Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Project Submitted to
By
March 2019
1
INDEX
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION 07
1.5 RESEARCH 10
METHODOLOGY
1.9 SAMPLING 12
METHODS AND SIZE
CHAPTER 2 CONCEPTUAL 13
2.1 FRAMEWORK
2.2 14
INDIAN WORK CULTURE
2.3 INDIAN WORK ETIQUETTES 15
2.9 34
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN INDIAN
WORK CULTURE AND WESTERN
WORK CULTURE
2.10 ADVANTAGES 40
2.11 DISADVANTAGES 41
BIBLIOGRAPHY 58
ANNEXURE 59
Certificate
This is to certify that Mr. Paradkar Ameya Vidyadhar has worked and duly
completed his Project Work for the degree of Bachelor of Management Studies
under the Faculty of Commerce in the subject of HUMAN RESOURCE
I further certify that the entire work has been done by the learner under my
guidance and that no part of it has been submitted previously for any Degree or
Diploma of any University.
It is his work and facts reported by his personal findings and investigations.
University Examiner
Declaration
Certified by
6
Acknowledgment
Lastly, I would like to thank each and every person who directly or
indirectly helped me in the completion of the project especially my
Parents and Peers who supported me throughout my project.
Chapter 1
Introduction
Work Culture is the set of collective beliefs, values, rules and behavior which
organization as whole conforms to. In a layman approach, it is a culture that a group
as an organization follows. Culture varies with family, region, social class and hence
in the work environment. However, there is a significant difference in the methods of
working in India and the western countries. The western part of the world is a cluster
of developed nations, and hence, a better standard of living and an upgraded lifestyle
is an obvious factor.
Working culture encircles with values and behaviors that contribute to the unique
social and psychological environment of a business. The working culture influences
the way people interact, work and be open to the superiors and co-workers.
According to the previous researches held, Positive workplace culture attracts talent,
drives engagement, impacts happiness and satisfaction, and affects performance. The
personality of your business is influenced by everything. Leadership, management,
workplace practices, policies, people, and more impact culture significantly.
It attracts talent. Job candidates evaluate your organization and its climate. A
strong, positive, clearly defined and well-communicated culture attracts talent
that fits.
Working culture impacts on how the employees interact with their work
and your organization. It drives engagement and retention
culture
Conceptual scope –
Organizational culture is known as the values, beliefs and basic assumptions,
and that explains how things are done around here. Organizational culture has
primarily been viewed as an internal phenomenon, having an impact on staff
behavior and attitudes, and ultimately influencing organizational performance.
Yet, it has more recently been conceptualized as a factor in shaping a
company's image in the marketplace.
Geographical scope-
As per the geographical scope, the work culture study’s questionnaire shall be
asked to the people whosoever would be having a sheer amount of experiences
of working in India and in any western country to understand the unbiased
impact and distinctions between the two working cultures.
The number of respondents is 20-30 at most.
The study of the working culture is using the hints of both conceptual and
geographical scopes.
Descriptive research
Every employer strives to create a good workplace for its employees. But
leaders are quickly realizing that a good work environment isn’t enough, it has
to be the best work environment for employees. So what makes the best work
environment? This latest research uncovers the answer.
The terms qualitative research and descriptive research are sometimes used
interchangeably. However, a distinction can be made between the two. One
fundamental characteristic of both types of research is that they involve
naturalistic data. That is, they attempt to study language learning and teaching
in their naturally occurring settings without any intervention or manipulation of
variables. Nonetheless, these two types of research may differ in terms of their
goal, the degree of control.
Primary data
There are several methods of collecting primary data, particularly
in descriptive research. In descriptive research, we obtain primary data either
through observation or through direct communication with respondents in one
form or another or through personal interviews.
Secondary data
There are several methods of collecting secondary data, particularly in
descriptive research. In descriptive research, we are not permitted to alter else’s
research, however ought to go through/analyze and find out the solution and
plausible answers. We shall also use business magazines, data from previous
researches, newspapers and search engines etc to make sure that we shall be
gathering an unbiased data.
In this research study, I am going for both primary and secondary data
The questionnaire is an instrument which is used to collect the data from those
who have worked in India and western countries, and are mindful about the
differences in their cultures.
