Professional Documents
Culture Documents
- Dying of Thirst -
Graham Bates
Email: icebergs@internode.on.net
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Version 11
P O Box 1254
Version 1 submitted to Mr Greg Strada, Consultant Engineer and The Hon. David Hawker
MP, Federal Member for Wannon on 13th December 2006
Version 2 presented to Alcoa – Portland Aluminium on 20th December 2006 and The Hon.
Malcolm Turnbull MP, Federal Minister for the Environment
Version 8 presented to David Hawker MP, Federal Member for Wannon on 25th January,
2007.
Version 8 presented to Mr. Anthony Albanese, Federal Shadow Minister for Water
Infrastructure on 25th January, 2007.
Version 9 presented to the Dr. Denis Napthine, State Member for South West Coast, on 7th
February, 2007.
Version 10 presented to Debbie Cuthbertson, Chief of Staff, The Age Newspaper on 12th
April, 2007.
Version 11 presented to Kevin Rudd MP and Peter Garrett MP, Federal ALP on 7th April,
2007.
Version 11 presented to Stephen Martin, Reporter from the ABC Office, Ballarat on 18th
April, 2007.
Version 11 presented to Linda Christian at the Office of Catherine King MP, Federal ALP
Ballarat on 18th April, 2007.
Version 11 presented to Mr Peter Hyett – The Bendigo Advertiser 23rd April, 2007
Version 11 presented for the 3rd time to The Hon. Malcolm Turnbull MP, Federal Minister
for the Water on 23rd April, 2007
Version 11 presented to Glenelg Shire Council on 24th April, 2007 & The Portland
Observer Newspaper
2
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
3
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Water Basics
What's a Megalitre?
One Megalitre is about equal to the volume of 1 Olympic sized swimming pool. 1
1
DPI Victoria Website: http://www.dpi.vic.gov.au/dpi/vro/vrosite.nsf/pages/pavs
4
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Executive Summary
This report is a concept plan to counter the imminent drought crisis facing our ‘Clever
Country’ – Australia.
This plan hinges upon a heat recycling process used in conjunction with construction
and development of water infrastructure as follows;
4. Ensure that a proportion of this water flows into the Murray River
enabling both environmental flows and extraction downriver for the
Adelaide water supply.
2
See Fact File (pdf file) on Dubai Aluminium – Smelter and Desalination Plant Cogeneration Project –
website : http://www.dubal.ae/mediacentre/news.aspx
5
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Introduction
Whilst there has been much debate about whether Climate Change is a fact or a myth,
the reality is that Australia has experienced a continuing series of very low rainfall
events.
In the summer (December) 2006 we faced a significant crop yield failure. Over this
harvest season, wheat exports are predicted to be the lowest in years.
“Matt OʹRourke walks across the dam that is Goulburnʹs major water
source and does not even get his feet wet. He is not God, but perhaps
another type of miracle is occurring. ʺItʹs raining,ʺ he says. ʺThis is not a
drought story after all.ʺ
But it is. The ultra‐light shower barely touches the ground. What does
make it disappears in the deep cracks ‐ just five years ago, this was the
bottom of a 10‐metre‐deep, 9000‐megalitre dam.
The people of Goulburn, one hour north‐east of Canberra, need a lot more
rain than this.
Today their dam is just 8 per cent full. If the drought continues, the dam
will be empty in eight months.”
3
The Age website: http://www.theage.com.au/news/Drought/Goulburn-could-run-dry-in-eight-
months/2005/05/19/1116361673744.html
6
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
On the 21st April, 2006, the ABC highlights Goulburn’s worsening situation. 4
“For the past few years the people of Goulburn in New South Wales have
been watching the water levels in their city dam drop lower and lower.
And this week, courtesy of the drought, the almost unthinkable happened
the dam has been declared officially empty.”
It appears that little has been done to alleviate the situation in Goulburn. In fact,
Goulburn has been on Level 5 water restrictions since 2004.
If this is any indicator of what drought can do to other inland cities and rural
communities, then we all need to quickly find some remedy for this dire situation.
We require a massive effort similar in scale to that of the Snowy Mountains Hydro-
Electric Scheme to provide a long-term drought-resistance plan for the nation.
This report aims to provide input into where some of this effort should be directed.
It provides a strategic plan to deal with the drought in the Southwestern and Western
parts of Victoria, extending north to the Murray Basin, a distance of approximately
600 kms.
4
ABC 2 – Story on drought in Goulburn NSW website:
http://www.abc.net.au/tv/australiawide/stories/s1620882.htm
7
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Current Situation
It is evident that many high population areas along the Eastern and Western Seaboard
are receiving significantly less rainfall over the past 50 years – population and water
demand is upwards – but the rainfall trend is downwards.
Less rainfall will see a reduction in the harvests from ‘Australia’s Food Bowl’ grains
and sheep/cattle growing areas.
