Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Io Upane I 123: Approach To Central Nervous System Imaging
Io Upane I 123: Approach To Central Nervous System Imaging
Related terms:
Method
A protocol for I-123 ioflupane is presented in Box 15-6. One of the most difficult
things concerning I-123 ioflupane use is the ordering process as the U.S. Federal
Drug Administration (FDA) approval hinged on meeting Drug Enforcement Agency
(DEA) insistence that it be treated as a Schedule II controlled substance. Patient med-
ications should be reviewed for any drug that might interfere with the examination
(Box 15-7). Patient preparation consists of blocking thyroid uptake with potassium
iodide (400 mg) or Lugol solution (equivalent 100 mg iodide) at least 1 hour before
injection. The patient should be well hydrated and void frequently in the first 48
hours after the examination. After radiotracer injection a 3- to 6-hour delay is needed
before SPECT imaging.
1.02.4.2 Brain
Nuclear medicine brain imaging can use both planar and SPECT techniques. Com-
mon diagnostic procedures include cerebral blood flow (brain death), evaluation
of dementia, evaluation of vasospasm, suspected trauma, epilepsy, and cerebral
vascular disease (Mettler and Guiberteau, 2006). Examples of neuro-SPECT imaging
are shown in Figure 25. In this example, an imaging agent called DaTscan is used
to differentiate between Parkinsonian syndromes (PS) and essential tremor. The
‘comma’ image is for a patient without PS (upper panel), while the abnormal ‘period’
scan is for a patient with PS (lower panel). DaTscan is a radiopharmaceutical indicated
for striatal dopamine transporter visualization. The data were collected using 128
view angles and a high-resolution, low-energy collimator. Because neuroimaging
only utilizes a portion of the imaging area of the detector, a zoom factor is used to
improve image resolution (by reducing voxel size) and more efficiently utilizing
system memory. Just as in bone imaging, a key to achieving the best image spatial
resolution is to make sure the detectors are as close to the patient's head as possible.
Figure 25. DaTscans showing patient with Parkinson's disease (bottom panel) and
patient negative for Parkinson's disease (top panel).
Radiopharmaceuticals
In Nuclear Medicine (Fourth Edition), 2014
Single-Photon Radiopharmaceuticals other than Tc-99m
The disadvantages of I-131 include relatively high principal photon energy (364
keV), long half-life (8 days), and presence of beta particle emissions. However,
it is an important radiopharmaceutical for the treatment of hyperthyroidism and
differentiated thyroid cancer.
Whenever possible, I-123 is substituted for I-131 for diagnostic purposes. It has a
shorter half-life (13.2 hours) (Table 1-2), and its principal photon energy (159 keV) is
better suited to imaging with the gamma camera. It decays by electron capture, and
the dosimetry is favorable compared with that of I-131. Even in applications in which
imaging over a period of several days allows for improved target-to-background
ratio and thus making I-131 seem advantageous, I-123 is now increasingly replacing
I-131—for example, for whole-body thyroid cancer scans and MIBG imaging. I-123
ioflupane (DaTscan) has recently been approved to confirm or exclude the diagnosis
of Parkinson disease.
Indium-111
In-111 has proved useful for clinical nuclear medicine (Table 1-10). Its principal
photon energies of 172 and 245 keV are favorable, and their abundance is high
(>90%). The 2.8-day half-life permits multiple-day sequential imaging. Examples of
radiopharmaceuticals include In-111 oxine leukocytes for detection of inflammation
and infection and the somatostatin receptor–binding peptide In-111 pentetreotide
(OctreoScan) to detect neuroendocrine tumors.
Thallium-201
Tl-201 became available in the mid-1970s for myocardial scintigraphy. It behaves
as a potassium analog, with high net clearance (~85%) in its passage through the
myocardial capillary bed, which makes it an excellent marker of regional blood flow
to viable myocardium.
Krypton-81m has advantages because of its high principal gamma emission (190
keV) and short half-life (13 seconds), allowing for postperfusion imaging and multi-
ple-view acquisition without concern for retained activity or radiation dose. However,
the rubidium-81/kr-81m generator system is expensive and must be replaced daily
because of its short half-life.
Movement Disorders
Parkinsonian symptoms are associated with a number of neurodegenerative disor-
ders, such as Parkinson's disease, multiple system atrophy and progressive supranu-
clear palsy. These disorders are frequently associated with abnormalities in a number
of neurophysiological processes. In particular, pathological evidence has shown that
these disorders are associated with a loss of neurons, particularly in the nigrostriatal
dopaminergic pathway.