Methods of sampling
The method of sampling for this research is “simple random sampling”. Simple
random sampling is the basic sampling technique where we select a group of
employees or people having the experiences of two different working cultures.
Each individual is chosen entirely by chance and each member of the group,
that has an equal chance of being included in the sample.
Sample size
20-30 people’s views shall be taken.
CHAPTER 2
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
The culture of India refers collectively to the thousands of distinct and unique cultures
of all religions and communities present in India. India's languages, religions, dance,
music, architecture, food, and customs differ from place to place within the country.
A flexible approach is important and it is often best to be guided by the person with
whom you are meeting. Etiquette requires a handshake, although some Indians may
use the Namaste, a common greeting involving pressing your palms together with
fingers pointing upwards, and accompanied by a slight bow. When entering a business
meeting, always greet the most senior person first. When exchanging business cards,
make sure to receive the card with your right hand and put it away respectfully. Small
talk at the beginning of a business meeting is common and could include questions
about your family. Equally, it is perfectly appropriate to ask after the family of
business partners, and in some instances, this may be a good way of building trust.
In General, Indians place importance on and prefer using formal titles. So if you are
meeting a doctor or a professor they may expect or appreciate being addressed by their
given title. The exception of this course is if they indicate otherwise. They use Mr or
Mrs when addressing a colleague or someone senior is preferred. Women in the
workplace are often addressed as Madam and men as Sir. The suffix Ji is commonly
used especially when addressing someone senior both in age and in rank.
The Indian Business Culture is an extension of the common culture of the society. It is
unique in its own way. However, in Indian business culture, the behavior, etiquette,
and approach of organizations and its professionals change according to the addressee
and the context of address.
Language
India is a multilingual country with each of its states having different official
languages. However, Hindi is the only officially recognized language in the
country. While talking on India business culture, English is the most preferred
language, which is followed religiously in every industry.
While greeting an individual, people use the appropriate formal title. One can
also add ‘Ji’ after the title to show respect for the person he/she is greeting.
Relationship Building
In India business culture, business development largely depends upon
relationship building. Indians tend to give a favorable deal to those whom they
know and trust. Hence, a good way to earn business is to earn the trust of the
customers first. You can earn the trust of people by demonstrating strong
business insight, showing honesty and respect.
Meetings
Any business meeting has to be arranged well in advance. These have to be
fixed in writing and confirmed by phone. It is better to avoid fixing meetings
on or near national holidays like Independence Day, Republic Day, Gandhi
Birthday or either of the two Eids. People often club their leaves to enjoy
extended holidays during this time.
Time
Indians value punctuality in others, but they often lag behind the schedule
themselves. A 10-minute late is acceptable in most of the cases. It can also be
seen that family responsibility getting preferences over the business, which
leads to the last-minute cancellation of meetings, though not quite often.
Process
If your business meeting involves negotiation, be prepared for a slow process.
In India business culture, the decision is taken at the highest level and may
take more time than one would have expected. You can’t get a favorable
decision unless you can establish the trust of the client. Until the trust is not
established, you should concentrate on building a rapport with the client. As
the decision is taken at the highest level, the absence of any higher-position
holder like Director or owner indicates that it is only the early stage of
negotiation.
Decision
Statistics, empirical data or commendable PowerPoint presentation cannot
solely influence the business decision. Indians tend to reckon the intuitions,
feelings, and faiths before they reach any decision. You must show your
patience and good character before any final verdict comes out. You cannot
afford to show frustration or anger.
Negotiation
One should refrain from putting high-pressure tactics while negotiation with
the clients. Do not confront or be forceful. If you are to disagree or criticize,
you need to do it in the most diplomatic language. Indians do not say "no"
directly, as it is often considered rude. If during the negotiation process, you
come to the terms like "We'll see", "possibly" or "We'll try", there is every
possibility that they are indicating a 'no'.
Business Attire
Business culture in India demands formal attire. Men usually wear formal shirts
and pants. Suits or Blazers are also quite worn, often during the winter. Women
wear sarees or suits. On the last working day of the week, people often wear
casuals. However, that has to be a decent one.
