Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/265889420
Process modeling of aluminum scraps melting in molten salt and metal bath
in a rotary furnace
CITATIONS READS
6 890
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Markus A Reuter on 25 December 2014.
Keywords: Process Modeling, Computational Fluid Dynamics, Aluminum Scrap Melting, Rotary Furnace
Structure of the Process Model The burner was set as the inlet, and it was simplified to reduce the
computing time. The profile of velocity, temperature and mass
The process model was developed based on a CFD framework, flows of gases at the inlet was defined using CEL, based on a
using the commercial CFD package, ANSYS-CFX 5 [13, 14]. The previous simulation with a full burner structure and finer meshes.
turbulent fluid flow with buoyancy force, heat transfer with Pressure boundary condition was set for the outlet, which is in
combustion and radiation, conjugated heat transfer between fluid high Z direction as shown in Figure 2.
and solid were simulated with this software.
Thermal boundary condition of the walls was defined as fixed
A user-developed sub-model for aluminum scrap melting was temperature. On one hand, in Z direction, the inner wall
developed based on a previous aluminum scrap melting model [4], temperature varies depending on the position of the flame.
heat transfer theory and experimental observations [12]. It was Normally the wall temperature in the middle of the furnace is
integrated with the CFD framework via CFX Expression higher. On the other hand, due to the effect of the furnace rotation
Language (CEL) and user FORTRAN interface [13] provided by and the cooling effect of the cold scrap, the temperature also
ANSYS-CFX 5. The melting sub-model provides melting varies according to the angular degree, i.e. temperature on the
information of scraps for the process model, e.g. heat sink due to downside wall is higher. The temperature on the wall also
phase change, amount of liquid and solid in scrap/salt zone, and increases with the increasing of combustion time during the
updated size distribution of aluminum scraps. At the same time, heating stage. According to these observations, for each point on
the CFD simulation provides flow and temperature information the wall, the temperature boundary condition was defined
for the sub-model, which is the key factor on the melting process. depending on its position and the combustion time, using a
position- and time-dependent function. The function was
Measurements and observations in industry were carried out to approximately defined based on the outside wall temperature
obtain the necessary information and data for the development of measurements in a secondary aluminum plant, the previous
the process model. A lot of first hand data, such as detailed heating simulations of the furnace and the estimation of cooling
furnace cycle information, mass and heat flows, property data of effect of the solid scrap.
participating materials, and temperature measurements, were
obtained. The data was reconciled and utilized to develop a mass Liquid flow after solid melting was not included in the model, and
and energy balance model [6], as well as the melting sub-model the liquid aluminum was assumed stagnant. Rotation of the
and the process model. Some of the data were used to define the furnace, with paddles mounted on the wall, was not fully included
boundary conditions of the process model and some of the data in the current model. Its effect on heating of the scraps is
were used to validate the model results. approached by defining a distributed wall temperature, as
discussed above. Its enhancement on heat transfer within the solid
Geometry and Boundary Conditions domain due to mixing of the scraps was estimated and represented
by applying an augmented thermal conductivity in the solid
scrap/salt zone, which is discussed in the following paragraphs.
