Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Emission Behaviour of Aerated Landfills: Results of Laboratory Scale Investigations
Emission Behaviour of Aerated Landfills: Results of Laboratory Scale Investigations
SUMMARY: Gas and leachate emissions play a decisive role respecting the complexity and
duration of aftercare measures after landfill closure. By the aeration of landfilled waste the
remaining emission potential can be significantly reduced, demonstrated by comprehensive lab-
scale investigations in Landfill Simulation Reactors (LSR), carried out at the department of
Waste Management at the Technical University of Hamburg-Harburg. Frequently leachate
analysis of the aerated waste material show a fast and sustainable decline of the organic- and
nitrogen parameters. Whereas carbon is mainly discharged via the gas phase the fate of
ammonium, however, could not clearly be defined so far. Recent investigations show that a large
portion of ammonium is stripped out as ammonia under aerated conditions.
1 INTRODUCTION
The old Kuhstedt landfill has been constructed in the middle of the sixties in a former sand- resp.
gravel pit. From 1973 on, the old disposal site was filled in a controlled way as combined pit-
/landraising landfill. In 1987, when operation stopped, the total waste volume came to about
220.000 m³, deposited within an area of 3.2 ha. The landfill height is between 8 and 10 m, but
the basis is about 2 – 3 m below the surface of the site. The old landfill can be regarded as
typical for a large number of old landfills in Germany due to its volume, the deposited kinds of
waste (mainly household waste, industrial waste similar to household waste, bulky- and
construction waste) and due to geological and hydro-geological conditions. Most of these old
disposal sites do not have the necessary installations for the collection of landfill gas and/or
leachate or they do not meet the requirements. However, exactly these emissions represent a
significant risk potential for the environment. As far as landfill gas production is concerned,
assessments (basing on laboratory investigations) indicate periods of 20 to 30 years for the
occurrence of significant gas quantities (partly usable) whereas assessments indicate a
considerably longer period of time for contaminated leachate resulting from these old landfills
(Krümpelbeck, 2000; Heyer, 1997). The occurring contamination (especially reduced nitrogen
compounds) might necessitate a collection and purification of leachate for up to 100 or even
more years, involving costs and technical requirements.
According to the actual state of knowledge, there are possibilities to exert a controlled and
accelerated active influence on old landfills - consisting in a washout of landfill
Proceedings Sardinia 2003, Ninth International Waste Management and Landfill Symposium
S. Margherita di Pula, Cagliari, Italy; 6 - 10 October 2003
2003 by CISA, Environmental Sanitary Engineering Centre, Italy
components(enhanced leachate circulation) (Pacey, 1999) and/or in a controlled aeration of the
landfill body to accelerate biological degradation processes. As a rule, the first variation is not
applicable to the thousands of smaller and medium-scale old deposits in Germany which are not
provided with a bottom liner and a leachate collection system. Controlled aeration, however, is a
promising approach which – apart from expected positive effects on the emission potential of the
treated landfill body - also offers cost saving potentials by e.g. a significant reduction of the
aftercare period (Heyer et al., 2001). In the following, the main influences of aeration measures
on the emission behaviour of waste material are presented, based on long-term laboratory
investigations in Landfill Simulation Reactors (LSR) and additional chemical-physical and
biological analyses of solid and liquid samples.
2.2 Aerobic and anaerobic treatment of waste samples in landfill simulation reactors
In three cases, the same waste material was placed in two landfill simulation reactors which,
subsequently, were operated under aerobic resp. anaerobic conditions at a constant temperature
of 35°C. Here, the anaerobic LSR serve as a control in order to simulate the emission behavior
under the initial, anaerobic landfill milieu conditions. By means of an intensive process water
circulation (twice a day), associated by a weekly leachate exchange (1 liter), it is possible to
simulate both effects, the “flushing” as well as the aeration of the waste. Therefore the
experiments simulate a base sealed landfill, applied with leachate re-circulation and aeration. By
modifying the experimental set up to a LSR-operation with only limited process water
circulation (according to the actual amount of precipitation, infiltrating into the landfill body)
and minimized water exchange it is possible to simulate an aeration measure for an unsealed old
landfill. For the described investigations, leachate and gas samples were taken at regular
intervals and analyzed in the laboratory.
