Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5,1999
Quantitation of fat in foods has been performed minor peaks) in the chromatographic traces of derivatized food
successfully with AOAC Official Method 996.06. A sample extracts have been identified. (3) Additional fatty acid
number of situations have been encountered that peaks in the chromatograms have been separated by better col-
render the method note, "Note: For any unknown umns and identified by mass spectrometry (MS). The first event
or uncalibrated peaks, use the nearest calibrated indicates that supplier references and calculation factors of the
fatty acid response factors and conversion fac- method should be updated. The second indicates that the word-
tors," inaccurate. Identification of extraneous com- ing of the method relating to peaks of unknown identity should
pounds and availability of additional standard fatty be changed, and the third indicates a need for updating the chro-
acid methyl esters combined with mass spectral matographic column used for identification and for including a
data lead to the recommendation of modifications table of peak relative retention times to assist analysts in identi-
in Official Method 996.06. The stepwise perfor- fying additional minor peaks in their chromatograms.
mance of the method remains unchanged.
During analysis of samples for major chocolate syrup Eight samples of chocolate syrups from 4 manufacturers
manufacturers for fat content by Method 996.06, a peak of and 2 samples of high-fructose corn syrup from 2 suppliers
retention time 28.6 [26.94] min positioned between C12:0 at were split into subsamples and analyzed in the 2 laboratories
27.9 [25.58] min and C14:0 [C13:0] at 31.0 [28.15] min for for total fat. Excellent agreement in data was obtained be-
the SP2340 [SP2560] column (Figure 1) was observed in tween the laboratories (Table 1).
some of the syrup samples. Analysis of the ingredients used A second unknown peak was also observed in the choco-
in the formulation of the chocolate syrups showed the same late syrup samples. This peak occurs at 23.0 [18.93] min,
peak to be present and in proportionally higher quantities in while C8:0 peak occurs at 20.4 [15.69] min and C10:0 at 24.5
some of the high-fructose corn syrups used for manufactur- [20.39] min on SP2340 [SP2560]. On the basis of retention
ing chocolate syrup. Minor peaks like these can have a major time and makeup of the sample, this peak was tentatively
impact on fat quantitation for products containing less than identified as sorbic acid. Chromatographic comparisons and
0.5 g fat per serving. MS of this peak confirmed it to be sorbic acid, the potassium
* Levulenic Acid
O -H
3 a
* Sorbic Acid
ures 4 and 5). Figure 6 shows an example of a chromatogram 60 m SP2340 column, slightly improved resolution of fatty
showing all 3 compounds present with peaks eluting during a acid peaks could be obtained. In particular, the diffi-
fatty acid analysis. Figure 6 is a chromatogram of raspberry cult-to-separate pair of peaks for the FAMES of CI8:3 and
angel food cake in which sorbic acid, benzoic acid, and C20:1 and the trio of peaks for the FAMES of C22:1, C20:3,
levulenic acid were found. and C20:4 are resolved. The SP2560 column has the same
In AOAC Official Method 996.06, Tables 996.06D and E chemical makeup as the SP2340 column but has improved
list the conversion factors for all the fatty acids that occur in resolution, perhaps in part due to its extended length. In addi-
major quantity in foods. Foods contain a number of additional tion to the GC/MS identifications, a number of fatty acid stan-
fatty acids present in small quantity (usually less than 0.1%). dards have become available and were purchased (Sigma,
GC/MS was used to establish the identity and retention times Inc., St. Louis, MO). These were used to establish the reten-
for a number of these fatty acids present in minor amounts. In tion times for myristelaidic acid (14: It), palmitelaidic (16: It),
the course of this identification effort, it was discovered that conjugated linoleic (18:2 conj), docosatrienoic acid (22:3),
Abundance Scan 1
Abundance Scan 16' 99
900000-
1400000-
850000-
115
1300000 800000
115 55
55
1200000 750000
700000-1
1100000
650000
1000000
600000
900000 550000-1
B
500000
800000-
450000
700000
400000 88
600000 88
350000
500000 A 300000 -
250000 :
400000
200000 :
300000-
150000
200000- 100000
130
50000H
100000- 130
Lab 2, first column, includes sorbic acid and levulenic acid in the calculation of total fat, while the second column does not.
Abundance Scan
Abundance Scan
b7
340000-
5000000
320000- i:.1
300000- 4500000
280000 -
111
4000000
260000-
240000-
3500000
220000- B
200000-
95
3000000
180000-
160000 - 2500000
140000 -
6 s 2000000-
120000 -
100000-
1500000
80000-
60000- 1000000
40000-
1
500000
20000-
II 1 >7
ril Ji
l.ull 1 167
• Vi | i '. . i
m/z--> 5C ) 3.00 ISO 2
m/z-->
Figure 3. (A) Mass spectrum—extraneous peak in fat profile of chocolate syrup at 18.93 min. (B) Mass
spectrum—sorbic acid.