Building good business relationships and trust are important in India, so you
should expect to spend plenty of time at meetings, dinners and social clubs with
potential business partners. In a first meeting let the Indian host guide the initial
stages of the conversation. As in some other Asian cultures, Indians like to
develop a personal
connection.
Hierarchy- In India, they follow hierarchy with all their hearts. Starting
from our families, we believe in paying more respect to the one who is older to
us, and we follow the same pattern in our workplace. We also create a division
between designated people of our level and the people working below us. A
manager would usually not have lunch with employees under him or her. It is
not a very sociable environment professionally.
India has the largest democracy in the world. A country where a handful of politicians
control more-than-a-billion population. Business, just as other things in India, is
adversely affected or rather controlled by politics. And mind this, when I say politics,
I mean politics and not the government. Because in India, Politics is at the helm of it.
Corruption has made deep roots in our system, through almost every fabric of our
society and is inevitable now. And it greatly influences the way businesses to run in
our country.
The influx of politics has rendered oodles of upheavals and disruptions in not just
India but also its workplaces and business organization. For instance, if a person
desperately needs to get recruited to a good company, all he does is get a letter from a
politician and he instantly gets the job. In contrast, people who are skillful and talent
irrespective of those they don’t get what they deserve this. This discriminatory issue is
ascribed to the politics, in fact, that is a precursor issue that has lapsed the Indian
working system comprising promotion, recruitment, and selection. However, if you
look on the bright side then political interferences have also streamlined the
infrastructures.
Therefore, because of this people have skewed to dishonesty and disloyally rely upon
politics.
1. Cost of living- According to Ashwin Shetty from Quora, The problem with
such a view is neglecting the cost of living. The cost of living in California is
148% more than Bangalore.
80,000 USD is equivalents53, 68,436. That is 53 lakhs sixty-eight thousand. If you
compared it to India's, this is Rs 7, 00,000, (seven hundred thousand). For California's
cost of living, the same salary will be 148% (let’s assume), which is 10, 36,000, a total
of seventeen lakhs thirty six thousand, which is still less. So let’s count the facts.
5. The resources they are offered is nowhere near to the resources offered
in India. That explains the work done on their campuses is more important
to the company.
6. The high-valued billion dollar companies in India are less than in the
United States. Therefore, they can afford more people than us.
7. They have higher taxes.
2. Competition-
Due to the huge population and unemployment of skilled youths, in India, people
have graduate degrees but they don't have jobs. They find it difficult and, thus are
ready to work for a nominal or even low income. The mentality of Indian society
also plays a vital role in which, if you don't have a job (especially IT or govt.
sector) then you will be termed aimless and failure. This whole scenario results in
the offering of low salary as a company can get employee of the same skills with
low salary demand. This creates a huge profit for big companies and, thus the
Indian youth suffers.
3. Population-
The situation is only going to get worse as highly paid employees will be replaced by
somebody who's equally qualified and willing to work at a much lower salary.
This issue has been in India for a very long time and seemingly cannot be solved.
4. Unequal Rights-
The working women of our country encounter maximum problems at the workplace
but are also most likely to speak up about them, a recent study states.
The study, conducted among G20 countries, cites that work-life balance topped the list
of challenges Indian women faced in the working environment.
Apart from the aforementioned issue, more than 25% of women cited unequal career
opportunities as the chief issue in the workplace according to the poll conducted
by IPSOS MORI, a UK-based market research firm.
It was also mentioned in the study that though the gender pay disparity was the
highest in India, over 60% of women were pretty sure they earned the same as their
male counterparts doing a particular role.
A woman is said to be better at multi-tasking than a man, but balancing roles at the
workplace and at home flusters the working woman. This especially becomes more
challenging for the working mom. Indian women are expected to excel at domestic
jobs as they are traditionally considered women-centric. If they feel them self unable
to manage to strike a balance between work and home, they must consider speaking
with their supervisor about its role.
3. Sexual harassment
The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act of 2013 clearly indicates that
every establishment which has more than 10 employees need to comply with the act.
Shockingly, many women choose to ignore forms of sexual harassment as they may be
difficult to prove or result in secondary consequences. Collector records as much
evidence of harassment over a period or the women’s cell about it.
