DOC TITLE Design Report for Treted Water Tank (7.5x4.5x3.

0)
DOC N0 SEPL-NRP-IOCL-150-CIV-DOC-02
Sr.NO Comments

Drawing & design calculations are not Senchronised few parameter in drawings is
1 shown different whatever assumed in design calculations

2 As per Soil Report

3 Check Input Inline with Drawings

4 Analysis Along the Y direction also to be done

5 RCC tank is Fixed Base ,R shall be considered as 2 & I value shall be 1.5

6 Sa/g Please check

7 Wrong Input Please check in line with Drawings

If hydrostatic pressure is more than 33%,effect of Hydrodynamic pressure shall be

consided
8

Wall shall be designed for most critical case along Y & along X direction.The wall
9 shall be designed for cumulative effect hydrostatic & Hydrodynamic effect
10 Wall Stability,pressure check,sliding check not performed
11 Crack width for base slabshall also be checked

DOC TITLE Design Report for Treted Water Tank (7.5x4.5x3.0)

DOC N0 SEPL-NRP-IOCL-150-CIV-DOC-02

Sr.NO Comments

1 Check Shall be made in the Calculation-Soil Unit Weight-15 KN/m3

2 2.5?

3 Show Calculaions
Actual Distribution & linear Distribution diagram for Impulsive & convective
4 pressure

5 Slashing wave height Calculation it shall be more than free board please check
6 Minimum Reinforcement of wall shall be 0.35%

7 Along X & Y Cumulative Pressure diagram with moment calculation required

 Date
Rev -A
Reply

Noted according Drawings is updated

Noted & incorporated as per soil report

-18.88kN/m3 considered for design
Noted & incorporated
Analysis along Y direction is added in
design calculations
Noted & Incorporated

Noted & Incorporated with(1.75X1/Tc)

Noted & Incorporated

Noted & Incorporated accordingly
cumulitive effect considered for wall design

Noted & Incorporated

Noted & Incorporated

Noted & Incorporated

Date-18-03-2021
Rev -B

Reply

Noted & incorporated with 18.88kN/m3

Maximum LVL of water is considered
Detailed Calculations are shown in
provided excel

Noted & incorporated

Noted & incorporated

As per IS3370 part 2 -Minimum percentage
of Steel shall be 0.3 %-792m2 in wall as
per cl7.1.1,Where aas we provided
=1607+904=2511m2
Noted & incorporated
DOC TITLE Design Report for Treted Water Tank (7.5x4.5x3.0)
DOC N0 SEPL-NRP-IOCL-150-CIV-DOC-02
Sr.NO Comments

Drawing & design calculations are not Senchronised few parameter in drawings is
1 shown different whatever assumed in design calculations

2 As per Soil Report

3 Check Input Inline with Drawings

4 Analysis Along the Y direction also to be done

5 RCC tank is Fixed Base ,R shall be considered as 2 & I value shall be 1.5

6 Sa/g Please check

7 Wrong Input Please check in line with Drawings
If hydrostatic pressure is more than 33%,effect of Hydrodynamic pressure shall be
8 consided

Wall shall be designed for most critical case along Y & along X direction.The wall
9 shall be designed for cumulative effect hydrostatic & Hydrodynamic effect
10 Wall Stability,pressure check,sliding check not performed
11 Crack width for base slabshall also be checked
 Reply

Noted according Drawings is updated

Noted & incorporated as per soil report
-18.88kN/m3
Noted & incorporated
Analysis along Y direction is added in
design calculations
Noted & Incorporated

Noted & Incorporated with(1.75X1/Tc)

Noted & Incorporated

Noted & Incorporated

Noted & Incorporated

Noted & Incorporated

Noted & Incorporated