Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1111
Quality control and TLC profile data on selected plant species commonly
found in the Brazilian market
Renato Braz et al.
pharmacies in controlling the quality of their plant and Aroeira Anacardiaceae HUEM 12677 Bark
Schinus terebinthifolius
herbal drugs, so as to guarantee the chemical quality Raddi
of the extracts. Therefore, the present contribution Bardana Asteraceae RFA 35.777 Leaves
lists several plant species that are commonly used Arctium lappa L.
in phytotherapy, and provides data on their physical, Catuaba Meliaceae MBM 65 901 Bark
chemical, and chromatographic attributes, in order to Trichilia catigua A. Juss.
The plants were selected according to surveys Marcela Asteraceae HUEM 5270 Inflorescences
Achyrocline satureioides
carried out in compounding pharmacies in the city (Lam.) DC.
of Maringá, state of Paraná, Brazil, and are listed in Nó-de-cachorro Malpighiaceae HUFMT Roots
Table 1. The species were identified by Prof. Dr. Cassia Heteropterys aphrodisiaca 22.181
Mônica Sakuragui. Voucher specimens are deposited A. Juss.
in the herbarium of the Department of Biology of the Tansagem Plantaginaceae HUEM 8427 Leaves
Plantago major L.
State University of Maringá.
Uva-ursi Ericaceae Natural Leaves
Arctostaphylos uva-ursi Pharma, Lot:
Reagents, standard solutions and materials (L.) Spreng. 1611R/015
lamps; Fanen® 315SE hot air oven; Christ® Alpha 1-4 conducted in triplicate with three replicates.
LD lyophilizer; and Büchi® B-480 rotary evaporator. Chromatographic analysis
Table 2. Chemical standards, eluent systems and visualizing agents used in the TLC.
Plant drugs Standards Aliquots (μL) Eluent systems (v/v) Chromogenic agent
Aroeira 25.0
1. Toluene: ethyl acetate: methanol: formic acid (75:25:10:6) A. Ferric chloride 1% in methanol
Gallic acid 5.0
2. Ethyl acetate: toluene: formic acid: water (80:10:5:5) B. Vanillin perchloric + 105 ºC/5 min
Catechin 25.0
Bardana 25.0
3. Ethyl acetate: water: formic acid: acetic acid
Chlorogenic acid 15.0 C. NR + PEG 400 + UV 365 nm
(100:27:11:11)
Rutin 5.0
Catuaba 15.0
4. Chloroform: acetic acid: methanol: water (32:16:6:4) B. Vanillin perchloric + 105 ºC/5 min
Cinchonain Ib 5.0
Chá-verde 5.0
Epicatechin 10.0 2. Ethyl acetate: toluene: formic acid: water (80:10:5:5) B. Vanillin perchloric +105 ºC/5 min
Epicatechin-3-O-gallate 5.0
Guaco 15.0
D. Potassium hydroxide 10% + UV
o-Coumaric acid 5.0 5. Toluene: dichloromethane: acetone (45:25:30)
365 nm
Coumarin 5.0
Marapuama 10.0
6. Toluene: dichloromethane: acetone (45:30:25) E. Anisaldehyde + 105 ºC/5 min
Lupeol 10.0
Marcela 10.0
Caffeic acid 15.0 1. Toluene: ethyl acetate: methanol: formic acid (75:25:10:6) C. NR + PEG 400 + UV 365 nm
Quercetin 5.0
Nó-de-cachorro 10.0
7. Ethyl acetate: formic acid: water (90:5:5) A. Ferric chloride 1% in methanol
Isoastilbin 5.0
Tansagem 35.0
Caffeic acid 15.0 1. Toluene: ethyl acetate: methanol: formic acid (75:25:10:6) C. NR + PEG 400 + UV 365 nm
Chlorogenic acid 15.0
Uva-ursi 15.0
Gallic acid 5.0 1. Toluene: ethyl acetate: methanol: formic acid (75:25:10:6) A. Ferric chloride 1% in methanol
Hydroquinone 5.0
NR: diphenylboric acid 2-amino-ethyl ester; PEG 400: polyethylene glycol 400; UV 365 nm= UV light at 365 nm in the dark.
