Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BS Iso TR 05925-2-1997 (1999)
BS Iso TR 05925-2-1997 (1999)
5925-2:1997
Fire tests —
Smoke control door and
shutter assemblies —
Part 2: Commentary on test method and
test data application
National foreword
Summary of pages
This document comprises a front cover, an inside front cover, pages i and ii,
the ISO/TR title page, page ii, pages 1 to 8 and a back cover.
This standard has been updated (see copyright date) and may have had
amendments incorporated. This will be indicated in the amendment table on
the inside front cover.
This British Standard, having
been prepared under the
direction of the Health and Amendments issued since publication
Environment Sector Board,
was published under the Amd. No. Date Comments
authority of the Standards
Board and comes into effect on
15 February 1998
© BSI 04-1999
Contents
Page
National foreword Inside front cover
Foreword ii
Introduction 1
1 Scope 1
2 References 1
3 Definitions 1
4 Fire and smoke 2
5 The role of doors in fire 2
6 Selection of test conditions 3
7 Test package 5
8 Some points relevant to tests 5
9 Practical application of test results 6
Annex A Estimation of smoke concentration 8
Figure 1 — Examples of different doors 6
Figure 2 — Different fire scenarios 7
Table 1 — Time (minutes) to reach 1 % & 2 % smoke concentration 8
© BSI 04-1999 i
ii blank
BS ISO TR 5925-2:1997
Foreword
ISO (the International Organization for Standardization) is a worldwide
federation of national standards bodies (ISO member bodies). The work of
preparing International Standards is normally carried out through ISO technical
committees. Each member body interested in a subject for which a technical
committee has been established has the right to be represented on that committee.
International organizations, governmental and non-governmental, in liaison
with ISO, also take part in the work. ISO collaborates closely with the
International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) on all matters of electrotechnical
standardization.
The main task of technical committees is to prepare International Standards, but
in exceptional circumstances a technical committee may propose the publication of
a Technical Report of one of the following types:
— type 1, when the required support cannot be obtained for the publication of
an International Standard, despite repeated efforts;
— type 2, when the subject is still under technical development or where for any
other reason there is the future but not immediate possibility of an agreement
on an International Standard;
— type 3, when a technical committee has collected data of a different kind from
that which is normally published as an International Standard (“state of the
art”, for example).
Technical Reports of types 1 and 2 are subject to review within three years of
publication, to decide whether they can be transformed into International
Standards. Technical Reports of type 3 do not necessarily have to be reviewed until
the data they provide are considered to be no longer valid or useful.
ISO/TR 5925-2, which is a Technical Report of type 3, was prepared jointly by
Technical Committee ISO/TC 92, Fire safety, Subcommittee SC 2, Fire resistance.
ISO/TR 5925 consists of the following parts, under the general title Fire tests —
Smoke control door and shutter assemblies:
— Part 1: Ambient and medium temperature leakage test procedure;
— Part 2: Commentary on test method and test data application.
Descriptors: Buildings, fire protection, smoke control, doors, fire doors, tests, fire tests, test results.
ii © BSI 04-1999
BS ISO TR 5925-2:1997
© BSI 04-1999 1
BS ISO TR 5925-2:1997
2 © BSI 04-1999
BS ISO TR 5925-2:1997
5.2 Smoke compartmentation In most cases, smoke control door assemblies need
When considering the concept of fire resistance to be provided with some closer mechanism to
(see ISO 834 and ISO/TR 3956) one of the basic ensure that the door is shut when not in use or
ideas is to restrict the spread of fire to different closes on the occurance of a fire. A fully or partially
parts of the building by providing fire open door will allow smoke to pass through and
compartments. In the same way, the spread of unless steps are taken to ensure the closure of doors
smoke in a building can also be restricted to a the purpose of smoke control could be negated.
limited zone, thereby, facilitating limited or full Smoke control door assemblies need to be
evacuation of the building depending upon considered as part of the fire barrier system.
circumstances. The sub-division of the building for Openings for services in shafts, walls, floors and
this purpose can be termed as smoke ceilings and even some partition and ceiling
compartmentation and each zone so formed is a constructions may allow the leakage of smoke
smoke compartment. The boundaries of smoke unless care is taken in their design and installation.
