You are on page 1of 171

February 21, 2017

Kristopher A. Isham
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
kristopher.isham@walmartlegal.com

Re: Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.


Incoming letter dated January 30, 2017

Dear Mr. Isham:

This is in response to your letter dated January 30, 2017 concerning the
shareholder proposal submitted to Walmart by Mary Pat Tifft. Copies of all of the
correspondence on which this response is based will be made available on our website at
http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cf-noaction/14a-8.shtml. For your reference, a
brief discussion of the Division’s informal procedures regarding shareholder proposals is
also available at the same website address.

Sincerely,

Matt S. McNair
Senior Special Counsel

Enclosure

cc: Mary Pat Tifft


***FISMA & OMB Memorandum M-07-16 ***
February 21, 2017

Response of the Office of Chief Counsel


Division of Corporation Finance

Re: Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.


Incoming letter dated January 30, 2017

The proposal requests that Walmart establish time-bound, quantitative goals for
reducing U.S. food waste and issue a report on its plans to achieve these goals.

There appears to be some basis for your view that Walmart may exclude the
proposal under rule 14a-8(i)(10). Based on the information you have presented, it
appears that Walmart’s public disclosures compare favorably with the guidelines of the
proposal and that Walmart has, therefore, substantially implemented the proposal.
Accordingly, we will not recommend enforcement action to the Commission if Walmart
omits the proposal from its proxy materials in reliance on rule 14a-8(i)(10).

Sincerely,

Sonia Bednarowski
Attorney-Adviser
DIVISION OF CORPORATION FINANCE
INFORMAL PROCEDURES REGARDING SHAREHOLDER PROPOSALS

The Division of Corporation Finance believes that its responsibility with respect
to matters arising under Rule 14a-8 [17 CFR 240.14a-8], as with other matters under the
proxy rules, is to aid those who must comply with the rule by offering informal advice
and suggestions and to determine, initially, whether or not it may be appropriate in a
particular matter to recommend enforcement action to the Commission. In connection
with a shareholder proposal under Rule 14a-8, the Division’s staff considers the
information furnished to it by the company in support of its intention to exclude the
proposal from the company’s proxy materials, as well as any information furnished by
the proponent or the proponent’s representative.

Although Rule 14a-8(k) does not require any communications from shareholders
to the Commission’s staff, the staff will always consider information concerning alleged
violations of the statutes and rules administered by the Commission, including arguments
as to whether or not activities proposed to be taken would violate the statute or rule
involved. The receipt by the staff of such information, however, should not be construed
as changing the staff’s informal procedures and proxy review into a formal or adversarial
procedure.

It is important to note that the staff’s no-action responses to Rule 14a-8(j)


submissions reflect only informal views. The determinations reached in these no-action
letters do not and cannot adjudicate the merits of a company’s position with respect to the
proposal. Only a court such as a U.S. District Court can decide whether a company is
obligated to include shareholder proposals in its proxy materials. Accordingly, a
discretionary determination not to recommend or take Commission enforcement action
does not preclude a proponent, or any shareholder of a company, from pursuing any
rights he or she may have against the company in court, should the company’s
management omit the proposal from the company’s proxy materials.
Legal
Corporate 702 SW 8th Street
Bentonville, AR 72716-0215
Phone 479.204.8684
Kristopher A. Isham Fax 479.277.5991
Associate General Counsel Kristopher.Isham@walmartlegal.com

January 30, 2017

VIA E-MAIL to shareholderproposals@sec.gov

Office of Chief Counsel


Division of Corporation Finance
Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, NE
Washington, DC 20549

Re: Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.


Shareholder Proposal of Mary Pat Tifft
Exchange Act of 1934—Rule 14a-8

Ladies and Gentlemen:

This letter is to inform you that Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (the “Company”) intends to omit
from its proxy statement and form of proxy for its 2017 Annual Meeting of Shareholders
(collectively, the “2017 Proxy Materials”) a shareholder proposal (the “Proposal”) and statement
in support thereof received Mary Pat Tifft (the “Proponent”).

Pursuant to Rule 14a-8(j), we have:

 filed this letter with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “Commission”) no
later than eighty (80) calendar days before the Company intends to file its definitive
2017 Proxy Materials with the Commission; and

 concurrently sent copies of this correspondence to the Proponent.

Rule 14a-8(k) and Staff Legal Bulletin No. 14D (Nov. 7, 2008) (“SLB 14D”) provide that
shareholder proponents are required to send companies a copy of any correspondence that the
proponents elect to submit to the Commission or the staff of the Division of Corporation Finance
(the “Staff”). Accordingly, we are taking this opportunity to inform the Proponent that if the
Proponent elects to submit additional correspondence to the Commission or the Staff with
respect to this Proposal, a copy of that correspondence should be furnished concurrently to the
undersigned on behalf of the Company pursuant to Rule 14a-8(k) and SLB 14D.
Office of Chief Counsel
Division of Corporation Finance
January 30, 2017
Page 2

THE PROPOSAL

The Proposal states:

Resolved: Shareholders request that Walmart establish time-bound, quantitative


goals for reducing U.S. food waste and issue a report, at reasonable cost and
omitting proprietary information, on its plans to achieve these goals.

A copy of the Proposal and related correspondence from the Proponent is attached hereto as
Exhibit A.

BASIS FOR EXCLUSION

We hereby respectfully request that the Staff concur in our view that the Proposal may be
excluded from the 2017 Proxy Materials pursuant to Rule 14a-8(i)(10) because the Company has
substantially implemented the Proposal based on disclosures made on the Company’s website,
including the Company’s 2016 Global Responsibility Report (the “2016 GR Report.”)1, attached
as Exhibit B.

ANALYSIS

The Proposal May Be Excluded Under Rule 14a-8(i)(10) Because The Company Has
Substantially Implemented The Proposal.

A. Background

Rule 14a-8(i)(10) permits a company to exclude a shareholder proposal from its proxy
materials if the company has substantially implemented the proposal. The Commission stated in
1976 that the predecessor to Rule 14a-8(i)(10) was “designed to avoid the possibility of
shareholders having to consider matters which already have been favorably acted upon by the
management.” Exchange Act Release No. 12598 (July 7, 1976) (the “1976 Release”).
Originally, the Staff narrowly interpreted this predecessor rule and granted no-action relief only
when proposals were “‘fully’ effected” by the company. See Exchange Act Release No. 19135
(Oct. 14, 1982). By 1983, the Commission recognized that the “previous formalistic application
of [the Rule] defeated its purpose” because proponents were successfully convincing the Staff to
deny no-action relief by submitting proposals that differed from existing company policy by only
a few words. Exchange Act Release No. 20091, at § II.E.6. (Aug. 16, 1983) (the “1983
Release”). Therefore, in 1983, the Commission adopted a revised interpretation of the rule to
permit the omission of proposals that had been “substantially implemented.” 1983 Release. The
1998 amendments to the proxy rules codified this position. See Exchange Act Release No.
40018, at n.30 and accompanying text (May 21, 1998).

1
The 2016 GR Report is available at http://corporate.walmart.com/2016grr.
Office of Chief Counsel
Division of Corporation Finance
January 30, 2017
Page 3

Under this standard, when a company can demonstrate that it already has taken actions to
address the underlying concerns and essential objectives of a shareholder proposal, the Staff has
concurred that the proposal has been “substantially implemented” and may be excluded as
moot. See, e.g., Exelon Corp. (avail. Feb. 26, 2010); Exxon Mobil Corp. (Burt)
(avail. Mar. 23, 2009); Anheuser-Busch Companies, Inc. (avail. Jan. 17, 2007); ConAgra Foods,
Inc. (avail. July 3, 2006); Johnson & Johnson (avail. Feb. 17, 2006); Talbots Inc.
(avail. Apr. 5, 2002); Exxon Mobil Corp. (avail. Jan. 24, 2001); Masco Corp.
(avail. Mar. 29, 1999); The Gap, Inc. (avail. Mar. 8, 1996). The Staff has noted that “a
determination that the company has substantially implemented the proposal depends upon
whether [the company’s] particular policies, practices and procedures compare favorably with
the guidelines of the proposal.” Texaco, Inc. (avail. Mar. 28, 1991). In applying
Rule 14a-8(i)(10), the Staff consistently has concurred with the exclusion of shareholder
proposals that, like the Proposal, request a report containing information that the company has
already publicly disclosed.

The Staff has concurred in the exclusion of proposals requesting that a company’s board
of directors prepare a report on a particular corporate initiative when the company has published
information about that initiative on its website. See Gap, Inc. (avail. Mar. 16, 2001) (concurring
that a proposal requesting that the board of directors prepare a report on the child labor practices
of the company’s suppliers was substantially implemented when the company had published
information on its website with respect to its vendor code and monitoring programs). See also
Honeywell International, Inc. (avail. Feb. 21, 2007) (concurring that a proposal requesting that
the board of directors prepare a sustainability report was substantially implemented when the
company had disclosed its sustainability policies on its website); Raytheon Co. (avail. Jan. 25,
2006) (concurring that a proposal requesting that the board of directors prepare a sustainability
report was substantially implemented when the company had published a stewardship report on
its website).

At the same time, a company need not implement a proposal in exactly the manner set
forth by the proponent. See 1998 Release, at n.30 and accompanying text. See, e.g., Hewlett
Packard Co. (Steiner) (avail. Dec. 11, 2007) (proposal requesting that the board permit
shareholders to call special meetings was substantially implemented by a proposed bylaw
amendment to permit shareholders to call a special meeting unless the board determined that the
specific business to be addressed had been addressed recently or would soon be addressed at an
annual meeting). Differences between a company’s actions and a shareholder proposal are
permitted as long as the company’s actions satisfactorily address the proposal’s essential
objectives. Thus, in the context of evaluating whether a company has substantially implemented
a proposal that requests a review and report, the Staff has taken into account a company’s
existing disclosures, even if not issued in the form of a report in response to a proposal. For
example, in The Coca-Cola Co. (avail. Jan. 25, 2012, recon. denied Feb. 29, 2012), in which the
proposal requested that the board prepare a report “updating investors on how the company is
responding to the public policy challenges associated with [Bisphenol A, or BPA].” The
company asserted that its website already disclosed “information about the use of BPA in
Office of Chief Counsel
Division of Corporation Finance
January 30, 2017
Page 4

aluminum can liners and the [c]ompany’s priority of ensuring the safety and quality of its
products and packaging.” Although the disclosures referenced by the company were scattered
across multiple pages of the company’s website, the Staff concurred in the exclusion of the
proposal under Rule 14a-8(i)(10), noting that the company’s “public disclosures compare
favorably with the guidelines of the proposal and that [the company] has, therefore, substantially
implemented the proposal.” See also Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (avail. Mar. 10, 2008); PG&E Corp.
(avail. Mar. 6, 2008); The Dow Chemical Co. (avail. Mar. 5, 2008); Johnson & Johnson (avail.
Feb. 22, 2008) (in each case, concurring in the exclusion, under Rule 14a-8(i)(10), of a proposal
requesting that the company issue a report based upon the company having already publicly
disclosed the subject matter of the requested report).

The Proposal requests that the Company (1) “establish time-bound, quantitative goals for
reducing U.S. food waste,” and (2) “issue a report . . . on its plan to achieve these goals.” As
discussed below, the Company’s website, including the 2016 GR Report, includes information
that substantially implements both of these requests.

B. The Company’s Website Provides Disclosure Regarding Time-Bound,


Quantitative Goals For Reducing U.S. Food Waste.

The Proposal requests that the Company “establish time-bound, quantitative goals for
reducing U.S. food waste.” As discussed below and disclosed on the Company’s website, the
Company has already adopted a time-bound, quantitative goal to reduce food waste in the United
States. Specifically, the Company has established a goal to achieve zero waste to landfill in key
markets, including the United States, by 2025.

On November 4, 2016, the Company’s Chief Executive Officer, Doug McMillon,


outlined a roadmap for the Company’s role in society.2 One of the three goals discussed in this
roadmap is the goal “to create zero waste in company operations.” More specifically, the
roadmap detailed how the Company plans to achieve zero waste to landfill by 2025 in markets
that include the United States:

Achieve zero waste to landfill in key markets by 2025: Progress so far has
been significant on the original goal. In 2015, 75 percent of Walmart’s global
waste was diverted from landfills, helping to reduce costs to the business,
customers and society. Under the roadmap, the company will achieve zero waste
to landfill from our own operations in key markets, including the U.S., U.K.,
Japan, and Canada by 2025. (emphasis added)

2
See Walmart Offers New Vision for the Company’s Role in Society, available at
http://news.walmart.com/2016/11/04/walmart-offers-new-vision-for-the-companys-role-in-society (last visited
Jan. 30, 2017).
Office of Chief Counsel
Division of Corporation Finance
January 30, 2017
Page 5

Further, as discussed on the Company’s website, the Company includes food waste in its goal of
zero waste to landfill. For example, the 2016 GR Report, in a section titled “[t]oward a zero
waste future,” on pages 70 through 79, has an extensive discussion on how the Company plans to
achieve this goal of zero waste, including a discussion solely focused on reducing food waste on
pages 74 through 75. Moreover, the Company’s goal of zero waste to landfill necessarily
encompasses a goal of zero food waste to landfill because the Company cannot achieve zero
waste to landfill if it has any food waste to landfill.

Thus, the Company has substantially implemented the first request in the Proposal
because the Company’s goal of zero waste to landfill in key markets, including the United States,
by 2025 is quantitative (as it sets a goal of zero waste), time-bound (as it specifies 2025 as when
the Company will seek to achieve the goal by), and encompasses the Company’s food waste in
the United States.

C. The Company’s Website Discloses How The Company Plans To Achieve These
Goals.

The 2016 GR Report details how the Company plans to achieve its move toward a zero
waste future, which includes zero food waste to landfill. The 2016 GR Report, on page 71,
discusses three main strategies the Company is taking to move towards a zero waste future: (1)
eliminating waste in the Company’s own productions, (2) promoting improvement and product
design, and (3) expanding recycling through support for educational and improved infrastructure.
The Company, in developing these three strategies to move toward a zero waste future, has
substantially implemented a plan to achieve its goal of zero waste to landfill in markets that
includes the United States by 2025.

As part of the Company’s plan to move toward a zero waste future, the Company details
its efforts to eliminate food waste in the Company’s own production, which will allow the
Company to reach its goal of zero food waste to landfill. Specifically, the Company, on page 74,
discusses how it plans to follow the United States Environmental Protection Agency’s Food
Recovery Hierarchy:

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) created the Food Recovery
Hierarchy to help organizations prioritize steps they can take to prevent waste and
divert unused food. Each tier of the Food Recovery Hierarchy focuses on
different management strategies. The top levels of the hierarchy generate the
most benefits for the environment, society and the economy. Walmart uses this
hierarchy as a guide in our efforts to put food that might otherwise go to a landfill
to its highest and best use.

As disclosed in the 2016 GR Report, the Food Recovery Hierarchy, from most preferred to least
preferred, is as follows: “Source Reduction” (reduce the volume of surplus food); “Feed Hungry
People” (donate extra food to food banks, soup kitchens and shelters); “Feed Animals” (divert
food scraps to animal feed); “Industrial Uses” (convert waste oils and food scraps into fuels or
Office of Chief Counsel
Division of Corporation Finance
January 30, 2017
Page 6

energy); “Composting” (create nutrient-rich soil amendment); and “Disposal” (use landfill or
incineration as last resort). Further, the 2016 GR Report provides shareholders with significant
detail on the Company’s current initiatives with respect to approaching zero waste for each of
above-referenced tiers in the Food Recovery Hierarchy.

With respect to “Source Reduction,” the 2016 GR Report discloses that the Company is
taking numerous actions:

 Utilizing whole crops because a significant portion of food waste occurs upstream in
the Company’s supply chain, as discussed on page 97. The Company also discusses
how it is working with its suppliers to achieve this goal.

 Improving date labels for customers with its “Best If Used By” date label
terminology, as discussed on page 97. The Company estimates it has eliminated an
estimated 660 million pounds of food waste.

 Removing only the broken eggs in a carton, and then consolidating the undamaged
eggs into whole cartons, as discussed on page 75. In 2015, this initiative resulted in
the Company preventing the waste of 37 million eggs in its United States stores.

With respect to “Feed Hungry People,” the 2016 GR Report, on page 97, discloses that
when food goes unpurchased, the Company works to get it to people and places that need it. In
2015, the Company donated 600 million pounds of food to people in need in the United States.

With respect to “Feed Animals,” “Industrial Uses” and “Composting” the 2016 GR
Report discloses that the Company is doing the following:

 Implementing a first-of-its-kind organics recycling program across the United States,


as discussed on page 72. As of 2015, the Company has diverted the equivalent of
more than 25,000 tractor-trailers full of food waste out of the waste stream.

 Selling garden products from Ecoscraps, a company that turns food scraps into
organic and sustainable lawn materials, as discussed on page 73. Ecoscraps are made
in part with food waste recycled by the Company.

Thus, based on these extensive disclosures in the 2016 GR Report, the Company’s disclosures
regarding following the Food Recovery Hierarchy to achieve its goal of zero waste to landfill in
key markets, including the United States, by 2025, compares favorably to, and substantially
implements the Proposal.

In this regard, the Proposal has provided the Company wide latitude in determining how
to accomplish this goal. The Proposal does not specify the precise goal, only that the goal should
be time-bound, quantitative and encompass the United States. Further, the supporting statement
Office of Chief Counsel
Division of Corporation Finance
January 30, 2017
Page 7

merely recommends that these goals “be consistent with the [Consumer Goods Forum] goal and
that the report include a quantitative value for total food waste generated by Walmart’s U.S.
operations annually” but does not require that the Company goals accomplish exactly this. The
Staff has recognized that when a proposal merely suggests that a certain issue be addressed, the
proposal may be excluded where the company has addressed the requested, but not suggested,
matters. For example, in ConAgra Foods, Inc. (avail. July 3, 2006), the Staff concurred in the
exclusion under Rule 14a-8(i)(10) of a proposal requesting that the board issue a sustainability
report, where the supporting statement recommended that the report follow certain guidelines
that the company did not address in its existing policies and procedures. See also Wal-Mart
Stores, Inc. (AFL-CIO Reserve Fund) (avail. Mar. 30, 2010) (concurring with the exclusion
under Rule 14a-8(i)(10) of a proposal urging the board to adopt principles regarding global
warming “based on” a set of principles listed in the supporting statement, where the Company
argued that it need not adopt the listed principles wholesale).

Further, the Staff has consistently concurred in the exclusion of shareholder proposals
seeking a report when the contents of the requested report were disclosed in multiple locations
on the company’s corporate website. See, e.g. Mondelez International, Inc. (avail.
Mar. 7, 2014); The Coca-Cola Co. (avail. Jan. 25, 2012, recon. denied Feb. 29, 2012); The
Gap, Inc. (avail. Mar. 16, 2001). As in Mondelez, Coca-Cola and Gap, the Proposal is
excludable as substantially implemented even though the Company has disclosed the
information sought by the Proposal in several different locations on its website, including the
2016 GR Report. Through these disclosures, the Company has publicly disclosed its plan to
achieve its time-bound, quantitative goals for reducing U.S. food waste. Accordingly, the
Company has substantially implemented the Proposal, and it may be excluded from the 2017
Proxy Materials in reliance on Rule 14a-8(i)(10).

CONCLUSION

Based upon the foregoing analysis, we respectfully request that the Staff concur that it
will take no action if the Company excludes the Proposal from its 2017 Proxy Materials.

We would be happy to provide you with any additional information and answer any
questions that you may have regarding this subject. Please direct any correspondence regarding
this matter to me at Kristopher.Isham@walmartlegal.com. If we can be of any further assistance
in this matter, please do not hesitate to call me at (479) 204-8684, or Elizabeth A. Ising of
Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP at (202) 955-8287.
Office of Chief Counsel
Division of Corporation Finance
January 30, 2017
Page 8

Sincerely,

Kristopher A. Isham
Associate General Counsel
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.

Enclosures

cc: Elizabeth A. Ising, Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP


Mary Pat Tifft
EXHIBIT A
December 17. 2016

Gordon Y. Alli son


Vice President & General Counse l
Corporate Division
Wal-Marl Stores, Inc.
702 Southwest 8111 St.
Bentonville. A R 7271 6-02 15

Dear Mr. Allison:

/
I hereby submit the enclosed shareholder proposal c ·Proposa r") for inclusion in Wa l-Mart
Stores, Inc.'s ("Company"') proxy statement to be circu lated to Company shareholders in
conjunction with the next annual meeting of shareholders. The Proposal is submitted under
Ruic 14(a)-8 (Proposals o f Security Holders) of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commissiorf s
proxy regu lations.
I am the benefi cial owner of approximately 700 of shares o f the Company·s common
stock. which been held continuously fo r more than a year prior to this date o f submi ssion. I
intend to hold the shares th rough the date of the Company· s next annual meeting of shareholders.
The record holder of the stock will provide the appropriate verification of the Fund· s
beneficial ownership by separate letter. Either the undersigned or a designated representative
will present the Proposal for consideration at the annual meeting of shareholders.
If you have any questions or wish to di scuss the Proposal. please contact
***FISMAme& OMB Memorandumor at
M-07-16***
Copies
***FISMA & OMB Memorandum M-07-16*** o f correspondence or a request for a "no-act ion" letter
should be forwarded to ***FISMA & OMB Memorandum M-07-16*** .

Sincerely,

Mary Pat Tifft


Walmart shareholder

Encl:
Shareholder Resolu tion
food Waste

Whereas:
40% of food produced in the U.S. goes uneaten every year. costing the U.S. economy
$2 18 billion. or 1.3% of GDP.

Food is the largest waste stream in American landfills; once there, it decomposes and
em its methane. a greenhouse gas 80 times as potent as C02. Globally, if food waste were
a country. its greenhouse gas (ghg) emissions would rank 3rd. Food recovery programs
can help feed the nearly 50 mill ion food insecure Americans.

Reducing food waste presents financial opportunities as $57 billion is lost by consumer
facing businesses each year. For example, Stop & Shop saved an estimated $100 million
annually by reducing losses of peri shables wh ile prov iding item s that were 3 days fresher
on average.

Wal mart did not meet its goa l to reduce food waste in developed markets I 0% by
December 3 1. 20 15 (versus 2009 baseline). Further. accord ing to its 2016 Globa l
Respon sibility Report ("G RR 20 16.. ). Walmarf s food waste in the U.S . has actually
increased during thi s period. Shareholders are concerned that the increase in food waste
in the U.S. in particular. which represents 62.3 percent o f total sa les for fiscal 2016,
signa ls Walmart 's food waste management approach may be insufficient. In fact.
Walmart has acknowledged foo d and other wastes increase "costs for our business. our
customers. and for society:· 1

In addition. Walmart has not provided quantitative data on the total food waste generated
by company operations. a data point which is crucial for investors seeking to understand
trends in the company·s performance. For comparison, Tesco. wh ich is also among the
top five largest globa l food retailers. discloses this data point. The 400 members of The
Consumer Goods Forum (CG F), of which Wal marl is a member. have committed to
halve food waste by 2025, yet due to increased food waste in Walmart's largest market
and a lack o f new reduction goals. it is unclear how Wa lmart will meet that com mitm ent.

From a regulatory perspecti ve. several states have laws that commonly require retailers to
divert food waste from landfi lls and food waste related bills have been introduced in
Congress. In 2015. the EPA announced a target to red uce food waste 50 percent by 2030.

In light of these politica l and industry trend s. the proponent believes establishing a new
U.S . food waste reduction target and repo11ing on total food waste generated will promote
food waste reductions that enable Walmart to cul costs, provide com petitive advantage.
strengthen brand reputati on, save resources. al lev iate hunger and reduce green house gas
emissions.

1
http://corporate. wa Ima rt .com/201 Ggrr/en hanci n g-susta in abi Ii ty /mo vi ng-towa rd ·a-zero-was te-f u tu re
Resolved : Shareholders request that Walmart establish time-bound. quantitative goals for
reducing U.S . food waste and issue a report, al reasonable cost and omitting proprietary
in formation. on its plan s lo achieve these goals.

Supporting Statement: We recommend these goals be consistent with the CG F goal and
that the report inc lude a quantitative value for total food waste generated by Walmarfs
U.S. operations annually.

2
Elizabeth A. Ising
Direct: +1 202.955.8287
December 23, 2016 Fax: +1 202.530.9631
Eising@gibsondunn.com

VIA OVERNIGHT MAIL AND EMAIL

Mary Pat Tifft


***FISMA & OMB Memorandum M-07-16***

Dear Ms. Tifft:

I am writing on behalf of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (the “Company”), which received on


December 20, 2016, your shareholder proposal entitled “Food Waste” submitted pursuant to
Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) Rule 14a-8 for inclusion in the proxy
statement for the Company’s 2017 Annual Meeting of Shareholders (the “Proposal”).

The Proposal contains certain procedural deficiencies, which SEC regulations require
us to bring to your attention. Rule 14a-8(b) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as
amended, provides that shareholder proponents must submit sufficient proof of their
continuous ownership of at least $2,000 in market value, or 1%, of a company’s shares
entitled to vote on the proposal for at least one year as of the date the shareholder proposal
was submitted. The Company’s stock records do not indicate that you are the record owner
of sufficient shares to satisfy this requirement. In addition, to date we have not received
proof that you have satisfied Rule 14a-8’s ownership requirements as of the date that the
Proposal was submitted to the Company.

To remedy this defect, you must submit sufficient proof of your continuous
ownership of the required number or amount of Company shares for the one-year period
preceding and including December 18, 2016, the date the Proposal was submitted to the
Company. As explained in Rule 14a-8(b) and in SEC staff guidance, sufficient proof must
be in the form of:

(1) a written statement from the “record” holder of your shares (usually a broker or a
bank) verifying that you continuously held the required number or amount of
Company shares for the one-year period preceding and including December 18,
2016; or

(2) if you have filed with the SEC a Schedule 13D, Schedule 13G, Form 3, Form 4 or
Form 5, or amendments to those documents or updated forms, reflecting your
ownership of the required number or amount of Company shares as of or before
the date on which the one-year eligibility period begins, a copy of the schedule
and/or form, and any subsequent amendments reporting a change in the
ownership level and a written statement that you continuously held the required
number or amount of Company shares for the one-year period.
Mary Pat Tifft
December 23, 2016
Page 2

If you intend to demonstrate ownership by submitting a written statement from the


“record” holder of your shares as set forth in (1) above, please note that most large U.S.
brokers and banks deposit their customers’ securities with, and hold those securities through,
the Depository Trust Company (“DTC”), a registered clearing agency that acts as a securities
depository (DTC is also known through the account name of Cede & Co.). Under SEC Staff
Legal Bulletin No. 14F, only DTC participants are viewed as record holders of securities that
are deposited at DTC. You can confirm whether your broker or bank is a DTC participant by
asking your broker or bank or by checking DTC’s participant list, which is available at
http://www.dtcc.com/~/media/Files/Downloads/client-center/DTC/alpha.ashx. In these
situations, shareholders need to obtain proof of ownership from the DTC participant through
which the securities are held, as follows:

(1) If your broker or bank is a DTC participant, then you need to submit a written
statement from your broker or bank verifying that you continuously held the
required number or amount of Company shares for the one-year period preceding
and including December 18, 2016.

(2) If your broker or bank is not a DTC participant, then you need to submit proof of
ownership from the DTC participant through which the shares are held verifying
that you continuously held the required number or amount of Company shares for
the one-year period preceding and including December 18, 2016. You should be
able to find out the identity of the DTC participant by asking your broker or bank.
If your broker is an introducing broker, you may also be able to learn the identity
and telephone number of the DTC participant through your account statements,
because the clearing broker identified on your account statements will generally
be a DTC participant. If the DTC participant that holds your shares is not able to
confirm your individual holdings but is able to confirm the holdings of your
broker or bank, then you need to satisfy the proof of ownership requirements by
obtaining and submitting two proof of ownership statements verifying that, for the
one-year period preceding and including December 18, 2016, the required number
or amount of Company shares were continuously held: (i) one from your broker
or bank confirming your ownership, and (ii) the other from the DTC participant
confirming the broker or bank’s ownership.

The SEC’s rules require that any response to this letter be postmarked or transmitted
electronically no later than 14 calendar days from the date you receive this letter. Please
address any response to Geoffrey W. Edwards, the Company’s Senior Associate General
Counsel, at 702 SW 8th Street, MS 0215, Bentonville, AR 72716-021. Alternatively, you
may transmit any response by facsimile to Mr. Edwards at (479) 277-5991.
Mary Pat Tifft
December 23, 2016
Page 3

If you have any questions with respect to the foregoing, please contact Mr. Edwards
at (479) 204-6483. For your reference, I enclose a copy of Rule 14a-8 and Staff Legal
Bulletin No. 14F.

Sincerely,

Elizabeth A. Ising

EAI/amw

cc: Geoffrey W. Edwards, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.

Enclosures

102231327.1
EXHIBIT B
Sustainability

Opportunity

Community

Our Stre n gths


Using
rs
To Help Othe
2016
GLOBAL
Y
RESPONSIBILIT
REPORT
About this report
This report covers the global responsibility activities of Walmart’s
operations and the Walmart Foundation for fiscal year 2016, which ran
from February 1, 2015, to January 31, 2016. For readers’ convenience, we
refer to this fiscal time period as “2015” throughout the report, unless
otherwise noted.

A message from our CEO 1


Performance highlights 2
A snapshot of Walmart 4
A message from our CSO 5
Using our strengths to help others 6

12 Creating economic opportunity


Enhancing economic mobility & inclusion 14
Spotlight: Women’s Economic Empowerment 38
Growing suppliers, local manufacturing & small business 40

54 Enhancing sustainability
Spotlight: The Sustainability Index 56
Reducing energy intensity & emissions 58
Moving to a zero waste future 70
Preserving natural capital 80
Spotlight: Sustainable food chain 88
Providing access to affordable, healthy food 90
Promoting product transparency & quality 102
Supporting worker safety & dignity 108

116 Strengthening community


Enhancing resiliency in the face of disasters 118
Spotlight: Global company, local action 124
Developing communities through engagement 126

134 Promoting good governance


Governance 134
Culture 136
Compliance 138
Political engagement 141
Public policy 142

143 GRI Index


Advocating
for the customer

Winning with customers means being actively on their side So what was once largely about our own operations has shifted
– making their daily lives better. As we share in our Annual Report, into helping rewire whole systems: Running on renewable energy
customers should be able to shop on their own terms – in a great has turned into joining the global effort to combat climate change;
store or club, with a quick pickup stop on the way home from reducing waste has evolved into seeking a circular economy in
work, or with items reliably arriving at the front door. And they which materials can be continually recycled; and selling sustainable
want to have some money left over to put toward their priorities: products has broadened into working with suppliers and others
an experience together as a family, a special gift every once in a throughout the supply chain to reduce impacts at every stage.
while, or savings for a rainy day. And beyond sustainability, we’ve undertaken journeys to enhance
economic opportunity inside Walmart and beyond and to
It’s no different with how we serve society. Our customers care strengthen the communities in which we operate and source.
about their neighbors, their communities and the planet. They
want to buy products that are good for the environment and the Today we view global responsibility in these three big areas –
people who made them. They want items that are safe and healthy Opportunity, Sustainability and Community. All three cut to the
for their families. And ultimately they want to use their dollars, heart of customer advocacy and leveraging our supply chain.
pounds or yen in a way that aligns with their values and has an
impact on the world. So we are not only advocating for customers We don’t pretend for a moment that we have this all figured out.
when we offer low prices and convenience, but also when we help The issues are complex, and the work is difficult. But our role
positively reshape the ways items are made, shipped and sold. is to get up every day, roll up our sleeves and lead. As we do,
we’re thankful to be joined by so many great suppliers, NGOs,
When we get it right, customers are able to shop at ease, knowing community groups and other stakeholders.
we did the work for them. They know that the products on our
shelves and website were produced at a low “true cost” for Ultimately, we believe that serving customers and society is the
all – not just in terms of being the best value, but in terms of same thing. You can’t have one without the other because, in
whether they enhance the environment and the lives of all the the long term, their interests converge. Putting the customer first
people who helped produce them. means delivering for them in ways that protect and preserve the
communities they live in and the world they’ll pass on to future
As you’ll see in these pages, we have made significant progress generations.
toward the three big goals we laid out in 2005: to create zero
waste, run on 100 percent renewable energy and sell products that When you put it all together, we’ll enable customers around the
sustain people and the environment. What’s even more exciting world to save money and time, so they can invest more of both in
is that we’ve also expanded their scope, as the supply chain is the things they love. And we’ll help make the world a better place
proving to be the biggest tool we have. It’s been said that “supply one community at a time.
chain is strategy,” and that’s true – it’s our opportunity to get things
to customers in a timely, cost-effective and sustainable way. The
individual choices we make along the supply chain greatly impact
the future for all of us. Doug McMillon

1
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Performance highlights:
Opportunity Sustainability
Invested $2.7 billion
over 2 years in 75%
wages, benefits of global waste
and training for diverted from
U.S. associates landfill*

Walmart and More than 1 million


the Walmart acres of wildlife
Foundation habitat protected –
committed an area comparable
$100 million to the Grand Canyon
over 5 years to National Park
increase economic
mobility among
U.S. retail and
Walmart and
the Walmart 35.6 U.S. fleet efficiency
doubled since 2005,
related-sector
workers
Foundation
committed
million saving nearly $1 billion
and eliminating nearly
650,000 metric tons
$20 million metric tons of of greenhouse gases
greenhouse in 2015
through 2019
1 Million + to support the gas emissions
Women farmers, factory reintegration of eliminated from Walmart
workers and others will U.S. veterans into our supply chain, doubled our
be trained by programs based on supplier
supported by Walmart civilian life sales of local
and the Walmart
reports produce in the
Foundation around U.S. between
the world 2009 and 2015

*Based on review of material handling and waste diversion processes in the U.S., U.K., Chile,
Central America, South Africa, Japan, Mexico, Canada, Brazil and Argentina, as reported by
waste vendors, food banks and stores. In cases where real numbers were not available due
to industry challenges, they have been estimated based on industry-acceptable standards.

2
Community
$25 million
(cash and in-kind) 1.25 $95 million +
Given through

Committed by million community,


state giving and
Walmart and associate volunteer volunteerism
the Walmart hours grants
Foundation over
5 years to improve
community
disaster response
800+ Global giving
Scholarships
awarded by
$1.42 $1.1+
billion in total billion in-kind giving
the Walmart
Foundation to
associates and

87 dependents for
higher education
Communities
helped after
disasters
$301+
Walmart and million in cash giving
the Walmart
Foundation
provided
$5.8 million
in response
contributions

3
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

A snapshot
of Walmart

We save people money


so they can live better.

28 11,530 $482 billion


countries stores worldwide total revenue

260 million 2.3 million


weekly customer visits associates
85 million
monthly Walmart.com visitors

4
A letter from
our Chief Sustainability Officer

Kathleen McLaughlin
Chief Sustainability Officer
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.

Last August, Walmart leaders joined the mayor of New Orleans For example, we have learned that lasting change requires
and many others to commemorate the tenth anniversary of collective action to reshape social and environmental systems, and
Hurricane Katrina – a devastating event that affected the entire that the most viable programs are those that create shared value
U.S. Gulf Coast, including hundreds of thousands of Walmart – value for business and society. We have been privileged to work
customers and associates. We remembered the heroes and the with dedicated stakeholders – including our customers, associates,
victims, sponsored a citywide day of service and led a disaster suppliers, community leaders, grantees and government leaders
resilience symposium with the United Nations RISE (Research – on ambitious efforts tackling issues ranging from economic
Initiative for Social Equity) initiative. mobility to climate change to disaster response.

We also acknowledged the impact of Katrina on the past 10 years Over the past 18 months, to sharpen our priorities, programs and
of Walmart’s engagement in addressing tough environmental and reporting, we heavily engaged stakeholders in discussions and
social issues. In the days after the hurricane struck, our associates surveys, including a 1,750-respondent survey led by Sustainalytics.
worked with others on the ground to deliver critical supplies and We are excited to share the resulting perspectives about societal
help people find first aid and shelter, and in doing so, we realized challenges relevant for retail and stakeholder views on where and
the difference we could make by using our strengths to help others how Walmart can help.
beyond our day-to-day business. Our CEO at the time, Lee Scott,
challenged us to “be that kind of company” every day. He and In this report, we’ll share our approach to whole-system change
other Walmart leaders of the day – including Doug McMillon, who in three priority arenas of Opportunity, Sustainability and
had become CEO of Sam’s Club a month prior to the tragedy – Community, informed by stakeholder perspectives; our key
set out broad aspirations for the company to do more by creating programs and indicators of progress, including the delivery of
economic opportunity through our jobs and purchase orders, several commitments that came due in 2015 (such as doubling
enhancing the sustainability of our operations and our products fleet efficiency and reducing supply chain emissions by 20 million
and strengthening our local communities. metric tons); some recent stories of impact; and also some of the
challenges we are encountering as we go about our work.
Over the past 10 years, our associates have worked hard toward
those aspirations. We have celebrated some important milestones Thank you to all who have been working with us and in
and accomplishments and have also struggled with obstacles and complementary efforts for the benefit of all. Working together, we
failures. We have learned a lot about what works and what doesn’t hope to accelerate progress in creating economic opportunity,
when it comes to achieving lasting change. enhancing sustainability and strengthening communities around
the world.

We have learned that lasting change requires collective action to reshape


social and environmental systems, and that the most viable programs are
those that create shared value – value for business and society.

5
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Using our strengths


to help others
Walmart provides food, apparel and household products to hundreds of millions of customers
in 28 countries around the world. We are committed to doing so in a way that creates economic
opportunity for associates, suppliers and others in retail supply chains; enhances the environmental
and social sustainability of supply chains; and strengthens the communities where we live and work.

For 10 years, we have been leading initiatives with our stakeholders in these arenas of opportunity,
sustainability and community. We aspire to use our strengths to help others while also strengthening
our business, and vice versa – reshaping the systems we all rely on to help improve social,
environmental and economic outcomes.

This introduction covers:

• Our approach to global responsibility: Shared value

• Stakeholder perspectives on societal issues, relevance for business,


and how Walmart can help

• Walmart’s social and environmental priorities and programs

• Performance highlights for the year

The rest of the report describes our priorities and programs in more detail, including aspirations for
system change and the impact we seek in business and society; indicators of progress; some recent
stories of impact; and also some of the challenges we face as we go about this work.

6
Our approach to global responsibility: Shared value
For Walmart, unlocking the full potential of our business means that we use our strengths to support and improve
the social and environmental systems upon which we all rely. We do this in six key ways:

Whole-system change. Working with Lead through the business. We work Use philanthropy to complement
others, we aspire to reshape whole to integrate our social and environmental business initiatives. We complement
systems to achieve significant and lasting priorities into our routine business activities and extend the impact of Walmart’s social
improvement in social, environmental (such as merchandising, sourcing, store and environmental initiatives through
and economic outcomes. For example, operations, logistics, human resources and philanthropic efforts. Through both in-kind
enhancing environmental sustainability technology), through leadership practices, and cash gifts, Walmart and the Walmart
in retail supply chains means addressing organizational roles, operational processes Foundation give over $1 billion annually to
their social and economic dimensions, and tools. projects that create opportunity, enhance
too. We have placed, and will continue sustainability and strengthen community.
to place, increasing emphasis on social Focus on actions that draw on Walmart’s
issues such as empowering women and particular strengths. We can make Collaborate with others. Since we believe
supporting worker safety and dignity. the most significant difference when that collective action is essential to the
we draw on our particular strengths as transformation of systems, we shape our
Create shared value for business and a retailer. These strengths include our programs in collaboration with other
society. We seek to create value for 2.3 million associates globally, supplier leaders and stakeholders. We are also
stakeholders across business and society, relationships, purchasing in categories investing in enhancing the effectiveness
because shared value enhances the quality like food and apparel, physical assets and ease of dialogue and action across
and viability of solutions. We believe that and capabilities in logistics, marketing, sectors through support for organizations
our social and environmental programs operations and merchandising. and tools, such as the Consumer Good
are of interest to long-term shareholders Forum and the Sustainability Index.
because they strengthen the systems
we rely on as a retailer.