They have every right to inquire about the laws that support the woman in the
workplace.
5. Pay discrimination
A woman is often paid lower than her male counterparts for a similar job description
as it is still assumed that her primary focus lies in managing the household and not the
office. While the salary's topics are hardly brought up
Racism at the workplace
Most of the Indian people associate lighter color with beauty and darker color with
ugliness. The same goes for the people too. When they see somebody with the darker
skin color, they pass racist comments towards them. In some Indian organizations,
they discriminate people over their skin color, caste, religion etc. This has been
happening for a long time and there’s nothing they can do about it yet. There exist
organizations that wouldn’t recruit a candidate thereby his religion; culture and skin
color etc irrespective of his/her qualification, skills, and performance.
Racism in India is also visible amongst Indian communities. Due to a large regional
diversity, we find communities pitted up against each other ideologically, or for
resources. There have been many cases of North Indian discriminating against those
from the South, the mainland population isolating the North Eastern and a multitude
of regional clashes. In a scenario where the country is so fragmented within itself, a
foreigner seems even more alien, and a common enemy of all.
Introduction:
Western culture, sometimes is equated with Western civilization, Occidental culture,
the Western world, Western society, and European civilization, is a term used very
broadly to refer to a heritage of social norms, ethical values, traditional customs, belief
systems, political systems and specific artifacts and technologies that have some
origin or association with Europe. The term also applies beyond Europe to countries
and cultures whose histories are strongly connected to Europe by immigration,
colonization, or influence. For example, Western culture includes countries in the
United States and Australia, whose language and demographic ethnicity majorities are
European. The development of western culture has been strongly influenced
by Christianity.
Western work culture comprises of the United States, European, Canada, New
Zealand, and Australia work cultures. Notwithstanding, those working cultures are
also different from each other. However, in this study, I am focusing on to find the
differences between Indian and western work culture, therefore all western countries
work cultures have been clubbed together to streamline the study.
Western work culture has the flexibility, infrastructure and all kinds of resources that
would pander to the employee’s likings and hence they love working there. Western
world work culture also does not put any pressure on the employees. Their
expectations are to get their employees to finish their tasks within the given timeframe
and most of the employees are extremely professionally driven, that they live up to
their expectations and, thus their organizations end up spreading their wings across the
globe in spite of a very huge competition and this is why people prefer western brands
over eastern.
Western work culture is downright different than Eastern culture in many ways and we
will certainly pan over it in detail. As it’s mentioned above, western culture is mostly
from Europe. Europeans started running business firms and organization before
Eastern countries did.
Hence, it is but obvious that they are having more experience than in eastern
countries. It is hypothetically safe to say that Western work culture is a totally
different level. Most of the Western countries have well-reputed organizations in
which there are perfectly tailored infrastructures, thereby by this time subsequently
doing their researches they are mindful about their employee’s needs and wants which
is extremely imperative for any business organization.
In western work culture, people tend to be very professional and this exudes from
their communication, code of conduct, dressing code and grooming. They stick with
their professionalism and this sticks out to somebody who’s from a completely
different environment.
It is also said that time is a very important factor in western culture and everyone is
abided by that rigorously. If you are not finishing your tasks
Shakings hands firmly and meeting people eye to eye are important parts of
greeting colleagues and new business contacts. To not offer your hand can
be
seen as rude. Stand when you greet people or when they walk into the room.
It’s rarely polite to stay seated when others are standing. If someone offers you
a seat, take it, and if they are visiting you, be sure to indicate where they can
sit.
Certain topics are best avoided when you’re talking to people you don’t
know especially in a business environment. Religion, politics, and personal
information (such as health or relationship issues) shouldn’t be discussed.
Equally, doesn’t comment on anyone else’s appearance sometimes even
compliments can go awry.
On the Contrary, too many Asian countries, gift giving is not a part of U.S.
business etiquette. There’s no need to take anything with you to a
company’s headquarters or a meeting.
The use of first names without any titles is increasingly common in the U.S.
Still, it doesn’t hurt to start formally until prompted to do otherwise (and
remember, women often use the more neutral “Ms.,” rather than Miss or
Mrs.)
