Professional Documents
Culture Documents
industry applications
Abstract
Surfactants are multipurpose active compounds and are ubiquitously present in detergents. Detergent demand spiked
due to the current COVID-19 pandemic, further alerting to the need to replace petrochemical synthetic surfactants
with natural and renewable surfactants to mitigate further environmental damage. The neem tree (Azadirachta indica A.
Juss) is a fast-growing tree that provides a multitude of commodities, namely neem oil. Neem oil possesses insecticidal
and medicinal activity. This work reports the extraction and characterization of a surfactant from neem oil (SNO),
displaying a yield of approximately 100%. SNO exhibited suitable detergent characteristics with a high potential to be
used as a cleansing agent for textile applications, such as high pH value (10.1), suitable foaming of 1.5 cm and a critical
micelle concentration of nearly 0.12 g mL1. In addition, SNO showed a moderate bactericidal activity against Escherichia
coli and bacteriostatic activity against Staphylococcus aureus, both common nosocomial pathogens. Therefore, SNO has a
good potential to be used in medical textile applications due to its detergent and bactericidal properties. Finally, an
economical overview of the SNO production process was assessed, underscoring its viability.
Keywords
Surfactant, neem oil, bactericidal, saponification, Azadirachta indica
The staggering concentrations of petrochemical-based molecule hydrophilic polar groups and hydrophobic
plastic waste present in the environment represent over non-polar groups.2 The non-polar group, also named
5 billion metric tons.1 This massive plastic waste con- as tail, is composed of one or two alkyl chains com-
centration allied to it highly recalcitrant nature is caus- prising between 8 and 22 carbons.3 In particular, sur-
ing an increasing apprehension to a more informed factants’ hydrophobic tail may contain fluorine.
society that demands the development of novel prod-
ucts able to replace common plastic or petrochemical-
based reactants. These novel active substances must be 1
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Federal University of Rio
obtained from renewable resources that represent low Grande do Norte, Natal, Brazil
2
to non-environmental impact during their entire life Faculdade Natalense de Ensino e Cultura, Natal, Brasil
3
Department of Textile Engineering, Federal University of Rio Grande do
cycle. Moreover, the development of novel environ- Norte, Natal, Brazil
mentally friendly active substances must display an 4
Centre for Textile Science and Technology, University of Minho,
enhanced efficacy to be able to compete with low-cost Guimar~aes, Portugal
petrochemical-based substances. Surfactants are
Corresponding author:
unquestionably an active substance with an intensive Andrea Zille, 2C2T- Centro de Ciência e Tecnologia Têxtil, Universidade
and widespread use. Surfactants may be synthetic or do Minho, Campus de Azurem 4800-058 Guimar~aes, Portugal.
natural amphiphilic compounds, displaying the same Email: azille@2c2t.uminho.pt
2 Textile Research Journal 0(0)
These extremely hydrophobic fluorocarbon tails pro- In the biological systems the surfactants are to solve
mote the development of bulkier clusters, due to fluo- solubility problems and to work as emulsifiers, disper-
rine’s larger atomic size and stronger hydrophobicity.4 sants and surface tension modifiers, thus essentially
Surfactants’ polar section, or head, encompasses ionic playing the same role as the synthetic surfactants.
groups (anions or cations), and may have an ampho- There are a few reports in the literature describing
teric behavior, meaning that it may display an acid or the synthesis of surfactants from renewable sources.
alkaline property depending on the pH of the solution. These materials are the saponins, which are active sur-
The surfactant hydrophilic region promptly links to factants obtained from the pericarp of chestnuts, soy
water through hydrogen bonding, whereas the hydro- and chickpeas. These vegetable surfactants are tradi-
phobic tail stabilizes with lipids through van der Waals tionally used in India for textile washing, as shower
interactions.5 Due to these properties, surfactants are gel and as a popular medicine due to their capability
able to alter both surface tension and interfacial ten- to produce foam in water.12
sion between liquids, gases and solid–liquid surfaces Vegetable oils and essential oils, similarly to surfac-
(wetting systems).6 This behavior makes surfactants tants, also possess a non-polar group that is widely
excellent compounds to act as dispersion agents, deter- used in different industrial areas. Vegetable oils are a
gents, emulsifiers, oil recovery agents and foam- complex blend of volatile compounds and lipophilic
forming agents, among others.7,8 compounds.13,14 The oils may be classified as fixed
The use of synthetic surfactants has been increasing and essential. The fixed vegetable oils are composed
considerably since the beginning of the 20th century, of a complex mixture of lipid compounds and are com-
and presently is among the most produced synthetic monly obtained from seeds. Fixed oils are character-
chemicals worldwide. The estimated surfactant produc- ized by poor water solubility and non-volatility and are
tion is more than 12 thousand metric tons and has an usually susceptible to light and heat, whereas essential
estimated annual increase between 3 and 4%. Domestic oils are low-molecular-weight, lipophilic and volatile
and industrial applications result in significant compounds, mainly present in aromatic plants.15,16
amounts of waste discharge in soil, fresh water and Both fixed and essential oils have been widely used,
marine water environments. Due to the increasing and their application has been constantly increasing
demand of the detergent and cosmetic industry, the due to the current demand for natural products.