compartments may often be contiguous with those Any requirements for smoke control doors need to
of fire compartments, but in many cases the former take into consideration smoke leakage through all
are subdivisions within the latter. The size of a potential routes.
smoke compartment depends upon the evacuation
needs, the amount of smoke that may be generated 6 Selection of test conditions
and the facilities for smoke control. Smoke control door assemblies will need to function
Each smoke compartment should be surrounded by in different conditions depending upon the
a smoke barrier i.e. a construction capable of proximity to the seat of fire, the rate of smoke
resisting the passage of smoke. The amount of production and the environmental conditions. The
leakage to a surrounding compartment should be technical committee responsible for preparing these
limited to the maximum that can be tolerated either standards has identified three typical situations for
for escape or fire fighting operations. which standard test methods would be needed.
5.3 The function of smoke control doors If a fire develops in a given room with a closed door,
Smoke control doors are provided in fire barriers to pressure due to fire on the affected side will increase
limit the passage of smoke and other combustion and the ensuing pressure differential will tend to
products from one side to the other thereby push the smoke-laden air through all available gaps
maintaining the integrity of the barrier and giving into the adjacent area. This will be typical of a door
more time for escape and fire control. Smoke control separating a room from a corridor (room/corridor
door assemblies can also be used to prevent damage door). Pressure across a given door is likely to be the
to sensitive equipment such as computers and combination of the pressure due to “normal”
telecommunication apparatus. conditions and the pressure created by the fire.
Mechanical ventilation effects may introduce a
It is not the purpose of this series of standard pressure difference of approximately the same
methods of test to give recommendations concerning magnitude. In the event that the windows to the
the proper provision and installation of doors in room are open, or break by heat, a wind generated
buildings. Such matters will normally be dealt with pressure difference may also become a factor.
by the national codes of practice or by regulations. Selection of an appropriate test pressure level has to
Some of important factors which can be used by the be a compromise based on probabalistic
authorities to formulate codes are described. considerations.
Any door, without louvres and other openings, when
in the closed position has the ability to obstruct the
passage of smoke and other products of combustion.
However, if it has not been specially designed it may
only have a limited effectiveness as a smoke barrier.
The standard fire resistance test of ISO 3008 has a
requirement for evaluating the passage of hot gases
through any openings in or around the door. The
technique used does not monitor gas flow rate as
such but only the effect of such a flow on the ignition
of a selected combustible material. The methods
specified in ISO 5925 are more precise and are able
to quantify the leakage rate.
© BSI 04-1999 3
BS ISO TR 5925-2:1997
As the temperature increases not only will the Figure 2 shows simple examples to represent
pressure differential increase but also a pressure various test condition. During the early stages of a
gradient will develop over the height of the room. fire, Figure 2 a), a door to a room will be exposed
According to ISO/DIS 834-1 (the revision in parts of only to moderate heating conditions represented by
ISO 834:1975), the maximum pressure differential the ambient temperature with other doors not
used in a test on a 3 m vertical element is 20 Pa. The receiving much heat. As the fire grows to full
higher pressures in the upper part will cause more intensity the door will be subjected to the conditions
leakage to occur through clearances in the upper of a fully developed fire simulated by the fire
part of the door, with either no flow at the bottom or resistance tests. If the door to the fire room is open
a flow in the reverse direction if opposing pressure there will be little resistance to the spread of fire
conditions prevail. At a later stage the increasing and smoke to the adjacent areas. If the door is closed
heat is likely to cause the door to distort, and then the leakage of smoke will be governed by the
combustible materials to decompose and char, thus effectiveness of this door. An ordinary (unclassified)
increasing the gap sizes through which smoke can door will not provide much resistance to the transfer
pass. The severity of exposure can also be an of fire and fire will be transmitted next door with
important factor for the extent to which a door may only little delay. With a fire control door the
allow the passage of smoke and hot gases. transmission of the fire will be prevented if the door
The possible range of test conditions have been is properly mounted and in a closed position.