8
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
The rainfall pattern during the 2002 – 03 drought is clearly illustrated as per the map
below.
This drought had very serious consequences for the nation. Treasury compiled a full
Report on the Economic effects of this drought, as per this web reference.5
The record high prices for cattle and sheep in 2004 – 05 have recently slumped, and
reports from South Australia suggest collapse. 6
“Prices for sheep and cattle have crashed in South Australia after massive
stock sell‐offs last week.
Across many regions a lack of rain has seen pastures dry up forcing
producers to sell off livestock early in the season.
More than 100,000 sheep, lambs and cattle went through the saleyards last
week, forcing prices down.”
5
Dept of Treasury Report Website.
http://www.treasury.gov.au/documents/817/HTML/docshell.asp?URL=03_article_2.asp
6 th
ABC Rural Website – 25 SEPT, 2006 http://www.abc.net.au/rural/news/content/2006/s1747976.htm
9
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Victorian and NSW prices are already following this trend as reported in the Infarmation
- Agribusiness website.7
At a lamb sale in Hamilton in Nov-Dec 2006, lambs that would have sold for $90 per
head last year are now selling for $9.
These prices are crashing now because farmers will be unable to feed and water their
stock over the summer period.
Many farmers along the lower southern fodder producing areas in Victoria (extending
West from Geelong to Hamilton/Portland) harvested and baled their hay and fodder
in October 2006, because of the unusually dry conditions.
There have already been a number of farmer suicides in the Murray area, with Beyond
Blue reporting the death of “1 farmer every 4 days.” 8
7
Infarmation Website http://www.infarmation.com.au/common/pdf/MLA_20061016.pdf
8
ABC News Online Website: http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200610/s1764557.htm
10
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Region of Interest
The Region of Interest (ROI) of this report encompasses the Southwest, Western and
the Lower Murray Basin in Victoria. The area extends from the Southern Victorian
coastline around Portland, northwards to the Murray River in the Mildura/Swan Hill
region.
Much of this area, including the Mallee and Wimmera districts are under a continuing
cycle of serious drought. The Victorian Dept of Primary Industries – Storage Level
Report at 31st of August, 2006, reflects a truly gloomy picture of this region that has
little in the way of major rivers and streams.
“Volumes in the major storages throughout the State reduced by 1.4% in
August 2006 (compared with an increase of 8.2 % in August 2005). (see map
and table)
At the end of the month, Victoriaʹs share of the volume in major storages
throughout the State was at 32.9% of capacity, compared with 46.1% at the
same time last year.
Storages in the Glenelg/Wimmera Basin are at 6.8% of capacity compared
with 9% at the same time last year.
Lake Eppalock is at 4% of capacity (compared with 7.8 % at the same time
last year).
Lake Eildon is at 22.6% of capacity (compared with 37.6% last year), while
Rosslynne Reservoir is at 6.9% of capacity (compared with 14.0% last
year).”
Ballarat, Bendigo, Hamilton, Dunkeld and other Western District communities are on
Level 4 restrictions as at early December.
9
Victorian Resources Online Website: http://www.dse.vic.gov.au/dpi/vro/vrosite.nsf/pages/water-streports-
storage
11
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Map Reference:
http://www.dse.vic.gov.au/DSE/wcmn202.nsf/LinkView/F0767547F8F075A8CA257211002D5233B4D07B20BF
8AB51ACA2572100009B86F
12
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Groundwater Reserves
As the surface water storage areas in the previous map show a critical shortfall of
water reserves, the groundwater or aquifer reserves show a different picture.
13
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
The highest Permissible Annual Volume (PAV) for extraction rates (megalitres) for
groundwater resources10 in Victoria are as follows;
The Portland, Heywood and Lake Mundi groundwater resources are within the
Glenelg & Wimmera areas of Victoria.
The current drawdown from the Portland resource is about 25% of the PAV.
The Glenelg Shire and parts of the Wimmera Shire are one of the only areas in
Victoria that has an over-abundance of water, albeit from groundwater resources,
however, with only 6.8% of available surface storage capacities filled, there is already a
significant deficit in groundwater recharge capacity.
“The Green Triangle Plantation Region is comprised of seventeen local
government areas throughout south‐west Victoria and south‐east South
Australia.
It is also the largest wood fibre producing region in Australia (GTRPC)
(b)”.
This project will only succeed if groundwater reserves are replaced with sterile
desalination water, otherwise groundwater reserves will be seriously depleted without
recharge.
10
DPI Victoria Website: http://www.dpi.vic.gov.au/dpi/vro/vrosite.nsf/pages/pavs
11
Greater Green Triangle Area Website: http://www.nre.vic.gov.au/dpi/vro/vrosite.nsf/pages/private-regional-
great
14
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
The map below shows both the area and the rainfall data, for normal years.
Reference: http://www.nre.vic.gov.au/dpi/vro/maps.nsf/pages/Victoria-private-regional-ggt-rain?Opendocument
These additional pipelines can also be networked into the Wimmera-Mallee pipeline
network.
