMQ\SRVWURQLH(QWHQW\
1DMVáDZQLHMV]\PL?PDNLDZHOLVWDPLSUDNW\NXM F\PL?E\OLMHGQDNEH]Z WSLHQLDGZDM
Vá\QQLIUDQFXVF\SROLW\F\SHUVRQLILNXM F\SRM FLHUDLVRQGCpWDWNVL
*
NDUG\QDá
$UPDQG-HDQGX3OHVVLVGH5LFKHOLHXQDNWyUHJRQRFQ\PVWROLNX
*
OH Dá\]DZV]HRERNVLHELHEUHZLDU]L.VL *
RUD]ELVNXSUHQHJDWL]GUDG]DMF\
ZV]\VWNLFKSDQXM F\FKOHF]QLJG\LQWHUHV)UDQFML&KDUOHV0DXULFHGH7DOOH\UDQG
3pULJRUGNVL *
%HQHZHQWX
*
:EOL V]\FKQDPF]DVDFKV]F]HJyOQHPLHMVFHQDOH \SU]\]QDüVRFMRORJRPSROLW\NL *
?UHDOLVWRPSROLW\F]Q\P?NWyU\FKLFKDGPLUDWRUDQW\NRPXQLVW\F]Q\HNVWURFNLVWD
-DPHV%XUQKDPQD]\ZD?PDNLDZHOLDQDPLREUR FDPLZROQR FL?
*
0LDQHPW\PRNUH OHQL]RVWDOLDXWRU]\REDUG]RUy Q\FKSU]HNRQDQLDFKSROLW\F]Q\FKOHF]
ZSRGREQ\FKáRGQ\DQDOLW\F]Q\LGRFLHNDM F\XNU\W\FKVSU
*\QG]LDáDQLDSROLW\F]QHJR
VSRVyEP\ O F\RSROLW\FHIUDQFXVNLDQDUFKRV\QG\NDOLVWDSURSDJDWRU?VWUDMNX
JHQHUDOQHJR?LDQDOLW\N?PLWXSROLW\F]QHJR?*HRUJHV6RUHOZáRVNL
OLEHUDáNRQVHUZDW\ZQ\WHRUHW\N?NODV\SROLW\F]QHM?LRGNU\ZFD?IRUPXá\SROLW\F]QHM?
*
MDNRPHWRG\OHJLW\PL]DFMLZáDG]\*DHWDQR0RVFDUyZQLH :áRFKL
NRQVHUZDW\ZQ\OHVHIHU\VWDWHRUHW\N?NU *HQLDHOLW?9LOIUHGR)HGHULFR'DPDVRPDUNL]
3DUHWRQLHPLHFNLVRFMDOGHPRNUDWDDSy(QLHMQDWXUDOL]RZDQ\ZH
:áRV]HFKIDV]\VWDDXWRU?*HOD]QHJRSUDZDROLJDUFKLL?5REHUWR0LFKHOV
QLHNWyU]\]DOLF]DMMHV]F]HGRWHJRJURQDUDG\NDOQHJRGHPRNUDW
LDQW\IDV]\VW
*XLGD'RUVD
*
,FKZ\ELWQ\PNRQW\QXDWRUHPMHVWUyZQLH IUDQFXVNLVRFMRORJSROLW\NL-XOLHQ)UHXQG
*
ZL NV]\P]DVSRNDMDM SRWU]HE\QLHHOLW\R:Z\SDGNXND GHMHOLW\Z\VW SXM *
]DZV]HGZLHSU]HFLZVWDZQHWHQGHQFMHDDU\VWRNUDW\F]QD]DSRPRF NWyUHMGDQD
*
JDQJVWHUyZ?%HUWUDQG5XVVHOOSRHQWX]MDVW\F]Q SRFKZDá L ?QLF]\PRU]HáXQRVLVL
?URPDQW\NLHP?&KRFLD*GRSLHUZV]HJRVWDQRZLVNDVNáDQLDVL
ERGDMZL
NV]Rü
NRPHQWDWRUyZZW\P(UQVW&DVVLUHU$XJXVWLQ5HQDXGHW/HRQDUGR2OVFKNL.HLWK
*
+DQFRFNF]\.DUO6FKPLGWRMHGQDNQLHEUDNXMHSRZD Q\FKLQWHUSUHWDWRUyZ
* *