1150 DEVRIES ET AL: JOURNAL OF AOAC INTERNATIONAL VOL. 82, No. 5,1999
follows: 14:lt is 32.01, 16:lt is 36.20, 18:2 conj ranges from constructed such a table (Table 4) based on the references in
45.05 to 45.40, 22:3 is 51.98, and 22:4 is 52.28. The conju- Method 994.15 to aid in peak identification.
gated fatty acid, linoleic acid (18:2 conj), occurs and is sold as
a mixture of isomers having double bonds primarily at the Recommendations
9,11 and 10, 12 positions. The areas of the peaks occurring
between 45.05 and 45.40 min in the standards and samples are On the basis of our results and analysis, we recommend
summed for quantitation purposes. that the current tables—996.06D and E—be deleted, that an
Table 2 lists the retention times and relative retention times updated table of relative retention times (shown as Table 2 in
of the FAMEs of the fatty acids for which GC/MS identifica- this paper) be inserted as table 996.06D in the method, and
tion or identification by comparison to known standards has that an updated table of conversion factors (shown as Table 3
been completed in our laboratories. GC/MS was performed in this paper) be inserted as 996.06E.
with the analytical conditions of Method 996.06 and the We further recommend that the column requirements for
SODA
\fi —
83
known relative retention times are listed in Table 996.06D. polyunsaturated fatty acids. In addition, trans-fatty acids
When peaks of unknown identity are observed during the should be identified and quantified using Method 996.06.
chromatographic run, attempts should be made to accurately We further recommend that the following be added to
identify such peaks by mass spectrometry, Fourier-transform Method 996.06 section G, just prior to the final Note: Calcu-
infrared spectroscopy, etc. Peaks of unknown identity should late the amount of polyunsaturates in the test sample (w/w; ex-
not be included in the summation when quantifying fat in the pressed as polyunsaturated fats; sum of C16:2, C18:2, C18:3,
test sample." C20:4> C22:4» C22:6>etc'^as ^ ° ^ o w s - I nc l u <i e only the all-ds iso-
Because virtually all the fatty acids in foods have now been meric fatty acids for nutrition labeling purposes:
identified and are quantifiable by this method, Method 996.06
should be considered as a substitute or replacement for Polyunsaturated fat, % =
Method 979.19 for the identification and quantification of ^polyunsaturated W/W sample ) x 100
200000 :
200000
B
180000-
180000
160000 :
160000
140000 - 140000 51
136
120000 : 120000
136
100000 51
100000H
80000- 80000
60000- 60000
40000 40000-
20000 20000-
m/z-->
p. ifh^Mt
50
,11, jt.ll, i| -,. I, | ,
100
100 150
150 m/z-->
r-f^
50
1 100 150
Figure 5. (A) Mass spectrum—extraneous peak in fat profile of orange soda at 24.56 min. (B) Mass spectrum—sorbic acid.
1152 DEVRIES ET AL: JOURNAL OF AOAC INTERNATIONAL VOL. 82, No. 5,1999
Figure 6. Identification of sorbic, benzoic, and levulenic acid in raspberry angel food cake.
Table 2. Retention and relative retention times of fatty acids on SP2560 column
Table 2. (continued)
For additional detail on the elution pattern of the 18 carbon fatty acids, see AOAC Official Method 994.15.
