Professional Documents
Culture Documents
60
Infrared absorption frequencies from 4000 to 400 cm.-1 are reported for bissalicylaldehydeethylenediimine and its Cu(II),
Ni(II), VO(II) and Co(II) chelates. Frequencies are assigned in most cases to bond or group vibrations, and the change of
spectra which accompanies coordination with a metal ion is discussed in connection with the structural change which occurs.
The spectral changes of inactive, active and oxygenated samples of the Co(II) chelate are discussed. The following bands
are tentatively assigned to the metal specific vibrations: a band at 1298 cm.-1 of the vanadyl chelate to V-0 stretching,
four bands in the 636-500 cm.-1 region of the metal chelates to metal-ligand bonds, and a band at 565 cm.-1 of oxygenated
Co(II) chelates to Co-0 stretching.
As an extension of the study previously reported3 imine and its Ni(II) and Cu(II) chelates were kindly pre-
on the spectra of bisacetylacetoneethylenediimine pared by Miss H. Hyytiainen of this Laboratory according
to the method described by Preiffer.10 The corresponding
chelates as models of the oxygen carrying chelate vanadyl chelate was prepared according to Bielig and
compounds, it was decided to carry out a similar Bayer.11 The inactive form of the Co(II) chelate was first
study on bissalicylaldehydeethylenediimine- prepared from ethylenediamine, salicylaldehyde and co-
baltons acetate in ethanol according to the procedure de-
Co(II), which is known to be an oxygen carrier.
See https://pubs.acs.org/sharingguidelines for options on how to legitimately share published articles.
Table I
Infrared Absorption Spectra or Bisalicylaldehydeethylenediimine and its Metal Chelate Compounds
Ligand Metal chelates Assignments
Ni(II) Cu(II) VO(II) Co(II) Active
Inactive Active oxygenated
Table I (Continued)
Ligand Metal chelates Assignments
Ni(II) Cu(II) VO(II) Co(IT) Active
Inactive Active oxygenated
550vw 547vw 552vw 550vw 548vw 1
Metal chelate ring
520vw 500m 510vw 514w 515w /
486m 486vw 467m 475m 473w 480w
473m 468w 463m 461m 465w 463m 465m
433w 430w 440w 433vw
418vw 418vw 418vw 412w 418vw 422w 413w
407w
°
Shoulder. 1
H bonded out-of-plane OH bonding.
the metal chelates. No such an absorption band chelates of Cu(II), Ni(II) and Co(II), both rings
was found, but a broad band of intermediate in- can be fixed in the same plane without steric
tensity appeared at 2600 cm.-1. Since no corre- hindrance by the central metal, which provides
sponding band can be observed in the absorption square planar coordination bonds to the tetra-
spectra of metal chelates, this broad absorption is dentate ligand, as is shown in the formula IV.
assigned to O-H stretching vibration. It is known In the vanadyl chelate, similar coplanarity of the
that strong hydrogen bonding causes a shift of the metal chelate is also necessary, with the exception
O-H stretching band at the lower frequency and of the oxygen-vanadium bond which is normal to
causes the broadening of the band.12 This is es- the plane of the molecule, as will be discussed later.
pecially true if the hydrogen bonding takes place The coplanarity of metal chelates of bissalicyl-
as part of a resonating ring system.13 aldehydeethylenediimine is further supported by
CH2CH: the fact that the cobalt (II) chelate was found to be
coplanar through X-ray study.7
HC= N=CH Several absorption bands between 2700 and 3200
cm.-1, which appear at the same position for both
ligand and metal chelates, can be assigned to C-H
stretching vibrations of CH, CH2 and aromatic CH
CH2CH2 bonds.
/ \ No significant absorption can be found either in
HC—N- -- -CH
ligand or in the metal chelates below this region
H \ down to 1650 cm.-1, and the main absorption
bands appear from 1650 to 450 cm.-1, the lower fre-
z^7 II Z >+
quency limit of potassium bromide optics. The
absorption bands in this region which are listed in
CH2CH2 Table I, can be classified roughly into three groups:
-Z \- the absorption bands which are common to both
HC—N N- -CH
ligand and the metal chelates, the absorption bands
which are characteristic of the ligand, and the ab-
<Z>0^ III
CH2CH2
> <3 sorption bands which are characteristic of the metal
chelates.