Rotating
direction Model Parameters and Main Assumptions
Inlet
Combustion air zone In the scrap/salt zone, it was assumed that scrap and salt are well
Outlet mixed, and for each cell in the solid domain, the mixed material
has unique thermal properties, such as density, melting point,
Scrap/salt zone specific heat, latent heat and thermal conductivity. These
properties are defined based on the mass fraction and phase state
of scrap/salt in the mixture. While in the current model, the
Figure 2. Geometry and boundary conditions effective density was only calculated based on densities of solid
of the furnace process model scrap and salt, and it was assumed that it’s not changing during
the process, despite the effect of thermal expansion. For the
The melting process in a rotary furnace can be regarded as three melting point of the mixture, 660oC was used, which is the
sub-processes: heating of the scraps, melting of scraps and heating melting point of aluminum metal, despite the influence of alloys,
of the molten melts. In the present work, the focus is on the first salt and contaminations. For the effective thermal conductivity, it
two sub-processes: heating and melting of the aluminum scraps. is influenced by the voidage of the scrap/salt zone. On one hand,
Figure 2 shows the geometry and some of the boundary conditions heat transfer in this zone is not only the conductive heat transfer
of the furnace model, the lining and the off-gas settling chamber within the solids, but also convective heat transfer because of the
were not included in the current model. The furnace is 6.9 m in hot gas flowing through the voids. On the other hand, heat transfer
length and 3.0 m in diameter. In the upper part of the furnace, in this zone is influenced by the conductance degree among the
natural gas is combusted with oxygen, and in the lower part of the solids. Both factors are dependent on the voidage of the packed
furnace scrap is melted and refined under a top salt layer. In the solids, and they can be combined into a voidage coefficient to
early stage of the melting process, the scraps and salt are mixed represent the influence of convective heat transfer of the gas flow
with each other. In the current process model, the scrap/salt zone and conductance degree of the particles. In general the lower
was regarded as a conducting solid, a mixture of scrap and salt voidage in this zone, the more conductive heat transfer and the
solids. Phase change of scraps melting was handled by the melting less convective heat transfer will be. Rotation of the furnace will
also enhance the heat transfer within this zone, and its effect on profiles for the process model. Eddy dissipation model was
thermal conductivity is represented by a rotation coefficient. Thus, developed for use in a wide range of turbulent reacting flows
the effective thermal conductivity in the scrap/salt zone was covering premixed and diffusion flames, it has been widely
estimated by the following expression: applied in the prediction of industrial flames. This model is based
on the concept that chemical reaction is fast relative to the
λeff = Cvoid ⋅ C rot ⋅ λmix (1) transport processes in the flow. When reactants mix at the
molecular level, they instantaneously form products. The model
assumes that the reaction rate may be related directly to the time
Where λmix is thermal conductivity of the mixture, calculated required to mix reactants at the molecular level. In turbulent
based on the mass fraction and phase state of metal and salt, Crot is flows, this mixing time is dominated by the eddy properties, and
the rotation coefficient, which is greater than 1 and depending on therefore, the rate is proportional to a mixing time defined by the
the rotation speed and furnace dimensions, and Cvoid is the turbulent kinetic energy, k, and its dissipation rate, ε. This concept
combined voidage coefficient, which is influenced by furnace of reaction control is applicable in many industrial combustion
structure, furnace operation, gas flow and material properties etc. problems where reaction rates are fast compared to reactant
In the work of Wu et al. [2] for a circular aluminum scrap melting mixing rates.
furnace, a value of 5.0 was used for Cvoid, after tuning with their
modeling and experimental results. In the present work, these ε
values have not been tuned yet, and currently the rotation rate ∝ (3)
coefficient, Crot, was set as 1.3 and Cvoid was set as 5.0. Crot and k
Cvoid are also changing with the change of liquid/solid ratio in the
scrap/salt zone during the melting process, but it has not been Radiation Model Radiation has a large contribution of the heat
included in the current model settings. transfer to the scrap/salt zone and the furnace wall. The goal of
radiation modeling is to solve the radiation transport equation, to
Heat transfer in this zone is also influenced by gravity, convection obtain the source term S for the energy equation, and the radiative
flow of the liquids and amount of molten melts. For example, the heat flux at walls among others quantities of interest. Currently,
molten melts would fill up the void in the lower part of the P1 radiation model [13] is applied, which is a simplification of the
scrap/salt zone, and the liquid salt and metal would be separated Radiation Transport Equation, assuming that the radiation
due to the difference of density. This was not taken into account intensity is isotropic or direction independent at a given location
in the current model. Solidification process may also happen, but in space. The P1 model is valid for an optical thickness greater
it has not been simulated, and its effect could be taken into than 1, and in the present case, the optical thickness is estimated at
account in the future by adjusting the coefficients to the effective 1.8. Other radiation models, which are implemented in the new
thermal conductivity of the scrap/salt zone. version of ANSYS-CFX 5.6, such as Discrete Transfer Model,
Monte Carlo Model, have not been applied in the present model
CFD Framework of the Process Model and will be tested and utilized in the future simulations.
Governing Partial Differential Equations Turbulent fluid flow Buoyancy Model For buoyancy calculations where the density is a
with buoyancy force, heat transfer with combustion and radiation, function of pressure, temperature or additional variables, the full
conjugated heat transfer between fluid (combustion gases) and buoyancy model [13] is employed, which is implemented by
solid (scrap/salt) was simulated with the CFD package. The adding a source term to the momentum equations. The buoyancy
generalized form of the partial differential equations can be force source term is a function of the local density variation:
expressed by [13]:
S M = ( ρ g − ρ ref ) g (4)
∂
( ρφ ) + ∇ ⋅ ( ρ uφ ) = ∇ ⋅ ( Γ∇φ ) + S (2)
∂t Where SM is the momentum source term due to buoyancy force, ρg
is the density of the gas mixture, ρref is the reference density, and
Where φ is the general flow variable such as mass fractions, g is the gravity acceleration. It is evident that the buoyancy is very
velocity components, temperature, turbulent variables, etc., ρ is much temperature dependent due to the strong variation of the gas
the fluid density, u is the fluid velocity vector, Γ is the diffusivity, density with temperature (ideal gas law).
and S is the source term.