7
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Stakeholder perspectives
At Walmart, we continually engage stakeholders to understand their perspectives,
improve the effectiveness and relevance of our initiatives, increase transparency and
trust and collaborate on addressing business and societal challenges.

Over the past year, to sharpen our social and environmental priorities, programs and reporting, we
heavily engaged our stakeholders – customers, associates, suppliers, advisory councils, community
leaders, grantees, other NGOs, government leaders and investors – in dialogues, working sessions
and surveys about their perspectives on Walmart’s role in society. These included interviews and a
1,750-respondent survey conducted by Sustainalytics. The Sustainable Development Goals recently
released by the United Nations also informed our discussions.

Although stakeholder perspectives varied in emphasis, there were consistent themes: While
people acknowledge we live in a time of unprecedented global prosperity (in part due to retail
and technological innovation, among many other factors), we also face unprecedented social and
environmental challenges in meeting the needs of a growing world population.

Stakeholders reinforced their expectation that Walmart – as a leading retailer – should use its
strengths in collaboration with others to help reshape social and environmental systems for the
benefit of society as well as business.

The accompanying exhibit summarizes stakeholder perspectives on societal challenges, the


relevance they see for businesses like Walmart and how they suggest Walmart can help.

“Walmart is expected to not only manage a significant number


of sustainability topics, but to also demonstrate transformative
leadership in many of them. Walmart is encouraged to invest in
those areas with the greatest sustainability impact and that are
most closely linked to driving business value.”
-Sustainalytics, commenting on stakeholder expectations

8
Summary of stakeholder perspectives

Societal changes Business relevance Perspective on how Walmart can help

Environmental

Climate Rising emissions Cost: energy, carbon Work to reduce energy intensity, adopt renewable energy,
and temperature and reduce emissions not only in own operations, but also in
Reputation
supply chains, including with customers

Natural resources Deforestation Supply security Collaborate with suppliers and others to create more
restorative supply chains in food and other commodities
Water quality, quantity Cost structure
with less environmental impact
Land use, soil health Growth
Fish stocks, biodiversity

Waste Landfill Cost Eliminate waste in own operations and help “close the loop”
on waste throughout production and consumption
Resource depletion Revenue streams
Pollution

Animal welfare Housing Customer trust Encourage suppliers to promote “5 freedoms” in


food production
Pain management Cost
Antibiotics

Social

Inclusive economic Cost of living Associate engagement Expand customer access to affordable food and other
mobility products through retail and e-commerce
Upward mobility/equality Productivity
Jobs, GDP, tax base Growth Continue to provide opportunity for associates, with the
Women, diversity Retention wages, upskilling and other practices that support mobility

Access to markets Reputation Support local manufacturing; help women-owned, diverse


suppliers grow; support smallholder access to markets

Worker dignity Workplace safety Customer trust Continue responsible sourcing practices and collaborate
in supply chains with others on initiatives that support healthier, safe work
Forced labor Supply security
conditions, free from forced labor
Reputation

Food security Affordability and access Waste Support continued development of safer, more affordable,
accessible, healthier and sustainable food system
Hunger Cost
Food/product safety Growth Help increase transparency into product ingredients and
Nutrition production methods, while advocating for better products

Community Belonging and inclusion Customer trust Support local community causes through volunteerism
resilience and giving
Natural disasters Associate engagement
Strength of community Reputation Help communities prepare for and respond to disasters
organizations
Cost

9
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Priorities, programs and initiatives

Opportunity Sustainability Community


Increase economic opportunity Enhance sustainability of Strengthen local communities
global supply chains

Priorities Priorities Priorities


• Enhance economic mobility • Reduce energy intensity and • Enhance disaster resilience
and inclusion of associates, emissions in our operations in communities
frontline retail workers and
workers in supply chains
and the supply chain
• Develop communities
• Move to a zero waste future through engagement of
• Promote growth of suppliers, across the supply chain associates, customers and the
local manufacturing and
small businesses – especially • Help preserve natural company
resources, especially forests,
women-owned, diverse water and land
• Help create a more affordable,
sustainable and healthy food
system
• Promote transparency and
quality in products we sell
• Support the safety
and dignity of workers
everywhere

Business impact Business impact Business impact


• Associate engagement • Cost of goods sold and • Sales, license to operate
• Productivity operating expenses
• Associate engagement
• Supply security
Societal impact Societal impact
• Frontline workforce mobility Societal impact
• Stronger communities
• Economic growth • GHG, natural capital
• Disaster mitigation
• Food security
• Worker safety, livelihoods
10
Opportunity Sustainability Community
Enhancing economic Enhancing sustainability of global supply chains Strengthening local
opportunity communities

As a large global retailer, Walmart collaborates with • Natural resources. We aim to We use our strengths to serve
Walmart is working with others suppliers, customers, nonprofit preserve natural resources local communities in ways
to use our strengths – our organizations and others to that are vulnerable to that go beyond our retail
jobs, our purchase orders, our enhance the environmental global consumption growth mission, in the face of disaster
company voice, the convening and social sustainability of through collective action in as well as day to day through
power of our brand and our global supply chains. We are Deforestation (focusing on the engagement of our 2.3
philanthropic investments – bringing our relevant strengths palm oil, soy, beef and paper), million associates in 10,000
to create a more inclusive to bear, including customer and Water and Land Conservation. communities worldwide.
economic system that supplier relationships, purchase Key programs include:
increases workforce mobility orders, philanthropy, our voice, • Sustainable food system. We
and economic growth in physical assets and capabilities aim to help the world feed
• Disaster response and
countries around the world. in sourcing, logistics, technology, a growing population by
preparedness. We aim to
We have two main programs: operations and marketing, to creating a more accessible,
enhance disaster resilience
name a few, to reshape systems affordable, sustainable and
through initiatives that
• Economic mobility. We aim to for the better. We have six main healthy food system. Key
enhance the speed and
enhance economic mobility programs: initiatives include Food Access,
focus of disaster response as
and inclusion of associates, Hunger Relief, Nutrition,
well as increase community
retail and adjacent sector Food Waste Reduction and
• Energy and emissions. We aim disaster preparedness.
workers beyond Walmart, Sustainable Food Production.
to reduce the energy intensity
and workers in supply
and emissions in our operations • Community development. We
chains. Key initiatives include • Transparency and quality. We
and work with others to reduce aim to enhance the quality of
Associate Opportunity, aim to promote transparency
emissions across supply chains. life in communities through
Retail Opportunity, Women’s and quality in products we sell,
Key initiatives include Walmart initiatives in Associate
Economic Empowerment through initiatives in Food/
Energy Efficiency/Renewables Engagement (in giving and
and U.S. Veterans. Product Safety, Sustainable
and Supply Chain Emissions volunteerism), Community
Chemistry and Animal Welfare.
Reduction. Investment and Associate
• Business development.
Support (through support for
We aim to promote • Worker dignity. We aim to
• Zero waste. We aim to scholarships and crisis funds).
inclusive development support the safety and dignity
eliminate waste in our own
of suppliers and other of workers in supply chains,
operations as well as support
businesses, through through Responsible Sourcing
waste reduction initiatives
initiatives such as Women’s and Compliance initiatives.
in the supply chain. Key
Economic Empowerment,
initiatives include Waste
Supplier Diversity, Local
Reduction (food and other
Manufacturing and
materials streams, in and
Small Business.
through Walmart operations),
Product Design/Packaging
and Recycling Education/
Infrastructure.

11
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Creating economic opportunity

Walmart began as a dream and with a simple investment – and small businesses spurs product innovation and sales growth.
while still wearing his Army uniform, Sam Walton stood in front In society, we hope our efforts will accelerate advancement and
of the store he bought with $5,000 of his savings and a loan from his improve the livelihoods of millions of people in retail and product
in-laws – and that first store has grown into the world’s largest retail supply chains, from entry-level to upper management positions,
company, creating economic opportunity for millions of people all while helping local economies grow.
around the world in retail and retail supply chains. Not only do We’re striving to make this vision a reality through a set of programs
we provide jobs and advancement opportunities for more than that fall within two main priorities:
2 million of our own associates, but also, we spend billions every
• Enhancing the economic mobility and inclusion of workers
year with our suppliers. They in turn provide jobs for millions around
in retail and its product supply chains, by
the world in farms, factories, distribution centers, construction sites
and corporate offices. • Providing ladders of opportunity for Walmart associates
• Promoting increased mobility in the retail sector
Since the late 1980s, globalization and technology have led to an beyond Walmart
unprecedented increase in global prosperity, with more people • Supporting integration of U.S. veterans into the
living longer and gaining greater access to necessities like clean civilian workforce
water and primary education. As a result, the world has witnessed • Empowering women in product supply chains
a decline in income disparity across countries. At the same • Promoting the growth of suppliers, local manufacturing
time, income inequality within countries – both in developed and small businesses, by
and developing nations – has increased, while overall global • Empowering women through sourcing from
economic growth has slowed.* women-owned businesses
As the world’s largest retailer, Walmart is working with others to • Fostering growth of diverse suppliers
• Promoting local manufacturing
use our strengths – our jobs, our purchase orders, our company
• Supporting small business growth
voice, the convening power of our brand and our philanthropic
investments – to create a more inclusive economic system that
increases mobility and growth in countries around the world.
Doing so benefits our business as well as society. By increasing
inclusion and accelerating upward job mobility, we aim to strengthen
the productivity and retention of our associates, improving customer
experience. Supporting a diverse, forward-looking group of suppliers

* ATKearney, When Rising Tides Only Lift Yachts: Addressing the Challenge of Inequality. January 2015. Accessed at: https://www.atkearney.com/gbpc/thought-leadership/
issue-deep-dives/detail/-/asset_publisher/qutCpQekuJU8/content/when-rising-tides-only-lift-yachts-addressing-the-challenge-of-inequality/10192.

12
13
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Enhancing the economic mobility and


inclusion of workers in retail and its
product supply chains
Even as global prosperity has increased in the past three decades, We see value in this approach for both society and our business.
many people feel the impact of increasing inequality closer to We hope to improve the economic inclusion and mobility of
home. They wonder about their ability to move up the economic millions of people. Investing in the inclusive development of
ladder. people will also strengthen the current and future talent pool in
As the largest retailer in the world, Walmart aims to use our retail and product supply chains. At Walmart, we see this as good
strengths to systematically accelerate the improvement of skills for our associates, our suppliers and our customers. We’re seeking
and the corresponding upward economic mobility of workers these outcomes through four key programs:
in retail and product supply chains. We place a special focus on • Providing ladders of opportunity for Walmart associates
the economic mobility of women, minorities and others who
may face particular barriers to advancement. To make the most • Promoting increased mobility in the retail sector beyond
impact, not only are we investing in our own workforce, but Walmart
also, we are also engaging with a broad base of stakeholders –
• Supporting reintegration of U.S. veterans into the civilian
workers, employers, educational experts, nonprofit organizations,
workforce
technology companies and governmental agencies – to find
innovative ways to improve hiring, training and advancement • Empowering women in product supply chains
beyond Walmart.

Associate Retail opportunity U.S. veterans Women’s economic


opportunity empowerment

14
Economic mobility and inclusion: Progress against commitments
As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

Invest in Walmart associate wages and upskilling. $2.7 billion invested in wages, benefits and training for
Associate opportunity Walmart associates in the U.S. over two years beginning
in 2015.

Commit $100 million from Walmart and the Over $39 million invested in the Retail Opportunity
Walmart Foundation over five years (beginning in Initiative; programs supported trained 3,014 people
2015) to increase the economic mobility of retail in retail or adjacent sectors; helped 275 advance
Retail opportunity
and adjacent sector workers, with goals of training their careers.
more than 50,000 people and helping 30,000
advance their career.
Commit $20 million from Walmart and the $14.5 million dollars invested, including support
Walmart Foundation over 5 years (beginning for launch of 3-year collective action pilot in
in 2014) to support U.S. veterans through job North Carolina.
training, education and innovative public-private
U.S. veterans reintegration community-based initiatives.
Offer a job at Walmart or Sam’s Club to any eligible More than 120,000 new veteran associates hired;
honorably discharged U.S. veteran who has been more than 13,000 promoted to roles with greater
discharged since Memorial Day 2013. responsibility.*

continued...

* Editor’s Note: These projections and reported hires/promotions include veterans hired under our original and expanded Commitment as well as other veterans hired by
Walmart in this time frame. While we think it is particularly important to support soldiers as they make the transition to civilian life, Walmart believes all veterans deserve
our respect and support, no matter when they left active duty.
15
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Commitments and progress and associates

Economic mobility and inclusion: Progress against commitments continued


As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

Use Walmart and Walmart Foundation resources Provided training and support to more than
to empower nearly 1 million women on farms, in 762,000 women.
factories, in retail and in workforce through training,
market access and career opportunities through • 420,452 women trained in agriculture.
2016, including providing funding to:
• Met goal; 103,000 women in factories received
• Train 500,000 women from emerging markets in training.
the agriculture value chain by the end of 2016.
• 26,000 women in emerging markets received training
for first retail job.
• Train 60,000 women working in factories in skills
they need to become more active decision-
Global Women’s Economic • Met goal; over 213,000 low-income women in U.S.
makers in their jobs and for their families.
Empowerment Initiative received training to gain skills.
• T rain 200,000 women for their first jobs in retail in
our emerging markets by the end of 2016.

• H
 elp 200,000 women in the U.S. from low-
income households gain the skills they need for
employment by the end of 2016.

Support Women’s Economic Empowerment Provided $122 million investments to date.


with $100 million in grants from Walmart and the
Walmart Foundation and donations from Walmart’s
business around the world.

16
Providing ladders of workers receive training in the • Raised the entry-level wage and hours worked, and hourly
skills that lead them to the next to $9 per hour for new hires, associates will be able to keep
opportunity for our level, household incomes can with an additional increase their unused time and carry
associates rise, overall economic stability to at least $10 per hour after it over to the next year – up
improves and the national successfully completing a to 80 hours for full-time and
Walmart provides employment workforce is strengthened. new, six-month Pathways 48 hours for part-time hourly
training program associates. Any hours beyond
opportunities to more than
2 million people around the In this section, we profile a those limits will be automatically
world, from product buyers major initiative launched this • Raised the wages of all compensated the following
to web designers and from past year in Walmart U.S. to associates hired before year through paycheck bonuses.
truck drivers to sales associates. accelerate the advancement Jan. 1, 2016, to $10 per hour In the event that an associate
We’ve long been a place where of our associates, and we leaves the company, any
anyone can start in an entry- highlight ways in which we • Issued annual pay increases accrued and unused PTO will
level position and build a are enhancing associate for associates already earning be issued in their final paycheck.
career – just ask the 75 percent opportunity in our other more than $10 per hour Associates will also get to
of our U.S. store management markets as well. The U.S. rather than waiting until their keep any sick or personal time
teams who began as hourly initiative includes four key anniversary date accrued under our previous
associates, or Doug McMillon, components: time-off plan.
• Boosted the starting rate of
our CEO, who started in a
Walmart warehouse. • Increasing wages and our non-entry-level hourly In addition to PTO, Walmart is
improving benefits pay bands, moving any providing a new, basic short-
We want to continue that associates falling below term disability plan at no
tradition of opportunity by • Upskilling through innovative the new minimum starting cost to full-time hourly U.S.
making it even easier and training and coaching points up to the new rate associates. It pays 50 percent of
faster for beginning Walmart immediately an associates average weekly
associates to improve their • Providing scheduling wage, up to $200, for up to
skills and advance to positions flexibility and predictability • Offered a lump sum payment 26 weeks. For those associates
of greater responsibility and equal to 2 percent of annual who desire, we are also offering
income within or beyond • Fostering diversity and pay to hourly associates at or an enhanced short-term
Walmart, and to do it in a inclusion above the maximum of their disability plan. This plan costs
way that fosters diversity and respective pay bands less than our previous voluntary
inclusion at all levels. Increasing wages and plan, and it provides up to
improving benefits for In March 2016, we implemented 60 percent of an associate’s
We believe these efforts to U.S. associates a new paid-time-off (PTO) average weekly wage with no
provide our associates with Walmart provides competitive program for hourly associates weekly maximum, for up to
wages and benefits to our in Walmart U.S. and Sam’s 26 weeks. Together, these
ladders of opportunity create
positive outcomes both for associates around the world. Club stores. It streamlines paid changes give associates more
our business and for society. This year we continued, for vacation, sick, personal and control over their time and
On the business side, a more our U.S. workforce, a major holiday time into one category more flexibility in the ways
engaged, productive and initiative to increase our wages, and eliminates a prior one- they choose to use it.
diverse workforce improves especially for entry-level day wait to use sick time. Both
our customers’ experience associates: full- and part-time associates
and grows sales. For society, as will earn PTO based on tenure

17
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Associates

“Upskilling” through practices and policies, followed process interactive and fun.
innovative training and immediately by customer- The supervisor’s role includes
coaching: spotlight on facing duties. According to leading associates through
Pathways, Lifelong Learning surveys, associates often felt lost hands-on applications of what
and Academies in the flood of information and they’ve learned, as well as
A job at Walmart is more than overwhelmed by the volume of regular, reflective check-ins as the
just a paycheck. It provides acronyms, terms and processes training progresses. By focusing
access to a ladder of opportunity, introduced. The feedback they on this kind of mentoring,
as a place where people can provided formed the basis of supervisors and associates have
earn while they learn on the job. the new program. more frequent opportunities
to discuss performance and
The Pathways training program Pathways seeks to better potential career opportunities
In addition to our wage integrate new hires into within the company.
increases for associates, in 2016, Walmart’s culture, reinforcing
all new Walmart entry-level our core values and focus on After successfully completing
U.S. associates – in all 4,500 serving the customer. It helps the program, associates receive
U.S. stores – will participate frontline associates understand an immediate pay increase
in our new training program, how key aspects of their jobs to $10 per hour. They are also
Pathways. As a key component are connected to other parts presented with information
“It is great to see a company like of our efforts to enhance of the business and how what about a range of career
Walmart leading the way on an economic opportunity for our they do makes a difference path options. As part of the
important initiative like upskilling associates, the program builds both for customers and the Pathways program, Walmart is
and pushing the envelope to on a successful pilot launched company. It also teaches valuable, monitoring 10 metrics to track
see how career pathways can be in 2015 and provides training transferable skills – including outcomes such as reduced
developed in retail, what it can over at least the first six months customer service, merchandising, turnover, improved productivity
mean to the employees, and how of employment. Pathways teamwork and communication and increased associate
it can benefit the company.” focuses on “upskilling” – the – valuable skills both within and engagement.
acquisition and improvement beyond Walmart.
– Jaime Fall, director of
of skills, and the gaining of
UpSkillAmerica at the
Aspen Institute knowledge that facilitates The Pathways program consists
faster progression in a career of two modules that mix
in retail. By comparison, our computer-based learning with
previous associate onboarding mentoring from a supervisor.
process had been short and The computer-based materials
intense for new associates: a are self-paced and feature
day-and-a-half of computer- short videos and games
based learning on internal designed to make the learning

18
Providing scheduling
flexibility and predictability
When it comes to scheduling,
our associates around the
world reflect a diverse set of
needs and preferences. Some
people prefer fixed schedules,
while others prefer flexibility
from week to week. As part of
our U.S. associate opportunity
initiative, we have been testing
and implementing new
approaches to scheduling
that we hope will provide our
associates with the flexibility
and control they need.
Following a successful pilot
Lifelong Learning: Creating • More than 60,000 associates program, we’re in the process
opportunity through education who have received no-cost of making a new flexible
Since 2010, Walmart has been language learning in English scheduling program available
helping associates succeed and 29 other languages to Walmart U.S. associates. The “Pathways gets you up-to-speed
in retail careers through an new program allows associates faster. After two to three weeks,
education initiative called • More than 2.5 million hours of to confirm their schedules two you have an understanding of
Lifelong Learning. The program college classroom time saved weeks in advance. This provides in-store practices and the larger
focuses on building skills them with more flexibility and mission. It would take associates
and credentials beyond their control over their schedules, up to a year to piece it together
• More than 8,000 associates
including the option for some on their own.”
immediate job at Walmart. The who have started college
learning opportunities range and taken more than 65,000 to have fixed schedules week
– Associate Jarod Newman,
from foreign language courses college courses available at after week, while others have Store 79, upon completing
to classes for completing a reduced or no cost the option to build their the Pathways program
high school diploma, as well as schedule each week based
earning no-cost college credit • More than 1,000 associates on their needs. Whether it’s a
through on-the-job skills. Since who have graduated working mother who needs
the program began, it included from college after taking predictability to plan her
these highlights: advantage of courses and childcare, or a full-time student
tuition discounts with a changing class schedule,
• More than 7,000 associates our program is designed to
accepted into our no-cost • More than $48 million in help all our associates find the
high school and GED programs tuition and program fees schedule that works for them.
saved for associates, as they
build their way toward a
brighter career

19
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Diversity and inclusion

Fostering diversity mirror the perspectives and ways to serve our customers.
and inclusion interests of our global customer In 2015, we undertook
The associates who work for us base. As competition within several initiatives to reinforce
come from a variety of races the retail sector continues inclusion in our culture,
and ethnicities, orientations and to increase, we are focusing such as launching multiple

200,000 backgrounds, and they reflect a


range of life experiences. Some
are with us to build a career;
on our culture, diversity and
inclusion strategy to recruit and
retain the best people we can,
forums to engage Walmart
associates in dialogue and
development. These included
associates others need part-time, flexible
work while they pursue an
especially among women and
people of color. With the right
forums on the inclusion of
women (as part of our Global
education. We value the talents training and development and Women’s Development
and differences our associates an inclusive environment, we Series), African-Americans and
bring to our company, as they believe we can build a diverse Hispanics (see sidebar). A new
enrich the Walmart culture, lead pipeline of talent that commits forum is planned for Asian-
to innovative solutions for our to helping our customers live a American Pacific Islander and
business, enable us to better better life around the world. other associates in 2016. We
We promoted more than meet the needs of a diverse also provided training on
200,000 associates to jobs customer base and strengthen Reinforcing inclusion unconscious bias for nearly
with more responsibility our business. We will continue in our culture 5,000 logistics managers.
and higher pay to build a diverse talent Respect for the individual, and Looking ahead in 2016, we plan
pipeline, meet the evolving for individual differences, is to train our supervisors on how
career needs of our associates one of our key values. When to better lead diverse teams
and work to strengthen our our associates come to and build an inclusive working
culture of inclusion. work each day, we want to environment.
encourage them to bring
Building a diverse their true, authentic selves
talent pipeline and be prepared to share their
Walmart seeks to hire and knowledge with their peers
develop talented people who and to find new and better

Women representation People of color representation Hourly promotions

Women
Total U.S. workforce Total U.S. workforce 56%
56% 42%
Management Management
43% 31%
U.S. corporate officers U.S. corporate officers People of color
31 % 22% 43%

20
Associate profile: Carlos Carmona, Pharmacy Manager,
Store 212 - Norman, Okla.
Carlos recalls. Today, he not only The conference ended on a
finds his job rewarding, he intends Thursday afternoon. The next day,
to continue building the career he Carlos received a phone call about
started as an intern. a vacancy for a Market Health &
Wellness Director. “I didn’t need
At a recent Walmart Hispanic to think this time – I just did
“I thought it was a tremendous
Forum in Bentonville, Arkansas, it,” Carlos said. He applied, was
effort to bring our inaugural
Carlos realized Walmart had big selected and started his new
Hispanic Forum to reality. It was a
plans for him, and he knew he was job as Market Health & Wellness
very well-planned and executed
ready to fully embrace them. “I Director in southern Oklahoma in
event, and the team was willing
believe that the Hispanic Forum August 2015. “My market director
to make on-the-go adjustments
was an amazing and eye-opening helped find other places for me
to make it more beneficial to
experience. It gave me the ability to go to learn – to help prepare
the attendees. I have been with
to be confident about reaching for me for bigger responsibility,”
the company for over five years,
Carlos Carmona started his higher goals. Being a part of the Carlos said. “When I first became
and this was the most insightful
Walmart career during college, as a Hispanic Forum made me realize a pharmacy manager, to be able
two-day conference I have
pharmacy intern in Norman, Okla. that opportunities within Walmart to say this was my store was a very
attended while at Walmart. The
When a visiting market manager are out there; it’s just a matter of proud and memorable moment.”
Hispanic Forum was full of rich
showed him what the possibilities looking for them and then tackling
discussion, emotional reflection
open to him are by staying with them head on. I also realized that Carlos says every day is his best
and heritage pride. I left the
Walmart, Carlos found himself fear played a huge role in my not day at Walmart, especially when he
conference feeling inspired
inspired. “She walked in and seeking other opportunities that can help a customer. “My patients
and committed to lead to leave
greeted everyone. After looking I felt that I could do, but was afraid are so thankful for what we do for
a legacy, proudly sharing my
around for a few minutes, she to take on. I decided at the end of them. We work with their doctors.
Hispanic identity. The ball is in
noticed a line growing at the pick- the Hispanic Forum that I would We help with their medication. We
our court now, and I pledge to
up window and she walked over no longer let fear be a hindrance make their lives better,” he said.
own my own development and
and began helping our patients. to my success in life. I was meant
bring others along.”
That spoke volumes to me about to live and strive for so much more
the kind of people Walmart than I ever gave myself credit for.”
- Manny Orejuela, Director, Local
wanted to run their company,”
Marketing & Member Acquisition,
Sam’s Club Marketing

U.S. new hires for the past three years

50% 51% 53% 45% 49% 51%


Women 2012 2013 2014 People 2012 2013 2014
of color

21
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Diversity and inclusion

Promoting inclusion around the world

Canada Central America South Africa

For the past five years, Walmart In 2015, Walmart Central America Massmart in South Africa
Canada has prioritized launched the first generation supports a range of internships
gender diversity, increasing of its Women in Retail program and apprenticeships for both
the number of female store with 131 store leaders. To its full-time and contract
managers through its Women continually improve training and employees, which serve to
in Retail program. Starting development in our business, empower our associates and
in 2009, the Women in Retail we also launched our local drive growth and sustainability
program has been developing, Learning Centers, where new in our business. In 2015,
retaining and advancing store leaders and administrators more than 850 full-time and
women in leadership. Since learn how to operate efficiently 300 contract employees
its inception, Walmart Canada in the workplace. were enrolled in accredited
has seen a positive increase Massmart-funded training
of 58 percent in the number programs. These programs
of women store managers – cover a variety of learning
from 15.5 percent at the end areas, from basic retail skills to
of 2009, to 24.5 percent by the advanced graduate and senior
end of 2015. The success of the management development.
program in Canada has led
to its rollout to other Walmart
international markets.

22
China Japan

Walmart China has focused on Empowering women is a


local talent development and nationwide effort in Japan,
encouraging talent diversity. and Walmart is doing its part
Today, more than 99.9 percent by facilitating learning ses-
of Walmart China associates sions for female leaders and
are Chinese nationals, and promoting open discussion
90 percent of store managers regarding diversity and inclusion.
have been promoted from Approximately 65 percent of
entry-level positions. Walmart Walmart Japan associates are
China also established female, and 13.4 percent of
the Women in Leadership total management positions
Committee and the Women are held by women.
in Leadership Institute, both
of which further help promote
the growth and development
of women throughout the
business.

23
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Retail workers & suppliers

Promoting increased people advance more quickly.


Our strategies for accelerating
mobility in the retail mobility are outlined in the
and adjacent sectors table on the right.

Through the end of January


Walmart seeks not only to
2016, we have made grants
improve the economic mobility
totaling more than $39 million
of our own associates, but also
in support of this commitment.
to increase mobility in retail and
adjacent sectors at large.
With these efforts, we hope
to enhance the quality of the
In 2015, as a complement to our
retail workforce. We’re also
own investments in wages and
striving to transform retail into
training, Walmart and the
an early workforce incubator
Walmart Foundation launched
for the economy – a place
a five-year, $100 million
where anyone can get a job
initiative to increase upward
and quickly develop the skills
mobility of frontline retail and
to advance their careers in
adjacent sector workers in the
retail or beyond.
U.S. Through collaboration
with other retailers,
educational institutions,
technology companies,
nonprofit organizations,
government agencies and
thought leaders, Walmart
and the Walmart Foundation
are aspiring to shift the
employment practices of the
whole retail sector to help

24
Work streams for retail sector opportunity initiative
What we do Approach Why we do it

Work with hiring managers and incumbent retail Current perception that frontline retail jobs require no skill or
Perception of retail workers to enhance awareness that frontline retail jobs that one can maintain a retail job without acquiring any skills
lead to workforce skill development. is a barrier to building advancement programs.

Invest in improving the effectiveness of training Pre-employment programs are often expensive, limited
programs that prepare prospective retail workers for in scale and rarely meet the needs of employers. Desire
Pre-employment training
employment. Lower barriers to entry for qualified to show pre-employment programs produce stronger
workers. candidates than untrained applicants.

Invest in NGO interventions related to upskilling Retail advancement is often employer-specific and lacks
incumbent workers, including potential development a clear definition of skills for advancement. With a more
Career advancement
of credentials to certify skills have been attained. transparent, competency-based system, transferability across
the sector and into adjacent sectors will be more feasible.

Invest in and pilot models employers can implement Ultimately, employer practices will have the greatest impact
that improve stability and upskilling, while of shifting the quality of opportunity available to workers.
Employer practices strengthening businesses. Recognizing industry credentials, providing high-quality
on-the-job training and defining clear career paths unlock
advancement.

Create tools (such as curricula, digital career pathways, A set of common tools used across the industry will unlock
technology training tools, certifications) to provide efficiency, allow us to leverage technology and create a
Tools and technology
quality content for training organizations and greater opportunity across the sector and into adjacent
employers. sectors.

Select 4 to 6 communities in the U.S. to work with a Impact is maximized not in single interventions, but in the
network of organizations (i.e., NGOs, local government combination. A local pilot allows us to test this theory and
Pilot and other employers) to test collective approach to reshape the ecosystem.
building greater career pathways and mobility in local
retail sector.

25
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Retail workers & suppliers

Creating a U.S. community of practice


Since 2003, the Hope Street Group Retail Community of Practice. “The path for today’s job seekers
(HSG) has pursued market-driven The Community brings together has transformed and will continue
solutions to complex, social all the grantees in retail and to evolve. The old systems and
problems. HSG brings together adjacent sectors funded by tools underpinning the U.S.
young entrepreneurs, business the $100 million Opportunity jobs marketplace are failing us,
executives and technology Initiative. HSG facilitates the both reducing productivity and
professionals concerned with sharing of key learnings between undermining national talent
individual and national economic the organizations, with the aim potential,” said Martin Scaglione,
opportunity. They create and of maximizing opportunities for CEO of Hope Street Group. “The
manage blueprints for social enhanced impact across the whole Retail Community of Practice is an
change by infusing the top drivers retail sector. The Community important step toward bringing
of economic opportunity – the seeks to create a trusted network all stakeholders together to work
education, health and jobs of relationships where workforce around a shared vision and blueprint
sectors – with the tools and practitioners, service providers to create a new system that can
resources to improve people’s and subject matter experts can respond to our changing world.”
ability to succeed. connect to strengthen their
knowledge, share challenges and
With a grant of more than improve problem-solving related
$600,000 from the Walmart to preparing retail workers for
Foundation, HSG leads a new career advancement.
collaborative effort forming a

Building a career in retail


need it. With a $3 million experienced workers from other communication, decision-making
investment from the Walmart industries, into middle skills or and customer service.
Foundation, Goodwill has supervisory and management
launched the Careers in Retail positions in either retail or into Upon completing the program,
Initiative (CiR), which aims to reach similar sectors, such as the food participants are ready to take on
more than 1,500 individuals in and beverage, hospitality and supervisory and managerial roles
eight locations over the 24-month tourism industries. Through the in retail and affiliated industries. CiR
duration of the grant. implementation of individual continues to support participants
career plans, the program for six months to ensure stability
CiR offers a free training and builds the skills necessary and success in their new positions
Goodwill® has long been known support program designed to for advancement and trains and to enable preparations for the
for its commitment to generating move experienced, entry-level participants in crucial content next steps on career pathways.
opportunity for those who most retail employees, as well as ranging across leadership,

26
Reshaping federal training: The Chicago
Cook Workforce Partnership
In the U.S., most federal funds for in the Chicagoland region and is
workforce training are distributed recognized as a national leader
through a network of 600 region- on workforce reform.
al workforce investment boards
(WIBs). But these funds are rarely The grant will support the ex-
invested in training or upskilling pansion of the Partnership’s retail
for the retail sector. In fact, usually sector hospitality center so that
WIBs’ only interaction with retail it can provide employers, current
comes through training workers workers and job seekers with skills
to leave the sector. training in sales, customer service,
logistics, merchandising and
With a 2015 grant of nearly management. It will also focus
$11 million issued over 27 months, on the work of WIBs through-
the Walmart Foundation has en- out the country by initiating a
gaged the Chicago Cook Workforce capacity-building pilot with 10
Partnership (the Partnership) to cre- other WIBs and by engaging in
ate a WIB-based upskilling program a nationwide effort to improve
that can serve as a national model the perception of retail career
for retail advancement. Chicago possibilities. The Partnership will
was a pioneer in sector-based join the Walmart Community of
training, specifically in retail, more Practice, where those working
than 10 years ago. As the second to build a stronger ecosystem in
largest WIB in the country, the retail training and advancement
Partnership administers more than are collaborating to learn and
$60 million in federal and private advance the field more quickly.
aid to a network of 49 agencies

27
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Retail workers & suppliers

Mobility around the world

Brazil

In 2015, Brazil’s Walmart


Institute celebrated its 10th
anniversary by renewing
its commitment to creating
opportunities for young people
to get a start in the labor
market. Since 2010, the Institute
has conducted the Social
School of Retail (SSR), which
offers professional training in
retail leadership and public
policy to young people ages
16 to 29. The SSR is a 300-hour
program that has trained nearly
7,000 people, and which also
helps the Institute contribute
to the improvement of public
policies that create stronger
connections between the
education system in Brazil and
potential employers.

28
China Japan India

In 2014, Walmart China With rising numbers of young Anees Khan had been one of Parasia’s well-known
launched a three-year people across Japan not successfully running a kirana – a retail stores. Reflecting on
collaboration with the China actively pursuing education, small mom-and-pop store – in his participating and growth,
Chain Store and Franchise training and employment the small town of Parasia in Anees said, “Best Price is a one-
Association (CCFA) to support opportunities, Walmart Japan the state of Madhya Pradesh. stop shop for me. I get the best
the Future Retail Star Training is undertaking an effort to Anees wanted to expand his quality products. I am happy
program. The program promote their social inclusion store into a modern retail store, that I am now able to provide
hopes to train 200 in-service and economic empowerment. but realized he needed help the same to my customers.
teachers and 20,000 secondary Together with Sodateage with skills and retail knowledge. My business is growing
vocational school students for Net, a nonprofit organization As a member of Best Price steadily as my customers are
future positions in retail, which focused on young people Modern Wholesale member – very pleased with our service,
will help address the growing and their entrance into the Walmart’s business-to-business quality products, assortment
demand for entry-level retail workforce, in 2013 Walmart operation in India – he was and transparent pricing. The
professional staff. Walmart Japan began to provide familiar with the store and support extended by Best Price
China has pledged nearly grants for youth from low- the team. Associates from the staff has helped me in taking
$780,000 over the duration of income households to take store brought Anees into a this venture forward.”
the program, with 168 teachers job-training programs and community upskilling initiative
and 4,570 students – the get short-term, job-related where they trained him in store
majority of whom are female – experience at our Seiyu stores. layout, product assortment,
having been already trained. Through 2015, 28 youths order planning, furniture layout,
participated in the program, display and merchandising.
and 20 of them found jobs The team also helped him in
following their training, setting up billing software
including four who continued and staff training. With
at Seiyu. In 2016, the program this assistance from the Best
will support an additional Price team, Anees launched
15 youths. Super Shopping Mall, today

29
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Veterans

Supporting This work will focus in states promoted to jobs with higher
with a strong military presence, pay and greater responsibility.*
reintegration of U.S. such as North Carolina, Texas Given this positive outcome,
veterans into the and California, and will offer in May of 2015, we announced
civilian workforce veterans a coordinated way to the expansion of our original
access a suite of reliable local projection, with the goal of
services for job placement, hiring 250,000 veterans by
Sam Walton, founder of housing, health care and other the end of 2020. We have also
Walmart, served as an Army services they may need. changed the eligibility from
captain during World War II, and within 12 months of active duty,
he used his Army savings as the As veterans reintegrate into to any veteran who has been
initial capital to open his first society, everyone benefits. honorably discharged since we
store. Like Mr. Walton, veterans Veterans provide businesses with announced the commitment in
offer important strengths to our extraordinary assets and talent May 2013.
communities, such as a strong as hard-working, high-skilled
work ethic, technical skills and people with strong leadership As another way to support
leadership capabilities, to name potential. Swift reintegration our veterans and their families,
a few. But transitioning from also enhances the stability of Walmart’s Military Family
the military to civilian life can veterans’ families and commu- Promise guarantees a job at
be difficult. Despite the wealth nities, while also building local a nearby store or club for all
of resources and opportunities economies, strengthening the military personnel, and military
available to veterans, some U.S. workforce, and preserving spouses, employed at Walmart
remain vulnerable to financial, the volunteer military in the U.S. and Sam’s Club, who move to
employment, relationship and a different part of the country
legal challenges as they return Welcoming veterans home due to a transfer by the United
home from service. On Memorial Day 2013, Walmart States military. The promise also
introduced our Veterans specifies that associates called
Walmart aims to make it Welcome Home Commitment, away to active military duty will
easier for U.S. veterans and which guaranteed a job offer be paid any difference in their
their families to reintegrate to any eligible, honorably salary if the associate is earning
into civilian life through our discharged U.S. veteran who was less money during their military
“Veterans Welcome Home within 12 months of active duty. assignment.
Commitment,” which offers Our goal was to hire 100,000
Walmart jobs to returning veterans by the end of 2018. Working collaboratively to
veterans. Additionally, Walmart meet the needs of veterans
and the Walmart Foundation The initiative has been success- Upon returning home, veterans
have committed $20 million ful beyond our expectations. often find it challenging to
over five years to work on Since our initial announce- navigate the multiple agencies
collective impact initiatives ment, we have hired more offering job placement, medical
to help support and integrate than 120,000 veterans, with care and other social assistance.
returning service members. almost 13,000 having been This can result in inconsistent

* Editor’s Note: These projections and reported hires/promotions include veterans hired under our original and expanded
Commitment as well as other veterans hired by Walmart in this time frame. While we think it is particularly important to
support soldiers as they make the transition to civilian life, Walmart believes all veterans deserve our respect and support,
30 no matter when they left active duty.
use and quality of services. To • Expanding high-quality job In 2015, the Walmart Foundation Walmart Foundation is focusing
address this problem, Walmart training opportunities for announced our support for on strengthening the regional
and the Walmart Foundation U.S. veterans transitioning to the Philanthropy-Joining and state ecosystems that serve
have pledged $20 million civilian life Forces Impact Pledge initiative. veterans and military families.
through 2019 to support the Through this, the Walmart
needs of returning veterans • Building innovative public- Foundation joins approximate-
by promoting a coordinated private partnerships that ly 30 funders finding ways to
approach to veterans’ needs. coordinate veteran service strengthen services and support
That’s why we are pursuing across organizations to for millions of veterans and
two strategies: create a coherent and military families. The Pledge
interconnected service has secured more than $275
directory million for these efforts, and the

NC4VETS: A public-private partnership supporting reintegration


In February 2015, the Walmart community-based network of one coherent and interconnected ‘home’ for its veterans and their
Foundation announced a $1 million service providers for veterans and service delivery network, the families by easing and streamlining
grant to the Institute for Veterans their families. program has responded to more access to comprehensive,
and Military Families (IVMF). The than 900 service requests. It community-based services that
grant helped start the Welcome “NC4VETS has tremendous reach, creates a single point of entry into best address their actual needs.
Home North Carolina (WHNC) and by partnering regionally with a more navigable ecosystem of
initiative, a three-year pilot to NCServes’ community-based services for veterans, where ‘guides’ “By building upon its existing
identify new ways in which the networks, we have a winning make the connection between strength in the public, private and
nonprofit, public and private formula to attract veterans and an individual’s needs and the nonprofit sectors, North Carolina
sectors can better work together help them make North Carolina community’s resources. is clearly demonstrating to the
to serve veterans. The pilot will be their new home,” said Ilario nation the successful creation of
administered through NCServes, a Pantano, director at North Carolina Through collective support and a statewide coordinated veteran
Department of Military and leadership from Governor Pat supportive services network
Veterans Affairs. McCrory and his team from the that is measurably improving
North Carolina Department of the lives of our nation’s veterans
Since launch, NCServes has Military and Veterans Affairs, and their families,” said Colonel
served more than 450 individual the Walmart Foundation, key Jim McDonough, Jr., USA (RET.),
service members, veterans and/ stakeholders from across the state managing director, Institute for
or family members. With more and the IVMF, North Carolina’s Veterans and Military Families
than 40 providers operating as goal was simple: to make the state (IVMF).