SPECT and PET have become important tools in the differential diagnosis of these
diseases, and may have sufficient sensitivity to detect neuronal changes before
the onset of clinical symptoms. Imaging is now being utilized to elucidate the
genetic contribution to Parkinson's disease, and in longitudinal studies to assess the
efficacy and mode of action of therapeutic interventions such as neuroprotective
drugs and surgery.
SPECT scans using the approved tracer, 123I ioflupane (DaTscan) are now widely used
to help diagnose patients with parkinsonian syndromes which are associated with
decreased presynaptic dopamine transporter binding. As the course of the disease
moves from posterior to anterior, the scans show a progressive loss as well. Thus,
SPECT studies have indicated a consistent pattern of dopaminergic neuronal loss
in PD, usually with a more pronounced decrease in the putamen rather than in the
caudate (Fig. 10). In addition, there is often a marked asymmetry of uptake in the
striatum, particularly in the early stages of the disease. This asymmetry usually has
a good correlation with symptom severity and illness duration. Most importantly,
SPECT imaging studies may be sensitive enough to detect very early PD, perhaps
even before clinical symptoms become apparent. Several large scale clinical trials
of treatment interventions for Parkinson's have utilized the 123I ioflupane tracer
with mixed success. However, the tracer has proved to be powerful techniques
for quantifying the loss of dopaminergic neurons in normal aging, PD, and other
neurodegenerative disorders.
Although most of the SPECT studies have shown highly significant differences
between groups of Parkinson's patients and age-matched normal controls, the
statistically significant differential diagnosis of an individual subject is more
problematic. Patients with severe PD are easily separated from healthy controls even
from a simple visual inspection of striatal images, which can be quantified using
some form of discriminant analysis, which has a sensitivity and specificity from 90%
to 100% in the proper clinical setting. However, patients presenting much earlier in
the course of the disease are more difficult to detect since there can be a substantial
overlap with an age-matched control group and consequently, a loss of diagnostic
accuracy. The situation may be further complicated if the early differential diagnosis
between several different movement disorders is required. Many of the symptoms
associated with parkinsonian disorders are non-specific, which is why the accurate
clinical diagnosis of these diseases is difficult. Indeed, some histopathalogical
studies have shown that as many as 25% of all patients who were diagnosed with
PD before death had been misdiagnosed. Studies measuring dopamine transporter
activity have had more difficulty in separating PD from MSA or PSP. Essential
tremor (ET) is another possible diagnostic consideration when evaluating a patient
for PD. Essential tremor may be easier to distinguish from PD since the former does
not typically involve the dopaminergic pathways to the same degree.
Volume 3
Yong Du, Habib Zaidi, in Encyclopedia of Biomedical Engineering, 2019
diagnosing PD, compared with on-site clinical diagnosis, which had a sensitivity
of 93% but a specificity of only 46%. The DAT SPECT can also be used to assess
atypical Parkinsonian syndromes and to differentiate dementia with Lewy bodies
from Alzheimer’s disease.
Fig. 9. DAT SPECT of two patients with PD. The patient on the left had mild
symptoms, and the images showed a slightly reduced uptake in the left striatum.
The patient on the right had more severe symptoms, and the images showed
significantly reduced uptake in the right striatum. Please note in the images, right
side of a patient is located to the left.
Quantitative analysis of DAT SPECT images has been shown to be a more objective
tool for detecting subtle changes in DAT binding in striatal subregions. It allows
accurate staging of the patient based on age- and gender-specific normal reference
values. The commonly used quantitative method is the reference region-based semi-
quantitative approach that measures the striatal specific binding potential (SBP, also
called SBR, striatal binding ratio), computed using activity concentrations measured
in the striatum and in a nonspecific binding reference region as [Striatum − Refer-
ence]/Reference. The left-to-right ratio and the caudate-to-putamen ratio are other
frequently used quantities. These quantitative measures can also be used to track
the disease progression and to monitor the effects of treatment. For example,
reference region-based measures of striatal dopamine deficiency are correlated with
bradykinesia and rigidity, the most characteristic clinical feature of PD. There is also
evidence that the DAT binding loss in PD follows an exponential curve. Fitting the
DAT binding potential to the curve could help score the patient more accurately,
potentially leading to better patient management.