15
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
“I love a sunburnt country, A land of sweeping plains,
Of ragged mountain ranges, Of droughts and flooding rains.” 12
Dorothea Mackellar
We no longer experience the same weather patterns that Dorethea Mackellar did when
she penned her observations about the ‘flooding rains’ that recharge the rivers, streams
and aquifers.
Today we are left with annual diminishing rainfall and increasing cycles of drought.
We are now into the autumn season and already many available surface water
resources are severely depleted. These scarce water resources will place additional
burdens upon a nation already suffering from the stress of drought.
Risks of Complacency
Some risks have already been touched upon, however this list below provides further
detail.
The ABC news on this same night reported that there were significant amounts of
Commonwealth Assistance Funding for people in the rural sector affected by the
drought.
Large inland cities are now approaching conditions similar to those in Goulburn,
NSW – these include Ballarat, Bendigo, Horsham, Hamilton and many others.
12
Poem – “My Country” – Dorothea Mackellar : http://www.dorotheamackellar.com.au/archive.asp
16
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Farm Walkouts
There have already been reports of farmers walking off their properties. This article is
in the Australian of 13th October, 2006. 13
“FARMERS are abandoning their properties in droves and thousands of
Victoriaʹs best milking cows are being slaughtered as hot, dry weather
pushes the state into a drought crisis.
Angry farmers in the north have scoffed at State Government warnings that
Victorians should brace for tough months ahead as crops fail and debt
soars.
They say the official response is too little, too late, to save hundreds of
farmers walking away from properties held by their families for
generations.
Kyabram real estate and stock agent Peter Croxford toured the district with
the Herald Sun yesterday, pointing out dozens of farms for sale.
Worse was the sight of thousands of prized dairy cattle awaiting slaughter
for export to the US.”
ʺWith cows worth $1500 a head as milkers being sold instead for $400 for
slaughter, itʹs no wonder farmers are walking away,ʺ Mr. Croxford said.
The effect of drought on farmers creates a Catch 22 for country
communities across the state.
ʺWhen farmers lose income they stop spending at the retail level and staff
are laid off across the board,ʺ he said.
Mr. Croxford and farmers were critical of the government response.
ʺThe Government canʹt make it rain, but they should be using some of the
excess in their coffers to subsidise fodder to feed cattle and help provide
water to keep properties running,ʺ Mr. Croxford said.
When farmers walk off the land in times of drought, business activity in local towns
and cities is severely curtailed and there is no-one left in the land-care role.
13
The Australian website: http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,20867,20573211-5006785,00.html
17
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
The Prime Minister has just visited bushfire ravaged areas14 , pledging support of the
Government. This support also needs to be directed toward long term solutions such
as planting fire-resistant shelterbelts.
In January 2006, a bushfire swept through the Grampians in central Victoria. The
only areas to survive, and stop, this fire were tree plantations of Blue Gum under the
management of Timbercorp, a forestry management organization.
There is a DVD available15 with aerial footage that clearly shows that the only ‘patch
of green’ in the fire devastated areas was Blue Gum plantation areas. Whilst they had
been scorched around the edges, the main central areas were untouched.
Export Collapse
Further drought pressure on our nation, which has already been assessed as having
50% of productive farmland declared as drought affected, may lead to an export
collapse.
14
Website for The Australian. http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,20867,20920302-
5006785,00.html
15
DVD available from John Kiely at Timbercorp in Hamilton VIC Tel: (03) 5572 3970
16
Article in The Age Newspaper “Farmers sue State Government”, website:
http://www.theage.com.au/news/national/farmers-sue-state-over-bushfires/2007/03/22/1174153243088.html
18
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Australia has always been an exporter of primary produce, however, such a situation
may well force us to import basic grains, fodder etc. Other nations experiencing
detrimental Climate Change effects such as we have, may also have their export
capacity curtailed.
We would then be at the mercy of the international market-place, forced to pay higher
prices and import costs – a nightmare in any Government effort to produce realistic
Forward Estimates.
“Australians all let us rejoice,
For we are young and free;
We’ve golden soil and wealth for toil;” 17
We all know that we cannot afford to lose our topsoil – but do we know why?
“In dry periods, soils become more susceptible to wind erosion as a result
of the removal of the protective vegetative soil cover. This is caused by
stock grazing and the trampling of the soil surface degrading the soil
structure.
As a consequence, strong winds are able to erode soil particles, depositing
them either as drifts along fence lines or at locations up to thousands of
kilometers away. Eroded soils and animal manure can foul both domestic
and stock water supplies decreasing the potability of the water.”
17
Australian National Anthem
18
Website of the Victorian DPI http://www.dpi.vic.gov.au/dpi/nreninf.nsf/childdocs/-
2BAF4D73531CD1544A2568B3000505AF-BFCF7D5EBE9AE2BCCA256BC80004E969-
7AB5497C04B0FFE84A256DEA00296590-49FE3D171C310C51CA256BCF000AD4F1?open
19
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
“Sandy soils are renowned for blowing during dry periods, however all soil
types are susceptible.