31
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Veterans and women

Sparking a movement then posting the video on


Walmart has undertaken social media channels to show
campaigns designed to raise support for members of the
public awareness of the military and their families. The
needs of veterans and the robust public response allowed
valuable role they play in our Walmart to donate $1 million
communities. Here we highlight to Fisher House Foundation,
two campaigns from the 2015 an organization that provides
holiday season. a home-away-from-home for
military and veterans’ families
The Greenlight a Vet campaign whose loved ones are in a
In advance of Veterans Day, nearby military or veterans
Walmart helped launch a hospital. The donation helped
campaign to raise national support more than 60 U.S.-
awareness of the importance of based Fisher Houses and will
“greenlighting” veterans back be used to fund a full year of
to civilian life by promoting a lodging for military families
show of visible public support staying at Fisher Houses on
for these valuable community U.S. military bases in 2016.
members. Encouraging the
public to change one light to Walmart also helped Operation
green, the campaign created Homefront, a nonprofit that
visible and actionable national works to build strong military
support for America’s veterans families, put a holiday meal
and their families, resulting in on the table of 8,500 military
over 3.4 million online acts of families in 26 locations
support and widespread media nationwide. We also helped
coverage of this important topic. provide tractor trailers, private
fleet drivers and a donation
Saluting our military families of $150,000 to Wreaths Across
and veterans at the holidays America to help honor U.S.
At the beginning of December veterans by laying wreaths
2015, Walmart called on the on National Wreaths Across
general public to “Sing to Salute America Day.
Military Families” – a nationwide
campaign that encouraged
the public to sing a portion of
a classic holiday song while
capturing it on video, and

32
and life skills. Such training
enhances their incomes and
builds their confidence as lead-
ers in their workplaces, families
and communities. The program
focuses on four major strategies:

• Train 500,000 women in


agriculture

• Assist 60,000 women in


factories in becoming more
active decision-makers in their
jobs and families

• Prepare 200,000 women in


Empowering women workforce. Studies further emerging markets for their
show that women in emerging first jobs in retail
in retail supply chains markets invest 90 percent of
their income back into families • Help 200,000 low-income U.S.
Women play a crucial role in and communities, breaking the women gain skills for better
retail supply chains around cycle of poverty. Yet around employment
the world, as well as in the the world women earn 10 to 30
economic well-being of percent less than men do. From a business point of view,
families and communities. In this initiative aims to increase
agriculture alone, women are To help address these issues, in factory and agricultural
responsible for 43 percent of 2011 Walmart and the Walmart productivity, while also
farm production in low- and Foundation launched The providing a stronger female
middle-income countries. In Global Women’s Economic talent pool, particularly in
China, according to Business Empowerment initiative to emerging markets. From the
for Social Responsibility, while train close to 1 million women perspective of society, we
women make up 44 percent around the world on farms, in believe that empowering
of the total workforce, they factories and in retail, partic- women economically not only
represent approximately 60 ularly in emerging markets. improves their livelihoods, but
percent of the workers who The program combines $100 also strengthens the stability
migrate from rural areas to cities million in philanthropic fund- of families, workplaces and
for work in factories. Walmart’s ing, Walmart’s global sourcing communities.
own internal statistics show reach and the expertise of non-
that women play a vital role in profit organizations, companies
the retail industry, making up and government agencies to
57 percent of our own global equip women with technical

33
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Women

Women in agriculture Walmart Foundation launched sensitivity. Up to 8,000 women


In the agriculture value chain, the Women in Factories will also receive leadership train-
Walmart and the Walmart Training Program, a five-year ing to develop the work and life
Foundation have now funded initiative that will train 60,000 skills necessary for personal and
training projects for 502,000 women in 150 factories and career development.
women. For example, in 2015, processing facilities produc-
through our cooperation with ing for top retail suppliers in The open-source Women in
the German Development industries with high percent- Factories Training Program
Improving opportunity Corporation, the Walmart ages of women. The program, curriculum, developed by
one acre at a time Foundation supported a new which was implemented in CARE and funded by the
rice initiative in Nigeria and collaboration with local NGOs, Walmart Foundation, can be
Ghana. This project will train will teach critical life skills related shared and adapted by other
One Acre Fund works with
smallholder farmers primarily approximately 22,500 women. to communication, hygiene, re- brands, organizations, factories
in East Africa to offer a productive health, occupational and other stakeholders who
market-based set of services Women in factories health and safety, identifying are interested in workforce
to increase their productivity In 2011, Walmart and the personal strengths and gender development in the factory
and economic opportunity.
The nonprofit focuses on rural
farmers who often need support
across a spectrum of issues,
including financing, seed and
fertilizer distribution, training
Asia Khatun, a garment worker in Bangladesh
in agricultural techniques and
market strategies. With support performance even long after her developing a household budget.
from the Walmart Foundation, husband had left. Her work supervisor has witnessed
One Acre Fund expanded its improvements in her performance,
Kenya program to more than In August 2014, Asia received the so much so that her responsibilities
56,000 new farmers in 2015, 64 opportunity from the factory have been increased. As a result of
percent of whom are female. This where she worked to take part in sanitary and hygiene training, she
brings the total number of people the Women in Factories Initiative’s has become more aware of easy,
reached to more than 136,000. foundational training. While initially common-sense practices that will
skeptical of the benefits of the help prevent disease.
training, she nevertheless attended
all the sessions and was surprised Most of all, her family members
by what she learned. have noticed that she feels happier
and more in control of her life. Asia
Asia Khatun first started working at The benefits of the training have has recently taken to sharing the
the age of 20 to help supplement had a remarkable impact on lessons from the training with her
her father’s low income. Like Asia’s well-being. She has been sister and other family members,
many women around the world, empowered to take charge of passing on the benefits she has
she suffered physical and mental her financial affairs – opening her experienced to others.
abuse from a spouse, which own bank account, saving part of
affected her overall health and job her paycheck every month and

34
sector. Because the program evaluated and monitored by Training women for retail online training for marginalized
focuses on job readiness, experts from Tufts University. in emerging markets women in poor communities
leadership and management, it Preliminary evidence indicates Outside the U.S., we are striving looking to enter e-commerce,
can be adapted across sectors. strong impact on certain to support training for 200,000 also with a goal of reaching
We are pleased to make the metrics, including the reduced from emerging markets for 8,000 women. In 2016, we plan
curriculum publicly available objectification of women, their first jobs in retail. By the to focus on developing new
for download. increased female promotion end of 2015, Walmart and the projects elsewhere in China, as
and increased factory pro- Walmart Foundation have well as in Mexico and Brazil.
Through the Women in Factories ductivity. Other anticipated funded training for 92,000
program, as of December benefits of training for women, women. This past year the
2015, 103,000 women have such as increased confidence Walmart Foundation launched
received foundational training and improved communica- two new training initiatives in
in life and work skills. Of those tion, have not been reported China. We are collaborating
women, 4,978 have completed to be as strong as expected with the China Chain Store &
advanced training, a more com- in the preliminary results. As Franchise Association (CCFA) to
prehensive 100-hour curriculum the study continues and more develop a training curriculum
that goes into more depth on precise data emerges, we will for women seeking retail
key components. The program seek to understand the results employment. The initiative aims
has been implemented in 127 and the factors driving impact to train 8,000 women and also
factories in Bangladesh, China, and will focus on identifying includes a special focus on food
El Salvador, Honduras and India, ways to sustain and scale the safety. The second initiative,
and these efforts are being initiative. led by Youcheng, will deliver

 The Social Retail School: Serving women in Chile


In Chile, the Walmart Foundation The program educated students “I came to the course because
has funded the International Youth in effective communication, time I wanted to learn and get ahead,”
Foundation to work with Acento management, goal-setting and said Romy Cortes, a young mother.
Consultores and the National responsibility, and it also provides “Now, my personal growth is on
Training and Employment Service targeted training in informa- the rise. I no longer get nervous
(SENCE) to offer the Social School tion technology systems and in in making presentations. I’m more
of Retail (SSR) to 5,000 vulnerable retail-specific skills like merchan- confident in myself.”
women and youth. SSR equips dising. Once training is complete,
participants with valuable skills participants receive assistance with
needed to secure a first job in retail. internship and job placement.

35
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic mobility – Women

work to enhance economic


mobility in retail is particularly
important to women, since
over 50 percent of retail workers
in the U.S. are women.

Promoting women in film:


The Bentonville Film Festival Reaching more than

762,000
Film shapes our culture in
powerful, important ways. As

women
actress Geena Davis says, “If
you see it, you can be it.” In
2015, Walmart helped inspire
and support the inaugural
Bentonville Film Festival,
promoted by the Geena Davis
Helping women in the U.S. Institute, to bring attention to By the end of FY16, the Walmart
We have also been working to the role of women and other Foundation and Walmart’s
help U.S. women from low- diverse voices in film. The global business invested in
income households improve festival screened 60 films made programs that provided support
their employment skills. The largely by women and other and training for more than
Walmart Foundation provided diverse populations. Judges 762,000 women around the
support and training for chose six of them to receive world.
more than 200,000 since the commercial support in the form
launch of our Global Women’s of a distribution agreement to
Economic Empowerment include a 25-screen releases
Initiative. Some of this work has sponsored by AMC Theaters;
been accomplished through marketing commitments; and
programs aimed at the retail shelf and premium placement
sector, such as our funding commitment from Walmart
of the Chicago Cook County and Vudu.
Workforce Partnerships. This

36
Notes from the field: Challenges to promoting
inclusive economic mobility
Shifting systems to promote for Women in Factories), managers to allow their female
inclusive economic mobility particularily outcomes over the workers to take time out to be
is, of course, complex and full long term, but have more work trained. Including male workers
of challenges, despite working to do to build robust approaches as well as demonstrating the
with some of the world’s to measurement and evaluation business benefit of better-
leading organizations to do so. across all programs. trained workers helped convince
A few examples of challenges many to allow the training.
faced by our Walmart and Assessments and credentials
Walmart Foundation teams Building industry-recognized Long-term engagement
working on our programs in assessments and credentials As veterans’ employment rate
inclusive economic mobility: for soft skills (e.g., customer has risen, some people think
service) is more difficult than there is no need to work on
Measurement and for hard skills (e.g., welding). reintegration – but successful
evaluation One of the reasons we set out reintegration is about more than
For many of our programs, we a five-year time frame for our getting that first civilian job. It
can gather input metrics (grants Retail Opportunity initiative was will be critical to keep funders
made) and output metrics allowing the field enough time and stakeholders engaged in
(number of people trained); it to make progress on this. this effort even if on the surface
is more challenging to measure things look promising.
and evaluate outcomes (impact Gender equality in
on livelihoods, mobility). We supply chain
have engaged third parties to In our women’s economic
assist us with measurement empowerment initiative, some
and evaluation in some of our of our grantees initially found it
programs (e.g., Tufts University challenging to convince factory

37
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Spotlight on

empowering women around the world

Creating opportunities for women


Sourcing
4-year spending for women-owned business
(in billions) $4.76
$4.30
$3.90
$3.50

Walmart’s Global Women’s


Economic Empowerment
FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16
Initiative provides $16.46 billion to date
opportunities
for women across
one of the largest
Sourcing from
supply networks
and promoting
in the world.
women-owned
businesses
U.S.
International

38
across our supply chain
Training Diversity

Empowering nearly Promoting diversity


1 million women and inclusion worldwide
through training

Farms Professional service firms


Factories Merchandise suppliers
Retail
Other careers

39
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Promoting the growth of suppliers,


local manufacturing and small businesses
Sam Walton started Walmart as a small business – a local, Main starters, small business owners make up an important part of
Street store with a vision of bringing affordable products to Sam’s Club membership base, so an investment in them is an
small-town customers. Over the years, he and his associates grew investment in the future of our company. As well, Walmart relies
the business into one of the largest in the world. Entrepreneurs on a healthy, diverse supplier base to provide innovative and
like Mr. Walton – whether running retail stores, farms, factories or relevant products for our customers.
other kinds of businesses – are important engines of economic Our programs to promote economic growth through business
growth around the world. development include:
As one of the world’s largest retailers, we aim to use our purchase
• Empowering women by sourcing from
orders, as well as our philanthropy, convening power and advocacy,
women-owned business
to promote the growth of women-owned and diverse suppliers,
local manufacturing and small business in general. In addition • Fostering diversity among our suppliers
to spending directly with small- and medium-sized businesses
as suppliers, we are investing in programs that help them access • Promoting local manufacturing
affordable capital and get the training and tools they need to
• Supporting small business growth
strengthen and grow their businesses.
We believe this approach fuels economic growth – a positive
outcome not only for society, but also for our business. For

Women’s economic Supplier diversity Local manufacturing Small business


empowerment

40
Promoting the growth of suppliers, local manufacturing and small businesses:
Progress against commitments
As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Source $20 billion from women-owned businesses for Since 2011, sourced more than $16.4 billion, including
our U.S. operations through 2016 (beginning in 2011). more than $4.7 billion in FY2016.
Double sourcing from women-owned businesses in our Tracking spend in six markets; on track to double
Women-owned business global markets through 2016. sourcing in Mexico.
Launch a dedicated e-commerce platform to give Completed by launching the Empowering Women
women-owned/empowering businesses access to Together platform.
customers.
Purchase an additional $250 billion in products On track to meet 2023 committment.
supporting American jobs between 2013 and 2023.

Local manufacturing
Create a $10 million U.S. Manufacturing Innovation Fund Awarded over $7 million in Research and Development
funded by Walmart and the Walmart Foundation to grants.
invest in breakthroughs in manufacturing technology.

Through funding from Sam’s Club and the Sam’s Club Multiple grants made in 2015; grantees across portfolio
Giving Program, enable 5,000 loans from CDFIs to report increasing loan disbursement and efficiency.
underserved small businesses, particularly those owned
by women, minorities and veterans.
Leverage funding from Sam’s Club and the Sam’s Club Grantees report positive progress increasing capital
Giving Program to unlock $100 million in new capital available for small business.
Small business from nonbank, community lending resources to
distribute to low- and moderate-income small business
owners through 2019.
Sam’s Club and the Sam’s Club Giving Program will Multiple grants in 2015 expected to support goal
fund programs that reach one million underserved through outreach and online programs.
small business owners with education on lending and
borrower practices.

41
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Growth – Women-owned businesses

Sourcing from market a new product or This approach offers important


service not offered by their advantages to our business and
women-owned competition. to society at large. Walmart’s
businesses women-owned suppliers in the
Despite these facts, WOBs U.S. are growing faster than our
represent a tiny percentage average sales and generating
Women-owned businesses
– less than 5 percent – of the higher margins, compared
(WOBs) offer a tremendous
supply base across consumer with the rest of business
opportunity to empower
goods categories, and many without WOBs. More broadly,
women economically and to
WOBs face challenges accessing when investments are made
fuel economic growth. They
affordable capital or other in WOBs, it not only drives
employ nearly 9 million people
means to scale their businesses. economic growth, it improves
in the United States alone.
the livelihood of women, their
WOBs also represent one of
In 2011, Walmart and the employees and families. Our
the country’s fastest-growing
Walmart Foundation launched strategies to elevate women’s
business segments, with 45
the Global Women’s Economic leadership in business include:
percent growth between
Empowerment Initiative, which
2007 and 2016 compared
includes sourcing $20 billion • Sourcing from WOBs in
with just 9 percent growth
of products and services from the U.S. and other markets
in all businesses. WOBs are
WOBs in the U.S. over five
increasing five times faster
years, as well as seeking to • Making it easier for
than the national average. The
double sourcing from WOBs in women to launch
latest Global Entrepreneurship
Walmart’s other markets around and grow businesses
Monitor Women’s Report
the world. We are combining in emerging markets
survey estimated that there
this use of our purchase order
are more than 200 million
with customer marketing, • Promoting WOBs
women starting or running
which promotes WOBs in through philanthropy
a new enterprise, and 128
stores and online, and through and marketing initiatives
million managing established
philanthropic initiatives, which
businesses, in 83 representative
economies. The study also support mentoring and access Sourcing from WOBs in
found that women in nearly to lower-cost capital. We’re the U.S. and other markets
also collaborating with other As part of Walmart’s
half of these countries are
organizations that advocate for commitment to the economic
equal to, or outpacing, male
the needs of WOBs. empowerment of women, we
entrepreneurs in terms of
have undertaken initiatives
innovating and offering the

42
to increase our sourcing from by hosting two Accelerator country can access to improve
WOBs both in the U.S. and in training classes at the Walmart their opportunity to source
other markets. Home Office. The training from women. Our global
ran for 2½ days and included WOB directory counts more
In 2011, we promised to subject matter experts from than 10,000 WOB profiles for
spend $20 billion to purchase within the business to teach WOBs that include current
products for our U.S. stores and answer questions directly suppliers and certified women-
from WOBs over a five-year from the WOBs themselves. owned businesses from the
period. Since 2012, Walmart Women’s Business Enterprise “I just wanted to thank you for
has sourced $16.46 billion in Also, we track our sourcing National Council (WBENC) and such an awesome experience.
products and services from with WOBs in five international WEConnect International. This The training sessions were so
valuable and I will definitely
WOBs in the U.S., including markets – India, Japan, Mexico, year through the WOB directory,
use what I learned with current
$4.76 billion in the past year. In Central America and Sub- Walmart is sending quarterly
and prospective business with
2015, we worked with Walmart’s Saharan Africa. The Walmart newsletters to WOBs in India, Walmart!”
supplier administration to create WEE team works with our Latin America and the U.S.
additional training resources country teams to design describing upcoming events -Elaine Robinson, CEO of Medelco
for our WOB suppliers. The market-level strategies to and resources – building even and participant in the Accelerator
training included 10 two- support and train current and more communication between July 2015 Class
minute videos focused on new WOB suppliers, support Walmart and the WOBs.
replenishment, logistics our buyers in selecting WOBs
and merchandising topics and communicate our best Making it easier for
to provide fundamentals to practices and learnings. In women to launch and
help businesses work with addition, the WEE team has grow businesses in
Walmart. We also found ways developed a series of global emerging markets
to accelerate existing WOBs tools and resources that each In emerging markets, women

Meet a supplier: Lisa Allen, CEO of Ziegenfelder Co.


Lisa Allen, CEO, says, “Our bread and butter of our country, Walmart recognizes that they have
responsibility is to provide the the lifeblood. As a small women’s the capacity to change the world
absolute best quality product business, Ziegenfelder has families and are not just selling products.
possible for our consumers. We are and incomes relying on the decisions They are helping suppliers, helping
proud of our price points and that we make. If you think of create empowerment and making
know we can provide that fun treat 300 employees, it’s really that sure our world is sustainable for
for every family. We like to think of times three to five, so there’s generations to come. The leaders
ourselves as smile-makers.” a lot of people that rely on us. at Walmart truly recognize they
Our vision is to be an enduring can help people save money and
Ziegenfelder Co. started selling Lisa understands Walmart’s company with opportunities live better. I am really proud to be a
their products to Walmart in 1992 support of women-owned for our family and any family. part of Walmart’s Global Women’s
and has a model that has always business extends to her team What’s important for the world to Economic Empowerment Initiative.”
been very similar to Walmart’s. As members. “Small business is the understand about Walmart is that

43
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Growth – Women-owned businesses

often face barriers to starting Getting Started, Evaluating Your technical experts, established Accelerating WOBs
and running businesses. Business, Journey to Shelf and WOBs, academic experts and Through a 2015 collaboration
Whether cultural or economic, The Strategic Supplier. business managers. with Agora, a nonprofit
Walmart is working to support organization that provides
women in overcoming those Supporting female Walmart has committed to resources and support to
obstacles to create thriving entrepreneurs in India support 25 women-owned entrepreneurs working on social
economic enterprises. Here we In January 2016, Walmart India businesses to attend this and environmental problems
highlight three such examples. announced an innovative program in regions of Andhra, in Central America, Walmart is
entrepreneurship development Delhi, Pradesh, Punjab, helping give five WOBs a jump-
Creating e-learning modules program for WOBs with the Telangana and Uttar Pradesh. start in their business. Agora’s
Walmart worked with aim of enhancing their skills, program uses a method known
WEConnect International to capability and sustainability. Announcing the program, as “accelerator training,” which
fund a 10-module e-learning Working with WEConnect Krish Iyer, CEO of Walmart targets entrepreneurs with
series called WEConnect International and Vrutti, a India, said, “I am extremely scalable, profitable businesses
Academy. The course provides market-based community delighted to support women- that can quickly create
business basics designed to development organization in owned businesses. Enhancing measurable impact, given the
help female entrepreneurs India, the initiative is designed the capacity of women right resources and timely
learn the necessary skills to to help women entrepreneurs entrepreneurs and providing investment. The five WOBs also
grow their business. Working achieve higher levels of them with the skills to scale up received the opportunity to
with WEConnect International business growth. A training their business will ultimately travel to SOCAP (Social Capital
& WindRider, Walmart created curriculum forms the core of help Walmart India continue Markets) to pitch their companies
four e-learning modules that the program, which will be to offer great assortment and to interested investors.
cover how to do business with delivered through workshops quality local products to
Walmart and include the topics: and mentoring sessions with our customers.”

Meet a supplier: Dr. Puri and the Society for Child Development
Walmart often helps our suppliers In India, one notable source of working with our buying team
see the possibilities for new waste comes from the flowers to increase their capacity. Noting
business opportunities. One of our used at temples, which are then the organization’s creativity in
suppliers in India, a nonprofit called discarded. SCD helps collect turning waste into a useable
Society for Child Development (SCD), these flowers every morning, after product, Walmart’s buyer, Deepak
founded by Dr. Madhumita Puri, which they are sorted, cleaned, Gandhi, and his team members
had been working on recycling dried, powdered and turned into a encouraged Dr. Puri to make lamps
waste through a “Trash to Cash” product for the Indian festival from recycled material for another
program. SCD’s approach helps of colors called Holi. Indian festival, Diwali. SCD’s
differently abled women and men products are now sold in 18 Best
earn a dignified livelihood through Dr. Puri and SCD began supplying Price Modern Wholesale stores
converting waste into products. Walmart in 2012 and have been in India.

44
Promoting WOBs the truth of this belief. As the (MWEDO) – deepening the
through philanthropy first retailer to feature products understanding of the com-
and marketing initiatives with the logo in signage in our plexities of microbusinesses
Without unique ways of stores and in our marketing, working with multi-national
identifying that products we tracked the sales of certain corporations.
come from WOBs, customers feature items and found that
have no way of knowing that products with signage drove Working with NGOs, we
their choices may support higher sales than the same connected artisan cooperatives
the economic empowerment feature without signage. from developing countries, giving
of women. Likewise, without them the opportunity to sell their
an organizing platform that In 2015, we also launched products on walmart.com. These
highlights WOBs to other a Women Owned page on artisan suppliers can face more
businesses, companies seeking walmart.com to feature WOBs challenges around logistics and
to do business with WOBs and their products. The page production for diverse markets
may miss those opportunities. aims to continue customer than our other EWT suppliers.
Walmart has supported two education about our work As EWT has matured, we have
With the rollout of the
initiatives designed to promote empowering women through worked to develop sustainable
Women Owned logo and
WOBs in just these ways. sourcing and products. solutions to overcome these
the work of the Global Women’s
challenges, such as exploring a
Economic Empowerment
Promoting women globally: Empowering Women Together new audit protocol for smaller
initiative, WBENC awarded
The Women Owned logo Launched in 2013, Walmart’s businesses, like these artisan
Walmart CEO Doug McMillon
Following the launch of the online platform Empowering suppliers, that will satisfy ethical
the WBENC Crystal Leadership
Women Owned logo by WBENC Women Together (EWT) gave standards requirements while
Award in June 2015.
and WeConnect International, opportunities to small business- also recognizing the capacity
in 2015 the logo was expanded es with less than $10 million in challenges of smaller businesses.
into French, Mandarin and annual revenue that aim to eco-
Spanish to continue to provide nomically empower women.
opportunities for international
WOBs. The Women Owned In 2014 and 2015, the Said
logo is a consistent label that Business School (SBS) at the
helps raise customer awareness University of Oxford, with fund-
of WOBs and facilitates the ing from Walmart, produced a
support of WOBs as part of research series on EWT, includ-
their purchasing behavior. All ing three case studies, a teach-
four logos can be used either ing case and an advisory note
by WBENC- or WeConnect on measurement – providing
International-certified businesses. insight into the challenges and
successes of the program. In
Walmart believes that if November 2015 at Power Shift, a
customers know that a product conference hosted by SBS, three
was made by a WOB, she would SBS senior faculty members
be more likely to purchase it. led a case study on Walmart
In 2015, we gained customer and the Maasai Women’s
insights that demonstrated Development Organization

45
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Growth – Diverse suppliers

Supplier diversity Strengthening • Strengthen the impact of


supplier diversity diverse businesses in the
communities we serve
As a global retailer, we see Annual Supplier Summit
firsthand the astonishing Each year, our U.S. Manufacturing Collaboration
diversity that exists between Supplier Summit allows our We support and collaborate
our stores located in different suppliers and buyers to come with leading organizations that
In FY16 in our U.S. markets, countries. We see it in our
we spent $12.1 billion with
together for dialogue and advocate for diversity-owned
supply chain as well, and we building relationships, while businesses. These organizations
more than 3,300 diverse believe we’re at our best when
suppliers – representing
also promoting diversity. The include:
we promote that diversity for summit seeks to:
about 8 percent of our the benefit of our customers. • National Minority Supplier
suppliers – and an additional Diversity among our suppliers • Advance dialogue between Development Council
$2.6 billion through second- not only allows us to broaden diverse businesses and
tier spending. the range of products and internal stakeholders • Women’s Business Enterprise
services we bring to the National Council
communities we serve, but also • Help potential suppliers
helps us tailor product lines to understand our Every Day • U.S. Pan Asian American
the local tastes of a given store Lost Cost and Every Day Low Chamber of Commerce
or region. In this way, we’re able Price strategy
to create a more inclusive and • USBLN Disability Supplier
resilient supply chain, where we • Provide opportunities for Diversity Program
source from and support the suppliers to present their
economic growth of suppliers products to our buyers • WEConnect International
both large and small, especially
those owned by minorities, • Expose our buyers to the • Department of Veterans
women, U.S. Veterans and insights, innovation and Affairs Center for Veterans
people with disabilities. expertise of diverse suppliers Enterprise

Increasing our supplier diversity – spending with diverse-owned businesses

Spend results (in Millions) FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016

Merchandising $8,096.8 $8,362.1 $8,128.6 $8,629.5


Services $1,039.1 $1,379.6 $1,444.8 $1,954.1
Direct import $963.8 $1,242.3 $1,415.4 $1,547.4
Tier 2 indirect spend $2,626.8 $2,572.4 $3,156.5 $2,592.9
Total direct spend $10,099.8 $10,984.1 $10,988.8 $12,131.1
Direct & indirect spend $12,726.6 $13,556.5 $14,145.3 $14,724.0

Since the launch of the Women’s Sourcing Goal, we have sourced an additional $10.9 billion in tier 2 indirect spend with
diverse suppliers from FY13 through FY16.

46
Meet our suppliers
Walmart’s Supplier Diversity
Program includes a significant
number of small, family-owned
businesses, often staffed and
managed by diverse owners who
employ from their communities.
These suppliers support their own
local communities, often through
donations, sustainability initiatives
and volunteer events.

Chef Jenn Trio Trucking Olé Mexican Foods

Jennifer McCullough launched Carvel Simmons, who hails from Veronica Moreno founded Olé
Chef Jenn in 2013. She began by Frankfort, Ohio, founded Trio Mexican Foods with a mission:
selling dips and seafood cakes at Trucking Inc. in 1982. He responded to bring authentic tortillas to the
small stores in her hometown of to an opportunity issued by a United States. She believed that
Memphis, Tenn. The next year, she Fortune 500 company seeking the tortillas sold in U.S. stores did
attended Walmart’s “Open Call” a trucking supplier for pending not taste as good as those she
event as a supplier of products transportation projects that met made in her home. In 1988, she
made in America, and she soon diversity, quality and capacity started the company with a small
after began selling her products requirements. The company has factory in Atlanta and today has
in 800 Walmart stores. Seafood been expanding since that time expanded the Olé Mexican Foods
used in her products is sourced through contracts with companies brand into Walmart stores across
using sustainable practices, like Walmart. the country.
and she has added shelf-stable
products to her line. Trio Trucking and Walmart have “I started in 1988 with one machine,
enjoyed a decade-long relationship, and I wanted to prove something
“I began selling soups and catering and Simmons has been honored to myself as a woman. Walmart is
fresh prepared meals out of my as a Walmart Diverse Carrier of the very important to us. It has helped
home. … I never dreamed that I Year on two occasions. Simmons us grow a lot. It helped us get to so
could do business with Walmart,” has worked with Walmart to many places,” Moreno said.
McCullough said. Today, the expand his trucking and rail
Chef Jenn grocery line includes service offerings. These types
dips, seafood cakes, sauces and of arrangements are mutually
breading. McCullough plans to beneficial, with Walmart receiving
add frozen meals to the line soon. transportation cost savings.

47
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Growth – Diverse suppliers and local manufacturing

Diversity on supplier supporting the Walmart businesses, to enhance local Investing in local manufacturing
account teams and Sam’s Club account. We and regional manufacturing offers a number of benefits.
With research showing the plan to expand the survey to of goods, and to help them Many of our customers tell
benefits to creativity and merchandising suppliers who deliver high-quality services. us they prefer to buy locally,
productivity that diversity do more than $1 billion in sales There are currently more than a factor second only to price
brings to team environments, with Walmart U.S. and Sam’s 2.5 million veteran-owned small when they make purchasing
Walmart actively encourages Club U.S. in 2016. businesses in the U.S., which decisions. Sourcing locally
its major suppliers to include generate $1.2 trillion in annual allows Walmart to respond to
women and minorities on their A coalition for veteran- sales and employ more than the customer faster, respond
teams that service Walmart owned small businesses 5.8 million Americans. to seasonal demands and
and Sam’s Club accounts. In continuing support of our mitigates risks such as currency
In 2015, we created a new commitments to small busi- Promoting local jobs and volatility in port delays,
website where suppliers can nesses and to U.S. veterans, in which drives out-of-stocks.
submit their team diversity 2015 Walmart and Sam’s Club Locally sourced products also
information and access collaborated with other leading More than two-thirds of save on transportation costs,
reference resources. The site companies, government agen- Walmart’s sales in countries which not only contributes to
also provides information on cies and nonprofit organiza- such as the U.S., Mexico and lower prices, but also reduces
Walmart’s work concerning tions to launch the Coalition India come from products greenhouse gas emissions
diversity through the Women’s for Veteran Owned Business. sourced locally in those by getting containers “off the
Economic Empowerment Led by First Data Corporation markets. With billions in water.” When we reach our 2023
initiative and our internal and the Institute for Veterans purchase orders worldwide, goal, we will have removed an
Diversity and Inclusion team. and Military Families at Syracuse Walmart can make a estimated 2.5 million containers
University (IVMF), this unique significant contribution from the shipping supply. And,
With the participation of national initiative supports to the growth of local ultimately, investing in local
nearly 50 top Professional the success of veteran-, manufacturing in sectors manufacturing capacity around
Service suppliers this year, we service member-and military ranging from food processing the world means local customer
noted trends toward a more family-owned businesses. It to textiles and beyond. spending creates more jobs in
diverse representation on connects these businesses with local communities.
supplier teams. From suppliers entrepreneurial education and Walmart aims to use
represented, 40 percent of training, small business resourc- our purchase orders, Funding innovative
their employees counted as es and solutions, and commerce supplier relationships and manufacturing
diversity representatives, up and supplier opportunities. philanthropy to promote local With support from Walmart
from 36 percent in our first manufacturing innovation and the Walmart Foundation, a
survey in 2014. As the level of The coalition is pledging to and growth. In the U.S., we $10 million U.S. Manufacturing
responsibility increased, so advocate for and support have committed to source Innovation Fund was created
did gender, with 54 percent of businesses operated by the an incremental $250 billion in 2014 to support innovative
reporting suppliers’ executives greater military and veteran in products supporting U.S. research into manufacturing
being female. community, including both jobs by 2023. In 2014 Walmart processes and outcomes over
business-to-business and and the Walmart Foundation five years. The fund supports
Procter & Gamble volunteered business-to-consumer models. committed to invest $10 million applied research projects that
to be the first merchandising It will also focus on creating to fund breakthroughs in advance cost-cutting solutions
supplier to report the diversity new opportunities to bolster manufacturing technology. to current manufacturing
and gender of their team the contributions of these challenges, such as reducing

48
waste in production and • Oregon State University: executives and merchants.
limiting shipping distances. Environmentally Conscious The summit featured an
This year’s grant projects, which Dyeing Of Fabrics Using “Open Call” segment where
focus on textile innovations Continuous Digital Printing registrants delivered business
and sustainable manufacturing And Drying Of Biopigment pitches and new business
processes, totaled $2.84 million Inks relationships were established.
in funding and include: The Supplier Academy sessions,
• University of Texas – Austin: which featured presentations
• Clemson University: On-Loom Fabric Defect on customer insights,
Energy and Effluent Inspection Using Contact manufacturing competitiveness
Reduction Through Image Sensors and government relations,
Innovative Dyeing of proved incredibly popular, and
Polyester Fabrics Promoting “Made in the USA” many people found significant
Over July 7-8, 2015, we value in meeting with their
• Cornell University: gathered more than 2,000 selected state representatives.
Post-Consumer Textile Waste suppliers, state representatives, In all, more than 500 product
As A Raw Material Substitute economic developers and trade meetings were held over the
For New Textiles organizations to Bentonville, two-day event.
Ark., for our U.S. Manufacturing
• North Carolina State University: Summit. The attendees came
Non-Stop Tying-In Process – from 46 states, the District
An Approach to Improving of Columbia and Puerto
Weaving Efficiency Rico to meet with Walmart

The environmental impact of local sourcing


By not needing to transport products through traditional shipping channels, the
environmental impact of Walmart’s local manufacturing initiative is equivalent to:

~2,500,000 ~115,000,000 ~400,000 homes ~10 billion miles


containers off tree seedling energy use for one year driven per year by
the water growth for 10 years the average vehicle

49
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Growth – Local manufacturing and small business

Supporting small To strengthen the small • Unlock $100 million in new


business sector in the U.S., capital from non-bank,
business growth Sam’s Club and the Sam’s Club community lending resources
Giving Program launched a to distribute to low- and
Small businesses play a major “Small Business Economic moderate-income small
role in global economic Mobility Initiative” in 2015. business owners through 2019.
growth. They account for nearly We are committed to helping
half of the gross domestic underserved, “Main Street” • Support jobs by both helping
product (GDP) in the U.S. They business borrowers gain better existing business owners
provide extensive economic access to capital by investing retain their role and helping
opportunity as job creators. in mission-driven lenders, such them create jobs for others
In the U.S., businesses provide as Community Development as they grow.
”Our founder Sam Walton Financial Institutions (CDFIs),
55 percent of all jobs and 66
started Sam’s Club to help
percent of all net new jobs since to build their capacity and • Reach one million underserved
small businesses get access
the 1970s. Small businesses also scale for lending. We’re also small business owners with
to big business savings,
save money and grow their provide Walmart with countless supporting organizations that education on responsible
businesses as a result. Through products, and they make up an train small business borrowers lending and better borrower
this philanthropic investment, important percentage of Sam’s on lending terms and finding practices.
our founder’s legacy is Club membership in the U.S. affordable rates. The initiative
carried forward by fortifying launched in 2015 with the
our communities’ lending Yet small businesses often face goals of:
resources to increase access to challenges securing the capital,
capital and borrower education tools and know-how necessary • Enable 5,000 loans from
for small business owners. In CDFIs to underserved small
to scale their businesses. In
collaboration with dedicated
the U.S. alone, more than 50 businesses, particularly those
nonprofits, we are proud to
percent of all credit requests owned by women, minorities
open doors for small business
and strengthen the backbone from small businesses were and veterans and with fewer
of the U.S. economy.” declined in 2014, according to than 20 employees.
the New York Federal Reserve
-Rosalind Brewer, president and Small Business Credit Survey.
CEO of Sam’s Club

Sustainability training in Chile

Walmart Chile and Corfo (the 2015, 12 of these suppliers finished


Chilean Entrepreneurship Office) a three-year training program,
have jointly financed a program where they learned to apply a
promoting the growth of small life-cycle assessment to their
and medium suppliers of private production processes, improve
brands through the introduction their productivity, enhance their
of sustainable practices. During sustainability and reduce costs.

