Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hydrometallurgy
j o u r n a l h o m e p a g e : w w w. e l s e v i e r. c o m / l o c a t e / h y d r o m e t
Comparative study of chelating ion exchange resins for the recovery of nickel and
cobalt from laterite leach tailings
Zaimawati Zainol a,⁎, Michael J. Nicol b
a
School of Materials and Mineral Resources Engineering, Engineering Campus, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 14300 Nibong Tebal, Penang, Malaysia
b
Parker Centre, Mineral Science, Murdoch University, South Street, Murdoch, WA 6150, Australia
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Commercially available chelating resins with the iminodiacetate functional group have been evaluated for their
Received 25 July 2008 suitability for the adsorption of nickel and other metal ions by a resin-in-pulp process from the tailings of a
Received in revised form 17 November 2008 pressure acid leach process for nickel laterites. The Amberlite IRC 748 and TP 207 MonoPlus resins were found
Accepted 17 November 2008
to be the most suitable in terms of loading capacity for nickel and kinetics of adsorption. The resin with the
Available online 3 December 2008
highest nominal capacity was observed to adsorb less nickel as a result of the adsorption of greater amounts of
Keywords:
the impurity ions. The equilibrium loading for nickel on the preferred resin was found to be similar from the
Nickel ammonium and protonated form of the resin although the kinetics of adsorption is greater when the resin is
Cobalt initially in the ammonium form. A study of the kinetics of the loading of nickel and cobalt from pulp has shown
Ion exchange resins that the rate can be described in terms of a first-order approach to equilibrium. The optimum pH for adsorption
Iminodiacetic acid was found to be in the range 4 to 5 as this pH is high enough to maximize the adsorption of nickel and cobalt
while preventing precipitation of nickel and cobalt as hydroxides from the pulp. A method for minimizing the
competition from more strongly loaded ions such as iron(III) and chromium(III) which are present in the pulp
was also developed in the initial laboratory phase of the study.
© 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
0304-386X/$ – see front matter © 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.hydromet.2008.11.005
284 Z. Zainol, M.J. Nicol / Hydrometallurgy 96 (2009) 283–287
2.1. Solutions
Analar grade nickel sulfate was used to prepare an aqueous the plant and contained approximately 0.5 g/l of soluble nickel at a
solution of 2.5 g/l nickel and the solution was adjusted to the desired pulp density of about 30–35% solids. The pulp was neutralized to pH 4
pH using dilute sodium hydroxide or sulfuric acid. This solution was with calcrete and oxidized by bubbling with air at 60 °C in order to
used to load the resins used in the elution testwork. precipitate iron. In addition, a small amount of hydrogen peroxide was
added to accelerate the precipitation of iron. The oversize solids were
2.2. Ion exchange resins removed from the pulp by screening at 250 µm in order to allow the
separation of slurry and loaded resin (N 600 µm) by wet screening
The following four types of commercial iminodiacetic chelating prior to elution.
resins were selected for comparison
2.4. Adsorption
1. Amberlite IRC 748 (Rohm and Haas)
2. Lewatit TP 207 (Lanxess) The adsorption behaviour of nickel, cobalt and several impurity
3. Lewatit TP 208 (Lanxess) ions were examined using a batch equilibration technique. A mea-
4. Purolite S 930 (Purolite) sured amount of the prepared feed slurry was allowed to equilibrate
5. Lewatit TP 207 Monoplus (Lanxess) for 24 h with a known amount of resin. After equilibration, resin and
slurry were separated by wet screening. The loaded resin was then
The important physical and chemical properties of the first four washed with distilled water and eluted with 250 ml 1 M sulphuric acid
resins are presented in Table 1. All of the resin samples were obtained using a bottle roll for 2 h. The concentration of metals remaining in the
from the manufacturers in the sodium form. The resins were washed slurry and the eluate from elution were analysed by ICP or Atomic
with distilled water and converted to the hydrogen form by passing 5 Absorption Spectrophotometry.
bed volumes of 1 M sulphuric acid through the resin in a column. The
samples were then washed with distilled water to neutrality and left 2.5. Kinetics of loading
to dry in the open air until the beads became free rolling. These resins
were screened and the +600 µm–1 mm fractions were used for The rate of loading of nickel onto a selected resin was carried out in
evaluation. The Lewatit TP 207 MonoPlus resin is produced through a a batch experiment as explained in section 2.4. At various time
continuous polymerization process which results in a monodispersed intervals, a sample of 10 ml of the slurry was taken using a syringe, the
size distribution (average 600 µm) compared to the conventional resin separated from the sample slurry by screening and returned to
heterodispersed resins produced from conventional batch processes. the original slurry. The pulp samples were filtered and the solutions
This resin only became available after the evaluation tests for the other analysed. After 4 h, the loaded resin was separated from the slurry,
resins were completed and therefore a limited amount of testwork washed and eluted. The concentrations of the metals remaining in the
was carried out on this material. It was used as supplied without slurry and in the eluate were analysed.
screening and treated as above.
