Professional Documents
Culture Documents
148–168, 2008
0160-7383/$ - see front matter Ó 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Printed in Great Britain
www.elsevier.com/locate/atoures
doi:10.1016/j.annals.2007.06.011
A NEEDS-FUNCTIONS MODEL OF
TOURISM DISTRIBUTION
Douglas G. Pearce
Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand
Abstract: This paper contributes to the development of a stronger conceptual basis for the
study of tourism distribution by presenting a generalized model emphasizing the needs of
tourists and the functions required to meet them. The model is developed by synthesizing
and reinterpreting a large body of empirical findings from New Zealand in the light of the
fundamental principles of distribution drawn from the wider literature. It is structured
around the needs, expressed in terms of time, place, form, and possession utilities, of three
segments—independent, customized, and package—and the functions undertaken by suppli-
ers, intermediaries, and the tourists themselves in three locations: the market, en route,
and at the destination. Keywords: distribution, customers, intermediaries, suppliers, chan-
nels. Ó 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
INTRODUCTION
This paper develops a generalized model of tourism distribution
emphasizing the needs of tourists and the functions required to fulfil
those needs. It represents the penultimate stage in a major five-year
project investigating the structure and functioning of tourism distribu-
tion channels in New Zealand. Begun in 2002, the project aims at
developing a more systematic understanding of the country’s diverse
distribution channels and examining ways of increasing their effective-
ness (Pearce 2003). Research to date has systematically investigated
these for particular markets, regions, and sectors; identified the factors
148
DOUGLAS PEARCE 149
The Model
On this basis, the first set of ‘‘significant features or relationships’’
might be simplified and structured as in Figure 1. The vertical axis
depicts the nature of demand segmented by type of travel and major
154 NEEDS-FUNCTIONS MODEL
bookings and purchase. This is especially the case with circuit travel
where en route distribution is practiced in gateways to capture demand
on arrival in a country or region and in nodes a night or two away from
the destination in question (Pearce and Tan 2006; Stuart et al 2005).
As noted earlier, this also meets the needs of independent tourists
seeking advance bookings but having differing time-place require-
ments and may involve reduced levels of service to those carrying out
such transactions in the market. Again, use of information centers
and other sector providers are common ways of doing this. Chain-
owned or franchised accommodation properties may benefit from in-
tra-group referrals or bookings while networked carriers will have their
own set of outlets through which bookings for onward travel to the
next destination can be made (Pearce and Sahli in press). In many in-
stances, however, intermediaries will be bypassed and the tourist will
simply call ahead or book online. Others still may attempt to reach
independent tourists before they leave home. Traditionally this has
been done mainly by advertising, for example in accommodation
guides, or by reliance on word of mouth. Carriers may have their
own outlets in the markets they serve. More recently, online channels
have opened up distribution opportunities for carriers and other sup-
pliers as well as for consumers and intermediaries.
Consideration of the functions of distribution aids understanding of
the changing role of online channels. Potentially, online channels of-
fer great scope for bridging the gap between consumers and producers
by making tourism products continuously available in the market, en
route, or at the destination, indeed from anywhere the Internet can
be accessed. In practice the impacts of online distribution have been
variable and, at least in the New Zealand case, the adoption of these
channels should not yet be overstated (Pearce and Sahli in press;
Pearce and Schott 2005; Tan and Pearce 2005). Variation occurs by
function, sector, and channel member.
In terms of functions, it is useful to distinguish among information
search, sorting, buying, and selling and consider who is performing
these functions. Effectively, use of online distribution channels has
meant much of the effort in looking for information and carrying
out transactions has been transferred from intermediaries and suppli-
ers to the consumer. The ease of information search is related to sev-
eral factors including the technology available and the degree of
sorting which occurs. Increasingly sophisticated search engines facili-
tate the search and sorting of information on individual suppliers’ web-
sites (Hewitt 2006) while third-party websites provide varying levels of
assortment, depending on whether they serve a particular sector (such
as transport and accommodation) or destination. While websites may
provide a range of information, they do not generally offer advice in
the same way that travel agents or information center staff do, nor have
they in many instances established the same levels of confidence in
tourists as guidebooks (Pearce and Schott 2005).
Opportunities for booking and purchase also vary depending on the
level of sophistication of the online channel. Some, such as those pro-
vided by major carriers, hotel chains, and e-intermediaries, may offer
164 NEEDS-FUNCTIONS MODEL
CONCLUSION
Going back to basics and focusing on the fundamental principles of
distribution has enabled a large body of comparable empirical material
to be abstracted, synthesized, and interpreted more fully. This in turn
has permitted a more systematic and comprehensive approach to the
analysis of tourism distribution, one that illustrates more explicitly
the needs of different segments and the functions that different chan-
nel members perform, that demonstrates the necessity to consider
more fully the activities that occur in different settings from the market
through to the destination and from one sector to another. The needs-
function model presented has practical applications and also provides
a sounder conceptual basis for further research.
An immediate outcome of this work is that it is perhaps no longer
useful to refer simply to tourism distribution per se. Rather, a more dif-
ferentiated approach must be adopted, one that takes fuller account of
the tourist segments being served or targeted and their specific needs.
