Professional Documents
Culture Documents
English Issue
Der Merkurstab
2008
Depression
• Markus Treichler • Michaele Quetz
Melancholia in mythology, Depression—a case record to
art and literature – examples demonstrate diagnostic and
of individual development treatment approach based on
in depression anthroposophical psychoso-
matics
• Eckhard Roediger
Anthroposophical aspects to • Susanne Reinhold
psychotherapy for depression Treatment of depression—
music therapy
• Johannes Reiner
How do antidepressants • Rudolf Steiner
affect essential human Composure in facing destiny
nature?
• Wolfgang Rissmann
Depressive disorders—anthro-
posophical insight and treat-
ment using anthroposophical
medicines and external appli-
cations
T
he incidence of depressive conditions has risen
How do antidepressants affect considerably in recent decades in all western civi-
essential human nature? lized nations. They present a particular challenge
■ Abstract not only to psychiatrists but in all medical disciplines.
Depressive disorders are the most common psychia- In the diagnosis, distinction may be made between
tric conditions. A first insight based on the anthropo- depressive changes accompanying numerous other
sophical view of the human being leads to a typolo- physical and mental disorders, and depressive disorders
gical study of the psychosomatic constitution—hys- in the narrower sense. In the latter case these are
teria and neurasthenia. In the hysterical type, the • bipolar affective disorder (ICD-10 F 31)
upper does not fully control the lower human being; • depressive episode (ICD-10 F 32)
in the neurasthenic type, the powers of the upper • recurrent depressive disorder (ICD-10 F 33)
human being prove too destructive. Clinical differen- • dysthymia (ICD-10 F 34.1)
tiation between the two types is based on a differen- • adjustment disorders: short or longer-term depres-
tiated symptomatology in body and soul. Anthropo- sive reaction, anxiety and depressive disorder mixed
sophical medicines and external applications achie- (ICD-10 F 43.2)
ve a degree of balance for one-sided constitutions Depressive disorders in the narrower sense cannot be
and thus indirectly a reduction in symptoms. considered to be a uniform pathology. They vary widely,
Deeper causes for depressive disorders are found in with many different causes, degrees of severity and evo-
the “organ-development disorders” of the lower hu- lutions. This means that explanations based on the an-
man being, especially in lung, liver, kidney and heart.
throposophical view of the human being also cannot be
These are functional disorders in the sphere of ethe-
uniform. One can only describe general pathological
ric powers of growth and development which lead
processes which present differently in every situation
to pathological symptoms in body and above all in
and have individual character.
soul. Specific treatment with anthroposophical me-
A first insight comes with the distinction which
dicines and external applications thus first addres-
Rudolf Steiner made between two constitutional types—
ses the bodily causes of depressive disorders.
the hysterical and the neurasthenic constitution (1).
■ Keywords
Apart from this, deeper causes may be found in the
Depressive disorders
functional metabolic disorders of the lower human being,
Upper and lower human being
Hysterical and neurasthenic constitutions referred to as “disorders in organ development” in lung,
Anthroposophical medicines liver, kidney, heart and possibly also other organs (3, 5).
External applications Treatment in anthroposophical medicine will ulti-
Functional organ diagnosis mately also have to be individual. The road to this does,
Disorders in development of lung, liver kidney, heart however, take us first to a typology of disease and con-
Constitutional treatment stitution and also to typical medicines and methods of
Individualized treatment treatment. In this respect not every medicine or method
can be highly specific, but requires a first orientation ac-
cording to typological criteria. Practical experience in
similar cases will always provide valuable support and
ideas. The suggestions offered below are intended to be
just that. They can help with the first steps in therapeu-
tic work, though there can be no claim for completeness.
Meaningful treatment of depressive disorders will, of
course, always be comprehensive, considering other el-
English Issue 2008 R i s s m a n n | D e p r e s s i v e d i s o r d e r s | D e r M e r k u r s ta b 3
ements as well as anthroposophic medicines and exter- tions of the lower human being reduce or extinguish
nal applications: conscious awareness.