CM CO CM CO in CM m CO o> C7) in CM m CO o ( ,— o CO in CO o CO CO
,— O) r^ in CO o CO in r». CO
en <* CO ^ CO CO
• * • *
Ol h~ en o CM C\l in CD CM
•<t
r~- o O) CO CO o O) O) in o> in in m
• * • * • * in r
m*. i^ CO o CO
in in in in en CO
• < *
o CO
o o
• *
CO CO CO CO CO CM in
CO in CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO
• * • *
co CO
CO CO
CO cn cn o> cn cn o> cn en cn en O) O) en o> O) en en o O) en O) O) O) C) O) O) en O) en O) O) en O)
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o
1^ CO • * 1^ o CO CO 1— CO 00 Oi T— r^ 1^ CO o r^ o i^ o 00 in CM o r^ 00 CM o 00 in CO
• * • * • o o CO CM
CO <7> CM CO CO CO Ti- CD CO CD in m in m CD CD CO
00 CO o> o> O) CJ> en o
• * • *
O) •*
0>
• *
0> en O)
• *
o> O) en O) O) en O) O) en O) O) cn OJ en O) O) O) en O) O) en O) O) O)
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o
00 in 00 CO i^ T —
1^ in 00 i^ o o CO CM m in in
CO en CM CO CO •t •<t in m in in m
• *
in m "* in cmn
in
• * • *
m
in
00
in in m
00 CO 00
in CD CO CO CO CO CO CO CO
IT- CM CM CM i— T- T— 1— "3-
co CO CO
in
< K CO CO cn en en cn cn cn rn rn<* •*
rn cn
• *
rn rn cn rn cn cn cn cn rn cn rn rn rn m cn en en cn cn cn cn en cn en cn
y-uL en en O) en en en en en cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn O) cn cn cn cn O) en cn en cn cn cn cn O) cn cn cn
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o
i^ CO o CO ^t CM o 00 in o CO CO CO cn en en in o in
CO m 1^ CO en o T— T— "* CD
CM
CM
CM CO CO CO ,— CO ^
in -a~
-
CO
CO
CM
CO
r^ CM 00 00 CO CO in
CO CD m in i^ 00 i^ i^ CO CO
• * • *
m in
T-
cn o cn
CM CO o •* CO o> f— CO N. in rn r^ ,—
• *
rn CO •
m* en
,— 00 CO r^ m rn CO r^ •* in h- cn CO i^
,— in
• *
T—
en CO f— • * • i^
o CO 1^ in cn CO CO CM CO in o •^f i^ i^ CD i^ CO CO in in in in CO CM CM CO
00 o rn o
• < * • * • * T* • *
y
CO 00 • *
m in CO CO h- 1^ 1^ i^ 00 00 CO 00 CO 00 00 CO o> cn o> en en en o o o o o o o o ~ " ' r~
T
CO en o CM in 00 cn CO CM CO cn 1^ o 00 m cn en en CO CO m 00 CO
CM CO CO 5 • *
in in
i^
m in
in in
CM o
in in
CM
CO CD m in in CO CO
1
CO CO • * • *
in in in
CO o o CO
102
"3-
o CO CO
00 o •3- 00
CM
CM
o CO
in in o 00
CO CO
CM
00
00
cn
CD
en en CM
cn en
CO
CM CM
CM
CM
o
CM
00 CD o
in
CM
in
o
m
00 CO CM 00
CO
CM
00 o
CO m CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO 00
CO
CM
o CM m 00 CO cn CO CM CO cn 1^ in CM CM en 00 CO 1^ en 00 CO in CO CM o CM m CO
CO CM CM CO CO CO 5 CO
• *
• * m in in in in in in in in in m CO CD CO
o CO
144
CM CO 00 CO CM
o CO
o CO CM
o oo CO CM
o oo CO CM CO
o CO CO CM o oo 00 CO
00 o CM
CM
CM
CM
CM CM
in
CM
in CO
CM
CO
CM
00
CM CM CM CO
o o o o
CO CO
CM
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CM m CO
CO
CO
CO
CM CM CM CM 00 CO CO CO CO CO
CO
CM
•o "o y o ~
ctadectet raen
ahexaen
o o CO C O O c
o O o CU
enta deca noi
enta dece no'
o CU O cu
§ ffl
penta
dieno
trieno
'o
atetra
apent
atrien
adien
icosan
rachi donic
anoic
leic, elaid
nole c, lin
almit oleic
arga rolei
eric
rach die
o O
OIU
o O
y o o IU CD CO
o co co CO co <n CJ
rvo
nole
teari
y §2 -^ = CD ~
Im O w co cu c c
o
o ou O O o R ^
ruci
•S2 » § S CO
•= T3 o O o cu
• = > ^
CO
_i _i
CO
o o o c
cu 0) o o o Oo CJ o - _lU) CU
CO o 0. o_ CL 0- ^ ^ C73 u u < LU LU < LU X CO LU a Q U Q O i- <L
cu o o
o
o
O T- o o
T- T- O t - CM CO
•* oo CM CO • * in o o CM CO i
i -
^- in CO o o
,
r~
m m CO co i^ 1^ 00 00 00 CO 00 O o O o CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CO
Q • * CO 00
CM
CM CM CM ,—
CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM ^- CM
CM •*
DEVRffiS ET AL: JOURNAL OF AOAC INTERNATIONAL VOL. 82, No. 5,1999 1155
fl
Ratnayake, W.M.N., Hollywood, R., O'Grady, E., and Beare-Rogers, J.L. (1990) Determination of cis and frans-Cctadecenoic Acids in
Margarines by Gas Liquid Chromatography/lnfrared Spectrophotometry, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 67, 804-810.
* Nonmethylene interrupted.