User Developed Sub-models When some part of the solid reaches
Turbulence Model The combustion gas flow in the upper part of the melting point of aluminum scrap, the melting sub-model starts
the furnace is a turbulent flow, at a velocity ranged from 0.0 m/s to calculate the melting rate based on the information provided by
to about 150.0 m/s. Natural gas combustion and heat transfer to the CFD simulations and the properties of the scraps and
the solid phase are highly dependent on the gas flow and its surrounded materials. The melting sub-model was simplified from
turbulent properties. In the process model, the widely used k-ε the previous work of modeling a single particle melting in molten
model was applied in the current simulations, where k is the melts [4]. For a multi-size particle system, the scrap is classified
turbulence kinetic energy, defined as the variance of the into several groups depending on the size of the scraps. It is
assumed that for each cell in the scrap/salt zone, it has the same
fluctuations in velocity, and ε is the turbulence eddy dissipation
initial size distribution. The sub-model handles each size group
rate, the rate at which the velocity fluctuations dissipate.
the same as a single solid particle, calculates the melting rate
based on the conditions in each cell in the scrap/salt zone.
Combustion Model Eddy dissipation model [13] was used in the
present process model and in the combustion model with a fully
structured burner model, which supplied the inlet boundary
Since the thermal conductivity of the aluminum metal is very balanced for such a simulation. In the current model, for a process
high, the temperature difference within the particle was ignored. lasting about 3 hours, it takes about 7 days of CPU time on a
Thus the heat transferred from the environment to the particle is workstation with a Pentium 4, 3.0 GHz CPU. Figure 4 shows the
totally used for melting of the solid metal. The heat balance at the temperature distribution in the upper combustion zone, at time t =
interface between the environment and the solid can be expressed 4800 s for Case A, when 79.3%wt of solid scrap/salt has been
as follows [4]: melted. Figure 5 shows the flow field in the combustion space.
The flow is shifted up a little and forms a circle close to the outlet,
ρ p ⋅ A ⋅ dR due to the buoyancy force and the furnace geometry.
⋅ ∆H = − h ⋅ A ⋅ (T f − Tmp ) (5)
dt Rotating
direction
Where ρp is the density of the particle, A is the surface area of the
particle, Tmp is the melting point of the solid, Tf is the environment Low
temperature, which is obtained from the CFD calculations, ∆H is High, middle
the latent heat of the solid melting, and h is the heat transfer and downside
coefficient around the particle, which is dependent on particle Low
size, fluid flow condition and fluid properties. Then the size
Low
change of the particle can be calculated by:
h ⋅ (T f − Tmp )
dR = − dt (6)
ρ p ⋅ ∆H
New particle size for each group in each cell and the total amount
of melted particle in each cell at the current time step can be
obtained. Heat sink for each cell due to phase change can be Figure 3. Temperature distribution on the
calculated and returned to the CFD framework as an energy wall of scrap/salt zone
source term, which influences the temperature distribution in the
scrap/salt zone and heat transfer from the combustion gas or
furnace wall to the scrap/salt zone.