• psychotropic drugs The two centres functioning as polar opposites are
• movement therapy (eurythmy therapy, gymnastics, like image and negative counter image. The dynamic
dance therapy, other forms of movement therapy balance between them is maintained in the rhythmical
with natural movement of all kinds) action of the heart and the movement of the blood. Pre-
• art therapy (sculpture and modelling, painting, dominance of the lower processes may lead to tachycar-
music, developed speech) dia, for instance, predominance of upper processes to
• work therapy bradycardia.The constructive processes of the lower hu-
• talks and psychotherapy man being predominate in children and young people,
• social help of all kinds with conscious awareness slowly developing. The invo-
• self-help groups lutional processes and sclerotic tendencies of the upper
• spiritual and religious care human being predominate in older and old people, on
the other hand, at the same time enhancing soul and
1. Hysterical and neurasthenic constitutions spiritual functions. The dynamic balance between the
At the beginning of the 20th century, hysteria and powers of the upper and lower human being must con-
neurasthenia were familiar terms in psychiatry, refer- stantly be maintained individually and varies a great
ring to two specific syndromes. The terms are no longer deal from person to person. It may be subject to a con-
used to refer to disease entities in modern psychiatric stitutional, i.e. innate, shift in one of two directions. Pre-
nomenclature. dominance of the powers of the upper human being re-
Steiner used these terms for two types of constitu- sults in a “neurasthenic” constitution, those of the low-
tion, speaking of them in his first medical course to er human being to a “hysterical” constitution.
introduce his medical approach to the human being. With the hysterical constitution, the processes and
He spoke of a “hysterical”and a “neurasthenic”constitu- powers of the lower human being predominate because
tion, two types of constitution with typical morbid ten- the upper human being is relatively weak and cannot
dencies in body and soul that call for typical methods maintain the balance. Metabolic processes from the
of treatment (1, 2). lower human being emancipate, losing form and cohe-
The description of the two constitutional types does sion, and lead to a disposition for organic disease in the
not primarily take its orientation in external anatomical lower human being and weaken the soul’s ability to take
phenomena of the human form but considers the inner hold consciously of personality or individual nature.“Let
functional aspect of the etheric powers of growth and us assume that the internal chemical or also organic
development. These are the powers that maintain and forces of ingested food preponderate in the lower
constitute life in the human organism. The inner func- sphere, that is, in food uptake and the digestive appara-
tional aspect consists in two energy centres that are tus in the wider sense. In a healthy organism the situa-
polar opposites and maintain dynamic tension between tion must be that all the forces active in the foods them-
them. One is in the “upper human being”, the other in selves, immanent in them, forces, therefore, which we in-
the “lower human being”. vestigate in food laboratories, have been overcome by
The processes and powers in the upper human being the upper principle, that they are not at all available for
have their centre in the head region and form the basis inner activity in the organism, that nothing at all hap-
for conscious awareness processes of all kinds, i.e. per- pens there by way of external chemistry, external dy-
ception through the sense organs, the forming of ideas, namics and the like, but that all of this has been com-
concepts and thinking processes, and ultimately main- pletely overcome. But it can happen that the upper prin-
taining a state of waking consciousness. The lung’s ciple is not meeting the situation adequately to work
breathing activity is also seen as belonging to this. The fully through the lower principle, cooking it all the way
processes in the upper human being inevitably lead through, as it were, or I might also say, etherizing it ful-
to the degradation of organic substance which must ly; then a process predominates in the human organism
then be eliminated or it will contribute to hardening and which does not actually belong to it, a process which
sclerotic tendencies. The result is premature tiredness otherwise takes place in the outside world and should
and ageing. The inner life and the intensity of conscious not take place in the human organism.To use a common
awareness are strengthened by the functions of the term, referring merely, I’d say, to certain forms of this ir-
upper human being. regularity, we have to chose the term “hysteria”. Let us
The processes and powers in the lower human being take the term hysteria—we shall see later on that it is
have their centre in the abdominal region and take care not a bad choice—for the situation where metabolic
of the digestion and assimilation of food and further processes emancipate to a great extent. The phenome-