GRVWU]HJDM F\FKZQLPQDPL WQR FLWDNVLOQH HD SU]HNUDF]DM FHJUDQLFHUHDOL]PX
)HGHULFR&KDERG?ZLHONSDVM
?5XGROIR5LGROILRUD]ZL]MRQHUVWZR9LWWRULRGH
&DSUDULLV
**
*
3DSLH 3DZHá,9SROHFLáZFL JQ üG]LHáD0DFKLDYHOOHJRQD,QGH[MX *
FRSRWZLHUG]Lá6REyU7U\GHQFNLOHF]SDSLH 6\NVWXV9QLH *
V]DWD VNLHMVSUDZLHLE\áF]áRZLHNLHPNWyUHPXREF RND]DáDVL ZV]HONDSRER QR ü
*
LVWRW NWyUHMREFHV ZV]HONLHXF]XFLDOXG]NLHD]ZáDV]F]DKXPDQL]PF]\OLWR ü:
VSUDZDFKZLDU\E\áRQFDáNRZLW\PDWHLVW ZG]LHG]LQLH]D SROLW\NLPR QDJRMHG\QLH *
SRUyZQDü]Z\]QDZFDPL0DKRPHWD?,XGLFLXPGH1XDHPLOLWLV*DOOL-RDQQLV%RGLQL
3KLOLSSL0RUQDHL1LFRODL0DFKLDYHOOLTXLEXVGDPVFULSVLVTXRUXP&DWDORJXPLQQHUVD
SDJLQDLQGLFDELW3RVVHYLQR]DNZHVWLRQRZDáMHGQDNQLHW\ONRPRUDOQR üOHF]L
*
UHDOL]PSROLW\F]Q\0DFKLDYHOOHJRSU]HNRQXM F H?NWRNROZLHN]HFKFLDáE\GDüZLDU
MHJRZ\ZRGRPPXVLDáE\UyZQLH*]JRG]LüVL
]W\P*HZQLHGáXJLPF]DVLHUR]V\SLHVL
L
UXQLHND*GHQDMVLOQLHMV]HQDZHWNVL
VWZRU]HF]SRVSROLWDNUyOHVWZRF]\
FHVDUVWZR?WDP*H:DUWRüGRZRGRZDQW\PDNLDZHOVNLFKGLDWU\E3RVVHYLQDSRGZD*D
GRZLHG]LRQ\MX*SU]H]+HUPDQD&RQULQJDIDNWL*ZáRVNLMH]XLWDQLHF]\WDá
RU\JLQDOQ\FKSLVP)ORUHQWF]\NDDVZRMNU\W\N
IRUPXáRZDáQDSRGVWDZLH(UyGHá
SRUHGQLFKJáyZQLHSDPIOHWXIUDQFXVNLHJRNDOZLQLVW\VLF,QQRFHQWD*HQWLOOHWD
'LVFRXUVFRQWUH0DFKLDYHO
=DUyZQR*HQWLOOHWLLQQLKXJHQRFF\?PRQDUFKRPDFKRZLH??NUyOREyMF\?NWyU]\
PRUDOQ\FK:\PRZQ\PZ\M WNLHPQDW\PWOHE\áSUDZGRSRGREQLHNU\SWRNDWROLFNL
?UHNX]DQW?:LOOLDP6KDNHVSHDUHNWyUHJRZ\REUD HQLHRPE\áRZSUDZG]LH *
*
UyZQLH ]JRGQH]SRWRF]Q\PVWHUHRW\SHP0DFKLDYHOOHJRMDNR?HUXG\W\]EURGQL?OH
GRFWHXUGHODVFpOpUDWHVVHDOHRFHQDEH]Z]JO GQLHXMHPQDLZGXFKXRSLQLL
NDWROLFNLFKDQW\PDNLDZHOLVWyZVSR UyGERJDWHMJDOHULL?0DNLDZHOyZ?V]HNVSLURZVNLFK
PLQ.ODXGLXV]Z+DPOHFLH-DJRZ2WHOOX(GPXQG*RQHU\ODL5HJDQDZ.UyOX/LU]H
QLHJRZ;;Z*LXVHSSH7RIIDQLQ5XGROIR5LGROILL/HVOLH-:DONHU
2GPLHQQHLRGNDWROLFNLFKLRGSURWHVWDQFNLFKDQW\PDNLDZHOLVWyZSRGHM FLH]QDOD]áR