50
Working to scale and educate: Accion U.S. Network $28
The Accion U.S. Network serves
small business owners across the
suppliers of varied sizes. They
understand firsthand how critical
resource library that attracts over
9,000 small business owners each
million
country, connecting them with
accessible financing, advice and
support to help their businesses
inclusive access to capital and
business development resources is,
particularly among those who are
month. Through this investment
in the efficiency and scale of its
operations, Accion U.S. aims to
in grants
grow. As a microfinance leader not served by traditional financial increase the number of small
and part of a global organization, institutions. The Sam’s Club business owners it reaches through
Accion works toward a financially Giving Program has consistently loans and business education
inclusive world where all businesses supported some of our most fourfold by the year 2020.
can access the resources and tools impactful initiatives, including
they need to achieve higher success. the WE Lend Initiative to expand “Using technology to make our
access to affordable loans and core processes more efficient is
Accion U.S. unites four independent training for women-owned small the price of entry for generating Since 2011 the Sam’s Club
CDFIs across the U.S. into the businesses, and the Driving Small significant social impact,” said Giving Program has provided
largest nonprofit microfinance Business Success Campaign to Harman. “Right now we are having $28 million in grants to
network in the country. Through enhance and scale access to loans an individual impact across the nonprofit organizations
programming and partnerships, and business resources among U.S. U.S. Our goal through this effort is working with local businesses.
Accion U.S. serves to foster small business owners nationwide.” to scale that impact to generate
These organizations offer
innovation, collaboration, learning transformational change at the
greater availability and variety
and capacity development within With continued support from community level. We thank the
the U.S. microfinance industry. Sam’s Club, Accion’s Driving Small Sam’s Club Giving Program for of lending products that meet
Business Success Campaign has continuing to work with Accion the needs of small businesses
According to Gina Harman, CEO been able to streamline and scale as we pursue a common goal of poised for growth.
of Accion U.S., “Sam’s Club has its online loan application process, greater financial inclusion among
a history of continued focus on as well as launch new technologies U.S. small business owners.”
serving small business as members and loan products. Accion also
and providing opportunity to maintains an online business

The Supplier Alliance


Supplier Alliance is a voluntary payment earlier than negotiated currently more than 250 suppliers
program Walmart offers Walmart payment terms. The in the program, accounting for
suppliers through our banking program has been enthusiastically approximately $9.5 billion in
service providers. The program used by our suppliers, and has purchase orders.
provides qualifying suppliers the now been expanded to include
opportunity to receive invoice all Walmart suppliers. There are

51
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Economic growth – Small businesses and challenges

Southern Girl Desserts: Saving a business


Coleman and her business partner could not keep up loan payments
“Economic projections indicate Shoneji Robinson started Southern and payroll. The feeling of knowing
that in the future a growing Girl Desserts in 2007 to do what that you are stuck financially while
number of Americans will they loved, and they shared similar everyone else sees this beautiful
be working for themselves. entrepreneurial interests. Both place is heartbreaking,” recalls
The for-profit and nonprofits Coleman and Robinson had too Coleman.
that can provide capital and much pride to ask their families
resources for this segment for money to start their business, “It was crazy because despite our
seek to leverage technology so they launched using personal issues making payments, we were
to lower their costs and savings. Eventually their families being offered more loans and
embrace new partnerships helped out, as Southern Girl accepted them. One letter looked
in order to compete and to Desserts was growing and doing different from the others and
better serve this growing Catarah Coleman, co-owner of well. The growing company had an that’s when we called Opportunity
market. The Sam’s Club Giving Southern Girl Desserts in Los opportunity to develop a location Fund.” As a California-based CDFI
Program is a welcome new Angeles, has fond childhood in a high-traffic mall, but the move and a Sam’s Club Giving Program
funder and contributor to the memories of baking. “Desserts would require building out the grantee, Opportunity Fund offers
national conversation about are special to my family. I can space and hiring new employees. reasonable interest rates and works
how to advance this diverse remember growing up and it While Southern Girl Desserts and its with businesses to match the right
entrepreneurial community wasn’t the turkey or the ham on owners had banking relationships, loan product to the business need.
and to meet their needs for the table that was the star of the banks would not loan them the
capital and knowledge to dinner, it was the desserts. I was working capital needed. “We “Opportunity Fund helped us
build their businesses.” raised in Florida, and in the South found a broker who would loan refinance the bad debt. We have
we are known for our hospitality us money, offering $45,000, and our cash flow again and we are
-Joyce Klein, Director of the Aspen and the love and the joy that goes we had the money within a week. better managing our business
Institute Microenterprise Fund into baking. Everyone in my family For a while everything flowed, overall. We are so grateful – they
for Innovation and Effectiveness, cooks, and time in the kitchen is but when business slowed due to helped save our business,” says
Learning and Dissemination family time.” seasonal changes, and we realized Coleman.
(FIELD) the interest rate was exorbitant, we

52
Notes from the field: Challenges to developing
small and local businesses in a global economy
Local sourcing is one of the fastest-growing of these loan products are ill-
Sometimes startup or other segments of new enterprises. matched to meet the needs of
incremental costs offset Additionally, once WOBs and small business owners, despite
transportation savings, small suppliers onboard, they their appeal of fast, easy approval
making it cost-prohibitive face the challenge of Walmart and swift loan disbursement.
to source products locally. systems and processes. While CDFIs are exploring cross-sector
Our teams work with we try to solve some of this collaborations with some online
potential suppliers and through our training classes, lenders willing to share their
other stakeholders to drive WOBs can be at a disadvantage technology platforms. While
the innovation necessary to the suppliers who have this promises to reduce costs
to support local sourcing. been replenishing and moving of acquisition and help scale
product through Walmart mission-driven lending, the
Women-owned and diverse stores for decades. impact of these collaborations
sourcing programs has yet to be evaluated.
Sometimes the suppliers with Small Business
the most exciting, customer- While the demand for loans
relevant product ideas are small. below $250,000 is high,
Supplying larger retailers like Community Development
Walmart can be challenging Financial Initiatives (CDFI)
for them, because the retailers are currently unable to meet
usually have supplier standards, the full demand, and banks
such as order minimums or tend not to lend at this level.
necessary certifications, which Private investment has ignited
may require the supplier to make innovation in financial services,
enhancements in technology, resulting in the creation of
infrastructure or capacity. In alternative online lenders to
some of our markets, especially fill the gap. These lenders
India, Japan and Mexico, it can represented nearly $10 billion
be difficult to identify growth- in outstanding loan capital in
oriented WOBs, particularly 2014, according to the State of
with the capacity, quality, and Small Business Lending from
innovation to sell to Walmart, Harvard Business School. There
even though the WOB segment is growing concern that some

53
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Enhancing sustainability

As the world’s population continues to grow, we face the enhancing food security, promoting transparency and quality
collective challenge of meeting people’s everyday needs in a of products and supporting the safety and dignity of workers in
way that our planet can sustain. Ten years ago Walmart set out in supply chains.
earnest to find a more sustainable approach to our retail business. While we have made progress, much more needs to be done.
We set long-term goals to operate with 100 percent renewable The scope of change we are undertaking requires collective
energy, to create zero waste in our own operations and to sell action, and we have been collaborating with customers,
products that sustain people and the environment. suppliers, other retailers, nonprofit organizations and
Along the way, we have deepened and broadened our governments to accelerate and increase impact. For our part, we
aspirations for sustainability. What began as a focus on are bringing our relevant strengths to bear, including customer
sustainable operations and products has now evolved into an and supplier relationships, purchase orders, philanthropy, voice,
effort to help rewire whole supply chain systems. Our focus physical assets, and capabilities in sourcing, logistics, technology,
on renewable energy has broadened into an effort to combat operations and marketing, to name a few. This is a whole-
climate change across supply chains. Our focus on reducing company undertaking – from merchants to marketers, engineers
our own operational waste has broadened into helping foster to truck drivers, store associates to agronomists – we're all
a circular economy, in which materials can be repurposed involved in some way to further our sustainability efforts.
and continually recycled. And our focus on selling sustainable While essential for society, enhancing sustainability also makes
products has broadened into an attempt to address social and good business sense. It strengthens our customer relationships,
environmental hot-spots along product supply chains: not only whereas we advocate not only for low cost but for low true cost in
reducing emissions and waste, but also preserving natural capital, supply chains. It enhances efficiency by reducing inputs and waste,

54
and it increases the long-term viability of our product supply. Our • Providing access to affordable, sustainable and healthier
stakeholders want to know that the world’s largest company is food, by
doing its part as we all strive for a more sustainable future. • Increasing access to affordable food
The following section describes our recent efforts and progress in • Supporting hunger relief and education
• Enhancing nutrition
six priority programs:
• Increasing the food supply through food waste reduction
• Improving sustainable food production
• Reducing energy intensity and emissions, by
• Reducing energy intensity and emissions in • Supporting transparency and quality in the products we
our own operations sell, by
• Supporting the reduction of emissions in • Promoting food and general merchandise product safety
product supply chains • Promoting reduction in use of chemicals of concern
• Moving to a zero waste future, by • Promoting animal welfare and responsible antibiotic use
• Eliminating waste in our own operations • Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere, by
• Improving packaging and product design • Promoting responsible sourcing practices in the global
• Expanding recycling through education and improved supply chain
infrastructure • Focusing on safety, health and environmental compliance
• Preserving natural resources, especially forests and water, by in our operations
• Getting to zero net deforestation
• Promoting a quality water supply
• Conserving land

55
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Spotlight on

The Sustainability Index

The Sustainability Index


How big data leads to more sustainable products

Value chain Raw materials Distribution

Food & beverages


Home & personal care
Toys
Apparel & textiles
Electronics
General merchandise

1 Manufacturing

The Sustainability
Consortium identifies
approximately 15 of
the most important Distribution Retail

product questions
to ask suppliers
about the biggest
sustainability Consumer use

challenges in their Climate


Waste
value chains Deforestation and water
Product safety and chemistry
Animal welfare
Worker health & safety

Product afterlife

56
$135 billion 260 buyers
worth of goods sold evaluated informed about their suppliers’
for sustainability performance sustainability performance

2 3
Walmart uses SAP’s Walmart analyzes the reports to help
Product Stewardship engage suppliers in continuous
Network to collect improvement, targeted sustainability
suppliers’ responses projects and helping drive a more
to approximately sustainable product portfolio
15 product-specific
questions and
processes their input Sample reports include:
into ‘big sustainability
Product evaluation: Supplier evaluation: Monitor impact areas:
data’ reports heat maps scorecards dashboards

57
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Reducing energy intensity and emissions


Despite significant efforts from companies, governments, chain reduction commitment, we’re also exploring ways we
nonprofits and individuals around the world, our planet’s might further engage our suppliers to set and meet their own
temperature continues to rise, with increased greenhouse gas goals and join us in reducing our collective footprint.
emissions (GHGs) as a leading contributor. This year, the world As we pursue these goals, their value to both our business and to
reached an important consensus at the United Nations Climate society is clear. Finding more renewable and low-carbon energy
Conference in Paris: that we all must do our part to limit the increase alternatives and reducing energy intensity lowers operating costs
in global temperature to no more than 1.5 degrees Celsius. and can enhance operational flexibility. Many of our initiatives to
At Walmart, we are working hard to be part of the solution and reduce emissions in supply chains, such as optimizing fertilizer
aggressively pursuing our energy and emissions reduction goals. inputs and developing energy-efficient consumer products,
With 153 other companies, we have signed the White House’s help to lower production costs and drive sales. And importantly,
American Business Act on Climate pledge. As part of this initiative, our customers and other stakeholders appreciate our efforts to
each company expressed support for a strong outcome in Paris reduce emissions.
at the U.N. Climate Change Conference, and many announced Walmart focuses on two strategies for reducing our energy
or reiterated pledges to reduce emissions, increase low-carbon intensity and emissions:
investments, and deploy more clean energy projects. These
companies also pledged to pursue further actions to build more • Reducing energy intensity and emissions in our own
sustainable businesses and tackle climate change. As part of this operations
commitment, Walmart is continuing our quest to be powered
• Supporting the reduction of emissions in product supply
by 100 percent renewable energy. We’re committed to ongoing
chains
improvements in the energy efficiency of our operations. With
the reported achievement of a 20 million metric ton GHG supply

Operations Supply chain

58
Reducing energy intensity and emissions: Progress against commitments
As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

To be supplied by 100 percent renewable energy. Supplied by 25 percent.

Drive the production or procurement of 7 billion Installed or contracted for more than 2 billion kWh from
kilowatt hours (kWh) of renewable energy globally more than 470 projects worldwide.
by the end of 2020.

By end of 2020, reduce kWh-per-square-foot Reduced kWh-per-square-foot energy intensity by


Reducing energy intensity and energy intensity of Walmart facilities by 20 percent 10 percent, which represents a 1 percent absolute
emissions in our own operations versus 2010 baseline. reduction since the end of 2014.

Begin phasing out HFC refrigerants as of 2015 in Continued incorporating refrigeration and store designs
favor of non-HFC where these are legally allowed that enable the transition to less HFC-reliant systems,
and available for new purchases of point of-sale while also testing HFC-free systems in several markets.
units and large refrigeration installations.
Double U.S. fleet efficiency by the end of 2015. Achieved in October 2015, saving nearly $1 billion in
FY16 and avoiding CO2 emissions of nearly 650,000
metric tons of CO2.

Engage 70 percent of our China-sourced business Trained more than 500 factories in China on RedE tool.
in a factory energy efficiency program by 2017.

Eliminate 20 million metric tons (MMT) of GHG Surpassed; reported reduction of 35.6 million metric
Supporting emissions reductions emissions from Walmart’s global supply chain by tons.
in supply chains the end of 2015.

Increase transparency into our supplier ability to Received Index responses covering 77 percent of
track and report Climate Smart Agriculture impacts Walmart food business, with suppliers reporting GHG
through the Sustainability Index. emissions for
46 percent of their supply.

59
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Energy and emissions – operations

Reducing energy renewable energy. To reduce 17 U.S. states. Together with and contracted, due in part
our emissions, we’re focused on: renewable electricity from to maintenance outages and
intensity and the grid, 25 percent of our variations in wind profiles.
• Investing in scalable,
emissions in our renewable energy sources electricity needs globally are
own operations supplied by renewable sources. We will continue to focus on
• Reducing our energy demand accelerating our renewable
through energy efficiency As of the end of 2015, we had energy program and that of the
The burning of fossil fuels over 2 billion kWh of renewable industry in a number of ways.
– mainly coal, petroleum energy contracted on an annu- This year we completed over
and natural gas – accounts • Improving refrigeration
systems in our stores alized basis. While this is more 80 new on-site solar and fuel
for more than 80 percent of than double our total in 2012, it cell renewable energy projects
the world’s energy use and is less than what we reported at our facilities in multiple
ranks as the primary source of • Maximizing the efficiency of
our fleet last year. The reasons for the de- countries and brought a large
carbon dioxide emitted into cline are tied to changes in pol- wind farm online in Texas (see
the atmosphere. Renewable icy and certification of sources, sidebar). We are also working
energy sources – hydropower, Renewable energy
Walmart is committed to particularly in the U.K., timing with developers and utilities
wind, solar, geothermal and of projects coming online and on new project opportunities
biomass – offer cleaner, more expanding the development of
on-site and off-site solar power, varying production from a few in regulated and deregulated
sustainable alternatives, but large wind projects. In the U.S., markets, and we are engaging
often at higher prices and with wind power, fuel cells and other
technologies to meet our goal we discontinued a renewable with trade and advocacy
varying availability. contract knowing we would be groups, such as the Corporate
of producing or procuring 7
billion kilowatt hours (kWh) of replacing it with a larger wind Renewable Energy Partnership
Fossil fuel-based energy project, but this new contract and RE100. These groups are
continues to be a significant renewable energy by the end
of 2020. At the end of 2015, we didn’t come online until late in striving to remove barriers to
driver of GHG emissions in 2015, resulting in a dip in the renewable energy at the state,
Walmart’s operations. We are had more than 470 on-site and
off-site projects in operation or actual renewable energy we federal and international levels.
committed to changing this acquired this year. Additionally,
trend through our aspiration under development in seven
international countries and a few wind farms in Mexico pro-
to be supplied by 100 percent duced less than we expected

Carbon Emissions (Scope 1 and 2) vs. Retail Area


Carbon emissions (million tonnes CO2e)
Retail area (million sq. ft.)
Over the period from 2005-
2014, Walmart has limited 36 1,200
1,102 1,134
34 1,072 1,100
our emissions growth to 32
1,037
985
less than one third of our 30
921
952 1,000
28 867
business growth rate during 900
26 805
the same period. 24 740 800
20.6 21.2 21.0 21.9
22 20.8 20.3 20.8
19.3 20.1 700
20 18.9
18 600
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

60
GHG Emission Contribution by Source Onsite Renewable Projects Total Renewable Energy*
(GWh)
New projects installed during fiscal year
Existing projects in operation Contracted**
Actual***
Purchased energy – 69%
Refrigerants – 18% 467 3,000
Transport fuel – 5.9% 389 2,500
Onsite fuel – 7% 326
2,000
Mobile refrigerants – 0.1% 256
1,500
152 1,000
70 152 387
104 256 326 500
82 70 61 80
0
FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15

*Totals represent the renewable energy from all


Walmart-driven projects (i.e. off-site and on-site)
only. This does not include the renewable energy
2015 Global renewable energy use received from local utility grids.
Walmart buildings
Electricity use Energy use **Contracted - This represents the annualized
amount of renewable energy that was under
6% 5% contract as of the end of the calendar year. This is
19% 15% projected amount for a 12 month period and can
vary from actual amount received.

***Actual – This represents that actual amount


of renewable energy received during the
calendar year indicated. The actual amount
can be different than the contracted/projected
amount for a number of reasons including; the
timing of project start and end dates, production
interruptions due to maintenance, and
variability in production due to meteorological
phenomenon (e.g. wind speeds, solar intensity).
Actuals are used to estimate the percentage of
our electricity supplied by renewable sources
and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions.

■ Walmart-driven renewable energy projects


■ Renewable energy from grid
■ Nonrenewable energy

61
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Energy and emissions – operations

Measuring and managing emissions: Walmart’s CDP climate disclosure


Walmart tracks our Scope 1 (direct), In 2015, Walmart received a being the best) and measures aspects of Disclosure and even
Scope 2 (indirect) and some Scope Disclosure Score of 96 and how effectively a company is more so on Performance. Our latest
3 (other indirect) GHG emissions Performance Band “B.” The addressing climate risk. response, along with all previous
according to the World Resource Disclosure Score ranges from responses to the Climate Investor
Institute’s GHG Protocol. Since 0-100 and measures the level According to FirstCarbon Solutions, Questionnaire, can be found at the
2006, we’ve publicly reported of transparency a company has an independent analyst, Walmart CDP website: https://www.cdp.
this information annually to CDP, shared through its response. ranked well above our industry net/en-US/Pages/HomePage.
formerly known as the Carbon The Performance Band issues group’s average, and well above aspx
Disclosure Project. letter grades from A to E (A the CDP program average on all

The road through Paris: Walmart and climate change


In 2005, Walmart’s then-CEO Paris for COP21, the United Nations advances that produce faster And we do believe that an
Lee Scott said: “Every company Climate Change Conference. results as we move closer to GHG international agreement has the
has a responsibility to reduce emissions levels that may cause potential to provide businesses
greenhouse gas emissions as The conference helped affirm the irreversible change with greater certainty when it
quickly as possible.” Since then, opportunities for businesses in comes to this issue. Given the
• Retailers specifically have a
Walmart has set aggressive targets addressing the challenge of climate risk that climate change poses in
significant opportunity to use
related to renewable energy change: general, a unified international
their broad reach to affect change
and energy efficiency within response gives businesses more
• By taking action now to reduce across our supply chain and to
our operations as well as GHG confidence in making plans, and it
GHG emissions, companies can educate customers
targets within our supply chain. gives financial institutions greater
see a positive impact to their Walmart regards the coming
We have also joined the We Mean confidence to make loans.
bottom lines, while mitigating together of world leaders to
Business coalition and – along risks
with 115 other companies – have take action combating climate Walmart is striving to lead by
committed to set science-based • Businesses must leverage their change as a positive development example on this issue and send the
emissions reduction targets for considerable assets in conjunction that we support. While the Paris right signals to all our stakeholders.
Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions. with key stakeholders Agreement largely speaks to the In many cases, leading through
actions of nations, the sections intentional action is a powerful
• Companies must also drive
In December 2015, Walmart relating to non-state actors affirm proof of concept for the business
for technological innovation,
representatives, including board what we have already been doing, community.
improved processes and scientific
member Rob Walton, traveled to and will continue to do.

62
9,000 construction jobs, as Wal-Mart de México's goal is to
well as 5,000 permanent jobs, procure 3,000 million kilowatt-
for American solar companies hours by 2020.
since 2010. The commitment of
Walmart and other companies Scaling renewable energy
to source energy from solar also requires innovation,
projects creates more certainty so we frequently pilot new
Efficiency improvements in
in the marketplace and technologies to test their
South Africa and Argentina
Doubling on-site solar encourages others to invest, performance and suitability
In 2015, Walmart ranked as helping to lower the cost for for adoption. For example,
In our South African business, we
the leading commercial solar everyone. this year in South Africa, we
are continuing to prioritize efforts to
energy user and the largest fulfilled a 2013 commitment
make our operations more energy
on-site renewable energy Scaling renewables globally we made to identify and efficient. Throughout our stores,
user in the U.S., with more Wal-Mart de México is more pilot a commercially viable we’ve been introducing a range of
than 340 solar installations than halfway to their goal renewable energy project at energy efficient technologies, such
throughout the country. In of being powered by 100 one of our stand-alone stores. as LED lights, building management
support of a 2014 initiative by percent renewable energy. We successfully identified two systems and high performance
the White House to increase With nearly 51 percent of their potential solar photovoltaic refrigeration plants.
the country’s generation of electricity needs supplied by (PV) pilot opportunities. These
In a similar effort to improve
clean energy, we’ve committed more than 1,100 million kWh include a 150 kilo volt amp (kva)
energy efficiency, Walmart
to doubling the number of from five renewable projects, PV plant that will be installed
Argentina’s Home Office
on-site solar energy projects they’re powering more than in our most efficient Builders conducted a study in 2015 to
at our U.S. stores, Sam’s Clubs 1,100 stores with cleaner Warehouse store, and three determine the extent to which
and distribution centers by energy. When combined with 700kva plants earmarked for associates in Supercenters were
2020 compared with our 2013 the renewable energy they our Makro Woodmead and using energy-saving strategies
baseline. When completed, we receive from the national Carnival Mall stores. We expect in daily operations. The results of
will have more than 480 solar grid, Wal-Mart de México is these projects to come online the study have formed the basis
meeting 60 percent of their in the second quarter of 2016 for an energy-efficiency initiative
installations across the U.S.
electricity needs today through fulfilling a commitment we set launching in 2016 that will seek
Walmart’s investment in solar to understand each associate’s
energy has led to an estimated renewable energy sources. in 2013.
energy-use habits and to reduce
total kWh used throughout the
stores.

Farm-grown renewable energy

In 2015, Walmart contracted with Comanche County, Texas. Our


a wind farm that will offer a clean facilities in central Texas will
source of power to more than receive more than 25 percent
380 Walmart stores, Sam’s Clubs of their energy needs from this
and distribution centers in Texas. renewable alternative. The power
Through a 10-year purchase from Logan’s Gap represents
agreement, Walmart will gain nearly 18 percent of the U.S.
58 percent of our expected portion of our goal to produce
energy from Logan’s Gap, or procure 7 billion kWh of
an 87-turbine wind farm in renewable energy by 2020.

63
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Energy and emissions – operations

Energy efficiency • Accelerating tomorrow’s food, our need for efficient


and demand technologies: Maintaining refrigeration equipment is
Walmart owns or leases more our focus on testing and growing as well. We look at
than 12,000 buildings around experimenting with next- refrigeration through a holistic
the world. As of year-end generation technologies lens and make decisions
2015, we were well on our way to accelerate the future of based on both the total
toward reducing the energy energy efficiency. cost of ownership and total
intensity of our global facilities energy savings throughout
by 20 percent compared with Taking efficiency through the life of the equipment. In
our 2010 baseline. Thus far, we the roof addition to striving to reduce
are operating with 10 percent In 2015, Walmart received an our energy use and prevent
less energy per square foot, award for installing the highest energy from being wasted,
which represents a 1 percent number of high-efficiency we’re transitioning away from
improvement since the end rooftop heating and cooling high Global Warming Potential
Imagining a more of 2014. units (RTUs) in the previous refrigerants (GWP) to using new
efficient business year. Walmart had replaced refrigerant gases with lower
Walmart continues to leverage more than 10,000 RTUs in 2014, overall environmental impacts.
Walmart and GE are teaming up our global size and scale with an estimated energy
to advance our shared goals of to invest in and implement savings of 89 million kWh/ Transitioning away from HFCs
promoting renewable energy technologies that reduce year, which led to an estimated In 2010, the Consumer Goods
sources and enhancing resource energy consumption and $8.9 million in cost savings and Forum (CGF) made a commit-
productivity across the commercial 135.4 million pounds of CO2e
transform the retail industry. ment to tackle the growing cli-
sector. In our Ecomagination 2020
We accelerate our efficiency of emissions avoided annually. mate impact of the refrigeration
collaboration, GE and Walmart
are working together to innovate worldwide by: The award was given by the systems used by its members.
novel energy and water solutions Advanced RTU Campaign, The refrigerant gases used in
to enhance business performance • Scaling technologies: a collaboration between the majority of systems – known
and environmental outcomes. Continuing to scale market- industry groups and the U.S. as hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) –
The collaboration will begin by ready efficiency technologies, Department of Energy. are powerful greenhouse gases.
testing new solutions within our leveraging our global demand Since 2011, Walmart, along with
own operations and then scale to provide scale and certainty Improving refrigeration systems our CGF peers, has been incor-
promising solutions across our to our suppliers. in our operations porating refrigeration needs
networks in order to magnify The refrigeration systems that into store designs that will
the impact. store the food we sell account for
• Transferring technologies facilitate the transition to less
globally: Piloting proven as much as 30 to 50 percent of HFC-reliant systems. Through
technologies in new the energy consumption of our 2014, we had completed over
geographies, store formats buildings. As our business grows 200 stores that implemented
and customer demographics. globally, especially with our these technologies.
expansions in fresh and frozen

64
This work has taught the Efficiency in our U.S. fleet of almost 650,000 metric tons
industry valuable lessons about In 2005, Walmart committed to of CO2. Moving ahead, we are
the equipment options, costs, a momentous goal: doubling folding our fleet goals into
energy demands, performance the efficiency of our fleet by the our broader goal of using 100
capabilities and maintenance end of 2015. By working with percent renewable energy, and
needs of these new low- our associates to establish more we will continue to look for
carbon technologies. These efficient techniques for loading, innovative ways to improve our
learnings have been captured routing and driving, as well fleet efficiency.
in the all-new Refrigeration as through collaboration with
Booklet, which highlights over tractor trailer manufacturers
a dozen real-life examples on new technologies, we have
from the CGF’s retailer and achieved this goal on schedule.
manufacturer members, who, With these new efficiencies, our
like Walmart, are phasing out year-end results were a 102.2
HFCs and successfully piloting percent improvement over our
and implementing natural 2005 baseline, with associated
refrigeration alternatives. savings of nearly $1 billion
annually, and avoided emissions

Improving our fleet’s efficiency Fleet efficiency contributors

Over the past 10 years, we have can play a role, there is no greater
tracked our U.S. efficiency based controllable impact on a truck’s
MPG
on the number of cases of efficiency performance than Routing
22.1%
products shipped per gallon of the driver of that truck. Through 39.2%
fuel burned, and we’ve employed weekly reporting, we are able to
a number of complementary monitor a driver’s performance in a Loading
strategies to improve our variety of driving categories. Their 38.7%
fleet’s performance. These have techniques – from how they idle,
included increasing our trailer fills, to how they accelerate – have a
decreasing the number of miles direct impact on the performance
per route and investing in more of the truck. Tracking them allows us
efficient equipment. to have well-informed conversations
with our drivers to better manage
Several factors account for a the things they can control while
truck’s fuel efficiency. While delivering a load of freight.
changing terrain and weather

65
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Energy and emissions – supply chain

Supporting the suppliers and stakeholders, now established baseline


we’re helping to enhance measures of GHG emissions,
reduction of efficiency both upstream and water use and farm yields. By
emissions in product downstream by: encouraging measurement,
supply chains disseminating best practices
• Promoting reduced emissions and reporting aggregate
in agriculture progress through CSA, Walmart
Walmart recognizes that hopes to accelerate the
addressing emissions across • Promoting reduced emissions adoption of better practices
the global supply chain is in manufacturing in our food supply chain and
as significant an issue as the broader food system. We
addressing them in our own • Supporting design of smart, believe this effort will improve
operations. In fact, 90 percent efficient home products environmental outcomes
of our environmental impact as well as the well-being of
exists beyond the footprint of Reducing emissions farmers and consumers. (For
our stores and facilities. That’s in agriculture more on reducing emissions in
why we’re engaging directly As part of our 20 MMT agriculture, see pg. 98 for our
with suppliers and investing in emissions reduction goal, we efforts in improving agricultural
efficiency worldwide to create are pursuing projects within productivity.)
more impact than would be our agricultural supply chain
possible on our own. Through that improve efficiency and Optimizing row crop production
our work with Environmental productivity. Through our Through joint support with
Defense Fund (EDF), we’ve Climate Smart Agriculture our suppliers, we expect by
successfully met our goal of Platform (CSA), we’ve asked the 2020 to see the elimination of
eliminating 20 million metric suppliers and growers in our an estimated 9 MMT of GHG
tons (MMT) of GHG emissions food business to measure and emissions in our agriculture
from our supply chain. In fact, report farm impact through supply chain through efficiency
we far exceeded the goal – our Sustainability Index. With improvements on 23 million
eliminating a reported 35.6 the participation of suppliers acres of land that use row
MMT since we began the who provide 70 percent of crops. We’re working with
initiative. Together with our our food sales volume, we’ve Field to Market: The Alliance

66
for Sustainable Agriculture to a new program, MB Grain progress with our manufac- operations and create strategies
support efforts to encourage Agronomics (MBGro), which turing suppliers, especially to reduce those emissions. In
adoption of best practices by provides free agronomic advice through our supply chain work this effort, we’ve been success-
farmers and track and measure to grain growers in Smithfield’s with CDP (formerly the Carbon ful in spurring a culture of sus-
continuous improvement in grain-sourcing regions. The Disclosure Project). The CDP tainability and climate change
environmental outcomes. Our program also connects growers Supply Chain program enables awareness among our suppliers
goal is to continue to support with technology trials at a companies to engage with through their own CDP reports.
farmers and their communities reduced price and assists them suppliers to understand climate Through this program more
improving productivity and in purchasing cover crop seed change risks and formulate than 700 of our suppliers have
farmer livelihoods. at wholesale prices. In 2015, strategies to reduce emissions reported. Many suppliers have
the first full year of MBGro within their supply chain. reported reductions, collective-
Optimizing fertilizer use implementation, more than Walmart has worked with CDP ly driving the elimination of 125
In response to Walmart’s 200 farmers, who farm more to encourage our network of million tons of CO2 emissions in
focus on promoting fertilizer than 90,000 acres, improved suppliers to take the first step 2015. (For Walmart’s own CDP
optimization in its supply their fertilizer application toward improvement and be- disclosure, see pg. 62.
chain, Smithfield Foods, a practices. gin measuring their greenhouse
major U.S. supplier of pork, set gas impact. Through measure-
an ambitious goal to engage Reducing emissions in ment and disclosure, suppliers
75 percent of their grain manufacturing can understand their own
sourcing acres – half a million In addition to pursuing emis- Reduction in carbon
emissions profile, identifyemissions
areas
acres – by 2018. Smithfield sions reductions in agricul- in of high
metric tonsemissions within their
collaborated with EDF to build ture, we’ve made significant

Collaboration with EDF

Walmart’s association with EDF global GHG emissions by 20 MMT Reduction in carbon emissions
began 10 years ago with three by the end of 2015. Working in metric tons
sustainability goals: to be supplied with EDF experts to identify key
by 100 percent renewable project areas and implement
energy, create zero waste and sell science-based solutions, Walmart
products that sustain the world’s was able to meet and exceed this
2.4
resources and environment. At goal with a 35.6 MMT reduction in .5
that time, EDF challenged Walmart GHG emissions along the supply 7.0
1.0
to create more specific and chain. EDF continues to work with 1.9
measurable goals addressing the Walmart to supply strategic advice 22.8
8.5 Palm oil & Brazil beef
central issue of climate change, and science to help Walmart set 8.2 Fertilizer
and in 2010 the Walmart team and reach sustainability goals. 10.7 Food waste & date labeling
.9 Other
announced a goal to reduce 2.9 Packaging & manufacturing
68.4 Smart & efficient home products**
2010-2015 2016-2020*
MMT MMT
(million metric tons) (million metric tons)
*Represents cumulative effect of changes made to products between 2010 and 2015 and extrapolated to 2020;
2020 projections don’t account for any future initiatives
**Includes items like refurbished electronics, LED Light Bulbs, coldwater wash detergent

67
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Energy and emissions – supply chain

We’ve also focused on efficiency and renewable 20 MMT of greenhouse gas


promoting efficiency within the technologies to transform the (GHG) emissions within the
factories in our supply chain, energy use in those factories. supply chain. This project
with a particular emphasis Given the focus on training focuses on increasing sales
on those in China. Since we to use the RedE tool since through strategic marketing of
announced our Chinese program launch, we don’t products designed to reduce
supplier initiative in August have all factories actively using energy consumption at home
2014, Walmart has trained RedE, and the full value of this for consumers when compared
more than 500 factories to initiative is yet to be realized. If with similar products in the
use the Resource Efficiency we’re able to achieve consistent market. The products range
Deployment Engine (RedE), a adoption by target factories from light bulbs to laundry
Web-based tool that guides we’ve trained, this would result detergent. In support of the
the identification of energy- in a GHG emissions reduction project, we conducted in-store
efficiency improvement of nearly 1 million metric tons marketing of home energy-
Sustainable manufacturing initiatives. From program (MMT). As we look forward to saving products, lowered
in Dongguan launch through 2015, RedE has 2016 and beyond, our focus will product price points and also
facilitated the completion of shift from training the factories conducted online marketing
In China, local relationships 118 individual factory efficiency on the RedE tool, to tracking through various communication
are important in promoting projects, with reported factory and encouraging improvement channels. Since we launched the
sustainability efforts. Through cost savings of more than $2.8 in our most strategic factories project in 2012, it has eliminated
collaboration with EDF, Walmart million, energy savings of more across the business. more than a reported 22 MMT
is supporting the efforts of the than 45 million kWh and GHG solely for this S&E project – the
city council in Dongguan, a emission reductions of more Supporting design of smart, equivalent of taking 4.8 million
major manufacturing hub in the than 33 thousand metric tons. efficient home products cars off the road.
Guangdong province of southern To further accelerate this work, The Smart & Efficient (S&E)
China, to launch a “Green Supply we’ve worked with the energy Home Products project
Chain” program. The goal of the
experts from EDF to train represents a major contributor
program is to promote sustainable
suppliers on the latest energy to Walmart’s goal of reducing
manufacturing practices that
reduce energy, conserve water
and reduce pollution in China.
To support this effort, Walmart
will be connecting our suppliers’ Making the switch to LEDs
factories in Dongguan with
technical training and insight from
This year, Walmart announced we ability to dim. For our customers,
EDF’s energy experts and other
are transitioning the assortment this means more affordable,
government officials to improve
of compact fluorescent light bulbs energy-efficient and longer-lasting
the efficiency of their facilities
(CFLs) to light-emitting diode bulbs bulbs.
and lower their environmental
(LEDs). Not only have LED prices
footprint.
come down dramatically over the
past five years to be comparable
with CFL bulbs, but also, testing
shows they outperform CFL
bulbs in features such as instant
brightness, light quality and the

68
Notes from the field: Challenges to reducing emissions in our operations
and supply chain
Weather countries and many states price of fossil fuels falls, investing Technological and
Weather conditions often within the U.S., our ability to in emission reductions in our behavioral change
work against our efforts to scale renewable energy projects own operations or in the supply Reducing emissions in our
reduce carbon emissions in is diminished because we’re chain may appear less financially operations and supply chain
our operations and supply not able to sign direct power viable in the short term. While requires continuous changes in
chain. With air temperature and purchase agreements (PPAs). some U.S. states and some technology and behavior. We
humidity correlating directly to We advocate for policies that countries have implemented cannot move toward a low-
energy demand, maintaining allow market-based solutions like carbon markets or tariff schemes, carbon economy by falling back
a pleasant indoor shopping or PPAs, which can lead to greater which put a value on carbon on the ways that things have
working experience in stores price certainty and cost savings. emissions and incentivize always been done. This is often a
or in manufacturing facilities Renewable energy installations lowering emissions, prices challenge as we introduce new
can be challenging. A severe or on roofs, parking lots or land are often volatile, vary widely equipment or processes that
prolonged winter will inevitably also require significant time by market and are at risk by require training, education or
lead to increased usage of to manage permitting rules changes in legislation. simply doing things differently.
natural gas and electricity to and regulatory relationships. In This can apply to anything
heat buildings, while heat waves the supply chain, producers of Offsetting growth from advanced refrigeration
can drive demand for electricity commodities look for a policy Walmart continually looks to equipment in our stores
to power air conditioning and environment that enables them expand our retail offerings requiring new maintenance
refrigerated equipment above to invest in technologies that worldwide, both in stores and procedures, as it does deep
normal levels. Weather can also reduce or convert farm emissions. online. This means more stores, in the supply chain in training
impact our ability to generate Policy also varies widely by clubs, data centers, distribution multi-generational farmers
electricity from renewable country, as emission reductions centers, suppliers, products and on climate-smart agricultural
sources such as wind and solar. strategies in some places are trucks to move products are practices. Furthermore, we need
Renewable energy systems viable without government added each year. In addition to technological innovations in
depend on natural flows, which incentives; in others, incentives building new facilities, we also the places that matter most.
can change throughout the like feed-in tariffs, subsidies and continue to expand grocery Much of our impact occurs in
year and over time, resulting crop insurance help make the offerings in many existing stores agriculture – from methane and
in variable rates of energy projects viable. Conversely, in around the world to meet the fertilizer-related emissions to
production from wind turbines some markets, local laws or demand for fresh and affordable deforested land conversion for
and rooftop solar arrays. import tariffs on renewable and food and produce. These food production. Technological
efficient technologies can slow remodels and expansions require innovation is needed at scale
Policy down project viability. more energy and use equipment to minimize these emissions,
Walmart believes that such as refrigerated cases and to convert them to uses such
businesses must have the Economics freezers. The combination of as anaerobic digestion and to
regulatory freedom to directly The current and projected long- new facilities, new equipment in increase production yields on
source electricity from project term price of fossil fuels is an existing facilities and increasing existing farm land to prevent
developers or independent important financial consideration sales volumes creates an uphill further deforestation.
power producers. In some in reducing emissions. When the battle on reducing absolute
carbon emissions.

69
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Toward a zero waste future

With the world’s population expected to reach 9 billion people our facilities every year, we aim not to generate any waste in
by 2050, the global waste problem is expected to grow as well, the process of getting things to customers. And if we can’t sell
unless we change course. The World Bank estimated that the a product, we don’t want it to wind up in a waste stream; we’d
world produced 3.5 million tons of solid waste per day in 2010, prefer to donate it, recycle it or reuse it in some way. To date,
and that amount is projected to double by 2025. That’s not we have made good progress – by the end of 2015, Walmart
simply a lot of trash, it’s a lot of lost value – as much as $2.6 trillion U.S. achieved 82 percent diversion of materials from landfill and
annually in raw materials and residual worth. Landfill waste is a diverted an average of 71 percent in international markets.*
double loss: wasted product, and wasted natural resources to As we have learned more about reducing waste in our own
produce the product in the first place. The world can’t afford to operations, we have embraced the concept of a “circular
use up water, forests, food, minerals, fossil fuels or any natural economy,” which moves away from a “take-make-dispose”
resource in this way. approach to one where products, their biological residue or
At Walmart, we’ve been attempting to reduce waste in our component parts, are cycled back into the economic stream. A
operations because we hate waste of any kind. Waste increases circular economy values the reuse and regeneration of materials
costs for our customers, our business and for society. As millions and energy, and it encourages product design and handling that
of tons of food, other products and packaging flow through minimizes total environmental impact across the life cycle.