2.6. Elution profiles
2.3. Preparation of pulp
The elution profiles of the resins were determined using a glass
The pulp sample supplied by a local company was the underflow column with a bed volume (BV) of 100 ml. The eluant which consisted
from the last stage of the counter-current decantation (CCD) circuit on of a 1 M sulphuric acid solution was pumped upflow through the
Table 1
Physical and chemical properties of the resins studied
Table 3 Table 5
Pulp properties Concentrations of metal ions (mg/l) in solution during loading
Table 4
Analysis of pulp during neutralization and oxidation
Table 6
Pseudo-equilibrium loading and kinetic parameters
iron and chromium is still very low whilst manganese and aluminium
are not strongly adsorbed by the resin. As a result of this, it is believed
Fig. 1. Kinetics of the loading of nickel onto various resins in the protonated form. IRC
that the nickel and cobalt lost to the precipitate (Table 4) in the
748 (◊), TP 207 (Δ), TP 208 (+), S 930 ( ).
neutralization stage is dissolved and recovered back by the resin
during loading when the resin is used in the protonated form.
pH to about 4.7–4.8 as this will help to keep the pH of the pulp in the The use of the resin in the ammonium form has no effect on the pH
RIP extraction tanks relatively high for selective loading of nickel and and thus no re-dissolution of metal ions is observed on loading.
cobalt onto the resin as previously discussed. A higher pH should be
avoided as this will precipitate additional valuable nickel and cobalt 3.3. Kinetics of adsorption
from the pulp.
The process of adsorption can be considered as initially involving
3.2. Metal loading behavior mass transport of nickel ions from the bulk solution to the surface of
the ion exchange bead. This is followed by diffusion of the adsorbed
As stated above, all the resins were supplied in the protonated nickel into the bulk of the resin bead as shown below (Fleming and
form. For comparison, all four samples were converted to the Nicol, 1980).
ammonium form by regeneration with 3 M ammonia solution and Resin Surface Solution
their performance is compare to the corresponding resin in the
kr K ks
hydrogen form. In each case, 1 l of the pulp which was neutralized to ½Nir p ½Nisr X ½Niss p ½Nis
pH 4.65 was contacted with 15 ml of each resin. Thus for each type of
resin, two tests were performed using resin samples which were in The subscript s and r refer to the solution and resin phase re-
either the protonated or the ammonium form. spectively and the superscript s refers to concentrations at the surface
It could be expected that the metal ion concentrations in solution of the resin bead. ks and kr are the mass transfer coefficients in the
would decrease with time as the loading on the resin takes place. This solution and resin phase respectively and K is the equilibrium con-
is however not the case for manganese, aluminium, iron and stant for the adsorption reaction which is assumed to be rapid relative
chromium when the resin used is in the hydrogen form as it was to mass transport.
observed that there is a small increase in the concentration of these If it is assumed that the equilibrium between the nickel on the
ions in solution with time. This is shown in the pulp solution analysis resin and that in the solution at the surface can be described by a
given in Table 5 and is caused by the re-dissolution of the precipitated simple linear isotherm,
metals by the protons released during loading of the resin.
The effect of the dissolution of these impurities however, it not a ½Nisr = K ½Niss ð3Þ
significant problem for the loading of nickel as the concentration of
the rate of loading of nickel on the resin in a batch adsorption can be
expressed as a first-order approach to equilibrium.
Fig. 2. Kinetics of the loading of nickel onto various resins in the ammonium form. IRC
748 (◊), TP 207 ( ), TP 208 (+), S 930 (Δ). Fig. 3. Kinetics of elution of nickel. IRC 748 ( ), TP 207 ( ), TP 208 ( ), S 930 ( ).