Z\UD]ZG]LHáDFKNDWROLFNLFKWDNZáRVNLFK*%RWHUR/=XFFROR/6HWWDODMDN
KLV]SD VNLFK)&HULRO$GH%DUULHQWRV%)HLMRRWDF\W\VWyZWMDXWRUyZ
LQVSLUXM F\FKVL ZL]M KLVWRULLQLHUHSXEOLNDQLQD/LZLXV]DOHF]FH]DU\VW\7DF\WD
WDF\W\FLQLHUH]\JQXMF]NU\W\NLVSU]HF]Q\FK]HW\NFKU]HFLMDVNSLHUZLDVWNyZP
SRWUDNWRZDOLJRMHGQDNMDNRSXQNWZ\MFLDSR?RF]\V]F]HQLX]SOHZ?GR
Z\SUDFRZDQLDQRZHMQDXNLR?SUDZG]LZHM?UDFMLVWDQXLOUDJLRQHGLVWDWRYHUR
YHUGDGHUDUD]yQGH(VWDGRL?NVL FLXFKU]H FLMD VNLP?LOSULQFLSHFULVWLDQRNWyUHJR
YLUWXZLQQDE\ü]DUyZQRSU]H]RUQDUR]ZDJDSUXGHQ]DMDNSRER QR üLNWyU\ZLQLHQ *
GEDüRSRVLDGDQLHGRUDGFyZPRJ F\FKZ\GDüZLDU\JRGQ RSLQL FRGR]JRGQR FL
]DPLHU]RQHJRG]LDáDQLD]PRUDOQRFLNDWROLFN
-HGHQ]?WDF\W\VWyZ?7UDLDQR%RFFDOLQLRUD]SURWHVWDQW$OEHULFR*
*
HQWLOL]DSRF] WNRZDOLWDN HWHQGHQFM GRRGF]\W\ZDQLD0DFKLDYHOOHJR
?QDRSDN?F]\OLWUDNWRZDQLD.VL FLDMDNRGREU]H]DNDPXIORZDQHMVDW\U\LSDPIOHWX
RVWU]HJDM FHJROXGSU]HGW\UDQL NVL *WRUD]SRXF]DMFHJRMDNVL
SU]HGQLEURQLü
ZV]\VWNRSRGSRU] GNRZ\ZDáG
*HQLXGRXZROQLHQLD?ZL
WHM?ZáRVNLHM]LHPLRG
( (
GHSF] F\FKM QDMH G FyZ:\]QDZFDPLWHJRSRJO GXDZMHJRNRQVHNZHQFMLWH]\L *
WH]\)ORUHQWF]\NDQDOH*\RJOGDüLRVG]DüMHG\QLHZNRQWHNFLHJHRJUDILF]QR
KLVWRU\F]Q\PE\OLPLQZ;9,,,ZGUDPDWXUJ9LWWRULR$OILHULLKLVWRULR]RI-RKDQQ
*+HUGHUZ;,;*:)+HJHODQJLHOVNLZLJ7KRPDV%0DFDXOD\L
)UDQFHVFR'H6DQFWLVDZ;;2UHVWHV7RPPDVLQL
6]F]\WHPPLVW\ILNDFMLLSU]HZURWQHMKLSRNU\]MLE\áRFLHNDM F\PRUDOQ\PREXU]HQLHPL
KXPDQLWDU\]PHP$QW\0DNLDZHOQDSLVDQ\SU]H]NUyOD3UXV)U\GHU\ND
,,NWyUHJRFDáDG]LDáDOQR üSROLW\F]QDXRVDELDSRM FLHPZMHJRRELHJRZ\PVHQVLHZ
*
W\PZ\SDGNXUDFM QDOH \SU]\]QDü9ROWDLUHCRZLNWyU\VWZLHUG]LáL SLV] F$QW\ *
0DNLDZHOD)U\GHU\NQDSOXáZVZyMXOXELRQ\WRUW HE\QLNWLQQ\QLHPyJáJRMH ü *
-DZQ\PHQWX]MDVW 0DFKLDYHOOHJRE\áQDWRPLDVWFHVDU])UDQFX]yZ1DSROHRQ,
* *
NWyU\XZD Dá HMHVWWRMHG\Q\SLVDU]SROLW\F]Q\JRGQ\F]\WDQLDDSR]RVWDOLWR
ED QLRSLVDU]H
7UXGQRWUDNWRZDüMDNRDUJXPHQWSU]HFLZNRPSRGREQ\HQWX]MD]PRND]\ZDQ\SU]H]