Men and women in the workplace are legally and socially equal, and the
U.S. has a long history of equality and civil rights movements. You should
always treat everyone in a meeting as equal, regardless of their gender, race,
sexual identification, or age.
While you might be in the habit of avoiding topics such as family and hobbies
in a business environment, you’ll find many meetings
start with small talk and family anecdotes. Family news and inoffensive
observations are pretty normal. In the same way, sports are a common topic, so
familiarize you with NYC’s major sports teams: The Knicks, Jets, Giants,
Yankees, Mets, and Rangers would be a good start.
Dressing code:
If you’re asked to wear “business clothes,” for work the expectation is that
you’ll be presentable and well dressed. For men, this generally means a suit
with a collared shirt, tie, and dress shoes. For women, this means a business
dress or suit, or a skirt and blouse, and nice shoes. Colors tend to be
conservative – black, gray, and navy blue. During meetings, take your cues
from others, but it’s normally perfectly fine to take off your jacket.
Wearing khakis with a shirt and jacket is considered casual dress, but is often
fine for meetings in NYC. For women, the casual dress would involve much
the same: trousers, button-down shirts, and nicer sweaters. It’s simpler to focus
on what you shouldn’t wear: no t-shirts, sweatshirts, jeans, baseball caps, short
skirts, or Capri pants.
It goes without saying that part of being dressed well for work is being clean
and presentable. Facial hair, as long as it’s trimmed and neat, is fine in NYC.
Tattoos should be hidden under clothing when possible. In the same way,
piercings should be kept to a minimum in more formal work environments such
as banking, insurance, and legal they wouldn’t recommend men having any
piercings or women having piercings beyond a set of earrings.
Many companies now allow for a relaxed wardrobe in the office but ask that
you dress smarter if meeting clients. In many offices, Fridays are “dress
down day” when jeans and relaxed clothes are common.
For the tech and startup the industry of New York, different rules apply
altogether. You can expect even the leadership team to come into the office in
jeans. But even here, the dress code needs to be adjusted when meeting with
clients coming from other industries. We always recommend inquiring about
the dress code before your first day of work.
The United Kingdom work culture:
The three main themes for CSR in the UK are workplace issues (work-life
balance, human rights, employment); community contribution (big
society/social justice) and the environment (sustainability of resources, etc.).
The UK has subscribed to the Millennium Goals of the United Nations and
many business leaders are actively working towards achieving these. The
UK Government supports CSR through tax breaks and the encouragement of
charitable giving.
Punctuality
In general, the British value time-keeping for business arrangements. If you set up a
meeting for two o’clock, the chances are your counterparts will arrive on time or just
before. Since the British are so time conscious, sometimes you may feel their lives are
very rushed. In fact, however, they are only doing their best to avoid losing time,
which is valued as an economic resource. It is considered very impolite to arrive late
for a business meeting. If your delay is inevitable and you arrive late, it is usually
sufficient to excuse yourself with an apology. If, however, you are running more than
a few minutes late, you should call ahead to apologize and give an indication of how
long you will be; in the case of a longer delay that would compromise the value of
attending the meeting, you should consider offering to postpone the meeting to a new
time and/or day. The busier people are, the greater the likelihood that they will have to
leave for another engagement, so respecting their time is very important.
Gift giving
Gift Giving is not a usual part of British business etiquette, although reciprocation is
good practice when gifts are received. Some organizations are encouraged not to
accept any form of gift and some are prevented from doing so on legal grounds.
However, where a gift is offered, it is important to ensure that it is not expensive
enough to be considered a bribe or so inexpensive as to be considered an insult.
When it comes to business dress codes, classical conservative attire is the norm for
both men and women in British culture and dark colors such as black, dark blue and
charcoal grey are predominant. It is common for women to wear either trousers or a
skirt in an office environment, and headscarves are accepted as part of religious
freedom. Many senior managers are fond of quality and express their status through
their choice of clothing. Shopping in designer boutiques is popular among British
society and bespoke suits, designer shirts, silk ties, and hand-made shoes are signs of
affluence and status.
A highly valued sense of fairness is probably the reason why the British are an honest
nation with relatively low levels of corruption. This has been confirmed in a recent
report (2012) by the Global Coalition against Corruption, Transparency International
and the United Kingdom has regularly ranked in the top 10% in the International
Corruption Perception Index, which compares countries from all over the world.