There are also many other brain SPECT neurotransmission agents developed for
imaging various nervous systems (Acton and Mozley, 2000). Examples include but
not limited to 123I-IBZM (Iodobenzamide) for imaging postsynaptic dopamine re-
ceptors; 123I-5-I-A for imaging the nicotinic cholinergic receptors; and 123I-IOM for
imaging the benzodiazepine receptors, etc.
Familial PD
Considerable heterogeneity in olfactory function occurs in inherited forms of PD,
although in many cases the olfactory dysfunction cannot be distinguished from
that of classic PD. Even though PD-related genes are relatively rare in the general
population, there are clear exceptions. The primary olfactory findings from studies
of various familial forms of PD are presented in Table 20.1 from Hawkes and Doty
(2018).
Table 20.1. Currently proposed genic forms of parkinsonism with some associated
pathologic features and olfactory deficits where known
Modified from Hawkes, C.H., Doty, R.L. 2018. Smell and taste disorders. Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge.
To identify possible familial PD, some investigators have administered olfactory tests
and other PD-related measures to first degree relatives of PD patients. Lower UPSIT
scores have been found in sons and daughters, in particular, where the affected
parent was the father (Montgomery Jr. et al., 1999, 2000). One study evaluated
olfaction and dopamine striatal transporter activity (DATScan) in 78 asymptomatic
first-degree relatives of nonfamilial PD patients (Ponsen et al., 2004). Forty were
hyposmia patients at baseline. 2 years later, four had abnormal DATScans and
displayed clinical evidence of PD. In the remaining 36 individuals with hyposmia
who displayed no sign of PD, the rate of decline of dopamine transporter binding
was higher than in normosmic relatives.
UPSIT scores typical of classic PD were found in five PARK 8 patients with the G2019S
mutation from London (Silveira-Moriyama et al., 2008) and 16 PARK 8 patients with
this mutation from Lisbon (Ferreira et al., 2007). Unaffected relatives at 50% risk of
PARK 8 were not similarly impacted. In another preliminary study from Brazil that
used SS, impaired olfaction was found in 22 LRRK2 patients carrying the G2019S
mutation, but it was less severe than those with classic PD (Silveira-Moriyama et al.,
2010b). In a German study, seven PARK 8 patients, three of whom were symptomatic
and four of whom were nonsymptomatic, exhibited low UPSIT scores relative to
controls (Kertelge et al., 2010). Less clear-cut results were documented in a large
French pedigree that carried the G2019S mutation (Lohmann et al., 2009).
A US-based investigation that used UPSIT in a study of 126 G2019S mutation carriers
found no significant olfactory dysfunction in nonmanifesting carriers, suggesting
to the authors that microsmia is not predictive of LRRK2-related parkinsonism
(Saunders-Pullman et al., 2014). Another group from Spain assessed UPSIT scores in
(a) 29 subjects with parkinsonism due to the G2019S mutation, (b) 49 asymptomatic
mutation carriers, (c) 47 noncarrier relatives, (d) 50 subjects with idiopathic PD and
(e) 50 community-based controls (Sierra et al., 2013). In the G2019S manifesting
carrier group, 50% were hyposmia patients compared to 82% in the IPD group,
and there was no significant difference between these two. Hyposmia was less
frequent in the asymptomatic carrier group (26%) and asymptomatic noncarriers
(28%), suggesting that olfactory dysfunction is not found in asymptomatic carriers
of the G2019S mutation. Normal B-SIT scores were found in a Norwegian study
of 47 nonsymptomatic family members of LRRK2 PD patients, of whom 32 were
positive and 15 negative for either the G2019S or the N1437H mutation (Johansen
et al., 2011).
Available presynaptic ligands for SPECT bind selectively the dopamine transporter
(DAT). The DAT is a 620-amino acid protein with 12 -helical hydrophobic trans-
membrane domains, two to four extracellular glycosylation sites, and up to five
intracellular phosporylation sites. Ex vivo studies have shown the expression of DAT
in the dopaminergic neurons of the substantia nigra and in the ventral tegemental
dopaminergic neurons. DAT controls dopaminergic neurotransmission by spatial
and temporal buffering, making the molecule an imaging target for diseases af-
fecting the dopaminergic nigrostriatal pathway. DAT levels correlate with striatal
dopamine concentration.