QDFHFKRZDQHFRQDMPQLHMUH]HUZ RVáDZLRQ\SURNXUDWRUVWDOLQRZVNL$QGULHM
:\V]\QVNLMJU]PLDáQDZHWREXU]HQLHPZPRZLHRVNDU \FLHOVNLHMSU]HFLZNRDXWRURZL *
/LEHUDá%HQHGHWWR&URFHSU]\SLVXMFDXWRURZL.VL
FLD?VXURZLGRMPXMF
ZLDGRPRüPRUDOQ?XQCDXVWHUDHGRORURVDFRVFLHQ]DPRUDOHZLG]LDáZQLP
XGU
F]RQHJRGRVWU]HJDQ\PLLRSLV\ZDQ\PL]EURGQLDPLKXPDQLVW
RUD]EROHMFHJRQDG
OXG]NLPLSU]\ZDUDPLPRUDOLVW
NWyU\?RGF]DVXGRF]DVXRGF]XZDPRUDOQ\
QLHVPDN?(OHPHQWLGLSROLWLFD%DULMHGQRF]HQLH&URFHXZD *Dá?Z\]ZROHQLH
SROLW\NLRGHW\NLLUHOLJLL?]D?V]F]\WRZHRVLJQL
FLH?0DFKLDYHOOHJRNWyU\WRSRJOG
UR]ZLQá(ULF:&RFKUDQHWZLHUG]FL*?0DFKLDYHOOLQLHQHJRZDáVáXV]QRFL
PRUDOQRFLFKU]HFLMD VNLHMLQLHXVLáRZDáQLNRPXZPDZLDü*H]EURGQLDSRG\NWRZDQD
SROLW\F]QNRQLHF]QRFLSU]HVWDMHE\ü]EURGQL3RSURVWXRGNU\á*HQDV]D
PRUDOQRüQLHPD]DVWRVRZDQLDZG]LHG]LQLHSROLW\NLRUD]*HND*GHG]LDáDQLHSROLW\F]QH
RSDUWHQD]DáR*HQLX *HPDRQDWDNLH]DVWRVRZDQLHPXVLGRSURZDG]LüGRNDWDVWURI\
-HJRSRGEXGRZDQDIDNWDPLRELHNW\ZQDDQDOL]DZVSyáF]HVQ\FKPXSROLW\F]Q\FK
VWRVXQNyZQLHMHVWSU]HMDZHPF\QL]PXDQLPRUDOQHMRERM WQR FLDOHZHZQ WU]QHM
WHRUL %XUFNKDUGWD]JDG]DOLVL LUR]ZLMDOLM PLQ)ULHGULFK0HLQHFNH&DUO-)ULHGULFKL
&KDUOHV6LQJOHWRQ
0\ OLFLHOHNRQVHUZDW\ZQL]UHJXá\PDM GRPVWRVXQHNNU\W\F]Q\Z\M ZV]\
NRQVHUZDW\ZQ\FK?GHF\]MRQLVWyZ?&DUO6FKPLWW$UPLQ0RKOHUZZ\SDGNX
NRQVHUZDW\VWyZNDWROLFNLFKSRZRGHPWHMNU\W\NLMHVWSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPGRNRQDQDSU]H]
DUJXPHQWDFMDRQLHPRUDOQR FLPLGRWNOLZ\PRNDOHF]HQLXSU]H]H LQWHOHNWX
SUDNW\F]QHJRF]áRZLHND-DFTXHV0DULWDLQR0LHF]\VáDZ$.U SLHF23,QQL
VDPHJR.U]\V]WRID.ROXPED?3UDZRQDWXUDOQHZ ZLHWOHKLVWRULL:DUV]DZD
:3ROVFH0DFKLDYHOOLE\áGREU]H]QDQ\LNRPHQWRZDQ\MX Z;9,ZZyMWZLOH VNL] *
F]DVyZSDQRZDQLD=\JPXQWD,,$XJXVWD$XJXVWXV5RWXQGXV$XJXVW\Q0LHOHFNL
.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\_XO:LWZLFNLHJRP:DUV]DZD_N]P#NRQVHUZDW\]PSO