optional
13
7 8 1 LSR
2 aeration (optional)
3 pump well (2 l)
10 4 transformator
6 5 leachate sampling and fresh water
5 Feststoff-
Solid 9 addition
sample
probe 6 pressure compensation
7 leachate circulation
BB, 0-6 m 1 8 gas sampling
Waste
material 9 volumetric gas analysis
12 10 leachate irrigation
2 11 perforated plate
11 12 Redox- and pH-measurement
13 gas washing bottles (acidic)
4 3 optional
2.3 Effect of the aeration of the waste samples on the leachate quality
The leachate analysis concordantly indicate a notably accelerated biodegradation of organic
waste compounds due to the aeration. This can be shown by a fast and significant decrease of the
parameters TOC, COD and BOD5. Additionally, the concentrations of the inorganic nitrogen
compounds are noticeably reduced under the influence of aeration as well.
100
leachate concentration [mg/l]
10
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700
LSR-operation time [d]
Figure 2. Trend of leachate nitrogen concentrations from LSR-experiments under eluted and
aerated (average of six LSR) resp. anaerobic conditions (average of two LSR);
Leachate exchange rate: 2000 ml/14 days
1000
100
limit value for direct discharge according to
leachate concentration[mg/l]
st
German waste water regulation, 51 appendix [Ntotal = 70 mg/l]
10
Figure 3. Trend of leachate nitrogen concentrations from LSR-experiments under aerated (LSR
Kuh-9) resp. anaerobic conditions (LSR Kuh-10)
In order to find out the possible potential for ammonia-stripping from aerated landfill material,
the LSR Kuh-11 was operated under aerobic conditions and the gas phase was lead through two
acidic scrubbers (gas-washing bottles). The Ntotal-concentrations in the gas-washing bottles was
analysed daily and accounted for NH3-N as the main soluble nitrogen component. Figure 1
shows the principle set up for the LSR-Kuh-11 experiment. In figure 4 the trends for the Ntotal –
concentration in the leachate as well as in the gas phase and the ammonium concentrations are
presented.
600 36
start of aeration
NH4-N (LSR leachate)
TN (LSR leachate)
500 N-discharge via gas phase 30
(90 days, maximum): 1070 mg TN (LSR gas phase)
300 18
200 12
100 6
0 0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200
LSR-operation time [d]
Figure 4. Comparison of the nitrogen discharge via the gas- and leachate phase, calculated on the
basis of the Ntotal concentration in the leachate and in the gas-washing bottles, in the
course of the LSR Kuh-11 experiment (initially anaerobic conditions; aeration after 2
weeks of operation)
From figure 4 it becomes evident, that ammonia is mainly stripped out during the first aeration
phase. In this period the pH-values increased to 7.4, therefore enabling a slight shift of the
ammonium / ammonia equilibrium towards NH3. However, as the pH-value in the later
experiment declined, the NH4+/NH3-equilibrium shifted almost completely to the non volatile
NH4+-ions, thus resulting in decreased N-discharge rates. In total, an amount of approx. 50% of
the total nitrogen removal from the leachate could be detected in the gas phase.
0,0 2,1 4,3 6,8 9,0 11,2 15,0 17,3 19,4 22,9
120
main period of reduction for organic leachate concentrations
under aerated conditions
(approx. 5 weeks of LSR-operation = 2,2 a landfill operation)
100
relative reduction of organic leachate pollution
Reihe4
40
20
0
0,13 0,26 0,39 0,52 0,66 0,79 0,92 1,05 1,18 1,31
Water / Solid - ratio [l/kg DM]
Figure 5.Relative reduction of TOC- and BOD5 concentrations under aerated/eluted conditions
based on the reduction under anaerobic/eluted conditions as well as calculation of the
real landfill operation time
Under alkaline milieu conditions, metal hydroxides -less stable than the sulfides- are formed
(Formula 2).