Operations Packaging and products Recycling education and


infrastructure
*Based on review of material handling and waste diversion processes in the U.S., U.K., Chile, Central America, South Africa, Japan, Mexico, Canada, Brazil and Argentina, as reported by waste
vendors, food banks and stores. In cases where real numbers were not available due to industry challenges, they have been estimated based on industry-acceptable standards.

70
Accordingly, we have extended our zero waste aspiration Moving toward a zero waste future benefits business as well as
to include the whole supply chain, from farming and society. Eliminating operational waste avoids landfill fees and
manufacturing, consumption to end of life. Working with increases revenue from resale of salvaged materials. Reducing
suppliers, customers, nonprofit organizations and others, we're waste upstream, increasing recycled content and repurposing
drawing on our strengths – such as our store and logistics products can lower cost of goods and generate innovative
infrastructure, our philanthropy and our connection to products for customers. And in the long term, the preservation
customers – to pursue practical initiatives that will start to build of natural resources enhances supply security.
a more circular economy. To this end, we're asking suppliers to In the following section, we describe our progress on three main
design products with more recycled content, and with reuse strategies to move toward a zero waste future:
and recyclability in mind. We’re returning waste materials to
the production stream by taking back certain products from • Eliminating waste in our own operations
customers and helping suppliers convert waste. We’re also
• Promoting improvement in package and product design
collaborating with suppliers and the Walmart Foundation to
encourage communities to invest in recycling infrastructure • Expanding recycling through support for education and
through the Closed Loop Fund and other initiatives. improved infrastructure

How Walmart supports a circular economy

Support suppliers in Provide customers Expand recycling


production of products education and choice through support
designed for reuse, of products with for education and
recycling and cascading circular attributes improved infrastructure

Manufacture User Recycle

Design Retailer Reuse/Repair

Support innovations Eliminate waste and Provide customers


that design out waste recover materials in with tools and
our own operations programs that will help
them to maximize the
value of their goods

71
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Zero waste – waste

Toward a zero waste future: Progress against commitments


As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

Create zero waste across our global operations. Diverted from landfills 82 percent of materials previously
considered waste from Walmart U.S., and an average
71 percent from Walmart International.*
Eliminating waste in Reduce food waste in our emerging market stores Reduced food waste in our emerging market stores and
our own operations and clubs by 15% and in other markets by 10% by clubs by 15.3 percent (versus 2009 baseline); Although
December 31, 2015 (versus 2009 baseline). progress was made in Japan, the U.K. and the U.S., we
did not meet
the overall goal for other markets.

At the end of 2015, Walmart Eliminating waste in trade-in program. We also For example, in the U.S., in
U.S. diverted from landfills 82 provide diversion options for collaboration with Metrolina,
percent of materials previously our own operations customers in Chile and Brazil. we have launched a program
considered waste, with Walmart In South Africa more than 143 that encourages our customers
International diverting an As we drive toward our zero tons of post-consumer e-waste to bring used floral containers
average 71 percent.* waste goal, the first step is was diverted in 2015 through a and trays into Walmart Garden
to reduce the amount of collaboration with electronics Centers. Metrolina picks them
waste in the system. In our companies Samsung and up and recycles them, repur-
operations, we do this through DESCO. posing the recycled materials
a combination of diverting into new floral pots for Walmart.
and repurposing materials, We are exploring additional After a successful pilot in 2013,
measuring waste and reducing ways we can work together the program expanded in 2014
food waste. with manufacturers, recyclers and 2015 to now include 732
and other retailers to support stores. This year, we received
Diverting and solutions that will easily allow more than 1.4 million pounds
repurposing materials customers to recycle used of plastic containers and trays,
Globally, we recycle nearly products, with the goal of which Metrolina can use to
3 million tons of fiber and eventually being able to resell, create the equivalent of
In 2009, Walmart and Sam’s Club plastics annually. For our donate or repair them. 500,000 pots.
U.S. launched a first-of-its-kind customers, we’re increasing the
organics recycling program number of trade-in programs As we pursue our zero waste
nationwide. As of 2015, the we offer for hard-to-recycle goal, Walmart looks for ways
equivalent of more than 25,000 items like smartphones, tablets we can help “close the loop” –
tractor-trailers full of food waste and video games. Thus far, bringing waste materials back
has been diverted out of the waste we’ve collected more than into the production stream,
stream through composting, 100,000 mobile phones and working with suppliers to
conversion to animal feed and tablets through our U.S. store create new products.
energy production through
anaerobic digestion.

*Based on review of material handling and waste diversion processes in the U.S., U.K., Chile, Central America, South Africa, Japan, Mexico, Canada, Brazil and Argentina, as reported by waste
vendors, food banks and stores. In cases where real numbers were not available due to industry challenges they have been estimated based on industry acceptable standards.

72
Current waste flows at Walmart

Current waste flows at Walmart


Walmart Materials Management Program

Unsold Unsold
Trade-in products/packaging food

1 2 3

Recycling

Reuse Donation Animal Composting/


Refurbish to people feed anaerobic
Resale digestion
Closed loop

Last resort

Landfill/
incineration Ecoscraps®: From food
waste to garden growth

Measuring waste management system. This time, this platform will allow In 2015, Walmart began
Pursuing zero waste in our platform will allow our waste our waste vendors to track selling garden products from
Ecoscraps®, a company that turns
operations requires that we vendors to submit information their performance monthly
food scraps into organic and
work collaboratively with directly to Walmart, and it and annually, as well as identify sustainable lawn materials such
hundreds of waste vendors at provides us with a tool for areas for improvement and as compost, potting mixes and
the national and local levels quality control, identification potential innovation. plant foods. Our sales of these
around the world. Given the of discrepancies in data and products to date amount to
fragmentation of the waste and performance management. more than 2.4 million pounds
recycling industry, efficiently When the system is fully of food waste diverted from
coordinating with vendors implemented, every market landfills. Ecoscraps® are made in
and obtaining reliable data is and store manager will be able part with food waste recycled
paramount. To address this, to view and receive actionable from Walmart and enrich the
in 2015 we began a rollout data on their recycling and soil, helping our customers
grow healthier plants in a more
of a global integrated data donation performance. Over
sustainable way.

73
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Zero waste – food

Reducing food waste will need 60 percent more baseline. We’re happy to report
As the world’s largest grocer, food by 2050 to feed a growing we achieved this target, with a
we are especially concerned population. As a result, Walmart reduction of 15.3 percent. For
with reducing food waste. is working to prevent food from this specific goal we limited
According to the United entering the waste stream at categories to meat, produce
Consumers and food waste Nations, approximately all and to donate food that isn’t and bakery and defined food
one third of global food is sold to its highest and best use. waste as food that wasn’t sold
The Walmart Foundation is also wasted from production to When food can’t be donated, to our customers or donated
exploring ways to encourage consumption each year. That we’re redirecting it according for human consumption.
consumers to reduce their own equates to roughly $1 trillion to the U.S. Environmental
food waste. For example, through annually in wasted food value. Protection Agency’s Food For stores in developed markets
a grant of nearly $375,000 to the In the U.S. alone, the Natural Recovery Hierarchy by turning – located in Canada, Japan,
nonprofit organization Global Resources Defense Council it into animal feed, recovering the U.K. and the U.S. – we set a
Green, we’re supporting the estimates that consumers it as energy through anaerobic goal of a 10 percent reduction.
study of the factors that motivate
waste almost 2 million metric digestion or composting it. While we made progress, we
residents of multi-family dwellings
tons of food every year. have not fully reached this goal
to participate in food scrap recovery.
That’s equal to the weight of In 2010, we set a goal to reduce in all markets. In the U.K., food
500,000 commercial airplanes. food waste in our emerging waste reduction programs
All this waste poses a risk to market stores – located in have been established for
the world’s ability to feed a Argentina, Brazil, Central a number of years, and the
growing global population. America, Chile and Mexico biggest opportunities for
According to the World – by 15 percent by 2015 in reduction have already been
Economic Forum, the world comparison with our 2009 realized. In the U.S. and Canada,

Recovering food: A hierarchy of priorities

The U.S. Environmental Protection


Agency (EPA) created the Food
Recovery Hierarchy to help orga- Food Recovery Hierarchy Most preferred
nizations prioritize steps they can
take to prevent waste and divert Source Reduction
Source Reduction — Reduce the volume of surplus food

unused food. Each tier of the Food


Recovery Hierarchy focuses on Feed Hungry
Feed HungryPeople
People — Donate extra food to food banks, soup kitchens and shelters

different management strategies.


The top levels of the hierarchy Feed
FeedAnimals
Animals — Divert food scraps to animal feed

generate the most benefits for


the environment, society and the Industrial
IndustrialUses
Uses — Convert waste oils and food scraps into fuels or energy

economy. Walmart uses this hierar-


chy as a guide in our efforts to put Composting
Composting — Create a nutrient-rich soil amendment

food that might otherwise go to a


landfill to its highest and best use. Disposal
Disposal — Use landfill or incineration as last resort
Least preferred

74
our emphasis on providing implement what we’ve learned production and packaging,
fresh and affordable food to in the past five years: how through ordering or distribution
our customers meant that important it is to build a culture or during handling in the
we unintentionally increased focused on waste reduction, stores. This allows us to address
our food waste by rigorously to enlist the support of store problems in systemic ways and
discarding food that was leadership and to have a close the gaps at every stage
bruised or damaged in the standardized way of measuring as necessary. It will also enable
handling process. waste reduction across our us to continue reducing waste
entire organization. We’re also without compromising our
Going forward, we will developing an end-to-end commitment to delivering fresh
continue to pursue our targets perspective on the value chain food to customers.
in food waste reduction. to determine the point where
As we move ahead, we will food waste occurs, either in

Lessons learned in reducing food waste


Walmart’s efforts to reduce food now tracked on a daily basis. These and provide our associates a simple, to orders; and increased the engage-
waste have taught us some measures have helped Asda keep safe means of removing only the ment of store employees.
important lessons along the way. its food throwaway rate at the very broken eggs and consolidating the
low level of less than 1 percent in undamaged product into whole Work proactively upstream in the
Promote an organizational culture the last five years. cartons. As a result, this year we supply chain. As we have tried to
that is anti-waste. Our Asda prevented 37 million eggs from increase our offering of fresh food
business in the U.K. internally Use associate knowledge to change being thrown out. to customers, we've learned there
adopted a “We hate waste” culture internal processes. In the U.S., is more for us to do in working
and widely promoted it across Walmart store managers brought Provide consistent measurement with our suppliers proactively.
the organization. Merchandising to our attention that a large and tracking tools. Wal-Mart de We were primarily focused on
and operations teams set up food volume of perfectly good eggs was México introduced a food waste preventing waste once food
waste reduction objectives that placed in the organics bin because scorecard that allowed consistent reached our stores, when there are
were tracked and rewarded when we had to throw the whole carton measurement and tracking of prog- interventions we can make earlier in
progress was made. Every store away when a single egg was ress across the organization. Each the distribution process. We believe
now does a “waste parade” at broken. In response, Walmart’s store has a food waste reduction this is an opportunity for us to
the end of the work day, where operations and merchandising goal, and they monitor daily perfor- reduce food waste in the future, by
department managers present teams crafted two simple mance with this scorecard. Using working on solutions that consider
food which needs to be discarded solutions. First, they worked on a this information, they have formed the whole process of distribution
to store managers. They discuss ruggedized, shelf-ready, reusable a cross-department committee that from harvest to purchase.
what happened and suggest plastic container to transport and has introduced a series of reduction
alternatives to prevent waste going merchandise the eggs, which solutions that have improved the
forward. Trading, supply chain and reduced in-transit damage. Then, monitoring of refrigerated products
operational teams also have food we worked to introduce a process during deliveries, as well as overall
waste reduction goals that are to consolidate egg lots in stores logistics; helped with adjustments

75
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Zero waste – products and materials and packaging

Improving packaging of the Sustainability Index, during transit. At the same time, Increasing the use and
to factor reuse and recycling packaging has an important supply of recycled content
and product design possibilities into their designs. function in preserving and pro- We’re also working with
As we work to eliminate waste
tecting products and providing our suppliers to help them
in our operations, we also know
Some waste streams, such information to customers about incorporate more recycled
that, as a retailer, we have the
as electronic waste, present the product itself. content into their packaging
opportunity to engage with
particular challenges. As the materials. In 2014, we surveyed
suppliers and manufacturers
number of electronic devices While we’ve made significant nearly 100 Walmart suppliers
to encourage them to “design
sold every year increases with progress with our suppliers about their current and future
waste out” of the products sold
consumer demand, there is a in optimizing packaging, we use of various types of post-
in our stores and online. While
corresponding need to keep still have work to do. Now consumer recycled (PCR) plastic.
the primary responsibility to
such products out of landfills. that we have packaging key In 2015, we used the Index to
create sustainable products
These products often include performance indicators (KPIs) collect PCR content data for a
rests with our suppliers, we
toxic materials, like metals, that in our Sustainability Index, we range of material types. More
don’t want our customers
require special handling and can better measure and track than 1,200 brand manufacturers
to have to choose between
could be reused if recycled progress toward more sustain- across 28 product categories
affordability and sustainability
properly. able packaging design and responded, and we determined
when they purchase from us.
end of life initiatives. We’ve also an average of 23 percent of
Building on our implementation
That’s where designing been working with customers store shelf packaging contained
of the Sustainability Index with
products with the end in to better understand their PCR content.
our suppliers (see pg. 56), we
mind is critical. For example, expectations of, and challenges
are engaging with suppliers to:
Samsung recently launched around, packaging.
• Design products for a television that is easier to
end of life disassemble at the end of its
life, which was awarded ISRI’s Walmart recycled content in packaging by product sector

• Optimize packaging Design for Recycling® Award.


The television utilizes snap- The Sustainability Index includes Index to the question, “What
questions for suppliers that track percent of sales packaging has
• Increase the use together parts that eliminate
their performance in key indicators. post-consumer recycled content,
and availability of the use of many screws. The following chart shows the sustainable sourced renewable
recycled content The result is a product that’s results from the suppliers that content or recyclable content?”
easier to disassemble, recover, participated in the Sustainability
Designing for end of life and recycle at the end – a
As waste continues to grow fitting example of the circular Percent of
globally, it's becoming more economy at work. Sector post-consumer
important to design products recycled content
at the outset with their end in Optimized packaging Electronics 27
mind. This allows important Let’s face it – packaging is a
hassle. Unwieldy boxes, diffi- Food, beverage and agriculture 25
materials to be recycled back
into the value stream. While cult-to-open plastic clamshells, General merchandise 29
Walmart is not ultimately overflowing bubble wrap: Once Home and personal care 14
responsible for the design packaging is opened at home, it
can be challenging to determine Toys 40
of the products we sell, we
are actively encouraging our what to do with the materials * Does not reflect all products on Walmart shelves
suppliers, through the use needed to protect a product

76
The soft side of packaging
Clothing and shoes – which come apparel orders, which is available done in our footwear business.
in all shapes and sizes – present to our buyers, replenishment and Since 2013, we’ve transitioned 85
a particular challenge when it sourcing teams. Through using this million pairs of shoes from boxes
comes to using the right amount tool, we reduced the overall number to hangers. This reduces the overall
of packaging. Too much packaging of boxes we ship by 8.1 million packaging while taking up less
creates unnecessary waste, while compared with FY2015, while also space. The results have been clear:
too little can fail to appropriately saving nearly 6.3 million pounds Better space utilization, with 16
protect a product during transit of corrugate, preventing more than million pounds of corrugate saved;
and in stores. In our footwear and 7,800 MT of greenhouse gases more than 20,000 MT of greenhouse
apparel business, we’ve started to and eliminating $15.3 million in gases eliminated; and $9 million in
address this dilemma in two ways. operational costs. associated cost savings.
The path to optimized
First, we’ve created a tool to Additionally, we’ve looked for areas packaging: Asda’s
optimize the size of corrugated where we can reduce packaging “Packaging Den”
cardboard shipping cartons for our or remove it altogether – as we’ve
Finding the right kind of
packaging requires a balance
of customer and environmental
needs. In our Asda stores in the
U.K., some ready-to-cook poultry
Transforming bottles into apparel labels meals were receiving a high
number of complaints because
In 2015, we worked with our labels toward lower impact versions. the type of packaging used
supplier Avery Dennison, a global One of the label changes for our emitted an odor upon opening.
packaging company, to find a No Boundaries line eliminated
more sustainable option for the 29 million cotton-dyed fabric We took our customers’
fabric labels in our private label endfold labels and implemented feedback into our packaging
apparel lines. This collaboration new recycled content labels that innovation lab – the “Packaging
resulted in transitioning our No use 100 percent less water and Den” – to come up with a
Boundaries and Secret Treasures 32 percent less energy, emit 39 solution. Drawing from previous
apparel to use 100 percent recycled percent less greenhouse gases and success with a plastic film that
content labels, which are derived create 98 percent less solid waste could go directly into the oven,
from plastic bottles recycled into than the old label. we worked collaboratively with
PET polyester. During the year, this our packaging supplier to create
initiative transitioned 80 million a new pack where the customer
only has to pierce the film,
eliminating any odors and the
need to handle raw chicken. The
package cooks directly in the
oven and then can be recycled
after use.

77
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Zero waste – packaging and recycling

illio
n tons
of GHG e
mi
te from la ssion
Expanding recycling information to customers of pulp and paper products –
5 m s of was regarding what can – and ranked as a Sustainability Leader
7 n
an n to w local
jobs
lio 0 ne lion on waste dis
ndfi s
lls through education can’t – be recycled. The labels based on their scores in the
Crea s 27 m th

0 bil led mat


and improved
re

po
27 il

c e
Diver s mo

+
cy ria
also offer an opportunity to 2015 Sustainability Index. As
Pro s $1 0

ls
,

re
vid .9

sa
e

l
tes

es

infrastructure
Reduc
t

generate local conversation one of a few select suppliers,


e
Sav

Potential impact
about why a particular item Georgia-Pacific volunteered to
$100 Million Closed Loop Fund may not be recyclable, or why pilot with Walmart in the use
We’re also helping to guide it's only recyclable in certain of the How2Recycle label on
The Closed Loop Fund: our customers through areas. We're working with our Walmart and Sam’s Club private
Investing in recycling the complicated terrain of suppliers to incorporate these label packaging. The pilot has
infrastructure recycling and make it easier labels on Walmart and Sam’s resulted in the development of
to recycle through facilitating Club private label packaging internal processes and guidance
Created in 2014 by Walmart and improvements in recycling and encouraging national documentation to help future
the Walmart Foundation with a infrastructure. In 2015, brand suppliers to consider suppliers use the label, as well
coalition of 11 other corporate and Walmart U.S. joined Green using the label as well. as recycling communication
foundation partners, the Closed Blue’s Sustainable Packaging for our customers. Walmart
Loop Fund (CLF) aims to invest Coalition’s How2Recycle™ label This year we worked on using plans to expand the use of
$100 million over five years to boost program. These standardized the label with Georgia-Pacific – the How2Recycle label across
the amount of recycled materials packaging labels provide
available for manufacturing
one of the world’s leading more of its private label
consistent and transparent manufacturers and distributors products in 2016.
and to redirect food waste to
beneficial purposes. Through
no-interest and below-market
interest loans to municipalities
and private companies, CLF funds
projects to improve local recycling
infrastructure and boost recycling
rates, thereby increasing the value
that can be recovered through
recycling and returned to the
production stream.

In 2015, CLF closed its first round


of funding with an initial capital
investment of $7.8 million, which
led to an additional investment
of $17 million to support three
projects: a plastics recovery facility
Expanding recycling
in Baltimore, Md., plus municipal
recycling conversions from dual to
single stream in Quad Cities, Iowa, In a collaboration with Coca-Cola, separate PET packages in their
and Portage County, Ohio. Walmart Argentina launched homes and bring them to recycling
the “Optimism that Transforms” stations available at Walmart
program, which is aims at stores. In 2015, more than 100,000
increasing the recovery and kilograms of PET were collected for
recycling of PET. The program recycling.
encourages the community to

78
Notes from the field: Challenges in the pursuit of
zero waste
Economic volatility short term, using nonrecycla- commodities to buyers can be
Over the past two years, a drop ble materials while working for unpredictable. Public policies
in commodity prices severely longer-term recyclable options. regarding recycling protocols
hampered the worldwide and materials recovery around
market for recyclables. That Long-term thinking the world are also far from
drop caused many suppliers There may be short-term unified, and lack of consensus
to turn to less expensive tradeoffs and necessary on and use of industry labels
virgin materials, decreasing innovations needed for long- can leave customers often
the demand for recycled term successes. For example, confused about what can – and
feedstocks. keeping food fresher for can’t – be recycled. Additionally,
longer might require using the recycling industry lags in
Quality of materials a nonrecyclable package in technological innovation and
The quality of recycled mate- the short term. With a longer- data gathering, which could be
rials is often variable, due to term view, we are striving used to provide more accurate,
mixing of different types of ma- for innovative packaging targeted assessments and
terials and potential contami- and waste systems that will solutions at the local level.
nants in the recycling stream. improve both recyclability and
This can affect both price and food preservation.
availability of recycled materi-
als. When it comes to packag- Industry and policy
ing, optimization often requires fragmentation
balancing the type of materials Significant fragmentation exists
used to protect a product in the recycling industry and
against the potential damages its global infrastructure. Even
to that product. This might when sufficient demand for a
be adding more packaging to recycled commodity exists, the
protect the product or in the distribution of those recycled

79
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Preserving natural resources, especially


forests and water
The natural world has come under increasing stress from the
demands of a growing global population for food, clothing,
shelter, energy and livelihoods, among other things. Because our
survival as a species depends on natural resources, society faces a
collective imperative to preserve them.
While retail does not directly use significant natural resources
relative to other industries, product supply chains certainly do.
The Sustainability Index points to forests, water and land as scarce
natural resources that are particularly at risk due to farming and
manufacturing of consumer products. Forests
Walmart aspires to preserve natural resources through
conservation and restoration by working with suppliers, industry
forums, nonprofit organizations, farmers and governments in
business and philanthropic initiatives. We are collaborating
to improve farming, manufacturing and sourcing practices to
reduce environmental and social impact on forests, water and
land. We are also supporting direct conservation. Reshaping
supply chains requires collective action, and sustained progress
will require all of us to accelerate and increase our efforts.
In addition to being critically important for society, working on
this matters to our business in other ways – for supply security,
commodity costs and even reputation. Our customers, associates, Water
suppliers and other stakeholders care about preserving nature for
themselves as well as future generations.
The following section describes our progress in three of our
strategies to preserve natural resources:

• Getting to zero net deforestation

• Promoting a quality water supply

• Conserving land

Land

80
Preserving natural resources, especially forests and water: Progress against commitments
As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

By December 31, 2015, any palm oil used in Walmart Achieved, based on supplier reports; continuing efforts
private brand products around the world must to improve.
be sustainably sourced, in accordance with the
principles of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm
Getting to zero net Oil (RSPO).
deforestation Source only sustainable beef that is free of Amazon Achieved 100 percent participation of Walmart
deforestation by the end of 2015. Brazil’s beef suppliers in their Beef Risk Monitoring
System, helping to see that no beef sold at Walmart
Brazil contributes to the deforestation of the Amazon
Rainforest.

Gain increasing visibility over the next 10 years into Received supplier Sustainability Index responses
Promoting a quality key metrics regarding yields, water usage and GHG covering 77 percent of Walmart food business, giving us
water supply in food supply chains. more transparency into our supplier's ability to track and
report water usage.

To conserve one acre of wildlife habitat for every Protected >1 million acres (over 10 acres for every acre
Conserving land acre of land occupied by Walmart U.S. through Walmart has developed since 1962) through support to
2015. Acres for America.

81
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Preserving natural resources – forests

world. As part of our participa- mass balance (18 percent),


tion in the Consumer Goods identity preserved (1 percent),
Forum, (CGF) we are resolved to and GreenPalm certificates
achieve zero net deforestation (71 percent). We currently
by 2020. We are also a signatory accept all forms of RSPO-certified
to the New York Declaration on sustainable palm oil, with the
Forests, which calls for halving expectation that our markets
the rate of forest loss by 2020. and suppliers will move to more
Through these commitments, mass balance and segregated
Walmart is striving to reduce sustainable palm oil as it becomes
deforestation associated with accessible across the industry.
palm oil, soy, beef and pulp and
paper, and we have set goals We are exploring how we
related to our sourcing of each. can deliver greater impact in
keeping with our 2020 CGF
commitment. We’re looking at
Getting to zero net ways to move toward physical
deforestation certified sources of sustainable
palm oil, as well as how we
can support an industry-wide
Forests comprise an important
movement with our national
element of our planet’s ecosys-
brand suppliers as the industry
tems, offering habitat for animal
transitions to 100 percent
and plant life and absorbing
traceability.
carbon from the atmosphere.
Palm oil
But forests – especially delicate
In 2010, Walmart committed Beef
and diverse tropical rainforests –
to sustainably source any This year based on supplier-
are particularly vulnerable
palm oil used in its global reported data, we achieved
to agriculture and industry.
private brand products. We our goal that we would source
According to Conservation
are pleased to report that we beef that is free of Amazon
International, nearly half of the
have achieved this goal. Based deforestation by the end of
world’s forests have already
on data reported by suppliers, 2015. One hundred percent of
been lost, and continuing
100 percent of our private Walmart Brazil’s beef suppliers
deforestation accounts for
brand palm oil was sourced are now participating in our
11 percent of annual global
sustainably by the end of Beef Risk Monitoring System,
greenhouse gas emissions.
2015, in accordance with the which tracks, monitors
Recent studies also demon-
certification standards of the and promotes responsible
strate that certain agricultural
Roundtable on Sustainable ranching and sourcing of
commodities – notably palm
Palm Oil (RSPO). In FY2016 palm beef. Walmart Brazil uses the
oil, soy, cattle and timber – bear
oil was sourced through a mix monitoring program in their
responsibility for the majority
of segregated (10 percent), purchase orders to source beef
of deforestation around the

82
that does not contribute to We are exploring ways to Additionally, the singular focus
deforestation and that does not deepen transparency within by the Soy Moratorium on
originate from conservation our beef-monitoring system by preventing deforestation in the
units, indigenous lands or extending our reach to other Amazon has led to conversion
embargoed areas. As of January sensitive biomes, as well as by of other sensitive ecosystems
2016, the System currently establishing further traceability. in Brazil, such as the Cerrado.
includes more than 52,000 The moratorium also does not
registered farms and analyzes include provisions for social
more than 200,000 types of issues, such as the protection
data to inform our orders, to of indigenous lands or worker
better clarify that no beef health, safety and livelihood.
comes from deforested areas. Walmart will continue to work
to promote the extension of
Despite this progress, we the Soy Moratorium through
recognize that there are still engagement with our supply
major risks of deforestation chain, while also attending to
within our beef supply. These Soy its unintended consequences in
include: The CGF has identified soy as the Amazon region.
one of the commodities for its
• Indirect purchases. Before cattle members to source through
arrive at the slaughterhouse, it deforestation-free channels.
is possible that they might be Walmart is working collectively
traded from high-risk ranches through CGF and with our
to “approved” ranches or supply chain to achieve this
slaughterhouses. target. Along with other
retailers and suppliers operating
• Administrative loopholes. in Brazil, we supported the Soy
Ranchers who contribute Moratorium and supported
to deforestation can simply its extension during the last Pulp and paper
re-register their operations renewal cycle in 2014. Before In accordance with our
under different names to the moratorium was enacted, 2020 commitment to zero
access clean supply chains. 30 percent of Brazilian soy net deforestation, we’re
came from deforested areas. encouraging our paper
• Leakage. The cattle Since the moratorium, that and packaging suppliers to
agreements cover only amount has fallen to about provide credible assurance
activity in the Brazilian 1 percent. Recent analysis by that products are sourced
Amazon, which leaves other the University of Wisconsin- sustainably.
sensitive ecosystems in Brazil Madison shows that, while
and neighboring countries no longer clearing forest to
open to deforestation. plant soy, some farmers have
merely switched to other crops.

83
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Preserving natural resources – water

Promoting a quality we estimate that more than the efficiency of our water
20 percent of our operations use in our facilities around the
water supply around the world are, or will be, world. For example, Wal-Mart
located in regions facing high de México, one of our largest
Compared with other industries levels of water stress. We are operations, plays a leading
– like mining, manufacturing actively working to preserve the role in water stewardship in
and agribusiness – that extract quality and quantity of water our company. We have water
and consume large quantities available by focusing on: initiatives in operation and
of water, retail uses relatively under development in multiple
little water directly. At the same • Improving efficient water use locations, and, in 2015, we
time, the products we sell – in our own operations increased our number of on-site
especially food – can require water treatment plants to 1,040.
Saving water in the significant water to produce. • Supporting water quality and These plants helped us treat
garden center For example, nearly 70 percent efficient use in supply chains and reuse 32 percent (1.8 million
of the world’s consumption of cubic meters) of our wastewater
During peak growing season, fresh water goes to agriculture, Water use in our operations for toilets and irrigation.
Walmart’s garden centers hold according to the United Nations. Walmart’s approach to Additionally, our Japanese
an average of 12,000 plants, each The world’s water systems are promoting a quality water business, Seiyu, reduced water
of which requires 15-20 seconds increasingly depleted, and supply includes maximizing consumption in 2015 by 30
to properly water. With so much
time and water going into
irrigation, we looked for a way to
cut both, and discovered one in
the irrigation mats produced by
WaterPulse. After a pilot program Ducks Unlimited: Improving water conservation on U.S. rice farms
to replace our hose-based system
revealed that we could cut our committed to wetland and wells fitted for precision water
previous daily water usage of waterfowl conservation. With a delivery. DU will also introduce the
20,000-30,000 gallons – as much $1 million grant from the Walmart practice of using “alternative wet
as the volume of an average Foundation, DU will work with 200 and dry” (AWD) cycles, where
backyard swimming pool – down rice farms – representing 75,000 the rice crop is irrigated in pulses.
to 400 gallons a day. In July 2015, acres of land – over two years to Research indicates that these
Walmart announced plans to adopt water conversation and practices can lead to a reduction in
implement these irrigation mats nutrient management practices. water use and GHG emissions.
in all garden centers. These include improving irrigation Additionally, DU will utilize this grant
Founded by sportsmen in 1937, through installing water control to fund analysis of the cost-benefit
Ducks Unlimited (DU) has been a structures at drainage points and of conservation investments.
leading nonprofit organization developing irrigation pumps and

84
percent, compared with 2010, promoting water availability,
through a variety of strategies especially in water-stressed
ranging from installing water- regions. Additionally, fertilizer
saving shower nozzles and runoff from agriculture into
handles for store kitchens, to waterways accounts for a major
defrosting frozen items in the source of pollution affecting
refrigerator. Throughout our fish and wildlife populations,
other facilities, we are continuing as well as making water more
to explore and implement difficult to treat for human
innovative methods for consumption. Walmart is
promoting efficient water use. working with suppliers to
improve water efficiency and
Enhancing water efficiency fertilizer usage in the supply
in our supply chain chain. (See pg. 66 for details
Since agriculture accounts for of our work on row crops and
approximately 70 percent of fertilizer use.)
global freshwater consumption
each year, water efficiency
in agriculture is central to

The roof way to conserve water Conserving water in California

launched this project to advance Despite its role as the largest part of our annual evaluations.
the scientific understanding of grower of produce and nuts in Through this annual evaluation
eco-roof performance in the the U.S., the state of California process, we are able to challenge
greater Portland area, especially suffers from frequent droughts suppliers who are water-intense
regarding rainfall runoff and long-term water stress. This to become more efficient and
management, energy conservation reality threatens the livelihoods we are able to strengthen our
and habitat creation. The design of growers there, as well as relationships with suppliers who
for the eco-roof resulted from the availability of key items for are good water stewards. Since
collaboration led by Walmart, P+R our customers. Last year, our California will continue to be an
Photo credit: PACLA Photo
Architects, Roofmeadow, Portland Global Food Sourcing team essential source of produce and
State University, the Audubon worked with our produce nuts in coming years, sustainable
At 40,000 square feet, the Hayden Society of Portland and the and nut suppliers in California water management is critical
Meadows Walmart store in Portland Bureau of Environmental to strengthen the suppliers’ to supporting the well-being
Portland, Ore., currently has the Services. The project received a water stewardship efforts. We of California communities and
largest, most intensively monitored Sustainable Gold Award from the established a process to review maintaining a secure supply of
eco-roof in the United States, as International Council of Shopping Supplier Index performance high-quality produce and nuts
confirmed by Roofmeadow, an Centers for excellence in and water stewardship plans as for our customers.
eco-roof consultant. Walmart innovation and creativity.

85
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Preserving natural resources – land

Conserving land

In addition to our efforts to reduce


deforestation and promote water con-
servation, Walmart has been a leader in
land conservation for the past 10 years.
Land conversion is largely driven by food
production and the demand to feed the
growing population. To help prevent land
conversion, we are working with suppliers
and nonprofits to create more transparen-
cy to farm yields and to work on contin-
uous improvement. (see pg. 98 for more
information).

Through a collaboration with the National


Fish and Wildlife Foundation (NFWF), in
2005 Walmart helped establish the Acres
for America program to conserve lands of
national significance, protect critical fish The Green River in western Wyoming flows through ranchland permanently protected by Acres for America,
a conservation program funded by Walmart and led by the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation.
and wildlife habitat and benefit people (Photo credit: Rita Donham, Wyoming Aero Photo)
and local economies. The priorities of the
program have included: America program has conserved more • Provided nearly $4 million in emergency
than 10 acres of vital habitat for every acre response funding to protect fish and
• Conserving critical habitats for birds, fish, of land Walmart has developed since the wildlife that were immediately threatened
plants and wildlife company was founded in 1962. Not only by the Gulf of Mexico oil spill in 2010 and
has our goal been achieved, but also, it Hurricane Sandy in 2012
• Connecting existing protected lands to has been exceeded by a factor of 10. In
unify wild places and protect migration its first 10 years, the Acres for America • Restored urban lands and habitats
routes program has: and connected youth to the outdoors
by investing more than $1.5 million in
• Providing access for people to enjoy the • Protected more than 1 million acres – an community-based projects located in
outdoors area comparable in size to Grand Canyon New York, Chicago, Los Angeles, San
National Park Diego, Denver, Bridgeport, Portland (Ore.),
• Projecting the future of local economies Albuquerque and Washington, D.C.
that depend on forestry, ranching and • Connected over 10 million acres of
recreation protected lands to support landscape- In November 2015, we announced with NFWF
scale conservation and wildlife a 10-year, $35 million renewal of this program
The program’s original goal was to migration to continue its exceptional work for another
permanently conserve one acre of wildlife decade.
habitat for every acre of land developed by • Funded 67 projects in 35 states, the
Walmart stores – approximately 100,000 District of Columbia and Puerto Rico
acres total. As of today, the Acres for

86
Conserving critical habitats in the U.S. Acres for America projects
Acres for America projects
In 2015, Acres for America Conservancy, while the others will
issued six grants to conservation be overseen by the Conservation
organizations that range from Fund, the Trust for Public Land and
$250,000 to more than $1 the Georgia Department of Natural
million each. These grants will Resources.
fund projects that support the
reintroduction of elk in West “As we embark on a new, decade-
Virginia, the conservation of long commitment to conservation
important wildlife habitats on between NFWF and Walmart, this
ranch lands in Montana and slate embodies what this effort
Colorado, as well as tracts of can accomplish,” said Jeff Trandahl,
forest in Georgia, Arkansas and executive director and CEO of
Massachusetts. In total, these NFWF. “The acres that these six
projects will conserve wildlife grants will protect contain some
habitat across more than 118,000 of the best habitat in the country
acres. Three of the grants will and will help maintain recreational,
be administered by the Nature forestry and ranching economies.”

Notes from the field: Challenges to preserving natural resources

Transparency in the time, but we’re working to themselves. But there is often years, with water rates likely
supply chain understand common issues, considerable pressure on all increasing and regulations
Like other retailers, Walmart help suppliers better understand parties, including governments, growing tighter, Walmart is
does not typically have a Walmart’s expectations for to develop 100 percent of well-positioned to effectively
relationship with the producers safe working conditions available land for production. manage costs and operational
of many agricultural commodities, and share best practices for Such pressure can make efficiencies. Further, our use of
which makes visibility and sourcing procedures. behavioral change difficult smart technology and industry
transparency difficult. Because throughout the sector. best practices helps us reduce
of this difficulty, the source Pressure to develop land water usage and adopt new
of products within the global To have an impact on the farm Water pricing measures that make sense for
commodity supply chain is often requires working with our The significant underpricing our operations going forward.
limited, making it challenging suppliers, commodity traders, of water in many geographies
to pinpoint where issues may producer associations and, in lowers the financial payback of
arise. Improvements will take some instances, the growers water projects. In the coming

87
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Spotlight on

sustainability in the food supply chain

Global food initiatives


Walmart and the Walmart Foundation support programs
that enhance food sustainability, including the following
Energy and emissions Zero food waste Training
Natural resources
Reducing emissions in food Eliminating food waste in our Getting to zero net deforestation
supply chains operations, supply chain and and promoting a quality water
with customers supply

North America South America

Brazil
seafood
beef
soy
palm oil
Canada produce
beef
palm oil
produce Argentina
seafood produce
U.S.
beef Chile
chicken Central beef
corn Mexico America palm oil
eggs palm oil palm oil produce
pork produce produce seafood
produce seafood seafood
soy
wheat

88
Food security and health Transparency and quality Safety and dignity of workers
Providing access to affordable, Promoting transparency, food Promoting responsible sourcing
sustainable and healthier food safety and animal welfare in our practices in the global supply chain
products for customers

Africa East Asia


Morocco Nepal
fruit dairy
Burkina Faso
rice
Ghana
cashews
rice
Nigeria Japan
cashews produce
rice Kenya China seafood
palm oil
Rwanda flowers
produce
corn produce
talapia
beans Tanzania
dairy flowers Thailand
produce fruit India shrimp
rice palm oil
Zambia produce
South Africa cotton
palm oil
peanuts
produce
soy
Indonesia
seafood palm oil
wine Bangladesh
dairy

89
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Providing access to affordable, sustainable


and healthier food
According to the World Economic Forum the global population and distribution relationships with food producers and suppliers
will reach 9.5 billion people by 2050, which will increase global around the world, billions of dollars in food purchase orders, our
demand for food by 60 percent. stores and logistics network, as well as our philanthropy – to
To meet this demand in a sustainable way, the world will require collaborate with others to bring about significant and lasting
substantial improvements in food production and distribution, as improvements in the food system.
well as significant reductions in food waste. While technological Our food initiatives strengthen our business as well as help
advances have improved yields in agriculture, fisheries and address social and environmental challenges in the food chain.
aquaculture, there is much more to do to generate sufficient Food is Walmart’s biggest business: We have over 260 million
quantities in a way that is restorative for nature, farmers and customers around the world, and many turn to us to feed
fishers. And once that food is produced, the challenge remains themselves and their families. Our initiatives help us serve them
of getting it to the people who need it, in a way that doesn’t better – expanding access, increasing availability, reducing prices
make them pick between an affordable price and a sustainable and price volatility, broadening the assortment, improving quality
and healthier choice. Finally, according to the United Nations, – resulting in stronger sales and customer loyalty.
approximately one-third of global food is wasted each year. Walmart has five main areas of focus in promoting the security of
Reducing that waste could unlock a big part of the global food the world’s food supply:
supply-and-demand challenge – but achieving this will require
systematic changes to behavior and infrastructure. • Increasing access to affordable food
Walmart aspires to help create a more affordable, accessible, • Relieving hunger
sustainable and healthy food system. To do so, we have major
initiatives underway involving farmers, fisheries, agronomists, • Enhancing nutrition
development agencies, food manufacturers, environmental
• Increasing the food supply through waste reduction
nonprofits, food banks, nutritionists, schools, community groups,
government agencies and producer associations, among others. • Improving sustainable food production
We aim to use our strengths – our expertise in food production

Food access Hunger relief Better nutrition Less food waste More sustainable
production

90
Providing access to affordable, sustainable and healthier food: Progress against commitments
As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

Increasing access to Open between 275 and 300 stores serving USDA- Opened 442 stores serving USDA-designated food
affordable food designated food deserts by 2016. deserts, net of any closures.