0
0 5 10 15 20 25
Group num ber
y=-0.7 m
Figure 8. Changing history of weight percentage
of un-melted solid for each scrap group
100
y=-1.2 m Case A
x=0.0 m
Figure 9. Melting curve of the solids in scrap/salt zone
x=0.5 m
1273
x=0.8 m Tave_Air
1173
Tave_Outlet
1073 Tave_Wall (dotted line)
Figure 7. Temperature distribution (YZ plane) in
the scrap/salt zone at t = 4800 s
Temperature (K)
973
Tave_Scrap
For both Case A and Case B, Figure 8 shows the changing history
of un-melted solid for each scrap group, in weight percentage to 873
the total weight of scrap/salt zone, at time 0 s, 2400 s, 3600 s,
4800 s and 6000 s. Here it is assumed that for a scrap with a 773
certain initial size, it’s always in the same scrap group during the
process. Figure 9 shows the weight percentage of un-melted solid 673
against heating time. For both cases with different scrap size
distributions, the start time of the melting process is around 1400s 573
(noticeable around 1800s in Figure 9). For Case A with a larger
portion of smaller scraps, the melting process is about 200 s ahead 473
of Case B. The total melting time, including the heating stage, for
0 1800 3600 5400 7200 9000 10800
both cases is about 7200 seconds, and it’s only a little bit shorter
for Case A. Time (s)
A process model has developed based on a CFD framework, in 5. T. Li, et al., “Thermodynamic Analyses of Energy Utilization
which fluid flow, heat transfer, natural gas combustion, and and Pollutant Formation Control in Secondary Aluminum Melting
radiative heat transfer were simulated with a commercial CFD Furnaces”, (Paper presented at the Energy Efficient
code – ANSYS-CFX 5. The melting sub-model was modified Manufacturing, The MPMD Fourth Global Innovations
from a previous melting model for a single particle in molten Symposium, TMS, San Diego, CA, March 2003), 43-51.
melts. In the modified melting sub-model, the scrap was classified
into several groups depending on the size of scraps to represent 6. V. Salet, “Steady state mass and energy balance model of the
the distributed nature of the scrap feed. Melting rate for each rotary furnace: study to determine the burn-off rate of aluminum
group in each cell at each time step was calculated with the metal inside a rotary furnace”, (MSc Thesis, Delft University of
exchange of information between the melting sub-model and the Technology, February 2003).
CFD framework. Results of previous experimental study [12],
numerical modeling work [4], data measurements in industry and 7. T. Bourgeois, et al., “Mathematical Modeling of an
heat/mass balance calculations were used to develop the sub- Aluminum Casting Furnace Combustion Chamber”, Metallurgical
model and the process model. Transactions B, 20B, (June 1989), 421-429.
Under the structure of the process model, some simulation work 8. G. Riverin et al., “Impact of Good Metal Circulation and
has been carried out. Influence of the size distribution on melting Furnace Operation for Increased Performances for Sidewell
behavior was studied preliminarily. The process model still needs Furnace”, Light Metals, (1997), 731-736.
to be improved in the future. The ANSYS-CFX software package
is keeping updated and integrated with advanced models, which 9. S.L. Chang, C.Q. Zhou, and K. Scheeringa, “Numerical
should be tested and applied in the future work. In the current Evaluation of the Impacts of Burner Operations on the Thermal
melting sub-model, some parameters such as voidage, heat Efficiency of Industrial Furnaces”, (Paper presented at the Energy
transfer coefficient around the solid particle, voidage coefficient Efficient Manufacturing, The MPMD Fourth Global Innovations
Cvoid, rotation coefficient Crot, and wall temperature distribution Symposium, TMS, San Diego, CA, March 2003), 15-26.
functions, were only approximately estimated. More accurate
definition and estimation should be investigated and tuned to have 10. C.E. Baukal, Jr., V.Y. Gershtein, and X. Li, Computational
a better approach. Other sub-models such as the metal burn-off Fluid Dynamics in Industrial Combustion, (Lewis Publishers, Inc.,
model and salt evaporation model are being developed and will be October 2000).
integrated in the future.
11. R.T. Bui, “Computational Modelling of Thermophysical
After the development of the process model, parametric study will Processes in the Light Metals Industry”, Rev Gen Therm, 36,
be performed. Case studies and process optimizations will be (1997), 575-591.
conducted based on the process model. Improvements on
operation of the furnace, energy/salt consumption, and reduction 12. B. Zhou, Y. Yang, M.A. Reuter, “Study of Melting
of environmental impact can be expected. Behaviours of Aluminum Scraps in Molten Melts”, (Paper
presented at the TMS Fall 2002 Extraction and Processing
Acknowledgement Division Meeting on Recycling and Waste Treatment in Mineral
and Metal Processing: Technical and Economical Aspects, Lulea,
This work is part of the E.E.T. (Economy, Ecology and Sweden, June 2002), 527-537.
technology) project supported by the Dutch government
(http://www.batchcentre.tudelft.nl, http://www.EET.nl) for batch 13. ANSYS-CFX 5 manuals and documents, ANSYS Inc.
process optimization. The financial support from the E.E.T.
program is gratefully acknowledged. 14. ANSYS-CFX, http://www.ansys.com/cfx/.