Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1)
a) current price
no of outstanding shares
2)
a) one half of
cash and cash equivalent
no of shares to be repurchased
b) dividend per share
5) cash received
a) repurchase
no of existing shares after reperchase
stock value
cost of buying shares
capital gains
after tax 20%
number of shares
dividend
dividend per share
total dividend
tax on dividend
cash received
share price after dividend
stock current value
cost of buying shares
capital gain
tax @20%
capital gain after tax
total cash received
4) dividend
cash received without tax
with tax cash
repurchase
no of shares repurchased
cash received without tax
cash received with tax
7)
DIVIDEND PAID
current price after dividend is paid 47.59
increase in price per year 10%
price after 5 years 76.6384426994572
overall increase year wise 110%
price after 10 years 123.426978351903
REPURCHASE
current price after dividend is paid 48.98
increase in price per year 10%
price after 5 years 78.88
overall increase year wise 110%
price after 10 years 127.041505695698
t=5
dividend paid after tax cash flow
t=5 repurchase
cash received from dividend after tax 0
cash from selling shares 78882779.8
cost of buying shares 10450000
capital gain 68432779.8
tax @20% 13686555.96
total cash inflow 65196223.84
difference between the two cash flow 1795469.68043427
t = 10
dividend paid after tax cash flow
t = 10
cash received from dividend after tax 0
cash from selling shares 127041505.695698
cost of buying shares 10450000
capital gain 116591505.695698
tax @20% 23318301.1391396
total cash inflow 103723204.556558
difference between the two cash flow 2891621.87503619
8)
rate of return is 20%
DIVIDEND PAID
current price after dividend is paid 47.59
increase in price per year 20%
price after 5 years 118.410298438329
overall increase year wise 120%
price after 10 years 294.642713810063
REPURCHASE
current price after dividend is paid 48.98
increase in price per year 20%
price after 5 years 121.8779136
overall increase year wise 120%
price after 10 years 303.271249969152
t=5
dividend paid after tax cash flow
t=5
cash received from dividend after tax
cash from selling shares 121877913.6
cost of buying shares 10450000
capital gain 111427913.6
tax @20% 22285582.72
total cash inflow 99592330.88
difference between the two cash flow 2774092.12933679
t = 10
dividend paid after tax cash flow
t = 10
cash received from dividend after tax
cash from selling shares 303271249.969152
cost of buying shares 10450000
capital gain 292821249.969152
tax @20% 58564249.9938304
total cash inflow 244706999.975322
difference between the two cash flow 6902828.92727137
9)
present value of cash flow
present value of cash flow
7/30/2019 7/30/2018 7/30/2017
97,793,000 108,784,000 129,818,000
47,755,000 61,837,000 83,703,000