Provide 4 billion meals to those who need them Provided nearly 2 billion meals to date, based on
from 2015 to 2020 through grants from Walmart donations of 1.2 billion pounds of food from Walmart
and the Walmart Foundation and food donations facilities and $122 million in funds from Walmart and the
Relieving hunger from our Walmart stores, Sam’s Clubs and Walmart Foundation; this includes FY16 donation of 611
distribution centers. million pounds of food and $61 million in funds.

Engage associates and customers in hunger relief Associates volunteered more than 130,000 hours toward
efforts. hunger relief efforts around the U.S.

Improve the nutritional quality of our private Reduced sodium by 18 percent and reduced added
brands, including our Great Value brand and sugars by > 10 percent across private and national
national food brands in the U.S. By the end of 2015, brands. Eliminated all industrially produced trans fats
compared with 2008 baseline, reduce sodium from our private brand products; 6 percent of national
by 25 percent and added sugars by 10 percent; brand products still contain trans fats.
remove industrially produced trans fats.

Develop a Great for You label, a front-of-pack seal to Rolled out the Great For You icon in stores in 2013, to
help U.S. customers quickly identify more nutritious highlight fresh produce, meat and qualifying private
choices. brand packaged foods.

Enhancing nutrition Investment by Walmart and the Walmart Supported nutrition education for nearly 1.9 million
Foundation in programs providing nutrition people.
education to 4 million people from 2015 through
2020).

Save U.S. customers approximately $1 billion per Saved customers $1.36 billion in FY2016, for a total of
year on fresh fruits and vegetables, and reduce or more than $6 billion over the last five years; reduced
eliminate price premiums on key better-for-you price premium on better-for-you items to 3.9 percent,
items. compared with 4.5 percent last year.

Double sales of locally sourced produce sold Achieved; more than doubled our sales of local produce
between 2009 and end of 2015. (from $404 million to $825 million).

Reduce food waste in our emerging market stores Reduced food waste in our emerging market stores and
Increasing the food supply and clubs by 15 percent and in other markets by clubs by 15.3 percent (versus 2009 baseline); Although
through waste reduction 10 percent by December 31, 2015 (versus 2009 progress was made in Japan, the U.K. and the U.S., we
baseline). did not meet the overall goal for other markets.

continued...

91
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Food – increase access, reduce waste

Providing access to affordable, sustainable and healthier food: Progress against commitments
continued
As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

Gain increasing visibility over the next 10 years into Suppliers covering 77 percent of our food business
key metrics regarding yields, water usage and GHG responded to the Index and reported GHG emissions
in food supply chains. Foster improvements in food for 46 percent, water usage for 28 percent and yield for
yields, water efficiency and GHG emissions through 34 percent of their supply.
special projects and continuous improvement.
Endorse Beef Quality Assurance Program and Helped found the U.S. Roundtable for Sustainable Beef,
work with NCBA to deliver environmental Best which developed a set of indicators for the U.S. beef
Management Practices in the U.S. beef supply supply chain.
chain.
Work with packers, feed yards and ranchers in the Developing a regional beef pilot in the Southeastern
Improving sustainable
U.S. to develop a transparency pilot for 15 percent U.S., together with our suppliers, NGOs and social impact
food production
of Walmart’s U.S. supply by 2023 to establish investors.
environmental best practices and quality standards
for customers.
Encourage suppliers to develop fertilizer On track to eliminate an estimated 9 million metric tons
optimization plans for 14 million acres of U.S. of GHG emissions and to engage an estimate 23 million
farmland by 2020 acres.
Provide funding through Walmart and the Walmart Awarded grants to provide training to an estimated
Foundation to train 1 million farmers and farm 875,000 farmers, more than 500,000 of whom are women.
workers, of which half will be women, in emerging
markets by the end of 2016.

Increasing access to million customers come to us for a Healthier America to open


for affordable, healthier food to 300 additional stores serving
affordable food feed their families. We’re work- USDA food deserts by 2016.
ing to provide greater access to Since the beginning of our goal,
Even where food is plentiful, food through expanding our we've opened and continue
it can remain inaccessible due retail distribution network and to operate 442 stores serving
to lack of income, geographic through our online pickup and USDA-designated food deserts.
barriers or because of poor delivery service.
distribution networks. We also know that our customers
Last year in the U.S., we also sur- want access to fresh local produce
Food is Walmart’s biggest passed our 2011 commitment and support the growers in their
business. Many of our 260 made as part of the Partnership community. In 2010, we set an

92
ambitious goal to double our We buy and sell watermelons $1 billion per year on fresh fruits
sales of locally grown produce from more than half the states. and vegetables. In 2015, we
in the U.S. grown and sold in the Sweet potatoes are a favorite saved customers $1.36 billion
same state by the end of 2015. in our home state of Arkansas. on fresh produce, taking total
We increased our local corn savings to $6 billion since 2012.
We’re proud to report that we sales by 97 percent in the Great We are also reducing the cost
have accomplished our goal. Lakes states. Looking forward, of “better-for-you” items relative
We have increased our sales we will continue to offer a wide to traditional items. Based on
of local produce from $404 assortment of fresh, locally Walmart U.S. pricing data, in
million to $825 million, including sourced produce items to our 2011, a Walmart-selected better-
strawberries from Florida, customers around the country. for-you item cost 5.7 percent
tomatoes from North Carolina, more, on average, than the
watermelons and greenhouse We’re also working to make traditional version. At the end of
tomatoes from Texas and fresh food more affordable by 2015, that average premium was
potatoes from Washington. saving customers more than reduced to 3.9 percent.

Walmart and Feeding America


To reach our goal of providing improvement and education. a project called Google advice on the ways that food
4 billion meals to individuals in Here are some of the highlights SNAP, which connects those banks can increase their
need by 2020, Walmart and the of this collaboration: searching for SNAP benefits on efficiency, and, through grant
Walmart Foundation have formed the internet to local food banks funds, a select number of
a strategic collaboration with Retail Store Donation Program. that can assist them with their food banks receive financial
Feeding America (FA). Drawing on Since 2009, the Foundation
FA’s national scale and capacity, as
application. resources to implement the
has donated funding to recommended changes.
well as their community presence secure more than 225 trucks
through member food banks Fight Hunger Spark Change. In
and 37 retail store donation 2015, Walmart, our suppliers Education. Each year FA
and agencies, this work allows
us to implement nationwide
coordinators to manage, and customers worked partners with the Food
programs, while also engaging capture and distribute food together to raise and donate Research and Action Center to
local associates and reaching donated from Walmart and $10.7 million in funds – making host the Anti-Hunger Policy
local communities. Walmart and other retailers across the U.S. Walmart FA’s largest cause Conference, which gathers
the Walmart Foundation have marketing supporter. With anti-hunger advocates to
provided nearly $75 million to FA SNAP Outreach and Application this success, Walmart and our discuss policy issues relating to
since FY2006 to provide charitable Assistance. Since FY2013, the suppliers launched another federal nutrition programs and
meals, increase access to federal Foundation has provided
nutrition programs (breakfast,
Fight Hunger Spark Change tax policy. The Foundation’s
funding to FA to be distributed campaign in April 2016. support of FA helps offset
afterschool and summer meals), to local food banks for SNAP
SNAP outreach and application some of the costs associated
application assistance. FA has Food Bank Efficiency. Walmart with the conference.
assistance, infrastructure
also piloted and expanded logistics associates provide

93
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Food – increase access, reduce waste

Relieving hunger reaching for this goal through Extending the reach of
a combination of grants to hunger relief programs
charitable organizations and The Walmart Foundation is
Hunger is reality for many hunger relief programs, as well investing in scaling access to
families, and they face barriers as through food donations federal nutrition programs such
to getting enough healthy from our Walmart stores, as the Supplemental Nutrition
food to thrive. In the U.S. alone, Sam’s Clubs and distribution Assistance Program (SNAP), as
the USDA estimates that more centers. In FY2016, Walmart well as programs that reach
than 48 million Americans face and the Walmart Foundation children with breakfast, after-
Year-round meals for food insecurity – the inability to contributed more than school or summer meals. This
children at the YMCA access food on a regular, pre- $61 million in funding to year the Walmart Foundation
dictable basis. To help address organizations working to invested more than $15 million
According to the USDA, only 14 this problem, we are working to alleviate hunger. helping to connect people with
percent of the 22 million children strengthen the charitable meal
who participate in free or reduced
federal SNAP benefits, with an
system and to extend the reach Our primary aim is to strengthen additional $21 million support-
meals through the National School
of hunger relief programs. the charitable food system as a ing children’s hunger programs.
Lunch Program continue to receive
free or reduced-cost meals during whole by building capacity and
their summer break. To address this Strengthening the developing infrastructure within
gap, the Walmart Foundation is charitable meal system organizations working in hunger
working with the YMCA to provide Walmart and the Walmart relief. This approach deepens
15 million meals and snacks to Foundation have committed local connections with commu-
480,000 children after school to providing 4 billion meals nities, allows for swift response
and during the summer at YMCA between 2015 and 2020 to in emergencies and promotes
locations across the U.S. those who need them. We’re scalable relief solutions.

Supporting the hunger relief system in Canada


In 2015, the Walmart Foundation FBC will pilot a capacity-building school-based breakfast programs.
issued grants of $1.5 million each to program designed to expand its The Walmart Foundation’s grant
two Canadian relief organizations – retail food recovery program, es- will help BCC provide 27 million
Food Banks Canada (FBC) and the pecially through the acquisition of school breakfast meals and sup-
Breakfast Clubs of Canada (BCC) refrigerated trucks and commercial port the ongoing operations of
– with the goal of strengthening refrigerated storage equipment. 1,455 existing breakfast programs
the capacity and response of the FBC will also develop its technical across Canada, as well as open
nation’s hunger relief system. infrastructure to improve efficiency 40 new school breakfast loca-
in routing and delivery, as well as tions. The funds will also facilitate
FBC targets Canadians living with work with retailers on best practic- equipment upgrades and the
food insecurity and supports a net- es in food handling. improvement of fundraising tools
work of 10 provincial associations, and evaluation programs.
550 affiliate food banks and 3,000 BCC focuses on feeding school-
food agencies that assist nearly 10 age children in low-income
million people annually. With the neighborhoods across Canada,
Walmart Foundation’s support, taking a long-term approach to

94
our sodium reduction stood by 2020. The work is focused
at 18 percent, while we’ve on encouraging people
maintained the percent to prepare meals at home
reduction in added sugars. and increase their fruit and
Additionally, we eliminated vegetable consumption, both
all industrially produced trans of which are part of an overall
fats from our private brand healthy lifestyle. This focus
products two years ahead of includes classes on cooking,
the FDA mandate, and only building shopping skills or
6 percent of our national helping families make the most
brand products still contain of healthy food resources. In
these trans fats. While we 2015, Walmart and the Walmart
came up short of our goal Foundation contributed $14.9
in reducing sodium, we’ve million to nutrition education
learned important lessons in efforts, for a total of $24.9
reformulating products without million since the program was
sacrificing the quality and taste announced. In the last year alone,
our customers expect. We will our investment helped bring
Enhancing nutrition more affordable and easier for continue to pursue progress in better nutrition tools and tips
customers to identify. We’re also this area through innovation, to nearly 970,000 people. Since
helping educate families about and we’re excited about the we initiated our commitment in
With the rates of obesity and nutritious eating and providing
nutrition-related illnesses precedent we’re setting across 2014, nearly 1.9 million people
tools to help them plan and eat the grocery industry. More have been reached.
rising around the world, health in healthier ways.
advocates and officials are than 30 percent of our private
calling for healthier eating brands continue to carry our In October 2015, Walmart
Nutritional quality Great For You icon, which launched “America’s Biggest
options and better public Since 2008, we’ve been
education on nutrition. makes it easier for customers Health Fair” in our U.S. stores
working to remove – from to identify more nutritious as a way to improve customer
According to the World Health both national and our private
Organization, in 2014 nearly options. The standards for these access to health and wellness
brands – ingredients that aren’t products were developed opportunities. Customers
2 billion adults qualified as necessary or that health experts
overweight, and more than with experts and are based on received, among other things,
indicate can cause significant scientific and governmental free blood pressure, blood
600 million as obese. Walmart health issues – things like
is doing our part to help make recommendations. glucose and vision screenings.
sodium, sugar and trans fats. In all, we conducted nearly
healthier food options both We set goals that, by the end
accessible and affordable in Educating about nutrition 300,000 screenings, 50,000
of 2015, we would remove all Walmart and the Walmart immunizations and distributed
the U.S. In support of the industrially produced trans
White House’s Partnership for Foundation are helping educate almost 2 million product
fats, reduce sodium by 25 families about healthier food samples over a four-hour period.
a Healthier America, we’ve percent and added sugars by
made commitments to and lifestyle choices through
10 percent. At the end of investment in nutrition
improve the nutritional quality 2015, and at the conclusion
of the food we sell and offer education programs, with a
of our five-year commitment, goal to reach 4 million people
healthier food choices that are

95
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Food – increase access, reduce waste

FoodCorps: Bringing healthy eating to children


FoodCorps, a nationwide team of school children of the Navajo Will nevertheless persisted in his
AmeriCorps leaders who educate Nation, at the Johns Hopkins efforts, and brought local tribal
children about healthy eating, Center for American Indian Health leaders into the program to help
received a $1.2 million grant from Feast for the Future Program, educate the children both in
the Walmart Foundation in 2015. in Tuba City, Ariz. In his early agriculture and in their native
Helping customers With this support, FoodCorps will efforts to source the local school customs. “I decided to devote a
help themselves provide the training and resources cafeteria through a local farm, he plot at the community farm my
needed to help children in 500 encountered some frustrating service site manages to education.
schools, across 16 states and the roadblocks. “I initially felt At the plot, children ranging
In October 2012, Walmart and District of Columbia, to access frustration for my inability to find a from pre-k to 6th grade planted
HumanaVitality launched a important nutrition education. The viable farm to source the cafeteria. native corn, melons and beans
first-of-its-kind effort to help programs build off the USDA My I soon learned that local farmers using traditional tools under the
customers in the U.S. save money Plate curriculum, which teaches do not sell their crops because guidance of a local elder and
on more nutritious foods. The kids about healthy food, initiates they did not view the land as farmer. The elder taught the
effort represented the first national the building and tending of school something to profit off of. Rather, youth the role of corn in the Hopi
program where a major retailer gardens and brings locally sourced they grew crops to maintain their creation story and the importance
and health care company came food from farms into school traditional lifestyles and shared of preserving the corn seeds
together to offer incentives for cafeterias. their harvests with friends and native to Tuba City. Standing in
people to make more nutritious families. Despite considering myself this field in the Painted Desert and
food choices. This ongoing “Vitality As a FoodCorps member, Will an environmentalist I realized watching the kids carefully drop
HealthyFood” program rewards Conway sees the real potential that I, unlike the native farmers, the correct amount of seeds into
Humana members with a discount that garden-based education has viewed farming as a profit-driven the earth, I realized that this is the
on Great For You items at Walmart on the way children eat and on enterprise. This was an eye- difference that FoodCorps makes
stores across the country. the relationship they have with opening moment for me.” in communities.”
food. He works among elementary

The easy way to better health: The ZP Challenge

Beginning in 2013, Walmart chance to win a prize and gain nutrition, better relationships and
developed a next-generation recognition. Submitted stories more regular physical activity. In
well-being program called and selected champions have 2016, our ZP journey continues
the ZP Challenge, which helps their success celebrated, which with the introduction of the ZP
people make better choices in serves as a catalyst for others to app, the first digital version of
the areas of fitness, food, family join the program. This approach the ZP Challenge, which has
and money. Open to Walmart has resulted in over 700,000 the capability of extending the
associates and their families and participants from every state and program to interested business
friends, the Challenge solicits Puerto Rico offering stories of how units around the world.
stories from participants who they have adopted healthier habits
complete a ZP Challenge for the and have experienced improved

96
terminology. We did this for all
private branded items suppliers
make for Walmart or Sam’s
Club, including those labeled
in-store, unless a food safety
or regulatory reason might
prevent us from doing so. As
of February 2016, 92 percent
of Walmart qualifying private
brand products have adopted
this new label, or have started
to transition to its use. We
expect the remainder of our
qualifying products to transition In the eye of the beholder:
by July 2016. The “Best If Used Promoting “imperfect”
By” terminology was poll-tested produce in the U.K.
with our customers in the U.S.,
as well as in other industry and Our Asda business decided
Increasing the food • Funding efforts to recover consumer surveys, and it was to help educate customers
food before it enters the found to best convey that the about the produce nobody
supply through waste stream wanted – the imperfect pear or
date on a food package refers
waste reduction to quality and freshness – not misshapen carrot that always was
Utilizing whole crops overlooked. Through discounted
safety. With these changes to
A significant portion of food prices, as well as their own bags
According to the United our labels, and the reduction and merchandising sections
waste occurs upstream in in food waste they facilitated,
Nations, about one-third of the called “Beautiful on the Inside,”
our supply chain. While many we were able to eliminate
food the world produces goes Asda set out to offer customers
factors contribute to this, one an estimated 660 million
uneaten, much of it thrown tips for choosing “unsightly”
of them is food that does not pounds of food waste and an produce and better value for
away by customers at home,
meet the high aesthetic quality estimated 900,000 metric tons their money. The campaign also
by grocery stores or restaurants
specifications that retailers strive of greenhouse gas emissions. helped Asda reduce unnecessary
or somewhere else in the
for. We are working with our food waste and support farmers
production and distribution
suppliers to find ways to utilize Donating unsold food through selling almost 1,000 tons
process. To help address this
whole crops and reduce this When food goes unpurchased of perfectly good produce. While
wasteful use of food and Walmart helps suppliers in many
particular form of food waste. by consumers, we work to
increase the available supply of markets find alternative uses for
food, Walmart and the Walmart maximize its use and get it to fresh but “imperfect” produce, the
Improving date labels people and places that need
Foundation are: Asda program will be evaluated
for customers it. In 2015, Walmart donated and tested in other markets over
In an effort to provide clearer $1 billion (or more than 600
• Exploring ways to utilize the coming years.
information to our customers, million pounds of food) to
whole crops
create consistency and reduce organizations that distribute it
food waste, in 2015 both to people in need in the U.S.
• Improving date labeling
the Walmart and Sam’s Club Much of our work in this area
for customers
private brand teams asked is done through our work with
suppliers to start converting to Feeding America, which is
• Donating unsold food
a “Best If Used By” date label detailed on pg. 93.

97
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Food – increase access, reduce waste

Recovering food • Increasing the availability of


In 2015, the Walmart sustainable seafood
Foundation launched an
initiative to promote innovative • Improving the sustainability
ways to address food waste of the beef supply
in the U.S. Through awards
totaling more than $2.3 million, • Engaging smallholders
the initiative is supporting 12
promising programs that have Tracking supplier yields
the potential to significantly As part of our commitment
reduce food waste at the to increase visibility into
production, processing and key metrics like agricultural
household levels. Collectively, yields, water usage and GHG
the programs supported by the emissions – what we call our
Foundation provide creative Climate Smart Agriculture
approaches that include: Platform (CSA) – we have
asked the suppliers in our food
• Using crowd sourcing business to measure and report
participation to identify new Improving to become more efficient if farm productivity through
food streams and match them it is to meet the 20 percent our Sustainability Index. In
to those in need
sustainable food improvement in food availabil- 2015, with 77 percent of our
production ity by 2025 recommended by food business responding
• Recovering food directly the World Economic Forum. to the Index, participating
through gleaning The practice of sustainable To meet these challenges and suppliers were able to report
agriculture sits at the junction to help provide a more secure their yields for 34 percent of
• Addressing the needs for of three pressing environmen- food supply, Walmart is explor- their sales. Moving forward,
thought leadership and tal issues: the need to feed a ing ways to help significantly this information will help us
infrastructure improvement growing global population in a improve agricultural produc- understand where to focus and
way that reduces GHG emis- tivity, while also reducing GHG support efforts that aim to help
• Preventing waste on college sions and conserves the use of emissions and water use. (For farmers improve their yields
campuses and engaging water and land. According to more information on agricul- and productivity.
youth in recovery efforts the United Nations and World tural emissions, see pg. 66; for
Economic Forum, agriculture water use in agriculture, see pg.
• Promoting models of accounts for approximately 85.) We’re particularly focused
consumer behavior change 70 percent of global fresh- on four key areas:
water consumption and 30
• Assessing food waste at the percent of global GHG emis- • Tracking and encouraging
institutional level sions. Agriculture will need supplier yield improvements

98
sustainably source the seafood In 2016, The Nature
in their stores. In addition, our Conservancy will publish a
Brazil, Chile and Mexico markets white paper, “U.S. Beef Supply
are expanding our sustainable Chain: Opportunities in Fresh
seafood efforts by forming poli- Water, Wildlife Habitat, and
cies and working with suppliers Greenhouse Gas Reduction“.
to gain more transparency into Walmart and The Nature
their seafood sourcing. Conservancy developed this
project to gain a better under-
Improving the sustainability standing of the key environ-
Increasing the availability of of the beef supply mental impacts across the U.S.
sustainable seafood Walmart customers expect beef supply chain, as well as the
Based on supplier-reported high-quality beef products that opportunities to reduce these Helping verify the sourcing
data, at the end of FY2016, have been raised in an environ- impacts. The hope is that this of cattle
in the U.S. 100 percent of mentally responsible way. That’s information will allow stake-
Walmart and Sam’s Club fresh why we’re working closely with holders to take more informed Cargill Cattle Feeders, LLC, the
and frozen, farmed and wild nonprofits to better understand positions within influential mul- cattle supply arm of the Cargill's
seafood is sustainably sourced the environmental impacts tistakeholder initiatives, such as U.S. beef business, has created
in accordance with Walmart’s in the beef supply chain, and the Global and U.S. Roundtables a verified beef supply chain
Seafood Policy. Of this, 53 per- collaborating with our suppli- for Sustainable Beef, and to sustainability assessment program
cent reported certification by ers to measure and manage improve the design of supply for Cargill feed yards, as well as for
the Marine Stewardship Council them. This year, together with chain engagement programs. the feedlots operated by Friona
or managing a program in Industries that supply Cargill with
the National Cattlemen’s Beef The Conservancy assessed the
cattle. The program includes a
accordance with the Principles Association and others, we’re main impacts of the U.S. beef producer questionnaire for key
of Credible Sustainability proud to have founded the U.S. supply chain, reviewing the rel- cattle suppliers to Cargill’s beef
Programs developed by the Roundtable for Sustainable Beef ative impacts of key production business. The assessment began
Sustainability Consortium. (USRSB). The Roundtable has phases (ranch and farm grazing, with a yearlong focus on the
In addition, 98 percent of already developed six high pri- feed production, feedlots, and economic, environmental and
our farmed supply chain ority indicators for sustainabil- harvest facilities) on three types community impacts of Cargill’s
reported certification by Best ity. These include animal health of environmental impacts: fresh four feed yards in Texas, Kansas and
Aquaculture Practices, with and well-being, efficiency and water (both water supply and Colorado. After the initial phase
2 percent of farmed suppli- yield, water resources, land re- water quality), wildlife habitat of discovery and data collection,
ers committed to obtaining sources, air and greenhouse gas and greenhouse gases (GHGs). an analysis was made to support
certification within the year. ongoing improvements that will
emissions, and worker safety This analysis was done as part
be appropriate, meaningful, holistic
Additionally, 47 percent of our and well-being. The USRSB will of the collaboration between and verified. The assessment was
suppliers reported involve- also work to establish methods The Nature Conservancy and completed late in 2015, and Cargill
ment in Fishery Improvement of verifying that beef has been Walmart, with funding support shared findings with Walmart.
Projects, with plans in place sustainably produced in accor- from Walmart.
to achieve sustainable certifi- dance with these indicators.
cation. Globally, our stores in
the U.K. and Canada are also
working with their suppliers to

99
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Food – increase access, reduce waste

Engaging smallholders in and grow their farms, and programs that trained more
Many of the world’s poor live without access to predictable than 900,000 farmers, of
in rural areas, surviving on and functional markets for their whom more than 400,000
less than $2 a day. Most are crops, many small-scale farmers were women. Additionally,
dependent on agriculture, find themselves unable to Walmart helps provide
working small plots of land escape from a life of subsistence technical assistance to small-
for their livelihoods and to and poverty. and medium-sized growers in
feed their families. Yet, these our supply chain through our
smallholders are not part of the To help smallholders in various sourcing organizations,
Local Sourcing in Wal-Mart formal economy. According emerging markets improve such as U.K.-based International
de México y Centroamérica to the World Bank, economic their incomes and increase and Procurement and Logistics, U.S.-
growth in the agricultural strengthen their crop yields, based Global Food Sourcing
Walmart de México is sector is twice as effective at Walmart and the Walmart and Hortifruti in Central America.
strengthening its relationships reducing poverty as growth in Foundation have committed The training ranges from
with produce growers in Mexico other sectors of the economy. by the end of 2016 to providing information sessions on retail
by establishing direct and long- Yet too often, significant barriers training to 1 million farmers sourcing standards to store visits
term sourcing arrangements stand in the way of individuals and farm workers – half of that allow farmers to experience
with local farmers. Through local realizing the benefits of their whom will be women. At the their products from the vantage
sourcing, growers have a stable
labor. Lacking in capital to invest end of 2015, we’ve supported of our customers.
market for their produce, and
customers receive fresher food.
Since beginning this program
in 2014, Wal-Mart de México has
increased its local sourcing to
13.4 percent of its produce
supply, with plans to continue
this growth. Strengthening the cashew sector in West Africa

Additionally, Walmart Central Cashew Initiative, West Africa grows West African cashew farmers could
America’s direct farm program, 45 percent of the world’s cashew double their yield, it would increase
Tierra Fertil, trains farmers and supply, making it one of the world’s the world’s supply of cashews by
promotes best practices to most important cashew-growing more than 40 percent.
increase productivity and reduce regions. Despite this significant
impact to the environment. In production volume, the region Walmart also joined the board
2015, this program trained more processes less than 2 percent of of the African Cashew Initiative
than 2,500 small- and medium- global cashews, due to a lack of to help strengthen the global
sized farmers, more than 400 processing capacity. Additionally, competitiveness of cashew
of whom were women. cashew yields in West Africa are production and processing in sub-
only half of those in Southeast Asia. Saharan Africa. Walmart continues
As part of our efforts to strengthen to work with its suppliers to secure
agricultural production of key In 2015, the Walmart Foundation financing and increase cashew
commodities and across sourcing awarded a $1 million grant to processing capacity and efficiency.
geographies, Walmart is working African Cashew Alliance to train Building processing capacity and
with our suppliers and other 35,000 smallholder cashew farmers improving yields in West Africa
organizations in West Africa to in Africa, approximately 50 percent contributes to the local economy,
increase cashew processing of whom are women. This grant reduces food miles and increases
capacity and bolster farmer training seeks to help West African cashew the availability of cashews for
programs. According to the African farmers increase their yields. If our customers.

100
Sustainability in the food supply chain
To focus our CSA efforts, we • Using a Low Energy Precision • Promoting a holistic approach By encouraging measurement,
conducted internal and external Application (LEPA) to deliver to reducing the supply chain's disseminating best practices and
interviews to gather insights close-to-the-ground, low- water footprint through a reporting aggregate progress
on prioritizing commodities by pressure, spray irrigation to collective action program that through CSA, Walmart hopes to
overall environmental impact, grains, row crops, certain promotes the protection of accelerate the adoption of better
their importance to our business produce crops and sugar cane watersheds, improves access to practices in our food supply chain
goals and the potential for us to to reduce evaporation water and protects water quality and the broader food system. We
make an impact throughout the believe this effort will improve
supply chain. These conversations • Optimizing the time of slaughter • Implementing a comprehensive environmental outcomes as well
identified dairy, beef, pork, poultry to minimize days cattle are on food waste reduction program as the well-being of farmers and
and grains as priority commodities. feed, which can reduce overall across our operations and consumers.
We also identified practices that costs and the environmental throughout our supply chains
can help us and our suppliers make impacts from methane, manure that is designed to reduce
a difference in the impacts of these and grain feeding, as well as costs, increase revenues
commodities. These include: potentially improving meat and decrease Walmart’s
quality and marbling environmental impact

Notes from the field: Challenges to providing sustainable, affordable food

Scaling relief Reliable information processes to make healthy to build the capacity for
As we progress toward our for customers advances without compromising transparency and to encourage
goal of providing 4 billion As the world’s largest grocer, taste, convenience, texture and behavioral and cultural change
meals to families in need, we aim to take a leadership other important qualities. We’re among producers. This often
one key challenge has role by becoming a trusted committed to finding solutions means balancing priorities,
been balancing the need source for clear and relevant for healthier foods without such as working for certification
for interventions at scale information related to healthy sacrificing the characteristics standards while maintaining
with the unique needs of eating. With fad diets and our customers expect, and that low prices, and finding the
local communities. This has conflicting nutritional advice takes time. right technological and
required diversification of leaving many consumers economic incentives to drive
investments beyond direct confused and even intimidated, Achieving sustainable sustainability.
program delivery, sometimes we are working with nonprofit supply
to address a system-level organizations across the U.S. to Walmart is often far-removed
issue, or sometimes to invest help empower people to make from the impacts that happen
in building nonprofit capacity healthier, informed choices. on the farm, at the point of
to help ensure organizations food production. To implement
have the infrastructure, food, Finding substitutes sustainable production
staff and training to assist Sometimes it’s challenging practices requires us to
families in need. to find food substitutes or collaborate across the industry
101
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Supporting transparency and


quality in the products we sell
More than ever, people want to know more about the food and
other products they buy. Not only do they expect them to be
safe, but also, they want to know how they were made, and with
what ingredients and materials. Yet the flood of information readily
available from experts and peers, through the media or at the
stroke of a keypad, can often confuse or concern as much as inform.
Walmart aspires to help make choices easier and more transparent
for people. We serve hundreds of millions of customers every
year, and we advocate for them among suppliers for the kinds
of products they want and need. Not only are we working every Safety
day to enhance product safety, but also, we're collaborating
with others to reduce chemicals of concern and promote animal
welfare. We’re also working with government agencies and others
within the retail industry to provide better standards for clear,
transparent information about products.
Promoting transparency and product quality is good for business
as well as society. Meeting customer needs for transparency and
product quality drives innovation in product development and
production, which in turn drives sales and fosters customer trust.
In the following discussion, we highlight our progress in three
strategies to promote transparency and quality of products:
Chemicals
• Enhancing food and general merchandise product safety

• Reducing chemicals of concern

• Promoting animal welfare

Animals

102
Supporting transparency and quality in the products we sell: Progress against commitments
As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

Disclose online ingredient information. Engaged 76 percent of suppliers queried through our
Sustainability Index in 2015 to report on their online
ingredient disclosure practices, with 78 percent of
those suppliers reporting that they disclose ingredients
online for all their products (according to a nationally
recognized standard).
Reducing chemicals of concern
Reduce, restrict and remove use of high-priority Achieved 95 percent reduction by weight in Walmart
chemicals using informed substitution principles. U.S.

Strive toward formulating and labeling private Began adding Safer Choice certification to our private
brand products in accordance with U.S. EPA’s Safer brand products and will continue our work to offer even
Choice program. more of these products to our customers.

Advance the humane treatment of farm animals Released our positions on animal welfare and
Promoting animal welfare and responsible antibiotic use. responsible antibiotic use in May 2015. (http://corporate.
walmart.com/policies).

Enhancing food and know what’s in what they buy, they were in recent decades in customers, and we help create
and we are working on ways to understanding where their food demand for a more sustainable
product safety help them make more informed comes from, what’s in it and supply of food.
buying decisions. how it’s made.
Walmart is committed to To increase food safety and
selling food and products Increasing food safety Walmart welcomes this transparency, Walmart collab-
that meet high standards for and transparency development. We’re responding orates closely with our supply
safety. We are also striving to be When it comes to the food that by requiring greater transparency chain partners. We encourage
transparent about the kinds of we sell, Walmart strives to make and information about the food upstream accountability by
components and ingredients it affordable while continually we sell. Our job is not just to have communicating our policies
used to create them in the first raising the bar on food safety. this information available, but to and standards and by estab-
place. Customers think a lot Today, average customers are make it accessible for customers lishing consistency within
about what they put in and on further removed than ever from to understand and use in their global requirements and
their bodies. They deserve to food production. Yet customers shopping decisions. In doing so, audit protocols.
are also more interested than we help meet the needs of our

103
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Transparency and quality

Product safety require. In some instances, we by sourcing safe and affordable Product recalls
According to the U.S. Consumer create our own Walmart- and merchandise to help our From October 2014 through
Product Safety Commission Sam’s Club-specific require- customers save money and September 2015, the U.S.
(CPSC), deaths, injuries and ments that exceed regulatory live better. Consumer Product Safety
property damage from requirements. In 2015, we fo- Commission conducted nearly
consumer product incidents cused on expanding our ability Compliance with applicable 415 consumer product recalls
cost the nation more than to identify and monitor supplier requirements is only part involving approximately
$1 trillion annually. As the and product compliance and to of the product safety 68 million units. On occasion,
world’s largest retailer, in hold suppliers accountable for equation. That’s why, in 2015, one of these recalls would
2015 we worked to positively adhering to our standards. Our we participated in several involve a product sold at
improve these numbers focused attention on product national consumer education Walmart or Sam’s Club. When
through our robust product compliance across our supply campaigns in collaboration this happened, we worked
compliance program. chain gives our customers trust with the U.S. government to remove the product,
in the items we sell. on areas of concern for implement sales blocks at
Product compliance federal agencies. We focused the register and notify our
We’re committed to selling Customer engagement specifically on swimming pool customers and members
products that comply with We value the trust of our safety, lead poison prevention as appropriate.
applicable safety laws and customers. We work to and the Anchor It campaign to
regulations. However, existing preserve that trust by raising prevent furniture and television
laws and regulations are the our customers’ and members’ tip-over accidents.
minimum level of safety we awareness of product risks and

Regulatory inspections
The regulatory inspection process contacts (including inspections, root cause analysis and a long-term
provides an important way to letters, phone calls and emails), corrective action process.
quantify and benchmark food and so that we are aware of all
product safety. Walmart works concerns across our enterprise With the application of this
to see that all stores and clubs that have been identified by closed-loop process, we have
operate in compliance with local, regulatory agencies. seen continual reductions in
state and federal regulations, and the number of both critical and
assists them in the resolution Our regulatory review process noncritical findings noted per
process for all critical violations includes a detailed review of all inspection. The system identifies
noted on regulatory inspection findings and corrective action trends in regulatory exceptions,
reports. To help with this process, plans for any findings noted. allowing us to focus our efforts
we require transparency from These findings and action plans and share best practices across
stores and Sam’s Club locations. are tracked through a closed-loop the company.
They must report regulatory system that allows us to focus on

104
stakeholders to accelerate listing those ingredients on
the development of safer Walmart.com for our private
ingredients and improve brands. We also asked national
transparency. When we set brand suppliers like Procter
our Sustainable Chemistry & Gamble and Revlon to list
Policy in place, we knew that product ingredients on their Improving the formulation
effective measurement would own websites, giving access of beauty and personal
be necessary to assess our to this information in multiple care products
progress and identify areas locations, so customers can
of improvement. It's not an make more informed choices. Walmart is participating in the
easy task. Understanding a This year, we engaged 76 Beauty and Personal Care Initiative
business chemical footprint percent of suppliers queried (BPC), led by Forum for the
Reducing chemicals Future, a nonprofit organization
is an evolving area and through our Sustainability
of concern involves many factors, not Index to report on their online
working on solutions to complex
sustainability issues. The BPC
the least of which is the ingredient disclosure practices. launched with an industry-wide
Walmart U.S. and Sam’s need to protect suppliers’ Of those, 78 percent reported summit in September 2014, where
Club have worked with proprietary information. that they disclose ingredients Walmart and Target convened
Environmental Defense Through close collaboration online for all their products a discussion on the ways the
Fund and a range of other with Environmental Defense according to a nationally industry can collaboratively
NGOs, suppliers, academics, Fund, we have an initial recognized standard. work toward better, more
government and industry framework for evaluating our sustainable beauty and personal
chemical footprint using UL’s Safer product formulations care products. A year into the
stakeholders to develop a
WERCSmart™ platform for in- In coordination with scientific initiative, the BPC has identified
company policy on sustainable key systemic barriers and is
chemistry for the formulated scope formulated consumable experts and industry groups,
launching an industry leadership
consumable products that we products. We started with Walmart has identified high group to address them in practical,
sell. Our customers expect that quantitative indicators priority chemicals (HPCs) that systematic ways.
the products they buy are safe, because we believe that, over we are seeking to phase out
affordable and sustainable, and time, they will adequately of the products we sell. In
we’re striving to meet those inform us about our policy’s our Sustainable Chemistry
expectations. We’re working effectiveness in achieving our Policy, we have initially
with suppliers to reformulate goals of increasing ingredient focused our attention on
household cleaning, personal transparency and advancing these substances, as they
care, baby, pet, beauty and the safer formulations of possess certain properties “Greater online access to
cosmetic products to remove, products. that can affect human health ingredient information gives
reduce and restrict the use of or the environment. Our shoppers the resources they
priority chemicals and replace Disclosing ingredients goal is to reduce, restrict and need to make healthy product
them with safer alternatives. to customers eliminate the use of HPCs by decisions.”
Walmart’s sustainable chemistry using informed substitution
To do this, Walmart is policy helps customers learn principles. We have been asking - Boma Brown-West, manager of
communicating with what’s in personal care and our suppliers to reformulate Consumer Health at Environmental
our suppliers regarding household products like their products to meet our Defense Fund
our expectations, and baby lotion, cleaners and pet expectations. When suppliers are
we’re collaborating with shampoo. In 2015, we started unable to remove HPCs, we ask

105
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Transparency and quality

them to develop time-bound Protection Agency’s (EPA) Safer to make progress in the coming
action plans to reduce, restrict Choice certification program years. We remain committed
and eliminate usage as well as helps consumers, businesses to our Sustainable Chemistry
to engage in broad stakeholder and purchasers find products Policy as a means of improving
initiatives to work toward that perform well and that are our chemical footprint. We'll
industry-wide solutions. To date, designed to be safer for human refine and continue to measure
we have successfully removed health and the environment. our progress and pinpoint key
95 percent of HPCs by volume Since we’ve announced our opportunities for improvement.
Promoting industry weight from the products we policy, we’ve begun adding
collaborations sell in Walmart U.S. that are in the Safer Choice certification to our For more details about the
scope of our policy. private brand products, and we Walmart Sustainable Chemistry
Walmart is committed to col- will continue our work to offer Policy and our chemical footprint
laborating with stakeholders to Designating “Safer Choice” even more of these products to methodology, please visit
meet the challenges posed by products our customers. walmartsustainabilityhub.com.
advancing safer chemical formu- The combination of safety,
lations in products. This year, we
affordability and product It's clear that there is still plenty
joined the Green Chemistry and
Commerce Council’s Preservatives
performance is very important of work ahead, but we're
Project, which works to accelerate to Walmart. The Environmental confident that we'll continue
the commercialization of new,
safe and effective preservative
systems for personal care and
household products. We are also
participating in The Sustainability
Consortium®’s (TSC) Common Supplier leadership
Chemical Criteria Task Force. Its
goal is to provide the home or Henkel, Walmart Sustainability Through ingredient transparency, a dual-compatible formula that is
personal care industry with con- Leader and the 2015 sustainability consumers can more easily tailor suitable for all washing machines
sistent, transparent and credible supplier of the year for Walmart their product selections. Scientists including HE. Persil Power-Liquid
guidance for the evaluation and U.S. consumables, has gone at Henkel consider sustainability 2in1 is Henkel’s top-performing
prioritization of chemicals, and to beyond ingredient transparency to be a key parameter during the variant and can be used as both
provide management recommen- disclosure to empower consumers product development phase, a detergent and a pre-treater.
dations for chemicals that meet with additional information on starting even from the basic These product design aspects
specific criteria. fragrances. Ingredient information research, to design new products bring efficiency in packaging and
for Henkel everyday products can and formulations and continuously transportation and convenience
be accessed on Henkel’s website improve the environmental and for consumers. Second, is Henkel’s
at www.henkel-northamerica. social footprint. Sustainability Dial® Complete® Foaming hand
com. Henkel is now disclosing is thoroughly reviewed and soap, where the new formulation
ingredient information online subjected to a rigorous internal has a significant reduction in
related to the EU 26 allergens for protocol throughout the project carbon footprint paired with a
their everyday products. Henkel management process. Two substantial increase in renewables
understands that some consumers examples are as follows. First, content, while still meeting the
have specific concerns about Henkel partnered with Walmart high standards of performance
fragrance ingredients that may on the US launch of Persil® that consumers have come to
cause allergies in individuals ProClean® laundry detergent in enjoy from the Dial brand.
sensitive to the ingredient. 2015. For Persil, Henkel provides

106
these freedoms and with the the practice of tail docking
judicious use of antibiotics. of dairy cattle from 2022 to
We’re asking our suppliers to January 1, 2017. Since January
eliminate their use of antibiotics 2014, Dairy Farmers of America
for growth promotion and to enrolled more than 8,000
publicly report antibiotics use. member farms in the FARM
program, representing more
With the recent release of our than 95 percent of member
egg position, we have taken milk production
the first step in implementing
our animal welfare position • Cargill, Smithfield Foods and
through our supply chain. Tyson, which have shown
Over the coming year, we will leadership in reducing use
be working to develop similar of antibiotics in beef, pork
category-specific positions with and chicken, respectively, in
Promoting Walmart supports the globally
comprehensive and timebound advance of a Food and Drug
recognized “Five Freedoms” of
animal welfare animal welfare: commitments across our meat Administration directive
and responsible and dairy business. calling for an end to using
medically important antibiot-
antibiotic use • Freedom from hunger or
In addition to our company ics for growth production
thirst
commitments, we applaud our
Walmart believes that animals • Freedom from discomfort suppliers and others who have One of the challenges in this
should be treated humanely made significant contributions space is the lack of visibility
throughout their lives and • Freedom from pain, injury to advancing animal welfare and data on current practices.
that antibiotics should be or disease and responsible antibiotic use We've developed an animal
used responsibly to preserve this year. They include: welfare and antibiotics survey
the effectiveness of antibiot- • Freedom to express normal that we're asking our suppliers
ics in human and veterinary behavior • The National Milk Producers to complete. Our goal is to
medicine. In May 2015 we Federation made several no- work with The Sustainability
announced our positions • Freedom from fear and distress table changes in the National Consortium and industry
on farm animal welfare and Dairy Farmers Assessing and nonprofits to integrate
responsible antibiotic use.* We are committed to working Responsible Management animal welfare metrics into
Walmart expects that its with suppliers and other (FARM) Program version our Sustainability Index as
suppliers do not tolerate organizations to implement 3.0, including expediting we move ahead.
animal abuse. practices consistent with the timeline for eliminating

*(http://corporate.walmart.com/policies)

107
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Supporting the safety and


dignity of workers everywhere
Global economic development has helped lift millions of people
out of poverty. Yet the well-being of people who produce
goods for the world’s supply chains can be overlooked. In some
instances, workers – especially those in emerging markets – have
little expectation of finding decent work where even basic safety
standards are applied. These workers may be subjected to poor
air quality, lack of emergency protocols, excessive overtime,
delayed compensation or even forced labor.
Walmart believes that all people deserve safe, healthy working
conditions that are free from coercion. Though we are one actor
among many, Walmart recognizes these risks and the importance
of supporting workers in our global supply chain. Through our
Responsible Sourcing program and collaborative initiatives, we’re
working to promote dignity and respect for the men and women
who make the products we sell. We set high standards of worker
dignity and well-being in our own operations and promote
Sourcing
responsible sourcing practices throughout our global supply
chain. We are also working collaboratively with other companies,
governments and nonprofit organizations to help improve
working conditions and employment opportunities for workers
around the world.
Improving the safety, freedom and livelihoods of workers not
only benefits them, their families and communities, but also,
it strengthens our business, too. When workers have what
they need, product supplies remain stable and quality is often
improved. And customers want products that are sustainable
not only for the environment, but also, for the people who
made them.
Walmart supports the safety and dignity of workers through two
main strategies:

• Promoting responsible sourcing practices in the global


supply chain

• Focusing on safety, health and environmental compliance Compliance


in our operations

108
Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere: Progress against commitments
As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

Provide supply chain capacity-building training to Launched our Responsible Sourcing Academy in 2015,
suppliers and facility managers. which provides suppliers and facility management with
tools and training opportunities designed to influence
continuous and sustainable improvement.

