Professional Documents
Culture Documents
On
Prepared By
Ms. Jayeeta Das
Roll no. 18dm052
Batch 2018-20
Chapter 3
SCF for small businesses
3.1 Need for SCF by small businesses
3.2 SCF Instruments
3.3 Technology as a Saviour
Chapter 4
Findings, Conclusion and Recommendation
4.1 Findings
4.2 Conclusion and Recommendation
Chapter 5
Reference
DECLARATION
The information and the data given in the report is authentic to the
best of my knowledge.
Jayeeta Das
(Name of the student)
ACKNOWLEDMENT
With the blessings of God, I take the opportunity with great pleasure,
a deep sense of gratitude and profound thanks to everyone who have
spared their valuable time and giving me their co-operation to make
this project successful.
I would also like to thank my parents for their constant help, support
and coordination which helped me a lot. Special thanks have to be
reserved for all the respondents for providing information and
extending full support.
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 RESEARCH
DESIGN Title of the study
The title of the study is “Supply Chain Finance: An Invoice Bill
Discounting and Finance Solution for the Small Businesses of Indian
Economy”.
Objective of the study
The objective of the study is to understand how bringing
together finance and supply chain operations can make a
company more operationally savvy and improve financial
efficiency.
Understanding the opportunities and challenges of
implementing SCF for small businesses in India.
How SCF can become opportunities for banks in India.
The key purpose was to get perception of SCF among the
companies and to see if technology infusion has changed the
way of working of SCF.
Type of Research
The research study is a basic or fundamental research as it is intended
to expand the boundaries of knowledge and is based on both historical
and current data.
Historical research is one which uses past or historical sources such
as documents, annual reports, financial statements, articles etc. to
study the theoretical concept. Before you begin new research, you
should start with a thorough review of what others have already
done.
Not only does this help us get up-to-date with current research in our
area of interest, but it also typically leads us to examples of useful
databases that are available, commonly used analysis methods, and
ideas for ways to present our findings.
Collection of Data
Information expressed in some quantitative form is called Data. Data
is of two types- primary data and secondary data.
Primary Data- The data which is collected for the first time and
is original in character is called primary data.
The primary data was collected through interaction with the company
staff through survey and interviews.
Secondary Data- The secondary data is one which is already
available. Secondary data sources include information retrieved
through pre-existing sources: research articles, Internet or library
searches, etc.
Opportunities
E-commerce–In line with the current trend of Indian Economy
moving towards online sales from offline platforms, banks have
a huge opportunity to fund different supply chains through SCF.
It has already taken major share in Mobile, Electronics and
Apparel industries.
Integrated Approach–Opportunity for banks to fund both
forward and back ward integration along the value chain. Some
of the banks have worked to their advantage in this space.
Online Platforms/Automation-This can provide a big leverage in
terms of both integration and flow of information for the Banks
& other stakeholders.
Potential Sectors-Focus on less tapped potential Industries i.e.,
Commodities, Electricals & Electronics, Consumer Durables,
FMCG& Agro based Industries to finance their Supply chain.
Startups- Templated Innovative products for New Startups
Focus on shorter periodic Assessments for flexible credit
decisioning
P2P Lending- trends online market place for SMEs for invoice
Discounting through Bidding by different Financial Institutions.
Challenges
Acceptability and awareness about the product among
stakeholders.
Concentration on few selected industries only
Lack of availability of a common platform for financers
Biggest lenders still use Traditional sourcing and Assessment
Techniques
Anchor requirement of pushing sales sometimes invariably
increase the risk in the system
Diversion of funds for other purposes
On-boarding and monitoring of dealers or suppliers due to
geographical spread.
CHAPTER 3
While these traditional tools fix the working capital problem, these
are still largely unable to satisfy the demand for timely funding. Firms
that do not have access to bank funding use fixed assets such as
property as collateral for borrowing. External events such as the one
witnessed in India recently, namely the collapse of IL&FS; an
infrastructure finance company creates a crisis of confidence. Events
such as these almost instantly cause the borrowing costs to rise
hurting every firm equally.
However, large, publicly traded companies, respond to tough times by
shortening their own working capital cycle by lengthening it for their
suppliers, namely, the smaller firms. This hurts small firms
substantially because they have to borrow at higher cost from banks.
Even non-bank lenders, who are more flexible in lending to small
firms, require clarity in financial projections, documentation, current
and fixed assets to be able to decide quantum of working capital
requirements vis-a-vis long term loan requirements of the SME,
which many of them are unable to provide.