33,413,000 46,548,000 70,492,000
11,750,000 8,934,000 11,708,000
21,663,000 37,614,000 58,784,000
10,586,000 10,503,000 10,002,000
5,491,000 5,554,000 5,146,000
5,627,000 5,683,000 5,357,000
-136,000 -129,000 -211,000
5,095,000 4,949,000 4,856,000
1,383,000 1,846,000 1,616,000
599,000 681,000 589,000
10,000 0 1,000
752,000 1,132,000 1,003,000
22,000 33,000 23,000
2,373,000 2,940,000 1,593,000
50,038,000 46,947,000 46,115,000
2,789,000 3,006,000 3,322,000
12,039,000 12,243,000 12,819,000
4,545,000 4,710,000 4,926,000
1,298,000 1,443,000 1,830,000
6,196,000 6,090,000 6,063,000
-9,250,000 -9,237,000 -9,497,000
35,730,000 34,258,000 32,305,000
33,529,000 31,706,000 29,766,000
2,201,000 2,552,000 2,539,000
4,958,000 4,882,000 4,738,000
4,065,000 3,219,000 4,239,000
4,065,000 3,219,000 4,239,000
2,496,000 1,582,000 1,511,000
48.98
4220000000
35.00645270556
5904500000
120549203.756635
1.39355676185981
10.45
1.39355676185981
1393556.76185981
278711.352371961
1114845.40948784
47.59
47586443.2381402
10450000
37136443.2381402
7427288.64762804
29709154.5905121
30824000
1393556.76185981
1114845.40948785
28566.1620276387
1399170.61611374
1119336.492891
t=5 10%
discount rate dividend repurchase
1% ₹ 61,438,487.56 ₹ 62,031,969.95
2% ₹ 58,538,861.82 ₹ 59,050,228.62
3% ₹ 55,804,892.88 ₹ 56,238,835.39
4% ₹ 53,225,643.84 ₹ 53,586,543.63
5% ₹ 50,790,995.27 ₹ 51,082,947.33
6% ₹ 48,491,577.12 ₹ 48,718,411.10
7% ₹ 46,318,706.89 ₹ 46,484,006.55
8% ₹ 44,264,333.37 ₹ 44,371,454.46
9% ₹ 42,320,985.45 ₹ 42,373,072.14
10% ₹ 40,481,725.57 ₹ 40,481,725.57
11% ₹ 38,740,107.17 ₹ 38,690,785.62
12% ₹ 37,090,135.99 ₹ 36,994,088.30
13% ₹ 35,526,234.68 ₹ 35,385,898.28
14% ₹ 34,043,210.42 ₹ 33,860,875.70
15% ₹ 32,636,225.38 ₹ 32,414,045.72
16% ₹ 31,300,769.65 ₹ 31,040,770.73
17% ₹ 30,032,636.45 ₹ 29,736,724.78
18% ₹ 28,827,899.37 ₹ 28,497,870.30
19% ₹ 27,682,891.56 ₹ 27,320,436.59
20% ₹ 26,594,186.56 ₹ 26,200,900.14
21% ₹ 25,558,580.72 ₹ 25,135,966.60
22% ₹ 24,573,077.05 ₹ 24,122,554.08
23% ₹ 23,634,870.33 ₹ 23,157,777.93
24% ₹ 22,741,333.38 ₹ 22,238,936.58
25% ₹ 21,890,004.53 ₹ 21,363,498.63
26% ₹ 21,078,575.90 ₹ 20,529,090.85
27% ₹ 20,304,882.72 ₹ 19,733,487.16
28% ₹ 19,566,893.41 ₹ 18,974,598.45
30% ₹ 18,190,511.84 ₹ 17,559,238.62
FROM THIS WE CAN SEE THAT AS LONG AS THE RATE OF DISCOUTN IS LESS THAN RATE OF RETURN REPURCHASE IS BETTER O
t = 10 10%
discount rate dividend repurchase
1% ₹ 97,052,636.56 ₹ 98,689,070.14
2% ₹ 92,441,116.45 ₹ 93,945,302.06
3% ₹ 88,093,054.37 ₹ 89,472,547.39
4% ₹ 83,991,056.43 ₹ 85,252,913.42
5% ₹ 80,119,028.85 ₹ 81,269,844.84
6% ₹ 76,462,069.65 ₹ 77,508,012.32
7% ₹ 73,006,370.32 ₹ 73,953,211.34
8% ₹ 69,739,126.31 ₹ 70,592,270.16
9% ₹ 66,648,455.72 ₹ 67,412,966.13
10% ₹ 63,723,325.13 ₹ 64,403,949.41
11% ₹ 60,953,482.06 ₹ 61,554,673.49