As is clear from the formulas of the ligand I and
HC=N/ \= of the metal chelates IV, absorptions resulting
from the aromatic rings can be expected for all
compounds. Three bands of very strong intensity
in the ligand at 1633, 1612 and 1579 cm.-1, and the
corresponding bands in the metal chelates with
If one considers the resonance contributions of the the exception of Ni and Co chelates (for which the
polar structures II and III, it would be reasonable first two bands are too close to be resolved), are as-
to expect strong hydrogen bonding in the ligand, signed to the C=C stretching vibration of phenyl
and the assignment of the broad band at 2600 cm.-1 rings. The last band at 1579 cm.-1, which shifts
to the hydrogen bonded O-H stretching vibration to slightly higher frequency by metal chelation,
therefore seems reasonable. is probably due to the vibration of phenyl rings
Because of the resonance in the hydrogen- conjugated with carbon-nitrogen double bonds.
bonded ring systems, it is necessary that each six- Another phenyl absorption band should occur near
membered ring including the replaceable hydrogen the 1500 cm.-1 region, and a very strong band of the
be planar and coplanar to the phenyl ring to which ligand at 1499 cm.-1 can be assigned to this ab-
this ring system is fused. However, the two bi- sorption. However, no corresponding band can be
cyclic ring systems cannot be in the same plane be- found in the metal chelates. Since the intensity
cause of steric hindrance and the electrostatic re- of 1500 cm.-1 absorption band of the phenyl ring
pulsions of N. .H-0 groups. These considera-
. .
was reported to fluctuate very widely,14 the cor-
tions are analogous to those previously reported responding band of metal chelates may be too
for bisacetylacetoneethylenediimine.3 In the weak to be observed.
(12) L. J. Bellamy, “The Infrared Spectra of Complex Molecules,” Several additional bands in the lower frequency
John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, N. Y., 1954, p. 8G.
(13) R. S. Rasmussen, D. D. Tunnicliff and R. R. Brattain, J, Am.
region also may be assigned to the phenyl ring
Chem. Soc., 71, 1008, 1073 (1949). (14) Reference 12, p, 02.
Sept., 1956 Infrared Studies on Synthetic Oxygen Carriers 1273
vibrations. Two absorptions of intermediate in- vibration of the hydrogen-bonded ring system of
tensity at 1248 cm.-1 and at 1113 cm.-1 in the the ligand. The shift to the lower frequencies in
ligand, and the corresponding bands in the metal the metal chelates can be explained by the in-
chelates, are assigned to o-disubstituted phenyl creased mass of metal linked to oxygen as well as
rings. Similarly two bands at 1020 and 980 cm.-1 to possible weakening of C-0 linkage. It is in-
in the ligand and the corresponding bands in the teresting to note that the increasing order of shift
metal chelates are assigned to the same grouping. from the original position follows the order of in-
One more band in this region at 1050 cm.-1, which creasing mass of the metal, i.e., V, Co, Ni and Cu,
is too weak to be observed in the ligand and Ni and parallels the order of decreasing basicity for
chelate, is perhaps due to o-disubstituted phenyl the metals Co, Ni and Cu. Although there are
rings. no data on stability constants of these metal che-
The o-disubstituted aromatic ring is also known lates, Pfeiffer16 found the relative stabilities of
to give rise to absorptions corresponding to C-H some metal chelates of this ligand to follow
out-of-the-plane deformation vibrations. The very a order of Cu > Ni > Zn > Mg. In general, the
strong bands of the ligand at 755, 749 and probably stabilities of metal chelate compounds has been
at 741 cm.-1, and the analogous two or three bands known to follow the general order Cu > Ni > Co.16
of the metal chelates can be assigned to this mode Therefore, if one assumes the shift of the C-0 ab-
of vibration. sorption band to follow the order of stabilities of
In the double bond region, there is an inter- the metal chelates, it can be seen that the strength-
mediate-intensity band common to all compounds ening of the metal-oxygen bonding will be accom-
which appears at 1526 cm.-1 for the ligand and is panied by a decrease in C-0 bond strength.