divided into three recognizable ranges, the near The doors directly exposed to a fire are assessed on
ambient conditions, the medium temperature range the basis of their performance under the standard
and the conditions of a fully developed fire. fire test conditions, if the door is of an unclassfied
ISO/DIS 5925-1 apparatus can be used for smoke type high temperature conditions can be expected in
control doors with smoke laden gases in the the next space as well, Figure 2 b), and therefore
temperature range from the ambient to 200 °C and any door in that area will also need to be assessed
replaces the special test which only dealt with under high temperature conditions. However in
ambient temperature conditions. The ambient practice doors further removed from the fire zone
situation occurs at the beginning of a fire or when are to be subjected to the conditions represented by
the door is remote from the fire and smoke and fire the medium temperature test as long as the first
gases have cooled down by the time they reach it. In barrier remains intact, Figure 2 c). Doors further
either case the temperature of gases will be low and away may be subjected to little temperature rise
hardly any fire generated pressure gradient will and can be assessed by the ambient temperature
exist over the height of the door. The test has test of ISO/DIS 5925-1.
therefore been designed to be carried out at or near In the simple layout in Figure 1 , doors A & B to the
to the ambient temperature conditions but over a fire room need to be subjected to the full heating
range of possible pressure differences. At the other conditions for their assessment, whilst the other
extreme, with a fully developed fire the door will be room doors need to be judged under medium
exposed to the full severity of heat and fire temperature conditions for smoke leakage. The
generated pressure, as in the standard fire performance of the lobby door and stair doors will
resistance test of ISO 3008. In between these two depend on their distance from the fire zone and the
extremes a variety of intermediate conditions will presence of intermediate barriers. Door E with a
exist and a choice has been made for the medium lobby approach is well protected and therefore the
temperature test, in which the temperature selected ambient temperature test should be appropriate for
is such as to represent partial cooling of the gases assessing its performance. When no lobby exists the
but it is still sufficiently high to cause physical medium temperature test of ISO/DIS 5925-1 is to be
distress due to distortion or surface damage. considered as suitable.
4 © BSI 04-1999
BS ISO TR 5925-2:1997
In some cases it may be almost impossible to predict The high temperature test is not available at
which of the three standard situations adequately present and when available will be an adjunct to
represent the role of a smoke control door assembly the ISO 3008 test. The pressure conditions of
in a building. In many cases the door may indeed be ISO/DIS 834-1 need to be adjusted to give positive
subject to a variety of conditions in succession. pressure over the whole height of the door to prevent
There will be instances when a door is required for air flow from the unexposed side. A partial
smoke control and fire control purposes, in such enclosure attachment on the unexposed side will
cases the door will need to be tested as a fire control allow the aggregate leakage of hot gases from the
door assembly in accordance with ISO 3008 as well door to be established by utilising a tracer gas
as ISO 5925. However, there are many situations in technique. If the covering on the unexposed side is
a building where a fire safety authority can foresee considered not to intefere with the measurement of
clearly the role of a door in a particular location, or the fire barrier properties of the door, a single test
a fire safety engineer can predict the most likely may be used for smoke control and for fire control
scenario for its primary function. For example, it measurements.
may be expected that in a residential occupancy the
emphasis will lie on rapid evacuation and therefore 8 Some points relevant to tests
the test conditions of ISO/DIS 5925-1 may be 8.1 Selection of test specimens
considered adequate. Access doors to lobbies, or
stairways without a lobby approach, need to provide If a test is to be carried out on a door specimen, then
resistance to smoke penetration at medium it is important to ensure that the complete door
temperatures, but with a degree of fire resistance to assembly chosen for the test is typical of the type
prevent vertical spread of fire. There may be other under consideration. It is recommended that the
situations where the evacuation problems require door assembly should be selected from the normal
the maximum safeguards as in health care manufacturing run under conditions which, as far
buildings with special evacuation problems. as, possible afford random selection within the
batch. This may not be possible where a door is in
7 Test package the development stage but in other cases the
national authorities may wish to provide rules for
As with all fire tests the test conditions have been making a selection. The door selected should be
selected with a view to offering pragmatic solutions typical as regards door leaf and frame, hinges, door
in the selection of suitable smoke control doors for furniture including any essential closing devices,
use in buildings. The test conditions should not be and door sealing systems, etc.