metabolic processes in all tissues, so that the body builds na which are actually hysterical in the narrower sense
up its own substance.They provide the basis for growth, are really nothing but a process of taking this irregular
energy conversion, the generation of heat, and reproduc- metabolism to its culmination.” (1)
tive processes. These processes of purely vegetative or With a neurasthenic constitution, the processes and
autonomous life are completely unconscious. The func- powers of the upper human being predominate, being
4 D e r M e r k u r s ta b | R i s s m a n n | D e p r e s s i v e d i s o r d e r s English Issue 2008
Use for at least 4 weeks, then a week’s - indurated, dry bodily constitution jor internal organs. The organs primarily
break, etc. and premature ageing involved are lung, liver, kidney and heart; in
Gencydo 1 %, 3 %, 5 % s.c. Use for 4 weeks; discontinue if lively a wider sense the spleen, gastrointestinal
- for signs of overflowing fluid organ- dreams develop or depressive symptoms tract, reproductive organs and endocrine
ism, poss. also with tendency to get worse. glands are also involved. Mental illness
hayfever; tumid, watery constitution Sulphur D6 trit. may be connected with functional disor-
combined with tendency for dissocia- - for chronic constipation, inner chilli- ders affecting the internal organs in vari-
tive symptoms ness ous ways and degrees. These functional
- when sensation of pain in skin is - indurated, dry bodily constitution disorders cannot as a rule be detected di-
reduced evolution stagnating rectly by means of laboratory tests, histo-
- suitable both for acute intervention - no pyrexia or febrile reaction logical preparations, X-rays, ultrasound or
in hysteriform and dissociative states Use for 4 weeks initially, discontinue if magnetic resonance images. They are “dis-
and for longer-term constitutional signs of inflammation develop or depres- orders of organ development”, i.e. disor-
treatment. sive symptoms get worse. ders in the etheric powers of growth and
Use s.c. injection, starting with 1 % daily, Mistletoe development in the organ concerned, and
between the shoulder blades or in the Above all in relatively high potencies for show themselves in functional bodily and
calf; later going up to 3 or 5 % depending chronic depressive states, absence of in mental symptoms. Careful history-tak-
on tolerance. febrile reaction, predominantly endoge- ing and diagnosis from this point of view
Bryophyllum D1 dil., nous depressive states results in a functional organ diagnosis (3, 5).
Bryophyllum 50 % trit. Teas The power of growth and development
for anxious restlessness and panic Lime blossom, chamomile flowers in an organ may be out of order in two
Use for 4 weeks initially, then break. Baths with essences or extracts ways.
Quartz D10 trit. - Calamus tea to treat marked exhaus- • One goes in the direction of psychotic
if skin and constitution in the upper hu- tion or weakness, gastric problems conditions. The etheric power is partly
man being are not fully structured, and and poor digestion squeezed out, as it were, of the organ
lack of containment against the world - Prunus essence for marked exhaustion and enters into the inner soul space,
Use long-term, e.g. for 6 months. and weakness, lack of vitality leading to productively psychotic
Teas - Sulphur bath for induration, dry skin symptoms.
Herbal teas containing bitter principles and lack of febrile response • The other goes in the direction of neu-
are particularly suitable, e.g. yarrow, Oil baths rosis and personality disorders. Previ-
wormwood and others. for general weakness of vital energies, ous trauma, esp. in early childhood,
Baths lack of enveloping warmth and poor gen- has not been worked through. The
not indicated if symptoms markedly hys- eration of warmth, exhaustion: Prunus, traumatic events remain, as it were, on
terical, only with secondary neurasthenic Melissa, Thymus, Hypericum, Lavandula, the boundary between inner soul
symptomatology. Rosemary, Solum uliginosum space and unconsciously active organ-
Arnica essence baths Hyperthermic baths creating etheric powers and cannot be
if trauma in history. - if resistant to chemical antidepres- integrated. This leads to anxieties,
Footbaths sants and psychotherapy; lack of compulsions, depressive moods and
- mustard footbaths febrile response; subnormal tempera- functional organic symptoms (4).
- lavender footbaths ture (< 36 °C) Below, a guide is given for functional organ
Compress - Contraindications: history of tubercu- diagnosis.
Mustard compress on calves losis, severe cardiac arrhythmias
3.1 Disorder in powers of pulmonary
Footbaths
2.2 Neurasthenic constitution growth and development
- Rosemary in the mornings
Bitters a) History
- Lavender, mustard, sulphur at night
To stimulate appetite and digestion Past pneumonia, tendency to develop
Rhythmic oiling
- Absinthium D1 dil. bronchitis, disposition to pulmonary
- to stimulate anabolism generally—
- Abrotanum D1 dil. TB, tendency to develop other harden-
arms, back and legs
- Amara drops ing pulmonary conditions (sarcoidosis,
- whole-body oiling
- Anagallis D1 dil. fibrosis, etc.)