surfactant annual production will have a significant Therefore, large quantities of oils are produced world-
increase, particularly because of the present detergent wide for the manufacture of fragrances and cosmetics
demand due to the COVID-19 pandemic. These syn- and to supply health industries and the textile indus-
thetic surfactants are usually non-biodegradable and try.17 Neem oil is collected from Azadirachta indica (A.
produce a negative impact, not only in the environ- Juss), of the family Meliaceae. Despite its Asian origin,
ment, but also to human health, because surfactants this plant can be easily found in different regions; due
are responsible for the development of dermatitis, to its resilience it is able to withstand adverse soil and
respiratory problems and irritations, among other com- climate conditions. Moreover, A. indica has a rapid
plications. Therefore, recently, carbohydrates, amino growth of approximately 0.6 m year1 in height.18
acids and organic acids obtained from renewable sour- Neem oil is extracted from fruits and seed and widely
ces are being increasingly used as raw materials for the used as an insecticide due to the presence of azadirach-
production of surfactants.8–10 Surfactants of vegetable tin in its formulation.19,20 Neem oil obtained from the
origin, also known as biosurfactants, are renewable seeds of A. indica is described to contain at least 100
compounds that can be synthesized from a wide biologically active compounds.21 A. indica seeds com-
scope of renewable substrates and display an impres- prise 45% of a brownish oil, mainly composed of oleic
sive chemical diversity. This allows the development of acid (50–60%), palmitic acid (15–19%), stearic acid
tailored applications for specific areas from different (14–19%) and linoleic acid (8–16%), and it contains a
fields, such as petrochemical industry, food industry, spicy flavor and an unpleasant and persistent odor.22
cosmetics and pharmaceutical companies. Some nota- Several references describe the use of neem oil as soaps
ble advantages of biosurfactants in comparison with through the saponification; in particular, one study
synthetic compounds include biodegradability, bio- describes the production and characterization of
compatibility, low cost, similar efficiency using lower soaps obtained from different oils, including neem
surfactant concentration, higher stability toward pH, oil.23 The produced neem oil soap was characterized
temperature and ionic strength variations and higher as a hard soap with a pH of 9.75. Other researchers
foaming capability. These compounds can be produced also produced soap bars from the saponification of
through the biotransformation of petrol hydrocarbons neem oil and attained a yellowish soap with a pH of
or from renewable substrates, such as waste from veg- 10.4.23 Therefore, this work envisaged the production
etable processing, glycerol and oils, among others.11 and characterization of a surfactant from neem oil
Siqueira de Azevedo Sá et al. 3
Figure 1. Surfactant from neem oil (SNO) extraction process: (a) reflux procedure, (b) ethanol evaporation step and (c) SNO
agglomerates.
(SNO), which is a natural, environmentally friendly solution (30% w/v). During the saponification process
surfactant. The results collected depict the high appli- a reflux condenser was used to prevent the solvent loss
cability of the obtained surfactant in several contexts, and a heating mantle was used to maintain the reaction
such as domestic use and textile industry. Moreover, it at 100 C for 2 h. Afterwards the SNO sample was
can be used for sanitizing several hospital textiles, such placed on top of a heating plate at 70 C for approxi-
as bed sheets and privacy curtains, among other mately 8 h to evaporate completely the ethanol and was
applications. then exposed to sunlight for drying (Figure 1).
Bactericidal analysis The net benefit (R0 ) was estimated using equation (3)
The bactericidal properties of SNO were evaluated
R0 ¼ ðturnover TCÞ
through the disk diffusion susceptibility test as described
½ððturnover TCÞ CD IF Þ TR (3)
in the literature.26,27 The bacteria tested were from the
American Type Culture Collection (ATCC): Gram-
positive Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923 and where CD and TR are capital depreciation and tax
Gram-negative Escherichia coli ATCC 25922. rate, respectively.