Table 3. Rf values of the standards used in TLC and their respective colors.
Standard Plant drugs Color Rf
Caffeic acid Marcela and Tansagem Blue 0.35
Chlorogenic acid Bardana and Tansagem Blue 0.58
Gallic acid Aroeira and Uva-ursi Brownish-blue 0.20
o-Coumaric acid Guaco Light blue 0.39
Catechin Aroeira Orange 0.81
Cinchonain Ib Catuaba Yellow 0.58
Coumarin Guaco Light blue 0.79
Epicatechin Chá-verde Red or orange 0.80
Epicatechin-3-O-gallate Chá-verde Red or orange 0.66
Table 4. Results of chromatographic analysis, extracts, standards, eluent systems, and chromogenic agents as listed in Tables 2 and
3.
(A) extract of 'aroeira' (A) extract of 'aroeira' (A) extract of 'bardana'
(B) catechin (Rf=0.81) (B) gallic acid (Rf=0.20) (B) chlorogenic acid
(Rf=0.58)
Eluent system: 2 Eluent system: 1 (C) rutin (Rf=0.67)
Chromogenic Agent: C
(A) extract of 'catuaba' (A) extract of 'chá verde' (A) coumarin (Rf=0.79)
(B) cinchonain Ib (B) epicatechin (Rf=0.80) (B) extract of 'guaco'
(Rf=0.58) (C) epicatechin-3-O- (C) o-coumaric acid
gallate (Rf=0.66) (Rf=0.39)
Eluent system: 4
Eluent system: 2 Eluent system: 5
Chromogenic Agent: B
Chromogenic Agent: B Chromogenic Agent: D
method to analyze plant drugs (Pittet & Royer, 2002; samples in spots, to improve the visual impression of
Głowniak et al., 2005; Zhang et al., 2008; Barbosa et al., the chromatogram. Another fundamental parameter in
2009), and has been used for a wide variety of applications. evaluating samples in TLC is the volume of the sample and
TLC is an important tool, not only for the quality control reference substances applied, which must be well defined
of medicinal plants, but also for the analysis of herbal and reproducible because the quality of separation depends
drugs (Durón et al., 2009). In several pharmacopoeias, on the size, shape, and homogeneity of the application
a great variety of plants are identified by use of TLC zones (Reich & Blatter, 2003).
methods (Farmacopeia Portuguesa, 2002; Farmacopeia In all cases, the criterion for acceptance of the
Espanhola, 2005; Farmacopeia Brasileira, 2010). TLC has TLC procedure was adequate detection of the specific
the advantages of low cost, ease of maintenance, and good marker, with respect to the color and relative position of
selectivity of detection. In addition, TLC can analyze several the band. The band of the specific marker should always be
parallel samples in a single run. It also facilitates repeated present in the chromatogram obtained from the samples.
detection (scanning) of the chromatogram with the same The physical and chemical tests carried out in this
or different parameters. Therefore, the simultaneous assay study, including loss on drying, content in extracts, and
of several components in a multicomponent formulation is total ash content, showed that the herbal drugs analyzed
possible. TLC was chosen because this separation system were within the technical specifications proposed by the
enables simultaneous evaluation of standards and samples, appropriate literature, when available. Data are shown in
thus matching the working conditions and environment Table 5.
for both, and reducing systematic errors (Kaiser, 2005). In conclusion, based on the results obtained,
The appearance of compounds in common and different we can suggest that the tests performed can aid in the
bands can be useful for identification and authentication quality control of the herbal drugs analyzed, contributing
of plant drugs. The TLC profiles of the plant drugs studied significantly to the quality-control protocol. These tests are
are shown in Table 4. also useful to indicate the existence of fraud, a common
All identifications in the TLC are based on occurrence in the medicinal-plants market, which may
comparison of the migration distances (Rf values), and of consist of adulteration or even falsification of raw plant
the color of the spots between the sample and a standard materials (Liang et al., 2004; Barbosa et al., 2009).
when the TLC plate is sprayed with a specific chromogenic However, it should also be borne in mind that TLC plates
reagent. The quality of the analysis depends on the correct from different manufacturers, with different thicknesses
positioning of the sample and on the reference substances and particle sizes, can also give variable results for a
used in the TLC. Accordingly, we opted to apply the particular assay method.