Introduction of radioactive iodine (123I) into the tracer molecules provides a suitable
method for DAT-SPECT imaging. A large number of 123I-labeled compounds have
been prepared, and DAT receptor-specific imaging agents are routinely used for
SPECT imaging studies. All of the successful agents for imaging DAT belong to a
group of tropane derivatives that share a similar backbone structure of cocaine. The
first successful DAT imaging agent for SPECT, [123I] -CIT, was reported in the early
1990s, and studies suggested a strong correlation between the decrease in local-
ization in the putamen area and PD symptoms. Currently, [123I] -CIT, [123I]FP-CIT,
[123I]IPT, and [123I]altropane are being developed for this purpose.
The two most widely used ligands to study PD patients are [123I] -CIT and [123-
I]FP-CIT. A direct comparison of the two compounds has been attempted in only
a few studies; briefly: (1) the nonspecific uptake of [123I]FP-CIT is greater than [123I]-
-CIT, causing [123I] -CIT to have a lower ratio of specific to non-displaceable striatal
uptake (V 3); (2) [123I] -CIT shows a lower selectivity for DAT, having an equivalent
affinity for the serotonin transporter (SERT), which results in a higher thalamic/mid-
brain [123I] -CIT uptake; (3) washout period of [123I] -CIT is about 1% per hour and
of [123I]FP-CIT is 5–8% per hour, making striatal V 3 values of [123I]FP-CIT stable as
early as 3–6 h, whereas [123I] -CIT stabilizes only after 18–27 h. In Europe [123I]FP-CIT
(DatScan, Amersham PLC, Buckinghampshire, UK) is commercially available for
routine clinical use.
One of the major drawbacks of using 123I-labeled compounds for routine imaging
is the availability of the isotope. Produced by cyclotrons or by accelerators, it is
not readily available in standard nuclear medicine clinics and requires overnight
shipment from production sites. As a consequence, it is relatively expensive and
inaccessible. As an alternative, 99mTc-labeled tropane derivatives have been inves-
tigated. Only [99mTc] TRODAT-1 has been tested successfully in normal subjects
and parkinsonian patients. This compound has some logistical advantages over the
most commonly used SPECT 123I-ligands, including absence of thyroid uptake, ready
availability, ease of use, and lower cost.
Clinical application
Diagnosis of PD
The effectiveness to demonstrate changes in presynaptic DAT sites in vivo in PD
patients has been demonstrated by using [123I] -CIT, [123I]FP-CIT, [123I]IPT, [123I]al-
tropane, and [99mTc]TRODAT-1.
At the point when cardinal motor signs required for a clinical diagnosis of PD appear,
as many as 58–64% of dopaminergic neurons in the substantia nigra (SN) have been
lost, and striatal dopamine content has been reduced by 60–80%. Imaging studies
of the dopaminergic system and postmortem cell counts of pigmented neurons in
the SN suggest that the onset of dopaminergic neuronal loss precedes the clinical
diagnosis of PD by approximately 4–6 years. Abnormalities have been shown in
individuals at risk for the disease years before disease onset.
In some large clinical drug trials of PD where patients were enrolled based on their
clinical diagnosis of early ‘untreated’ PD, a significant proportion of patients has
normal scans. These individuals have been defined ‘subjects with scans without
evidence of dopaminergic deficit’ (SWEDD) and represented from 5.7% to 14.7% of
cases clinically diagnosed as early PD. Uptake values measured by fluorodopa PET
(REAL-PET study) and by [123I] -CIT (ELLEDOPA study) remained normal after 2-
and 4-year follow up respectively, thus questioning the diagnosis of a progressive
and neurodegenerative disorder as PD in these subjects. Alternative explanations on
false-negative PD at DAT SPECT are the theoretical possibility of scans in the normal
range at a very early stages of the disease and greater specificity of quantitative versus
qualitative analysis of the SPECT scans.
Differential diagnosis
Essential tremor
Atypical parkinsonism
Vascular parkinsonism
Drug-induced parkinsonism
Disease progression in PD was originally evaluated with [123I] -CIT/SPECT. The mean
reduction of [123I] -CIT binding in PD patients versus healthy controls was reported
of 5.8% for a period of 15 months and, when calculated for 1 year, 5.6%. Further
studies with [123I] -CIT showed similar results with an annual rate of progression
ranging between 5% and 8%, although one report documented a higher rate
of 11.2% per year. One study with a 2 years follow up reported striatal [123I]IPT
binding decreases of 6.6% in the first year and 5.3% in the second year. Similarly,
[123I]FP-CIT/SPECT showed a mean annual decrease in striatal binding ratios of about
8% (of the baseline mean) (Figure 2).