Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ANTONIO M. LA Vlt'tA
Ateneo de Manila University
• phenomenologiCIIl, apprOllCh to the undetBtandtng of mclDl reality. The author elaborates Ileto's use
of phenomenological sociology, /Uld mggestB how other sociological perspective couldbe harnessed
to enhance [urthet interpretations of similar events;
85
86 PHILIPPI~E SOCIOLOGICAL REVIEW
religious and literary texts - poems, songs, discovers again and again are themes in the
scattered autobiographies, confessions" prayers pasyon which the participants interpreted as
and folk sayings. Note 'that the use of justifications for their actions. These themes
non-traditional sources is integral to writing a and the meanings they communicated to the
history from below. According to Ileto, a peasants were not flxed, but rather depended
language contains within it the history of its on the socio-historical situation. At times,
speakers and expresses a unique way of the pasyon encouraged subservience and
relating to the world. To use only American, resignation. But during periods of social
Spanish or lllustrado sources would inevitably
introduce an elite bias on the interpretation of
events. Thus Ileto's methodology is to let the
ferment, attributed to economic and political
factors, the pasyon themes became a call to
-Iive in the here and now, thus encouraging
•
masses speak with their own words, in a revolution and instilling hope among the'
language which come to us today through the masses.
texts they have left behind.
This revolutionary potential of the pasyon .
Ileto's thesis is that 'we cannot dismiss the . . was possible because of the dominant role it
religious nature of the popular movements- played in the lives of the peasants. According
from the Cofradia to the Sakdal - as to Ileto, the pasyon was not' just sung, heard
aberrations, fanaticisms, nativism and or celebrated by the masses in the 1800's, "it
millenarianism. We cannot reject and disparage was lived, both individually and socially,
the cultural contexts from which these during holy week and oftentimes beyond it
movements arose. In fact, Ileto says that we (p, 28):~ It was an activity the people looked
can understand them only if we study these . forward to, an occasion for self-renewal, for'
cultural contexts. A major cultural coritext, "liberating" oneself and one's community. It
Ileto argues, is noted in the Tagalog's folk was no. surprise, therefore, to find that the
religious traditions and values which, inspite ( masses saw the struggle against Spain in terms
of their seemingly other-worldly nature, of the pasyon. The other-worldly "liberation"
contained latent, possibly revolutionary of the pasyon became a call for a concrete
meanings. What Ileto does is to show how liberation of the people and of Inangbayan.
these traditions, specifically the pasyon,
fundamentally shaped the style of the And the masses fought the Spaniards when
movements and uprisings. He elaborates how the situation called for it. But the rationale
the pasyon. tradition had' provided' a for peasant participation in these events
language for the masses to articulate .their cannot be found in the democratic and
values, ideals, and even hopes of liberation. He republican ideas that the illustrados brought
demonstrates how the themes of a lost back from Europe. It was rooted, rather, in
paradise, suffering, the strenghtening of ioob, the consciousness which the pasyon gave
liwanag, brotherhood, conflict and struggle, them, this. "collective consciousness" that
evil and selfishness, journey, freedom, Christ's made participation in the popular movements
second coming - all drawn from. in the meaningful.
pasyon - contributed to the transformation
of what was previously a tool for pacification The bulk of Ileto's book marshalls case
into a tool for revolution. studies to demonstrate the pasyon thesis.
The first case to be analyzed is the Cofra-
What was it in the pasyon that shaped dia de Juan de Dios, a movement founded
revolutionary consciousness of the masses? and led by Apolinario de la Cruz. Ileto
. Ileto answers this by' going over the texts of. studied the letters, poems and other
the pasyon and those left behind by persons writings of de la Cruz and his followers, the
who participated in the movements. What he prayers and rites of the Cofradia, the centr~
BETWEEN STRUcrURES AND PEOPLE WI
role de la Cruz played in the movement, and anting-anting, the definition of liberation as
the like. What he found in studying these Kalayaan and not Independencia, the resolute
texts is the dominance of certain pasyon and almost obstinate will to continue the
themes as mentioned earlier. From them, Ileto struggle, the firm hope in the future, and
makes sense out of this 1841 uprising. He says above all, the. walking towards death without
that this was not simply a blind reaction to fear and trembling. No ideology, no political
oppressive forces in colonial society; "it was a conviction, neither backwardness r or
conscious act of realizing certain possibilities frustration, can explain these phenomena. For
of existence that the members were made Ileto, all these made sense only in the light of
conscious of through reflection upon certain the pasyon.
mysteries and signs (p. 39)." These possibilities
and the very act of reflection upon certain Ileto's Theoretical Framework
"signs" and "mysteries" were embedded in their
consciousness through the pasyon. Ileto does not explicitly state his
theoretical framework; the task belongs to us.