Australia work etiquettes:
Greetings
Australians are not very formal, so greetings are casual and relaxed a
handshake and a smile are appropriate.
However, while an Australian may say, ‘G’day’ or ‘G’day, mate’, this may
sound patronizing from a foreigner. Visitors should simply say the traditional
‘Hello’ or ‘Hello, how are you? ’As to titles of courtesy, they prefer to use
first names, even at the initial meeting.
Regarding the dress code, men should wear a dark colored, conservative
business suit.
In Brisbane or other tropical areas, depending on the job function and company
culture, men may wear shirts, ties and Bermuda shorts.
You can present your business card in the introduction. Keep its content to facts
and figures - emotions and feelings are not important.
Body Language
Men should wear darker color suits with a conservative tie. To maintain
formality, a white shirt would be worn.
Women should wear a suit, a dress, or skirt and blouse with a jacket. The
wardrobe should incorporate classic styles and colors (navy and grey).
Talking is minimal while you are eating a meal. The conversation will occur
before and after your meal. Dinners are reserved for social interactions only;
therefore business is discussed on these occasions. Lunch is used for
business conversations.
Boisterous behavior is always inappropriate, even when you are drinking. Pace
yourself to maintain the proper reserved and polite behavior.
When meeting someone, and when leaving, use a firm handshake with good
eye contact. Good eye contact means looking into the other person's eyes
when shaking hands, not looking down at your hand. The eye contact is
maintained during the handshake. You are not staring at the other person, but
showing genuine interest in meeting or seeing the person.
Men generally wait for a woman to be the first to extend their hand for a
handshake. Women do shake other women's hands. Use your same firm
handshake with good eye contact.
When you are meeting someone, say "How do you do?" A more relaxed
greeting, such as "Hello", is reserved for the meetings after you've had
the opportunity to get to know the person.
The people are reserved, but always very warm and polite when you meet
them.
Address a person using his/her title, or Mr., Mrs., Miss plus the full name.
Honesty is the best policy. Don't hype your product or service, and don't be a
braggart.
Avoid confusing or comparing New Zealand with Australia, as they are two
distinct countries. If you are not familiar with New Zealand, spend time before
your trip to learn about history and culture.
In India, we take a 1-hour lunch break where we go for long strolls on the
premises. We also take 15-20 minutes of tea/smoke breaks that are mini
gatherings between all employees in either inside or outside of the office
building. This is pretty time-consuming, we know, but it has an advantage too.
It refreshes everyone’s mood and lightens the environment.
India is now catching up with this factor. We believe in team building activities.
From taking employees to yearly trips to encouraging physical health by giving
fitness vouchers, offices are showering employees with incentives. It makes the
work environment relaxed and productive. It also leads to better mouth-to-
mouth publicity of your company and employee retainer-ship.
Hierarchy
Western countries do not follow authority as such. A person of younger age
could get hired for one of the highest positions based on his or her knowledge.
They might be younger than most employees, yet the environment will be
smooth. Employees at higher posts also do not show their superiority and
behave normally with everyone.
In India, we follow hierarchy with all our hearts. Starting from our families, we
believe in paying more respect to the one who is older to us, and we follow the
same pattern in our workplace. We also create a division between designated
people of our level and the people working below us. A manager would
usually not have lunch with employees under him or her. It is not a very
sociable environment professionally.
These were the major differences between the work culture in India and Western
Countries. All these cannot be certified as good or bad, the rules and regulations were
made as per the location and situation of an organization. Nor is this a debate to show
which workplace cultures are better or worse in comparison with one another. What
you need to do is see between the lines and accept the cultures that suit your company
the best.
Giving Instructions
Indian - Often suggest their ideas and directives with subtle inferences and non-
verbal clues that are commonly used within their country.
Asking Questions
Westerners - Underlings are expected to ask questions that are explicit and even
challenging of their superior’s instructions and purposes.
Indian-Understand that the emotional states of others are of great importance and
spend a lot of time seems to talk in circles about problems while working to find a
consensual solution that does not offend anyone.
