Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DESIGN THINKING
Evolving the Global Business Landscape
Executive Summary 03
Key Elements 07
Success Stories 22
Use Case 26
Copying or distribution without written permission is prohibited
03
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
• The world as we know it is changing everyday, with customer’s becoming increasingly aware about the market, and demanding superior
services. However, hidden behind those clear demands are the areas of untapped potential, ripe for being leveraged by the innovation driven
businesses.
• Understanding the implicit needs from the explicit needs makes all the difference, as a business goes all the way to capture share of
customer’s wallet.
• Today’s business environment requires that managers adapt and change their business models on an ongoing basis. Fast-paced dynamics
demand a constant need for firms to amend their strategies in order to achieve sustained revenue growth.
• But what can leaders do to sustain growth in this volatile, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous business environment? Design thinking is the
answer.
• Financial services as an industry is not far behind the curve, when it comes to understanding customer needs and addressing them through
technological innovation and improved product design.
• The element of empathy is what drives the innovation, and DESIGN THINKING plays the ever important role of the harbinger of change.
• The role of design thinking in financial services has been crucial in the product design and customer outreach over the past decade. Large
enterprises are being increasingly aware of the potential of design thinking to serve their customers better and thus elevate their profit
margins.
• In this report, we deep dive into design thinking as a tool for innovation and transformation of the financial services industry.
Design Thinking
Fostering Innovation
DESIGN THINKING
UNDERSTANDING THE CONCEPT
DESIGN THINKING
EVOLUTION
• The process of design has evolved over the past two centuries, and should now be imbibed in the organization’s culture, fostering
innovation at every level.
CUSTOMER
None Little For feedback As co-creators
INFLUENCE
RELATED Industrial revolution Advertising, marketing User centred design, Service design, design
MOVEMENT/ modern architecture research, industrial ergonomic & human strategy, user
INFLUENCERS design factors design, human- experience design
computer interaction,
usability
DESIGN THINKING
KEY ELEMENTS (1/2)
DESIGN THINKING
KEY ELEMENTS (2/2)
Design Thinking
Understanding The Process
DESIGN THINKING
PROCESS FLOW
• Understand the unspoken customer needs by being in their shoes, Interpret their
PROBLEM FINDING
• Involves a diverse team with members from different streams and positions to
brainstorm.
• Develop a prototype of the product based on the idea generated.
PROTOTYPE • The inputs during prototype development will help the designer to change the POV if
the need arises.
DESIGN THINKING
BEGINNING WITH EMPATHY
• Tools such as “Day in the Life Of” (DILO) provide a structured way to tackle this
process. By adopting such an approach, businesses will be able to focus both on Empathy is what accentuates the design
what consumers really need (not what they say they need) and why (deep needs thinking approach to business strategy as
and goals of customers), and thus develop their business strategy accordingly. compared to the traditional approach
• The traditional model of problem solving includes problem identification using tools
like surveys, customer feedback, etc. What customers said was the bottom line
around which the product/service was built.
• This approach of dealing with the obvious gave rise to numerous incumbent
businesses built around product provisioning.
• However, the tricky part was when the problem was not clearly defined, or the
customers could not convey what they actually needed. This is where the power of
empathy resides – Understanding the unspoken needs by being in customer’s shoes
and feeling their pain-points. Implicit Needs : Example
• Design thinking is built around the concept of empathy, as is all about connecting
with the customers in a way that has been done before. Problem Statement: Financial instability in the rural
India. People unable to manage finances and save
• Innovators need to lead the way and show customers the answers to their problems,
money.
answers they could not think existed. Explicit Need: Increasing need of credit for rural
• This can be very clearly understood by a quote by Henry Ford who built the first customers.
Implicit Need: To make savings account easily
ever car, as he said: “If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have accessible. It will give people more control over their
said FASTER HORSES.” finances and they will need credit less often.
If you define the problem CORRECTLY, you almost have the SOLUTION
If you define the problem CORRECTLY, you almost have the SOLUTION
IDEATION
• This stage is about summarising the information gained during the empathising process.
