MGMT20143: Assessment 3A: Idea Selection Marking Rubric 15%

Weighting Fail-III Fail-II Fail-I Pass Credit Distinction High Distinction

Very limited
No development of A very basic A credible
development of an Poor or limited Very sound
an evaluation development of an development of an Exemplary development
Idea Selection: Develop an evaluation development of an development of an
framework to evaluation evaluation of an evaluation
evaluation framework to framework to evaluation framework evaluation framework to
compare the ideas framework to framework to framework to compare
compare the ideas that were 20% compare the ideas to compare the ideas compare the ideas that
developed individually in that were compare the ideas compare the ideas the ideas that were
that were that were developed were developed
Assessment 2 developed that were developed that were developed developed individually in
developed individually in individually in
individually in individually in individually in Assessment 2
individually in Assessment 2 Assessment 2
Assessment 2 Assessment 2 Assessment 2
Assessment 2

Very limited Poor or limited A credible Very sound and

No description or
Idea Selection: Describe and
justification of how
justify how the best idea was 20%
selected the best idea was
selected
Basic description or Exemplary and highly
description or description or description or persuasive description
justification of how persuasive description or
justification of how justification of how justification of how or justification of how
the best idea was justification of how the
the best idea was the best idea was the best idea was the best idea was
selected best idea was selected
selected selected selected selected

Very limited
No attempt to Poor or limited Basic attempt to A credible attempt
attempt to identify Very good identification Exemplary identification
Idea Selection: Identify any identify any gaps attempt to identify identify gaps that to identify gaps that
gaps that need to of gaps that need to be of gaps that need to be
gaps that need to be that need to be gaps that need to be need to be need to be
addressed before the idea is
20% be addressed addressed before the addressed before the
addressed before addressed before the addressed before addressed before
pitched to an investor before the idea is idea is pitched to an idea is pitched to an
the idea is pitched idea is pitched to an the idea is pitched to the idea is pitched
pitched to an investor investor
to an investor investor an investor to an investor
investor

Very limited A credible attempt

No attempt to Poor or limited Basic attempt to
Idea Selection: Revision of attempt to revise to revise the Very good revision of Exemplary revision of the
revise the business attempt to revise the revise the business
the business model canvas to the business model business model the business model business model canvas
20% model canvas to business model model canvas to
incorporate the above canvas to canvas to canvas to incorporate to incorporate the above
changes incorporate the canvas to incorporate incorporate the
incorporate the incorporate the the above changes changes
above changes the above changes above changes
above changes above changes

No attempt to Very limited Poor or limited

Idea Selection: Prepare 'best prepare 'best case'
case' and 'worst case' cash and 'worst case'
flow projections for the first
20%
cash flow
two years
projections for the
first two years
Basic attempt to Credible preparation Very good preparation Exemplary preparation of
attempt to prepare attempt to prepare
prepare 'best case' of 'best case' and of 'best case' and 'worst 'best case' and 'worst
'best case' and 'best case' and 'worst
and 'worst case' 'worst case' cash case' cash flow case' cash flow
'worst case' cash case' cash flow
cash flow projections flow projections for projections for the first projections for the first
flow projections for projections for the
for the first two years the first two years two years two years
the first two years first two years

100%