Authority
Westerner’s managers - Often consider themselves part of the team but just
happen to be the ones in charge because of specialized skills and greater experience.
(Note: Management styles can vary tremendously among individuals.)
Meaning of YES
Indian- Often uses the word “YES” to acknowledge that they are listening to what
is being said. It does not necessarily mean an agreement has been made or something
will get done.
Reprimanding Staff
Indian managers - Rarely scold their staff or people associated with their
business in front of others.
Privacy
Westerners - Profess that information deemed confidential should remain so
under most circumstances.
Indian-Considers it rude and disrespectful if colleagues and friends have secrets that
are not shared with the group.
Accepting of Others
Westerners -Often become distressed and angry if commitments are not upheld.
2.9 Advantages
Publicly claim that worrying about one’s standing in the social pecking order is
akin to showing-off and is not important to them. That said, they seem to enjoy
when their own high status is displayed.
Think it is best to solve problems directly and quickly with as little emotional
fuss as possible even if it means disrupting the feelings of others.
Often consider themselves part of the team but just happen to be the ones
in charge because of specialized skills and greater experience. (Note:
Management styles can vary tremendously among individuals.)
2.10 Disadvantages
It’s no secret that Americans are overworked. Even though Americans are
working longer hours than ever and with fewer benefits and rights than ever,
the economy is still in the worst shape since the Great Depression.
In the West eating your lunch anywhere else than at your table can set you up
to look like a slacker who doesn't want to give "100%".
Stuffing our faces in front of our monitors will not help productivity. It is
doubtful people can even digest food properly when staring at their work.
The sad truth is that many Westerners discuss TV shows at the workplace, this
usually being the only conversation topic that they can all add to. Being
overworked leads to just going home and flopping down in front of the TV
and watching whatever everyone else watches. Talking about the lives of
fictional characters or reality show "stars" is perceived as better than getting
into personal issues and talking about our own lives.
Introduction:
A survey had been conducted on the comparative study of Western and Indian
work culture. 12 questions had been given in that questionnaire with two
options each. Respondents were supposed to choose any one option. I’ve
managed to get a total of 24 respondents, who successfully answered the survey
questionnaire and also mentioned their views on it.
This survey had also been conducted to seek out some unbiased information
from people on which culture do they prefer the most. The respondents gave
their honest views on what they feel and think about Indian and Western culture
from their practical and virtual experiences.
Interpretation- From the above diagrams and table, a survey had been
conducted, 11 questions were asked and 24 respondent responded on it.
The first question was, In reply, 47.80% of the respondents rooted for
Indian working culture, whereas 52.20% supported western working
culture. Respondents genuinely think, experienced that, western working
culture is better in celebrating an employee’s accomplishment and success.
Now, this gives motivation to the employees to step up and do even better.
Interpretation- Straight from the questionnaire, the second question had been
asked to the respondents, ” In reply, respondents voted 95.20% to Indian
working culture and 4.80% to the western working culture. According to some
previous and this research, most of the people from India are abhorrent and
despised by politics. However, sometimes politics could also turn out to be
good on rare occasions.
Nepotism
Indian Western
Healthy Balance
Indian Western
Statement 5- In which culture do you feel more respected by your team and the
organization?
Respect
Indian Western
Interpretation- On this question, 23 respondents have answered it. From 23
responses, 47.8% have voted to Indian working culture and 52.2% have voted
for western working culture. According to this and previous researches,
people those have/had worked in western countries, they felt or feel
westerners pay more respect than Indians do. However, unlike Indians,
westerners don’t hold back and bluntly air their comments out whether it’s bad
or good. Most of the Indians are also racists and call those who have a darker
skin tone by racist names very casually. If that happens in the western working
culture, they promptly take actions against that employee.
Statement 6- In which work culture Do You Feel like You Can Share
Your Honest Thoughts with Your Manager?
Freedom
Indian Western
Interpretation-The seventh question from the survey is, “On this question, 23
respondents have responded it, and from that 65.2 % voted to western working
culture and 34.8% voted to Indian working culture. Giving feedback to the
employees on time is one of the best leadership traits. This would help the
organizations to grow and spread its wings across the globe. Western working
culture is well-aware of that. However, Indian working culture must consider
that as their initial priority.