shifted to slightly higher frequency with increasing Several absorption bands were found to be
intensity for the metal chelates. The absorption characteristic of the metal chelates. It is to be
due to non-conjugated C=N stretching vibration expected that there would be a change in the
is usually found in the region of 1690-1640 cm.-1, spectra as the result of the influence of coordina-
and it is known to shift to the lower frequency with tion on the nature of the ligand bonds not directly
conjugation. The difference of about 100 cm.-1 attached to the metal, as well as some additional
cannot be considered as merely a conjugation effect, bands arising from the metal-ligand vibrations.
however, in view of the wide differences in bond These metal-ligand absorptions should appear in
strength and charge distribution between aro- the lower frequency region as was found in the case
matic rings and the H-bonded ligand rings and of bisacetylacetoneethylenediimine-metal che-
metal-chelate rings being considered here. The lates,3 for which three metal-specific absorptions
hydrogen-bonded ring systems of the compounds were observed in the region between 668 and
under investigation are greatly stabilized by con- 480 cm.-1. Thus two weak absorption bands of
jugation and the situation would thus be inter- the metal chelates of bissalicylaldehydeethylene-
mediate between simple conjugation and that diimine at 636-626 cm.-1 and 593-598 cm.-1 are
which exists in aromatic ring systems. Therefore assigned to the metal-specific vibrations. Two
the 1526 cm.-1 band is tentatively assigned to the additional absorptions at 547-552 cm.-1 and at
absorption originating from C=N stretching vibra- 520-500 cm.-1, which are usually very weak, are
tion of the conjugated ring system. also assigned to metal-donor linkages. Since,
Next to the double bond region, a band of strong however, there are no apparent relationships be-
or intermediate intensity which is fairly stable in tween the shift of metal-specific absorptions and
position from the ligand to the metal chelates, is the kind of metals, these bands must result from
found in the region of 1461-1472 cm.-1. This rather complicated modes of vibration and should
band is assigned to the C-H deformation vibration be assigned to the vibrations of the central metal
of the ethylene bridge. chelate rings rather than to specific metal-ligand
A strong ligand band at 1282 cm.-1, having no bonds.
Some irregularities are found in the metal-
corresponding bands in the metal chelates, is as-
signed to hydrogen-bonded O-H in-plane bending specific absorptions of the vanadyl chelate. An
vibration. This assignment is supported by disap- absorption at 628 cm.-1 is unusually strong and
two bands at lower frequencies are missing, and
pearance of the band when the hydroxyl hydrogen
is replaced by a metal, and by the fact that similar are probably too weak to be observed. The ir-
O-H absorptions were observed in the region of regularities in the absorption spectra of vanadyl
1290-1280 cm.-1 for bisacetylacetone-ethylene- chelate are found not only in the metal-specific ab-
diimine and related compounds.3 An additional sorptions, but also in the higher frequency regions.
band of strong intensity at 855 cm.-1 is similarly An ordinarily medium or weak metal chelate ab-
assigned to the hydrogen bonded out-of-the-plane sorption at 1384-1391 cm.-1 becomes very strong
O-H bending vibration, since the corresponding in the vanadyl chelate. A similar irregularity is
band is observed in 850-800 cm.-1 region for observed in the absorption band at 1313-1298
cm.-1. This band is of intermediate intensity but
bisacetylacetoneethylenediimine and related com- becomes strong in the vanadyl chelate, and has the
pounds.3
lowest frequency of this group of bands. This
Another characteristic absorption of intermediate
absorption band, however, may be the result of the
intensity is found at 1105 cm.-1 in the ligand, with
a corresponding band of the metal chelates in the (15) P. Pfeiffer, H. Thielert and H. Glaser, J prakt. Chem., 152, 145
(1939).
lower frequency region of 1090-1085 cm.-1. This (16) D. P, Mellon and L. Maley, Nature, 159, 370 (1947); 161, 430
absorption is assigned to the C-0 stretching (1948).
