Article Presenters Scoring Rubric for Journal Article Review

5 4 3 -6 Your
Score
Reference APA style is Minor edits Major edits No reference
Perfect; needed to needed to listed; or
article selection APA style; APA style. inappropriate
approved by article Article article selection;
instructor. Turns selection selection or article not
in Article to approved by approved by turned in to
instructor instructor. instructor. instructor
Article turned Article turned
in to in to
instructor. instructor
Review of Major points Some major Does not Missed the jest of
Article selected and points selected focus on the article.
discussed. but also minor major issues
points selected
or no
supporting
example
explained
Writing Clear articulate Minor edits Major edits Turns in
writing used. One needed. Proof- needed. something. Not
or two minor reading will process. college level work
edits needed to be help you. at all.
a perfect paper!
Organization Well organized Minor Major No organizational
of writing thinking that jumping jumping thought
reviews the around on around on demonstrated in
article, discusses points. Could points made writing of review
the major points be better with in review. or major points
in an order that few minor Major edits discussed in the
makes sense. adjustments. needed to article
read clearly.
Your Articulates Brief mention Fails to Does not write
Thoughts thoughts on the of thoughts or provide any of your own
article in clear ideas & how mention of thoughts or ideas;
manner. the article thoughts on fails to identify
Discusses what relates to the article or how the article
was learned from Respiratory omits how relates to
reading the article Care. the article respiratory care
and how the relates to
article relates to Respiratory
Respiratory Care. Care.