Professional Documents
Culture Documents
POPULATION MOVEMENT IN A
CHANGING ENVIRONMENT
POLICY PAPER
2008
1
from degraded and unviable environmental conditions security. Over-exploitation, coupled with the use of
or from disasters triggered by natural hazards such unsustainable practices, accelerates resource degradation
as earthquakes, volcanoes and, more recently, extreme causing more vulnerability and poverty. The socio-
climate-related disasters. Development projects such as economic situation of many developing countries reduces
dam construction, poorly sited housing in floodplains their ability to cope and respond to climate change. If
and inappropriate agricultural schemes also contribute to vulnerable communities and governments are not assisted
population movement linked to environmental factors. to meet the extra challenges posed by climate change,
environmentally induced population movement is likely to
Climate change has become one of the main factors of become a humanitarian crisis.
both sudden and gradual environmental change, and is
increasing the risk and rate of environmental migration
2.2 The impacts of population movement on the
and displacement. Global temperature has risen as a result
of contemporary greenhouse gas emissions, disrupting
environment
local weather patterns, disturbing livelihood practices Lessons are being learned from the mass population
and increasing weather-related hazards in frequency and movement that have occurred in the past 20 years. Many
intensity. Melting ice caps are causing a sea-level rise that of the impacts are connected to the environment and
threatens homes and livelihoods through coastal flooding. are likely to become more severe with climate change
Climate change is also increasing vulnerability by and the risk of growing flows of migrants and displaced
weakening or even destroying livelihoods and protective persons. In addition to a deteriorating situation at the
ecosystems, as well as by accelerating land degradation place of origin, population movement also puts pressure
and erosion. These effects also contribute to decreasing on resources and ecosystems in the receiving areas as
the adaptive, coping and recovering capacity of populations well, some of which might already be stressed by climate
who may be periodically or constantly faced with disasters change and have limited capacity – and willingness from
and environmental degradation. the host population – to accept additional people. This
could lead to further human insecurity such as epidemics,
Regardless of current emission reductions, climate change
food insecurity, water scarcity and pressure for grazing
impacts will continue to adversely affect hundreds of
land for livestock, some of which may end with conflict.
millions of people. It is projected that migration or
Even short-term, temporary migration or displacement
displacement may be an adaptation mechanism in some
can cause severe impacts and conflict in the receiving
cases or a last resort solution for many of the most vulnerable
areas as well as on their return, for example if there is
affected populations. This would is particularly affect
pre-existing ethnic tension, political instability, with land
Small Island or Developing States facing inundation as a
grabbing and loss of property, or when victims surrender
result of sea-level rise, which might not have the resources
to human trafficking. These social and environmental
to invest in coastal barriers, or where the communities
effects increase the risk of recurrent population movement
will not be able to buy land elsewhere.
and a downward spiral of conflict.
While awareness of these issues is growing, it is important
An additional concern is rural to urban population
to understand that environmental change is rarely the sole
movement. As of 2005, some 3.2 billion people were
push factor in environment-related population movement
living in cities but this number is expected to increase to
As impacts become more severe, however, this is likely to
more than 5 billion in the next 25 years. There has been
change, and the environment will become in some cases
a discernible decrease of rural activities, a loss of capacity
the determining factor to migration or displacement
and skilled labour and a decline in productivity, leaving
decisions.
community members who may have remained in a more
There are complex and often cyclic relationships – some vulnerable situation. In addition, rural to urban population
of which are not yet fully clarified – between climate movement is often permanent and the receiving cities,
change hazards, environmental degradation, population which are often already strained, do not have adapted
growth, poverty, development deficiency and human services and infrastructures to receive uncontrolled flows
insecurity. Often, when these factors coincide, they re- of people. Urban expansion is increasing poverty, while
inforce each other. Population growth and rapid unplanned unplanned settlements are forcing people to live in unsafe
development -- particularly in urban areas – places environments, which are more and more vulnerable to
additional pressure on natural resources, livelihoods and disasters and will possibly promote further population
services. The pressures of northern consumption and movement.