1274 Keihei Ueno and Arthur E. Martell Vol. 60
superposition of two bands, a strong absorption Two samples of active oxygen carriers prepared
band at 1298 cm.-1, and a band of intermediate by different methods were also compared. When
intensity which corresponds to the bands observed the spectra of bissalicylaldehydeethylenediimine-
for the other metal chelates. It is interesting to Co(II) prepared from the pyridinate and that of
note that a similar band, observed in the vanadyl the active form prepared from the chloroformate
chelates of tetraphenylporphine at 1337 cm.-1, were compared, they were found to be identical.
was assigned to the V-0 stretching vibration.17 A rather interesting finding is the difference of
The central metal ion in the vanadyl chelates is spectra of active and inactive forms in the 1650-
known to have five coordinate bonds,18 four to the 1600 cm.-1 region. Two absorption bands of the
tetradentate ligand and one to the oxygen. Since inactive sample, with maxima at 1628 and 1608
the ligand has a planar structure, it is reasonable to cm.-1, changed into single band in the active sample
assume that the direction of the vanadium-oxygen with a maximum at 1607 cm.-1, with the first
bond is normal to the plane of the ligand molecule, band submerged as a shoulder at around 1625
an arrangement which is shown schematically in cm.-1. However, in the case of bissalicylaldehyde-
Fig. 1. Since the steric configuration around van- 1,2-propylenediimine-Co (II), which is a homolog
of the ethylenediamine derivative, and which has
been known to be deficient of the oxygen carrying
property, the spectra of the metal chelate synthe-
sized directly from the components by the same
method, and the spectra of sample prepared by
heating the pyridinate in vacuo, are completely iden-
tical, with two absorption bands in the 1650-1600
Fig. 1.—Steric configuration of bissalicylaldehyde-ethylene- cm.-1 region. Thus the additional methyl group
diimino-VO(IV). attached to the ethylenediamine carbon bridge
prevents the chelate molecules from forming the
adium is somewhat similar to that of the tetra- crystal lattice arrangement which is favorable for
phenylporphine vanadyl chelate,17 the absorption oxygenation. The difference in the absorption
band of the vanadyl chelate at 1298 cm.-1 can spectra of active and inactive chelates must there-
reasonably be assigned to V-0 stretching vibra- fore be due to a difference in crystal structure.
tion. Taking this frequency value for this mode This conclusion is further strengthened by com-
of vibration, one calculates the stretching force parison of the absorption spectra in chloroform
constant of this particular bond to be 12.0 X 105 solution. The spectra of both samples in 1650-
dyne/cm. This value is about the same as that 1600 cm.-1 region were found to be exactly the
of the C:0 stretching force constant (A;oo(ace- same, with a single maximum at 1605 cm.-1.
tone) =
12 X 106 dyne/cm.), and slightly lower Calvin7 also found polymorphism in the active and
than the value obtained for vanadyl tetraphenyl- inactive forms through X-ray studies.
porphine. 17 Remarkable changes in the absorption spectra
Changes in Infrared Absorption Spectra in the resulting from oxygenation of active sample are
Course of Reversible Oxygenation.—It has been illustrated in Fig. 2. These spectral changes may
shown already that not all crystalline forms be due to the difference in the crystal structure
of bissalicylaldehydeethylenediimine-Co(II) are before and after the oxygenation, as well as to the
capable of reversible oxygenation, and that only direct coordination of oxygen to cobalt and the
special forms which are prepared by certain chem- secondary influences of oxygenation on the other
ical process have well-developed oxygen carry- bonds in the ligand.