Vancomycin (30 mg mL1) was used as positive control The net present value (NPV) was determined using
for S. aureus, and gentamycin (10 mg mL1) for E. coli. equation (4)
SNO (10% w/v) and the antibiotics were tested using a
cellulose disk of 6 mm. Each bacterium was incubated in R0
NPV ¼ IF þ (4)
tryptic soy broth for 12 h at 37 C at a shaking speed of ð1 þ iÞy
120 rpm. From these pre-inocula, each of the bacterium
concentrations was adjusted to approximately where i is the discount rate and y the time (in the cur-
1.0 107 CFU mL1 and inoculated in tryptic soy agar rent overview, 10 years were used).
at a mild temperature and plated in 90-mm Petri dishes. The return on investment (ROI) was estimated using
Once the tryptic soy agar was solidified, the discs were equation (5)
carefully placed on the inoculated medium under aseptic
conditions. The plates were incubated for at least 18 h at TI R0
37 C and the zone of inhibition (ZoI) was determined. ROI ¼ 100 (5)
TI
Economical overview
An industrial scale economical overview was per-
formed based on the production process described by
Results and discussion
this work (Supplemental material). In a short descrip-
tion, the industrial process would comprise four critical The neem oil physicochemical characteristics are repre-
pieces of equipment: a saponification reactor, a hot sented in Table 1. The density of the neem oil was
plate for ethanol evaporation, an industrial blender similar to the values reported in the literature (0.92
for SNO liquid preparation and an automatic bottle and 0.88 g mL1).28,29 The saponification value was
filling equipment for the preparation of the final prod- nearly 1.5-fold higher than the exhibited neem oil col-
uct. Several equipment units were considered to ensure lected from the seed, and close to the reported standard
redundancy. The economical overview reference value values.30,31 The refractive index value was also in agree-
was based on the purchase equipment cost (PCE). The ment with the standard values for the neem oil.31
direct facilities’ costs were used to estimate the fixed The estimated molecular weight of the neem oil was
capital (IF), encompassing construction costs (50% of 773.02 g mol–1. This value was estimated based on the
PCE), electrical installation (15% of PCE), piping saponification value, which provides an indirect weight
(20% of PCE), control and instrumentation (15% of value of the fatty acids obtained after the saponifica-
PCE), health and security costs (1.5% of PCE) and tion process, because these values are negatively
design and engineering costs (20% of PCE). The total correlated.
investment (TI) was calculated according to equation The obtained SNO presented a yellowish color sim-
(1) ilar to the neem oil; however, unlike the neem oil it
displayed a soft and pleasant smell (Figure 2). As
TI ¼ IF þ IC (1) observed in Figure 2(b), the SNO forms a clear
where IC corresponds to the contingency investment. Table 1. Neem oil chemical characterization
The calculation of the total cost (TC) was performed
using equation (2) Properties Values
dispersion in water, thus its hydrophilic–lipophilic bal- 0.1165 g mL1. Therefore, at concentrations above
ance is clearly higher than 10. 0.1165 g mL1, the neem oil surfactant will be arranged
The pH of the SNO aqueous solution was 10.1, in micellar structures, whereas in lower concentrations
which is within the pH range for soap of 8–10.5. it will be organized in its monomeric form.
Such a high pH is due to the incomplete alkaline hydro- For the foaming test, it is important that the surfac-
lysis during the saponification process. Despite the high tant displays a relevant reduction of the surface ten-
pH value, the SNO is not corrosive to the skin, in fact, sion, because the lower the surface tension, the
its alkalinity favors its detergent effect.23 Surfactants greater amount of foam can be produced with the
are characterized by their impact on the surface ten- same amount of agitation.8,15,32,33 Moreover, the foam-
sion, therefore the characterization of SNO effect on ing test is an important indicator of the detergent capa-
the surface tension of a liquid is of paramount impor- bility of the surfactant. However, some surfactants
tance. The surface tension of a liquid is determined by have a high detergency efficacy and produce negligible
the molecule’s energy at the interface. The energy amounts of foam. Foam stability is defined by the sur-
requirements for displacement of these molecules in factant capability preventing the water to quickly run
adsorption are directly correlated with the surfactant through the foam bubbles.32 The foam produced by the
efficacy. The critical micellar concentration was calcu- extracted surfactant was 1.5 cm, a value within the
lated through the estimation of the interception of the range of reported values in the literature (Figure 4).30
two equations of the surface tension (Figure 3). The Extracted surfactant SEM images are displayed in
determined concentration of neem oil surfactant was Figure 5. The SEM images denote the presence of white
Figure 2. Surfactant from neem oil: (a) in solid state and (b) diluted in distilled water (2% w/v).