While some commonalities do occur, especially in terms of packaged
tours where products from the various sectors are bundled together
(Figure 2), important sectoral differences have also been shown sug-
gesting accommodation, transport, and attractions providers may need
DOUGLAS PEARCE 165
REFERENCES
del Alcázar Martı́nez, B.
2002 Los Canales de Distribución en el Sector Turı́stico. Madrid: ESIC Editorial.
Alderson, W.
1958 Factors Governing the Development of Marketing Channels. In Marketing
Channels for Manufactured Products, R. Clewett, ed., pp. 5–34. Homewood:
Irwin.
Bitner, M., and B. Booms
1982 Trends in Travel and Tourism Marketing: The Changing Structure of
Distribution Channels. Journal of Travel Research 20(4):39–44.
Buckley, P.
1987 Tourism: An Economic Transactions Analysis. Tourism Management
8:190–194.
Bucklin, L.
1966 A Theory of Distribution Channel Structure. IBER Special Publications,
Graduate School of Business Administration. University of California:
Berkeley.
Bucklin, L.
1972 Competition and Evolution in the Distributive Trades. Englewood Cliffs:
Prentice-Hall.
Buhalis, D.
2001 Tourism Distribution Channels: Practices and Processes. In Tourism
Distribution Channels: Practices, Issues and Transformations, D. Buhalis and
E. Laws, eds., pp. 7–32. London: Continuum.
Buhalis, D., and E. Laws
2001 Tourism Distribution Channels: Practices, Issues and Transformations.
London: Continuum.
Coelho, F., and C. Easingwood
2004 Multiple Channels Systems in Services: Pros, Cons and Issues. The Service
Industries Journal 24(5):1–29.
Frazier, G.
1999 Organizing and Managing Channels of Distribution. Journal of the
Academy of Marketing Science 27(2):226–240.
Garnham, R.
2005 Corporate Travel Agents: Channels of Distribution: An Evaluation. In
Sharing Tourism Knowledge. Proceedings of the CAUTHE Conference, P.
Tremblay and A. Boyle, eds., Darwin: Charles Darwin University.
Haggett, P., and R. Chorley
1967 Models, Paradigms and the New Geography. In Models in Geography, R.
Chorley and P. Haggett, eds., pp. 20–41. London: Methuen.
Hewitt, C.
2006 Online Accommodation Bookings: The Future Innovation through
Disruption. Paper Presented at the Tourism Futures Forum, Melbourne.
Hudson, S., and N. Lang
2002 A Destination Case Study of Marketing Tourism Online: Banff, Canada.
Journal of Vacation Marketing 8(2):155–165.
King, B., and H. Choi
1999 Travel Industry Structure in Fast Growing but Immature Outbound
Markets: The Case of Korea to Australia travel. International Journal of
Tourism Research 1:111–125.
DOUGLAS PEARCE 167
Schott, C.
2007 Selling Adventure Tourism: A Distribution Channels Perspective. Interna-
tional Journal of Tourism Research.
Sharda, S., and D. Pearce
2006 Tourism Distribution in Emerging Markets: The Case of Indian Travel to
New Zealand. Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research 11:339–353.
Smith, K.
In press The Distribution of Event Tickets. Event Management.
Smith, K., and R. Garnham
2006 Distribution Channels for Convention Tourism: Association Conventions
in Wellington, New Zealand. Journal of Convention and Event Tourism
8(1):1–30.
Stern, L. W., and A. El-Ansary
1988 Marketing Channels. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
1992 Marketing Channels (4th ed.). Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
Stuart, P., D. Pearce, and A. Weaver
2005 Tourism Distribution Channels in Peripheral Regions: The Case of
Southland, New Zealand. Tourism Geographies 7:235–256.
Swarbrooke, J.
2001 Distribution channels: Ethics and Sustainability. In Tourism Distribution
Channels: Practices, Issues and Transformations, D. Buhalis and E. Laws, eds.,
pp. 87–105. London: Continuum.
Tan, R., and D. Pearce
2005 Providers’ and Intermediaries’ Use of the Internet in Tourism Distribu-
tion. In New Zealand Tourism and Hospitality Research Conference 2004, K.
Smith and C. Schott, eds., pp. 424–432. Wellington: Victoria University of
Wellington.
Taniguchi, M.
2006 Structure and Function of the Tourism Distribution Channels between
Japan and New Zealand. Proceedings of the 2006 New Zealand Tourism and
Hospitality Research Conference.
Ujma, D.
2001 Distribution Channels for Tourism: Theory and Issues. In Tourism
Distribution Channels: Practices Issues and Transformations, D. Buhalis and
E. Laws, eds., pp. 33–52. London: Continuum.
Wahab, S., J. Crampon, and L. Rothfield
1976 Tourism Marketing. London: Tourism International Press.
Wynne, C., P. Berthon, L. Pitt, M. Ewing, and J. Napoli
2001 The Impact of the Internet on the Distribution Value Chain: The Case of
the South African Tourism Industry. International Marketing Review
18(4):420–431.
Yamamoto, D., and A. Gill
2002 Issues of Globalisation and Reflexivity in the Japanese Tourism Production
System: The Case of Whistler, British Columbia. The Professional Geographer
54(1):83–93.
Received 28 January 2007. Resubmitted 12 April 2007. Resubmitted 20 April 2007. Final
version 6 June 2007. Accepted June 15 2007. Refereed anonymously. Coordinating Editor:
Russell Arthur Smith