- Gentiana lutea D1 dil. 3. Functional organ diagnosis b) Nature of solid organism
- Gentiana lutea Rh 5 % dil. In the anthroposophical view of the hu- Structure of organs dense, hardened,
- Gentiana stomach pilules man being, life in soul and spirit is seen to tending towards rigidity
- Geum urbanum D1 dil. be connected not only with the brain but c) Autonomic system
Argentum D6 trit. in a direct way also with the whole body. Hunger and appetite abnormal
- indicated mainly where conflicts have Mental illness is therefore considered to Malnutrition
hardened and seem insoluble; past relate not only to disorders in brain func- d) Psyche
injuries and traumas tion (neurotransmitter problems) but also - Compulsive personality structure
- evolution stagnating to problems affecting processes in the ma- with excessively correct and pedan-
6 D e r M e r k u r s ta b | R i s s m a n n | D e p r e s s i v e d i s o r d e r s English Issue 2008
- Oxalis ointment 30 % (tendency to Aurum met. prep. D12 s.c. or trit., Literatur
1 Steiner R. Spiritual Sci-
cramps; traumas in history) also D20 s.c.
ence and Medicine / Introdu-
Baths Guilt feelings, cardiac anxieties, fear of cing Anthroposophical Medi-
Sulphur baths for dried-up, sluggish and death, bad conscience cine. 2nd of these tr. C. E.
Creeger. Lecture of 22 March
afebrile constitution Use long-term
1920
Oil baths Leonurus cardiaca D3 dil. 2 Schrauth M. Histrionisch
Oxalis oil Cardiac anxieties combined with inner – dissoziative Symptome bei
psychiatrischen Patienten
cardiac unrest, anginal symptoms
3.5.3 Process of renal development und ihre Behandlung im Rah-
Use long-term men eines naturkundlich-
Symptoms: General restlessness, tension, Hypericum Auro cultum Rh D3 s.c. or dil. anthroposophischen Ansat-
agitation, vibrating inwardly, air hunger Depressive symptoms with gloom, lack of zes mit einem Extrakt aus
and emotional irritability Citrus limon und Cydonia
perspective and tired of life combined oblonga (Gencydo). Diss.
Cuprum met. prep. D6 s.c. with existential anxieties Freiburg 2005
Tension and restlessness combined with 3 Steiner R. Spiritual Sci-
Use long-term
ence and Medicine / Introdu-
inner chilliness Carbo D8/Crataegus D2 s.c. cing Anthroposophical Medi-
Use for at least 4 weeks Anxieties with anginal symptoms and cine. Lecture of 4 Apr. 1920
Chalcosine D4 trit. 4 Ibid. Lecture of 5 Apr. 1920
dyspnoea
5 Steiner R. Psychoanalysis
tensin and restlessness, esp. also if com- Use relatively long-term in the Light of Anthroposo-
bined with thyroid hyperfunction Crataegus drops phy / Psychoanalysis and Spi-
Use for at lest four weeks ritual Psychology, lecture of
Old people with incipient heart failure,
2 July 1921. Tr. M. Laird-Brown
Chamomilla Cupro culta Rh D3 s.c. or dyspnoea accompanied by anxieties
Chamomilla Cupro culta Radix D3 dil. Cactus comp. II pilules
Inner tension going as far as spasms in Anxieties combined with cardiac arrhyth-
the gastrointestinal region. mias or anginal pain
Use for at least 4 weeks Use long-term
Melissa Cupro culta Rh D3 s.c. or dil. Ointment dressing
Inner tension combined with anxiety and Aurum Lavandula Rosae comp.
chilliness (anxious unrest and problems going to
Use for at least 4 weeks sleep)
Equisetum arvense Rh D6 s.c. or dil. Compress
Lack of structure in lower human being Arnica essence (anxious unrest and angi-
with tendency to fluid deposits or func- nal pain)
tional congestion of fluids Oil baths
Use for at least 4 weeks Melissa oil
Carbo Betulae cum Methano D6 trit. Wolfgang Rissmann, MD
Inner unrest with flatus and tendency to Friedrich Husemann Clinic
diarrhoea D-79256 Buchenbach
Use for at least 4 weeks
Carbo Betulae D8 / Crataegus D2 s.c.
Inner unrest combined with dyspnoea
and cardiac symptoms
Compresses
- Ginger kidney compresses (inner un-
rest, tension, air hunger, inner chilli-
ness)
- Equisetum kidney compress (fluid con-
gestion)
Organ massage for kidney
Cuprum met. prep. 0.4 % oil or Red Cop-
per Ointment
Baths
Equisetum tea
Oil baths
Equisetum ex herba 5 % oil