ing properties. Calvin and co-workers7 have at- It is noteworthy that the single band at 1607
tributed this property to the special arrangement cm.-1 with a shoulder at around 1625 cm.-1, found
of the metal chelate molecules in the crystal lattice. in the active sample, splits again into two bands
The absorption spectra of inactive samples at 1631 and 1604 cm.-1 upon oxygenation. In
synthesized directly from salicylaldehyde, ethylene- general, the spectra of oxygenated samples are
diamine and cobaltous acetate in ethanol, are found to resemble more the spectra of the inactive
different in some respects from the spectra of the chelates than those of the active unoxygenated
active form. The most remarkable changes, illus- forms.
trated in Fig. 2, were observed in the regions 1650- A few remarkable differences are observed in
1600 cm.-1, 1350-1250 cm.-1, 975-925 cm.-1, 650- the regions 1350-1250 cm.-1 and 650-550 cm.-1.
550 cm.-1 and 500-450 cm.-1. Since the active In the 1350-1250 cm.-1 region, a characteristic
and inactive samples have the same chemical com- band of the active sample at 1309 cm.-1 decreases
position, and since there should be no difference in in intensity on oxygenation, remaining as a weak
the structure of the chelate molecules, the differ- shoulder at the corresponding position and a new
ence of absorption spectra should be due to the band of intermediate intensity appears at 1274
different arrangements of molecules in the crystal- cm.-1. In the 650-550 cm.-1 region, an addi-
line lattice.19 tional band of weak intensity at 565 cm.-1 is ob-
(17) K. Ueno and A. E. Martell (to be published elsewhere). served in the oxygenated sample. Since the
(18) . M. Jones, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 76, 5995 (1954). bonding between oxygen and cobalt cannot be
(19) It is known that differences in crystal structure may some-
times result in rather striking differences in the infrared spectra of very strong, and since the oxygen molecule is con-
otherwise identical substances, cf. H. Gilman ‘Organic Chemistry,” sidered to bridge two cobalt atoms, the 565 cm.-1
Vol. 3, John Wiley and Sons, New York, N. Y., 1953, p. 139. band can reasonably be assigned to the stretching
Sept., 1956 The Crystal Structure of Li8Pb; 1275
Cm.-1.
1650 1600 1550 1350 1300 1250
—I-1-1-1- —I-1-1-1-1-
vibration of Co-O-O-Co linkages in the oxygen- cobalt(II) atom. As a result, the chloroform solu-
ated crystals. tion of the oxygenated form would be expected
When the oxygenated sample was dissolved in to have spectra identical to those of inactive or
chloroform, the evolution of oxygen was observed, active samples.
and the resulting solution gave exactly the same The fact that the spectrum of the deoxygenated
spectra as those of inactive or active samples. The sample, which was prepared by heating the oxy-
dissolution of an oxygenated sample results in the genated sample in vacuum, was identical to that
breakdown of the crystal lattice and preferential of the active sample, indicates the reversibility of
coordination of the chloroform molecule to the the oxygenation process.
The compound LigPbg has been characterized by single crystal and powder X-ray diffraction data. It is monoclinic,
space group C2/m, with a = 8.240, b = 4.757, c = 11.03 A., 0 = 104° 25', and Z = 2. There is a body centered cubic
pseudocell with a = 3.364 A. and containing two atoms. The structure consists of ordered substitution in these sites in
such a way that one-third of the Pb atoms have 8 Li neighbors each and two-thirds have one Pb and 7 Li neighbors each.
and Li3Pb. Some preliminary diffraction data for found to be Li8Pb3 (Li/Pb 2.67) on the basis of
=
this phase along with a determination of the struc- the crystallographic investigations and also by
tures of LisPb and Li-Pb2 have already been pub- chemical analysis (Li/Pb 2.68 ± 0.01). It will
=
lished.2 Grube and Klaiber3 studied the phase be noted that the difference in compositions be-
(1) The work described in this paper was sponsored by the U. S· tween the stoichiometry we have determined and
Atomic Energy Commission.
(2) A. Zalkin and W. J. Ramsey, This Journal, 60, 234 (1956).
that given by Grube and Klaiber3 amounts to only
(3) G. Grube and H. Klaiber, Z. Electrochem., 40, 754 (1934). 0.013 mole fraction unit.