COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

CRS-3-PU101-PR-DI-034 Rev.06
Client
Project Title
Document Title Reference No.
Contractor Reference No.
ENAR/OGDCL Ref. No.
: OGDCL
: UCH-II Development Project “AMINE GAS SWEETENING UNIT& INCINERATOR Package”
Doc. P&ID (PIPING AND INSTRUMENTATION DIAGRAM) N. 3-PU101-PR-DI-034
: Transmittal No. 0226
: Transmittal No.0226

CLIENT/CONSULTANT STATUS
Document No/ COMMENTS (Piping /Civil & &REMARKS
Client/Consultant
S. No. Drawing No Structure / I&C / Process / BELLELLI RESPONSES
Response
&Section Material &Corrosion /
QA&QC

MECHANICAL COMMENTS

3-PU101-PR-DI- please provide the list of all

1 Noted.
034 special piping items

Detailed specification will be provided in a

3-PU101-PR-DI- please provide its detailed relative document.
2
034 specification This comment is not appropriate to this
document.

3-PU101-PR-DI- where it is written? please

3 Removed.
034 show

Detailed characteristics will be provided in a

3-PU101-PR-DI- please mention the bursting relative document.
4
034 pressure of hose on P&ID This comment is not appropriate to this
document.

Page 1 of 5
 CLIENT/CONSULTANT STATUS
Document No/ COMMENTS (Piping /Civil & &REMARKS
Client/Consultant
S. No. Drawing No Structure / I&C / Process / BELLELLI RESPONSES
Response
&Section Material &Corrosion /
QA&QC
is this flexible pipe? may be it Detailed characteristics will be provided in a
will deteriorate due to any
3-PU101-PR-DI- relative document.
5 human/machine interface
034 This comment is not appropriate to this
leads to pump closure. please
explain document.
Which other utility connections could be
necessary?
why did not you provide
Isolation valves are provided upstream and
3-PU101-PR-DI- valve here as for other utility
6 downstream of every regeneration reboiler
034 connections? how will one
300/310-E103A/B. Please refer to sheet 9 of
train isolate if require?
the P&ID.

Which other utility connections could be

necessary?
why did not you provide
Isolation valves are provided upstream and
3-PU101-PR-DI- valve here as for other utility
7 downstream of every regeneration reboiler
034 connections? how will one
300/310-E103A/B. Please refer to sheet 9 of
train isolate if require?
the P&ID.

After the 3rd DRM was made an evaluation

between process department and air cooler
as per MOM 33 of 3rd DRM, supplier in order to check the feasibility of the
M/s Bellelli to mentioned proposed solution.
3-PU101-PR-DI- isolation valves at each Air cooler supplier and process department
8
034 connection of air cooler. these agree that the equipment cannot work as half
should be easily accessible service and the total system cannot perform
from nearest platform without the air cooler when this is necessary.
Therefore is useless the addition of valves at
each connection or by-pass the equipment.

Page 2 of 5
 CLIENT/CONSULTANT STATUS
Document No/ COMMENTS (Piping /Civil & &REMARKS
Client/Consultant
S. No. Drawing No Structure / I&C / Process / BELLELLI RESPONSES
Response
&Section Material &Corrosion /
QA&QC

even after six (o6)th

3-PU101-PR-DI-
9 revision,documents are not Noted.
034
aligned.
Harmonic analysis is typically performed on
piping connected to equipment which may
please provide generate significant pulsating loads which
reference/criteria or may result in piping mechanical vibration
3-PU101-PR-DI- (e.g. pulsating compressors). Since this piping
10 supporting
034 is not connected to such equipment, harmonic
calculation for not
implementing this analysis is not necessary and will not be
performed.

please provide
We have check with our stress analisys
reference/criteria or
3-PU101-PR-DI- department and the impact load due to BDV
11 supporting
034 operations will be considered into calculation
calculation for not
if the loads will be not negligible.
implementing this

3-PU101-PR-DI- please mention this note

12 Noted.
034 on P&ID (where applicable)

please mention this note

on P&ID (where applicable)
3-PU101-PR-DI-
13 For example a paint bucket might be suitable.
034
what size will be the small
container?

3-PU101-PR-DI-
14 why not before approval? Added in this revision.
034

Page 3 of 5
 CLIENT/CONSULTANT STATUS
Document No/ COMMENTS (Piping /Civil & &REMARKS
Client/Consultant
S. No. Drawing No Structure / I&C / Process / BELLELLI RESPONSES
Response
&Section Material &Corrosion /
QA&QC
noted. but please note that
if in 06th revision, Bellelli
can delete an item due to
3-PU101-PR-DI- The addition of a new items would result in
15 some technical reasons, than
034 extra-costs and extra time.
can be added an item due to
some technical reason. please
confirm
Detailed characteristics will be provided in a
3-PU101-PR-DI- relative document.
16 not clear?
034 This comment is not appropriate to this
document.
Detailed characteristics will be provided in a
3-PU101-PR-DI- relative document.
17 not clear?
034 This comment is not appropriate to this
document.
why out of Bellelli scope?
where we agreed that it will The battery limits are clearly indicated in the
out of Bellelli scope? P&ID sheet 19 since the first revision.
In addition, this pipeline will have to be
in the referred E-mail, ENAR placed on the main pipe rack that runs
provided the process piping between the two trains of amine sweetening
detail. now it is Bellelli unit together with other many pipes.
3-PU101-PR-DI- responsibility to provide not
18 The design and routing of the pipes in the
034 only this material but also
main pipe rack is out of bellelli scope of
pipe supports required to
supply.
support it, hydrotest drain and
vent connections (with So not having information and detail about
complete assembly), NDE the main pipe rack it is impossible to provide
examinations of these what you requested.
materials and other relevant
items necessarily required for
Page 4 of 5
 CLIENT/CONSULTANT STATUS
Document No/ COMMENTS (Piping /Civil & &REMARKS
Client/Consultant
S. No. Drawing No Structure / I&C / Process / BELLELLI RESPONSES
Response
&Section Material &Corrosion /
QA&QC
its operation.

no justification in this regards

shall be acceptable.

also please note that margin

in length of pipes shall be as
per point no. 31 of 3rd DRM
All detail fabrication drawings of HSS skid
3-PU101-PR-DI- it must be required at this
19 have already been provided with TN 231 of
034 stage
27/06/2013.
no such deviation was
submitted
All detail fabrication drawings of HSS skid
3-PU101-PR-DI- at the time of bid. now its
20 have already been provided with TN 231 of
034 Bellelli's responsibility to
27/06/2013.
provide the required
information as per contract.

CONTRACTOR ENAR
PREPARED BY DATE SIGN REPLIED BY DATE SIGNATURE

EM/MD 27/08/2013
APPROVED BY
SV

Page 5 of 5