Z. Zainol, M.J. Nicol / Hydrometallurgy 96 (2009) 283–287 287
4. Conclusions
The presence of competitive ions in the pulp such as iron (II), iron (III),
chromium (III) and aluminium (III) which are strongly adsorbed by the
iminodiacetate resins requires that these metals be removed from the
pulp before loading. It was found that neutralization and oxidation is not
Fig. 4. Elution profile for nickel. IRC 748 ( ), TP 207 ( ), TP 208 ( ), S 930 ( ). only an effective (N90% impurities precipitated) but also an economical
way to remove these impurities as it only requires inexpensive reagents
such as lime or limestone. Although all the five resins studied have the
Plots of the kinetic data in Table 5 on this basis are shown in Figs. 1 same functional group (iminodiacetic acid), their performance, particu-
and 2 for the loading of nickel from which the first-order rate constant larly in regard to the kinetics of loading are not identical. The observed
k can be obtained. differences are possibly caused by variations in the synthesis procedure
The rate constants for each of the resins are compared in Table 6. The which results in variations in the structure of the matrix, degree of
loading after 4 h of some of the metals adsorbed by the resins is also crosslinking, density of functional groups, proportion of iminodiacetate
given in the same Table. The results show that under the conditions of groups and also the particle size. For all the heterodispersed resin
these tests, all the resin samples produced similar loadings of nickel with samples, it was found that the ammonium form of the resin exhibited
somewhat higher loading with the MonoPlus resin and lower loading greater kinetics of adsorption but exhibited similar equilibrium loading
with TP 208 in the protonated form. The equilibrium loading of nickel to the resin in the protonated form. The MonoPlus resin proved to be
onto the resins in the ammonium form is not significantly greater than superior to the conventional heterodispersed types of resins in terms of
that measured in the protonated form. However, from the kinetic point loading capacity for nickel and also the kinetics of adsorption. This,
of view, the calculated rate constants show that the resins in the am- coupled to its uniform bead size (a larger bead size is also now available)
monium form adsorb nickel at a higher rate than the resin in the makes this resin a preferred choice for use in a RIP application.
hydrogen form while the TP 207 MonoPlus and IRC 748 resins exhibited
the greatest rates of loading under these conditions. Acknowledgements
None of the resins loaded significant quantities of aluminium, iron,
chromium or copper. Manganese however appeared to load more The authors gratefully acknowledge financial support by the A J
strongly on the TP 207 and TP 208 resin samples. The TP 208 resin Parker Cooperative Research Center for Hydrometallurgy and Uni-
appeared to show the lowest adsorption (after 4 h) and the poorest versiti Sains Malaysia.
kinetics despite having the highest quoted capacity (Table 5) of all the
resin samples. References
Eger, C., Anspach, W.M., Marinsky, J.A., 1968. Coordination behavior of cobalt, nickel,
3.4. Elution copper, and zinc in a chelating ion-exchange resin. I. J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. 30 (7),
1899–1909.
The elution testwork was based only on the elution of nickel in the Fleming, C.A., Nicol, M.J., 1980. A comparative study of kinetic models for the extraction
of uranium by strong-base anion-exchange resins. J. S. Afr. Inst. Min. Metall. 80 (2),
absence of other loaded metal ions. All of the resins initially in the 89–99.
protonated form were loaded with nickel from a synthetic solution at Grimshaw, R.W., Harland, C.E., 1981. Ion Exchange: Introduction to Theory and Practice,
pH 4. The resins were subsequently eluted in a column using 1 M 137 pp.
Luo, W., Feng, Q., Ou, L., Zhang, G., Lu, Y., in press. Fast dissolution of nickel from a lizardite-
sulphuric acid at a flowrate of 4 bed volumes (BV)/h. The results are rich saprolitic laterite by sulphuric acid at atmospheric pressure. Hydrometallurgy.
shown in Figs. 3 and 4. Mayze, R., 2001. Nickel laterite processing in Western Australia. Copper, Cobalt, Nickel
It is apparent from Fig. 3 that the IRC 748 resin exhibited the fastest Zinc Recovery, Conf.: F1–F12.
Moore, B.W., 2000. Separation of rare-earth metals by ion exchange in iminodiacetic
elution rate whilst the performance of the other three resins was
resin column followed by elution, U.S. (USA). Us, 10 pp., Cont.-in-part of U.S. Ser.
roughly the same but lower than that of IRC 748. The TP 208 resin No. 686,263, abandoned.
which has the greatest nominal capacity revealed the poorest elution Moskalyk, R.R., Alfantazi, A.M., 2002. Nickel laterite processing and electrowinning
kinetics. These results are consistent with the relative loading rates of practice. Miner. Eng. 15 (8), 593–605.
Priya, P.G., Basha, C.A., Ramamurthi, V. and Begum, S.N., in press. Recovery and reuse of
the resins. The elution profiles show that 4 bed volumes are sufficient Ni(II) from rinsewater of electroplating industries. Journal of Hazardous Materials.
for the elution of the IRC 748 resin while in excess of 6 bed volumes of Sziden, R.D., Fritz, J.S., 1961. Separation of metal ions on chelating resin. U.S. At. Energy
1 M sulphuric acid is not sufficient to elute all the nickel from the Comm. IS-340: 28 pp.