assumed to represent the range likely to be met in
“real” fires. This does not make them any less useful 8.2 Allowance for use
as an indication of the way in which a door in The test procedures specified do not simulate the
question will contribute to the protection of wear and tear to which a door may be subjected in
occupants and the building. practice. The requirement that the door should be
The ambient temperature test, ISO/DIS 5925-1, has opened and closed a certain number of times before
been designed to be as simple as possible. It can be the test is undertaken has been only included to
used not only as a smoke control test but also for any ensure that the door is capable of operating correctly
purpose where air leakage through a door assembly at the start of the test. The national authorities may
under the test conditions is of interest. wish to provide guidance on procedures to simulate
door usage.
The medium temperature test, ISO/DIS 5925-1,
uses the same apparatus but creates conditions 8.3 Extrapolation of results
under which door assemblies will be exposed to a Normally the results obtained from testing one type
moderately elevated temperature, defined of fire door assembly cannot be used to assess
as 200 °C. The test temperature level corresponds to results of another type. Even minor variations of the
temperatures at which doors of combustible door furniture, e.g. hardware, may significantly
materials suffer only limited damage due to affect test results, however, in the case of smoke
charring or decomposition but distortion can take control doors tested to ISO/DIS 5925-1 small
place and sealing materials can be affected. The variations are possible which have been listed
temperatures may not be high enough for some in ISO/DIS 5925-1 :--, clause 11.
intumescing materials to operate satisfactorily and
It may be useful to express the test results in terms
therefore seals of other types will be needed to
of the ratio of effective air flow area to the door leaf
reduce smoke penetration. The test is able to make
as suggested in ISO/DIS 5925-1.
some distinction between doors able to resist heat
damage and others.
© BSI 04-1999 5
BS ISO TR 5925-2:1997
1) McGuireet al, Factors in controlling smoke in high buildings, Technical Paper No 341, Division of Building Research, National
Research Council, Ottawa, Canada, 1971.
6 © BSI 04-1999
BS ISO TR 5925-2:1997
© BSI 04-1999 7
BS ISO TR 5925-2:1997
Y 2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
1 49,5 216 574 Z Z 114 703 Z Z Z
2 6,4 24,7 57,5 108 182 13,6 57 149 351 Z
3 2 7,4 16,5 29,8 48 4,2 16,1 38,1 74,3 133
4 1 3,2 7 12,4 19,5 1,9 6,8 15,4 28,6 47,7
5 0,5 1,7 3,6 6,3 9,9 1 3,6 7,8 14,1 22,8
8 © BSI 04-1999
blank 9
BS ISO TR
5925-2:1997
BSI — British Standards Institution
BSI is the independent national body responsible for preparing
British Standards. It presents the UK view on standards in Europe and at the
international level. It is incorporated by Royal Charter.
Revisions
It is the constant aim of BSI to improve the quality of our products and services.
We would be grateful if anyone finding an inaccuracy or ambiguity while using
this British Standard would inform the Secretary of the technical committee
responsible, the identity of which can be found on the inside front cover.
Tel: 020 8996 9000. Fax: 020 8996 7400.
BSI offers members an individual updating service called PLUS which ensures
that subscribers automatically receive the latest editions of standards.
Buying standards
Orders for all BSI, international and foreign standards publications should be
addressed to Customer Services. Tel: 020 8996 9001. Fax: 020 8996 7001.
Information on standards
Copyright
Copyright subsists in all BSI publications. BSI also holds the copyright, in the
UK, of the publications of the internationalstandardization bodies. Except as
permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 no extract may be
reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any
means – electronic, photocopying, recording or otherwise – without prior written
permission from BSI.
This does not preclude the free use, in the course of implementing the standard,
of necessary details such as symbols, and size, type or grade designations. If these
details are to be used for any other purpose than implementation then the prior
written permission of BSI must be obtained.