12% ₹ 58,329,393.33 ₹ 58,855,331.83
13% ₹ 55,842,188.77 ₹ 56,296,799.87
14% ₹ 53,483,609.83 ₹ 53,870,582.21
15% ₹ 51,245,962.50 ₹ 51,568,764.22
16% ₹ 49,122,074.29 ₹ 49,383,967.69
17% ₹ 47,105,254.78 ₹ 47,309,310.35
18% ₹ 45,189,259.49 ₹ 45,338,368.65
19% ₹ 43,368,256.70 ₹ 43,465,143.62
20% ₹ 41,636,797.04 ₹ 41,684,029.61
21% ₹ 39,989,785.47 ₹ 39,989,785.47
22% ₹ 38,422,455.63 ₹ 38,377,508.15
23% ₹ 36,930,346.10 ₹ 36,842,608.29
24% ₹ 35,509,278.71 ₹ 35,380,787.91
25% ₹ 34,155,338.42 ₹ 33,988,019.67
26% ₹ 32,864,854.83 ₹ 32,660,527.92
27% ₹ 31,634,385.11 ₹ 31,394,771.12
28% ₹ 30,460,698.28 ₹ 30,187,425.60
30% ₹ 28,271,722.24 ₹ 27,935,674.67
SIMILARLLY FROM THIS ALSO WE CAN SEE THAT AS LONG AS THE RATE OF DISCOUTN IS LESS THAN RATE OF RETURN REPURC
(for every 35 shares company will purchase 1 share)
28566.16 shares
20%
dividend repurchase
₹ 93,234,077.52 ₹ 94,758,685.58
₹ 88,806,107.20 ₹ 90,203,842.50
₹ 84,631,108.64 ₹ 85,909,219.47
₹ 80,692,380.27 ₹ 81,857,636.38
₹ 76,974,468.86 ₹ 78,033,197.22
₹ 73,463,065.60 ₹ 74,421,183.20
₹ 70,144,911.56 ₹ 71,007,955.50
₹ 67,007,711.87 ₹ 67,780,866.95
₹ 64,040,057.54 ₹ 64,728,181.67
₹ 61,231,354.31 ₹ 61,839,001.86
₹ 58,571,757.78 ₹ 59,103,201.03
₹ 56,052,114.20 ₹ 56,511,363.16
₹ 53,663,906.48 ₹ 54,054,727.13
₹ 51,399,204.76 ₹ 51,725,135.87
₹ 49,250,621.27 ₹ 49,514,989.93
₹ 47,211,269.01 ₹ 47,417,204.97
₹ 45,274,723.85 ₹ 45,425,172.80
₹ 43,434,989.87 ₹ 43,532,725.69
₹ 41,686,467.45 ₹ 41,734,103.60
₹ 40,023,924.13 ₹ 40,023,924.13
₹ 38,442,467.65 ₹ 38,397,154.85
₹ 36,937,521.37 ₹ 36,849,087.98
₹ 35,504,801.46 ₹ 35,375,316.95
₹ 34,140,296.03 ₹ 33,971,714.92
₹ 32,840,245.88 ₹ 32,634,414.98
₹ 31,601,126.70 ₹ 31,359,791.84
₹ 30,419,632.69 ₹ 30,144,444.98
₹ 29,292,661.47 ₹ 28,985,183.13
₹ 27,190,812.03 ₹ 26,823,110.29
RN REPURCHASE IS BETTER OPTION
20%
dividend repurchase
₹ 227,377,354.53 ₹ 232,830,313.99
₹ 216,501,409.83 ₹ 221,638,669.26
₹ 206,246,812.32 ₹ 211,086,407.78
₹ 196,572,539.69 ₹ 201,131,316.49
₹ 187,440,635.92 ₹ 191,734,337.60
₹ 178,815,955.77 ₹ 182,859,305.69
₹ 170,665,932.79 ₹ 174,472,709.01
₹ 162,960,368.41 ₹ 166,543,472.38
₹ 155,671,239.97 ₹ 159,042,759.73
₹ 148,772,525.93 ₹ 151,943,794.19
₹ 142,240,046.54 ₹ 145,221,694.12
₹ 136,051,318.46 ₹ 138,853,323.57
₹ 130,185,422.07 ₹ 132,817,155.65
₹ 124,622,880.11 ₹ 127,093,147.74
₹ 119,345,546.81 ₹ 121,662,627.35
₹ 114,336,506.37 ₹ 116,508,187.65
₹ 109,579,979.90 ₹ 111,613,591.74
₹ 105,061,240.23 ₹ 106,963,684.97
₹ 100,766,533.69 ₹ 102,544,314.40
₹ 96,683,008.29 ₹ 98,342,255.01
₹ 92,798,647.76 ₹ 94,345,141.72
₹ 89,102,210.93 ₹ 90,541,407.06
₹ 85,583,175.93 ₹ 86,920,223.74
₹ 82,231,688.79 ₹ 83,471,451.76
₹ 79,038,516.18 ₹ 80,185,589.75
₹ 75,995,001.70 ₹ 77,053,730.07
₹ 73,093,025.72 ₹ 74,067,517.36
₹ 70,324,968.17 ₹ 71,219,110.39
₹ 65,162,422.67 ₹ 65,906,709.79