In the course of the LSR-experiments, neutral to slightly alkaline pH-values were found for both,
the aerated / eluted as well as the anaerobic / eluted LSR. However, after starting the aeration,
the redox-potential increases significantly into the positive range of 50 to 100 mV. The leachate
analysis show a steep increase of the sulfate concentration, accompanied by significantly
increased metal concentrations (mainly copper, cadmium and lead concentrations raise whereas
nickel and chromium show only a slightly increase). Figure 6 shows the comparison of the
sulfate concentrations and the cumulative heavy metal discharge via the leachate phase as an
average for six aerated / eluted and two anaerobic / eluted LSR. The cumulative metals load
covers the analysed elements Cr, Ni, Cu, Cd and Pb.
From figure 6 it becomes evident, that particularly in the beginning of the aeration period
metals are released via the leachate. Later, showing a clear accordance with the declining sulfate
concentrations, the mobilization tendency becomes less intensive. After 360 days of LSR-
operation the sampling / leachate exchange intervals were extended significantly. Accordingly
the sulfate concentrations increase, but at that time the metal mobilization is comparatively
limited. One possible explanation might be, that the metals were more effective bind to organic
components, carbonates and hydroxides due to the longer retention times. Thus, in accordance
with the remaining oxidizing milieu conditions (positive Eh-values), SO42- is produced without
an accordant metal release.
1 0 0 ,0
1200
cumulative heavy metal discharge [mg * 10²]
leachate concentration [mg/l] resp.
5 0 ,0
900
Eh-value [mV]
0 ,0
600
-5 0 ,0
300
-1 0 0 ,0
e x te n s io n o f th e s a m p lin g in te rv a ls ,
th e re fo re re d u c e d d ilu tio n e ffe c ts
0 -1 5 0 ,0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700
s ta rt o f a e ra tio n
L S R -o p e ra tio n tim e [d ]
30
4 VS
20 anaerobic degredation under intensively process water
additional influence of the TN
circulation / -exchange (flushing effect) 5
accelerated aerobic degredation
[mgO2/gDM] / [%DM]
15
13,33
9,73 21 %
10 8,93
7,38
6,93
4,92 23 %
5
Figure 7. Comparison of the biological activity and chemical-physical parameters before and
after treatment in LSR (ROT-1: anaerobic/eluted; ROT-2: aerated/eluted; period:
1300 d)
The comparison of the waste characteristics before and after the treatment demonstrate the wide
potential of the applied treatment methods towards a significantly biological stabilisation of the
waste material. Whereas under anaerobic conditions mainly the biological activity (measured as
respiration activity over a period of 4 resp. 21 days) can be reduced to a high extend, the
parameters TOCsolid, VS and TKN are reduced only by 45, 27 and 7% respectively. However,
under changing milieu conditions in the course of aeration, a further decrease of the parameters
by 19 to 23% can be achieved. The increased reduction in the organic (carbon) content under
aerated conditions show, that particular hardly degradable substances are metabolized by the
aerobic microorganisms that might remain unchanged or become degraded extremely slowly
under anaerobic milieu conditions. Consequently, the residual emissions respecting gas
formation and leachate pollution from aerobic stabilized waste material are further reduced in
comparison to the “anaerobic” material, as demonstrated by the LSR experiments.
3 CONCLUSIONS
The emission behaviour of landfilled waste material can be altered significantly by applying
aeration, as demonstrated in comprehensive long term investigations in LSR. In comparison with
the initial anaerobic conditions, the changing to aerobic degradation processes lead to an
acceleration of the biological metabolism and therefore reduce the organic load in the leachate.
Nitrogen compounds in the leachate are reduced to a wide extend under aerobic conditions, due
to nitrification / de-nitrification processes as well as ammonia stripping via the gas phase. In this
regard, the LSR-experiments show NH3-discharge ratios up to 50% (in relation to the total N-
reduction), depending on the actual pH- and temperature values. Metals, mainly bound in stable
metal-sulfide-complexes under reducing milieu conditions, are partly mobilized if aeration is
applied. This counts particularly for the first aeration phases. However, in the presence of
organic matter (e.g. humic substances, formed under aerobic milieu conditions), carbonates or
hydroxides, the metals might partly be absorbed again, thus remaining in the waste matrix.
Hardly degradable organic substances, persistent against anaerobic degradation, can be
aerobically converted in comparative short time periods, thus reducing the long term emission
potential of the waste material significantly. After an intensive aeration measure the remaining
organic (carbon) substances can be stated as widely inert, respecting residual gas formation as
well as leachate pollution.
4 REFERENCES