• The cross-functional team of designers reframes the empathetic explorations made during customer interaction, and presents it in a format
relevant to the scope of business.
• The goal here is to create meaningful and actionable problem statements, and come up with innovative ideas to solve the problems.
• Techniques such as bodystorm and brainwriting are commonly used in the ideation and brainstorming process.
PROTOTYPING TESTING
• This stage involves development of cost effective and simple • In this stage, the purpose is to give the prototype in the hands of
prototypes based on the outcomes of ideation. the end-customer and get feedback.
• A prototype transforms an idea into something tangible • This stage is related to the first stage (Empathize) since the
and experiment-able. As per IDEO, “A prototype is worth a objective is to understand what the customer thinks about the
thousand meetings.” product, and why he/she thinks that.
• The talk and hype-building about the product starts here. • Multiple iterations are done based on the feedback.
Design Thinking
Evolving Mindset
DESIGN THINKING
A SHIFT IN MINDSET
DESIGN THINKING
FAIL EARLY, FAIL OFTEN – BUT: FAIL SMART
Too late to
fail
• As clichéd as it may sound, failure paves the way for success. This couldn’t be more
$ COST OF AN ERROR
apt than in the context of design thinking.
Prototype,
• The process of design thinking is an iterative one, where every input from the end fail and learn
early
customer is incorporated in the product design. and cheap
• The stages of ideation and prototyping are the ones where a business can make as
many changes in the design, as needed. Multiple failures to meet customer’s
Project Timeline Launch
expectations is allowed. Also, It could take a long time before the product is
+$
finalised. But as long as the customers are happy with the final prototype, it’s all
worth it.
INVESTMENT / RETURN
• As we go ahead in the product lifecycle, the cost of failure increases significantly.
• The investment in terms of money and time/effort is higher in this process of fine- Return
tuning the design, but it gives much better return over a long period of time. Investment Time
• This is the reason why modern day businesses spend a long time in their beta
testing phase, before launching the final product in the market.
-$
Design Thinking
Transforming Financial Services
• Traditional banks are being bogged down by their conservative approach towards
financial problem solving.
Traditional banks are acting too slowly
• Some of the roadblocks for traditional banking innovation include:
in the move to comprehensive digital
• Banking legacy & profit-centred mindset services. On the one hand, they can
• Bureaucracy commit to investing a lot of money to
• In-house competition between departments
FinTech; on the other, conservatism and
bureaucracy seriously hamper putting
• Waterfall approach in designing new products
effective FinTech in place.
• A huge hierarchy that slows down the speed of decision-making.
• Traditional banks are still stuck in their old age approach of being a payment processor,
and money handler. However, they are slow in realising that existing economic and
financial models were created for the industrial age and they no longer meet consumers
needs while entering the information age. When customers think of
• However, there are some innovative banks offering Omni-channel digital banking, innovation, they think of FinTech.
interactive dashboards and financial assistance. But even these early adopters face yet Banks need to change this
another problem — lack of usability and appeal. perception.
• A lack of perspective towards customer driven solution design is hurting the traditional
incumbents, and they need to act fast.
• In the modern business landscape, FinTech is the most funded industry and, Design thinking is behind the emergence of most
according to experts, the most promising business segment. of the FinTech business models, solving problems
for customers across the globe.
• With the help of Design Thinking approach, a small team of like-minded
people can produce an alternative to bank products, get customer support, Problem Statement Solution Design
find funding to develop their ideas and ultimately change the world.
• Long queues in bank, heavy
• Apart from the superior leverage to their technological capability, its the paperwork in account opening,
• Neo banks (Branchless, App only
banking)
customer-centred approach that is helping FinTech stay ahead on the bank far away from home
innovation front. FinTech is all about changing the way people manage their • Migrants and students unable to • Alternative credit scoring, using
finances, and this has been achieved by accurately defining a real problem – get a loan due to lack of credit the social media activity &
history mobile/utility bill payment data
courtesy Design Thinking.