The process starts with seller uploading the invoice on the platform. It
then goes to buyer for acceptance. Once the buyer accepts, the invoice
is then factored and becomes factoring unit. The factoring unit then
goes for auction. The financiers then enter their discounting (finance)
rate. The seller or buyer, whoever is bearing the interest (financing)
cost, gets to accept the final bid. TReDS then settle the trade by
debiting the financier and paying the seller. The amount gets credited
the next working day into the seller’s designated bank account
through an electronic payment mode. The second leg of the settlement
is when the financier makes the repayment and the amount is repaid
to the
financier. As per RBI TReDS guidelines, only MSMEs can participate
as sellers, while banks, non-banking financial companies and
factoring companies are permitted as financiers.
CHAPTER 4
FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
4.1 FINDINGS: Are firms willing to try out the newer SCF
options?
I ran a detailed survey to understand various SCF tools implemented
by companies, through a questionnaire among companies and 16
companies responded to the questionnaire.
i. Companies responded in the questionnaire act as seller or buyer or
both.
ii. 75% of the responding companies under the present study
responded to our survey as buyers taking this number to 12.
iii. Other 18.75% responded as both buyers and suppliers and one
organization filled the survey from supplier’s perspective.
iv. Industries such as automobile, fishing, electrical equipment,
pharmaceutical, IT, leather and the new age e-commerce have
been represented in this study.
v. The annual turnover of the responding companies ranged from 50
lakhs to 10 crores for the responding companies who participated
in the survey.
vi. As for the position of these responding companies in the market
respondent recognized themselves as a swiftly growing company.
vii. I had also asked companies to place themselves in their supply
chain. Some of the companies play multiple roles and they
responded accordingly.
viii. 13 respondents placed themselves as manufacturers and six as
service providers. Two responses were filled from perspective of a
distributor, one from supplier, one from contractor and three from
retailers’ perspective.
ix. Of the companies that responded to our survey, only two
companies had a SCF initiative that ran for last four years. Three
companies were new to SCF practices. The remaining companies
does not have SCF initiatives.
x. The most surprising results of the study came from the
perception of the challenges faced by organisations in
implementing SCF management solutions. Financial reasons
were listed well below the learning, training and technology
management problems. The biggest impeding factor for SCF
management has been perceived as lack of training in Supply
Chain Finance. Lack of automation, lack of information and
knowledge and lack of trained workforce have been identified as
significant reasons for not adopting technology driven SCF
solutions.
Top ChaUenges faced by organizations in implementation of SCF
■ Total
lack of training in su pply chain finance
lack of automahon of invoicing and paymenL
7.76%
lack of knowledge & informati.on o:n, s,upply...
7.76%
Lack of IT ex perts to sillpport automation 6.9 %
Lack of abllity to access SCF at vartous stages in. 6.03 %
5.17%
Financially weak su pplier
5. 7%
Hig:h day sales outstand ing
(DSOJ - '5. 7 %
Slow processing of paym en,t transactiom --- ---
Lon ger transaction cycle in sovrcing AS%
Poor vlsibility into movem.int of goods .4 5%
Lack of coo rd ination}coUabor aition among...
AS%
longer tra r1saction cycle ln distr\bution
f
S%
Lack of appropriate ted molog,y for payment.. A5%
lack of fmanciing o.n acceptable ternns for irn-...
Laok of cash 11.ow managerne:ril
Lac:k of common vision among SC partner,s 2 .s r
2 . S
259% l!.72% 1.72%
Non,-e ffe ctive inven tory management techni.q
I.72%
ue.s Lack of collaborati:ve techno log ies to 1.72%
manage...
R.e dud ng the total cash low cyc-le time from...
lade of financing on accepta ble tem1s fo r work-
... Lack of coordination/collabo ration in
payment... Missing early payment d lscount
given by...
G.eog rapMca l challenges
iL.ack of working ca,pital/casn management tools
High diversity of business
lack oftrust among Supply Cha in pa rtn e.-s
Lack of app ropriate procedure for supp
lier...
lack of t ird party sourcing
Govemme,nt law.s &
mgulatto:ns
Culture
Prem 1re from top management to
lmprovekey-.. Unreliable and unpredictable
casn flows
MO% 2.00% 4.00% 6.00% S..00% 10.00% 12.00%
4.2 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
The fact that small and medium enterprises (except one) did not
respond to the survey and the fact that even the larger businesses
have identified skill, automation, personnel and training as
significant impediments gives us some sense of how the SCF
management has evolved in India. Indian business has a long
road ahead in embracing technology driven SCF management
practices.
Half of all the companies that responded to our survey
maintained conservative working capital, implying that they
were not availing the best ways to manage working capital to
minimum. The rest were evenly divided between aggressive and
matching policy. Whereas, the companies that identified
themselves as growing, opted for aggressive working capital
management.
CHAPTER 5
REFERENCES