Erosion of topsoils by wind takes with it nutrients such as nitrogen,
phosphorous and organic carbon all of which are vital for the health of the
soil and production.”
“With every 1 mm of topsoil eroded, approximately 13 t/ha of topsoil, 130
kg/ha of organic carbon, 20 kg/ha of nitrogen equivalent to 40 kg of urea
and 8 kg/ha of phosphorous equivalent to 100 kg of superphosphate are
lost.
Although the consequences of soil erosion may not be seen until a number
of years after the drought, removal of soil through erosion will decrease the
productivity of the paddock for many years to come.”
Unless there is adequate groundcover and shelterbelts maintained during the drought,
the most enriched part of the topsoil is at extreme risk of being blown away 19 .
During the 2006-2007 fire season just over 1,000,000 hectares of bushland in the
eastern parts of Victoria was devastated.
The Ash Wednesday fires of 1983 20 saw extreme weather conditions combine with
severe drought to produce some of the most devastating bushfires that Australia has
ever experienced.
“The Ash Wednesday fires consisted of some of the most devastating
bushfires Australia has ever experienced, sweeping through parts of
Victoria and South Australia.
Weather conditions leading up to the Ash Wednesday fires.
Between April 1982 and January 1983, Victoria experienced severe drought
conditions and little rainfall, resulting in its driest period on record. A
19
Website of the Victorian DPI http://www.dpi.vic.gov.au/dpi/nreninf.nsf/childdocs/-
2BAF4D73531CD1544A2568B3000505AF-BFCF7D5EBE9AE2BCCA256BC80004E969-
7AB5497C04B0FFE84A256DEA00296590-49FE3D171C310C51CA256BCF000AD4F1?open
20
Ash Wednesday fires, 1983 website: http://home.vicnet.net.au/~gscfa/ash.htm
20
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
combination of dry grasslands and forests, very hot temperatures, low
humidity and high wind gusts presented Victoria with a high bushfire risk.
The temperature was 43 degrees Celsius on Ash Wednesday.”
“Around 180 bushfires broke out on 16 February 1983, known as Ash
Wednesday.
The largest bushfires started in Victoria at Cudgee and Branxholme (near
Hamilton), around Mount Macedon, in the Dandenong Ranges ‐ Cockatoo,
Upper Beaconsfield and Belgrave Heights, Monivae, Branxholme,
Warburton and in the Otways.”
Whilst the Blue Gum plantations cover approximately 50,000 hectares and represent
some fire inhibiting potential, the native or natural forests are still high risk bushfire
areas, especially in very hot windy conditions where crown fires destroy everything.
As surface water levels are already extremely low in this area, the ability of CFA
(Country Fire Authority) and DSE (Department of Sustainability and Environment) to
access water reserves will only worsen as summer continues.
Comment
Maintenance of sufficient groundcover and shelterbelts is necessary to prevent
erosion, whether it is caused by dry winds during drought or water erosion
after flooding.
This requires regular use of water resources to develop, maintain and extend
shelterbelts.
Dust-Bowl Conditions
There have been numerous studies about the American experience in the 1930’s
depression, when drought cycles and depression created the infamous Dust Bowl. 21
“The most important factor in the creation of the major dust storms during
the Dust Bowl was wind erosion. The combined factors of drought, climate
misconceptions, and poor land management made wind erosion a major
problem. Wind erosion is essentially the wind blowing loose topsoil off of
21
The Causes of the Dust Bowl website: http://snr.unl.edu/metr351-03/jnothwehr/causes.html
21
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
the ground. There were a number of reasons this occurred to such a great
extent during the 1930ʹs.”
“During the previous decades, the predominant crop planted on the Great
Plains was wheat. Wheat is not a very good crop in terms of keep the soil in
big clumps. The fine particles of soil were free to blow around in the wind,
especially after the crops died in a drought and there was nothing holding
the soil in place at all. The farmers also did a poor job of practicing crop
rotation. Wheat was continually planted in the same fields, and the soil was
broken down as a result. Also, the large amount of cultivated land did not
have year round vegetation covering it. When the land was covered with
grasses or other vegetation, it had something to keep the soil in place all
year long. However, when the land was used to grow crops, it did not have
a vegetation cover all year long. There were periods during the year when
nothing was growing at all. This left the uncovered fields vulnerable to
wind erosion. With the increase of cropland, the threat for wind erosion in
this respect also increased.”
Australia could suffer similar climatic conditions with high inland temperatures
creating an increase in atmospheric pressure gradients across weather front systems.
This can generate large front windstorms.
“In 1934, windstorms covered the Great Plains. They easily uplifted the
soil, blowing massive clouds of dust all over the plains.