Recognition
Indian Western
Three more questions had also been asked regarding professionalism, code of conduct,
dress code and usage of the employee’s strength.
Strength usage 5 9
10
9
8
7
6
5 Indian
4 Western
3
2
1
0
In this survey, ratings had also been taken from the respondents.
Respondents were asked to rate Indian working culture and Western
working on the scale of 0-10, and 24 of them out of 24 have rated the
working cultures.
Does your company make most out of your strength? If yes, then
rate it on the scale of 0-10 (Indian and Western each)”
from their behavior, punctuality, and dedication towards the work. Some
recent research found out an amazing about Indian employees that, most
of them take the risk as in they don’t complete their projects on time and
stretch it to a very last minute. Now, this portrays an image of themselves
right across expatriates and foreign
clients who are absolutely punctual and complete their tasks within the
given time frame.
3. In this survey, ratings had also been taken from the respondents, they
had been asked to rate on the scale from 0-10 over Indian and Western
working cultures, “Professionalism, code of conduct, dress code and
usage of the employee's strength”. From the above table and graph, the
respondents voted to western working culture.
5. The dress code has never been an issue for neither Indian working
culture nor western working culture. However, still, the respondents
rated more to western working culture dress code thereby it accentuates
the professionalism. Every country is entitled to uphold its work culture
in some or the other way.
6. From the respondent’s ratings, they’ve voted more to the proper usage
of employee’s strength and talent. Prior to placing that employee in a
particular, he has to go through many interviews. Western working
culture has properly tailored infrastructures to harness and make the
most out of that employee. Most of the Indian working culture overlooks
and then only focus on how that particular employee is performing.
7. From the hindsight, Indian working culture has to come a long way.
Although they have one of the beautiful cultures in the world, ignoring
things such as 1) professionalism 2) Code of conduct 3) Employees
satisfaction put them behind the western working culture
8. Employees are a pivotal part of the company. They slog their guts out to
complete their task every day. Thinking to do something for them as in
rewarding them for their every accomplishment would boost up their
motivation level and they’d perform even better than they did.
9. Time management is quite fluid in India. They will work late hours into
the night, even on weekends, to meet the deadline. Americans or
Europeans would never do that. There they believe in a strict 8 to 5 pm
working day
11. It's hard to get Indians to call the boss by his first name.
Expats squirm when emails begin with the phrase "My respected sir."
Tom Albanese, CEO of Vedanta says "Indians can be too eager to
please sometimes. The only time I get flowers is when I am in India. I
find awkward garlanding moments all the time. “The bowing low and
garlanding are occasional and symbolic, but a practical day-to-day
problem is addressing the CEO by his first name.
12.When it comes to big issues, where the stakes are high, we would
rather let the boss decide. People avoid taking full responsibility for
anything because they don't want to take any blame if things go wrong.
Then if things do go wrong, they blame something else instead of taking
responsibility
Annexure
I. In which work culture, do you feel like Your Organization Celebrates
Its Accomplishments and Learning?
a. Indian b. Western
III. In which work culture do you feel like recognition is meaningful When
You Receive It?
a. Indian b. Western
IV. In which working culture, do you feel like Your Manager Cares about
Your Feedback?
a. Indian b. Western
V. In which work culture Do You Feel like You Can Share Your Honest
Thoughts with Your Manager?
a. Indian b. Western
VI. In which culture do you feel more respected by your team and the
organization?
a. Indian b. Western
VII. In which work culture Do You Feel That You Maintain a Healthy
Balance between Work and Your Personal Life?
a. Indian b. Western
VIII. In which work culture do you find the scope for nepotism?
a. India b. Western
IX. Rate western and Indian working culture on the scale of 0-10 on dress code.”
a. Indian (0-10) b. Western (0-10)
X. Does your company make most out of your strength? If yes, then rate it on the
scale of 0-10 (Indian and Western each).
a. Indian (0-10) b. Western (0-10)
XI. Rate western and Indian working culture on the scale of 0-10 on
professionalism, code of conduct.
a. Indian (0-10) b. Western (0-10)
XII. Which work culture would you prefer and recommend others over the other?
Mention why.
a. Indian(0-10) b. Western (0-10)