This document defines and compares defining and non-defining relative clauses. Defining relative clauses provide essential information about a noun, and use no comma. Non-defining relative clauses provide non-essential extra context, require a relative pronoun, and use two commas. The information in a defining clause is necessary to understand the noun, while the information in a non-defining clause is not necessary and can be removed.
This document defines and compares defining and non-defining relative clauses. Defining relative clauses provide essential information about a noun, and use no comma. Non-defining relative clauses provide non-essential extra context, require a relative pronoun, and use two commas. The information in a defining clause is necessary to understand the noun, while the information in a non-defining clause is not necessary and can be removed.
This document defines and compares defining and non-defining relative clauses. Defining relative clauses provide essential information about a noun, and use no comma. Non-defining relative clauses provide non-essential extra context, require a relative pronoun, and use two commas. The information in a defining clause is necessary to understand the noun, while the information in a non-defining clause is not necessary and can be removed.
Defining relative clauses are used to give information about someone or something (a noun) – information is essential to understand what or who is being referred to. The noun + relative pronoun + the defining relative clause. The relative pronouns are: who, that, which, whose, whom. They introduce a defining relative clause this way: • They are the people who want to rent our flat. • We should give the money to somebody who needs the treatment most. • They are the people who/that rent our flat. (The people rent our flat. The people is the subject.) • Here are some treatments which/that the researcher has discovered. (The researcher has discovered some treatments. Some treatments is the object.) IMPORTANT: NO COMMA
B. Non-defining relative clauses
When we use a non-defining relative clauses we give an extra information about some person or thing. The information is not necessary, the speaker just wants to offer a context. We don’t really need it to understand who or what is being referred to. The relative pronoun is important: who, which, whose, whom, we can’t skip it. The noun + the relative pronoun + the non-defining relative clause. • Right: David, who I work with, is getting a promotion this month. • Wrong: David, I work with, is getting a promotion this month. . IMPORTANT: NO THAT Punctuation: • When we write, we need two commas around non-defining relative clauses: My uncle, who lives in Spain, is a doctor. The information given by a defining relative clause is essential, we can’t leave out the relative clause <=> The information in a non-defining relative clause isn’t essential, we can leave out the relative clause. • The boy who had blue T-shirt seemed to be the most important one. without this information we do not know which boy the speaker is referring to => the clause is a defining one. • The tournament was finished when Simona Halep, who was number one in the world for more than a year, won in front of Serena Williams. It is a non-defining relative clauses which we can leave out: The tournament was finished when Simona Halep won in front of Serena Williams. We can replace who with that in defining relative clauses, but not in non-defining relative clauses: The girl, who came to us earlier, is my cousin. The girl that came to us earlier is my cousin.