Thousands of people were forced to leave their homes because of the Dust
Bowl.
89 million acres of land were severely damaged or destroyed.
The Dust Bowl only served to make the Great Depression even more
miserable.”
22
Dust Bowl Article, website: http://library.thinkquest.org/26026/History/the_dust_bowl.html
22
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
In every case it is the destruction of the topsoil that devastates the farming land. 24
“Dust‐storms are for the most part restricted to the drier inland areas of
Australia, but occasionally, during widespread drought, they can affect
coastal districts. The figure above shows the average distribution of dust‐
storms over Australia.
One of the most spectacular examples was the storm that swept across
Melbourne in February 1983, late in the severe El Niño drought of 1982/83.
The extended dry period of the 1930s and 1940s generated many severe
dust‐storms, culminating in the summer of 1944/45 when on several
occasions dust in Adelaide was so thick that street lighting had to be turned
on.
But uncomfortable as dust‐storms may be for town and city dwellers, by far
their worst effect is the stripping of topsoil from Australiaʹs arable land.”
23
Australian Dust Storms – BOM website: http://www.bom.gov.au/lam/climate/levelthree/c20thc/storm8.htm
24
Australian Dust Storms – BOM website: http://www.bom.gov.au/lam/climate/levelthree/c20thc/storm8.htm
23
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
This photo of the dust storm after the Eyre Peninsula Bushfire in January, 2005 is
indicative of the devastation.
In scenes reminiscent of January 11th, 2005 - the day of Eyre Peninsula's bushfire, this is the view of Saturday's dust storm
blowing over Franklin Harbor from Lucky Bay. Photo: Donna Lamb in Lucky Bay.
In the great dust storm of 1983, in Melbourne the following comments are significant.
25
“At its height, the dust‐storm extended across the entire width of Victoria,
and was many kilometres across. The dust‐cloud was some 320m deep
when it struck Melbourne, but in other areas extended thousands of metres
into the atmosphere.
It was estimated that about 50,000 tonnes of topsoil were stripped from the
Mallee (approximately 1,000 tonnes of it being dumped on the city), leaving
the ground bare, and exacerbating the effects of the drought. Open water
channels in the northwest were clogged with sand and dirt.
“The combined effect of drought and dust‐storm inflicted damage on the
land that, according to the then President of the Victorian Farmers and
Graziers’ Association, would take up to 10 years and tens of millions of
dollars to repair.”
25
BOM website: http://www.bom.gov.au/lam/climate/levelthree/c20thc/storm7.htm
24
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
8th FEB, 1983 – Dust Storm in Melbourne with topsoils stripped from the Wimmera.
Comment
Wimmera topsoils deposited over Melbourne emphasize the need for the
urgent implementation of mitigation programmes in the Western Districts of
Victoria – the source of these devastating dust storms.
Shelterbelts using Blue Gum plantation or other low fire-risk vegetation can be
developed to prevent erosion and reduce the fire risk.
26
Heywood Pulp Mill website:
http://www.heywoodpulpmill.com.au/documents/Panel%20Assessment%20Report.pdf
25
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
recycling techniques, however, there will still be water required from the
Aquifer.
3. Penola Pulp Mill – Penola SA. This project has also been given the green
light from the Federal Government subject to remedial habitat work to
save black cockatoo breeding areas. It is of a similar design to the
Heywood mill, requiring 6 ML/day.27
Aquifer Replenishment
Additional long-term reduced rainfall will force governments into adopting ‘fire-
brigade’ policies to meet the threat of drought. When surface capacity fails, authorities
and communities will be forced into seeking whatever water resources that they can
find – this will inevitably lead to the aquifers.
Aquifers can readily be ‘mined’, however there are many scientific papers that stress
the need to correctly replenish these finite resources, as they are really the last
freshwater reserves that we have.
The problems associated with simply taking water from an aquifer system and
providing no recharge capacity is illustrated as follows:
“Anand, Gujarat, 16th February 2002. If India fails to master the game of
groundwater aquifer recharge, the over‐use of this resource will have
disastrous consequences for much of western and peninsular India. It will
create serious ecological problems and put the brakes on socio‐economic
progress in the region. These are the findings of researchers from the
International Water Management Institute (IWMI) and a coalition of Indian
research partners, which will be presented in a special conference in Anand
on 19‐20 February 2002.” 28
The Australian National Water Initiative (NMI) has just released its report.29
27
Penola Pulp Mill website: http://www.penolapulpmill.com.au/
28
International Water Management Institute Website: http://www.iwmi.cgiar.org/Press/iwmi-tata.htm
29
NWI Website: http://nwc.gov.au/NWI/index.cfm#overview
26
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
News media comments such as those below are becoming increasingly prominent in
the public eye.30
“AUSTRALIAʹS first national audit of water resources has ʺfailedʺ the
states in key areas and recommended urgent work to cut irrigation rights,
manage bore water and save crucial rivers.