Author contributions
All authors contributed to the writing of the manuscript. All
authors have approved the final version of the manuscript.
Acknowledgements
The authors acknowledge the Federal University of Rio
Grande do Norte for carrying out the analyzes through its
transversal laboratories
Conclusions References
1. Geyer R, Jambeck JR and Law KL. Production, use, and
SNO was a surfactant obtained with a yield of approx- fate of all plastics ever made. Sci Adv 2017; 3: e1700782.
imately 100%, through the saponification of neem oil 2. Barel AO, Paye M and Maibach HI. Handbook of cos-
using mild and cost-effective conditions. SNO physico- metic science and technology. CRC press, 2014.
chemical properties were characterized, in particular to 3. Sakamoto K, Lochhead R, Maibach H, et al. Cosmetic
observe its potential to be used as a fully natural deter- science and technology: theoretical principles and applica-
gent for hospital textiles, such as patient linens, privacy tions. Elsevier, 2017.
curtains and medical staff uniforms. SNO exhibited a 4. Kovalchuk NM, Trybala A, Starov V, et al. Fluoro- vs
critical micelle concentration of 0.12 g mL1, a high pH hydrocarbon surfactants: why do they differ in wetting
value (10.1) and an adequate foaming of 1.5 cm. performance? Adv Colloid Interface Sci 2014; 210: 65–71.
5. McNamee CE and Kawakami H. Effect of the surfactant
Moreover, unlike the neem oil, SNO has a soft and
charge and concentration on the change in the forces
agreeable odor. Finally, SNO exhibited a weak-
between two charged surfaces in surfactant solutions by
to-moderate bactericidal activity against a Gram- a liquid flow. Langmuir 2020; 36: 1887–1897.
negative bacterium and a moderate bacteriostatic 6. Banat IM, Makkar RS and Cameotra SS. Potential com-
effect against a Gram-positive bacterium. Its activity mercial applications of microbial surfactants. Appl
may be potentiated with the application of a high wash- Microbiol Biotechnol 2000; 53: 495–508.
ing temperature during hospital textile laundry proce- 7. De S, Malik S, Ghosh A, et al. A review on natural
dures. Nevertheless, further analysis must be surfactants. RSC Adv 2015; 5: 65757–65767.
8 Textile Research Journal 0(0)
8. Pradhan A and Bhattacharyya A. Quest for an eco- 23. Mak-Mensah E and Firempong C. Chemical character-
friendly alternative surfactant: surface and foam charac- istics of toilet soap prepared from neem (Azadirachta
teristics of natural surfactants. J Clean Prod 2017; 150: indica A. Juss) seed oil. Asian J Plant Sci Res 2011;
127–134. 1: 1–7.
9. Ivankovic T and Hrenovic J. Surfactants in the environ- 24. Nielsen SS. Introduction to food analysis. In: Food anal-
ment. Arch Ind Hyg Toxicol 2010; 61: 95–110. ysis. Springer, 2017, pp.3–16.
10. Foley P, Kermanshahi pour A, Beach ES, et al. 25. Atolani O, Olabiyi ET, Issa AA, et al. Green synthesis
Derivation and synthesis of renewable surfactants. and characterisation of natural antiseptic soaps from the
Chem Soc Rev 2012; 41: 1499–1518. oils of underutilised tropical seed. Sustain Chem Pharm
11. Muntaha S-T and Khan MN. Natural surfactant 2016; 4: 32–39.
extracted from Sapindus mukurossi as an eco-friendly 26. Tavares TD, Antunes JC, Padr~ao J, et al. Activity of
alternate to synthetic surfactant—a dye surfactant inter- specialized biomolecules against Gram-positive and
action study. J Clean Prod 2015; 93: 145–150. Gram-negative bacteria. Antibiotics 2020; 9: 314.