Collaborate with other organizations to empower Collaborated with the Alliance for Bangladesh Worker
workers in the Bangladesh ready-made garment Safety – of which Walmart is a founding member – to
industry. train more than 1.1 million factory employees on basic
fire safety and to offer an anonymous helpline for
Promoting responsible workers in more than 400 factories in Bangladesh.
sourcing practices in the global
supply chain Collaborate with other organizations to address Walmart participated in the Consumer Goods Forum,
forced labor and human trafficking risks in the which agreed in January 2016 to address forced labor as
global supply chain. an industry priority.

Over the past two years, the Walmart Foundation


has supported International Justice Mission, Polaris
and Issara Institute, organizations that work to increase
human dignity
in the supply chain.

Taking a risk-based approach to auditing

In early 2015, we implemented a risk-based approach to auditing that focuses


on areas posing the highest potential risks to social, safety and environmental
compliance. Currently, our approach includes a consideration of country
governance risk factors to assess potential facility risk. Using the Worldwide
Governance Indicators from the World Bank, we consider how factors like
government effectiveness, rule of law, control of corruption and government
stability affect the risk of noncompliance in certain facilities in a particular
country. In the future, we may evolve our risk-based approach to include
additional factors such as industry- or supplier-specific risks.

109
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Sourcing and compliance

environment. We expect supplier may lose the ability to


compliance with these standards do business with Walmart.
from our suppliers and their
facilities. Walmart’s standards for We use detailed social, safety
suppliers are available online at: and environmental compliance
http://corporate.walmart.com/ audits to evaluate the practices
sourcing-standards-resources. of facilities within the scope
of Walmart’s Responsible
We expect suppliers to display Sourcing program, including
our standards in all facilities whether:
falling within the scope of
our Responsible Sourcing • Workers are properly paid for
program. The standards for all labor hours
suppliers must be displayed
in the language spoken by • All labor is voluntary
the majority of workers, as we
want the workers themselves • Facilities comply with all child
Responsible • Establishing accountability to know our expectations labor laws and standards
through audits and other tools of suppliers and facility
sourcing in the management. We also require • Working hours are not
global supply chain • Building capacity within these facilities to display a excessive and are consistent
the supply chain through toll-free phone number, email with local laws or regulations
training and worker well- address and website where
Walmart values the men and
being programs workers can anonymously • Facilities meet health and
women around the world who
work to produce the products report concerns in their local safety standards
• Collaborating with industry language. Walmart uses these
our customers want. We
stakeholders to promote reports to inform potential Audit results are assigned a
expect our suppliers and their
supply chain responsibility investigations and auditing color rating based on the type
facility managers to provide
workers with safe and healthy decisions. and severity of issues found,
Setting expectations for and facilities can be re-audited
employment conditions.
suppliers Establishing accountability on a schedule based on those
We consider the safety and through audits and other ratings. We use these ratings to
Through our Responsible
well-being of workers across tools help make decisions regarding
Sourcing program, we’re
our supply chain a high priority. All facilities within the scope of our use of particular suppliers
striving to create meaningful,
Walmart provides our suppliers Walmart’s Responsible Sourcing and facilities. Facility audit
sustainable changes for
with our standards for suppliers program must be disclosed results are sent to suppliers
workers in our global supply
as well as a standards manual to us and available for an using that facility, and it is the
chain. We focus our efforts in
to make clear our fundamental audit. If we find that a supplier suppliers’ responsibility to work
areas such as:
expectations regarding, among is producing merchandise with facilities to remediate
other things, the treatment in, or subcontracting to, an audit findings.
• Setting strong expectations
and safety of workers and unauthorized facility, that
for suppliers
the suppliers’ impact on the

110
Building supply chain noncompliance issues
capacity and develop a systematic
Although primary responsibility approach to continuous
for compliance with our stan- improvement using root-
dards rests with our suppliers, cause analysis methodology
we recognize our potential to and procedures.
positively influence the global
supply chain by leveraging our • Supply Chain Forum – invites
size and scale. Our Responsible suppliers, facilities and
Sourcing Academy aims to do stakeholders from similar
just that by providing suppliers sourcing regions to discuss
and facilities with tools and relevant issues and share
training opportunities designed best practices.
to influence continuous and
sustainable improvement. The We'll continue to evaluate
Academy currently includes the and evolve the Responsible Collaborating with industry industry stakeholders, nonprofit
following programs: Sourcing Academy to meet the stakeholders to promote organizations, governments and
changing needs of our suppliers supply chain sustainability other partners, we are working
• Responsible Sourcing Audit and other stakeholders. We work to promote a to improve transparency,
Orientation – provides new responsible supply chain by empower workers and drive
suppliers and facilities Empowering and identifying areas where we can positive change throughout
with training in social and developing workers leverage our scale and assist our supply chains.
environmental compliance; Alongside these training efforts, suppliers in making a positive
fire, chemical and machine Walmart and the Walmart and lasting impact on the Improving labor conditions
safety; dormitory and canteen Foundation are developing people and communities where in the produce supply chain
standards; region-specific programs to support the they operate. But we can’t do it In agriculture, we work with
trends; and more. well-being of workers in the alone; many issues in consumer suppliers and their growers to
global supply chain. We believe goods supply chains cannot be help them better understand
• Violation Correction Training – all workers, no matter where solved through the actions of Walmart’s expectations and
addresses common trends they live, should work in a safe any one company. improve conditions for workers.
related to social and environment and have the Through collaboration with
environmental compliance, opportunity to grow. In addition While we continue to manage other stakeholders, we are
offering root-cause analysis to the training we're doing for supply chain risk through striving to develop mechanisms
and methods to address women workers around the audits, programs and training, to improve the safety and
those issues in locally relevant world (see pg. 33), we're also we're also collaborating to well-being of growers and
ways, and culminating in focused on the issues of forced address complex, systemic farm workers, who typically
the development of plans to labor and human trafficking. issues that affect the entire fall outside the scope of
remedy potential violations. sector. We believe this more Walmart’s and other retailers’
collaborative approach will audit programs.
• Orange School Program – create greater impact in our
trains facility management supply chain, and do so more For example, in 2014 Walmart
to proactively identify effectively. By joining forces with joined the Fair Food Program,

111
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Sourcing and compliance

a unique partnership among Addressing human trafficking In late 2015, one of the industry
farmworkers, Florida tomato and forced labor associations we support – the
growers and participating Perhaps the most marginalized Consumer Goods Forum
retail buyers organized by the workers in globalized supply (CGF) – reached a consensus
Coalition of Immokalee Workers chains are those who are forced to address forced labor as an
Polaris: Fighting human (CIW). The Fair Food Program to work, coerced to accept industry priority. The CGF brings
trafficking in Mexico encourages humane working unsafe conditions or abuse, or together more than 400 retailers,
conditions for the workers who are subject to other forms of manufacturers and service
The U.S. State Department has pick fruits and vegetables on exploitation. For workers who providers in the consumer
identified Mexico as a source and participating farms. Our work find themselves in exploitative goods industry to create positive
destination for people in forced with the CIW includes: conditions, the very act of try- change across the retail industry.
labor. In this environment, the ing to earn a living can poten- Walmart’s Responsible Sourcing
nonprofit organization Polaris • Working to expand the tially put them in physical and representatives on CGF’s Social
works to disrupt human trafficking Fair Foods Program beyond emotional danger and lead to Sustainability Committee helped
by equipping key stakeholders Florida to the tomatoes we ongoing economic uncertain- drive this industry-wide priority.
and communities to identify, map
purchase from participating ty and hardship. That’s why we
and eliminate trafficking networks.
Florida-based growers with are working with suppliers in We’re also collaborating with
They also use targeted campaigns
to address and prevent human operations outside the state high-risk categories to reinforce International Justice Mission
trafficking, and effectively respond our standards and expec- (IJM), an organization that
to its victims. The Walmart • Committing to using tations and training them works to fight human traffick-
Foundation awarded Polaris a suppliers who best reflect on effective management ing. Asda, Walmart's business
grant of nearly $1 million to help the principles of the Fair systems. We’re also asking key in the U.K., sponsors Stronger
the organization further its efforts Food Program shrimp suppliers to map their Together, a multistakeholder
to end modern slavery in Mexico. supply chains and encourag- initiative aiming to reduce
The grant will be used to build • Exploring whether the ing them to adopt controlled the risk of human trafficking,
the capacity of a human trafficking Fair Food Program can be supply chains, where the forced labor and other hidden
hotline within Mexico and create
expanded to crops beyond supplier can verify the origin third-party exploitation of
a thorough assessment of stake-
tomatoes in our produce of the materials and labor workers in U.K. companies’
holders and policies that have direct
impact on the issue. supply chain that go into a finished prod- supply chains. Stronger
uct, as well as the conditions Together provides download-
In 2015, we also began testing under which the product was able resources for employers,
a program with a select group produced at every stage. Since labor providers, workers and
of tomato growers in Mexico. human trafficking and forced worker representatives. And
In this project, we are assessing labor affect many industries, finally, Walmart is working with
the viability of combining tools, addressing them requires co- the Shrimp Sustainable Supply
such as grower self-assessments, ordination between business, Chain Task Force, an initiative
supplier capability assessments government and nonprofit or- established by a group of Thai
and verification audits, to better ganizations. At Walmart, we’re seafood suppliers that works
manage risk at the grower level. working to form coalitions and to improve standards and
We will continue to assess test engaging with governments compliance at all levels of
program results as we work to to develop solutions to con- the shrimp supply chain.
understand how best to address front these challenges in the
potential risks upstream in our global supply chain through
supply chain. collective action.

112
Creating safer working
conditions in the ready-made
garment industry
Walmart is working toward
meaningful and sustainable
reform of the ready-made gar- Issara Institute:
ment industry. We are a found- Anti-trafficking work
ing member of the Alliance for in the seafood industry
Bangladesh Worker Safety, a
group of brands and retailers With a grant of more than
seeking to create safer working $400,000 from the Walmart
conditions for men and women Foundation, Issara Institute aims to
in the ready-made garment in- improve how anti-trafficking work
dustry in Bangladesh. According is done around the world, through
to the Alliance’s second annual a focus on metrics and analytics
report, published in September to pinpoint the cost-effectiveness
Additionally, we’ve committed sector. Program components and impact of programs. Launched
2015, it has: $1.6 million – with $1.2 million include monitoring factories, in 2014, Issara Institute was formed
contributed through the end conducting training modules as a public-private sector platform
• Trained more than 1.1 million of 2015 – to improve safety for workers and engaging with to tackle human trafficking and
factory employees on basic training via the newly created key stakeholders, including forced labor in Southeast Asia’s
fire safety Environmental Health and workers, factories, communities seafood supply chain. Through the
Safety Academy (EHS) in and governments. grant, Issara Institute will increase
• Provided a helpline in more Bangladesh. The purpose of the capacity of its reporting
than 400 factories where EHS Academy is to provide Asda, Walmart’s business in hotline, improve its use of mobile
workers can anonymously a local, long-term platform the U.K., is a founding member technology to reach workers and
report safety or other job- update its information technology
for addressing fire safety of the Ethical Trading Initiative
related concerns systems for better processing and
challenges in the supply chain (ETI) and works within a multi- analyzing of data. The Institute
through technical training and stakeholder environment will also use the funds to host
• Provided, together with engagement. on industry issues such as discussions with nonprofit,
factory owners, wages for home workers, working-hours academic, donor community and
more than 6,000 displaced Walmart also works with the projects, fire safety, living wages private sector organizations to
workers Better Work Program in several and purchasing practices. ETI share the insights and engage in
countries. The International touches a wide spectrum of collective problem-solving.
• Published the results of factory Labour Organization and issues to help drive positive
inspections on its website, the International Finance change through the supply
along with corrective action Corporation launched the base from which Asda sources.
plans for factories entering Better Work Program to
remediation improve factory working
conditions in the garment

113
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Sourcing and compliance

recycle as much as possible spent in training by three hours


within local guidelines. In per associate. At the same time,
compliance with appropriate it provides a more targeted
recommendations, we recycle training that mirrors associates’
lead-acid car batteries, lamps experience.
and bulbs, tires, automobile oil
and spent cooking oils. Such We continue to improve our
recycling programs create a programs to better serve the
double bottom line: They help health and wellness needs
preserve our natural resources, of our customers. In 2015,
and they’re good for our we expanded our pharmacy
business. In fact, automobile offerings to include additional
and cooking oil recycling alone types of immunizations and
has generated more than $147 certain medication.
million in additional revenue
for our business over the past
Maintaining Environmental compliance six years.
When it comes to environmental
safety, health and impact, Walmart aims to Health and wellness
environmental meet the highest standards of compliance: process and
compliance in our compliance and to promote progress in our store
sustainable business practices pharmacies
operations within our operations and In a complex and constantly
throughout our supply changing industry, Walmart’s
As Walmart buys, moves and chain. Our environmental health and wellness compliance
sells products in stores across compliance programs guide group helps to ensure the safe
28 countries, complying with our responsible management operation of our pharmacies.
safety, environmental and other of waste materials, including This group works to protect
regulations helps us to create a wastewater, stormwater, air our pharmacy customers and
safer environment for our associ- emissions and recyclable the communities in which we
ates and customers. Throughout materials. Around the world, operate through monitoring Fleet safety
our operations all around the subject matter experts train compliance with local and Each year, we move millions of
world – whether in our stores, our associates in all markets to national regulations. products from manufacturers
distribution centers, production comply with environmental to Walmart distribution centers,
facilities, pickup points or on the regulations and implement We reorganized controlled and from distribution centers
road – we address safety and best practices. In the U.S., substance mandatory trainings to the shelves in our stores. Our
compliance by training associ- environmental regulatory in the U.S. for new pharmacists, logistics network operates one
ates, enforcing stringent stan- agencies inspected our facilities technicians and pharmacy of the largest and safest fleets
dards and fostering continuous more than 2,100 times and found sales associates. Through in the U.S., and our drivers clock
improvement and innovation no significant violations. the elimination of redundant thousands of miles each day
through improved communica- material, the new program to make millions of deliveries
tion and collaboration. Since 2010, Walmart has saves nearly $1 million annually to our stores and clubs. Our
made a significant effort to by reducing the time actually fleet drove more than 700

114
million miles last year, and Champion program; the of our customers. To maintain
was again recognized at champions promote ethics and business continuity, our licensing
the 2015 American Trucking compliance values, programs compliance team works hard
Association's Safety and HR and policies with other asso- to monitor legislative trends,
National Conference as the ciates throughout the store. evaluate our effectiveness and
industry’s safest fleet in its class Nationwide calls are conduct- consistently update associate
for 2014. This year we also had ed monthly to enhance their training to help fulfill all legal
more than 25 drivers surpass knowledge and understanding requirements.
3 million miles or more without of all facets within compliance,
a preventable accident. including a culture of safety. Using a proprietary, web-based
license managing system, our
OSHA compliance Licenses and permits licensing compliance group
In FY2015, our OSHA compliance Each year, Walmart’s licensing procures and keeps required
safety team worked to improve compliance group secures or real estate, construction and
corporate safety programs in maintains more than 215,000 operating licenses and permits.
technical safety areas like work- licenses and permits globally This includes licenses and
ing from heights. We continue to keep our doors open for permits relating to developing
to mature our Compliance business and products available property, building facilities and
Champion program with a to customers. distribution centers, owning
champion now in place at and operating stores, selling
every store. Our Compliance Licenses and permits affect merchandise and providing
Champion program is intended the sale of many items such specific lines of service.
to foster a culture of ethics and as food, prescription drugs,
compliance. Members of store alcohol and tobacco. Obtaining
management recommend the right licensure allows us to
associates to the Compliance continue to meet the needs

OSHA recordable incident rates: Walmart U.S. and Sam’s Club vs. industry
■ Walmart ■ Sam’s Club ■ Industry rate

5.98 4.54 5.90 5.44 3.97 5.40 5.37 3.87 5.60 5.25 3.82 5.30 5.02 3.77 5.30 5.04 4.00

2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015*

*Industry data have a one-year lay time and therefore do not appear in this chart.

115
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Strengthening local communities

Walmart’s 2.3 million associates live and work in more than 10,000 Strengthening local communities creates value for business as
communities in 28 countries around the world. Every day, our well as society. Strong communities foster social stability and
associates bring the stuff of daily life – food, medicine, clothing, more inclusive economic growth – which in turn support a
household or other items – to more than 300 million friends and healthier customer base, associate talent pool and supplier base
neighbors in these communities. for business.
Over the years, we have realized that we can use our strengths Our priorities and programs include:
to serve local communities in ways that go beyond our retail • Enhancing resilience in the face of disasters
mission.
• Improving the speed and focus of response to disasters
For example, in times of disaster, our associates have rallied to • Strengthening the preparedness of communities
direct donations of food, water and other supplies from our for disasters
stores and distribution centers and work with others on the • Developing communities through associate, customer and
ground to coordinate relief and recovery efforts. Increasingly, company engagement
we are working with other organizations to strengthen disaster
• Empowering associates to engage in their community
preparedness (as well as continuing to provide relief), drawing • Supporting associates through scholarships and
on our philanthropy, associate expertise and relationships with hardship funds
suppliers, nonprofits and government agencies. • Investing in communities
And day to day, we aim to strengthen communities by working
with organizations such as hospitals, food banks, schools and
youth sports – through a combination of cash and in-kind
donations, customer campaigns and associates volunteering
time and their considerable skills in logistics, operations and
technology (to name a few).

116
117
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Enhancing resilience in the face of disaster

A little more than 10 years ago, Hurricane Katrina slammed into over $56 million in cash grants as well as food, water, products
the Gulf Coast of the United States, devastating New Orleans and associate expertise to assist with disasters in communities
and many other communities. Walmart became an unexpected around the world – from Hurricane Sandy in the U.S. to the
early responder – providing more than 2,400 truckloads of tsunami in Japan; from the floods in the U.K. to the tornadoes in
supplies and 100 truckloads of donated goods, while pitching in the American South; from the earthquakes in Nepal to the lead
to help coordinate relief efforts on the ground. We guaranteed contamination of water in Flint, Michigan.
job transfers for our displaced associates, helping them and As the severity and frequency of disasters have increased,
their families get back on their feet, while we worked to reopen we are collaborating with others to expand our focus from
our damaged stores and restore our communities. providing relief to enhancing the preparedness of communities
The experience of Hurricane Katrina taught us how we can in the face of disaster in two ways.
draw on our strengths – our presence in 10,000 communities; First, we are supporting the use of technology to help improve
our associates’ compassion and expertise; our food, water and the speed and focus of disaster response so that people, food,
other products; our logistics and operations capabilities; our water and other resources are quickly deployed to the right
philanthropy; and our relationships with other community places. According to Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, 50 to
leaders – to provide relief in the aftermath of disaster. Since 70 percent of the physical goods donated during disasters are
Katrina, Walmart and the Walmart Foundation have contributed non-priority items and ended up in landfills. In line with our

Disaster response Disaster preparedness

118
company’s focus on eliminating waste in our operations and Enhancing disaster preparedness in our communities creates
supply chain, we want to prevent waste and instead help people clear benefits for business and for society. More effective
deploy precious resources where needed. preparedness and relief programs reduce the loss of life and
Second, we are investing in efforts that enhance the preparedness property and strengthen cohesiveness of communities in
of communities to mitigate the loss of life and property in our neighborhoods and the workplace. Our customers agree, telling
communities. According to U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon, us that of all the ways we help communities, one of the most
the average cost of damage to commercial and residential important to them is our work in disaster response.
buildings worldwide is $314 billion each year. Preparedness The following describes the two main initiatives in our disaster
can help reduce damage and therefore the costs of relief preparedness program:
and reconstruction.
• Improving the speed and focus of disaster response
To underscore our commitment to disaster response and
preparedness, this past year Walmart and the Walmart • Strengthening disaster preparedness
Foundation announced a five-year, $25 million commitment of
cash and in-kind contributions for relief efforts and innovations
that will help enhance response and preparedness across
communities around the world.

Enhancing resilience in the face of disaster: Progress against commitments


As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Commitment Progress

Invest $25 million through Walmart and the More than $5.8 million invested in disaster preparedness
Disaster response and
Walmart Foundation in response and preparedness and response in FY16.
preparedness
between 2015 and 2020.

119
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Strengthening local communities – Disaster resilience

Improving speed hurricanes, earthquakes and Walmart also made philanthrop-


wildfires, including severe ic investments of $2.5 million
and focus of disaster weather in Texas, an earthquake in technologies to enhance the
response in Nepal and flooding in South speed and focus of relief efforts,
Carolina. Last year, we supported such as Good360’s platform
immediate relief efforts with to direct donor contributions
Walmart and Walmart
Disaster program Foundation focus on disaster
$2.1 million in cash grants
as well as donated products
toward the specific, registered
needs of local charities, and the
response initiatives includes
contributions providing relief in the wake and our associates’ expertise
in logistics and operations.
American Red Cross RC View’s
platform that provides real-time
of disasters, as well as

FY2016 investments in technologies


and other innovations that
improve the speed and focus
Walmart emergency operations’
associates collaborated with the
Walmart Foundation, responders
data about evolving circum-
stances on the ground.

such as firefighters and police,


of response.
Response nonprofits such as the American
Red Cross and government
$2,102,000 Over the past year, Walmart
and the Walmart Foundation
agencies to increase and
accelerate delivery of much-
Flood helped 87 communities deal
needed goods and services.
with disasters such as floods,
$1,365,000
Earthquake
$250,000 A decade of contributions to disaster
response and preparedness – FY2006-FY2016
Wildfire
$187,000
Severe Weather
$185,000
Other Response
$115,000 $45,084,707
Preparedness
Preparedness
$3,742,500
$10,960,500
Total
$5,844,500 $56,045,207 – Total

120
Relief in Nepal
In April 2015, the Walmart
Foundation teamed up with
International Medical Corps to
meet the urgent needs of families
devastated by the earthquakes in
Nepal. Within hours, International
Medical Corps deployed mobile
medical teams by foot, car and
helicopter to the rural epicenter of
the quake, providing 4,547 medical
consultations over four weeks.
Mobile teams provided emergency
health care for those suffering from
injuries and trauma; conducted
emergency evacuations; distributed
hygiene kits to stop the spread
of disease; and provided primary
Using technology to focus disaster response health care to meet ongoing
needs. Teams also constructed
The $25 million disaster commitment on the ground. The Red Cross has (DR360), an online giving platform two long-term physical therapy
by Walmart and the Walmart contracted with Environmental that connects individual and units; mobilized 22 tons of
Foundation includes grants for Systems Research Institute (a corporate donors to the disaster supplies; rebuilt 13 health posts;
technologies that will accelerate software company specializing in relief “wish lists” of local charities. and constructed 2,120 latrines –
and focus disaster relief efforts. geographic management applica- So often in the wake of disaster, ultimately providing care for more
tions) to develop RC View, which well-intentioned donors send than 185,000 people. International
For example, in 2015, Walmart will aggregate and share critical unsolicited product donations that Medical Corps continues to work
awarded a $1.5 million grant to real-time data across organizations only complicate and strain relief with the government of Nepal
the American Red Cross to develop during emergency situations to operations on the ground. DR360 and local partners to improve
a computerized data tracking tool enable a faster, more coordinated, will help channel donor goodwill emergency response; rebuild and
– RC View – to help relief organi- and more efficient response. to provide the right products at the equip health posts with medications
zations know where to focus their right time in the right place. This and supplies; train health workers
efforts. In the hours and days after Walmart also contributed $1 million year, for example, DR360 helped to provide mental health care for
disaster strikes, many organizations to Good360 (a nonprofit that donors better meet needs on the those still suffering; operate nutrition
manually collect disaster impact facilitates in-kind donations from ground in the Flint, Michigan water stabilization centers; provide
data – losing precious time, and consumer product companies crisis, the South Carolina floods and ongoing physical therapy; and build
often missing critical information for disaster relief) to develop the northern California wildfires. overall capacity for communities
about changing circumstances and launch Disaster Recovery360 to respond to future disasters.

121
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Strengthening local communities – Disaster resilience

Preparing for the worst: Building preparedness in


Cities of Service the U.S. Gulf region – United
Nations $1.2M grant
In FY2016 the Walmart Foundation
provided a grant of $300,000 to Hurricane Katrina was one of the
Cities of Service, a coalition of over defining moments for disaster
200 cities who have committed awareness around the globe. The
to developing and implementing event highlighted the need for
volunteer projects that address increased disaster preparedness
local community needs in cities investments and public-private
across the United States. With the partnerships to create more resil-
grant, Cities of Service will fund ient communities. For Hurricane
disaster resilience projects within Katrina’s 10-year commemora-
nine counties of the San Francisco tion, the Walmart Foundation
Bay Area. Projects will be selected announced an investment in
and implemented in the summer preparedness efforts for the Gulf
of 2016 and will engage local Coast highlighting our relationship
citizens in addressing community- with the United Nations for ARISE:
specific issues and hazards a program aimed to enhance
that may leave the city more community preparedness in the
susceptible to disaster events. region. The grant aims to better
prepare communities for disasters
by generating metrics to measure
disaster preparedness, developing
Community Resilience Coalitions,
Team Rubicon: Veterans on an effective manner. To date, Team
creating preparedness plans and
standby for disaster response Rubicon has responded to over
assessing the vulnerability of small
120 disasters with nearly 35,000
businesses and engaging with
When disaster strikes, a swift and volunteers worldwide. Walmart
them on disaster preparedness.
organized response is essential to and the Walmart Foundation
prevent loss of life as well as homes have proudly supported Team
and possessions. Team Rubicon, a Rubicon’s operations and disaster
disaster response organization that deployments through financial
unites the skills and experiences support and Walmart volunteers.
of military veterans with first For example, in the 2015 Texas
responders, maintains a network flooding, about 30 Walmart
of volunteers on standby, rapidly volunteers joined Team Rubicon
deploying them to assist with during Operation Double Trouble
response efforts. These highly in Wimberley, Texas, to aid in
skilled, experienced veterans assess cleanup efforts.
impact, provide basic services
and help lead other volunteers to
quickly expand response efforts in

122
Strengthening nonprofit organizations and for strengthening future disaster in support of Mayor Mitch
other companies to share preparedness and response Landrieu’s “Katrina 10-Resilient
disaster preparedness best practices in improving efforts. Building on the study’s New Orleans” Day of Service
preparedness. findings, Walmart and the events throughout the parishes
As noted previously, the Walmart Foundation convened in and around New Orleans.
five-year, $25 million disaster In 2015, Walmart and the Walmart global stakeholders from the To conclude the week and
commitment by Walmart Foundation commemorated the nonprofit, academic, government display our investment in
and the Walmart Foundation 10-year anniversary of Hurricane and corporate sectors to share a more resilient Gulf Coast,
expands our focus from Katrina in New Orleans. best practices in disaster, and the Walmart Foundation
response to preparedness. Starting the week, Louisiana led a discussion with the Clinton announced a series of grants
Our goal is to help improve State University’s Stephenson Global Initiative on the future for preparedness programs led
the planning and response Disaster Management Institute of the disaster field. Walmart by local Gulf Coast nonprofits
capacity of communities released a white paper with also sponsored Urban league such as St. Bernard Project and
and their citizens , as well support from Walmart detailing of Greater New Orleans “RISE: the Mississippi State Gulf Coast
as convene discussions lessons learned from Hurricane Katrina 10” events and helped Community Design Studio.
with government agencies, Katrina and recommendations organize over 10,000 volunteers

Notes from the field: Challenges to building preparedness

Fragmentation Because community Technology


While many organizations are preparedness initiatives are Technology, when used properly,
working in disaster response often funded from state or can be a powerful lever during
and preparedness, there is a lack national counterparts, they times of disaster. However, under-
of cohesion and coordination are often underfunded, or not investment in disaster response
across the efforts. As a result, funded at all, when compared and preparedness can leave
useful data to enhance resilience with more chronic problems. technological vulnerabilities and
is not shared, resources are gaps in generating accurate and
not effectively distributed, and Local planning insightful information.
expensive tools are duplicated. Many communities lack a formal
Such fragmentation inhibits the disaster preparedness plan. In
effectiveness of preparedness, communities that do have such
burdens the relief process, plans established, they can be
and confuses accountability, underdeveloped, fail to assess
coordination and role clarity. key risks to which a community
is susceptible or are not widely
Funding communicated to community
Often, states and communities residents.
lack the financial resources to
enhance disaster preparedness.

123
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Spotlight on

strengthening local communities

Global company, local action


Grants
152,000
grants
Giving by focus area*
Community engagement – 36%

Hunger relief & healthy eating – 36%


Over
Health & wellness – 11%
$95 Education – 6%

million Sustainability – 2%
in cash grants Career opportunity – 9%

* Includes community, state giving and volunteerism grants

Food Water Products


Donated

611 Local community needs

million
pounds of food

Contributed disaster assistance to


Disaster 87 communities worldwide
Products
124
Associates

Community Associate more than


volunteers scholarship program
1.25
million
volunteer
Massmart in South Africa regularly spends hours
1 to 2 percent of its profits
supporting local vulnerable people

Customer Parking lots


contributions to for disaster relief
local food banks distribution
and children’s
hospitals
Spaces
125
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Developing communities through associate,


customer and company engagement
When Sam Walton opened his first Walmart, it was a store of, by and
for the local community. Today Walmart’s 2.3 million associates are
fellow residents, friends, neighbors and relatives, and they remain
passionate about the health of local communities.
Walmart aims to enhance the vitality of our communities not
only by providing products, services and jobs through our retail
business, but also by facilitating associate volunteerism as well
as local donations from the company, the Walmart Foundation,
customers and associates.
Strengthening local communities creates a virtuous circle of value Associate engagement
for business as well as society. More stable, cohesive communities
support business growth, creating more opportunities for associates
who can better serve our customers; more engaged associates and
customers create more stable, cohesive communities.
Walmart and the Walmart Foundation strengthen communities
through the following initiatives:
• Empowering associates to engage in their community

• Supporting associates through scholarships and


hardship funds

• Investing in communities Associate support

Community investment

126
Empowering To encourage associate In conjunction with the 50th volunteerism.” For example,
volunteerism at scale, Walmart birthday of Asda in the U.K., we worked with nonprofit
associates to engage U.S. runs a program called associates travelled the country organizations Pyxera Global and
in the community Volunteerism Always Pays (VAP), celebrating local community Taproot to more systematically
through which associates earn groups and charities with a engage Walmart associates
money for eligible charities – in gift of cake and funding, in all with particular technology and
Our associates around the
the form of Walmart donations investing more than £450,000 in leadership skills in disaster- and
world contributed their time,
– simply by volunteering at more than 70 groups. technology-related charitable
expertise and money to a
least 25 hours. In 2015, 71,000 efforts in the U.S. and India.
variety of local causes, including
full- and part-time associates Walmart also piloted programs
education, environmental
volunteered more than 1.25 to better match charities to
sustainability, health and
million hours, generating $12 associates who have relevant
wellness, hunger relief and
million in Walmart donations. skills and passion, to facilitate
workforce development.
what is known as “skills-based

Developing communities through associate, customer and company engagement:


Progress against commitments
As of Fiscal Year End 2016

Initiative Progress

Empowering associates to Walmart U.S. associates volunteered more than 1.25 million hours to charitable organizations, generating
engage in their community $12 million in Walmart donations.

The Walmart Foundation has given to organizations that awarded more than 800 scholarships to Walmart
Supporting associates U.S. associates and associate dependents. Continue to support the Associates in Critical Need Trust, a public
charity.

Gave $46.5 million in community grants in 2015.


Investing in communities

127
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Strengthening local communities – Community development

Supporting the Associate Scholarship a public charity supported


program, which encourages by Walmart, the Walmart
associates the pursuit of higher Foundation, Walmart
education by associates and associates and Walmart alumni.
Sometimes unexpected events their dependents. In 2015, ACNT offers grants to U.S.
strike close to home. In several the Foundation donated to associates facing hardship as a
Associate Giving Program Walmart markets, including organizations that awarded result of an unexpected crisis
the U.S., the U.K. and Brazil, more than 800 scholarships (for example, due to a fire,
Through the Associate Giving hardship funds exist to support to Walmart U.S. associates and flood or sudden death in the
Program, the Walmart Foundation associates experiencing a crisis. associate dependents. family). In 2015, ACNT awarded
matches the voluntary charitable grants totaling over $8 million.
contributions of U.S. associates to For example, the Walmart The Wal-Mart Associates in
any of 11 charities, up to applicable Foundation also supports Critical Need Trust (ACNT) is
limits:

• Associates in Critical Need Trust


(ACNT)
• United Way Associates Lauren’s story: Help when you
• American Cancer Society
supporting need it most
• American Diabetes Association
associates Lauren and her children were
• American Heart Association
• American Indian College Fund
in Brazil understandably frightened when
their home burned down. The
• Asian & Pacific Islander In 2009, Walmart associates in house fire left them homeless;
American Scholarship Fund Brazil began “The Charity Club” they lost all of their belongings,
• Hispanic Scholarship Fund – an associate-sponsored including three beloved pets.
emergency fund – to help their Lauren’s Walmart family rallied
• United Negro College Fund behind her and provided donations
co-workers in times of sudden,
• Feeding America unexpected needs. Associates and household goods to replace
voluntarily authorize a monthly many of the things she lost.
• EarthShare
payroll deduction that is in turn
matched by Walmart Brazil Lauren has been a Walmart Lauren also turned to ACNT for
dollar-for-dollar. Any associate associate since 2012. She works as help during this difficult time.
with a qualifying emergency a supply chain manager for the She applied for and received
situation is eligible to receive grocery transportation team and is an ACNT grant, which allowed
help, whether or not they the mother of two small children. her to buy clothes and provide
donate to the fund. As of She never dreamed she would transitional lodging in a long-
2015, nearly 600 associates need the resources of ACNT – until term stay hotel with her two girls.
received help. she received a phone call from her “If it wasn’t for getting the grant
best friend with the news her from ACNT, I don’t know what I
house was on fire. would have done.”