• Payment with Mobile wallet/
• PayPal changed the way people pay online. • Cash withdrawal charges, Hassel
Apple Pay , using NFC/QR code
in withdrawing cash from ATMs
• Mint raised personal financial management to a new level. scanning)
• TransferWise saved millions to its users with fair currency rates. • Local, bi-directional settlement
• High FX conversion and transfer of international payment(
fee while making an TransferWise model)
• P2P lending services such as Lending Club delivered quick and hassle free lending international money transfer • Blockchain based remittance
solutions that banks refused to provide. (Veem/Align Commerce)
• Alternative credit scoring companies like ZestFinance, Lenddo, Kabbage • Unable to save money every • Savings tools for visualisation of
month due to unregulated spending, dash-boarding,
brought millions of unbanked customers under the credit spectrum. spending. Unable to keep track spending recommendation
based on monthly trend. E.g.
of budget for spending Digit, Qapital
• Financial services is the people’s business. Banking is essentially nothing but an EXPERIENCE METRICS
interconnected web of human interactions that spreads all around the world.
• With multiple stakeholders and their ever changing needs, the financial services As a part of an organization’s strategy, experience
metrics must be an essential part of the product KPIs,
industry needs a reform in assessing these needs accurately, and instantly.
along with business and technology metrics, in order
• The incumbent players including banks and insurers have huge concerns over losing to capture the user experience as a parameter to
their dominance over customer experience, as the new age FinTech start ups are measure product’s success with the customers.
grabbing their share of wallet.
• These FinTech players use the elements of design thinking (e.g. Empathy) to develop Business Metrics
Market performance Quantitative data -
their business models. This enables them to accurately assess the customer needs of a product Dashboard
and addressing that using the advanced technologies at their disposal.
• The focus on ease-of-use and experience-over-product is making the difference Technology Metrics
Technological performance
as the FinTech players are gradually taking over the customer experience. KPIs
and maturity of a product
• User experience is being seen as the driving force for a modern business, and thus Business performance
enterprises and modern banks are pushing for increased effort on UI design, Experience Metrics assessment
especially for the mobile channel. User behaviour while
Interacting with the product
• Modern Banks and financial institutions are gradually realising the need to KEY DESIGN PRINCIPLES
change their business strategy from product-provisioning to need-
servicing, and are now transforming their strategy to be the enabler of
their customers’ financial well being.
Personalisation Transparency Self-Service Mobile First
• The role of banks has gradually shifted from being mere payment
processors, to being trusted consumer advisors by focussing on the
customer experience.
Simplicity Asthetic Holistic
• Modern banks have begun to set up innovation labs and are applying
design thinking within their organizations. However, they still need to
make it a part of their day-to-day culture and processes.
• The way ahead for banks and Fis is to identify the areas of innovation and The biggest change design thinking has brought in the
landscape of financial services is a user-centricity. Thanks to it
break it down into smaller targets to meet. Greater adoption happens users expectations have grown and they are not ready to put up
with difficult, insufferable, slow, unreasonably expensive and
when bite-size challenges yield incremental yet valuable innovations.
inconvenient services.
E.g. “Improving the banking experience” is broader goal, which starts with
“improving the account-opening experience” ALEX KREGER
CEO, UXDA
Using design thinking principles, a diverse, cross-divisional team In 2014, Capital One started building its internal deign group, Capital
within OCBC Bank developed the initial concept for an investment One Labs, hiring a new first vice president of design: Daniel Makoski,
product based on customers’ insights. former Google innovator. As a part of this initiative,, Capital One
acquired Adaptive Path, a consulting design firm focused on user
Once the first product concept was ready, the team had a co-creation experience to lay the ground work for the design group.
workshop with front-line employees. During the session, co-creators With this acquisition, Capital One planned to leverage the digital
were not merely validating what had been developed, but were product design capabilities, and build on top of it, cross pollinating with
redefining a new product communication concept. their practises, thus developing an in-house culture of design thinking
and innovation.
