CONFIDENTIAL

MEWAR UNIVERSITY
GANGRAR, CHITTORGARH 312901 (RAJASTHAN)

EXAMINER’S REPORT ON THESIS FOR Ph.D DEGREE

1. Name of Candidate...Narendra Kumar Gadiya..............................
2. Title of thesis:
“Mewar the testimony of the eventful and glorious past...................................................................................
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………”
3. Name of Supervisor.Dr. M .C. Dubey .......................................

PART-I : DETAILED EVALUATION

(Kindly adjudicate the thesis under the following three heads: Quality, Originality and Presentation and grade each
of them on a scale of 0-5 where:
„5‟ stands for “Excellent”
„4‟ stands for “Very good”
„3‟ stands for “Good”
„2‟ stands for “satisfactory”
„1‟ stands for “poor”
„0‟ stands for “Inferior”

(A) QUALITY:
1. Introduction to the work ( 4 )
2. Review of literature ( 3 )
3. Scope of the work ( 4 )
4. Technical soundness ( 4 )
5. Problem statement ( 3 )
6. Content of thesis ( 3 )
7. Timeliness of work ( 4 )
8. Contribution to the field ( 4 )
9. Conclusions drawn ( 3 )
10. Scope for further research in the field ( 4 )
(B) ORIGINALITY:
11. Formulation of the problem and hypotheses ( 3 )
12. Adequacy of data and their analysis ( 4 )
13. Original contribution ( 3 )
14. Importance of the original contributions ( 3 )
(C) PRESENTATION:
 CONFIDENTIAL

15. Clear explanation of the work ( 3 )

16. Sufficient details of the methods/techniques adopted ( 3 )
17. Justification of the work done ( 3 )
18. Clarity and unambiguity of the language ( 3 )
19. Clarity of objectives ( 3 )
20. Freedom from redundant/irrelevant material and errors ( 4 )
Total Score out of 100 (sum of score from 1 to 20) ( 68 )

(Score in Words..Sixty Eight...............................................................................)

PART –II : A DETAILED REPORT

(Kindly fill the detailed report under the following headings or please enclosed a separate sheet if required.)

A. GENERAL & CRITICAL APPRAISAL:

Through the topic is very wide as it covers from past
present to past but the work done is good
__________________________________________________________________________________
to present
__________________________________________________________________________________
and best tried to cover almost all the field relevant to the topic upto present as many changes
__________________________________________________________________________________
seems to take place from time to time . Some topics are related to past in a very significant
manner . So in general good work is done.
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________

B. TECHNICAL APPRAISAL:
The problem to relate past with present is represented in a very systematic manner with
__________________________________________________________________________________
adequacy of data and the work is original. The originality of the work will bring lot of scope
__________________________________________________________________________________
for other scholars
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________

C. ASPECT (STRENGTHS) / (WEAKNESSES) REPORT:

__________________________________________________________________________________
The topic is very wide but still have tried to cover it as sufficient details are covered . The
objectives are very clear but still some features do lack like the event at the times of
__________________________________________________________________________________
Maharaja Fateh Singh etc.
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
 CONFIDENTIAL

__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________

Please suggest at least three questions which should be answered by scholar at the time of viva.

1. Why Mewar was always important during the medieval period ?

_____________________________________________________________________
2. How origin of Mewar took place ?
_____________________________________________________________________
3. What was the administrative system of Mewar?
_____________________________________________________________________
4. How will you prove that women of Mewar was also brave?
_____________________________________________________________________
5. _____________________________________________________________________
Give any one example of patriotism of Mewar?

PART-III : FINAL RECOMMENDATION

A. The thesis satisfies the following requirements (Tick any two):

It is an original contribution to knowledge characterized by discovery of facts and their significance or by a

new interpretation of facts of theories. ( Y )
It evinces the candidate‟s capacity for critical examination and sound judgment. ( )
The literary presentation is in a form suitable for publication. ( Y )

B. The Examiner recommends that (Tick any one):

The thesis be accepted for the award of Ph. D degree. ( Y )

OR
The thesis may be accepted after due corrections / minor changes. ( )
OR
The thesis may be revised and resubmitted. ( )
OR
The thesis be rejected. ( )
.
*Please strike out the clauses not applicable.

(Note: Please attach additional sheets, if required).

Signature of Examiner

Name: ____________________
Dr. Usha Choudhary
Designation: _______________
Principal

Date: 17th Feb 2021

Place: Dhariyawad