(Malpighiaceae). Rev Bras Farmacogn 17: 604-615. flavan-3-ols from Trichilia catigua and their in vitro
Mohammad A, Bhawani SA, Sharma S 2010. Analysis of antioxidative activity. J Braz Chem Soc, in press.
herbal products by thin-layer chromatography: a Sahoo N, Manchikanti P, Dey S 2010. Herbal drugs: standards
review. Int J Pharma Bio Sci 1: 1-50. and regulation. Fitoterapia 81: 462-471.
Müller L, Kasper P 1996. The mutagenic potential of arbutine, Schenkel EP, Gosmann G, Athayde ML 2003. Saponinas.
a naturally occurring hydroquinone glycoside. Mutat In: Simões CMO (org). Farmacognosia: da planta
Res 360: 291-292. ao medicamento. 5th ed. Florianópolis/Porto Alegre:
Osório AC, Martins JLS 2004. Determinação de cumarina em Editora da UFSC/ Editora da UFRGS, p. 711-740.
extrato fluido e tintura de guaco por espectrofotometria Silva AB, Silva T, Franco ES, Rabelo AS, Lima ER, Mota
derivada de primeira ordem. Rev Bras Ciênc Farm 40: RA, Câmara CAG, Pontes-Filho NT, Lima-Filho JV
482-486. 2010. Antibacterial activity, chemical composition,
Pereira AMS, Câmara FLA, Celeghini RMS, Vilegas JHY, and cytotoxicity of leaf's essential oil from Brazilian
Lanças FM, França SC 2000. Seasonal variation in pepper tree (Schinus terebinthifolius Raddi). Braz J
coumarin content of Mikania glomerata. J Herbs Microbiol 41: 158-163.
Spices Med Plants 7: 1-10. Veneziani RCS, Oliveira DCR 1999. Cosntituents of Mikania
Pittet A, Royer D 2002. Rapid, low cost thin-layer glomerata Sprengel. Biochem System Ecol 27: 99-
chromatographic screening method for the detection 102.
of ochratoxin A in green coffee at a control level of 10 WHO 2000. General guidelines for methodologies on research
μg/kg. J Agric Food Chem 50: 243-247. and evaluation of traditional medicines. p. 1
Pizzolatti MG, Venson AF, Smania Júnior A, Smania EDFA, Yang CS, Lambert JD 2003. Mechanisms of cancer prevention
Braz-Filho R 2002. Two epimeric flavalignans from by tea constituents. J Nutr 133: 3262S-3267S.
Trichilia catigua (Meliaceae) with antimicrobial Zhang JS, Guan J, Yang FQ, Liu HG, Cheng XJ, Li SP 2008.
activity. J Biosci 57: 483-488. Qualitative and quantitative analysis of four species
Polydoro M, De Souza KCB, Andrades ME, Da Silva EG, of Curcuma rhizomes using twice development thin
Bonatto F, Heydrich J, Dal-Pizzol F, Schapoval layer chromatography. J Pharm Biomed Anal 48:
EES, Bassani VL, Moreira JCF 2004. Antioxidant, 1024-1028.
a pro-oxidant and cytotoxic effects of Achyrocline
satureioides extracts. Life Sci 74: 2815-2826. *Correspondence
Poole CF 1999. Planar chromatography at the turn of the
century. J Chromatogr A 856: 399-427. João C. P. de Mello
Reich E, Blatter A 2003. HPTLC for the analysis of herbal Programa de Pós-graduação em Ciências Farmacêuticas,
drugs, herbal drug preparations and herbal medicinal Universidade Estadual de Maringá
products. In: Sherma J, Fried B, editors. Handbook Av. Colombo, 5790, 87020-900 Maringá-PR, Brazil
of Thin-Layer Chromatography 3rd ed., Chapter 18. mello@uem.br
New York: Dekker. Tel. + 55 44 3011 4816
Resende FO, Rodrigues-Filho E, Luftmann H, Petereit Fax: + 55 44 3011 5050
F, Mello JCP 2011. Phenylpropanoid substituted