The team prototyped communication ideas using simple materials and
stationery. In the testing phase, the team met 16 customers one-on-
one and showed them the prototype. As per the feedback, 30
iterations were made before the product was finalised.
MOVEN
After the process, OCBC Bank increased sales of its new investment
product by 150%, one month after the product launch. and increased
A great example of defying the traditional banking norms by elimination
their customers’ trust perception.
of product silos and fulfilling customer needs, MOVEN is one of the
pioneers in the now-established neo banking space. After a intensive
beta testing phase, MOVEN is now on its way to become a technology
platform provider to banks like TD Bank in Canada & Westpac in New
Zealand who are at the forefront
of being customer driven in their design.
One of the early adopters of design thinking in banking, Bank of For a 165 years old company like MassMutual, the biggest challenge was
America used this concept to solve a critical banking problem of early to get their millennial customers on board for using their life insurance
2000s: How to get more customers to open checking accounts. After products. The real problem here was identified as the lack of awareness
hiring a design research firm, a team of five BoFA researchers visited about savings and spending habits in millennial. Partnering with IDEO,
Atlanta, Baltimore and San Francisco to closely observe and interact MassMutual with a mission to get young people interested in their own
with the customers. spending habits.
From this, they identified two POVs : People unable to save efficiently In the process, MassMutual organized meet ups and surveys to
and people rounding off their check book entry to an even dollar, as it understand the spending habits of millennial across US. From this
was convenient and faster. Combining these POVs, BoFA put together exercise, the problem statement was defined as lack of financial
a cross functional team, who developed 80 product prototypes over awareness.
20 ideation sessions. As an outcome of multiple iterations, the product
concept was framed: rounding up the financial transactions of After defining the problem, the team conceptualised a program called
consumers and transferring the difference to their savings. “Society of grownups”, which was about helping people navigate
complicated financial situations. After building and testing full-scale, live
This concept was tested via multiple communication channels with prototypes, the brick-and-mortar Boston location opened in 2014. After
over 1600 customers. After multiple iterations, the product “Keep The two years of prototyping, it was understood that the digital channel is
Change” was launched. It saw instant success and went on to become the way forward. Thus the store was closed. Society of Grownups is
one of the most innovative case studies of design thinking in financial launching a deeper interactive web presence in 2017.
services.
Design Thinking
LTP Exclusive: Use Case
LTP presents an exclusive use case for a realistic implementation of design thinking in financial services. In
this scenario, we present a hypothetical situation where a bank uses design thinking get more millennial on-
board for its savings and investment programs.
• This trend was observed by the executives of ABC bank in New York, $10-20 K
7.8%
4.7%
while analyzing the sales figures for their savings products. The
number of millennial customer on-braded with the bank ‘s saving $5-10 K
8.1%
6.4%
products in the previous financial year was less than 10% of their
total customer base. $1-5 K
16.6%
19.6%
• In order to understand this problem and capture the millennial
47.1%
market share, the bank executives crated a cross functional team and < $1 K
57.6%
created a roadmap based on the concept of design thinking.
Age 25-34 Age 18-24
1 EMPATHISE 2 DEFINE
• A diverse team of executives from the ABC bank – consisting of • From the inputs during the meet-ups, the team found the
product manager, marketing manager, underwriter and following insights:
software developer (the design team) - visited 5 university
campuses and 4 IT firms meet young professionals and • Young customers were apprehensive about long term fixed savings
conduct primary research interviews with millennial. The team and wanted to have liquidity in their account for their desired
spoke to them about their financial awareness, short-term and spending.