In a stinging assessment of the slow progress of the states to meet their
water reform obligations under the $2 billion National Water Initiative, the
audit delivers a rude shock to premiers and chief ministers as they hold
their own summit on federation issues, such as water management, in
Melbourne today.
Its criticisms have also coincided with the introduction of new water
restrictions in Adelaide and Brisbane, and likely tougher restrictions in
Melbourne.
South Australia introduced the toughest water restrictions in the stateʹs
history to combat record low Murray River flows.
There have been many recommendations in the NWI for water conservation
measures, in addition to the following major issues regarding:
30 th
The Australian Newspaper 13 OCT, 2006 :
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,20867,20572341-601,00.html
31 th
The Bay Journal – article of 24 SEPT, 2006
http://bayjournal.com.au/joomla/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=893&Itemid=44
27
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
ʺOur Government is investing significant funding in the project with $80
million committed for early works such as preparing the site and ordering
specialized tunnel boring machines,ʺ Ms Bligh said.
ʺWhen completed this plant will deliver a significant new source of water
that we hope will prevent an ʹArmageddonʹ water situation.
ʺThe project has the potential to deliver 125 million litres of desalinated
water per day by the end of 2008.
ʺThis represents more than 15 percent of the entire south‐eastʹs current
needs and is sufficient to meet the water needs of at least 400,000 people.”
This project will cost in excess of $1.1 billion when pipeline connection costs to the
various reservoirs are included.
Desalination Plants
There are several types of desalination plants. The major ones include:
32
Water Desalination in the Middle East: http://www.unu.edu/unupress/unupbooks/80858e/80858E09.htm
28
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
operating costs and high construction costs associated with using high
quality stainless steel in tubes and chambers. 33
Of these processes, MED would appear to provide the best value with its low
temperature operational costs. There is also the requirement that sterile water be used
for aquifer recharge due to the presence in the sea around Portland of a virus that
causes ganglioneuritis, a herpes-like disease that is killing the wild abalone.37 This
would appear to seriously compromise any desalination effort by a filtration process
using Reverse Osmosis (RO) methods.
Full details about other desalination plants and processes may be found at Annex A,38
in hardcopy versions of this document.
A significant factor in any desalination process is related to the energy levels required
to produce potable water.
33
Introduction to Water Desalination, by Hari J Krishna
http://www.twdb.state.tx.us/Desalination/The%20Future%20of%20Desalination%20in%20Texas%20-
%20Volume%202/documents/C1.pdf
34
“Distillation Plant Development and Cost Update”, by Neil M Wade, page 7 Website:
http://www.desline.com/articoli/4051.pdf
35
Ibid.
36
Ibid.
37
ABC Rural Website: http://www.abc.net.au/rural/regions/content/2006/s1655934.htm
38
Introduction to Water Desalination, by Hari J Krishna
http://www.twdb.state.tx.us/Desalination/The%20Future%20of%20Desalination%20in%20Texas%20-
%20Volume%202/documents/C1.pdf
29
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Energy Costs
The on-going operational energy costs for an MED desalination plant should be
drastically reduced by using the 2 significant heat resources within the Portland area:
Full costings for such a plant are dependent upon plant size, however, a paper by Neil
M Wade40 of the UK, entitled “Distillation Plant Development and Cost
Update”, compares the various available desalination processes.
1. Road – very inefficient for delivering high volumes over long distances,
and mainly suitable for individual farmers.
3. VLCCs – Very Large Crude Carriers – There have been several papers
outlining costs of shipping bulk water over distances of several thousands
of kilometers. In a North American paper on the subject, their conclusion
was that it was not economically sustainable to undertake such a task.
39
VIC Dept of Sustainability Report by SKM in collaboration with Monash University pp 66-76 website:
http://www.sustainability.vic.gov.au/resources/documents/SKM_Geothermal_Report.pdf
40
“Distillation Plant Development and Cost Update”, by Neil M Wade, Website:
http://www.desline.com/articoli/4051.pdf
30
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Many of the Country Fire Authority (CFA) stations have been established along Main
Supply Route (MSR) corridors. Given the requirement for easy access to water for
these units, it may be worthwhile planning for secure water access to the pipeline at
these CFA stations
Dams and reservoirs in this area already depleted. Several CFA units in the
Grampians area are currently unable to conduct ‘fuel reduction’ burns because they
have to save all their water for ‘the real thing’, a major bushfire. Pipelines from a
desalination plant will guarantee fire-fighting access to water. .
Use of the existing transport corridors should reduce impact on landowners, costs for
additional easement purchase from graziers etc.
Comment
Desalination Plants guarantee the delivery of water around the clock. This
enables authorities, industry and users to adequately plan their business
around realistic delivery and seasonal timetables.
31
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Key Elements
Key elements for successfully commissioning such a project in the Portland Bay Area
are:
8. Geothermal Resources
Details of these of the key elements that identify Portland as a prime site for an effort
of this scale are outlined on Page 35 of this document.