trades can also influence the practices and schemes of
developing countries, and negatively affect local human
2
Seasonal population movement is becoming an essential 3. THE PRINCIPLES UNDERPINNING
part of some communities’ structure, despite the many
accompanying negative psychological and social effects PROACT’S APPROACH
like ageing populations or the loss of traditional practices
and customs. Remaining family members often have to
diversify their income with unsustainable practices, such 3.1 Encouraging a holistic approach with multi-
as deforestation, that contribute further to degrading sectoral and multi-level planning
their quality of life. As climatic conditions worsen these
Climate change is a cause and consequence aggravator and
temporary migrants may leave for longer periods of time:
is linked to many other migration or displacement factors
an increasing number may not return and eventually the
and impacts. Long- and short-term support must take
families follow.
into account the fragility of the environment to climate
2.3 Limited institutional support change and our dependence on it, while also understanding
how it is related to other economic and social factors and
There are two main points in the conceptual debate about impacts.
environmentally induced population movement. First,
recognition of the environment as a push factor makes In order to overcome the complexity of the causes
it hard to define and quantify environmental migrants and consequences of environment related population
or displaced persons. Some even forcibly question their movement, a multi-sectoral and multi-level approach is
existence. This lack of conceptual clarity to the debate fundamental. Environmental changes are being studied,
has, in part, resulted in a wide variance on the numbers of and increasingly understood, practical solutions can be
people predicted to be affected by environmental change found to manage many of these changes but greater co-
by the middle of this century. On top of this, there still operation is required between different sectors and lessons
needs to be common understanding on the types of already learned need to be shared. Working relationships
migrants or displaced persons: the following concerns between actors in all fields – environmental as well as
will have to be addressed -- slow or sudden movements; social – are necessary to ensure better communication and
temporary, seasonal or permanent settlements; internal or co-operation. Multi-level approaches involving different
cross border; forced or voluntary; a last resort survival or stakeholder groups such as local people, private companies,
an adaptation mechanism? local and national governments, academic institutions,
non-governmental organisations and donor agencies are
A second problem relates to the lack of a responsible needed to enhance the sustainability and the scale of
authority that would provide such migrants or displaced projects, reducing the risks of conflicts and encouraging
persons with protection or assistance. While waiting solutions that aim to make migration or displacement a
for an appropriate conceptual model to be developed, positive input to societies.
there is currently no institutionalised way of dealing
with environmentally induced population movement. Although ProAct supports the need of conceptual
This seriously restricts any possibilities for agencies clarity regarding environmentally induced population
and governments to engage in a meaningful and well- movement – as well as institutional and legal recognition
co-ordinated manner, without putting people in worse – guidance and tools that cover preparedness, prevention
situations with further social and environmental impacts, as well as response are now urgently needed to cope with
particularly as thus far the policy dialogue has been current and pending situations. The challenges need to
mostly focused on the definitional aspects and has not be approached in a holistic manner, from understanding
paid sufficient attention to the practicalities of providing and treating the causes, to attempting to mitigate or aid
assistance or listening to and learning from those in some cases population flows, and dealing with actual
communities forced to move as a result of environmental impacts and recurrences. In many of these cases, the most
change. vulnerable families or communities will not have the
capacity to move, will not have an insurance contributing
to a preference to protect property and will therefore
remain in extremely exposed situations. The absence of
policy instruments must not lead to a neglect of what can
be done now to prevent, react and respond to the problem.
Environmental migration and displacement must be
integrated and understood when planning development,
disaster risk reduction, climate change adaptation and
disaster recovery projects.
3
3.2 Finding sustainable solutions at the local level It is important that the environmental situation and risk
assessments and predictions related to current changes are
ProAct believes that solutions implemented at the well communicated at all levels of society. Equally, there
local level stand the highest chances of being successful and is a clear need for an improved understanding and better
sustainable. Community-based projects ensure that the communications about climate change and its potential
more vulnerable people are being aided and that solutions impacts – and what this means for civil society – between
will take account of the local context of the problem. decision-makers, planners and communities.
Local level governance and community empowerment are
important for long-term results. Projects dealing with Only with a well-informed knowledge base can peoples’
environmentally induced population movement should needs be understood and meaningful solutions be
therefore include essential components such as awareness implemented, such as concrete and simple guidance to
raising, capacity building, communication, co-operation respond and cope with the changes, a large number of
and resource sharing. which must be community-based projects.