• Majority of the young customers looked at investments only as a
long term goals, their wish lists and future holiday plans to means of tax exemption.
understand their spending habits, and the challenges they face • Most of them had planned a certain short term goal, i.e. owning a
in saving. car, holiday in Europe, buying an Xbox/TV etc. However, they always
fell short of cash over a period of time as they spent it on
• Some millennial customers of the bank were directly unplanned events, i.e. Parties, eating out, shopping, impulse buy,
approached by the relationship managers for a one-on-one etc.
interaction. They were invited for a meet-up session over • They were not serious about being prepared for emergencies like
health issues, accidents, etc, and thus didn’t consider life insurance a
dinner at a local restaurant , where the team of executives had priority.
a casual conversation with them, getting to know their lifestyle
and specifically understand their challenges when it comes to • Based on the above insights, the following POV was created:
savings.
Millennial are reluctant to enrol in savings/investments as
• The team spent a few days with some of the customers, they are unaware of its importance, and are not guided
meeting them during their outings/shopping trips and getting properly to manage their finances better.
to know their day-to-day activities.
3 IDEATION
• Based on the POV, the cross functional design team conducted internal brainstorming sessions with the additional involvement of 5 young employees
of ABC bank from different levels of hierarchy.
• Every idea was aptly noted and discussed for its feasibility and viability.
• Multiple sessions and hundreds of ideas later, the team landed on a unique solution concept: A special membership program called “Spend with a
friend”
• Young customers of ABC bank, who enrol in the above program will be provided the following services:
• A dedicated financial advisor/counsellor will be assigned to every young customer, who will hold biweekly call with them, understanding their spending and goals for the month,
and assist them on savings.
• Every customer will be enrolled to a short term fixed saving plan (2/3 year). Based on the counselling sessions, every month a flexible amount will be deposited in the account.
• The bank will conduct several meet ups and community building events. The executives and advisors will interact with the customers over dinner and understand their
experience. Apart from the discussions, the events will have recreational activities and dinners for the young customers to bond with each other, and also with their advisors. This
will build an element of trust and comfort, and will enable them to open up to their advisors about their challenges and their goals.
• The bank will provide a savings tool (in partnership with major savings tool like Even, Digit etc.) for the customers, enabling them to monitor their spends, and offering
recommendations to optimize spending. The inputs from the savings tool will also act as a reference for the advisor during the bimonthly counselling sessions.
• After one year, the bank executives will hold a review meeting with the customer to understand their progress in saving and financial awareness. Then they will be offered to
enrol in the regular savings and investment programs by the bank. They will be given incentives based on their progress.
4 PROTOTYPING 5 TESTING
• By partnering with leading savings tool providers (Digit, • This prototype of the program was provided to 400 existing
Qapital, etc.), ABC bank created a prototype of its savings tool customers over a period of 6 months. In this duration, 12
mobile app. counselling sessions and 2 meet up events were conducted.
• All the aspects of the program was formally documented and • Customer feedback was taken on an ongoing basis by a
processes were built around the functionalities such as financial separate QA team appointed by the design team.
counselling, events meet up and progress tracking.
• Every feedback was discussed in the brainstorming sessions
• The bank trained a set of relationship managers to be the and based on that the program outline and the savings tool
financial advisors/counsellors. features were modified.
TM
About MEDICI
MEDICI is the world’s leading FinTech Research and Global Contacts
Innovation Platform. As a premiere destination for FinTech
insights, MEDICI has over 13,000 FinTechs on the platform, Lloyd Layton
which enables FinTechs to scale and create global economic Head of Sales, Americas
lloyd@gomedici.com
impact. By partnering with banks, various technology
companies, and FIs globally, MEDICI is committed to Nicolo Petrone
supporting the complex financial services ecosystem and Head of Sales, Europe
nicolo@gomedici.com
enabling stakeholders benefit from the industry’s accelerated
growth and global impact.
Subhagini Chaudhary
Head of Sales, Southeast Asia
Website: www.goMEDICI.com | Twitter: @gomedici subhagini@gomedici.com
Shubhanga Prasad
Aditya Khurjekar Amit Goel Head of Client Services
CEO & Founder CSO & Founder shubhanga@gomedici.com
ak@goMEDICI.com amit@goMEDICI.com
@khurjekar @amitTwitr