32
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Why Portland
Some vital statistics about average datasets for Australian Aluminium production41
include:
• Green House Gas (GHG) emissions of approx 2.5 tonnes CO2-e per tonne
of metal produced.
In October 2006, Alcoa won the prestigious Prime Minister’s Community Business
Partnership Award for community work in Western Australia. 42
“Working in partnership not only has the potential to enrich people’s lives
but can also deliver tangible results for all Australians. Community and
business partnerships are a driver to accomplish better outcomes than any
group acting alone could achieve.”
The Hon. John Howard, MP, the Prime Minister of Australia.
Greenhouse gas emissions are becoming an increasing area of concern with activist
groups adopting a more militant stance toward industry.
Many industry leaders are seeking ways of both effectively reducing their greenhouse
gas emissions and ‘value-adding’ other goods and services by utilizing by-product
development. This will then achieve acceptable results to both communities and the
corporate ‘bottom-line’.
41
Australian Aluminium Council website: http://www.aluminium.org.au/Page.php?d=1050
42
Alcoa website: http://www.alcoa.com/australia/en/news/releases/20061018_Alcoa_wins_PM_awards.asp
33
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
“The plan looks more critically at all aspects of the business through what
could be referred to as the “triple bottom line” of business enterprise.
The triple bottom line refers to balancing environmental, economic and
social values in business.
In todayʹs climate of strong environmental awareness, it makes sense to
ensure environmental and social concerns factor into the equation of
making money.”
The International Community is already discussing the issues involving carbon credits.
“New South Wales continues to be a pioneer in introducing carbon dioxide
emissions trading and exploring methods to use forests for Greenhouse‐
friendly products. The first carbon trades in Australia involved State
Forests of NSW working with Pacific Power and Delta Electricity.
It is an exciting new era for those who grow forests. Now, when we create a
healthy forest, we not only receive a return for the wood products being
grown but may also benefit from trading in carbon credits.”
Comment
Pro-active support by Portland Aluminium for a Desalination Plant where
potable water is used for drought mitigation purposes will ensure generation of
Carbon Credits to offset GHG emissions.
This activity fits well within the “triple bottom line” doctrine of Portland
Aluminium.
43
Smelter in the Park & Ballarat University website:
http://www.ballarat.edu.au/projects/ensus/case_studies/PA/index.html
44
State Forests of NSW website:
http://www.forest.nsw.gov.au/publication/forest_facts/greenhouse/default.asp
34
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Power Generation
Desalination plants require large capacity power stations to run them, and also provide
pumping capacity for fresh water product.
There are currently plans for a 1,000 MW gas-fired power station to be built at
Mortlake in Victoria. 45
This plant is close to the 500 KV transmission lines that carry power to the Alcoa
Aluminium Smelter in Portland – hence the power line easement for this line may also
be used for further electricity distribution.
This power station will be fed from the Otway Gas Project.46
Origin Energy plan that construction will take 30 months, and based on the current
trends of National Electricity Market (NEM) indicators, 2010 appears favourable for a
construction start date.
Perhaps this starting date may be brought forward, subject to compelling reasons for
immediate commencement.
Approval has also been given for the Macarthur Wind Project47 just north of Portland.
This facility will have a generating capacity of approx 330 MW, which can also be used
for pumping water north.
Key Elements
Portland meets all of the elements necessary for success of this project:
1. Easy access to unpolluted seawater – whilst Port Phillip Bay, close to the
power stations of Melbourne and Geelong may appear an attractive alternative, the
Yarra River continues to pollute the Bay.
There will also be the problem of returning the very high salt concentrates into the
fragile Port Phillip Bay ecosystem – always a problematic environmental issue.
2. Deep Water Port Access – Portland already has the only deep water Port
between Geelong and Adelaide.
45
Mortlake – Origin Energy Project website:
http://www.originenergy.com.au/about/template.php?pageid=1376
46
Otway Gas Project – Woodside Petroleum website: http://www.otway.woodside.com.au/The+Project/
47
ABC News Website – Macarthur Wind Farm Approval:
http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200610/s1774962.htm
35
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
It is therefore suitable for delivering any large/oversize modules necessary for the
Desalination Plant or even the Power Station 140 kms away at Mortlake.
4. Main Supply Routes North – There are already main road and rail links in
place along the north-south corridor linking Portland to Mildura.
Whilst the upgrading of the Portland to Hopetoun standard gauge line has been
delayed due to the costs blow-out of the Very Fast Train programme, there are still
plans to upgrade this line. This will enable delivery of pipes without additional heavy
vehicle traffic on the already busy road network.
This 1,000 MW facility will have the capacity to supply the pumping stations, and use
much of the existing power line easements in linking the electricity grid.
The Macarthur Wind Farm project has also been approved, with construction given
the green light
After this massive energy load has been used to produce the extremely high
temperatures (800 deg C and above) the heat is just dissipated into the air, wasted.