128
Investing in local address pressing social issues percent of its profits supporting community grants within the
within a single community. We the most vulnerable people U.S., supporting hunger and
communities also ask our customers to join in surrounding communities; healthy eating, disaster relief
causes, helping to raise money this year, Massmart focused and preparedness, along
Walmart and the Walmart for nationally recognized on projects promoting early with many other causes that
Foundation have a long charities. And we make a childhood development and strengthen local communities.
tradition of supporting the special effort to invest in the facilitating school maintenance
communities where we communities where we are and repairs. The projects affect
operate, both in the U.S. and headquartered and have the more than 3,000 children under
around the world. We provide largest associate presence. the age of five.
both community and regional
grants to organizations, and we For example, Massmart in South In 2015, Walmart donated
collaborate with local groups to Africa regularly spends 1 to 2 more than $46.5 million in

Walmart customers supporting causes


Sometimes a little bit can go a Forest Restoration Bokin (OISCA), Together with customers and
long way. Our customers are Foodbank Bokin (Second Harvest participating suppliers, The “Fight
generous and support worthy Japan), Providing School Meals to Hunger. Spark Change.” campaign
causes through Walmart. Africa Bokin (Table for Two) and of Feeding America generated
Sick Childcare Bokin (Florence). $10.7 million. During the holiday
Walmart Japan continued season, the Red Kettle campaign
its store fundraising program In 2015, our U.S. and Canadian at Walmart also surpassed the
called “Bokin.” In 2015, more than stores and clubs supported $500 million mark in lifetime
9 million yen was raised for four major cause campaigns with support of The Salvation Army,
charitable programs, with Walmart the help of our customers. For thanks to customer contributions
Japan matching the contributions Children’s Miracle Network in the familiar red kettles outside
to each dollar-for-dollar. The Hospitals, associates and customers our stores and clubs.
charities included Seashore together raised over $60 million.

129
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Strengthening local communities – Community engagement

1. Canada 5. Brazil
Walmart Canada has been In 2015, Walmart stores in
Investing around a supporter of Food Banks Brazil donated more than
Canada and its local food 200 tons of food, benefiting
the world bank partners since 2011, more than 300,000 people.
donating more than $1.1 Throughout the year, stores
Outside the U.S., our international million and $630,000 in mobilize to engage with
businesses incorporate local 2015 alone. The donation is civil society organizations
investment into the normal course used to help fund programs in product campaigns with
of business. Here are some of their that will deliver food locally customers and associates.
highlights from the past year. to Canadians who need it
most. Walmart Canada’s food 6. A
 rgentina
donation amount to food Walmart Argentina’s annual
banks in FY2016 was 1 campaign, “With a little we
do a lot,” invites customers
2.2 million pounds.
to round up their change
2. Mexico and donate to worthy
In 2015, Walmart de México y causes. The campaign is
Centroamérica supported the in 86 stores around the
development of nearly 23,000 country. In 2015, AR$900,000
small suppliers, supporting the was collected, which was
local communities where we donated to Cåritas National
live and work.
2 Commission and four other
organizations.
3. Central America
In 2015, to help the 3
communities where we
operate, we performed
230 volunteer days with
participation of 8,406
volunteers who donated 5
39,713 hours to benefit more
than 1,013,635 people.

4. Chile
El Kilómetro de mi
supermercado is an initiative 4
to support the needs of
the communities within 6
a 1-kilometer radius of
each of our stores. The
program provides grants to
support local social projects
administered by NGOs.

130
7. U.K. 9. India 10. China 11. Japan
The Asda Foundation At Walmart India, associates In collaboration with Walmart Japan helped
increased its funding for and customers participated China Foundation for fund Japan’s very first in-
local disasters to £500,000 in blood donation drives Poverty Alleviation and home daycare for disabled
to help local communities to support the National Tencent Charity, Walmart children, which provides
in their time of need after Thalassemia Welfare Society. China mobilized suppliers, qualified childcare services
extreme flooding affected The donations went to customers and associates to for special needs. This
the north of England. help children affected donate to a local charitable daycare has enabled parents
by thalassemia – a blood meals program, raising to continue their careers.
8. South Africa disorder that requires blood awareness and helping
At Massmart we understand transfusion almost every day. provide nutritious meals to
that we need to support schoolchildren in poverty-
7 vulnerable people in our stricken regions.
communities. In 2015
alone, our school mobile
kitchen program enabled
the hygienic preparation of
40 million meals supplied
through the National School 11
Nutrition Program.
10
9

131
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Strengthening local communities – Community engagement

Giving back in our home office


Walmart has two global headquarters that support our operations in 28 countries around the world – Bentonville, Arkansas, and Silicon
Valley, California. We’re proud to be a part of these thriving communities and to give back to them.

families of all income levels) demand and to provide free technology field and the positive
Northwest Arkansas has been to increase the value of SNAP access to the arts for children. impact of technology on women
home to Walmart since Sam Walton assistance at local farmer’s around the world
opened his first store in Rogers, markets. San Francisco Bay Area has • Code 2040, which creates
Arkansas. Today, we operate all • Increasing access to health become our other global pathways to educational,
over the world, but we still call care. For example, the Walmart hometown – home to our global professional and entrepre-
northwest Arkansas home. In 2015, Foundation gave a grant of more .com business. Walmart and the neurial success in technology for
our global headquarters employed than $340,000 to WelcomeHealth Walmart Foundation contributed underrepresented minorities
more than 20,000 associates, (a free clinic serving the more than $5.4 million in grants • American Red Cross of the Bay
and Walmart and the Walmart uninsured and underinsured) to and in-kind giving in the San Area, which has made a positive
Foundation invested over $10 provide free dental care for low- Francisco Bay Area. The grants impact on disaster preparedness
million in grants to strengthen the income individuals and families. ranged from $250 to $300,000 and in the area, responding to 95
local community in three ways: • Enhancing quality of life by support over 250 organizations. disasters and providing support
• Providing greater access to increasing access to the arts Additionally, more than 2.3 million for 169 families
hunger relief and nutrition and recreational facilities. For pounds of food have been provided • Silicon Valley Education
education. For example, a grant example, Walmart and the to local organizations, for more than Foundation, which advocates
of almost $100,000 was given Walmart Foundation gave a 1.9 million meals. Highlights include: to enhance STEM education in
to the “Double your Dollars” $900,000 grant to The Walton • Anita Borg Institute, which Silicon Valley and the Bay Area.
program at The Jones Center Arts Center to expand and works with businesses and
for Families (an area recreational renovate the Center to better academic institutions to increase
and educational center serving accommodate community the number of women in the

132
Notes from the field: The challenge of supporting
and measuring local needs
Matching associates to Measuring impact
the right organization Last year, we gave 152,000
The nonprofit organizations community grants; we can track
that we support often have activity, but it’s very challenging
need of specific skills – legal, to track impact.
logistics, marketing, among
others – to address their Avoiding dependence
particular needs. Meanwhile, we We are proud to have
have over 2 million associates established long-term
with a broad range of skills and relationships with many
passions. Trying to match the grantees, yet we encourage
right associates with the right them to cultivate broad-based
skills to the right organization support to promote their own
in need of those skills presents sustainability over time.
a significant challenge for us
that we are just beginning to
address through “skills-based
volunteerism.”

133
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Promoting good governance


Governance
Walmart continually benchmarks ourselves against other
companies and across industries, consults with corporate
governance experts and engages with key stakeholders to
strengthen our processes at Walmart. We’re proud of our
corporate governance policies and continue to strengthen our
practices to meet changes in the landscape. To assist our Board
of Directors, the Compensation, Nominating and Governance
Committee (CNGC) oversees an annual evaluation process that is
used as a tool for promoting the effectiveness of the Board and
Board committees.
The CNGC is responsible for reviewing and advising management
regarding the company’s charitable giving strategy and the
company’s social, community and sustainability initiatives.
For more information go to: stock.walmart.com/investors/
corporate-governance.

134
In our governance structure, We recognize the importance for reviewing and advising of lead independent director,
the CEO is responsible for the of Board independence. The management regarding the who is elected annually by
general management, supervi- majority of our directors are company’s charitable giving the independent members of
sion and control of the business independent, in accordance strategy and the company’s the Board, and whose duties
and general affairs of our com- with the requirements of the social, community and include, among other matters,
pany, including the execution New York Stock Exchange. Our sustainability initiatives. The presiding over executive
of Board directives and reso- directors serve on one or more company’s charitable giving sessions of our outside
lutions. Our chairman presides of the six standing committees includes amounts donated directors and independent
over all meetings of the Board of the Board: to the Walmart Foundation, a directors. For more information
and Shareholders, and advises separately incorporated 501(c) about the duties of the lead
and counsels the CEO and (1) Audit Committee (3) that focuses its activities on independent director, please
other officers regarding our (2) Compensation, Nominating serving communities where see our Corporate Governance
business and operations. In ad- and Governance Committee Walmart operates and sources. Guidelines, available on our
dition, our lead independent (CNGC) corporate website at http://
director actively participates in (3) Executive Committee Our Board regularly reviews s2.q4cdn.com/056532643/files/
the review of Board and com- (4) Global Compensation our corporate governance doc_downloads/Gov_Docs/
mittee agendas, presides over Committee policies and practices to corporate-governance-
the meetings of our outside (5) Strategic Planning and identify areas where we can guidelines.pdf.
and independent directors Finance Committee enhance our company’s
and performs additional duties (6) Technology and corporate governance
described in our Corporate eCommerce Committee profile. For example, in 2013, From the
Governance Guidelines. our Board increased the beginning, integrity,
Each committee is governed
stock ownership guidelines
by a written charter that
We believe that our structure
outlines its specific roles in our
applicable to our CEO and opportunity, family
of having a separate CEO and certain other executive officers
chairman is the most effective
company’s governance.
of the company to further and community,
leadership configuration for align the long-term interests purpose and
Consistent with our
Walmart Shareholders. It allows of our executives and our
commitment to participating
our CEO to focus on managing
in the political process in a
Shareholders. In addition, the responsibility have
our complex daily operations Board recently amended our
and our chairman to address
thoughtful and compliant
bylaws to allow Shareholders served as our core
manner, in 2014, the Board
matters related to the responsi- owning 10 percent or more strengths and will
amended the charter of
bilities of the Board. The Board of Walmart common stock
the CNGC, requiring the
held a total of six meetings
committee to review and
to call a special Shareholders’ continue to drive
during FY2016 to review signif- meeting. The Board also
icant developments affecting
advise management regarding
amended our Corporate our success moving
the company’s legislative affairs
our company, engage in strate- Governance Guidelines to more forward.
and public policy engagement
gic planning and act on matters fully articulate (and, in some
strategy. Similarly, following its
requiring Board approval. instances, expand) the role
charter, the CNGC is responsible

135
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Promoting good governance – Culture

Culture
As a global company, Walmart celebrates the diversity of our Ethics and integrity Walmartethics.com: A website
available in 14 languages and
associate base while honoring the bond that unites us: a way of
accessible globally, where
doing business that serves our customers, drives performance stakeholders can ask questions,
and creates a positive place for us to work. Our culture of ethics and read our Statement of Ethics, submit
Walmart’s four core beliefs are at the heart of our culture and
integrity – the attitudes and ethics concerns and follow up on
conduct that help create an previously reported concerns.
guide us in how we perform our jobs:
honest, fair and compliant Global case management system: A
Service to our customers: We’re here to serve workplace – defines who we repository and system to manage
customers, support each other and give to our local are as a company and how we ethics cases.

communities. treat one another, our suppliers Global case management process:
and our customers. Today we A process we use to encourage
Respect for the individual: We value every associate, consistency across our global
summarize our ethical principles operations in the handling of
own the work we do and communicate by listening
in the company’s Statement any ethical concerns raised by
and sharing ideas. of Ethics. Throughout their stakeholders.
Strive for excellence: We work as a team and model careers with our company, we
positive examples while we innovate and improve work to provide this and other Global learning
every day. relevant tools and resources
to our associates to help them
Act with integrity: We act with the highest level of In 2015, our compliance
succeed and to promote and
integrity by being honest, fair and objective, while and ethics teams expand-
recognize ethical decision-
working to operate in compliance with all laws and ed our electronic learning
making. These resources include:
our policies.
management system to all
Global helpline: A series of global retail home office locations
These principles − as relevant today as they were when our first and local phone numbers where and some field locations.
store opened in 1962 − help define the Walmart culture and associates can ask questions and Through a combination of
report concerns 24 hours a day,
empower us to save people money so they can live better. e-learning modules and in-
seven days a week. The helpline
is equipped to handle most local structor-led training sessions,
languages in all the markets in the system improves our
which we operate. training and is designed to
reduce risk. We will continue
to roll it out to more field
locations in 2016.

136
Recognizing Ephie Smith, Canada tried to inappropriately persuade Emilio Machuca, Chile
A couple visited the Walmart Pankaj, but he stayed the course, Emilio had just finished his break
integrity in action Canada store where Ephie was assisting the investigation through when another associate pointed
working to purchase gift cards for its conclusion. out he could take extra time off
their family. When the shoppers because his supervisor was not
It’s important to recognize Martha Calderón, Central America
got to the register, they noticed there that day. Emilio informed the
our associates when they Martha became aware that some
their envelope of cash was missing. associate that it would not be fair
make ethical decisions so their associates in her facility were
Ephie found the envelope and to let someone else do his work for
example will inspire others. Our stealing from the company. Martha
immediately turned it in. The store him. Emilio did the right thing: he
global recognition program, reported the incident and followed
contacted the couple, who were respects the time he is scheduled
up to make sure action was
The Integrity in Action Award, elated. They offered Ephie a reward, to work, whether his supervisor is
taken. Her courage to stand up
celebrates associates who model which she humbly declined. there or not.
for what was right makes her a
integrity or encourage others to Toru Imamura, Japan great example of what it means Jack Howard, U.S.
do so. Associates nominate and Toru is responsible for training to live and work with integrity. A couple visited the store where
vote for candidates, and Walmart associates. He found that the Jack works and misplaced an
Maria Lenir Pereira, Brazil
recognizes the award winners explanation of our company values expensive electronic device during
Maria was using the ATM in her
at the annual Shareholders’ was difficult for some associates their visit. Jack found the device in
store to make a withdrawal when
meeting. Recipients in 2015 to understand. In response, Toru the parking lot and immediately
it began to dispense additional
included: developed a simple poster to turned it in. Because the device
money without her request. It
help his fellow associates better aided their everyday activities, they
Sue Ryles, U.K. was clear an attempt at fraud
understand how to act with were overjoyed when they learned
While processing orders for a had previously been initiated at
integrity. it had been found. Jack’s swift
customer, Sue noticed orders were the ATM. Maria notified the store
action shows how integrity helps
coming through with duplicate Dongmei Sun, China manager, the police and the bank
our customers.
items, which seemed suspicious. While working with a supplier, to ensure that the money was
She immediately shared her Dongmei was offered a large safely returned. Dante Donda, Argentina
concerns with a manager. She was sum of money in an attempt to Dante was working in one of our
Francisco Romário Lemos da
able to give a description of the gain favor with the company. She stores when he came across a
Silva, Global eCommerce, Brazil wallet with a large amount of cash
customer and, by doing so, set declined the offer and explained
After returning from a business trip, inside. He immediately turned
actions in motion to uncover Walmart’s policies and culture to
Francisco discovered the company it in. The customer who lost
an attempt at fraud. the supplier. Dongmei exemplifies
had reimbursed his expenses at the wallet wrote him a personal
how Walmart associates not only
Lucas Bonokwakhe Mvelase, almost 10 times more than the letter of gratitude, expressing her
act with integrity, but model it
South Africa expected amount. He immediately appreciation and acknowledgment
for others.
Lucas stood firm against an alleged informed Human Resources of the of Dante’s integrity and character.
external organization and provided Pankaj Sharma, India issue and returned the money.
information leading to the arrest of Pankaj discovered that a fellow Francisco said that despite facing
several of its employees for fraud- associate had been shoplifting. many difficulties in his life, he has
ulent activities within his store. As He reported the situation and always valued the integrity that
a result, he’s developed a stronger assisted the investigation to help his parents taught him. Once he
connection with his team and determine how much merchandise noticed the mistake, he knew he
increased associate engagement. had been taken. The associate had to return the funds.

137
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Promoting good governance – Ethics and compliance

Ethics and compliance


With continued advances in technology opening new growth Anti-corruption Walmart associates at all levels,
opportunities in the retail sector, Walmart has developed a and provided live, instructor-
robust, flexible ethics and compliance program to keep pace led training to more than
Walmart continues to enhance 18,000 associates. To date, we
with this evolving landscape. Around the world, online shopping its processes and systems to have provided anti-corruption
continues to grow in popularity, complementing the traditional help prevent corruption – that training to more than 1,300
shopping experience. This dual setting online and in-store reaches is, the use of improper payments external entities that interact
more customers every day, making it an exciting time to be in the or anything of value, including on our behalf.
retail business, but it also presents its own compliance challenges. gifts or travel, to secure an
improper business advantage
Our ethics and compliance program addresses 14 key areas of
from a government official or Antitrust
relevance to the changing retail sector, several of which have commercial party. In 2015 and
been noted in this report. Here, we further highlight six areas of early 2016, we published We continued our efforts to
critical importance to both our business and to our stakeholders. updated, unified anti-corruption increase associate antitrust
compliance procedures to awareness to further foster
promote consistency across conditions that help protect
all Walmart markets. We con- competition; enable open mar-
tinued to implement our kets; and enhance productivity,
Global Donations Management innovation and value to cus-
System (GDMS) to automate tomers. These efforts include
and simplify our donations providing risk-based antitrust
processes. We established a training to associates and
program to audit a sample of issuing consistent guidelines
our third-party intermediaries in and other communication tools
high-risk markets. We expanded addressing potential antitrust
our anti-corruption continuous risks. We also continue to mon-
improvement program to itor antitrust and competition
monitor progress and identify law developments worldwide,
enhancement opportunities. thereby being in a position to
Furthermore, we continued to update and enhance our ongo-
provide risk-based training to our ing compliance initiatives.
associates and third-party inter-
mediaries. In 2015 alone, we
delivered anti-corruption train-
ing to more than 100,000

138
Consumer protection Asda ethics and compliance text of the policy to deter- locations. U.S. imports restruc-
team collaborated with the mine that explanations of our tured their Customs Operations
business to create an app with practices and commitments and Post Entry areas to further
As we expand our business an algorithm that is designed are presented without unnec- drive efficiencies and increase
to serve customers in new to make it easier for store essarily complex terms. Our regulatory skill sets. During 2015
and more convenient ways, management to accurately policy covers online and offline they achieved a 98 percent pa-
we continue to implement price beer, wine and spirits and collection of data, as well as the perless clearance, and 98 percent
additional consumer protection stay in compliance with this use and sharing of our con- of entries cleared on or before
standards and controls. In new law. sumers’ personally identifiable vessel arrival.
2015, we undertook a major information. The full policy may
initiative in our international be found at: http://corporate.
markets to improve guidelines Privacy
walmart.com/privacy-security/
and processes for reviewing walmart-privacy-policy.
advertising claims. In response Our founder Sam Walton
to this, Walmart Canada created reminded us that “a promise
a new and innovative process we make is a promise we
Trade
that streamlined the advertising keep,” and it’s our promise to
review process. customers that we respect the Global trade remains a complex
trust they place in us and the and ever-changing environ-
We also focused on improving privacy of the information they ment. This necessitates strong
controls to help us price our share. In March 2015, Walmart standards and procedures in
products accurately. When revised the online presentation each Walmart market. In 2015
new pricing laws are passed, of our U.S. privacy policy to we focused on creating and
the ethics and compliance make it more readable and documenting these proce-
team often has to work quickly user-friendly. Implementing dures. We assessed our trade
with the business to keep us industry-tested best practices, risks and sanction policies
in compliance. For instance, our website presents a lay- in each international market
in 2014 the U.K. government ered version of the policy that and developed new training
introduced legislation that set permits readers to view a more programs designed to meet
a minimum price on beer, wine accessible, condensed version. emerging needs. In U.S. exports
and spirits, depending on the Readers can also expand each we increased the quality of
level of alcohol content. This section of the condensed export filings by centralizing
variable pricing model made version to review more detailed the classification function and
accurately pricing alcohol explanations of our practices. implementing export systems
very difficult. In response, the In addition, we reviewed the at a number of Sam’s Club

139
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Promoting good governance – Ethics and compliance and political engagement

Ethics and compliance continued


Labor and In 2015, we strengthened This year we placed a higher
our labor and employment priority on initiatives that
employment compliance efforts in the U.S. put the customer and store
compliance and international markets by: associates first by:
• Enhancing our governance • Implementing enhancements
Labor and employment laws framework for the company’s to the associate scheduling
differ in each country where immigration compliance system
we operate. Our ethics and program • Increasing associate
compliance team works • Working with the business understanding of customers
with our human resource to make necessary policy or with disabilities
professionals to promote process changes to enhance
a work environment that • Collaborating with our human
our programs resource business associates
supports the needs of our
associates, encourages growth • Leveraging strong compliance to create efficient solutions
opportunities and creates programs and subject matter
fair and consistent labor and expertise across our markets
employment practices for to reduce labor fines
every associate. • Working with legal, HR and
business leaders to develop
As business needs evolve and and enhance standards and
new initiatives emerge, we controls and to implement
leverage our expertise to training, communication
increase operational and HR and monitoring on key labor
effectiveness. compliance issues

140
Political engagement
We take seriously our commitment to provide additional Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Political understand details around our
transparency into our political engagement. As a result, we included Action Committee for state lobbying efforts and relat-
this important issue in our 2013 and 2014 Global Responsibility Responsible Government ed reported expenses. A state
(WALPAC) is our primary vehicle lobbying “report card” is posted
Reports. In FY2014, the Walmart Board of Directors voted to amend
for financially contributing to on our corporate website
the charter of the Compensation, Nominating and Governance the political process in the providing our annual reported
Committee, adding to its responsibilities and obligations the review United States. WALPAC is lobbying expense and links to
and oversight of the company’s legislative affairs and public policy funded solely with voluntary state lobbying reports. In 2016
engagement strategy. Walmart’s Executive Vice President of contributions from eligible we will also provide a statement
Corporate Affairs provides the committee with regular updates, at associates. To access informa- related to expenses reported
tion about federal contributions for federal lobbying so that
least annually, concerning the company’s strategy and support of
made from WALPAC in the U.S., information is easier to access.
key U.S. policy objectives. The briefing includes information related please go to www.fec.gov and The state and federal lobbying
to stakeholder relationships, elected official outreach, lobbying, search the appropriate disclo- information is updated quar-
political giving and our commitment to governance compliance. sure database for “Walmart.” terly. Links to other publicly
Walmart is a member of certain available information concern-
U.S.-based trade associations ing our federal policy-oriented
that the company believes can activities in the U.S., such as
assist Walmart in achieving its federal lobbying disclosure
long-term strategic objectives. reports, which are maintained
Some of these U.S. trade by the United States House of
associations engage in political Representatives and the United
activities, including the making States Senate, can be found at
of political contributions and lobbyingdisclosure.house.gov
lobbying. Walmart periodically and http://senate.gov/legisla-
reviews its memberships in such tive/Public_Disclosure/LDA_
trade associations. reports.html.

In addition, we have policies The above links, as well as our


and oversight in place to com- corporate government relations
ply with federal, state and local policy, are available on our
laws and regulations relating to Walmart corporate website,
the reporting requirements of http://corporate.walmart.com/
corporate political contributions policies.
made in the U.S. We frequently
review our process to help
file public reports accurately
and appropriately. In 2015 we
made it easier for Shareholders
and other interested parties to

141
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Promoting good governance – Public policy

Public policy
Walmart’s mission is to save people money so they In 2015, we updated the enable us to streamline our
can live better, and customers around the world structure of corporate affairs work with governments, NGOS
trust us to deliver on that promise. We pursue our teams to enhance alignment and international organizations
between global government to assist in shaping public
mission by creating more economic opportunity for
affairs and public policy. In policy that helps improve
our customers and associates, while putting tools in addition to internal subject the lives of our customers,
place that can help grow our suppliers, partners and matter experts in the associates, workers in our
the economy more broadly. Through our store and international, state, federal supply chain and communities
e-commerce growth and presence in 28 countries, and local markets, we have we serve. Walmart will continue
including the U.S., we work to help strengthen local dedicated policy experts to advocate for our customers
communities in a way that is sustainable for the focused on new and emerging while leading on issues that
issues such as food, supply support industry efforts and
planet and people.
chain, environmental, labor our mission to create growth
and e-commerce policy. This and opportunity for our
new structure will better customers and associates.

142
Global Reporting Index
General Standard Disclosures
Standard
Standard Disclosure Title/ Topic Response
Disclosure
Strategy and analysis
G4-1 Provide a statement from the most senior decision-maker Advocating for the customer, page 1
of the organization.
G4-2 Provide a description of key impacts, risks, and opportunities. Advocating for the customer, page 1
A letter from our Chief Sustainability Officer, page 1
Our approach to global responsibility: Shared value, page 7
Form 10-K
Organizational profile
G4-3 Report the name of the organization. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
G4-4 Report the primary brands, products, and services. Form 10-K
G4-5 Report the location of the organization’s headquarters. Bentonville, Ark.
G4-6 Report the number of countries where the organization Form 10-K
operates. Annual Report
A snapshot of Walmart, page 4
G4-7 Report the nature of ownership and legal form. Form 10-K
G4-8 Report the markets served (including geographic breakdown, A snapshot of Walmart, page 4
sectors served, and types of customers and beneficiaries). Annual Report
Form 10-K
G4-9 Report the scale of the organization. A snapshot of Walmart, page 4
Annual Report
Form 10-K
G4-10 Breakdown of Employee Type. Economic mobility – Diversity and inclusion, pages 14, 20-23
G4-11 Report the percentage of total employees covered by Form 10-K
collective bargaining agreements.
G4-12 Describe the organization’s supply chain. Spotlight: Sustainable food chain, page 88
Spotlight: Women’s Economic Empowerment, page 38
The Sustainability Index, page 56
Form 10-K
Standards for suppliers
G4-13 Report any significant changes during the reporting period Form 10-K
regarding the organization’s size, structure, ownership, or its
supply chain.

143
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Global Reporting Index

Standard
Standard Disclosure Title/ Topic Response
Disclosure
G4-14 Report whether and how the precautionary approach or Walmart addresses the precautionary approach for products with
principle is addressed by the organization. the application of the Walmart Sustainability Index. We ask vendors
in our consumer goods product categories to complete an assess-
ment to inform our merchandising and product-placement decisions
for 2015 and beyond. Walmart products are also required to comply
with FDA and government regulations. Walmart products and
suppliers adhere to a variety of internal and external standards. For
suppliers, this includes our Standards for Suppliers, which include
13 fundamental expectations from our suppliers related to social
and environmental conditions. These Standards are utilized to
evaluate employment practices and environmental compliance in
those facilities producing merchandise for sale by Walmart.
G4-15 List externally developed economic, environmental and Spotlight: Women’s Economic Empowerment, page 38
social charters, principles, or other initiatives to which the Enhancing Sustainability – Environmental Defense Fund UL’s
organization subscribes or which it endorses. WERCSmart, Closed Loop Fund, TSC Common Chemical Criteria
Task Force, CDP
Zero waste – packaging and recycling, pages 70-79
Transparency and quality, pages 102-105
Energy and emissions- operations, pages 60-65
Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
G4-16 List memberships of associations (such as industry associations) Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
and national or international advocacy organizations. Enhancing sustainability, page 54
Identified material aspects and boundaries
G4-17 List all entities included in the organization’s consolidated A snapshot of Walmart, page 4
financial statements or equivalent documents. Annual Report
Form 10-K
G4-18 Explain the process for defining the report content and the Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
Aspect Boundaries.
G4-19 List all the material Aspects identified in the process for defining Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
report content.
G4-20 For each material Aspect, report the Aspect Boundary within Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
the organization. Report whether the Aspect is material within
the organization.
G4-21 For each material Aspect, report the Aspect Boundary outside Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
the organization.
G4-22 Report the effect of any restatements of information provided There were no restatements of information provided in
in previous reports, and the reasons for such restatements. previous reports.
G4-23 Report significant changes from previous reporting periods in None
the Scope and Aspect Boundaries.
Stakeholder engagement
G4-24 Provide a list of stakeholder groups engaged by Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
the organization.
G4-25 Report the basis for identification and selection of stakeholders Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
with whom to engage.
G4-26 Report the organization’s approach to stakeholder Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
engagement.

144
Standard
Standard Disclosure Title/ Topic Response
Disclosure
G4-27 Report key topics and concerns that have been raised through Stakeholder perspectives, pages 8-9
stakeholder engagement, and how the organization has Enhancing sustainability, page 54
responded to those key topics and concerns. Our approach to global responsibility: Shared value, page 7
Report profile
G4-28 Reporting period for information provided. FY2016 (February 1, 2015 through January 31, 2016)
Limited inclusion of 2016 (January – April)
G4-29 Date of most recent previous report. April, 2015
G4-30 Reporting cycle. Annually
G4-31 Provide the contact point for questions regarding the report or CASSR@wal-mart.com
its contents.
G4-32 Report the ‘in accordance’ option the organization has chosen. ‘In accordance’– Core
G4-33 Report the organization’s policy and current practice with We did not seek external assurance for this report.
regard to seeking external assurance for the report.
Governance
G4-34 Report the governance structure of the organization, including Governance, page 134
committees of the highest governance body. Proxy statement
CNGC Charter
G4-35 Report the process for delegating authority for economic, CNGC Charter
environmental, and social topics from the highest governance
body to senior executives and other employees.
G4-36 Report whether the organization has appointed an executive- Governance, page 134
level position or positions with responsibility for economic, CNGC Charter
environmental, and social topics, and whether post holders
report directly to the highest governance body.
G4-37 Report processes for consultation between stakeholders and Proxy statement
the highest governance body on economic, environmental, Corporate governance guidelines
and social topics.
G4-38 Report the composition of the highest governance body Proxy statement
and its committees. Corporate governance guidelines
Form 10-K
G4-39 Report whether the Chair of the highest governance body is Governance, page 134
also an executive officer.
G4-40 Report the nomination and selection processes for the highest Proxy statement
governance body and its committees, and the criteria used for CNGC Charter
nominating and selecting highest governance body members.
G4-41 Report processes for the highest governance body to ensure Proxy statement
conflicts of interest are avoided and managed. Statement of ethics, page 136
G4-42 Report the highest governance body’s and senior executives’ Governance, page 134
roles in the development, approval, and updating of the CNGC Charter
organization’s purpose, value or mission statements, strategies,
policies, and goals related to economic, environmental, and
social impacts.
G4-43 Report the measures taken to develop and enhance the Governance, page 134
highest governance body’s collective knowledge of economic, CNGC Charter
environmental, and social topics.
G4-45 Report the highest governance body’s role in the identification Proxy statement
and management of economic, environmental and social
impacts, risks, and opportunities.

145
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Global Reporting Index

Standard
Standard Disclosure Title/ Topic Response
Disclosure
G4-46 Report the highest governance body’s role in reviewing the Proxy statement
effectiveness of the organization’s risk management processes CNGC Charter
for economic, environmental, and social topics.
G4-47 Report the frequency of the highest governance body’s Governance, page 134
review of economic, environmental, and social impacts,
risks, and opportunities.
G4-49 Report the process for communicating critical concerns to the Statement of ethics, page 136
highest governance body. Proxy statement
G4-51 Report the remuneration policies for the highest governance Proxy statement
body and senior executives.
G4-52 Report the process for determining remuneration. Proxy statement
G4-53 Report how stakeholders’ views are sought and taken into Proxy statement
account regarding remuneration.
Ethics and integrity
G4-56 Describe the organization’s values, principles, standards, and Statement of ethics, page 136
norms of behavior such as codes of conduct and codes of ethics.
G4-57 Report the internal and external mechanisms for seeking Statement of ethics, page 136
advice on ethical and lawful behavior, and matters related to
organizational integrity, such as helplines or advice lines.
G4-58 Report the internal and external mechanisms for reporting Statement of ethics, page 136
concerns about unethical or unlawful behavior, and matters
related to organizational integrity, such as escalation through
line management, whistleblowing mechanisms, or hotlines.

Specific Standard Disclosures


Category: Economic
Aspect: Economic performance
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Creating economic opportunity, page 12
G4-EC1 Direct economic value generated and distributed Form 10-K
Our approach to global responsibility: Shared value, page 7
Strengthening local communities, page 116
G4-EC2 Financial implications and other risks and opportunities for the Form 10-K
organization’s activities due to climate change Enhancing sustainability, page 54
G4-EC3 Coverage of the organization’s defined benefit plan obligations Form 10-K
Creating economic opportunity, page 12
Aspect: Market presence
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Form 10-K
Creating economic opportunity, page 12
G4-EC5 Ratios of standard entry-level wage by gender compared with The ratio of our standard entry-level hourly wage to local
local minimum wage at significant locations of operation minimum wage varies from location to location around the
world. This variation is necessary to comply with local conditions
and with national wage minimums in countries that set them.

Additionally, beginning in 2015, Walmart has invested $2.7 billion


in wages, benefits, and training for Walmart associates in the
U.S. over two years.

146
Standard
Standard Disclosure Title/ Topic Response
Disclosure
Aspect: Indirect economic impacts
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Creating economic opportunity, page 12
G4-EC7 Development and impact of infrastructure investments Creating economic opportunity, page 12
and services supported Strengthening local communities, page 116
Category: Environmental
Aspect: Energy
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Reducing energy and emissions, pages 58-61
G4-EN3 Energy consumption within the organization Reducing energy and emissions, pages 58-61
CDP Climate Filing, page 62
G4-EN4 Energy consumption outside of the organization Reducing energy and emissions, pages 58-61
CDP Climate Filing, page 62
Aspect: Water
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Preserving natural resources, pages 80-87
G4-EN8 Total water withdrawal by source Preserving natural resources – water, pages 80, 84-85
CDP Water Filing, page 62
G4-EN9 Water sources significantly affected by withdrawal of water Preserving natural resources – water, pages 80, 84-85
CDP Water Filing, page 62
G4-EN10 Percentage and total volume of water recycled and reused Preserving natural resources – water, pages 80, 84-85
CDP Water Filing, page 62
Aspect: Biodiversity
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Preserving natural resources, pages 80-87
G4-EN13 Habitats protected or restored Preserving natural resources – land, pages 80, 86-87
Aspect: Emissions
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Reducing energy and emissions, pages 58-61
G4-EN15 Direct greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (Scope 1) Energy and emissions – operations, pages 60-65
CDP Climate Filing, page 62
G4-EN16 Energy indirect greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (Scope 2) Energy and emissions – operations, pages 60-65
CDP Climate Filing, page 62
G4-EN17 Other indirect greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (Scope 3) CDP Climate Filing, page 62
G4-EN18 Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions intensity CDP Climate Filing, page 62
G4-EN19 Reduction of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions CDP Climate Filing, page 62
Aspect: Effluents and waste
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Toward a zero waste future, pages 70-79
Preserving natural resources, pages 80-87
G4-EN22 Total water discharge by quality and destination CDP Water Filing, page 62
Aspect: Products and services
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Enhancing sustainability, page 54
G4-EN27 Extent of impact mitigation of environmental impacts of Enhancing sustainability, page 54
products and services
Aspect: Transport
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Reducing energy and emissions, pages 58-61

147
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. | 2016 Global Responsibility Report

Global Reporting Index

Standard
Standard Disclosure Title/ Topic Response
Disclosure
G4-EN30 Significant environmental impacts of transporting products and Energy and emissions – operations, Efficiency in our U.S. fleet,
other goods and materials for the organization’s operations, and Improving our fleet’s efficiency, page 65
transporting members of the workforce
Aspect: Supplier environmental assessment
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
pages 108-109
Standards for suppliers
G4-EN33 Significant actual and potential negative environmental Preserving natural resources, pages 80-87
impacts in the supply chain and actions taken Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
pages 108-109
Progress against commitments, page 41
Sourcing and compliance, pages 40-43
Standards for suppliers
Category: Social
Sub-category: Labor practices and decent work
Aspect: employment
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Enhancing the economic mobility and inclusion of workers in
retail and its product supply chains, pages 14-15
Standards for suppliers
G4-LA2 Benefits provided to full-time employees that are not provided Economic mobility and inclusion: Progress against
to temporary or part-time employees, by significant locations commitments, pages 15-16
of operation
Aspect: Occupational health and safety
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
pages 108-109
G4-LA6 Type of injury and rates of injury, occupational diseases, lost Maintaining safety, health and environmental compliance
days, and absenteeism, and total number of work-related in our operations, pages 108-109
fatalities, by region and by gender
Aspect: Training and education
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Enhancing the economic mobility and inclusion of workers in
retail and its product supply chains, pages 14-15
G4-LA10 Programs for skills management and lifelong learning that Economic mobility – associates, pages 14-19
support the continued employability of employees and
assist them in managing career endings
Aspect: Diversity and equal opportunity
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Fostering diversity and inclusion, pages 14, 20-23
Culture, pages 136-137
G4-LA12 Composition of governance bodies and breakdown of employees Economic mobility – diversity and inclusion, pages 14, 20-23
per employee category according to gender, age group, minority
group membership, and other indicators of diversity
Aspect: Supplier assessment for labor practices
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
pages 108-109
Standards for suppliers
G4-LA14 Percentage of new suppliers that were screened using labor Sourcing and compliance, pages 40-43
practices criteria Standards for suppliers

148
Standard
Standard Disclosure Title/ Topic Response
Disclosure
Sub-category: Human rights
Aspect: Child labor
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
pages 108-109
Ethics and compliance, pages 138-140
Standards for suppliers
G4-HR5 Operations and suppliers identified as having significant risk Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
for incidents of child labor, and measures taken to contribute pages 108-109
to the effective abolition of child labor Ethics and compliance, pages 138-140
Standards for suppliers
Aspect: Forced or compulsory labor
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
pages 108-109
Ethics and compliance, pages 138-140
G4-HR6 Operations and suppliers identified as having significant risk Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
for incidents of forced or compulsory labor, and measures pages 108-109
to contribute to the elimination of all forms of forced or Ethics and compliance pages 138-140
compulsory labor Standards for suppliers
Aspect: Assessment
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Ethics and compliance, pages 138-140
G4-HR9 Total number and percentage of operations that have been Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
subject to human rights reviews or impact assessments pages 108-109
Standards for suppliers
Aspect: Supplier human rights assessment
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Supporting the safety and dignity of workers everywhere,
pages 108-109
Standards for suppliers
G4-HR10 Percentage of new suppliers that were screened using human Sourcing and compliance, pages 40-43
rights criteria Standards for suppliers
Sub-category: Society
Aspect: Local communities
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Strengthening local communities, page 116
G4-SO1 Percentage of operations with implemented local community Strengthening local communities, pages 116, 126-133
engagement, impact assessments, and development programs
Sub-category: Product responsibility
Aspect: Customer health and safety
G4-DMA Generic Disclosures on Management Approach Enhancing sustainability, page 54
Spotlight: Sustainability in the food supply chain, page 88-89
Providing access to affordable, sustainable, and healthier food,
pages 90-101
G4-PR1 Percentage of significant product and service categories for Spotlight: The Sustainability Index, pages 56-57
which health and safety impacts are assessed for improvement Food – increase access, reduce waste, pages 92-101
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (NYSE: WMT)
702 S.W. 8th Street
Bentonville, Arkansas 72716 USA
479-273-4000
walmart.com

You might also like