The rest of the book follows this line of Note, however, that this attempt to identify
thinking. After the Cofradia revolt, Ileto the sociological underpinnings of Ileto's work
studies the Katipunan (the central role of will be limited to a specific range of
Bonifacio, the differing conceptions of the contemporary sociological theories. Ileto, we
struggle between the masses and the elites, the must also note, uses an interdisciplinary
structures and rites of the Katipunan, its approach in his study. Other than sociology.
secrecy, the poems of Jacinto, and so on), he also makes extensive use of anthropological
the 1896 revolution and its aftermath (the theory (e.g, Levi-Strauss' structuralism) and
success of the illustrados in imposing their literary criticism. For this paper, we will limit
• own definition of revolution, Aguinaldo's
central role in this success, the masses'
ourselves to certain sociological perspectives.
meaningful to the masses depended upon. . symbolic interactionist's view. He also asks:
Thus, lleto's extensive textual analyses. We what gave the masses this capacity of
also get a sense of social reality as not of pure meaning-giving, of recognizing each other's
order, of society as not static, but of an . gestures and behavior? Ileto answers that it
unfmished social world, of a society was the pasyon: The pasyon made it possible
continually in the process of being for the. masses to acquire a shared subjective
constructed. Finally, to accent lleto's state, a .shared view of the world, a shared
humanistic perspective, we 'see that the masses response to socio-historical events. This
are portrayed as people, not facts; as persons, process was not a' merely individual one, but a
not robots; as free actors in an existirig but social one as well. The pasyon, for those who
dynamic social world interacting, joined the movements, became the
reconstructuring, changing, creatively starting-point, the touchstone of a' common
responding, even defying this world. language, of a paramount reality. The pasyon
consciousness became their stock knowledge;
To further specify these' points, let me cite it gave them what Schutz called "the sense
the important influence of phenomenology in of an absolute reality" that shaped and
lleto's work. Indeed, Ileto's. aim to arrive at a guided all social. events. The pasyon cons-
historical perspective from within makes it ciousness became the frame of reference
inevitable for him to use phenomenology. His which enabled the masses to respond to
method is phenomenological, if by such what was happening in their world.
method we mean an attempt to suspend
preconceived biases and attitudes. His use of
literary, religious and biographical texts, rather An example of how the pasyon gave the
than illustrado writings or foreign documents, masses the capacity to interpret each other's
is an indication' of this phenomenological
methdology. It is also clear that Ileto asks the
behavior
how
were
is lleto's account (pp. 79-80) of
Hermano
perceived
Pule and others -like him
by ordinary peasants:
•
same questions about the masses the way
Alfred Schutz, following M~ Weber, asked of ... But even more than the memory of a
ordinary men: "why and how do actors come specific' man and a specific movement, it
to acquire common subjective states in a was the validity of the pasyon tradition
situation? how do they create a common view that made it possible for ordinary folk to
of the world?" The creation and recognize the appearance of other
maintenance of intersubjectivity is a clear Christ-like figures, each bringing the same
problem in Ileto's attempt to explain popular message of hope that Apolinario
movements. His answer to this sociological brought.
(also philosophical) question .is close to The process by which the pasyon
Schutz's and the' symbolic interactionist's facilitated a common social world for the
answer. masses can be seen also in Ileto's account
(p. 76) of the Cofradia's Aritao commune:
The symbolic interactionist would answer
the above questions by saying that the masses
were able to share a common vision ·and a Returning to the Aritao phenomenon ...
it is logical for the cofrades to have
common response because of their capacity to
perceived their expulsion from the towns as
contruct symbolic environments (Turner 1978). a further 'dying' to a past characterized by
This capacity to interpret, define, map, symbo- hierarchical social patterns and relationships
lize and evaluate each other's gesture and . . . Being a community apart heightened
behavior made it possible for the masses to the bonds of solidarity among the brothers
respond collectively to what was .happening and sisters of the Cofradia, bringing them a
around them. But Ileto goes further than the step closer to the ideal of perfect unity,
• BETWEEN STRUcrURES AND PEOPLE 89
The book contains many other accounts of lectical process: man makes society; society
how the pasyon shaped the masses' worldview, is objective, society makes man. One
how this helped them recognize each other's implication is that there is an objective social
gestures and behavior, and how this aided reality (facts and structures) and a subjective
them in arriving at a creative and collective social reality (meaning, response).