7. Significant Carbon Credits – The GHG emission levels from the electrical
generation using lignite at the Yallourn Power Station can be offset by extending the
“Smelter in the Park” concept northwards, with the supply of potable water to
industries, towns, communities and new forests.
36
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
(1) Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health
and well‐being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing,
housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to
security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood,
old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.
Whilst there may be legal interpretations as to the exact meaning of citizens having the
“right to a standard of living……including food,” it would be a brave Judiciary System
that would refuse to recognize “water” as an integral part of “food”.
If Government Authorities therefore fail in taking all reasonable steps to ensure that
their citizens have adequate access to water – including developing new water sources,
then they too may face lawsuits.
This would be a parallel situation to those property owners in Gippsland, who are
seeking compensation for the loss of their properties because of poor fire
management practice.
48
UN Charter Of Human Rights website: http://www.un.org/Overview/rights.html
37
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Next Steps
38
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Conclusion
These sites include Power Stations (Gippsland VIC), Steel Works (Wollongong
NSW), Newcastle (NSW) and the Aluminium Smelter (Gladstone QLD).
Greenhouse gas emission and carbon credit trading will soon become a prime
consideration in Government Policy affecting industry and revenues.
Additionally, there are the social issues of responsible environmental and water
management that will be thoroughly scrutinized by the public and the press.
Many of our forests, farms, rivers, communities and cities are dying of thirst or being
devastated by bushfires.
“I love a charcoal country
A land of sweeping flames
Of burnt out houses, bushland…
…And little animals’ remains”
Graham Mibus Unpublished Works 2006
39
The Clever Country – Dying of Thirst
Index
abalone, 29 heat exchanger unit, 36
aquifer replenishment, 26–27 Heywood Pulp Mill, 26
quarantine & sterile water, 29 Iluka Minerals Sands Project, 25
quarantine & sterile water, 29 International Water Management Institute, 26
aquifers, 15, See also groundwater reserves key elements (for desalination project success),
Ash Wednesday fires, 20 35–37
Ballarat, 15 Macarthur Wind Farm Project, 35, 36
Beyond Blue, 10 Mallee district, 11
blue gum plantations, 18, 21, 25 Mortlake, 35
Bureau of Meteorology Map, 8 multi-effect distillation, 29, 36
bushfire, 18, 31 National Water Initiative, 27
carbon credits, 34, 37, 39 Origin Energy, 35
Climate Change, 6 Pacific Power, 34
Commonwealth Assistance Funding, 16 Penola Pulp Mill, 26
complacency, risks of, 16–18 Permissible Annual Volume (PAV) extraction, 14
Country Fire Authority, 21, 31 pipelines, where to build, 31
crop yield failure, 6 port access - deep water, 36
deep water port access, 36 Portland Aluminium, 30, 33
delivering water, 30–31 Portland geothermal bores, 30, 37, 38
Delta Electricity, 34 power generation, 35, 36
desalination, 16–30 Primary Industries, Victorian Department of, 11
energy costs of, 30
quarantine protocols, 29
multi-effect distillation (MED), 29, 36
multistage flash (MSF), 28 rainfall trends, 8
Reverse Osmosis (RO), 29 Region of Interest, 11
drought Rural Sector Collapse, 16
2002-2003, 9 shelterbelts, 18
stories, 6, 9, 10, 17, 20 loss of, 20
Drought Relief Programmes, 6 soil, importance of, 20
dust storms, 24 sterile water, 29
dust-bowl conditions, 25 stock sell-offs, 9, 17
El Niño drought, 23 storage levels, 11–12
energy costs of desalination, 30 supply routes, 36
export collapse, 18 temperatures, extremely high, 36
Eyre Peninsula bushfire, 23 Timbercorp, 18
farm walkouts, 17 topsoil loss, 19, 23
farmer suicides, 10 tree plantations, 18
firestorm, 18 triple bottom line, 34
ganglioneuritis, 29 unpolluted seawater, 35
gas-fired power station, 35 Very Large Crude Carriers (VLCCs), 30
geothermal bores, 30, 37 Victorian Department of Primary Industries, 11
Glenelg Hopkins Catchment Management water delivery, 31, 36
Authority, 14 water resources
Gold Coast City, 27 access for fire-fighting, 31
golden soil, 19–25 aquifer replenishment, 26–27
aquifers, 13–15
Goulburn, 6
audit, national, 27
Greater Green Triangle, 14–15 delivery, 30–31, 36
rainfall map, 15 groundwater reserves, 13–15
greenhouse gas emission, 33, 34, 37, 39 rainfall, 8
groundcover. See shelterbelts storage levels, 11–12
groundwater reserves, 13–15 water storage levels, 11–12
for desalination project success, 36 wheat exports, 6
permissible extraction, 14 Wimmera district, 11
recharge capacity, 14
Yallourn Power Station, 37
harvest reduction, 8
40