12. Schmitt C, Grassl B, Lespes G, et al. Saponins: a renew- 27. Padr~ ao J, Ribeiro S, Lanceros-Mendez S, et al. Effect of
able and biodegradable surfactant from its microwave- bacterial nanocellulose binding on the bactericidal activ-
assisted extraction to the synthesis of monodisperse ity of bovine lactoferrin. Heliyon 2020; 6: e04372.
lattices. Biomacromolecules 2014; 15: 856–862. 28. Machado G, Calil C Jr, Polito W, et al. Preservante nat-
13. Carvalho IT, Estevinho BN and Santos L. Application of ural de madeira para uso na construç~ao civil: o leo de
microencapsulated essential oils in cosmetic and personal neem. Minerva 2006; 3: 1–8.
healthcare products—a review. Int J Cosmet Sci 2016; 38: 29. Paes JB, de Souza AD, de Lima CR, et al. Rendimento e
109–119. leos de nim (Azadirachta
caracterısticas fısicas dos o
14. Amorati R, Foti MC and Valgimigli L. Antioxidant indica) e mamona (Ricinus communis). Floresta e
activity of essential oils. J Agric Food Chem 2013; 61: Ambient 2015; 22: 134–139.
10835–10847. 30. Warra A, Wawata I and Yauri AB. Soap preparation
15. Tmáková L, Sekretár S and Schmidt S. Plant-derived from mechanically cold pressed Nigerian neem
surfactants as an alternative to synthetic surfactants: sur- (Azadiracta indica) seed oil. Chemsearch J 2011; 2: 12–15.
face and antioxidant activities. Chem Pap 2016; 70: 31. Usman J, Okonkwo P and Shehu M. Investigation into
188–196. the usage of solvent for extracting neem oil from neem
16. Campos EVR, de Oliveira JL, Pascoli M, et al. Neem oil seed for industrial application. Acad J Interdiscip Stud
and crop protection: from now to the future. Front Plant 2014; 3: 39.
Sci 2016; 7: 1494. 32. Daltin D. Tensoativos: quımica, propriedades e aplicaç~
oes.
17. Do TKT, Hadji-Minaglou F, Antoniotti S, et al. Editora Blucher, 2011.
Authenticity of essential oils. Trends Analyt Chem 2015; 33. Jian H-l, Liao X-x, Zhu L-w, et al. Synergism and foam-
66: 146–157. ing properties in binary mixtures of a biosurfactant
18. Bisaria A, Tyagi SR and Ahanger MA. Growth perfor- derived from Camellia oleifera Abel and synthetic surfac-
mance of different provinces of Azadirachta indica. tants. J Colloid Interface Sci 2011; 359: 487–492.
Indian For 2014; 140: 841–846. 34. Noriega SE and Subramanian A. Consequences of neu-
19. Anjali CH, Sharma Y, Mukherjee A, et al. Neem oil tralization on the proliferation and cytoskeletal organi-
(Azadirachta indica) nanoemulsion—a potent larvicidal zation of chondrocytes on chitosan-based matrices. Int J
agent against Culex quinquefasciatus. Pest Manag Sci Carbohydr Chem 2011; 2011: 809743.
2012; 68: 158–163. 35. Chaudhari A, Gite V, Rajput S, et al. Development of
20. Saleh Al-Hashemi ZS and Hossain MA. Biological activ- eco-friendly polyurethane coatings based on neem oil
ities of different neem leaf crude extracts used locally in polyetheramide. Ind Crop Prod 2013; 50: 550–556.
Ayurvedic medicine. Pac Sci Rev A: Nat Sci Eng 2016; 36. Jerobin J, Sureshkumar RS, Anjali CH, et al.
18: 128–131. Biodegradable polymer based encapsulation of neem oil
21. Benelli G, Bedini S, Cosci F, et al. Larvicidal and ovide- nanoemulsion for controlled release of Aza-A. Carbohydr
terrent properties of neem oil and fractions against the Polym 2012; 90: 1750–1756.
filariasis vector Aedes albopictus (Diptera: Culicidae): a 37. Shikata T and Okuzono M. Are all polar molecules
bioactivity survey across production sites. Parasitol Res hydrophilic? Hydration numbers of ketones and esters
2014; 114: 227–236. in aqueous solution. J Phys Chem B 2013; 117:
22. Nicoletti M, Maccioni O, Coccioletti T, et al. Neem tree 7718–7723.
(Azadirachta indica A. Juss) as source of bioinsectides. 38. Ameh AO, Muhammad JA and Audu HG. Synthesis and
In: Perveen F (ed.) Insecticides: advances in integrated characterization of antiseptic soap from neem oil and
pest management. Rijeka, Croatia: InTech, 2012, shea butter oil. African Journal of Biotechnology 2013;
pp.411–428. 12: 4656–4662.