response to the events of their world. I think
that phenomenology and symbolic Ileto recognizes the presence not only of
interactionism helped Ileto to arrive at this both objective and subjective realities, but the
interpretation. It is important to point out, presence of "multiple subjective realities," a
though, that Ileto's perspective also differs point also noted in Berger and Luckrnann's
significantly that of Herbert Blumer and sociology. In fact, one of the main insights
Alfred Schutz. For Ileto, the social world was Ileto emphasizes is the divergent perspectives
not an illusion; it was not a world which of the elite's and masses' conception of what
existed only because the masses believed and the revolution was all about. This meant that
convinced themselves about its existence. The for these two groups, the social situation was
social world of the masses, for Ileto, did exist. objectively the same: the colonial state of the
It was a world that existed independent of the country. The difference laid in how this
masses, a world they shared with the reality was perceived, explained and given
illustrados and the colonizers. It was an meaning. For the masses participating in
objective reality, an objective facticity. The popular movements, the purpose of the
point of the movements was precisely to struggle was to attain Kalayaan, a total kind
respond creatively to this objective world. of liberation - involving a self-cleansing, the
Deto stresses this important point, but gives conversion of the whole community, a
liberation not only from Spanish and
• more weight to the subjective response of the
masses to this facticity; and in doing so, he
discovered a link between collective
American domination, but from all forms of
injustice, oppression and evil. For the masses,
consciousness and the pasyon, which is also this would be the time
part of the objective reality. . . . when society would be turned on its
head, when all men would be brothers,
Let me elaborate this interaction between
leaders would be Christ-like, all forms of
the objective and subjective worlds by oppression would end and property would
showing the possible influence of Peter, Berger be shared; in other words, when their
and Thomas Luckmann's sociology on Ileto's image of Kalayaan would turn into lived
work. Berger and Luckmann (1963) suggest experience (p. 257).
•
that there are three dialectical moments in
the social construction of reality. They see This vision of liberation contrasts with the
society, first, as basically a human product, elite's conception as articulated in the Malolos
a result of man's externalization. As then, Republic: the image is not that of Kalayaan
by the process of objectivation, this human but of Independencia. The purpose of the
product we call society becomes an objec- struggle was centered on liberation from Spain
tive reality, something "out there," inde- and ultimately, the United States. This
pendent of the particular subjects within divergence of perceptions is explained by the
that reality. This objective would now different meaning-giving apparatus that these
begins to influence and shape these classes had: the elite being influenced by
subjects. At the same time, the subjects European ideas of democracy and
respond creatively to this objective reality. republicanism, the masses by the pasyon.
This would be the third dialectical moment, I
the internalization of the objective world. Even as Ileto recognizes the existence of an
Again, we must stress that this is a dia- objective social world, his stress rests on the
90 PHILIPPINE SOCIOLOGICAL REVIEW
•
subjective aspect of the dialectic. This; I.. will to see beyond the loss of a human life.
say. later, is both the strength and the
·weakness of his work. Given his aim and the Berger (1967:52), writing about religion, pro-
methodology he uses, the focus is not poses that:
surprising. In the end.. what lleto tells us is Every human society. in' the last resort,
that the masses were able to respond are banded together in the face of death.
creatively to the objective social situation, one The power of religion depends, in the last
characterized by social ferment rooted in resort, upon the credibility of the banners
economic and political factors, because of the it puts in the hands of men as they. stand
consciousness the pasyon was able to give before death, or more accurately, as they
them. It was this consciousness that served as walk, inevitably towards it.'
the legitimating device for their participation In summary, we have said that Ileto's aim
in popular movements. Using Berger's words, makes it inevitable for him to fa:ll back on
it was the pasyon that made possible a humanistic or .interpretative sociology. We
common symbolic universe for the peasant, have shown this by noting that his
within which he could locate himself, within methodology is phenomenological, one which
which his biography became intimately linked acquires a perspective from within, rather than
up with the biographies of other individuals, imposes categories from the outside. We have
·peasants and illustrados alike; This, in turn, .also shown how the symbolic interactionist's
made it possible for him to see himself as emphasis on the process of symbol-giving and
linked to history. symbol-interpreting surfaces in Ileto's
It was this pasyon consciousness, awakened . framework. And finally, we pointed out
'by the objective social reality, that ordered his. .Berger's influence on lleto, noting" that
roles, his priorities, his life. It was the pasyon 'although Ileto recognizes the objective reality
that legitimated his act of defiance against his of the social situation,' his emphasis lies in the
society, against the "routine'" of his everyday subjective reality of the masses' consciousness
life. It was the pasyon consciousness that and their response to this objective world.
helped him construct and reconstruct his This is my intelligent guess, given Ileto's text
world, ordered his experience, and shielded and my limited knowledge of sociological
him from the terror of anomie ., a real danger theories. As I said earlier, this explicitation of
in that period of unrest. It was the pasyon, Ileto's framework is necessarily incomplete'
·.belonging to the human enterprise we ca:ll because of his . interdisciplinary;approach.
Religion, that made his response to his world
A Critique
·creative, legitimate, and meaningful.
"